🌜 We expect discussion on Theoretical and Practical Spiritual Science and Philosophy of Different Thoughts of Islam for Self realisation and Peaceful bright future of human and world with Quranwala Zafar Heretic Ex Muslim Sameer Towards the Truth 🌞
@@jaybhavani8416we expect discussion on Theorotical science and philosophy of different sects of Hinduism for self realisation and peaceful bright future of human and World with Ex Hindu awaz e haq uncensored Ex Hindu islamic awakening Ex Hindu elaina ali Ex Hindu haneen mukhtar To know the truth😊❤😊❤
@@jaybhavani8416we expect discussion on Theorotical science and philosophy of different sects of Hinduism for self realisation and peaceful bright future of human and World with Ex Hindu awaz e haq uncensored Ex Hindu islamic awakening Ex Hindu elaina ali Ex Hindu haneen mukhtar To know the truth😊❤😊❤
@@jaybhavani8416we expect discussion on Theorotical science and philosophy of different sects of Hinduism for self realisation and peaceful bright future of human and World with Ex Hindu awaz e haq uncensored Ex Hindu islamic awakening Ex Hindu elaina ali Ex Hindu haneen mukhtar To know the truth😊❤😊❤
Islam is 💯 true religion. No one can debunk. Let's focus on the commands of Allah relating to our lives. Successful person is one who protects himself from major sins.
سنت مسلمانوں کے عمل میں پائی جائے گی عملی اجماع اور تواتر سے ھد ھد کی جو خبر تھی سلیمان علیہ السلام اللہ کے نبی تھے اوسکی تصدیق ہو گئی ہوگی وحی سے اج اگر کوئی یہ کہے کے باہر ایکسیڈنٹ ہو گیا ہے تو کسی کی مرضی کی وہ مانے یا نہ مانے لیکن حدیث کا معاملہ یہ نہیں ہے حدیث میں دین کا بیان ہے اس میں بات رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم کی نسبت سے بیان ہو رہی ہے جس پر ہماری دنیا اور اخرت کا انحصار ہے اوسکو قطعی الدلالہ ہونا چاہیے گمان غالب نہیں رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم ہمیں دین قران و سنت میں دے کر گئے ہیں حدیث میں اسی دین کی تفہیم و تبعین ہے حدیث رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے علم و عمل کا تاریخ ریکارڈ اور اپ صلی اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم کا اسوہ حسنہ ہے
Ap ko quran hi nahi smaj aya....na yah smaj aya kay hafiz sahib nay is ayat kay kis point ko importance de...... Home work for u Muslim kay tawatur say sabit karo kay Aurto (opposite gender) say had shake ho sakta.... Twature or sunat say sabit kar do.
جس کو جو چیز اچھی لگتی ہے مانے بیٹھا ہے اللہ سے اپنا تعلق مضبوط کرنے کی بجائے ان بحثوں میں ڈال دیا ہے جس کا پوچھا ای نہیں جانا جس کا مقصد ہی نہیں ہے سادی زندگی گزارنی چاہیے اللہ کی عبادت کی حقوق العباد پورے کیے سیدھا جنت میں بات ختم
Ghamidi sb stance on Quran sunnat n hadees is very strong zubair sb is unable to defend zubair sb arguments r weak v dont learn namaz from bukhari but from parents n society this is true for roza qurbani haj zakat biggest examples of ijma n tawatur n the hujjat of quran n sunnat jazakallah
Actually his stance is pretty weak in the light of philosophy of history. But Pakistanis in general do not have the acumen to comprehend these matters and they follow their favourite personalities blindly (be it Ghamidi or an orthodox scholar).
I will accept that you have understood Ghamidi sahib. If you have watched all the lectures of Ghamidi Sahib on Meezan, just watch 50 lessons on it, then I will accept that you have understood him. I was an agnostic, by the way; those lectures are one of the biggest reasons I got my faith back by Allah's blessings, and Allah guides alone.
Brother ghamdi sahab had done blunders he is not a scholar . He said that you can skip roza if there is exam . He denied the coming of Isa alaisalam and imam mehdi . He denied the Hayat of Isa alaisalam . Brother this are the few things I have mentioned there are many others. Just because it helped you it doesn't mean ghamdi sahab is correct. You are not a scholar how can you decide that he is correct or not . And all the major scholars of Pakistan have clearly stated the mistake of ghamdi sahab . So brother instead of following ghamdi sahab blindly do some research and sit with proper scholar. Ghamdi who doest have a beard which is sunnah how can that man be a scholar and dr hafiz zubair had done full research on ghamdi sahab from 20 yrs pls stop this bullshit . He had listen all the lecture of ghmadi sahab infant he have met him personally. So have some shame and stop defending ghamdi
@@zeeshansiddiqui3695 what a shame you are speeding here on UA-cam. all of your allegations are either false or already answered with facts and evidence.
@MuhammadAdilRafique-km8nk then pls send me the vedio of answers brother you are just blind follower . If you have proof just send me the vedio link . Brother many vedios he clearly said isa alaisalam is dead . He said imam mehdi is just a made up story brother just go do some research go and write on UA-cam ghamdi view on imam mehdi you will get the vedio . You Ghamdi followers are most jahil
@@MuhammadAdilRafique-km8nk where you have gone you are typical blind ghamdi follower when I have asked you evidence you run away. You people have no shame brother you have told I am putting allegation. Brother I have given you evidence just go on UA-cam and write ghamdi views on imam mehdi . You will get the answer . Brother if you don't have evidence stop lying and defending ghamdi . Your ghamdi doest have a beard which is obligatory for men . How ghamdi can become if he himself is not following sunnah
غامدی صاحب کی یہ بات کہ عقیدہ خبر واحد سے ثابت نہیں کیا جاسکتا ہے بالکل صحیح ہے کیونکہ عقیدہ دلیل عقلی قطعی یا دلیل نقلی قطعی پر بنا ہوتا ہے جبکہ خبر واحد ظنی ہے
بالکل غلط۔ آپ کے فرقے کی اصل گمراہی اس اصول پر ہے کہ حدیث سے دین ثابت نہیں ہوتا (اس میں آپ کے استاد کفر تک بھی پہنچ جاتے ہیں لیکن چونکہ آپ سب خود جاہل ہیں اس لئے آپ کو معلوم نہیں ہوتا)۔
Ghamidi shb ki sunnat ki taareef khud iss he tanqeed ka shikaar hai. Riwayati hadeeth aur Ghamidian sunnat mei farq "documentation" ka he hai. Ghamidi ki sunnat mei shak ka arsa 1400 saal hai jabke Riwayati hadeeth mei shak ka arsa 200 saal hai. Aaj 1400 saal baad hum sab ek doosre ko ek makhsoos tariqay se namaz parhte huay dekhte hain, iska matlab yeh hargiz nahi hota ke yeh tariqa mutawaatir hai. Yeh amli sunnat shahaadat-e-waahid ki bunyaad pe itni aam ho sakti hai ke woh kisi daur mei mutawaatir ka libaas aurh le.
Agar khaalisatan falsafay ke aitbaar se dekhain, toh jab aap kisi aqeeday ko khabr-e-waahid ki bunyaad pe reject karte hain, toh aapko technically nabuwat mei jitne aqaid bataye hain unko bhi reject karna parega.
As an inquisitive Muslim, my questions about Islam were answered once I started listening to Ghamidi Sahib. He is a Blessing from Allah SWT for our times. For that, I say Alhamdo lillah..
Ghamdi sahab though use islamic logic to satisfy intellect but at the same time sugarcoat the aspects of religion that may be acceptable to "freethinkers"...
یار حد ہو گئ ہے میں ذاتی طور سے راجہ صاحب کی بڑی عزت کرتا ہوں ، الحاد کے خلاف انکا کام زبردست ہے۔ لیکن ہدہد کی مثال سے عقیدہ ثابت کرنا 😂 یہ واقعی کمال ہے او توہاڈا بھلا ہو جائے 😂😂😂
غامدی صاحب کو اللہ جزائے خیر دے ۔بہت بہترین کام کرتے ہین۔آپ نے جو بات زیر بحث لائی ہے اس پر خوبصورت بحث ہوسکتی ہے۔غامدی صاحب نے اسلام کو سمجھنے کا ایک بہترین طریقہ دریافت کیا جو شاید پہلے بند پڑا تھا ۔غامدی صاحب کوئی فائنل اتھارٹی نہی ہیں جس کا برملا اظہار بھی کرتے ہیں اور تجسس و تفکر کر جو بات وہ سمجھتے ہیں سابقہ سے رجوع کر بتاتے ہیں اور یہی چیز انکو ایک منفرد مقام عطا کرتی ہے جو شاید بقیہ مکاتب فکر میں مفقود ہے۔ذخیرہ احادیث سچ میں ایک ٹڑین رکارڈ ہے ۔احادیث ایک narrated شورش یے جو حجت نہیں بن سکتا۔جبکہ قرآن واحد حجت ہے۔رہی بات سنت کی تو سنت اور حدیث دو الگ الگ چیزیں ہیں۔جبکہ عمومی طور دونوں کو ایک درجہ دیا جاتا ہے۔
Zubair shb gave example of hudhud which is totally wrong: 1-Hudhud was ordered by Allah to give information about the worshippers 2- even if we don't agree, that this was something god granted, Can birds lie like humans do or they have the power to decide things like us? 3- Hudhud was a single narrator and he viewed all these things right in front of him whether as in hadith there are at least 4-5 people in between. 4- hudhud gave information about what he saw or heard maybe after some time but a narrator in hadith narrates an event or saying which has happened at least 150 years ago which automatically makes it weak.
extraordinary communication and control that Sulaiman (A.S.) had over creatures, granted by divine will was indeed a miracle. In contrast, Suhabi narrators of early prophetic times relied on their natural cognitive and linguistic abilities, which are limited and do not involve divine intervention. The comparison is an attempt to draw parallels between divine miracles and human storytelling to make your point.
Ghamidi sb per jahan koi tanqeed ho to fat se lgata hun k shayed koi bat ho jis men wazan ho, aur seekhny k liay lagata hun per shayed hi koi video 10 minutes se ziyada dekh paya hon. 5, 10 minutes men pta chal jata h k ye log un ki bat ko smjhna hi ni chahty.
@@Aqeel-t5n ghamdi has so many contradictory points thats why u ur self has not understood ghamdi. U cant even prove ur jahil ustad on itmam jahalt qanoon.
@@electronicsurdupakistan9181 kindly let me know his one contradiction and I will think about it. If I found it reasonable, will accept it otherwise will explain the reason behind that concept.
People here have refuted the hazrat suleiman (A.S.) wala point really well. What i'd like to elaborate on is the ijma'a and tawatur wala point. Ghamidi sahab amlan ijma'a aur tawatur say sabit sunnat sirf ussi ko samajhtay hain jo cross-culturally, from generation to generation amlan muntaqil hoti ayi hai (jesay Quran muntaqil hua hai). For example Namaz, poori muslim, there's ample evidence that muslim ummat nay by-and-large hamesha, cross-culturally namaz parhi hai (Rasul ullah SAW say pehlay tak) toh woh sunnat bangayi. Agar koi cheez Quran say wazeh tor par sabit nahi, aur amlan cross-culturally and gen to gen muntaqil nahi hui, toh usko sunnat nahi samjha jayega. Toh your point about cultural relativism and bid'at is rendered moot. Khabr-e-ahad (chahay uskay 1,2,3 ya 4 bhi rawi hon) deen ka maakhaz nahi bansakti, kyunkay agar woh deen kay haqaiq ko bayan karrahi hoteen, toh woh kabhi bhi khabr-e-wahid nahi hoti, aik well-established (quran aur sunnat say) baat hoti. That's their line of arguments.
Inka ijm'a aur tawatur, traditional ijmaa tawatur say alag hai, kyunkay traditional ijma aur tawatur fehm ka ijma aur tawatur hota hai. Inka ijma'a o tawatur since amli hai, aur ummat nay unanimously apnay aamaal say agay barhaya hai, toh yeh epistemically qati sabit hojata hai (kind of like Quran). Akhbar e ahad on the other hand is dhanni.
Ok. So, straightening the twisted words. Sunnah of prophet hold less value than practice of subsequent generations till now. What a illogical argument. At any given point, preserved knowledge even it's historical holds more meaning and relevance than dynamic practices over a span of 15 centuries.
@@wasimirza37 the practice of subsequent generation IS the sunnah ya Akhi. I explained extensively how "akhbar-e-ahad" is dhanni ilm, and amlan ijma'a and tawatur say muntaqil hue sunnat is qati. Toh by definition it holds more value on epistemological grounds.
This is convenient wordplay. Ap apni merzi se apny ap ko suite kerne k liye Ijmah and Sunnah ki definitions nahi badal skty. Limiting it to only Amli-tawattur opens the door to numerous issues. Milad is celebrated cross-culturally, cross-sects, across the world, and has been for centuries. Even in KSA, so is it sunnah now? You'll have to rely on historical records in some way to realize this is a biddah. New practices that are being introduced right now, 500 years into the future will become "sunnah" according to your standards when they become widespread and normalized lol. Things that are "sunnah" right now might not be in the future if they are abandoned as Zubair hinted at. There is amli tawatur (as well as tawatur of it being fard) of Hijab, mass practiced by Muslims around the world from Morocco to Indonesia, but your teacher refuses to accept this lol. There has been amli tawatur of state-craft and state building according to sharia until only a century or two ago, but nope, Islam is secular I guess lol. Secondly, you said "the practice of subsequent generations IS sunnah". Nope. This is what I was talking about convenient word play. Sunnah is the actions and teachings of the Prophet (SAW), period. It does not depend on the subsequent generations infinitum. Ahadith are an indispensable historical record that make us jump 1300 years back to see what the three blessed generations were doing. Today, 1400 years later, ahadith IS the source of sunnah.
Weird play of words just to say they have a different definition of what sunnah is compared to what has been considered standard for centuries. And if we go by this definition of sunnah, that itself is self-defeating. This new definition of Sunnat is "consensus that has been followed for centuries" well what has been followed was followed through hadith. At the end we're still going back to that so why do it in such a roundabout way. i don't see a point in complicating things by changing definitions and what has been standard since pretty much the beginning.
Yah payoo ku kay shaytan kay toilt kay ander hay is liya , ghamdi ka payo bi napak hay ....or koi muslam ghamdi kay napak poye say tu bohat upar hay....
میں مانوں گا کہ آپ غامدی صاحب کو سمجھ گئے ہیں۔ اگر آپ نے میزان پر غامدی صاحب کے تمام لیکچر دیکھے ہیں، اس پر صرف 50 اسباق دیکھ لیں، تو میں مانوں گا کہ آپ ان کو سمجھ گئے ہیں۔ میں ایک agnostic تھا, ویسے; وہ لیکچرز اللہ کے فضل سے میرے ایمان کی واپسی کی سب سے بڑی وجہ ہیں اور اللہ ہی ہدایت دیتا ہے۔ Translated by google
sunnat and hadith are different. hadith can be a source of sunnah but you cannot equate both. Hadith was collected and started compiling at least 200 years after the death of the holy prophet(pbuh).
Brother problem with you that you have no knowledge about hadees . Brother hadees were written by the sahaba also. Imam malik hadees book which is written much before shaeeh bukhari is present with us now also . So hadees was always there with the ummah before it was oral tradition people have learnt it . Brother how you will verify something is sunnah . You will verify by seeing the hadees literature. Brother we have one special thing which is chain of narration which goes back to prophet muhammad saw. This chains is present for every hadees . Brother you are talking like non Muslims they say the same thing regarding hadees brother its sad you are Muslim and you don't the hadees collection . Brother hadees are necessary to follow quran without hadees you can't pray namaz,you can't give zakat ,you can't do hajj . All are transmitted to us thorough hadeees . So learn islam from scholars not form ghamdi
@@zeeshansiddiqui3695 first of all, I am not a ghamidi follower neither a blind follower of some other so-called scholar. Imam malik was born about 80 years after the death of the prophet (pbuh). how can he be a sahaba? first learn before preaching. understand the difference between hadith and sunnah
@kamrankhalid5180 when I said imam malik is sahaba .he is not sahaba . he is from the salaf we have his books now . He came much before imam bukhari . My main point is hadees is a part of islam . To follow quran you need hadees . In quran there are islamic rulings . But how to follow the ruling and how to amal on that you need hadees . Allah had sent prophet with book . Because to explain the quran prophet muhammad came. The interpretation of quran is there inhadees . So hadees is a credible source . If you reject hadees you can't follow Islam completely
@kamrankhalid5180 brother first understood what I am saying .sunnah is the actions,statements, silent approval of prophet muhammad saw. Where you will find sunnah . Hadees is the source of sunnah. How can you reject hadees and follow sunnah. For following sunnah you need to follow hadees
Biddat kabi bi ijma say muntaqil nahi hoti us ko society ka thora hisa adopt karta hay aur ahel ilm usko du aur du char ki tarah alag kar dety hain jazakalalh
Sunnat is akin to all those routine practices which we have seen and learnt from our fathers and they learned from their fathers and go on and on. Reading Namaz, fasting, paying Zakat and many practices were all learned from our parents and they learnt from their parents. Widespread use of written knowledge is only a phenomenon of only less than of 400 - 500 years. Before that everything is learned and taught from observation let along at the time of Holy Prophet PBUH
Meny boht Dafa khali u zehn ho kr Ghamdi Sahb pr jo tanqeedat ki jti h suni h taa k haq jan sako lekin hmesha mayosi hoi k on k makhlafeen siwaye tbasry k kuch zyada on pr naqd nhi kr sky
Different sources sy baqaida research or itny saal deen prh ky phur jamia guftago bnti.... Apko prhna hy to phly hades hi prh ly sahih kia khbr wahid matwatr kia... Is trha agy agy rasty khulty jy gy..... Hafiz zubair ky hi bhut sy courses hin.... Aisy basic sy strt kry.... More valid content arabic min hy....
@@mutahira999 Thanks for suggestions brother Islam teacher ke sath parna chaheye aur hadeeth ka ilm to phir boht mushkil hay sirf book aur arabic se ni hotha but mein political science aur philosphy ki book ki taraf ishara kar raha tha QAR ko
Ghamidi sb se me ikhtilaf rakhta hu bahut se mamle me..lekin unse seekhne ko bhi bahut kuch mila hai . Mujhe bhi ghamidi sahab ki bahut se aara se shadeed ikhtilaf hai lekin wo is Daur e jadeed ke bade logo me se hai.
Sirf accha insaan hona kafi nahi hota balki Islam ko sahi tanazur me samajhna aur samjhaana zaruri hai, sath hi salaf saleheen ki nahij ko bhi nahi chhodna hai.
راجہ صاحب اور حافظ زبیر تھوڑا بہت علمی انداز رکھتے ہیں ۔ مایوسی ہوئی ان کی گفتگو سن کے ۔ اگر زمانہ پہلے والا ہوتا جہاں دوسرے کا موقف جاننے کے لیے دس کتابیں دیکھنی پڑتی تھیں ، تو ان حضرات کو شک کا فائدہ دیا جا سکتا تھا کہ انہوں نے فطرت کے بارے صاحب کو پورے موقف کا جانا نہیں ۔ لیکن اب تو ہر موضوع پر 23 اختلافات سیریز موجود ہے ۔ آپ اگر ایک گھنٹہ ویڈیو دیکھ لیتے تو اس خفت سے بچ جاتے جو آپ کے اعتراضات کے جوابات کے طور پر غامدی صاحب کے موقف پر مبنی ہیں اور آپ کے اس پوڈ کاسٹ کے جواب میں یو ٹیوب پر لگائی گئی ہے ۔ اگر آپ تھوڑی تحقیق کرتے تو آپ کو ضرور غامدی صاحب کی فکر پر بہتر تنقید مل جاتی ۔
May Ghamdi saab live long, he has given a very clear and logical direction for understanding rel8gion, whereas the typical molvies drain energies repeating the same old fallacies
Example of hud hud for explaining authenticity of hadees. Waah. Kya kehnay. Kooi rabt aur تعلق hee nahin hai baat ka. Why do they criticize Ghamdi sb. Just talk of your understanding of religion. Stop taking names of people.
Fundamental point khabr-e-waahid ki reliability ka hai. Aapke paas jawaab na hona iss argument ko nullify nahi karta. Kya ek mutawaatir khabr behtar hai khabr-e-wahid se? Bilkul. Kya khabr-e-waahid pe kabhi bharosa kya ja sakta hai. Bilkul, agar kuch conditions meet hon toh.
@@philosopher-x lekin agar ak rawayat me 4-5 ravi hon or hr ravi bat ko alfaz badal k apny alfaz me byaan kr rha ho or koi pori bat byan kr rha ho koi jis ko 30-40 saal baad jitni yad reh gai ho utni byaan kr rha ho to asi bat pe yakeen krny k liye us baat ko us kitab or us amal (Sunnat) pe parkhana zarori hai jo bialajma or Qool e twatur / amli twatur se Muhammad Rasool Allah se hi hum tk muntikal hua hai jis me shak ki koi gunjayash ni hai.
غامدی صاحب عالم دین نہی ہیں، حیرت ہے ہم نے علاج کروانا ہو تو اچھے سے اچھا ڈاکٹر ڈھونڈنے ہیں لیکن دین کے معاملے میں غامدی جیسے لوگوں پر اعتماد کر لیتے ہیں
ان حضرات میں شاید یہ جرآت ہی نہیں ہے کہ غامدی صاحب کی 23 اعتراضات والی سیریز دیکھ سکیں یا کم از کم ان کی کتاب میزان کا بغور مطالعہ کر سکیں۔ حافظ صاحب کی غامدی صاحب پر سطحی تنقید پر مبنی کتاب کا محترم جناب عاصم مغل صاحب نے بہت اچھا رد کیا ہے۔ قیصر احمد راجہ صاحب سے گزارش ہے کہ حافظ صاحب سے پوچھنے کی بجائے 23 اعتراضات والی سیریز خود دیکھیں اور پھر غامدی صاحب پر علمی تنقید کریں۔ ورنہ لوگ یہی سمجھیں گے کہ قیصر راجہ صاحب دوسروں کی نظر سے غامدی صاحب کو سمجھتے ہیں۔ اگر وہ غامدی صاحب کو خود پڑھنا اور سمجھنا نہیں چاہتے بلکہ دوسروں کے سہارے اپنے آپ کو بہلانا چاہتے ہیں تو ان کے لیے خاموش رہنا ہی بہتر ہے۔
My appeal to every Muslim, my brother or sister, the owner of the channel, I know that it is not my right to comment on your channel, but God is my witness that our circumstances are harsh and forced me to do this. Please forgive me. My brother, there is still a brotherhood of faith. I asked you for a bag of flour. My brother, we women cannot go out among men. There is still a woman with you. My brother, God has honored you. You are men. We are women. We cannot go out or work like you. My brother, where is the brotherhood of faith in your hearts? We are women. There is no brotherhood, no mercy, no compassion, no humanity. And give good tidings to the patient. It is the greatest hope while waiting for what we want. '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' How many times I called and talked and tried hard, but no one responded. Oh man, we are with you. My mother ordered us food from the restaurant. More and today. My mother left. Crying. She said, Why are you crying, my mother? She said, My daughter, I ask. God, that I may be honored by death. She said, Why, my mother. She cursed us. She said, "My daughter, today the restaurant owner insulted me. I said, 'Why?' I said, 'How can I be better than people?' I ask God, my daughter. May God gather me. With death alone, a gathering that is better than this humiliation and this humiliation. It is true. I am saying this. It diminishes my value and respect. But, man. I swear to God that I did not say this. I kiss your boots. I am so hungry that my conscience no longer allows me to let you go and ask us for food. I kiss your boots, man, and I ask you by God Almighty and in the Book of God, man, I kiss your boots, man. He has caused us harm, my brother, so that we can buy a kilo of flour and pay the rent. My brother, have mercy on us. He who is in the show will have mercy on you, He who is in the sky. My brother, this is my WhatsApp number: 00967711500090. Whoever can help us, message me on WhatsApp. We will send him the full name. He will transfer us as much as he can. May Allah reward you. Allah knows that my family and I, our house rent is 20 thousand Yemeni riyals per month, and now we owe 60 thousand for 3 months. The owner of the house is one of those people who do not have mercy. By Allah, my brother, he comes every day and humiliates us and talks about us and wants to throw us out of the house and into the street because we were unable to pay him the rent. We will have until the end of the week, and if we pay him, he will swear by Allah that he will throw us out into the street without mercy. See my situation for yourselves. I ask you by Allah, the Living, the Eternal, to help me. By Allah, the Almighty, even at night we cannot sleep from fear. We do not have mattresses or blankets to warm ourselves from the cold. Everything is flooded from the rain, and we have no one but Allah and then you. My brothers, I kiss your boots, don’t turn me away empty-handed. Help us with whatever you can. Is it acceptable to you that we live in this place? We are girls and we have no one. Our father died in a car accident. Consider us your daughters and your honor, and help me with whatever you can. May God reward you with good =>[[}>] ^][/*&;;&;&&;•̥·-`.`.`.`.`.•.,¸-•.,¸°꒰·̮ •̥·°`.`.`.`.`.,.•¯,.•¯}:;:;:;;::;;::;;::;;-,'-|.................،,..،،,,,,,,,,،،،،،،،,,,،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،,،،،،،،،،،،،،,,،،،،،،،,,,،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،
حضرت سلیمان علیہ السلام اللہ کے نبی ہیں۔ نبی کو اللہ کی طرف سے تصدیق مل جاتی ہے اس لیے یہاں خبر واحد سے متعلق آپ کا استدلال درست نہیں ہے جس کا اطلاق احادیث پر نہیں ہو سکتا کیوں کہ نہ راوی نبی ہیں اور نہ ہی محدثین نبی ہیں۔
@adarabi3149 for the sake of the argument, let's assume your justification. So tell me Know, you will put Mr Ghandi in which category? And from where on earth he obtains the knowledge?
محترم انبیاء کرام علیہم السلام کو تصدیق اللہ تعالیٰ کی طرف سے ملتی ہے اور یہاں بھی تصدیق اللہ تعالیٰ ہی کر رہا ہے۔ ہد ہد کی زبان سے الفاظ اللہ تعالیٰ نے ہی حضرت سلیمان علیہ السلام تک پہنچائے
@@omerjaved-hk7xd محترم غامدی صاحب غیر جانبدار اور ایماندار عالم دین ہیں۔ وہ قرآن کے نزول کے زمانے کے اعلیٰ ادب اور اس کی زبان پر درک رکھتے ہیں اور اس زمانے کے انداز تکلّم سے بخوبی واقف ہیں۔ اس کے علاوہ اُن کے ہاتھ سے سیاق و سباق کا دامن نہیں چھوٹنے پاتا۔ اُن کی یہی خوبیاں اُن کو اپنے ہم عصر علماء سے ممتاز بناتی ہیں۔ اگر آپ کو صحیح معنی میں اُن پر تنقید کرنی ہے تو پہلے آپ خود کو ان مذکورہ محاسن سے مزیّن کریں پھر اس وادی میں قدم رکھیں، آپ کا خیر مقدم ہے۔
Sunnat musalmano kay amal may hay practical amal may hud hud ki khaber Allah kay nabi ko hay wahi say tasdeeq ho gi ho gi agar koi kahy kay bahir accident ho gia tu koi yaqeen karay ya na kary magar hadees tu deen hay us ko qati hona chahia kyon kay wo hamary Nabi PBUH ki khaber hay jis per inhisar hay dunya ur akhirat ka us ko qati hona chahia guman ghalib nahi
You mean prophet religion is determined by the nonprophets (muhadseen), you people are unintentionally damaging the sources of Islam that is Quran & Sunnat. That's it! It's not about believing or not believing in Hades, it's about the content of Hades. Sweeping statements are not enough for people to say they don't understand him, let discuss the arguments of Ghamidi Sahab exactly the way he addresses them and then criticize him, otherwise, you are only criticizing yourself not him, and wasting our time. If you do this, doesn't matter if I convinced or not but at least in this way knowledge keeps on going and at least we gain something from you and expectedly get back to the right direction if we were wrong. JazakAllah ❤️
Both of you are the best and keep up the good work because it is an age of hypocracy and the hypocrates are trying their level best to explain Islamic rituals in context of western interest
اب تک میں جتنا بھی حافظ صاحب کی غامدی صاحب پر ت قید کو سنا ہے میں یقین سے کہہ سکتا ہوں کہ حافظ صاحب کو غامدی صاحب کی بات نہیں سمجھ آتی۔ یا مسئلہ کچھ اور ہے۔ 😊
غامدی صاحب سے آپکا بنیادی اختلاف فہم قرآن اور فہم حدیث پر ھے۔ اس پر میں نے بار بار آپ کو بھی سنا ھے اور غامدی صاحب کو بھی ۔ غامدی صاحب 100% درست معلوم ھوتے ھیں۔
Ghamidi sahib bht c chezon mein sahi hain lekin meri trh wo b bht c chezon mein khud confuse hain. Aur wo apne followers ko b confuse kr rhy hain. Aik naya firqa bna rhy hain, jese engineer sahib ne aik naya firqa bnaya hai. Allah abko hidayat ata frmae
ویڈیو کے اختتام پر ڈاکٹر صاحب نے فرمایا کہ چونکہ 90 فیصد امت نماز نہیں پڑھتی اور جھوٹ بولتی ہے، تو وہ تعامل بن جائے گا۔ حیرت ہے ویسے ایسی سوچ پر۔ کیا کبھی کسی نے نماز نہ پڑھنے اور جھوٹ بولنے کو دین کے طور پر بیان کیا ہے؟ یہ اب چونکہ زیادہ تر لوگ جھوٹ بول رہے ہیں اور نماز نہیں پڑھ رہے، تو اب سے یہ دین ہے؟ کمال ہے۔ اور وہ جو سامنے بھائی "مسٹر افلاطون" صاحب بیٹھے ہیں، وہ صرف سر ہلا رہے ہیں۔ مجال ہے کہ کراس سوال کر رہے ہوں کہ جناب، آپ فرما کیا رہے ہیں؟
😂janab aap Kai ghamdi Sahab ki yahi logic hai. Hadith Nahi balqai logo Kai amal KO dekh Kar namaz fardh hoi hai. Waise agar Dekha jai Tou wo to apni hi baat sai contradicts Kar rahen kyun Kai musalman hadith ko bhi Deen Ka hisa samjhte a rahen hain.tu yai bhi ijma ummat sai sabit hai. Aur un Kai buhut sai aqaid wo hai jo ummat mai kbhi pai hi Nahi Jate the.
غامدی صاحب سے اختلاف کرتا کوئی نا جائز بات نہیں ، آ پ بحر حال انسان ہیں لیکن اس نے دین کی خدمت بھی بڑی جرات سے کی ہے ۔ اس کی بھی قدر کرنی چاہیے ۔ ہمارا ایک اجتماعی مسئلہ ہے کہ کسی عالم دین کو فرشتہ یا پھر شیطان ثابت کرنے کی کوشش کر رہے ہیں جو کہ بہر دو صورت مناسب نہیں ۔
@@muhammadnazir7287 darust farmaya aapne. Koi ikhtalaf nahi, Yahan QAR sahib se masla ye hai k ye sahib targeted tehreek chala rahe hain aur majaal hai k koi qable feham dalil kabhi pesh ki ho khud se
@@pakexperiment876Pori ummah iss waqt Nabi asli kay videos dekh rahee hai all with authentic references. 😂. Zameen sakin hai by ex Muslims of North America. 😂
yaad rakhein Allah ko jawab dena hai har accusation ka. Just watch two short videos:1. "Sunnat ki Nauyat ka faisla-Ghamidi'; 7 minute 39 second video 2. Sunnat kia hai Ghamidi" 11minute 8 second video! these few minutes will be enough for you to prove why you are misrepresenting.
قرآن و سنت اجماع اور تواتر سے منقل ہوئے ہیں۔ اجماع سے مراد کسی بات پر اتنے لوگوں کا جمع ہوجانا ہے کہ ان کا کسی غلط بات پر جمع ہونا عقلاً محال ہو۔ جبکہ تواتر سے مراد یہ ہے اس عمل میں تسلسل ہو، کوئی انقطاع نہ ہو۔ اب سوال یہ پیدا ہوتا ہے کہ کسی عمل پر اجماع اور تواتر ثابت کیسے ہوگا؟ اس کا جواب یہ ہے کہ ویسے ہی ثابت ہوگا جیسے تاریخی چیزیں ہوا کرتی ہیں۔ ہم اس زمانے کے آثار دیکھیں گے، تصنیفات دیکھیں گے، فقہاء کی رائے دیکھیں گے، اخبار احاد بھی دیکھیں گے۔ اور ہماری علمی تاریخ تو ایک درخشندہ تاریخ ہے کسی سے ڈھکی چھپی تو نہیں۔ وگرنہ تو یہ سوال بھی بنتا ہے کہ قرآن بھی رسولاللہ سے براہ راست ہمیں موصول نہیں ہوا۔ تو کیا پورا قرآن بھی روایات سے ثابت ہوتا ہے؟
The biggest question muslims should be asking to themselves should be: If we have the ultimate divine truth revealed to us, then why almost all Muslim societies in the world are dysfunctional at all levels, not to mention ethical and moral derrogation?? To find answers, we need people like Ghamidi who have the ability to see in a skeptical way everything that has been done in last 14 centuries and at the same time have courage to point out everything. I don't mean any disrespect to anyone, but people like Qaiser Raja are more prone to convincing people that the problem lies with them i-e apke aqaid thek nhn hn, apka emaan durust nhn ha" in order to tap on guilt button of masses which help them gain audience and some drama!!
introduced parents to Ghamdi 8 yrs ago. regret it today. trying to get them away now. he's very popular here in the US. still I'm not as knowledgeable.
With due respect to both respected persons ..Inki baatein sun kar ye Lagta hai ke yaa to inki fahem mein koi kami hai ya Phir ye taassub (bias)ke buri tarah se shikaar hain..
we expect discussion on Theorotical science and philosophy of different sects of Hinduism for self realisation and peaceful bright future of human and World with Ex Hindu awaz e haq uncensored Ex Hindu islamic awakening Ex Hindu elaina ali Ex Hindu haneen mukhtar To know the truth😊❤😊❤
Salaam, the link to the full podcast:
ua-cam.com/video/TS5msVoeS7s/v-deo.htmlsi=0NiyMpoRljVZNNZm
🌜
We expect discussion on
Theoretical and Practical
Spiritual Science and Philosophy
of
Different Thoughts of Islam
for
Self realisation and Peaceful bright future of human and world
with
Quranwala
Zafar Heretic
Ex Muslim Sameer
Towards the Truth
🌞
@@jaybhavani8416we expect discussion on
Theorotical science and philosophy of different sects of Hinduism for self realisation and peaceful bright future of human and World with
Ex Hindu awaz e haq uncensored
Ex Hindu islamic awakening
Ex Hindu elaina ali
Ex Hindu haneen mukhtar
To know the truth😊❤😊❤
@@jaybhavani8416we expect discussion on
Theorotical science and philosophy of different sects of Hinduism for self realisation and peaceful bright future of human and World with
Ex Hindu awaz e haq uncensored
Ex Hindu islamic awakening
Ex Hindu elaina ali
Ex Hindu haneen mukhtar
To know the truth😊❤😊❤
@@jaybhavani8416we expect discussion on
Theorotical science and philosophy of different sects of Hinduism for self realisation and peaceful bright future of human and World with
Ex Hindu awaz e haq uncensored
Ex Hindu islamic awakening
Ex Hindu elaina ali
Ex Hindu haneen mukhtar
To know the truth😊❤😊❤
Wa alaykum us Salam wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakātuh
Two beautiful personalities in a single frame❤
Bshk❤
ہد ہد کی خبر والی مثال سے۔۔
عقیدہ ثابت کر رہے ہیں ماشاءاللہ
یہ علمی استدلال ہے ان کا 😅
ہد ہد کی بات کا تو حضر سلمان نے بغیر تحقیق کے یقین نہیں کیا ۔ نمل ۲۷-۲۸
Ku nahi ho sakta. Quran ki har bat aqeeda hay.
Islam is 💯 true religion.
No one can debunk.
Let's focus on the commands of Allah relating to our lives.
Successful person is one who protects himself from major sins.
every religion person thinks this way. You are what you are taught since childhood
@@RiteshArora-s9xTum bhi religious ho kyuki tum science par imaan leke aaye hue ho.
سنت مسلمانوں کے عمل میں پائی جائے گی عملی اجماع اور تواتر سے ھد ھد کی جو خبر تھی سلیمان علیہ السلام اللہ کے نبی تھے اوسکی تصدیق ہو گئی ہوگی وحی سے اج اگر کوئی یہ کہے کے باہر ایکسیڈنٹ ہو گیا ہے تو کسی کی مرضی کی وہ مانے یا نہ مانے لیکن حدیث کا معاملہ یہ نہیں ہے حدیث میں دین کا بیان ہے اس میں بات رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم کی نسبت سے بیان ہو رہی ہے جس پر ہماری دنیا اور اخرت کا انحصار ہے اوسکو قطعی الدلالہ ہونا چاہیے گمان غالب نہیں رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم ہمیں دین قران و سنت میں دے کر گئے ہیں حدیث میں اسی دین کی تفہیم و تبعین ہے حدیث رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے علم و عمل کا تاریخ ریکارڈ اور اپ صلی اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم کا اسوہ حسنہ ہے
بالکل درست۔
ویڈیو میں ھد ھد والی دلیل قوی نہیں کے۔
حضرت سلمان نے تو تحقیق سے پہلے ہد ہد کی بات کا یقین بالکل بھی نہیں کیا۔ یہ تو مثال الٹی ان کے ھی گلے پڑ جاتی ھے ایسے۔ نمل ۲۶-۲۸
hazrat Sulman ne to tehkeek k baghair yakeen ni kia hud hud ka . namal 27-28
Hud hud ne kisi paghember ki bat nhi byan ki thi@@MuhammadAdilRafique-km8nk
Ap ko quran hi nahi smaj aya....na yah smaj aya kay hafiz sahib nay is ayat kay kis point ko importance de...... Home work for u Muslim kay tawatur say sabit karo kay Aurto (opposite gender) say had shake ho sakta.... Twature or sunat say sabit kar do.
Hafiz Zubair SB ❤ Ma SHa ALLAH ❤ JazakAllah Khair hamysha Khush rahn ❤
جناب حضرت سلمان نے تو تحقیق سے پہلے ہد ہد کی بات کا یقین بالکل بھی نہیں کیا۔ حافظ صاحب یہ تو مثال الٹی آپ کے ھی گلے پڑ جاتی ھے ایسے۔ نمل ۲۶-۲۸
When ghamidi followers can't defend their ustad they say you can't understand the depth of ghamidi's knowledge 😂😂😂
😂😂😂 😂
@@uzair-v8f Tereko dimag k ilaj ki zaroorat hai bhai 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
@faizs9676 Yes
Yehi sach hai.. ye kal k bachon ka itna intellect he nai k wo ghamdi sb ko samjh sakain..
@@Adnanakber-u1u 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂 maine jo kaha vo sach sabit hua. Ghamidi k chooze jab ghamidi ka difa nahi kar pate hai to kuch aisa hi bhokte hai 😂
Dr Hafiz zubair is one of our diamond 💎. Respect for you both
Jzk
True❤❤
Ma sha Allah...so nice of you....both ma Sha Allah great work ...
Bahut ala logic bayan ho raha .buht mazrt k sath jis k hamy koi smjh nahi hain
ﷲ تعالٰی ہدایت دے غامدی صاحب کو،
آمین۔اللہ تعالی ھم سب کو ھدائیت عطا فرمائے اور دین کا درست فہم عطا فرمائے
حضرت سلمان نے تو تحقیق سے پہلے ہد ہد کی بات کا یقین بالکل بھی نہیں کیا۔ یہ تو مثال الٹی ان کے ھی گلے پڑ جاتی ھے ایسے۔ نمل ۲۶-۲۸
Always waiting for your vedio sir ❤
بالکل درست ہے کہ غامدی صاحب سمجھ نہیں آتے !😆
May Allaah bless you both ❤
Good to see you both sharing the same table.
Happy to see them both together
غامدی صاحب صرف لبرلز اور سیکولرز کی ہی سمجھ میں آتے ہیں
جس کو جو چیز اچھی لگتی ہے مانے بیٹھا ہے
اللہ سے اپنا تعلق مضبوط کرنے کی بجائے ان بحثوں میں ڈال دیا ہے جس کا پوچھا ای نہیں جانا
جس کا مقصد ہی نہیں ہے
سادی زندگی گزارنی چاہیے اللہ کی عبادت کی حقوق العباد پورے کیے
سیدھا جنت میں
بات ختم
Ghamidi sb stance on Quran sunnat n hadees is very strong zubair sb is unable to defend zubair sb arguments r weak v dont learn namaz from bukhari but from parents n society this is true for roza qurbani haj zakat biggest examples of ijma n tawatur n the hujjat of quran n sunnat jazakallah
Baat cross verification ki hai when there are so many different versions from generations how to decide which one is correct baat phir wahi aajati hai
Actually his stance is pretty weak in the light of philosophy of history. But Pakistanis in general do not have the acumen to comprehend these matters and they follow their favourite personalities blindly (be it Ghamidi or an orthodox scholar).
Allah Ghamidi Saheb ko bohot lambi aur sehatmand umar ata farmain Aameen
MashaAllah, two gems together.
غامدی کو علماء تسور کرنا ہی زہنی مسئلہ کی طرف اشارہ ہے
I will accept that you have understood Ghamidi sahib. If you have watched all the lectures of Ghamidi Sahib on Meezan, just watch 50 lessons on it, then I will accept that you have understood him. I was an agnostic, by the way; those lectures are one of the biggest reasons I got my faith back by Allah's blessings, and Allah guides alone.
Brother ghamdi sahab had done blunders he is not a scholar . He said that you can skip roza if there is exam . He denied the coming of Isa alaisalam and imam mehdi . He denied the Hayat of Isa alaisalam . Brother this are the few things I have mentioned there are many others. Just because it helped you it doesn't mean ghamdi sahab is correct. You are not a scholar how can you decide that he is correct or not . And all the major scholars of Pakistan have clearly stated the mistake of ghamdi sahab . So brother instead of following ghamdi sahab blindly do some research and sit with proper scholar. Ghamdi who doest have a beard which is sunnah how can that man be a scholar and dr hafiz zubair had done full research on ghamdi sahab from 20 yrs pls stop this bullshit . He had listen all the lecture of ghmadi sahab infant he have met him personally. So have some shame and stop defending ghamdi
Well, good for you that you got saved from Godless lifestyle, now its time for you to move forward and explore your deen from Qur'an and Sunnah.
@@zeeshansiddiqui3695 what a shame you are speeding here on UA-cam. all of your allegations are either false or already answered with facts and evidence.
@MuhammadAdilRafique-km8nk then pls send me the vedio of answers brother you are just blind follower . If you have proof just send me the vedio link . Brother many vedios he clearly said isa alaisalam is dead . He said imam mehdi is just a made up story brother just go do some research go and write on UA-cam ghamdi view on imam mehdi you will get the vedio . You Ghamdi followers are most jahil
@@MuhammadAdilRafique-km8nk where you have gone you are typical blind ghamdi follower when I have asked you evidence you run away. You people have no shame brother you have told I am putting allegation. Brother I have given you evidence just go on UA-cam and write ghamdi views on imam mehdi . You will get the answer . Brother if you don't have evidence stop lying and defending ghamdi . Your ghamdi doest have a beard which is obligatory for men . How ghamdi can become if he himself is not following sunnah
0:13 Mashaallah Qaisar Bhai ki smile 😊😊❤❤❤❤
kya bhai hatti kaga raha kya dekh dekh ke?
qaiser bhai ko dekh ke khada toh nahi karte ho na?
Qaiser Bhai ko dekh ke khada toh nahi karte ho na?
ya Qaiser bhai ko dekh ke hatti laga rahe?
Thanks MAHARAJA G ❤
2 of my favorite ideologists in one video.
Two esteemed scholars… Dr. Hafiz Zubair & Sir Qasir Ahmed Raja. Alhumdulillah
غامدی صاحب کی یہ بات کہ عقیدہ خبر واحد سے ثابت نہیں کیا جاسکتا ہے بالکل صحیح ہے کیونکہ عقیدہ دلیل عقلی قطعی یا دلیل نقلی قطعی پر بنا ہوتا ہے جبکہ خبر واحد ظنی ہے
بالکل غلط۔ آپ کے فرقے کی اصل گمراہی اس اصول پر ہے کہ حدیث سے دین ثابت نہیں ہوتا (اس میں آپ کے استاد کفر تک بھی پہنچ جاتے ہیں لیکن چونکہ آپ سب خود جاہل ہیں اس لئے آپ کو معلوم نہیں ہوتا)۔
Ghamidi shb ki sunnat ki taareef khud iss he tanqeed ka shikaar hai. Riwayati hadeeth aur Ghamidian sunnat mei farq "documentation" ka he hai. Ghamidi ki sunnat mei shak ka arsa 1400 saal hai jabke Riwayati hadeeth mei shak ka arsa 200 saal hai. Aaj 1400 saal baad hum sab ek doosre ko ek makhsoos tariqay se namaz parhte huay dekhte hain, iska matlab yeh hargiz nahi hota ke yeh tariqa mutawaatir hai. Yeh amli sunnat shahaadat-e-waahid ki bunyaad pe itni aam ho sakti hai ke woh kisi daur mei mutawaatir ka libaas aurh le.
Agar khaalisatan falsafay ke aitbaar se dekhain, toh jab aap kisi aqeeday ko khabr-e-waahid ki bunyaad pe reject karte hain, toh aapko technically nabuwat mei jitne aqaid bataye hain unko bhi reject karna parega.
Kesar bhai zubair sahab dono mashallah legends h
MashaAllah Dr Muhammad Zubair buhat ilmi insan hain.
As an inquisitive Muslim, my questions about Islam were answered once I started listening to Ghamidi Sahib. He is a Blessing from Allah SWT for our times. For that, I say Alhamdo lillah..
Astaghfirullah
Astaghfirullah
What were your questions?
I would recommend Muhammad Hijab and muslim latern to critical thinkers..
Ghamdi sahab though use islamic logic to satisfy intellect but at the same time sugarcoat the aspects of religion that may be acceptable to "freethinkers"...
یار حد ہو گئ ہے میں ذاتی طور سے راجہ صاحب کی بڑی عزت کرتا ہوں ، الحاد کے خلاف انکا کام زبردست ہے۔
لیکن ہدہد کی مثال سے عقیدہ ثابت کرنا 😂 یہ واقعی کمال ہے
او توہاڈا بھلا ہو جائے 😂😂😂
غامدی صاحب کو اللہ جزائے خیر دے ۔بہت بہترین کام کرتے ہین۔آپ نے جو بات زیر بحث لائی ہے اس پر خوبصورت بحث ہوسکتی ہے۔غامدی صاحب نے اسلام کو سمجھنے کا ایک بہترین طریقہ دریافت کیا جو شاید پہلے بند پڑا تھا ۔غامدی صاحب کوئی فائنل اتھارٹی نہی ہیں جس کا برملا اظہار بھی کرتے ہیں اور تجسس و تفکر کر جو بات وہ سمجھتے ہیں سابقہ سے رجوع کر بتاتے ہیں اور یہی چیز انکو ایک منفرد مقام عطا کرتی ہے جو شاید بقیہ مکاتب فکر میں مفقود ہے۔ذخیرہ احادیث سچ میں ایک ٹڑین رکارڈ ہے ۔احادیث ایک narrated شورش یے جو حجت نہیں بن سکتا۔جبکہ قرآن واحد حجت ہے۔رہی بات سنت کی تو سنت اور حدیث دو الگ الگ چیزیں ہیں۔جبکہ عمومی طور دونوں کو ایک درجہ دیا جاتا ہے۔
حدیث اور راوی کے بغیر سنت اور اسوہ حسنہ ہم تک کیسے پہنچتا؟
😂
@rizwanhaider1248 uswa e Husna waqayi me pohanch gayi ha kia hum tak ?
@@AlphaDemonZ جی بالکل۔ اگر سو فیصد نہیں تو اس کا بیشتر حصہ
@@rizwanhaider1248 so amal kon karega ? 😥
Zubair shb gave example of hudhud which is totally wrong:
1-Hudhud was ordered by Allah to give information about the worshippers
2- even if we don't agree, that this was something god granted, Can birds lie like humans do or they have the power to decide things like us?
3- Hudhud was a single narrator and he viewed all these things right in front of him whether as in hadith there are at least 4-5 people in between.
4- hudhud gave information about what he saw or heard maybe after some time but a narrator in hadith narrates an event or saying which has happened at least 150 years ago which automatically makes it weak.
ڈاکٹر صاحب اللہ راضی ہو آپ سے
MASHAALLAH TWO GREAT MEN ON THE PLANET EARTH
extraordinary communication and control that Sulaiman (A.S.) had over creatures, granted by divine will was indeed a miracle. In contrast, Suhabi narrators of early prophetic times relied on their natural cognitive and linguistic abilities, which are limited and do not involve divine intervention. The comparison is an attempt to draw parallels between divine miracles and human storytelling to make your point.
غامدی کو زیادہ نہ سمجھنا غامدی دل میں آتا ہے دماغ میں نہیں
ڈاکٹر پروفیسر حافظ زبیر یزیدی رحمۃ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ علیہ ۔
After watching this whole programme, which includes this bit also the irony is that they still don't understand Ghamidi's point of view.
Tyjhay smaj aye hay tu tu ku ghamdi ki good ma chup kar batha live a kr bta day....tape recorder of ghamdi
Ghamidi sb per jahan koi tanqeed ho to fat se lgata hun k shayed koi bat ho jis men wazan ho, aur seekhny k liay lagata hun per shayed hi koi video 10 minutes se ziyada dekh paya hon. 5, 10 minutes men pta chal jata h k ye log un ki bat ko smjhna hi ni chahty.
@@Aqeel-t5n ghamdi has so many contradictory points thats why u ur self has not understood ghamdi. U cant even prove ur jahil ustad on itmam jahalt qanoon.
@@electronicsurdupakistan9181 kindly let me know his one contradiction and I will think about it. If I found it reasonable, will accept it otherwise will explain the reason behind that concept.
@Aqeel-t5n what is reasonable? Are u sure u will not do taweel of muhkam ayat, what is ur baseline or for u every aya can be interpreted?
یہ ہے مکتبہ غامدی کا کمال ــ نہ کوئی مسلم رہا نہ کوی اسلامی شعار ْـــ۔ ایک ہی صف میں کھڑے ہو گئے لبرلز اور غامدی کے سب یار
People here have refuted the hazrat suleiman (A.S.) wala point really well. What i'd like to elaborate on is the ijma'a and tawatur wala point. Ghamidi sahab amlan ijma'a aur tawatur say sabit sunnat sirf ussi ko samajhtay hain jo cross-culturally, from generation to generation amlan muntaqil hoti ayi hai (jesay Quran muntaqil hua hai). For example Namaz, poori muslim, there's ample evidence that muslim ummat nay by-and-large hamesha, cross-culturally namaz parhi hai (Rasul ullah SAW say pehlay tak) toh woh sunnat bangayi. Agar koi cheez Quran say wazeh tor par sabit nahi, aur amlan cross-culturally and gen to gen muntaqil nahi hui, toh usko sunnat nahi samjha jayega. Toh your point about cultural relativism and bid'at is rendered moot.
Khabr-e-ahad (chahay uskay 1,2,3 ya 4 bhi rawi hon) deen ka maakhaz nahi bansakti, kyunkay agar woh deen kay haqaiq ko bayan karrahi hoteen, toh woh kabhi bhi khabr-e-wahid nahi hoti, aik well-established (quran aur sunnat say) baat hoti. That's their line of arguments.
Inka ijm'a aur tawatur, traditional ijmaa tawatur say alag hai, kyunkay traditional ijma aur tawatur fehm ka ijma aur tawatur hota hai. Inka ijma'a o tawatur since amli hai, aur ummat nay unanimously apnay aamaal say agay barhaya hai, toh yeh epistemically qati sabit hojata hai (kind of like Quran). Akhbar e ahad on the other hand is dhanni.
Ok. So, straightening the twisted words. Sunnah of prophet hold less value than practice of subsequent generations till now. What a illogical argument.
At any given point, preserved knowledge even it's historical holds more meaning and relevance than dynamic practices over a span of 15 centuries.
@@wasimirza37 the practice of subsequent generation IS the sunnah ya Akhi.
I explained extensively how "akhbar-e-ahad" is dhanni ilm, and amlan ijma'a and tawatur say muntaqil hue sunnat is qati. Toh by definition it holds more value on epistemological grounds.
This is convenient wordplay. Ap apni merzi se apny ap ko suite kerne k liye Ijmah and Sunnah ki definitions nahi badal skty. Limiting it to only Amli-tawattur opens the door to numerous issues. Milad is celebrated cross-culturally, cross-sects, across the world, and has been for centuries. Even in KSA, so is it sunnah now? You'll have to rely on historical records in some way to realize this is a biddah.
New practices that are being introduced right now, 500 years into the future will become "sunnah" according to your standards when they become widespread and normalized lol.
Things that are "sunnah" right now might not be in the future if they are abandoned as Zubair hinted at.
There is amli tawatur (as well as tawatur of it being fard) of Hijab, mass practiced by Muslims around the world from Morocco to Indonesia, but your teacher refuses to accept this lol.
There has been amli tawatur of state-craft and state building according to sharia until only a century or two ago, but nope, Islam is secular I guess lol.
Secondly, you said "the practice of subsequent generations IS sunnah". Nope. This is what I was talking about convenient word play. Sunnah is the actions and teachings of the Prophet (SAW), period. It does not depend on the subsequent generations infinitum. Ahadith are an indispensable historical record that make us jump 1300 years back to see what the three blessed generations were doing. Today, 1400 years later, ahadith IS the source of sunnah.
Weird play of words just to say they have a different definition of what sunnah is compared to what has been considered standard for centuries. And if we go by this definition of sunnah, that itself is self-defeating. This new definition of Sunnat is "consensus that has been followed for centuries" well what has been followed was followed through hadith. At the end we're still going back to that so why do it in such a roundabout way. i don't see a point in complicating things by changing definitions and what has been standard since pretty much the beginning.
Allah sub ko zindagi day they are serving deen
Aap dono ka ilm Ghamdi Sahb k paon ki Khaaq k barabar bhi nahi
Yah payoo ku kay shaytan kay toilt kay ander hay is liya , ghamdi ka payo bi napak hay ....or koi muslam ghamdi kay napak poye say tu bohat upar hay....
میں مانوں گا کہ آپ غامدی صاحب کو سمجھ گئے ہیں۔ اگر آپ نے میزان پر غامدی صاحب کے تمام لیکچر دیکھے ہیں، اس پر صرف 50 اسباق دیکھ لیں، تو میں مانوں گا کہ آپ ان کو سمجھ گئے ہیں۔ میں ایک agnostic تھا, ویسے; وہ لیکچرز اللہ کے فضل سے میرے ایمان کی واپسی کی سب سے بڑی وجہ ہیں اور اللہ ہی ہدایت دیتا ہے۔
Translated by google
Qaisar bhai is so addictive....
sunnat and hadith are different. hadith can be a source of sunnah but you cannot equate both. Hadith was collected and started compiling at least 200 years after the death of the holy prophet(pbuh).
Brother problem with you that you have no knowledge about hadees . Brother hadees were written by the sahaba also. Imam malik hadees book which is written much before shaeeh bukhari is present with us now also . So hadees was always there with the ummah before it was oral tradition people have learnt it . Brother how you will verify something is sunnah . You will verify by seeing the hadees literature. Brother we have one special thing which is chain of narration which goes back to prophet muhammad saw. This chains is present for every hadees . Brother you are talking like non Muslims they say the same thing regarding hadees brother its sad you are Muslim and you don't the hadees collection . Brother hadees are necessary to follow quran without hadees you can't pray namaz,you can't give zakat ,you can't do hajj . All are transmitted to us thorough hadeees . So learn islam from scholars not form ghamdi
@@zeeshansiddiqui3695 first of all, I am not a ghamidi follower neither a blind follower of some other so-called scholar. Imam malik was born about 80 years after the death of the prophet (pbuh). how can he be a sahaba? first learn before preaching. understand the difference between hadith and sunnah
@@zeeshansiddiqui3695 I am not denying the importance of hadith but there are hadiths of varying level of authenticity
@kamrankhalid5180 when I said imam malik is sahaba .he is not sahaba . he is from the salaf we have his books now . He came much before imam bukhari . My main point is hadees is a part of islam . To follow quran you need hadees . In quran there are islamic rulings . But how to follow the ruling and how to amal on that you need hadees . Allah had sent prophet with book . Because to explain the quran prophet muhammad came. The interpretation of quran is there inhadees . So hadees is a credible source . If you reject hadees you can't follow Islam completely
@kamrankhalid5180 brother first understood what I am saying .sunnah is the actions,statements, silent approval of prophet muhammad saw. Where you will find sunnah . Hadees is the source of sunnah. How can you reject hadees and follow sunnah. For following sunnah you need to follow hadees
So good to see you two guys together... serving the real Islam
Biddat kabi bi ijma say muntaqil nahi hoti us ko society ka thora hisa adopt karta hay aur ahel ilm usko du aur du char ki tarah alag kar dety hain jazakalalh
Sunnat is akin to all those routine practices which we have seen and learnt from our fathers and they learned from their fathers and go on and on. Reading Namaz, fasting, paying Zakat and many practices were all learned from our parents and they learnt from their parents. Widespread use of written knowledge is only a phenomenon of only less than of 400 - 500 years. Before that everything is learned and taught from observation let along at the time of Holy Prophet PBUH
Qaisar bhai is a 💎 💎
Meny boht Dafa khali u zehn ho kr Ghamdi Sahb pr jo tanqeedat ki jti h suni h taa k haq jan sako lekin hmesha mayosi hoi k on k makhlafeen siwaye tbasry k kuch zyada on pr naqd nhi kr sky
Sweet podcast but i wanna suggest to mention a good book in every video that open door of knowledge and thoughts for standing up
Different sources sy baqaida research or itny saal deen prh ky phur jamia guftago bnti....
Apko prhna hy to phly hades hi prh ly sahih kia khbr wahid matwatr kia... Is trha agy agy rasty khulty jy gy..... Hafiz zubair ky hi bhut sy courses hin.... Aisy basic sy strt kry.... More valid content arabic min hy....
@@mutahira999 Thanks for suggestions brother Islam teacher ke sath parna chaheye aur hadeeth ka ilm to phir boht mushkil hay sirf book aur arabic se ni hotha but mein political science aur philosphy ki book ki taraf ishara kar raha tha QAR ko
Ghamidi sb se me ikhtilaf rakhta hu bahut se mamle me..lekin unse seekhne ko bhi bahut kuch mila hai .
Mujhe bhi ghamidi sahab ki bahut se aara se shadeed ikhtilaf hai lekin wo is Daur e jadeed ke bade logo me se hai.
Sirf accha insaan hona kafi nahi hota balki Islam ko sahi tanazur me samajhna aur samjhaana zaruri hai, sath hi salaf saleheen ki nahij ko bhi nahi chhodna hai.
@zaidqureshi. Mei bilkul aap hi ki tarah Ghamidi sahab ke baare mei yehi moqaf rakhta hu.
@@mukald hr kisi ko apna tanazur Quran or Hadith k mutabik sahi hi lgta hai
راجہ صاحب اور حافظ زبیر تھوڑا بہت علمی انداز رکھتے ہیں ۔ مایوسی ہوئی ان کی گفتگو سن کے ۔ اگر زمانہ پہلے والا ہوتا جہاں دوسرے کا موقف جاننے کے لیے دس کتابیں دیکھنی پڑتی تھیں ، تو ان حضرات کو شک کا فائدہ دیا جا سکتا تھا کہ انہوں نے فطرت کے بارے صاحب کو پورے موقف کا جانا نہیں ۔ لیکن اب تو ہر موضوع پر 23 اختلافات سیریز موجود ہے ۔ آپ اگر ایک گھنٹہ ویڈیو دیکھ لیتے تو اس خفت سے بچ جاتے جو آپ کے اعتراضات کے جوابات کے طور پر غامدی صاحب کے موقف پر مبنی ہیں اور آپ کے اس پوڈ کاسٹ کے جواب میں یو ٹیوب پر لگائی گئی ہے ۔ اگر آپ تھوڑی تحقیق کرتے تو آپ کو ضرور غامدی صاحب کی فکر پر بہتر تنقید مل جاتی ۔
May Ghamdi saab live long, he has given a very clear and logical direction for understanding rel8gion, whereas the typical molvies drain energies repeating the same old fallacies
Example of hud hud for explaining authenticity of hadees. Waah. Kya kehnay. Kooi rabt aur تعلق hee nahin hai baat ka. Why do they criticize Ghamdi sb. Just talk of your understanding of religion. Stop taking names of people.
Mojzay ko utha kr insano pe fit krdiya 😂
حضرت سلمان نے تو تحقیق سے پہلے ہد ہد کی بات کا یقین بالکل بھی نہیں کیا۔ یہ تو مثال الٹی ان کے ھی گلے پڑ جاتی ھے ایسے۔ نمل ۲۶-۲۸
Fundamental point khabr-e-waahid ki reliability ka hai. Aapke paas jawaab na hona iss argument ko nullify nahi karta.
Kya ek mutawaatir khabr behtar hai khabr-e-wahid se? Bilkul. Kya khabr-e-waahid pe kabhi bharosa kya ja sakta hai. Bilkul, agar kuch conditions meet hon toh.
@@philosopher-x lekin agar ak rawayat me 4-5 ravi hon or hr ravi bat ko alfaz badal k apny alfaz me byaan kr rha ho or koi pori bat byan kr rha ho koi jis ko 30-40 saal baad jitni yad reh gai ho utni byaan kr rha ho to asi bat pe yakeen krny k liye us baat ko us kitab or us amal (Sunnat) pe parkhana zarori hai jo bialajma or Qool e twatur / amli twatur se Muhammad Rasool Allah se hi hum tk muntikal hua hai jis me shak ki koi gunjayash ni hai.
@@philosopher-x Hazrat Salman ne b hud hud ki khabar e wahid ka yakeen ni kia jb tk tehkeek ni kr li. namal 27,28
غامدی صاحب ایک حقیقی سکالر اور وضع دار انسان ہیں اللہ پاک ان کی عمرمیں برکت ڈالے۔
ameen
Ghamdi sahib aik farigh admi hen. Fitna hen bohat bara.
Sorry
It's your opinion.. obviously a futile one
غامدی صاحب عالم دین نہی ہیں، حیرت ہے ہم نے علاج کروانا ہو تو اچھے سے اچھا ڈاکٹر ڈھونڈنے ہیں لیکن دین کے معاملے میں غامدی جیسے لوگوں پر اعتماد کر لیتے ہیں
ان حضرات میں شاید یہ جرآت ہی نہیں ہے کہ غامدی صاحب کی 23 اعتراضات والی سیریز دیکھ سکیں یا کم از کم ان کی کتاب میزان کا بغور مطالعہ کر سکیں۔ حافظ صاحب کی غامدی صاحب پر سطحی تنقید پر مبنی کتاب کا محترم جناب عاصم مغل صاحب نے بہت اچھا رد کیا ہے۔ قیصر احمد راجہ صاحب سے گزارش ہے کہ حافظ صاحب سے پوچھنے کی بجائے 23 اعتراضات والی سیریز خود دیکھیں اور پھر غامدی صاحب پر علمی تنقید کریں۔ ورنہ لوگ یہی سمجھیں گے کہ قیصر راجہ صاحب دوسروں کی نظر سے غامدی صاحب کو سمجھتے ہیں۔ اگر وہ غامدی صاحب کو خود پڑھنا اور سمجھنا نہیں چاہتے بلکہ دوسروں کے سہارے اپنے آپ کو بہلانا چاہتے ہیں تو ان کے لیے خاموش رہنا ہی بہتر ہے۔
MaShaALLAH ap dono ko dekh kr acha laga, request hai, hum mazeed apko ek sath dekhna chahte hain
قیصر راجہ آپ نے نہیں سمجھا یہ سوفیصد ٹھیک بات ہے
in bhai ne bahot Acha explain kea 👍👍
My appeal to every Muslim, my brother or sister, the owner of the channel, I know that it is not my right to comment on your channel, but God is my witness that our circumstances are harsh and forced me to do this. Please forgive me. My brother, there is still a brotherhood of faith. I asked you for a bag of flour. My brother, we women cannot go out among men. There is still a woman with you. My brother, God has honored you. You are men. We are women. We cannot go out or work like you. My brother, where is the brotherhood of faith in your hearts? We are women. There is no brotherhood, no mercy, no compassion, no humanity. And give good tidings to the patient. It is the greatest hope while waiting for what we want. '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' How many times I called and talked and tried hard, but no one responded. Oh man, we are with you. My mother ordered us food from the restaurant. More and today. My mother left. Crying. She said, Why are you crying, my mother? She said, My daughter, I ask. God, that I may be honored by death. She said, Why, my mother. She cursed us. She said, "My daughter, today the restaurant owner insulted me. I said, 'Why?' I said, 'How can I be better than people?' I ask God, my daughter. May God gather me. With death alone, a gathering that is better than this humiliation and this humiliation. It is true. I am saying this. It diminishes my value and respect. But, man. I swear to God that I did not say this. I kiss your boots. I am so hungry that my conscience no longer allows me to let you go and ask us for food. I kiss your boots, man, and I ask you by God Almighty and in the Book of God, man, I kiss your boots, man. He has caused us harm, my brother, so that we can buy a kilo of flour and pay the rent. My brother, have mercy on us. He who is in the show will have mercy on you, He who is in the sky. My brother, this is my WhatsApp number: 00967711500090. Whoever can help us, message me on WhatsApp. We will send him the full name. He will transfer us as much as he can. May Allah reward you. Allah knows that my family and I, our house rent is 20 thousand Yemeni riyals per month, and now we owe 60 thousand for 3 months. The owner of the house is one of those people who do not have mercy. By Allah, my brother, he comes every day and humiliates us and talks about us and wants to throw us out of the house and into the street because we were unable to pay him the rent. We will have until the end of the week, and if we pay him, he will swear by Allah that he will throw us out into the street without mercy. See my situation for yourselves. I ask you by Allah, the Living, the Eternal, to help me. By Allah, the Almighty, even at night we cannot sleep from fear. We do not have mattresses or blankets to warm ourselves from the cold. Everything is flooded from the rain, and we have no one but Allah and then you. My brothers, I kiss your boots, don’t turn me away empty-handed. Help us with whatever you can. Is it acceptable to you that we live in this place? We are girls and we have no one. Our father died in a car accident. Consider us your daughters and your honor, and help me with whatever you can. May God reward you with good =>[[}>] ^][/*&;;&;&&;•̥·-`.`.`.`.`.•.,¸-•.,¸°꒰·̮ •̥·°`.`.`.`.`.,.•¯,.•¯}:;:;:;;::;;::;;::;;-,'-|.................،,..،،,,,,,,,,،،،،،،،,,,،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،,،،،،،،،،،،،،,,،،،،،،،,,,،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،،
Aslamoalikum ❤
Great 🎉
حضرت سلیمان علیہ السلام اللہ کے نبی ہیں۔ نبی کو اللہ کی طرف سے تصدیق مل جاتی ہے اس لیے یہاں خبر واحد سے متعلق آپ کا استدلال درست نہیں ہے جس کا اطلاق احادیث پر نہیں ہو سکتا کیوں کہ نہ راوی نبی ہیں اور نہ ہی محدثین نبی ہیں۔
@adarabi3149 for the sake of the argument, let's assume your justification. So tell me Know, you will put Mr Ghandi in which category? And from where on earth he obtains the knowledge?
محترم انبیاء کرام علیہم السلام کو تصدیق اللہ تعالیٰ کی طرف سے ملتی ہے اور یہاں بھی تصدیق اللہ تعالیٰ ہی کر رہا ہے۔ ہد ہد کی زبان سے الفاظ اللہ تعالیٰ نے ہی حضرت سلیمان علیہ السلام تک پہنچائے
@@omerjaved-hk7xd محترم غامدی صاحب غیر جانبدار اور ایماندار عالم دین ہیں۔ وہ قرآن کے نزول کے زمانے کے اعلیٰ ادب اور اس کی زبان پر درک رکھتے ہیں اور اس زمانے کے انداز تکلّم سے بخوبی واقف ہیں۔ اس کے علاوہ اُن کے ہاتھ سے سیاق و سباق کا دامن نہیں چھوٹنے پاتا۔ اُن کی یہی خوبیاں اُن کو اپنے ہم عصر علماء سے ممتاز بناتی ہیں۔ اگر آپ کو صحیح معنی میں اُن پر تنقید کرنی ہے تو پہلے آپ خود کو ان مذکورہ محاسن سے مزیّن کریں پھر اس وادی میں قدم رکھیں، آپ کا خیر مقدم ہے۔
تو پھر کیا کہنا چاہتے ہیں؟@@muhammadimran-kv6ou
Sunnat musalmano kay amal may hay practical amal may hud hud ki khaber Allah kay nabi ko hay wahi say tasdeeq ho gi ho gi agar koi kahy kay bahir accident ho gia tu koi yaqeen karay ya na kary magar hadees tu deen hay us ko qati hona chahia kyon kay wo hamary Nabi PBUH ki khaber hay jis per inhisar hay dunya ur akhirat ka us ko qati hona chahia guman ghalib nahi
You mean prophet religion is determined by the nonprophets (muhadseen), you people are unintentionally damaging the sources of Islam that is Quran & Sunnat. That's it!
It's not about believing or not believing in Hades, it's about the content of Hades.
Sweeping statements are not enough for people to say they don't understand him, let discuss the arguments of Ghamidi Sahab exactly the way he addresses them and then criticize him, otherwise, you are only criticizing yourself not him, and wasting our time.
If you do this, doesn't matter if I convinced or not but at least in this way knowledge keeps on going and at least we gain something from you and expectedly get back to the right direction if we were wrong.
JazakAllah ❤️
Both of you are the best and keep up the good work because it is an age of hypocracy and the hypocrates are trying their level best to explain Islamic rituals in context of western interest
❤QAR❤ and ❤Dr. Zubair Sb❤
اب تک میں جتنا بھی حافظ صاحب کی غامدی صاحب پر ت قید کو سنا ہے میں یقین سے کہہ سکتا ہوں کہ حافظ صاحب کو غامدی صاحب کی بات نہیں سمجھ آتی۔ یا مسئلہ کچھ اور ہے۔ 😊
غامدی صاحب سے آپکا بنیادی اختلاف فہم قرآن اور فہم حدیث پر ھے۔ اس پر میں نے بار بار آپ کو بھی سنا ھے اور غامدی صاحب کو بھی ۔ غامدی صاحب 100% درست معلوم ھوتے ھیں۔
Asalamalikum sir can you do a video of book recommendations on different topics such as atheistism secularism comparative religion
MashaAllah❤❤❤
جو صاحب اپ نے بٹھائے ہوئے ہیں ان سے پوچھیں کہ جن باتوں پے ان کو اختلاف ہے غامدی صاحب سے ان پے ان کا اپنا موقف کیا ہے نا کے ان کے بابوں کا
ہد ہد کی مثال نے آپ کی تمام گفتگو پر پانی پھیر دیا
افسوس ہوا اور یقینا بہت افسوس ہوا
Qaisar Ahmad raja zindabad 🎉
May Allah bless ustad imam Javed ahmad Ghamidi sahab long healthy life ❤
أراحَنا الله منه عاجلا غير آجل
حضرت سلمان نے تو تحقیق سے پہلے ہد ہد کی بات کا یقین بالکل بھی نہیں کیا۔ یہ تو مثال الٹی ان کے ھی گلے پڑ جاتی ھے ایسے۔ نمل ۲۶-۲۸
Islam is oneness and it's all above cultures
قیصر بھائی دی گریٹ ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Ghamidi sahib bht c chezon mein sahi hain lekin meri trh wo b bht c chezon mein khud confuse hain. Aur wo apne followers ko b confuse kr rhy hain. Aik naya firqa bna rhy hain, jese engineer sahib ne aik naya firqa bnaya hai. Allah abko hidayat ata frmae
ویڈیو کے اختتام پر ڈاکٹر صاحب نے فرمایا کہ چونکہ 90 فیصد امت نماز نہیں پڑھتی اور جھوٹ بولتی ہے، تو وہ تعامل بن جائے گا۔ حیرت ہے ویسے ایسی سوچ پر۔ کیا کبھی کسی نے نماز نہ پڑھنے اور جھوٹ بولنے کو دین کے طور پر بیان کیا ہے؟ یہ اب چونکہ زیادہ تر لوگ جھوٹ بول رہے ہیں اور نماز نہیں پڑھ رہے، تو اب سے یہ دین ہے؟ کمال ہے۔
اور وہ جو سامنے بھائی "مسٹر افلاطون" صاحب بیٹھے ہیں، وہ صرف سر ہلا رہے ہیں۔ مجال ہے کہ کراس سوال کر رہے ہوں کہ جناب، آپ فرما کیا رہے ہیں؟
😂janab aap Kai ghamdi Sahab ki yahi logic hai. Hadith Nahi balqai logo Kai amal KO dekh Kar namaz fardh hoi hai. Waise agar Dekha jai Tou wo to apni hi baat sai contradicts Kar rahen kyun Kai musalman hadith ko bhi Deen Ka hisa samjhte a rahen hain.tu yai bhi ijma ummat sai sabit hai. Aur un Kai buhut sai aqaid wo hai jo ummat mai kbhi pai hi Nahi Jate the.
غامدی صاحب سے اختلاف کرتا کوئی نا جائز بات نہیں ، آ پ بحر حال انسان ہیں لیکن اس نے دین کی خدمت بھی بڑی جرات سے کی ہے ۔ اس کی بھی قدر کرنی چاہیے ۔
ہمارا ایک اجتماعی مسئلہ ہے کہ کسی عالم دین کو فرشتہ یا پھر شیطان ثابت کرنے کی کوشش کر رہے ہیں جو کہ بہر دو صورت مناسب نہیں ۔
@@muhammadnazir7287 darust farmaya aapne. Koi ikhtalaf nahi,
Yahan QAR sahib se masla ye hai k ye sahib targeted tehreek chala rahe hain aur majaal hai k koi qable feham dalil kabhi pesh ki ho khud se
غامدی تو کہتا ہے نماز پڑھنا نہ پڑھنا برابر ہے 😂😂😂
قیصر بھائی، شام کی صورتحال پہ ویڈیو بنائیں۔ کوئی کہ رہا باغی غلط، کوئی کہ رہا حکومت غلط تھی۔ حقیقت کیا تھی۔؟؟؟؟
أقرأ باسم ربك الذي خلق
یہ پہلی وحی ہے یہ بات منکرین حدیث کیسے ثابت کریں گے🤔
@@IrfanShaikh-kx1nt ghamdi is ka bhi inkari karta he k yeh ayat phli wahi he.
@pakexperiment876 غامدی بتائے پھر نزول قرآن کی ابتداء کہاں ہوئی کس آیت سے ہوئی اور دلیل قرآن سے ہونی چاہیے کیونکہ حدیث تو یہ مانتے نہیں۔
@@IrfanShaikh-kx1nt Bhai us ki apni mantiq he. Us ka kaam sirf logo k dimagh men shako shubhat dalna he .
@@pakexperiment876acha Ji bahu say shadiyan tu aap log karwa Rahay ho 😂.
@@pakexperiment876Pori ummah iss waqt Nabi asli kay videos dekh rahee hai all with authentic references. 😂. Zameen sakin hai by ex Muslims of North America. 😂
yaad rakhein Allah ko jawab dena hai har accusation ka.
Just watch two short videos:1. "Sunnat ki Nauyat ka
faisla-Ghamidi'; 7 minute 39 second video
2. Sunnat kia hai Ghamidi" 11minute 8 second video!
these few minutes will be enough for you to prove why you are misrepresenting.
قرآن و سنت اجماع اور تواتر سے منقل ہوئے ہیں۔ اجماع سے مراد کسی بات پر اتنے لوگوں کا جمع ہوجانا ہے کہ ان کا کسی غلط بات پر جمع ہونا عقلاً محال ہو۔ جبکہ تواتر سے مراد یہ ہے اس عمل میں تسلسل ہو، کوئی انقطاع نہ ہو۔ اب سوال یہ پیدا ہوتا ہے کہ کسی عمل پر اجماع اور تواتر ثابت کیسے ہوگا؟ اس کا جواب یہ ہے کہ ویسے ہی ثابت ہوگا جیسے تاریخی چیزیں ہوا کرتی ہیں۔ ہم اس زمانے کے آثار دیکھیں گے، تصنیفات دیکھیں گے، فقہاء کی رائے دیکھیں گے، اخبار احاد بھی دیکھیں گے۔ اور ہماری علمی تاریخ تو ایک درخشندہ تاریخ ہے کسی سے ڈھکی چھپی تو نہیں۔ وگرنہ تو یہ سوال بھی بنتا ہے کہ قرآن بھی رسولاللہ سے براہ راست ہمیں موصول نہیں ہوا۔ تو کیا پورا قرآن بھی روایات سے ثابت ہوتا ہے؟
Two strangers in wisdom would 😮
جب علماء اور دانشور لوگ غامدی کو نہیں سمجھ سکتے تو عوام کیسے سمجھ سکتے ہیں جن میں غامدی کے فالورز بھی شامل ہیں۔
The biggest question muslims should be asking to themselves should be: If we have the ultimate divine truth revealed to us, then why almost all Muslim societies in the world are dysfunctional at all levels, not to mention ethical and moral derrogation??
To find answers, we need people like Ghamidi who have the ability to see in a skeptical way everything that has been done in last 14 centuries and at the same time have courage to point out everything.
I don't mean any disrespect to anyone, but people like Qaiser Raja are more prone to convincing people that the problem lies with them i-e apke aqaid thek nhn hn, apka emaan durust nhn ha" in order to tap on guilt button of masses which help them gain audience and some drama!!
introduced parents to Ghamdi 8 yrs ago.
regret it today.
trying to get them away now.
he's very popular here in the US.
still I'm not as knowledgeable.
The two legends on screen!
You both should join hands. Great 👍
great
محترم غامدی صاحب کا فہم وفراست بہت گہرا ہے ہر کسی کے سمجھنے کی چیز نہیں ہے
MashAllah Great Personalities❤
Mic 🎤 sitting not good ❤ but I love you
With due respect to both respected persons ..Inki baatein sun kar ye Lagta hai ke yaa to inki fahem mein koi kami hai ya Phir ye taassub (bias)ke buri tarah se shikaar hain..
we expect discussion on
Theorotical science and philosophy of different sects of Hinduism for self realisation and peaceful bright future of human and World with
Ex Hindu awaz e haq uncensored
Ex Hindu islamic awakening
Ex Hindu elaina ali
Ex Hindu haneen mukhtar
To know the truth😊❤😊❤
Pori video kaha h? ..
I am wondering how a bird not only is speaking but has the abilities of understanding & analysis as well! Was it really a bird???
ایک پیغمبر کے لیے اطلاع کو ایک عام کے لیے اطلاع کے کیسے برابر کر دیا۔ آپ پیغمبر کے مقام کو نیچے کیسے لے آۓ۔
جناب یہ ھد ھد کی بات غامدی سے کیوں نھیں کھا انکے ایک شاگرد سے کھتے ھیں اور اسکو اپنی مضبوط دلیل سمجھتے ھیں عجیب بات ھے