Black Sea Grain Deal Initiative Explained | Why Russia quit exit agreement | Ukraine grain export
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 чер 2024
- In this video, we'll learn about what is the Black Sea Grain Deal or initiative, why Russia canceled it, quit the deal or exited from the deal, withdrew from it, and what is its impact. Ukraine grain export is in serious trouble what will Ukraine do with the grain?
#blacksea #ukraine #russia #grain #geopolitics
Podcast available on:-
Spotify:- open.spotify.com/show/3uMcktM...
Google Podcast:- podcasts.google.com/search/am...
UA-cam:- / amitsenguptaaks
Instagram:- / amitsengupta01
Facebook:- / amitsengupta01
Telegram:- t.me/SenguptaAmit
Quora:- www.quora.com/profile/Amit-Se...
Koo:- www.kooapp.com/profile/amitse...
Hindi Channel
/ amitsenguptahindi
-- Geography playlist
• Geography terms and de...
-- Economy playlist
• Economics
• Indian Economy - UPSC ...
-- Current Affairs playlist
• UPSC Current Affairs v...
-- Indian history playlist
• Modern History for UPS...
-- Govt of India schemes playlist
• Government of India Sc...
-- Map based learning
• Map based learning
-- Climatology playlist
• Climatology
-- Previous year solved question paper analysis
• Solved Question Papers...
-- Environment & Ecology playlist
• Environment and Ecolog...
-- International relations playlist
• International Relation...
-- Check the other playlists of NCERT Geography videos
Class 6 - goo.gl/DDFtIF
Class 7 - goo.gl/ppPK05
Class 8 - goo.gl/OD3Gwh
Class 9 - goo.gl/AIEXxQ
Class 10 - goo.gl/inWIAR
Class 11 - goo.gl/Pn5EIE
Class 11 (Part 2) - goo.gl/X4zY9K
Class 12 - goo.gl/Kszpz5
Only 2.5 % of Ukraine grain exports during the agreement actually went to African nations in need. The vast majority of Ukraine grain exports went to high income countries in Europe.
So, They even need it
Now Euorpe will buy from somewhere else and Afrcia will get very less food.
Fake news Poland and Hungry block grainshipments to the EU
You are obviously lying, Ukraine grain is banned in Europe, search for it. most of the grain goes to china and Asia. Ukr grain can go to EU by land anyway.
@@nsevvaccording to Statista -China, Spain, turkey,Italy,Netherlands are top 5 importer of grain(wheat, barley,corn) from Ukraine during Ukraine russia grain deal.and most of the Asian countries consume RICE.wheat is not main food here.
I think You need to search in Google.
@@parthjain1496es most people forget russia action will cause general food inflation and poor will suffer. Russia cruelty towards poor is unfathomable. Even inside russia all the poor and minorities are sent to war to die for putin.
Ukraine retaliated on russia outside office hours at 4am, on the other hand, russia strikes residential area in the evening when civilians and children are having dinner.
By your own words, Russia didn't cancel the agreement, they simply didn't renew it. Not the same thing.
You missed... Two Other Conditions that were part of the Grain Deal agreement that were not met by the West for 1 Year! UK/West were to re-start/ allow insurance of Russian Merchant vessels & Russia was to be allowed to use SWIFT system. None of these agreed conditions were honored by West. [UK has the largest Insurance market in world]
How keep yourself updated like this? Please guide me.
Yes, this happened since the war
Good summary .....BUT ONE factor you avoided mentioning is the millions of hectares in Ukraine owned by foreigners, that benefit form the sale of Ukrainian grains. We know from some reports that American and Europeans firms own some of this land.
How keep yourself updated like this? Please guide me.
@@aisha_siddiqah I read a number of select geopolitical newsletters and ex-government advisors almost daily. Then do research to confirm relevant points.
Exactly.
Oh that's great dear,
Can please metion some newsletter which will be helpful for me in my UPSC preparation
The oblasts of Kherson, Zapporhzhzia, Donetsk, and Luhansk are now legally considered part of Russia so all of that land is Russian state owned. This land is some of the most fertile in the world. The remainder of the land in Ukraine is state owned at the present and it remains to be seen where the final borders are drawn including the lands in the future demilitarized area as to where this land is actually located. Zelensky may think that he has sold off the heritage of the state of Ukraine to US corporations and for his own self interest at the expense of the citizens of Ukraine but that remains to be seen.
Russia didn't cancel the deal. They did not extend it as it was up for renewal.
exactly this
Yeah that's right
Yes, he said they didnt renew it
The West says that Ukraine grain is for poor African countries, but they only received less than 5%. Most Ukraine grain goes to Europe. So the deal is useless, like previous Minsk Agreements before.
Ukraine grain is banned in Europe to protect Europian farmers. You are obviously high on propaganda. Ukr is third largest supplier of grain to Africa. Most Ukr grain goes to china and Asia.
@@nsevvB S it's banned now, it wasn't banned before. Also grain in Ukraine is technically US/EU grain, because their corporations planted it.
@@nsevv only in central europe, spain, italy, france, etc. still beneficial
If Europe consume more Ukraine grain then they can get it via road and rail which share land border only African and Latin American are loosers
They are greedy
Turkey was and is not honest with not only Russia but anyone.
I agree. Ever since the shot down of the Russian pilot by the turk military it was shown that erdogan was a lame dog, a shameless traitor.
Yup Turkey 🦃 is fishy 😅😅😅
You know everything man you must be an Agent or something
Turkey is a backstabbed. India got it recently.
Sooner or latter it will be their undoing.
Russia did not cancel the Black Sea grain deal.
The deal EXPIRED
and Russia
DID NOT RENEW IT.
Same as cancel and they destroyed grain silos that were storing grain for china and Asia. China even reprimanded russia due to this.
"Same as cancel" 😂😂😂😂😂
@@Intense_CloudYes same as cancel, that is how we cancel our subscription, we let them expire.
Yeah, we know that - we've just watched Amit say that.
@@nsevv
Contracts “ expire”
No masala, no shouting, screaming or drama, no taking sides.
Just plain facts, put in a simple language.
This is what journalism is supposed to be. Kudos.
Tip : your map in the thumbnail made us click. Didn't get disappointed despite not finding anything related to what grains grown where etc shown on the map *because your script never left any room to slip the focus outside what is told.* Kudos. And kudos for your showing the undersea mines on map too. Are they accurate or just assumption?
Mines were set by Ukraine, not Russia. Ukraine no longer has a functioning navy. Look into it.
But you forget to say that most of the grain goes to European countries, not precisely to the poorest African countries
Because that is not true UKr grain is banned in Europe to protect local farmer. UKr is thrird largest supplier to Africa.
@@nsevvare you not a tire of this lie
Once again you're my go-to for explanations on these geopolitical situations. Thank you sir
02:10 - Small correction. Both Russia and Ukraine laid mines in the waters.
At 08:47 he has mentioned. No corrections required.
@@karthikmnagaleekar6323exactly. Dunno why people jump the gun!!!!!
A clear and concise summary.
Thank you Amit ❤
Africa is not impacted because wheat or bread is not our staple food, even then Russia and other wheat producers supplies most of African wheat needs
russia supply 3.5k France supplies 2.2k, Ukraine supplies 1.5k. Ukraine is 3rd largest supplier to Africa. Russia will pay for this cruel backstab and betrayal.
What is the African continent's staple diet?
@@tumultuous_cojones Cassava , millet, rice, corn, etc
@@tumultuous_cojones it varies from cassava, rice,maize, sorghum, millet, yam, peas etc depending on the country and the people
@@cushiterevenge5696 You call yourself Cushite - pls tell us more about that name. - In an Indian history epic Mahabharat (tagged as mythology), earth is mention to have 4/5 islands (continents) named Shash (rabbit), Shaak (vegetation), Kraunch (crane), and Kush (a kind of grass).
Easy to guess Rabbit is Eurasia and crane is North America.
Vegetation is probably amazonian rainforests Thus Kush can only be Africa. Later we realised, Kush could be African sawanna.
The third point was that the free grain destination to the Africa on 1/3 reached the continent the 2/3 evaporated to the Western ports .
How about reports that Russia will give it's grain for free to poor countries in need? The weapons smuggling through Odessa on these ships? Using these grain ships as cover for Black Sea attacks on Russia? Grain was said to not going to the places in need in the first place (going to the EU)
Russia actually raised its prices for grain to Africa.
@@nsevv Not Russia's fault but because of the sanctions that made insurance fees many times higher and caused many other problems too.
@@learning7140😂😂
@@nsevv no it did not lol only the exporter did ince due to sanction rus could not sell by themselves.
@@learning7140yes Russia need to stop this war now
A "key" demand by Moscow is the re-connection of the Russian agricultural bank to SWIFT. It was cut off by the EU June 2022. It has greatly hindered transactions for Russian exports of grain and fertilizer to Africa. The EU/GB/US are creating the food crises. Not Russia.
It is always Great to see another fellow Truth Seeker like Amit fighting the good fight!
Very well explained....Thank you
Ukraine also uses the traffic shipment commodity to blow up Russia's bridge. One thing you didn't mention in your narrative. GREAT JOB LIKE ALWAYS YOUR CHANNEL IS VERY INFORMATIVE
Russian bridge that was built on Ukraine territory, correct? That bridge?
@@alexbrown5110 USSR Territory
@@moonlighmax USSR doesn't not exist since 1991 and Crimea belongs to Ukraine. So, bridge was built on Ukrainian land illegally. What was the point of your comment @moonlighmax?
@@alexbrown5110 Anglo Empire doesn't exist too but I can see they still expanding using the name of NATO. Anglo imperialism is dangerous for the world.
@@moonlighmax you know that joining NATO is optional and there is clear path to do that for any country. NATO expansion in 1997 was a way for Baltic states to have security from Russia. Baltic states were forcefully added to USSR in 1939 and NATO is insurance this doesn’t happen again. Take imperialism out of your head. It clouds your judgment. Or perhaps it’s lack of knowledge on your behalf?
I like how Amit sir exposes western dupIicity in each video.....👍👌
He exposed putin hypocrisy and double standards. Ukraine grain is banned in Europe to protect Europian farmers. You are obviously high on propaganda. Ukr is third largest supplier of grain to Africa. Most Ukr grain goes to china and Asia.
Clear and straight forward
Thank you Amit.. 🙏
You forgot 1 major factor which was the attack on the Crimea bridge. Russia was accusing Ukraine was using grain ships to launch unmanned surface vehicles and others marine weapons from them.
Thank you, Amit...
Odessa is not the only Black Sea port where panamax vessels can be berthed. Burgas, Varna and Constanta also
He meant in Ukraine
Yes he meant in Ukraine. Please don't jump the gun 🔫
People of Europe should be more self dependent . You can listen music in your mobile , or in other gadgets otherwise under pressure , you may be asked to listen same music attending at fm radio studio for no reason .
Similarly , if Europe expects Ukraine food grains deal will help them to Hogg foods for Africa on the way of shipping vessels move from there place s , is not at all fair expectation .
If Europe feels so hungry they can enter in Ukraine & grab foods sitting over there and return back to Europe . Due to wastage of food grains , Dipak & Vikram offered free of cost foodgrains & cooking materials to run Dhabas in Ukraine . They though denies the truth . Ask all credits for themselves ( that they are funding moneys from there own pocket to run the food charity in Ukraine ) like tipical avarage indian beggars in foreign soils .
Europe is welcome inside !!
Europe should experience the truth as well as test of real Ukraineian food grains in indian cuisine !
Welcome .
11:37 1 11:37
Ok. I thought he mean in whole Black Sea. My bad.
VERY INFORMATIVE WE THANK YOU!
As alex christophorou pointed out, part of the deal was opening swift for russian agriculture bank. Its a press of a button. They didnt Do it.
Russia specifically said sanction and SWIFT restrictions makes russia strong. 2ndly those SWIFT restrictions were lifted but russia launched more attacked which automatically led to more sanctions and SWIFT restrictions placed.
@@nsevv No, the SWIFT restrictions were never lifted. They dropped the equivalent of the atomic bomb of economy on Russia, yet the Russian economy survived somehow! But the radiation will kill it slowly.
Don't fool yourself. The sanctions were planned out beforehand by the Anglo-American Empire (decisions are made in London too, not only in Washington) in order to defeat Russia through economic war in a few months, because they thought Russia would win militarily and occupy much of Ukraine. The opposite happened: Russia didn't succeed in its Special Military Operation, yet its economy survived.
Do you care about Ukraine? You should be asking for permanent neutrality, like Finland in 1948. It lasted long enough for Finland - 75 years before it broke the Treaty it signed and joined NATO.
Thank you! Most helpful.
Yes, I found it informative 👍. Thank you! 😊
Thank you for the wonderful video sir
It will be interesting to connect 1. Saudi oil cuts 2. China rare earth and metals export ban 3. Russia terminating grain deal 4. India rice ban
Is it synchronized in any way? Is it BRICS+ in action?
Your analysis is appreciated. Thank you. 😊😊😊
It's not synchronized, its simply a causal effect.
the west is saved by africa as always
US and EU sanctioned Russia. Now Russia with BRIKS going to sanction all warld.
@@GP99911 it's actually the opposite, the world is being sanctioned by the WEST, as sanctioning one is basically sanctioning all, while BRICS is an alternative for those countries currently sanctioned by the WEST.
Your layman's analysis is too useful. Helped me understand this grain deal better
Amazingly explained sir🎉
The best explanation❤
Russia did not cancel the grain agreement. after three extensions by russia, it expired this month and russia did not renew it because the other parties were not honoring their end of the agreement.
Sir you are very famous nowadays among Upsc aspirants,
Keep going with this quality content 👍
Keep uploading videos related to international relations sir, we are waiting for it.
Thank you
Excellent Research
A good analysis of the situation .However ,the analysist missed a major and vital point as to why RF withdrew.Ukraine behind the grain deal was utilising merchant ships for commando attacks on Kerch bridge which led to Russian civilian casualties recently.Further Odessa port was used by British and Nato base to launch drone attacks on sevatopol etc thereby making the agreement meaningless.This is perhaps the main issues behind withdrWal and subsequent attacks on Odessa and Danube ports
Another problem with the rail option is this; Ukraine's rail system was built under Tzar Nicholas the I. This means that the trains in Ukraine can't go into Europe because of a slight difference between the rails in Europe and Russia/Ukraine. Unless Ukraine updated their rails. I doubt.
How keep yourself updated like this? Please guide me.
Very informative. Thank you.
Thank you Sir
Thanks Amit
Excellent
Excellent Interpretation Amit.
Well explained, doesn't sound like one sided media narrative
that was some explanation🔥
Thanks for your information
🇮🇳🇮🇳 jai hind sir 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Super Explanation 👏👏
Yes of course,Amit is all ways super informative.
You are very right in your narrative
Very nice explanation.
Very informative
Thanks 😊
Informative video sir
Very informative video Sir. Thank you so much for your efforts sir🙏🙏
Well explained!
Excellent sir
Thankyou sir
Well done bros
Well articulated
Very informative and interesting 👍🏾
you are the best man
Why can't they export the grains in the way they are importing the arms.
😂😂😂
They are. But this grain is mostly bought by china.
This is a very good xplanation
Good summary… but you forget to mention that Ukraine is major contributor to UN food aid programs.
Why don't you come up with structured course videos for geo
Well said
100%informative
Nice explain sir this topic ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
You forgot to mention that the Russian ammonia pipeline was destroyed on the territory of Ukraine after the grain deal have started, so the conditions of the grain couldn’t be fulfilled.
As for the second point - Putin already announced at the African forum that Russia is ready to supply its grain to Africa countries for free. He also mentioned that only 2% of the grain exported through the deal reached Africans countries, all the rest went to the western market that is why he didn’t consider it helped against hunger.
Excellent contain
Can you please make a video on the judicial reforms in Israel and why the sides are at such opposite sides of the spectrum.
Many thanks for your objective and high quality videos 😊😊
Now, that's a boost to the inflation in the US and Europe. What a magnificent reason to continue raising rates by the Fed.. to retain investment in the US otherwise the outflow could be unimaginable 😮
2:06 sir,I like ur teaching but I always has to wait for ur videos, where my other friends already has knowledge from other source. My pray to u is kindly try to upload ur teaching as soon as possible. Thank u sir.
If your wer my history lecture i will pass will fly colors keep up informative news you are one of the kind
Good
Please increase the consistency and upload asap
Thank you sir
Amit does a great job.
"asap" 😄 what sort of prick says that?
Oh, you do.
Before the war, most of the grain from Ukraine was going to Third World countries, but since the war, the majority goes to Europe.
Because actually, it’s not important that the grain goes directly to Africa but it’s more important that the green is on the market.
Because green sold like gold with an act, of course who is changing every second.
The market for green is always either the same or bigger than last year, because they are more and more people on this planet, and even when there is one percent less than normally on the market test it is high impact on the price, and this price is payable for us Europeans, but not for Third World countries.
How keep yourself updated like this? Please guide me.
Russia❤
❤
Sir how to make daily editorial notes?? I am a beginner and have just started UPSC preparation. I'm having trouble making notes...sir please give some solution...waiting for your response..
The UN and Turkey were disingenuous . I am in total agreement with Russia; agreements must be held up; people need to honour their words.
What is ordinance bill ?
Sir please make a video on the situation of Russia Ukraine war and west's stand on it
Sir, I heard the same voice on FirstPost news channel with Palki Sharma. Is that you ??💓💓💓
💕💕💕
Amit can you do a video on why India is not backing the BRICS gold currency thx
I think Ukraine can get help from Romania, it's only 300~600km from Ukraine.
Russia has foreseen this and has bombed the Reni port near Romania already.
No, you cannot bomb Russian ammonia pipeline and arm Ukraine, using Russian kind agreement in the Grain deal. Russia asked for safety of the ammonia pipeline, as one of the points in the Grain deal.
Where did you get the information that Russia places mines in the Black Sea?
If someone doesn't playing by rules why would Russia be playing by rules? RU given time (as with 8 years of Minsk 2) and now not renew grain deal cause not all points of the deal is working... that's all.
Anyone angered by this move could f off.
I thought Rus is exporting from the Baltic sea route. I saw some news like that.
They can't. Baltic is just a nato sea now. They export oil via the Baltic though
👍🏻
It cant donate if it cant export
at the moment, anything could be the one of factor of territory defence. There is "no trusty" anymore.
I love you amit
👍
Succinct explanation
War doesn't give us any advantage instead of disadvantages