What I love most was that these two soliders did not mesh well together for most of the film, but they were both in perfect synchronization during this scene: they both recognized the situation and trust the other one to play his part.
@Brian Waas Certainly SS children would be the first children in a class to jump up and Sieg Heil, even if no one said Heil Hitler. Also, Brian, BTW, there were French SS men, some in fact fought in the Battle for Berlin in the Reichstag.
The food may be good, the conversation polite. But a new order, and a new dispensation has been granted. One that need not ask permission, say 'please', much less beg. Judgement Day has come.
Yeah, this film deserves more love. It's pretty good, maybe a bit slow or misleading at times. Like, I think some folks might have been going in thinking they were gonna see more Saving Private Ryan or Band of Brothers kind of battles with these guys in it.
@@Muzical-Man Oh, George, you know that Mr. Colt has been playing a supporting role in various military dramas since 1911, from Mexico to Belleau Wood, Guadalcanal, Tunisia, Sicily, Italy, Normandy, the Ardennes, Berlin, Pusan, Chosin, Ia Drang, and Hue, and since then still turned in a great, but limited performance in Kuwait, Iraq and Afghanistan. And Mr. Colt is still around. He never got the big awards and accolades, but he was a solid and reliable performer, and he still turns up from time to time even now when he's needed. Mr. Colt is anything but a "newcomer."
The Nazis had been in power since 1933. These kids are probably younger than 10. It’s 1943. They grew up in a totalitarian dictatorship. No independent schools, no independent newspapers, propaganda at every corner of every village. Gestapo, the secret state police, capable of targeting anyone they wanted or knew about. If a young German child in Nazi Germany doesn’t say this stuff when being greeted in this manner during this period, it is very likely to be deaf. Even though slightly more than half of the population never voted for the NSDAP and not everyone who did was a fierce, fanatical party member, nearly all children born during the reign of the Nazis that were old enough to understand basic concepts, would have given this response.
Well if he did, he probably wouldn't have suggested the Americans go to his cottage. At least the Nazi should have re-framed the portraits. Not as good at hiding them as the ones who put the art work in the caves.
I love the scene where they introduce the Uncle. He's a jolly fellow who laughs when Bill Murray says not to make him angry as he digs in Murrays teeth.
I had to stop it after the flamethrower scene. I just burst into a violent fit of tears. The scene stunned me; my reaction stunned me. But I had to take about half an hour to recover enough to keep watching the film. I adored it, but I don’t think I could go through it again.
Oh, yeah! He was Burgdorf in Downfall! I forgot, the mustache threw me off. The uncle was also in the movie too. Sort of feels like Clooney saw Downfall and then said: "Get me some of the cast from it to play our Germans."
Don't you just wish that scene was longer? Such a tasty moment, I wish it could just go on and on and on. I also love the Clooney scene talking about Sids Deli in NY, and how some day he'll read on page 18 about a low level Nazi being hanged for his crimes, and then he'll never think about him again. It's so low key, and another tasty scene I wish could just go on and on.
"They super secretly won because you think about them! See mom, my ideology isn't stupid, someone on the internet thinks about them!" I hope you recover some day.
I’m not sure how many times I’ve watched this clip but tonight is the first time that as Babalan sits down you just see Murray’s right arm slowly move and his weight shift a bit. Great scene
1:32 you can see Murray move to draw the .45. Since the .45 rests in the holster with the hammer cocked and the safety is a toggle on the back of the handle, as soon as you put it to-hand it is ready to fire without making a sound.
Oh the movie was good, but the books better, try reading it The Monuments Men: Allied Heroes, Nazi Thieves, and the Greatest Treasure hunt in history, which the film is loosley based off of. That book is amazing.
Best scene in a really underappreciated film. Bob Balaban and Bill McMurray in the same scene makes me instantly flash to The Grand Hotel Budapest and the order of the Cross Keys. I'm sure that the OCK does indeed exist, and also that Bob and Bill are high up in the order!
That is one of the most brillant jokes in film..well trained puppies 😂. Few month later we learnd about art treatmen in middel eastern deserts. I like Cate Blanchett smoke 😂😂😂
I do to, bro, but I acquired most of mine at thrift stores, flea markets, and garage sales. A lot of my paintings I started buying in the 1980s, and many date from the '20-60s and are certainly worth more than I paid for them.
This scene exposes the thin veneer of " civilization " most of us good folks put on every day. So much for humanity. Notice Bill Murray's face with his hand on the pistol. This is how i want to go through life, *NOT* pretending all of us who appear to be good *are* actually " good people." HA !!!!!
@@mencken8 Who says you have to keep your hand on the pistol? You put your hand on your gun only to shoot, while being threatened, or expecting a threat. Otherwise, you keep the hand off the gun. Too many chances of an accident when your hand is fingering the gun.
the movie is amazing. Not exactly accurate, but a great piece of cinema. As with all movies, you need to put some of your brain away to truly enjoy it, or you'll ruin the experience.
I picture this scene going down like in the Band of Brothers when the SS guard ran out of his cottage and was shot in the back trying to escape. I would have cheered this guy being taken out that way.
Read the book, see the movie. Both were great. I think, if I remember correctly, that they were looking for a dentist for a bad tooth, and somehow ended up in this house because it was a relative of the dentist.
Too bad they didn't show the scene where earlier Bill's character and the guy in the eyeglasses had to go to a dentist's that was also the town butchers shop while bill is getting his tooth fixed because of a care package well the dentist / butcher was doing him his apprentice was dealing with the customer who came to purchase pork chops she got them and got out of there lickety split because she did not want to hear him screaming 😱😱😱😱
The fact that those nazis were so confident that nothing will catch them up, they didn’t even bother to cover the jewish collector’s name, on the back of the paintings…
Comparing this to the scene from Inglorious Basterds with Hans Landa and the French farmer, you can really tell how that other scene excelled, and this one failed.
Yes. Louis and Alphonse Rothschild lived in Vienna at the breakout of WW2. After the Anschluss in 1938, their homes were looted by the Nazis and part of their collections were earmarked for Hitler's museum. A couple hundred pieces stayed in museums in Austria. And after the war, the Austrian government refused to entertain petitions for restitution, under the argument that Austria had been a victim of the Nazis, not a willing participant in the atrocities, which was a bald-faced lie. Decades later, and only under outside pressure, did the Austrian government return any of the items stolen to the Rothschild heirs.
@@mhb0676 which is ironic, since the Rothschild's are rumored to have financed both sides of the war. Satanists just like seeing people kill one another and bomb (chemically poison) the earth.
@@mhb0676 Im gonna go with Indiana's view here. "It belongs in a museum". Not in the private home of some corrupt traitorous family. I dont think many would weep if this happened to Paul Getty and his collection.
@@rovhalt6650 "It belongs in a museum" and how exactly were those museums filled by exotic artefacts, large portion of those were simple war booty through history...
What I love most was that these two soliders did not mesh well together for most of the film, but they were both in perfect synchronization during this scene: they both recognized the situation and trust the other one to play his part.
Getting the kids to innocently out their parents was pure genius. So simple, so brilliant.
The best scene 😂
I dont get it, how did they out them?
@Brian Waas Certainly SS children would be the first children in a class to jump up and Sieg Heil, even if no one said Heil Hitler. Also, Brian, BTW, there were French SS men, some in fact fought in the Battle for Berlin in the Reichstag.
@@Cons1337 They didn't. A common misperception...just showing the indoctrination.
@twitteriscancer5403Unless you understand you screwed up as badly as this guy😂.
Love the idea of a little cottage with millions of dollars worth of art casually hanging on the wall.
Sometimes the best place to hide something is in plain sight.
Sometimes…
@@crabman732well this situation shows that nah not really 😂
@@BaronPratobevera lol that’s why I said sometimes
Bill dead cold delivery of that line always sends a chill down my spine.
bill murray has always been one of my favorite actors. Most tend to play the essentially the same character over and over. Murray has range
Murray is so quietly good. All the time. This movie was one of his best performances.
Most people think of Bill Murray as a low brow, slapstick, comedian, but his best work has always been his more dramatic parts, like this.
@@MrSirwolf2001 Loved his performance in, "Razors Edge".
The food may be good, the conversation polite. But a new order, and a new dispensation has been granted. One that need not ask permission, say 'please', much less beg. Judgement Day has come.
One of the most underrated movies ever.
Yeah, this film deserves more love. It's pretty good, maybe a bit slow or misleading at times. Like, I think some folks might have been going in thinking they were gonna see more Saving Private Ryan or Band of Brothers kind of battles with these guys in it.
I have a feeling Murrey had more fun with the delivery of this line than everyone thinks.
I always loved that scene. Everyone smiling, then the "Heil Hiter" and Mr. Colt .45 makes his appearance!
Then the real smile on Bill's face.
Bill Murray with a .45 is not something to face.
@@Muzical-Man Not so 'new'. The pistol was adopted into the U.S. Armed Forces in 1911. The bullet was created by Colt a lot longer ago.
@@morganpirate9127 okay then. Best Supporting Actor is Mr. Colt 45 lol
@@Muzical-Man Works for me. In South Viet Nam Mr. Colt 'acted' flawlessly for me!
@@Muzical-Man Oh, George, you know that Mr. Colt has been playing a supporting role in various military dramas since 1911, from Mexico to Belleau Wood, Guadalcanal, Tunisia, Sicily, Italy, Normandy, the Ardennes, Berlin, Pusan, Chosin, Ia Drang, and Hue, and since then still turned in a great, but limited performance in Kuwait, Iraq and Afghanistan. And Mr. Colt is still around. He never got the big awards and accolades, but he was a solid and reliable performer, and he still turns up from time to time even now when he's needed. Mr. Colt is anything but a "newcomer."
Hard to imagine an art historian who can be menacing but Murray pulls it off
At 2:19 I was thinking "Busted!" You learn so much about people through their children's behaviors.
im the kid on the left
Decafarini what are you doing here ese
@@whytheangelscry geezah
@@oliverwiesmann4153 propa geezah
The Nazis had been in power since 1933.
These kids are probably younger than 10.
It’s 1943.
They grew up in a totalitarian dictatorship.
No independent schools, no independent newspapers, propaganda at every corner of every village.
Gestapo, the secret state police, capable of targeting anyone they wanted or knew about.
If a young German child in Nazi Germany doesn’t say this stuff when being greeted in this manner during this period, it is very likely to be deaf.
Even though slightly more than half of the population never voted for the NSDAP and not everyone who did was a fierce, fanatical party member, nearly all children born during the reign of the Nazis that were old enough to understand basic concepts, would have given this response.
I felt bad for his uncle, I genuinely believe he didn’t know what his nephew was up too
Well if he did, he probably wouldn't have suggested the Americans go to his cottage. At least the Nazi should have re-framed the portraits. Not as good at hiding them as the ones who put the art work in the caves.
I love the scene where they introduce the Uncle. He's a jolly fellow who laughs when Bill Murray says not to make him angry as he digs in Murrays teeth.
Beautifully done. And true. Like many American heroes, their contribution was subtle but substantial.
Oh Bill... he is such a good actor, even when he just says a few words you can notice
Until the Bill Murray character quietly drew his pistol, I bet the dentist never suspected that his introduction would go south the way it did.
Who would imagine that some random soldiers were art experts who could tell an original from a fake much less knew the actual paintings.
I don’t believe the uncle knew what the nephew had been up to, otherwise he wouldn’t have introduced them.
@@rnash999they aren’t random, most of them had experience with art in some way
@@FervantTwo8Yes but the couple here didn't know that, at least not ahead of time or they wouldn't have had all of those paintings hanging lol
@@therefore_I_yam true
This scene has the exact same energy as when Magneto kills the two Nazis in Argentina. Or the opening to Inglorious Bastards
Or Woody Woodpecker in "The Barber of Seville" short.
Fun Fact: Julius Von Dohnányi did played General Burgdorf from Downfall.
did you mean Justus? I knew he was in Downfall
And Michael Brandner, the dentist, was Hans Fritzsche whom Burgdorf nearly shoots at the end of the movie!
Good catch! Steiner...Steiner bist nicht...
Had to watch this movie for arts class and this scene is FLAWLESS, got everyone off their seat
I had to stop it after the flamethrower scene. I just burst into a violent fit of tears. The scene stunned me; my reaction stunned me. But I had to take about half an hour to recover enough to keep watching the film. I adored it, but I don’t think I could go through it again.
Good acting from everyone but especially Justus Von Dohnanyi, a talented actor from a very talented family.
Oh, yeah! He was Burgdorf in Downfall! I forgot, the mustache threw me off. The uncle was also in the movie too. Sort of feels like Clooney saw Downfall and then said: "Get me some of the cast from it to play our Germans."
Don't you just wish that scene was longer? Such a tasty moment, I wish it could just go on and on and on. I also love the Clooney scene talking about Sids Deli in NY, and how some day he'll read on page 18 about a low level Nazi being hanged for his crimes, and then he'll never think about him again. It's so low key, and another tasty scene I wish could just go on and on.
And yet they live rent free in your head
@@DapperLindy Oh I charge them rent, but they won't pay so I'm thinking of filing an eviction notice.
@@DapperLindy
There's space there. I understand your apartment in that place is a skid row single residency.
@@DapperLindy Imagine trying to make fun of someone for thinking, Really shows how limited your own intellect is.
"They super secretly won because you think about them! See mom, my ideology isn't stupid, someone on the internet thinks about them!" I hope you recover some day.
my favorite scene
Same
Mine too.
im the kid on the left
i swear on my life, i have no reason to lie
As for Bill Murray...I can kinda take him or leave him. But his total deadpan delivery and casually putting the .45 on the table...very, very good.
The German......"It was a gift"
The American Soldier "And the Renoir too????"
I can't decide if this scene, or the mine scene is my favorite.
+No This or the 'Merry little Christmas' scene. Both incredible scenes.
"Looks like the Lieutenant stepped on a mine."
"Why would you step on a mine?"
"I asked him the same thing."
"He did."
Ironic that the painting by Renoir behind the Nazi is of a Jewish girl
Art is art.
They found her in an attic.
@@ephemispriest8069
I want to be Frank with you....?
It’s not irony at all.
I’m not sure how many times I’ve watched this clip but tonight is the first time that as Babalan sits down you just see Murray’s right arm slowly move and his weight shift a bit. Great scene
The second he heard "jewish" his quick response was just another sign.
The best scene of the movie.
That was incredible
No irritating music for suspense
The shear terror of a realistic silence between each and every statement
Just perfection
1:32 you can see Murray move to draw the .45. Since the .45 rests in the holster with the hammer cocked and the safety is a toggle on the back of the handle, as soon as you put it to-hand it is ready to fire without making a sound.
Best scene. Ever
Excellent scene, Looking forward to the movie….
Oh the movie was good, but the books better, try reading it The Monuments Men: Allied Heroes, Nazi Thieves, and the Greatest Treasure hunt in history, which the film is loosley based off of. That book is amazing.
1. The kids are narcs. 😆
2. The Americans were suspicious the whole time as to who he was and what was hanging on the walls.
im the kid on the left
Gee, you really think the Americans are suspicious?
This is a great movie. 😀
This film was far better than Inglorious Bastards.
Helps that it's true.
Best scene in a really underappreciated film. Bob Balaban and Bill McMurray in the same scene makes me instantly flash to The Grand Hotel Budapest and the order of the Cross Keys. I'm sure that the OCK does indeed exist, and also that Bob and Bill are high up in the order!
This is my favorite scene in the movie ❤
Ah, the innocence of kids.
A film I watch EVERY time it shown.Its just one of those films
Like Shawshank
Bill Murray just staring him down with the strap.
It's that Drunkard Burgdorf!
That is one of the most brillant jokes in film..well trained puppies 😂. Few month later we learnd about art treatmen in
middel eastern deserts. I like Cate Blanchett smoke 😂😂😂
Bill Murray is quietly menacing in this scene.
2:18 I know that kid on the left
Cool. Does he have any recollection of filming? Actually, better question, do you still keep in touch with him or has you or him moved away?
always good to see well behaved children
Nobody has a cottage with art like that all over the walls. Well, I do, but I inherited them. Swear to God.
I do to, bro, but I acquired most of mine at thrift stores, flea markets, and garage sales. A lot of my paintings I started buying in the 1980s, and many date from the '20-60s and are certainly worth more than I paid for them.
The dentist is such a wonderful unwitting fool
It makes me feel bad for the Rothschilds.
@@JohnSmith-dd8bf why’s that?
Great movie.
Best scene in the movie
I liked the Merry Little Christmas scene best. But it has to start at mail call and go to when he returns from the shower.
Bill Murray, bad ass.
Wow! Amazing scene!
Good movie
A wonderful movie !
thats such a great scene
Love this film.
most excellent scene
This scene exposes the thin veneer of " civilization " most of us good folks put on every day. So much for humanity. Notice Bill Murray's face with his hand on the pistol. This is how i want to go through life, *NOT* pretending all of us who appear to be good *are* actually " good people." HA !!!!!
Try that for a couple of days in your everyday life. Keep your hand on your pistol, see how that works out for you.
@@mencken8 Who says you have to keep your hand on the pistol? You put your hand on your gun only to shoot, while being threatened, or expecting a threat. Otherwise, you keep the hand off the gun. Too many chances of an accident when your hand is fingering the gun.
Are you okay? Did you OD on game of thrones, do you need a nap?
Fritzsche finally forgave Burgdorf for trying to kill him
Hey its Burgdorf from Downfall
It's him! Justus Von Dohnanyi is Viktor Stahl!
We need to make a parody of how Burgdorf was arrested by Allies American for stealing a picture.
The greatest red flag for them is when they saw those children playing Red Baron plane toys.
Every kid had one of those!
That's where Burgdorf was hiding after pretending to be dead.
great film
Indeed
Brilliant
The Truth will FIND YOU!!!!!!!!
You can run but you can’t hide it’s beyond ridiculous just how small this world is.
Im not 100% sure what it means to be a "great actor" But in my book Bill Murry qualifies.
Good movie✔
I agree
So the dentist really had no idea Stahl was an actual Nazi who had actually fought in the war?
There is no movie that isn't made better with a dash of Bill Murray.
Love it cant wait to see it!
about the same vibe in the intro of Hans Landa.
General Burgdorf met the guy from Ghostbuster.
NEIN NEIN NEIN....It was FEIGELIEN FEGELIEN FEGELEIN...and no fish were involved.
Burgdorf and Venkman!
Peter: This damned Nazi slimed me but i '''Busted" him!
. the gold tht they seized.(also as depicted in the movie) .wht happened to all of it. tons of gold..where is it ?
It is in Merkers
It's in fort Knox💰💰💰💰
Go to Mark Felton’s channel. He just released a video detailing this
Whats the oainting behind Stahl? The girl with red hair and the pink dress facing left?
It's Burgdorf!
So Burgdorf got away from Berlin? Not for long though XD
Gotcha!
Girwitz, without Huber, without Schaller.😍🥰😆
Otherwise not a great movie, but this was the best scene.
In Ostdeutschland klappt das immer noch!
Kids can't lie when you need them to
How come they didn't ro the arm thing to
I liked the look of that cake.
Nazi cake?
Could the movie be good? For a WW2 historian?
the movie is amazing. Not exactly accurate, but a great piece of cinema. As with all movies, you need to put some of your brain away to truly enjoy it, or you'll ruin the experience.
Fritzsche and Burgdorf
Burgdorf!!
najlepsza scena ever...!
He said “ red shield” lol
I picture this scene going down like in the Band of Brothers when the SS guard ran out of his cottage and was shot in the back trying to escape. I would have cheered this guy being taken out that way.
Read the book, see the movie. Both were great. I think, if I remember correctly, that they were looking for a dentist for a bad tooth, and somehow ended up in this house because it was a relative of the dentist.
Yeah I thought the book read like a collection of newspaper articles. That said, it’s an amazing account.
Too bad they didn't show the scene where earlier Bill's character and the guy in the eyeglasses had to go to a dentist's that was also the town butchers shop while bill is getting his tooth fixed because of a care package well the dentist / butcher was doing him his apprentice was dealing with the customer who came to purchase pork chops she got them and got out of there lickety split because she did not want to hear him screaming 😱😱😱😱
to ask this guy about 'Rothschild' may not ring a bell with him. The German, and correct, pronunciation is 'Rode-shield'.
The fact that those nazis were so confident that nothing will catch them up, they didn’t even bother to cover the jewish collector’s name, on the back of the paintings…
They arrested that German Guy.
Burgdorf with moustache
Crazy enough to have their ill-gotten gains hanging on the wall…..
You want to hide something? Put it where everyone can see it. 😉
Comparing this to the scene from Inglorious Basterds with Hans Landa and the French farmer, you can really tell how that other scene excelled, and this one failed.
Crear scene
im the kid on the left, ama
Cool! What was it like being in the same room as Bill Murray and Bob Baladin?
Really?
@@CW-dl2dd Bill was pretty quiet, didn't smile a ton haha
@@redfooddye8609 yep!
@@whytheangelscry wow, that's so cool!
взрослые легче вылечивались от фашизма, но детей травмировали навсегда
Did they say Rothschild?
Yes. Louis and Alphonse Rothschild lived in Vienna at the breakout of WW2. After the Anschluss in 1938, their homes were looted by the Nazis and part of their collections were earmarked for Hitler's museum. A couple hundred pieces stayed in museums in Austria. And after the war, the Austrian government refused to entertain petitions for restitution, under the argument that Austria had been a victim of the Nazis, not a willing participant in the atrocities, which was a bald-faced lie. Decades later, and only under outside pressure, did the Austrian government return any of the items stolen to the Rothschild heirs.
@@mhb0676 which is ironic, since the Rothschild's are rumored to have financed both sides of the war. Satanists just like seeing people kill one another and bomb (chemically poison) the earth.
@@mhb0676 Im gonna go with Indiana's view here.
"It belongs in a museum". Not in the private home of some corrupt traitorous family. I dont think many would weep if this happened to Paul Getty and his collection.
@@rovhalt6650 "It belongs in a museum" and how exactly were those museums filled by exotic artefacts, large portion of those were simple war booty through history...
@@robynperdieu3434 I heard a rumor that you had a functioning brain. See how often rumors are wrong?
Oh mein Gott, der Girwidz hat da mitgespielt xD
Such cute children ready to stand attention. So let's see the basement Fritz.