Me too. They were so full of life. I often watch Shannan's videos to remember them. I don't get how someone could come to the idea to harm them. I will never understand that! They will always be remembered and loved my many people around the world! 💜💜💜💙
This is so very true! I feel like I've known them bc Shanann was an open book, full of love, positivity, and happiness that she was instilling in her girls.
MissKreena the love Bella showed CeCe was demonstrated by their mother. Shananne showed those girls so much love everyday day of their short life. They were always so happy. She was an amazing woman.
I followed this heartbreaking story from the beginning when Chris was lying his ass off on the front porch. Why couldn't he have gotten a freaking divorce.
Omg no matter how many times I watch the last clip... it rips me apart. Such a caring, loving, big sister Bella is. At LEAST they are still together... Rest in peace always, you sweet tiny angels.
That last video makes me so happy then so upset too. I imagine them sitting in the back of that ‘PRICKS’. truck as he was driving them to their death. Sorry for being graphic but it’s just what goes through my head and it hurts my soul so bad 😓
@@irishdeetalks no worries... my mind takes me there EVERY SINGLE TIME as well. I can't help it, either. It's because we have heard all of the details and we cannot fathom a father acting out such a thing to his own flesh and blood. It's literally unbelievable, and gutwrenching that they had to go through that horror.
@@marilynmanord1790 will do! Something else to occupy my time while staying home. As depressing as homicide stories/shows are, I am forever drawn in. Thanks for the recommendation!
Marilyn Manord ..I also looked up the story! What the hell? Vicious vicious crime, how can they so easily do away with the people they love and love him? There MUST be something wrong with them from the start! A mental disorder if some kind.. it’s just so hard to imagine, especially those of us who would KILL anyone who dare even think of hurting someone we love! There’s a saying... Think of me as a massive mother bear, hurt one of my cubs and I’ll kill you!
“Don’t be scared”... and to think, Bella would be forced to watch her beloved baby sister murdered at the hands of their father. Shameful and unimaginable...
Spot on will never comprehend why he did what he did . Poor Bella having to watch her baby sister being smothered by the man that's ment to protect them all . So sad .
Bella singing a few months before about how her father is her hero. So surreal. That poor little Bella in the last few minutes of her life what she saw and heard. Begging her dad for her life. This is the worst of the worst for a human being to do to a child even if you weren't the father.
he couldnt - he was a coward and a sociopath.......his mother also a narc sociopath. his family disgusting. shannans family GOdly and loving. what a nightmare.
@@alexperkins8433 Leave off his family. The guy is probably a sociopath - born missing something. Perhaps half of America has bitter tensions between in-laws. 99% of them won't get burned the way Cindy did. The murders most likely knocked the stuffing out of her. It will be a long time before she is able to accept her son was capable of annihilating his family.
LeeLoveGL Rayne : that one really got to me; those babies learned love from their beautiful mother; ya know, ShanAnn was beautiful but I think she became more beautiful with each passing day. Bella was an old soul and Cece’s smile makes me smile.
My favorite video of them..it's so sweet. When Cece lays across Bellas lap, look at the joy on Bellas face. And when she crinkles her forehead and says not to take her away..My heart fills with love for these babies. Like another comment reads..it makes you laugh and cry at the same time. Bella reading `"..after nigh-nigh, then she gets to go to school.." just the most beautiful moment..it's simple, an everyday kinda thing...but rare and special because she didn't get the chance to have more "moments." God be next to this family in Heaven.💞
When I think about Bella last moments I want to strangle Chris back and forth he is a freaking monster. I cry for Bella and her last moments and how alone she was and she though that sob was a hero
They were actually not alive when they were put into the oil tanks. All the info is out there. They died from being smothered/suffocated. Either way, it's horrific what he did to those little girls.
I know what you mean, they were beautiful inside as well as outside and I just can't understand how or why anyone can do what he did. I think poor Bella suffered the most from the fact of what they found in her stomach. She fought for her life up until her very last breathe of air. Now no one can separate the four of them, they will be together forever . Shanann and her little family will always be protected from people like him who should always remain nameless.
I love how the girls were the opposite of each other in the best way. Shy, thoughtful, mothering Bella and energetic, crazy, brave CeCe. They would have been the best big sisters to Nico and Shanann was an absolutely brilliant mother. Fly high sweethearts.
I can't understand how a man can wipe out such a beautiful family. He chose a lowlife heffer. I will never forget Shannan and her babies. They are forever in everyone's heart.. They're in Gods hands protected... God Bless them all..
It's almost as if shanann knew all their lives would be short to sit and record so much. I am happy her family can watch these and have them in this sense at least. God Bless them all. I wish the world would stop hate and just love and care for eachother. That is all that matters in life infinity.
Otis Russell that’s pretty much what’s going on behind the scenes of this virus. Gods picking the evil and removing from earth. If you get a minute go watch “The Plan To Save The World!” Also watch some of weekend warrior on UA-cam. Very enlightening. If you have time. It’s very good. The time has come for big time names and people who have gained our trust and admiration all while hating us down to our soil & soul. Trump decided to take control & they turned on him Bc he wasn’t part on “hating America!” They spin everything he says. He’s not perfect but he’s for the people of the USA 🇺🇸 that we can be grateful!
So eerily true, @Otis Russell. I have seen comments from Frankie Jr on many of these captured videos and it is clear there still is pain with the joy of watching them. I know the pain will never go away but I pray in time it will be almost completely outweighed by joy. So many people have sniped that Shanann posted all these videos to market Thrive when that clearly is not true. Her dear Rzucek family lived more than 1500 miles across the country, don't these snipers get how happy they all were to bridge the distance via video?! Not to mention all the friends. Thank you, @Shining Light, for sharing these.
I agree. shanann was proud of her babies. she always enjoyed making videos to make loving memories of her with her precious angels. God bless them all.🙏
@@VIPviveeCastillo69 it's a friendly reminder as most parents give their kids when dealing with a smaller child. I don't see anything you all wanna see. I see a vibrant human whom I would have loved to have as a friend ... Think what you want. Keep your opinion to yourself. I don't really care for it at all.
When ceecee was in Bella’s lap all I could think about was the car ride to the oil fields how Chris said they took turns putting their heads in the others lap...my heart breaks for both families but especially for Bella having to watch her best friend die
Yes, I was thinking the same thing! She also watched her mom die also right? Just terrible! He gained nothing!! He lost everything! This was utterly senseless!!
That couldn’t even been made up too just to drive the knife further in. I don’t believe any story he gives of the events of that night anymore except the fact he murdered them.
Bella rubbing little Ce Ce's cheek and back watching tv..i still just can't wrap my mind around how that monster could do what he done to his very own sweet, loving , innocent family. God rest their precious souls.
Andy Looney He has Npd. He only thinks of and highly of himself. He did it because he was selfish and too much of a coward to divorce. In his sick mind, he would rather go to jail than go bankrupt and pay child support.
I can't believe 2 parents who would LOCK their baby girls up for 15-16 hours every day after drugging them so neither one had to be bothered with them are people who did not really want children. Or should I say raise children. Bella was and is an absolute sweetheart but little miss Celeste needed some form of right and wrong. Oh I forgot she was the funny one who could sell sell sell that thrive.
@@linzbell7354 you heard about the Benadryl/ Tylenol every day and night yeah I said it and meant it. No disrespect to the dead but truth is just that. I am so sorry the man she should have trusted with her life took her life along with the lovely baby girls as no one deserves that but I think they were co conspirators in the abuse of Bella and Celeste
@barbara baker-ruff- what is the matter with you ? One thing to call sweet children “ugly” but to talk so poorly of the deceased is of very poor taste . Very low class. You clearly have some major insecurities within yourself. I hate to wonder what you must look like to speak so horribly about these girls to make yourself feel some sort of gratification in your obviously miserable life. These sweet innocent girls were viciously murdered. Have some decency and compassion or don’t comment at all!
@@barbarabaker-ruff4520 imagine having to be such a miserable disgusting thing, that you result to commenting on how these beautiful innocent children look.
@@barbarabaker-ruff4520 they were little. I'm sure had their life not been robbed from them they would have grown up to be beautiful! Because both parents were great looking! I don't think they were ugly at all. I honestly believe you should have kept your opinion to yourself. That way you wouldn't have caused strife or hurt other people's feelings especially because of this very touchy subject. ❤
@@barbarabaker-ruff4520 not true for me as cece looks a lot like my youngest son 😏❤️ Anyway I spose I know what you mean as there is kiddos who actually make me go mad like mostly because I don't like their parents or because they are spoilt lil brats 😅 but then nooo, they might be annoying but they are not ugly. I havent seen an ugly kitten, dog puppy, piglet or toddler in me life! A baby is always a baby.
My absolute FAVORITE video of these two beautiful Angel's together is when they are on the couch together and Bella says, "NO, DONT TAKE HER AWAY!" Then she just holds her baby sister telling her not to be scared and rubbing her back. OMG it breaks my heart. Bella seemed to be such a kind and loving soul. I cant imagine how Shananns family makes it thru a day without those beautiful angels. If these moments make me cry, I cant fathom how they feel. I am so unbelievably sorry for your loss.
It wasn’t and isn’t just Shannans family who would have a hard time getting through each day. Cindy and Ronnie Watts are also their grandparents and are equally affected. In fact, more than 4 years later and Cindy barely makes it through to the end of each day. The girls death affected all of us, strangers from all over the world, I can’t even begin to imagine the pain both families have gone through and will go through every single day for the rest of their lives. The most horrific murders I’ve ever known. I honestly don’t know how the thoughts could enter someone’s mind with how they were murdered, and then not only thinking of such a sick twisted way, they actually did it! I still find it hard to comprehend.
Imho although their sperm donor took all their lives I don't believe for a nano second that one set of grandparents misses them any more or less than the other. How cold and just a silly comment. God Bless all affected by this tragedy.
I have yet to see or even hear of Watts’s parents crying over the grandbabies. All they are consumed with is getting their killing son out. Even watts’s pushed the picture of them away when he was talking to Chris. Hell, they didn't even go to the birthday party for CeCe.
i cannot get enough of the story I’m absolutely horrified with this guy that was two children I mean I don’t understand why he had to dump them in the oil tanks I mean literally destroying them he should’ve just put them with their mamaLove to ask him why he had to destroy them it was not enough that he told them he had to destroy them and let them soak in the oil tanks I mean how evil could you beAnd premeditatedly driving them there knowing he was going to kill them both is unreal and one by one not even to put the babies together in one tank put one in each tank I mean so conscious of what he was doing it’s sickening and then walk away and act like you did nothing keeping a straight face well not really talking to the media knowing they’re floating in the oil tanks is unbelievable this guy I hope he rots in prison
Those two precious angels are the sweetest. They are so loving, just watching Bella being so tender hearted and saying “Don’t take her away” is a tear jerker in light of what has happened.
Those of us who have raised two or more children close in age know how much hard work it takes to teach and develop those little personalities, as well as keeping them fed, in clean clothes and active daily. Shanann was a beautiful and exemplary mother. Bella always can't seem to get close enough to CeCe. What a beautiful child aptly named.
Such a beautiful family every time I see one of her videos I sit and I just cry she was a beautiful woman she definitely deserve better and so did her children 💔😢
How these girls love each other is sooooo beautiful and sweet. My heart is completely melted. I imagine them like this always! I hope my angel daughter has found them and they play together! 💜💜💜
Omgoodness, this video speaks volumes,, they should all be here!😢😔💕💕 the three of them were so nsync. Thank you for posting. I watch all the time . ♥️💜💜💜💜
Those girls are so incredibly cute. So precious. How anyone could take their last breath by smothering them is beyond me. So incredibly sad. Those girls would’ve been the best big sisters to Nico. Between Bella’s sneakiness and CC’s energy, they definitely kept Shannan on her toes! They’re in the arms of the angels now.
I go back and watch all of their videos almost everyday. I never get them out of my head it's almost as if I lost them and they were my loved ones I feel so bad for their family but I love going back and watching their sweet videos
Whoever puts out these video’s every year, thank you. I can’t ever forget them. I feel like they were my own family and I didn’t know them. I love her family. God was there when they passed to bring them home. I hope I meet them in heaven. Seriously, I can’t wait to see all the family and friends I’ve lost along the way. My time is soon and I’m not sad about it. Jesus has me and will meet me too.
That shot of those stairs just creeps me out Shan’ann never would have imagined that her doting husband would be dragging her down through those stairs. The kids are sooooooooo adorable. Why Chris, why!?!?
I still cannot wrap this around my mind. Such a,sad loss but why ? It's like happening more all the time They were all robbed of their lives.God Bless Her Family and Friends.🤗🤗🤗
Everytime I come on UA-cam I have to watch me some Bella and CeCe. They are my stars. I wish I could have seen them grow up. RIP Shannon, Bella , CeCe and Nico. You are missed soooo much. Cant wait to meet you in heaven.
Bella was such a loving soul. She really looked out for CeCe and protected her. Shannan was a wonderful mother. She showed them true love and kindness . ❤️
I will NEVER be able to comprehend just how he, as their father and a husband he, could do such a thing. As rough tough blue collard worker who has rode some of the busiest fire trucks in this country and has seen more death and destruction cannot watch the video of these beautiful innocent angels without crying.... and I don’t think we’ve see a legitimate tear come from that animalistic coward.
My goodness I can't stop crying. I'm watching the Christmas cookie video and I just can't comprehend it. HOW? They seem like such a lovely family, my mind just can't accept that what happened to them cannot be undone. I never knew I could feel this much pain for a family I've never met.
Bella says: " Hi Bell" thinking that's what Shanann meant, her sweet little voice- she was so precious. CeCe so adorable and her personality- have you ever seen a more precious little girl!? I still think about them and visit videos to watch them as if I knew them. The cold reality, they're gone, something that's so hard to accept.
Shannan and her girls were so precious. I never met them, but after watching a lot of her videos, I feel like I knew them. RIP Shannan, Bella, Celeste, and Nico ❤️
They were beautiful ! Bella is very sweet and Cece too, Bella has an aura of sweetness! I know God has them all! This is so sad even after a year! Shannan ❤️
Oh I'm so I love with them.cant help myself from tears watching their videos.Shannan truly loved her daughters. My prayers for your souls shannan,bella,CeCe and Nick#FromPhilippines
I do too. GORGEOUS woman mothering her precious babies. It is simply heartbreaking to know they aren't here with their Nana, Pop Pop and Uncle Frankie. I cannot imagine the depths of their pain. My heart prays for their peace💜💜💜💜
I have never seen two little ones so close to each other. They are loving and caring of each other. Momma had done a good job with her precious babies.
This video and many others are precious. Their grandparents must watch them over and over again. Little Bella is so gentle and little Cece is adorable. It’s so sad and to think we will never get to see little Nico. It’s heartbreaking......so sad.........and he lives on
@taurpio yes it's amazing how photo's change our opinion"s of who someone looks like! I love this. When I look at photos of my son when he's little ( or show them to others) Everyone including myself see his father - not me...as more photos were taken even only months apart and the same folks see the photos- they will say "I don't understand -" "Christopher?" ( my son) isn't looking like his dad he looks so much like your mother! This is why I love how we change in the opinions of others practically over night lol! I must say this and I'm sure others will see this as well- CeCe is the spitting image of Sandy - CeCe's Gramma ( Shannans moma) GOD bless ALL of them - they are missed so MUCH.
That was precious. Little Bella was so relaxed reading us her book, chattering away. Yes, I am so glad that Shannan captured these memories for her family to cherish always and to show and remind the world of the beauty that was taken by the horrible atrocity that was committed upon them
@@theresacunningham2823 yes I'm so happy she did too. I don't see " fixed" videos - I only see genuine love in ALL her videos with the girls " the love of mother and her daughter's. You can't fake/ fix any of that .
@@margcourierservice4010 Yes, I see what you mean... So many of the Thrive videos were torn apart by others criticizing everything about them. That was Shananns JOB and only represented a few moments of the day with her children... These home videos truly show what they were like in life more so than the Thrive videos... Truly heartbreaking
NC here!! I will never be able to rap my head around this one. It makes no sense at all why. Shanann was young, and someone would have loved to have them in their life. They could have moved on.. and been just fine with Sandy and Frank, Frankie Jr., all behind them for support.
I love the videos of Bella and Cece sitting together on the couch. I remember watching that last video (a few years ago) with Bella being so loving to Cece and telling her not to be scared and then there is a part where it sounds like Bella stated, "We can go home now." I imagined her comforting her in a similar way after their father they loved and trusted turned into a monster they did not know or recognize. She would be protective of Cece and Nico. I know they all found a new home in heaven. I do feel that Bella had a bit of intuition, but none of them could ever foresee what was about to happen to them. I love how they are so engrossed in the movie. They are so cute and innocent. I love this video and The Vision Board as also great with Bella. Shanann was such a great mom. Thank you for sharing this.
I love seeing Shannan holding her girls. Such simple loving little girls. Their Mommy took such good care of them. And they were so happy. I will never understand how something so terrible, could happen to these amazing girls. May they RIP.
@@underthefallenstars2788 you're just another hater, who can't wait to victim blame. She was a good mom. But nobody is perfect, of course. And those girls were well-developed, intelligent for their age. Bella was very protective of her sister, even though she was a baby herself. And those are the things people learn at home. So Shanann raised them well.
I cant get over the fact... That she thought her husband was having a affair little did she know he was also planning to kill off her and her precious babies... One thing I'm at peace with is that they are together ❤ and that monster is behind bars probably trying to fool himself or the guards or inmates...yeah I killed my family but im still a cool dude ... just sickness me... Watching her posts I smile and cry... She did get to live and enjoy life for awhile and even spend time with her family before it all went down.. What a loss for us here on earth but a huge gain for heaven with their presence 🤍💫🙏
Bella, CeCe Niko and Shannan together forever in each others arms, Four beautiful souls too good for this earth, Four lights forever shining free from pain, discomfort and hurt, We will remember them though we knew them not in life, Yet we will remember them with love and share in their smiles. Remember them happy, and joyful and fun For they were an unknown blessing for each one of us Do not be sad that they are not here, they are safe and they are loved in a far away place where there is no fear. God bless Shannan and Niko Bella and Celeste, God called them home because he only takes the very very best.
It's hard to believe they aren't here anymore. More so how they went. God give their family the strength to get through each day. May they rest in paradise eternally Shannan, Cee Cee, Bella, & Baby Nico. 🙏👼👩👧👧💕
I will never forget this two beautiful babies. Even though I don't know them, I love them so much & they are still in my heart forever and ever. Love from Philippines 🇵🇭
Pure sisterly love. I've been bawling my eyes out for days now thinking about that moment during the car ride to the oil field, holding each other and napping in each other's laps, not knowing what horrific nightmare awaits them, completely entrusting their lives to that monster. Sweet angels, May God Have Mercy on Us!
I can't believe any human being, let alone a Dad , could do what he did. I still miss not seeing Shannon, Bella, and cc .Still makes me want to cry 😢😢😢❤❤❤
Little Bella would have loved school if she had gotten the opportunity to go. It still breaks my heart that they were taken away like that. Karma will come around to all those involved in their murders. Rest in peace Shanann, Bella, C.C. & Nico. ❤️😇 We all are still thinking of you everyday!
I totally agree. She adored books and although her speech was a bit delayed she sure could get into books even making up stories from the pictures. She was destined to be someone great. CeeCee needed some discipline in her little life but what 2 yo doesn't? Fly high lovely Angels and yes I am including Niko.
Bella loved Cee Cee so much . I’ll bet Bella is still taking care of Cee Cee in Heaven. We will never forget these little Angels or beautiful ShanAnn .🥰❤️🙏🏼😇😇😇😇
I will never forget them. To this day, I cannot forget them and never will.
Me too. They were so full of life. I often watch Shannan's videos to remember them. I don't get how someone could come to the idea to harm them. I will never understand that!
They will always be remembered and loved my many people around the world! 💜💜💜💙
Me too , even with all the craziness it’s going on , they will never go away from my mind.
Same
So sweet so sad she is the best mamma 😘
God bless 😇 sweet souls
I’ve never met them but they’re in my heart forever. I’ll never forget them. Ever. They’re the proof that you don’t need to know someone to miss them.
Yes! I miss them too. But marla we know them already because in heaven we are all brothers and sisters!😉😊
❤️
💔😰💔❤️❤️❤️
This is so very true! I feel like I've known them bc Shanann was an open book, full of love, positivity, and happiness that she was instilling in her girls.
Exactly right!!
My god.... I wish someone loved me as much as Bella loved CeCe....
Bella would have made an
EXCELLANT MOMMA don't you think 😭
Shagumagu absolutely ... no question ...
To think Bella had to watch Cece be killed is just awful. They were so precious 😪😪😪
Katey Hero I can’t even let my mind fully go there
MissKreena the love Bella showed CeCe was demonstrated by their mother. Shananne showed those girls so much love everyday day of their short life. They were always so happy. She was an amazing woman.
This case really affected me, sometimes I wish it didn't. It's just so unbelievably heartbreaking.
You are not alone. They are in all our hearts.
😢😢May they rest in peace 🙏
I wish I never come s a cross this case. Its soul destroying.
I followed this heartbreaking story from the beginning when Chris was lying his ass off on the front porch. Why couldn't he have gotten a freaking divorce.
Me too it's so unfair.
Omg no matter how many times I watch the last clip... it rips me apart. Such a caring, loving, big sister Bella is. At LEAST they are still together... Rest in peace always, you sweet tiny angels.
What an nice post, APRIL & yes the little ones are together with PEACE.
That last video makes me so happy then so upset too. I imagine them sitting in the back of that ‘PRICKS’. truck as he was driving them to their death. Sorry for being graphic but it’s just what goes through my head and it hurts my soul so bad 😓
@@irishdeetalks no worries... my mind takes me there EVERY SINGLE TIME as well. I can't help it, either. It's because we have heard all of the details and we cannot fathom a father acting out such a thing to his own flesh and blood. It's literally unbelievable, and gutwrenching that they had to go through that horror.
@@marilynmanord1790 will do! Something else to occupy my time while staying home. As depressing as homicide stories/shows are, I am forever drawn in. Thanks for the recommendation!
Marilyn Manord ..I also looked up the story! What the hell? Vicious vicious crime, how can they so easily do away with the people they love and love him? There MUST be something wrong with them from the start! A mental disorder if some kind.. it’s just so hard to imagine, especially those of us who would KILL anyone who dare even think of hurting someone we love! There’s a saying... Think of me as a massive mother bear, hurt one of my cubs and I’ll kill you!
“Don’t be scared”... and to think, Bella would be forced to watch her beloved baby sister murdered at the hands of their father. Shameful and unimaginable...
Spot on will never comprehend why he did what he did . Poor Bella having to watch her baby sister being smothered by the man that's ment to protect them all . So sad .
This is my all time favorite video of the girls watching the cartoon together. Absolutely precious.
Heart breaking!!
Bella singing a few months before about how her father is her hero. So surreal. That poor little Bella in the last few minutes of her life what she saw and heard. Begging her dad for her life. This is the worst of the worst for a human being to do to a child even if you weren't the father.
Jesus warns us to never hurt or even mislead the precious children. 😞😔. My heart is rent to shreds thinking about these two sweet angels
They make you smile and cry at the same time
Yes it does. ☹️💜💜💜💙
They really do
So true
So true, I’m doing that right now watching this just about the 2 year anniversary.
I wish they were never taken away so soon
Walk away...he could’ve just walked away. Selfish & senseless.
he couldnt - he was a coward and a sociopath.......his mother also a narc sociopath. his family disgusting. shannans family GOdly and loving. what a nightmare.
@@alexperkins8433 Leave off his family. The guy is probably a sociopath - born missing something. Perhaps half of America has bitter tensions between in-laws. 99% of them won't get burned the way Cindy did. The murders most likely knocked the stuffing out of her. It will be a long time before she is able to accept her son was capable of annihilating his family.
Yes, he should have😢.
He also had to be heartless to do that too.
Mary Lagasse He could walk away from the marriage without walking away from his kids. That wouldn’t be heartlessness.
Awwwww🥰 sweet Bella saying “don’t take her away “ and rubbing her back telling her not to be scared . She had motherly instincts ❤️
LeeLoveGL Rayne : that one really got to me; those babies learned love from their beautiful mother; ya know, ShanAnn was beautiful but I think she became more beautiful with each passing day. Bella was an old soul and Cece’s smile makes me smile.
Kathy Williamson you couldn’t describe it better 🥰
We know who she got those protective instincts from!
Angie Welch exactly !!!!! Momma bear 👩👧👧🐻
My favorite video of them..it's so sweet. When Cece lays across Bellas lap, look at the joy on Bellas face. And when she crinkles her forehead and says not to take her away..My heart fills with love for these babies. Like another comment reads..it makes you laugh and cry at the same time. Bella reading `"..after nigh-nigh, then she gets to go to school.." just the most beautiful moment..it's simple, an everyday kinda thing...but rare and special because she didn't get the chance to have more "moments." God be next to this family in Heaven.💞
Poor Bella - She suffered the most. Unfathomable.
💔💔
so true she would have suffered the most because she was aware of what was happening. at least Cece was not old enough..
When I think about Bella last moments I want to strangle Chris back and forth he is a freaking monster. I cry for Bella and her last moments and how alone she was and she though that sob was a hero
Bella is so motherly..xx
They were actually not alive when they were put into the oil tanks. All the info is out there. They died from being smothered/suffocated. Either way, it's horrific what he did to those little girls.
I cannot watch this without tears in my eyes, such a beautiful sweet innocent family 😪
😔 😔 😔
I know what you mean, they were beautiful inside as well as outside and I just can't understand how or why anyone can do what he did. I think poor Bella suffered the most from the fact of what they found in her stomach. She fought for her life up until her very last breathe of air. Now no one can separate the four of them, they will be together forever . Shanann and her little family will always be protected from people like him who should always remain nameless.
They were all innocent even Chris. Nicole killed those babies
Everything good, pure, innocent and beautiful in these baby girls was from Shanann and God. They deserved life.
And they loved him so much....but he was evil to the core. So sad..these babies and Shannan deserved the world and he took it all away. Final.
She looked so much like him. How could he look in her beautiful little innocent face and smother her ? He is pure evil.
Exactly they deserved to live a full happy life.
I love how the girls were the opposite of each other in the best way. Shy, thoughtful, mothering Bella and energetic, crazy, brave CeCe. They would have been the best big sisters to Nico and Shanann was an absolutely brilliant mother. Fly high sweethearts.
Beautiful comment Michael👍
I KNOW..so heartbreaking.
I can't understand how a man can wipe out such a beautiful family. He chose a lowlife heffer. I will never forget Shannan and her babies. They are forever in everyone's heart.. They're in Gods hands protected... God Bless them all..
He's sick
It's almost as if shanann knew all their lives would be short to sit and record so much. I am happy her family can watch these and have them in this sense at least. God Bless them all. I wish the world would stop hate and just love and care for eachother. That is all that matters in life infinity.
Agreed. How great would the world be if everyone just loved one another.
Otis Russell that’s pretty much what’s going on behind the scenes of this virus. Gods picking the evil and removing from earth. If you get a minute go watch “The Plan To Save The World!” Also watch some of weekend warrior on UA-cam. Very enlightening. If you have time. It’s very good. The time has come for big time names and people who have gained our trust and admiration all while hating us down to our soil & soul. Trump decided to take control & they turned on him Bc he wasn’t part on “hating America!” They spin everything he says. He’s not perfect but he’s for the people of the USA 🇺🇸 that we can be grateful!
So eerily true, @Otis Russell. I have seen comments from Frankie Jr on many of these captured videos and it is clear there still is pain with the joy of watching them. I know the pain will never go away but I pray in time it will be almost completely outweighed by joy. So many people have sniped that Shanann posted all these videos to market Thrive when that clearly is not true. Her dear Rzucek family lived more than 1500 miles across the country, don't these snipers get how happy they all were to bridge the distance via video?! Not to mention all the friends. Thank you, @Shining Light, for sharing these.
I agree. shanann was proud of her babies. she always enjoyed making videos to make loving memories of her with her precious angels. God bless them all.🙏
She recorded for her family in the beginning bc they lived so far away. Then she did them for thrive afterwards
“Don’t take her away” these precious souls it literally makes me sick.
Those little girls... You can see how much they loved eachother.
Shanann is so patient and loving. Rest in peace, angels 💕
Shanann era so amor,bondade
Might wanna c some more videos cause theres some odd stuff goin on
Be nice to cece she was! You have to look beyond what you wanna c in their mom, shes mean to bella
@@VIPviveeCastillo69 it's a friendly reminder as most parents give their kids when dealing with a smaller child. I don't see anything you all wanna see. I see a vibrant human whom I would have loved to have as a friend ... Think what you want. Keep your opinion to yourself. I don't really care for it at all.
@@VIPviveeCastillo69 and I've seen them all!! ❤️
When ceecee was in Bella’s lap all I could think about was the car ride to the oil fields how Chris said they took turns putting their heads in the others lap...my heart breaks for both families but especially for Bella having to watch her best friend die
😢😢😢😢😢
Yes, I was thinking the same thing! She also watched her mom die also right? Just terrible! He gained nothing!! He lost everything! This was utterly senseless!!
Me to Mary...so heartbreaking.
That couldn’t even been made up too just to drive the knife further in. I don’t believe any story he gives of the events of that night anymore except the fact he murdered them.
@@siaw6487 I know. He's just in something he couldn't get out of. We all know NA did it.
Bella rubbing little Ce Ce's cheek and back watching tv..i still just can't wrap my mind around how that monster could do what he done to his very own sweet, loving , innocent family. God rest their precious souls.
Andy Looney He has Npd. He only thinks of and highly of himself. He did it because he was selfish and too much of a coward to divorce. In his sick mind, he would rather go to jail than go bankrupt and pay child support.
Andy Looney Nope... I don’t guess normal decent men aren’t suppose to be able to wrap their minds around what this monster did.
I can't believe a father who could hurt his beautiful wife and children...
How did he ever overpower Shan Ann?
She was asleep more then likely and he strangled her. It takes around 10 seconds for someone to lose consciousness...
I love them baby girls Rip angels xxx😍
I can't believe 2 parents who would LOCK their baby girls up for 15-16 hours every day after drugging them so neither one had to be bothered with them are people who did not really want children. Or should I say raise children. Bella was and is an absolute sweetheart but little miss Celeste needed some form of right and wrong. Oh I forgot she was the funny one who could sell sell sell that thrive.
@@linzbell7354 you heard about the Benadryl/ Tylenol every day and night yeah I said it and meant it. No disrespect to the dead but truth is just that. I am so sorry the man she should have trusted with her life took her life along with the lovely baby girls as no one deserves that but I think they were co conspirators in the abuse of Bella and Celeste
Bella got the looks from her dad, but the hearth of her mother.
Check out Shannan's childhood photos if you can find them. Bella looks very much like them too.
@barbara baker-ruff- what is the matter with you ? One thing to call sweet children “ugly” but to talk so poorly of the deceased is of very poor taste . Very low class. You clearly have some major insecurities within yourself. I hate to wonder what you must look like to speak so horribly about these girls to make yourself feel some sort of gratification in your obviously miserable life. These sweet innocent girls were viciously murdered. Have some decency and compassion or don’t comment at all!
@@barbarabaker-ruff4520 imagine having to be such a miserable disgusting thing, that you result to commenting on how these beautiful innocent children look.
@@barbarabaker-ruff4520 they were little. I'm sure had their life not been robbed from them they would have grown up to be beautiful! Because both parents were great looking! I don't think they were ugly at all. I honestly believe you should have kept your opinion to yourself. That way you wouldn't have caused strife or hurt other people's feelings especially because of this very touchy subject. ❤
@@barbarabaker-ruff4520 not true for me as cece looks a lot like my youngest son 😏❤️ Anyway I spose I know what you mean as there is kiddos who actually make me go mad like mostly because I don't like their parents or because they are spoilt lil brats 😅 but then nooo, they might be annoying but they are not ugly. I havent seen an ugly kitten, dog puppy, piglet or toddler in me life! A baby is always a baby.
My absolute FAVORITE video of these two beautiful Angel's together is when they are on the couch together and Bella says, "NO, DONT TAKE HER AWAY!" Then she just holds her baby sister telling her not to be scared and rubbing her back. OMG it breaks my heart. Bella seemed to be such a kind and loving soul. I cant imagine how Shananns family makes it thru a day without those beautiful angels. If these moments make me cry, I cant fathom how they feel. I am so unbelievably sorry for your loss.
It wasn’t and isn’t just Shannans family who would have a hard time getting through each day. Cindy and Ronnie Watts are also their grandparents and are equally affected. In fact, more than 4 years later and Cindy barely makes it through to the end of each day.
The girls death affected all of us, strangers from all over the world, I can’t even begin to imagine the pain both families have gone through and will go through every single day for the rest of their lives.
The most horrific murders I’ve ever known. I honestly don’t know how the thoughts could enter someone’s mind with how they were murdered, and then not only thinking of such a sick twisted way, they actually did it! I still find it hard to comprehend.
.
Imho although their sperm donor took all their lives I don't believe for a nano second that one set of grandparents misses them any more or less than the other. How cold and just a silly comment. God Bless all affected by this tragedy.
@@jayceec3178 I totally agree with you.
I have yet to see or even hear of Watts’s parents crying over the grandbabies. All they are consumed with is getting their killing son out. Even watts’s pushed the picture of them away when he was talking to Chris. Hell, they didn't even go to the birthday party for CeCe.
I love to see Dieter in her videos too, so sweet and caring little dog.
Bella was just the sweetest, gentlest soul, she was an amazing big sister to Cece 😿💗
I've been thinking about Shanann, Bella & CeCe so much these past few days. Not sure why but my hope is that they'll never be forgotten.
i cannot get enough of the story I’m absolutely horrified with this guy that was two children I mean I don’t understand why he had to dump them in the oil tanks I mean literally destroying them he should’ve just put them with their mamaLove to ask him why he had to destroy them it was not enough that he told them he had to destroy them and let them soak in the oil tanks I mean how evil could you beAnd premeditatedly driving them there knowing he was going to kill them both is unreal and one by one not even to put the babies together in one tank put one in each tank I mean so conscious of what he was doing it’s sickening and then walk away and act like you did nothing keeping a straight face well not really talking to the media knowing they’re floating in the oil tanks is unbelievable this guy I hope he rots in prison
Those two precious angels are the sweetest. They are so loving, just watching Bella being so tender hearted and saying “Don’t take her away” is a tear jerker in light of what has happened.
What a gorgeous woman!! Her daughters were so precious...my heart is broken 💔
Those of us who have raised two or more children close in age know how much hard work it takes to teach and develop those little personalities, as well as keeping them fed, in clean clothes and active daily. Shanann was a beautiful and exemplary mother. Bella always can't seem to get close enough to CeCe. What a beautiful child aptly named.
I've never seen the first 3 videos before... They were just beautiful! Bella is so sweet to her Cece! Precious babies! 💜💜💜💙
CeCe looks so much like her NONNA.
Verdade,pobre nonna,as amava tanto,com seu quente sangue italiano
Sounds like her too
@Grape Jam 1968 wtf are you saying.
Just like her ♥️
And pop pop too!
Such a beautiful family every time I see one of her videos I sit and I just cry she was a beautiful woman she definitely deserve better and so did her children 💔😢
Even now , I still can’t believe they are gone ! ❤️
Oh Lord Jesus, my heart aches! I can’t wait to see them in Heaven!
That sweet lil voice and the baby sucking her thumb is so precious 😍
I don't get how their father can even do that to his precious daughters. They were so adorable and little.
How these girls love each other is sooooo beautiful and sweet. My heart is completely melted. I imagine them like this always! I hope my angel daughter has found them and they play together! 💜💜💜
Omgoodness, this video speaks volumes,, they should all be here!😢😔💕💕 the three of them were so nsync. Thank you for posting. I watch all the time . ♥️💜💜💜💜
sweetmisvixen you’re very welcome. ❤️
Aww " Don't be cared cece don't be cared." That was so precious. May they always be remembered 🌈❤
And then her mom hit her with, “be nice to CeCe.” Kind of weird.
It doesn't make any sense. Why? Such beautiful little girls with their whole lives ahead of them and Shanann a beautiful soul. R.I.P Angel's xxx
I can watch them 24/7. They are loved, Blowing infinity kisses to you all
Sweet little girls, in heaven with their mommy
Those girls are so incredibly cute. So precious. How anyone could take their last breath by smothering them is beyond me. So incredibly sad. Those girls would’ve been the best big sisters to Nico. Between Bella’s sneakiness and CC’s energy, they definitely kept Shannan on her toes! They’re in the arms of the angels now.
I love watching these videos of Shanann & her girls..... so sweet 🙂
I go back and watch all of their videos almost everyday. I never get them out of my head it's almost as if I lost them and they were my loved ones I feel so bad for their family but I love going back and watching their sweet videos
How can anyone kill a child heartbreaking
Whoever puts out these video’s every year, thank you. I can’t ever forget them. I feel like they were my own family and I didn’t know them. I love her family. God was there when they passed to bring them home. I hope I meet them in heaven. Seriously, I can’t wait to see all the family and friends I’ve lost along the way. My time is soon and I’m not sad about it. Jesus has me and will meet me too.
Cece is so cute. She looks just like Sandy
I see the same resemblance as well. Beautiful children!
I always thought that too!!🤗🥰 ...looks just like her Na-Na.❤
And those pigtails...precious babies.
That shot of those stairs just creeps me out Shan’ann never would have imagined that her doting husband would be dragging her down through those stairs. The kids are sooooooooo adorable. Why Chris, why!?!?
I still cannot wrap this around my mind. Such a,sad loss but why ? It's like happening more all the time They were all robbed of their lives.God Bless Her Family and Friends.🤗🤗🤗
I never get tired of seeing those two sweet little angels!!! oh my goodness, they are so so cute💖💖
Baby Cece 😍 I’ve never seen those videos before! Thank you so much for sharing! I can watch them all day ☺️
What beautiful kids & beautiful loving mom. Ill never understand how he could have done such a thing. He never deserved them.
Truly heartbreaking. I will never forget them either.
Bella was an awesome big sister!
Everytime I come on UA-cam I have to watch me some Bella and CeCe. They are my stars. I wish I could have seen them grow up. RIP Shannon, Bella , CeCe and Nico. You are missed soooo much. Cant wait to meet you in heaven.
Beautiful family, so sad they are not here 💔😢🥺💔 he's a monster
NK was a monster-evil. I keep thinking about her “dark friends”-I do believe he became as dark and evil as NK.
It hurts me so bad to know they aren’t here anymore .. I can only imagine how ppl who knew them feel . God bless you sweet beautiful angels
Bella was such a loving soul. She really looked out for CeCe and protected her. Shannan was a wonderful mother. She showed them true love and kindness . ❤️
Bella’s adorable “hi” at the start melts my heart! I can’t believe she had to witness her sister/BFF die :((
Such a beautiful loving Mother thank god for her videos for her family..
I will NEVER be able to comprehend just how he, as their father and a husband he, could do such a thing. As rough tough blue collard worker who has rode some of the busiest fire trucks in this country and has seen more death and destruction cannot watch the video of these beautiful innocent angels without crying.... and I don’t think we’ve see a legitimate tear come from that animalistic coward.
Sucks. I don’t understand.
Aww Bella was such a good big sister❤️ that part where she’s rubbing Cece’s back just melts my heart 💕
My goodness I can't stop crying. I'm watching the Christmas cookie video and I just can't comprehend it. HOW? They seem like such a lovely family, my mind just can't accept that what happened to them cannot be undone. I never knew I could feel this much pain for a family I've never met.
It’s heartbreaking 💔 They deserved so much better. It helps a little knowing they are in heaven pain free.
I never get over this case. It makes me really sad watching them. It breaks my heart with those little innocent girls.
Bella says: " Hi Bell" thinking that's what Shanann meant, her sweet little voice- she was so precious. CeCe so adorable and her personality- have you ever seen a more precious little girl!? I still think about them and visit videos to watch them as if I knew them. The cold reality, they're gone, something that's so hard to accept.
They were all so lovely. ❤️
Those girls were absolutely precious! He didn't deserve them. Hope he rots in his cell. RIP Shannan and your beautiful angels!
Shannan and her girls were so precious. I never met them, but after watching a lot of her videos, I feel like I knew them.
RIP Shannan, Bella, Celeste, and Nico ❤️
They were beautiful ! Bella is very sweet and Cece too, Bella has an aura of sweetness! I know God has them all! This is so sad even after a year! Shannan ❤️
I hope her family and her friends 👫 are healing, I think about them every day 😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪😪
Oh I'm so I love with them.cant help myself from tears watching their videos.Shannan
truly loved her daughters. My prayers for your souls shannan,bella,CeCe and Nick#FromPhilippines
Thank you for posting Shanann’s old videos. I love seeing her. ❤️
I do too. GORGEOUS woman mothering her precious babies. It is simply heartbreaking to know they aren't here with their Nana, Pop Pop and Uncle Frankie. I cannot imagine the depths of their pain. My heart prays for their peace💜💜💜💜
I have never seen two little ones so close to each other. They are loving and caring of each other. Momma had done a good job with her precious babies.
SO SO sweet n adorable. My goodness! 😢💞😇😇
precious babies. my heart hurts for them and shannan
awww these little girls were angles how could he do what he did to them shanann is sweet as can be
You can tell the way she interacts with her children she would never hurt them, may there soul Rest In Peace.
They where the cutest little girls 💖 Love you Shannan, Bella, Cece and Nico 💖💜💖
This video and many others are precious. Their grandparents must watch them over and over again. Little Bella is so gentle and little Cece is adorable. It’s so sad and to think we will never get to see little Nico. It’s heartbreaking......so sad.........and he lives on
When Bella leaned into the camera while reading, she looks just like Frank Sr. ❤️
It’s the first time I’ve seen Shan’s side in her. ❤️❤️
@taurpio yes it's amazing how photo's change our opinion"s of who someone looks like! I love this.
When I look at photos of my son when he's little ( or show them to others) Everyone including myself see his father - not me...as more photos were taken even only months apart and the same folks see the photos- they will say "I don't understand -" "Christopher?" ( my son) isn't looking like his dad he looks so much like your mother!
This is why I love how we change in the opinions of others practically over night lol!
I must say this and I'm sure others will see this as well- CeCe is the spitting image of Sandy - CeCe's Gramma ( Shannans moma)
GOD bless ALL of them - they are missed so MUCH.
That was precious. Little Bella was so relaxed reading us her book, chattering away. Yes, I am so glad that Shannan captured these memories for her family to cherish always and to show and remind the world of the beauty that was taken by the horrible atrocity that was committed upon them
@@theresacunningham2823 yes I'm so happy she did too. I don't see " fixed" videos - I only see genuine love in ALL her videos with the girls " the love of mother and her daughter's. You can't fake/ fix any of that .
@@margcourierservice4010 Yes, I see what you mean... So many of the Thrive videos were torn apart by others criticizing everything about them. That was Shananns JOB and only represented a few moments of the day with her children... These home videos truly show what they were like in life more so than the Thrive videos... Truly heartbreaking
I thought bella always looked like Chris but in this video I can see she woulda grown up looking like her mom
NC here!! I will never be able to rap my head around this one. It makes no sense at all why. Shanann was young, and someone would have loved to have them in their life. They could have moved on.. and been just fine with Sandy and Frank, Frankie Jr., all behind them for support.
I love the videos of Bella and Cece sitting together on the couch. I remember watching that last video (a few years ago) with Bella being so loving to Cece and telling her not to be scared and then there is a part where it sounds like Bella stated, "We can go home now." I imagined her comforting her in a similar way after their father they loved and trusted turned into a monster they did not know or recognize. She would be protective of Cece and Nico. I know they all found a new home in heaven. I do feel that Bella had a bit of intuition, but none of them could ever foresee what was about to happen to them. I love how they are so engrossed in the movie. They are so cute and innocent. I love this video and The Vision Board as also great with Bella. Shanann was such a great mom. Thank you for sharing this.
Everytime I see this, I catch myself smiling as I watch these beautiful precious girls. So sweet ❤❤
I love seeing Shannan holding her girls. Such simple loving little girls. Their Mommy took such good care of them. And they were so happy. I will never understand how something so terrible, could happen to these amazing girls. May they RIP.
@@underthefallenstars2788 you're just another hater, who can't wait to victim blame. She was a good mom. But nobody is perfect, of course. And those girls were well-developed, intelligent for their age. Bella was very protective of her sister, even though she was a baby herself. And those are the things people learn at home. So Shanann raised them well.
Mia Caruso so true! If only she left that monster before he had a chance to get rid of them.
@@underthefallenstars2788 wat is wrong with you??
She was absolutely beautiful, with lovely girls. Please Rest In Peace.
Awe what pretty girls!!
I cant get over the fact... That she thought her husband was having a affair little did she know he was also planning to kill off her and her precious babies... One thing I'm at peace with is that they are together ❤ and that monster is behind bars probably trying to fool himself or the guards or inmates...yeah I killed my family but im still a cool dude ... just sickness me... Watching her posts I smile and cry... She did get to live and enjoy life for awhile and even spend time with her family before it all went down.. What a loss for us here on earth but a huge gain for heaven with their presence 🤍💫🙏
Bella, CeCe Niko and Shannan together forever in each others arms,
Four beautiful souls too good for this earth,
Four lights forever shining free from pain, discomfort and hurt,
We will remember them though we knew them not in life,
Yet we will remember them with love and share in their smiles.
Remember them happy, and joyful and fun
For they were an unknown blessing for each one of us
Do not be sad that they are not here, they are safe and they are loved in a far away place where there is no fear.
God bless Shannan and Niko Bella and Celeste, God called them home because he only takes the very very best.
Beautiful 💗
I am not a number! You made me cry and smile.. ❤️
@@shininglight143 thank you.
@@rebecca3242 im sorry, I didn't mean to make you cry.
I am not a number
That was so beautifully written .
Such beautiful Angels.... I used to watch her all the time.
It's hard to believe they aren't here anymore. More so how they went. God give their family the strength to get through each day. May they rest in paradise eternally Shannan, Cee Cee, Bella, & Baby Nico. 🙏👼👩👧👧💕
I will never forget this two beautiful babies. Even though I don't know them, I love them so much & they are still in my heart forever and ever. Love from Philippines 🇵🇭
Bella reading the book was too much. Shes so cute!!!
Pure sisterly love. I've been bawling my eyes out for days now thinking about that moment during the car ride to the oil field, holding each other and napping in each other's laps, not knowing what horrific nightmare awaits them, completely entrusting their lives to that monster. Sweet angels, May God Have Mercy on Us!
Same here ! May they Rest In Peace, and CW burns in hell one day
Our hearts are broken still to this day 💔 I look for there videos every day still can't believe this happen to such beautiful people ❤️
I can't believe any human being, let alone a Dad , could do what he did. I still miss not seeing Shannon, Bella, and cc .Still makes me want to cry 😢😢😢❤❤❤
They're always included in my daily Holy Rosary, I care so much for them.....Shannan, Bella and Cece and the unborn baby boy Nico. God bless them !
They are soooooo precious when I see Shannan I see such a strong woman full of light and life. Rest in peace 💞💞💞💞
Pretty little blessings. Beautiful woman.
Loving these precious videos!!!! Of true Angels 💖💖💖
Little Bella would have loved school if she had gotten the opportunity to go. It still breaks my heart that they were taken away like that. Karma will come around to all those involved in their murders. Rest in peace Shanann, Bella, C.C. & Nico. ❤️😇 We all are still thinking of you everyday!
I totally agree. She adored books and although her speech was a bit delayed she sure could get into books even making up stories from the pictures. She was destined to be someone great. CeeCee needed some discipline in her little life but what 2 yo doesn't? Fly high lovely Angels and yes I am including Niko.
Bella loved Cee Cee so much . I’ll bet Bella is still taking care of Cee Cee in Heaven. We will never forget these little Angels or beautiful ShanAnn .🥰❤️🙏🏼😇😇😇😇