1) is there any doubt that temples were not destroyed in large numbers? 2) I also understand we cannot hold back into past, but should not the other community hand over Kashi and mathura if it was destroyed? These 3 are very important temples historically for Hindu community just like Mecca medina and al-aqsa for Muslims. If USA plans to destroy any of the above 3, will they forget the past and move forward? Without acknowledgment there won’t be peace. I hope and pray for peace in our country so that we can focus on real issues.
Your last sentence says it all! How about working on the NUMEROUS REAL issues and leaving the past where it should rightly belong - in the past! Imagine if the whole world began trying to right the wrongs of history! There'd be mayhem!! So let's all get down to helping each other to make our nation truly great! Jai Hind!
@ferryanklesaria unfortunately world doesn't work that way. Acknowledgment is very important, we could get over Britishers because there was honesty. People need to tell history as such, it was a part of our history and you cannot erase it, the more you try to hide the more people go behind it and doubt your intent. And I'm sure with honesty would come acceptance as "most" of the indians are mature. So I hope politicians stop their work in hiding and mingling history and do the work for which they're chosen.
Al aqsa mosque also built after destroying Jewish temple Mount. There r thousand of temples that have been destroyed during invasions. That romila thapad and her gang has delibrately whitewashed history textbooks. Changing history textbooks doesn't make Islam secular
It's unfortunate that when GOI under Modiji is extending welfare schemes to poor people irrespective of caste, creed and religion muslims who have also benefited from the schemes are openly saying we will not vote for bjp.
@@sridharmahalingam8190 fool someone else..BJP/RSS is about Brahmanwad which is am quite aware of being Brahman.. So basically we should not believe our eye and ear and experience..how Muslims are being treated and projected by Whole BJP and it's Godi Media and the whole system..and believe ur bllsht.
Every person has the right to vote for anyone they choose, irrespective of whether they are recipient of any welfare schemes or not! I have met several people in Maharashtra who voted for Uddhav Shiv sena but are beneficiaries of the ladki behna scheme launched by the Mahayuti government. They are all Hindus!
If welfare schemes are for all the poor then why so much against reservation and support for EWS? Why don't poor upper castes be happy with them and oppose affirmative action for backward castes?
I believe he's clearly stated the problems that plague the Muslim community, lack of secular education, poverty, ghettoisation, (for which we are partly responsible), lack of enlightened leadership and sectarian conflicts! Here's an upright man who's served the nation faithfully and is working in the field of education! Which Muslim would want a dialogue with the RSS? But he did!! Salute you sir for your service to the nation! Jai Hind
@ I don’t think he sees ghettoisation as an issue. Also he said education is important but never talked about secular education. I am only criticising him to the extent that we need people who takes the issue of radicalisation headon and don’t beat around the bush.
General sb thank you for your service to the country. Since you mentioned AMU, I have studied from AMU and it is highly communal. AMU closes its cafeterias during ramzan even though non Muslim students study and live there. I can cite several examples of how rotten the university is. Hope you will double click and see for yourself
Correct. It is highly radical Islamist....and that's not a minority. Although the behavior and discipline in the student population is noteworthy, it is the discipline that one sees at a madrassa.
She does not ask about stone pelting by muslims; opposition to CAA and NHRC laws, Kashmir Pandit massacre, Secular Hindu majority, Communal nature of muslims etc
No it is not ..infact family size is what make them survive. Most Muslims are physical labour. More people work more household income. Same goes with Hindu labour community especially Tribal Sc St.. It is only the privilege cast has the luxury to do family planning and be a Hindu nationalist to look down upon Muslims and Minority which BTW were low cast Hindu once
There is a very interesting debate going on currently in Pakistan about whether Gazhnavi was a hero of Islam. It is very difficult to reconcile with people who believe that Gazhnavi and Aurangzebs were heroes and secular leaders.
If everything will be fairly calculated forward castes will not be able to repay. A timely rethink is needed before things might get out of hand. The case against muslims could easily turn against the disproportionately well-endowed on the basis of a single caste-census.
Only a reconciliation process such as what happened in South Africa is what is required to address the festering sore between the two communities. Anything less will not be sufficient to sublimate what is smoking! Immeasurable empathy on the face of Barkha, right through!
Exactly, Sir. That too in response to abuse of Hindu Gods by criminal Rehmani and manipulated by Zubair and escalated by Owaisi himself so some mullahs that made jihadis killing innocent people and confined her to house but even Modi's government found helpless to punish as CJI released Zubair to satisfy opposition parties that he is not Sanghi but neutral.
Criticize the violence in ur community sir. When majority of muslims think there should be death penalty for insulting prophet,leaving islam,gays dont you think its a problem.
Respected General SB don't want to catch the bull by the horn that is religious orthodoxy and fundamentalism among Muslims which is holding back the Indian and largely the whole world Muslim community that's why they are suffering from poverty, illiteracy and ghettoization etc . Hindu fundamentalism is rising in reaction to this Muslim radicalization and enlightened people like Mr. Shah needed to take lead and take them to the right path towards modernization and enlightenment. Salute to his services to the nation 🙏.
For the highly graded Muslim onto the TV that too in front of Barkha, should have the Persian Word HINDU, should have recited Surah Al Kafroon, where its declared by the Quran addressing disbelievers that Unto you, yours, unto is mine. The Arabic Version is Lakum Dina Kum.
Sir, you don't even know the meaning of, word Hindu, the Supreme court judged the Hindu is not the name of any religion, why should you have a problem for a Geographical name?
Next time Sir, if you r invited to talk about Islam do accompany the the Islamic Theologist, islam is not about warfare, or disciplinning fellow muslims, kindly read The Quran. You may probably find the most cosmopolitan and generious musings before 1400 Years ago.
Seriously no one cares what is written. Its not my religion, why would i care. You will get judged based on how your community is doing with social indicators and whether they are blocker to Bharats progress or an enabler.
Who cares what is there but what is understood by mullahs and jihadis that matters. It's they who are killing other religion people in the name of kafirs and want to establish islamic rule throughout the world,sir. Not seeing what's happening through out the world?. How you people claim so seeing how IS, Taliban and HAMAS etc killing other religion people and even among themselves in the name of sunnis, Shias and Ahnedias etc. Are on earth or in MARS?
Theses educated Muslims should do more to bring madrasa students to mainstream edication
1) is there any doubt that temples were not destroyed in large numbers?
2) I also understand we cannot hold back into past, but should not the other community hand over Kashi and mathura if it was destroyed? These 3 are very important temples historically for Hindu community just like Mecca medina and al-aqsa for Muslims. If USA plans to destroy any of the above 3, will they forget the past and move forward? Without acknowledgment there won’t be peace.
I hope and pray for peace in our country so that we can focus on real issues.
Your last sentence says it all! How about working on the NUMEROUS REAL issues and leaving the past where it should rightly belong - in the past! Imagine if the whole world began trying to right the wrongs of history! There'd be mayhem!! So let's all get down to helping each other to make our nation truly great! Jai Hind!
@ferryanklesaria unfortunately world doesn't work that way. Acknowledgment is very important, we could get over Britishers because there was honesty. People need to tell history as such, it was a part of our history and you cannot erase it, the more you try to hide the more people go behind it and doubt your intent. And I'm sure with honesty would come acceptance as "most" of the indians are mature. So I hope politicians stop their work in hiding and mingling history and do the work for which they're chosen.
@@ferryanklesariathat's not how it works.
Al aqsa mosque also built after destroying Jewish temple Mount. There r thousand of temples that have been destroyed during invasions. That romila thapad and her gang has delibrately whitewashed history textbooks. Changing history textbooks doesn't make Islam secular
It's unfortunate that when GOI under Modiji is extending welfare schemes to poor people irrespective of caste, creed and religion muslims who have also benefited from the schemes are openly saying we will not vote for bjp.
@@sridharmahalingam8190 fool someone else..BJP/RSS is about Brahmanwad which is am quite aware of being Brahman..
So basically we should not believe our eye and ear and experience..how Muslims are being treated and projected by Whole BJP and it's Godi Media and the whole system..and believe ur bllsht.
Every person has the right to vote for anyone they choose, irrespective of whether they are recipient of any welfare schemes or not! I have met several people in Maharashtra who voted for Uddhav Shiv sena but are beneficiaries of the ladki behna scheme launched by the Mahayuti government. They are all Hindus!
If welfare schemes are for all the poor then why so much against reservation and support for EWS? Why don't poor upper castes be happy with them and oppose affirmative action for backward castes?
I think he is severely downplaying the issues within the Muslim community.
I believe he's clearly stated the problems that plague the Muslim community, lack of secular education, poverty, ghettoisation, (for which we are partly responsible), lack of enlightened leadership and sectarian conflicts! Here's an upright man who's served the nation faithfully and is working in the field of education! Which Muslim would want a dialogue with the RSS? But he did!! Salute you sir for your service to the nation! Jai Hind
@ I don’t think he sees ghettoisation as an issue. Also he said education is important but never talked about secular education. I am only criticising him to the extent that we need people who takes the issue of radicalisation headon and don’t beat around the bush.
General sb thank you for your service to the country. Since you mentioned AMU, I have studied from AMU and it is highly communal. AMU closes its cafeterias during ramzan even though non Muslim students study and live there. I can cite several examples of how rotten the university is. Hope you will double click and see for yourself
Correct. It is highly radical Islamist....and that's not a minority. Although the behavior and discipline in the student population is noteworthy, it is the discipline that one sees at a madrassa.
@@ashu1973 exactly. They worship Mohd Ali Jinnah in that campus
She does not ask about stone pelting by muslims; opposition to CAA and NHRC laws, Kashmir Pandit massacre, Secular Hindu majority, Communal nature of muslims etc
it's hard for INDIA to get people like APJ ABDUL KALAM anymore. It isn't easy to trust people who don't acknowledge the past.
General Saab just missed the most important cause of Muslim poverty and that’s their family size, hope General Saab would have mentioned it
No it is not ..infact family size is what make them survive.
Most Muslims are physical labour. More people work more household income. Same goes with Hindu labour community especially Tribal Sc St..
It is only the privilege cast has the luxury to do family planning and be a Hindu nationalist to look down upon Muslims and Minority which BTW were low cast Hindu once
I mean the bigger problem is the violence.
Family size has reduced to 2.3 children per family.
Hopefully reaches 2 or below
Too much hatred.
Hatred begets hatred.
Who is responsible?
From 712 with Gauri and then Gaznavi.
Is it possible to forgive and forget?
There is a very interesting debate going on currently in Pakistan about whether Gazhnavi was a hero of Islam. It is very difficult to reconcile with people who believe that Gazhnavi and Aurangzebs were heroes and secular leaders.
Exactly
If everything will be fairly calculated forward castes will not be able to repay. A timely rethink is needed before things might get out of hand. The case against muslims could easily turn against the disproportionately well-endowed on the basis of a single caste-census.
@@devil1000ish Let's first calculate it with Muslims. Muslims are not paying us through reservations..
@@devil1000ish Let's first calculate with Gaznavi worshipers. They are not paying us through rerservations.
Only a reconciliation process such as what happened in South Africa is what is required to address the festering sore between the two communities. Anything less will not be sufficient to sublimate what is smoking! Immeasurable empathy on the face of Barkha, right through!
The same venomous barkha she will never change
The problem is not with the officer and vice chancellor but with badi kitab
General Saab has an impeccable English with an impeccable accent. Salute for your services to the nation.
Great conversation! Most interesting.
Nupur had never insulted prophet. She quoted quran and hadish text. Fake narrative made against her.
Exactly, Sir. That too in response to abuse of Hindu Gods by criminal Rehmani and manipulated by Zubair and escalated by Owaisi himself so some mullahs that made jihadis killing innocent people and confined her to house but even Modi's government found helpless to punish as CJI released Zubair to satisfy opposition parties that he is not Sanghi but neutral.
Criticize the violence in ur community sir.
When majority of muslims think there should be death penalty for insulting prophet,leaving islam,gays dont you think its a problem.
What abt the various hate speeches made by prominent muslim leaders like Owaisi...
Respected General SB don't want to catch the bull by the horn that is religious orthodoxy and fundamentalism among Muslims which is holding back the Indian and largely the whole world Muslim community that's why they are suffering from poverty, illiteracy and ghettoization etc .
Hindu fundamentalism is rising in reaction to this Muslim radicalization and enlightened people like Mr. Shah needed to take lead and take them to the right path towards modernization and enlightenment. Salute to his services to the nation 🙏.
ZU Shah sir is a thorough gentleman
Great guy.
This was an excellent interview 👏👏👏 👌! The fact that in these charged times you haven't been trolled so far, is a huge comment initself! 😊
If every person was like u sir there would be no problem but reality is different
Having this stupid discussion reinforces the fact that you as anchor have not changed. Same old crappy ideas
For the highly graded Muslim onto the TV that too in front of Barkha, should have the Persian Word HINDU, should have recited Surah Al Kafroon, where its declared by the Quran addressing disbelievers that Unto you, yours, unto is mine. The Arabic Version is Lakum Dina Kum.
Sir, you don't even know the meaning of, word Hindu, the Supreme court judged the Hindu is not the name of any religion, why should you have a problem for a Geographical name?
Next time Sir, if you r invited to talk about Islam do accompany the the Islamic Theologist, islam is not about warfare, or disciplinning fellow muslims, kindly read The Quran. You may probably find the most cosmopolitan and generious musings before 1400 Years ago.
Seriously no one cares what is written. Its not my religion, why would i care. You will get judged based on how your community is doing with social indicators and whether they are blocker to Bharats progress or an enabler.
Who cares what is there but what is understood by mullahs and jihadis that matters. It's they who are killing other religion people in the name of kafirs and want to establish islamic rule throughout the world,sir. Not seeing what's happening through out the world?. How you people claim so seeing how IS, Taliban and HAMAS etc killing other religion people and even among themselves in the name of sunnis, Shias and Ahnedias etc. Are on earth or in MARS?
Thanks for commenting. You showed your true colours.
We donot need to know anything about arabic religion which is very divisive and violent.
Silute. Mathura and Gyanbapi too to be solved.
The title suits the anchor better than anyone.
Major sahab. U know very well how secular islam and muslims r. Idlam doesnt have concept of secularism pluralism freedom of speech and expression...