Dear Yulia, thank you for presenting this interesting talk to us. It may interest you that what Mr. Cooper so wonderfully did with the first movement I tried to do also with the Scherzo and Andante. Here is my piano reduction of this Scherzo based on Beethoven's sketched powerful main theme (24 bars) and Trio (7 bars) : ua-cam.com/video/xBzqt2uUrVM/v-deo.html gerdprengel.de/Scherzo_on_10th_piano.pdf
Liszt wrote that the duration of the Hammerklavier sonata was almost one hour, so even in those days it wasn't played that fast. This is an interesting video about metronome markings for Beethoven's works: ua-cam.com/video/vBFmJVG0wak/v-deo.html
I listened to Barry Cooper’s symphony. It has nothing to do with Beethoven, it is a hodgepodge, a low hanging fruit. Nothing personal, he sounds like a fun guy but the music!
Such a pleasure to have done this project! Please let me know if you have any questions!!Would be delighted to connect.
Dear Yulia, thank you for presenting this interesting talk to us. It may interest you that what Mr. Cooper so wonderfully did with the first movement I tried to do also with the Scherzo and Andante. Here is my piano reduction of this Scherzo based on Beethoven's sketched powerful main theme (24 bars) and Trio (7 bars) : ua-cam.com/video/xBzqt2uUrVM/v-deo.html gerdprengel.de/Scherzo_on_10th_piano.pdf
Are you a musicologist yourself, Yulia?
Liszt wrote that the duration of the Hammerklavier sonata was almost one hour, so even in those days it wasn't played that fast. This is an interesting video about metronome markings for Beethoven's works: ua-cam.com/video/vBFmJVG0wak/v-deo.html
The Revolution which never occured. Its structure would really affect 19th century music, and it would look completely different.
I listened to Barry Cooper’s symphony. It has nothing to do with Beethoven, it is a hodgepodge, a low hanging fruit. Nothing personal, he sounds like a fun guy but the music!
What about the themes, sketches and fragments. Not beethoven? Or is it about the harmony?
@@sativares it has Beethoven’s elements but it is a mishmash. Compare it to the scherzo of the 9th Smphony, the distance is abysmal