I am getting a Geshelli DAC some day. I'm buying a new house at the ripe old age of 67 (stupid) and my new listening room will be 3 times the size of my current one. I need some upgrades badly!!! I'm waiting patiently for Randy's garage sale! LOL
I've been using a D50s in my bedroom system, it sits between a 50 year old Sansui AU-517 and my modern sources, USB from a laptop that fetches hi-rez rips on my home server, Optical is connected to a Google Chromecast Audio and Coax is connected to Pioneer Elite CD/HDCD/SACD player. It is a great device and adding a remote volume to a vintage set-up is fantastic.
This channel has turned into a joke. Next up a 200 dollar speaker is going to beat a Borresen speaker 30 times it's price. Oh wait, the SSCS5 does that... my bad...
You know I have always thought I had the latest stuff but I never heard of DACS until this year when I came across your channel learning so much. Thank you.
Makes all the difference. Before my setup cost was 70% speakers, 20% signal (CD) and 10% amp. Now its almost the opposite. You can make some speakers sound so much better with a good DAC (doesn´t need cost much). Even with Spotify its a big difference.
Agree that the Su1 is a great little unit with amazing performace for the price. I recently upgraded it to the SMSL DO100Pro and playing CDs through my oppo UDP - 203 as a Transport which has given me a greater sound stage, lower floor and instruments have a little bit more air. not sure of pricing in the States between the Do100 Pro to the 50III but in Australia the are in the same price point with the later been $100 more. Specs wise it also has two chips like the Topping in the form of the ES9039Q2M chips. Woiuld be really interested of your review on the SMSL DO100Pro at some stage. Keep up the good work.
I am using 3 Topping E50's on my disc spinners. The first 2 were $200 and the last one on sale was $159. 3 filter settings and a sample rate display. Audio Science Review loves this DAC. If it has never been measured I won't buy it.
Let me ask you guys something. How would be the aound quality comparing the topping with the built in dac on the wiim ultra, would the extra cost of having a external dac wirth it? Tks!
I'm pretty happy with my Matrix mini pro (2015). It doesn't have the fancy streaming stuff of the newer models but it sounds great! It only cost me $130 too!
I'm kind of curious how this compares to my SMSL SU8s. I find it strange that they're using TRS connectors for the balanced out on the d50III instead of XLR connectors that offer significantly better electrical noise reduction while still being cheap as chips.
You were the first to mention that there is no Topping Tune version for MacOS. This is a major downside for people who, like me, are not willing to use Windows 10/11 just to tune a DAC. Honestly, I don't believe they will make a Mac version in the future. I am looking for a DAC to use with TIDAL through my smartphone (Galaxy S21 FE) wired or wirelessly. The SMSL SU-1 failed due to the absence of separate inputs for power and data via USB-C. I had to increase my budget, and the model that seemed most interesting was the SMSL D6S, which comes with a built-in power supply and all the connections I need... and MQA compatibility! The release of the Topping D50III made me consider this product as the main competitor to the D6S because they are in the same price range and have practically the same connections and sound characteristics. The lack of an included power supply is a downside because we know that the quality of the power supply affects the equipment's performance. Another point that matters to me is the presence of a joystick instead of a rotary knob to adjust the volume. Although I haven't made a direct comparison between the D50III and the D6S, the comments from colleagues are helping me decide, and I am seriously inclined to go with the SMSL D6S. Thank you, friends!
Uhm all of Amir's reviews get Pink Panthers. The question is which one? Happy Panther is good. Golfing Panther is top rating... And if its neither of them... fugitabout it.
hey i need a amp to power my subwoofers or just to give them the extra kick they can produce i have one amplifier that i get all the main power from then it goes into a small amp and makes my subs sound amazing but it will cut in and out or the music will cut out totally and i have to turn the amp off and back on i think its because of volt drop its a fosi audio TB10D amp it only happens at high volume and it has the 48v 5a power supply so i either need a new power supply if you recommend one or a new amp amp specifications i would like cheep 4 channel around 100watts rms more or less also it is connected to a other amp too 4 ohms it would power 4 15inch subs 500watt rms 1000watts peak
No annihilates either....that's been used to death. I know it's about getting attenion but lately it's all been overused. What happened to this channel that it has come to this?
A properly designed DAC cannot sound better or worse than any other well designed DAC by definition as any difference perceptible to a human would immediately disqualify it from being "properly designed". The electrical differences in competently designed DACs are so infinitesimally small you'd have a better chance of noticing a blade of grass under your pillow at night when going to sleep.
How' bout testing of different hearing aid devices ?? - Even though, your channel, most probably, appeals to the younger segment, still - the old farts, don't always buy, only, most expensive stuff.... And what is the good stuff good for - if your hearing ssucks ??!! 😀😀
I use a Topping D50 in my vehicle, because it runs off 5v. I connect my iphone to it via cable, not Bluetooth, through an adapter. Then connect the D50 to the stereo system by 3.5mm cable. It sounds much better this way, rather than via Bluetooth straight to the vehicle stereo system. I wished more manufacturers would use 5v supplies. It saves utilising an inverter to supply the 240v (UK) supply of most equipment.
I like the smsl d6s a touch more. The midrange is more pleasing but the topping has better highs 🤷 great review CAM. Maybe a side by side in the future?
This is the impression I got after watching many reviews, IIWIreviews describes the Topping d50 iii highs as “radiant” and Rick Ruiz Audio has a sound test that shows this, while the d6s has been described as having better mid-range in comparison, but from many online reviews the d6s is already relatively a leaner sounding DAC tonally, this made it easier for me to choose the d6s because I valued mid-range rather than the highs in this class of DAC’s.
I bought a Topping D50 last summer and my experience wasn't good. I really like my SMSL SU-1 but if I was spending more than the Schitt I'd just go with Geshelli J2. If this was priced closer to the Schitt that would give me pause but if my choices are similar performance and one is domestic and one isn't I'll probably go with domestic.
I own a WiiM Pro Plus that I'm using both as a streamer and a DAC. How much better would the D50 III sound compared to the DAC inside my WiiM Pro Plus?
Join the dark side... get a PC! In all seriousness though, I have never plugged headphones into a DAC before, so I don't know if I want to spend the money on one or not??? Maybe I will order one from a place that will let me return it since I am not sure if I'll be able to tell the difference between using one or not using one.
3 місяці тому+1
There are over 2 Billion PCs in the world. How many Macs are there? 40? 50? It's not Topping's fault if they made a product for VHS and you bought betamax. FTR, I have an M1 MBP13, but I don't expect anything to work on it. I have useful computers for that.
I bought the Eversolo D6 this time last year. It’s an excellent streamer/NAS device for roughly $900 plus some for adding 4GB solid state storage. Feed it FLAC files with a subscription to Tidal to drive a pair of rebuilt Carver Amazing Loudspeakers and I’m in audio heaven!
More destruction! Will thy mayhem never end? This video destroyed my subscription. We had a good run, cheap aufio man. I can't do anymore of your paid infomercials of destruction.
Funny how you’re the only reviewer that I can find that hates the SU-X. If you have a warm sounding system, the SU-X might just be the ticket? Topping D50 III looks nice, but by time you buy a proper Pwr Supply this makes this alternative around the $500 price range. The D50 III is in the SMSL D100 Pro price bracket. Curious which would sound better?
Noob question... Would there be a benefit to using the output control on the DAC rather than using the volume control on my stereo amplifier? Could I leave the DAC on 100% or is a lower number optional? I have no idea. Thanks in advance.
I'd suggest using the DAC to control source volume and using the amp volume more as a gain knob; set at amp at the max you would ever listen at then never touch it again. In theory the Dac can lose quality at lower volumes because of they way they sample but if initial sample rate is high enough it shouldn't matter. An amp can also have channel imbalance at lower volumes too( ex. left louder than right), and using the dac for volume will let you keep the amp out of (above) that zone where there might be channel imbalance.
I read the same thing. If it worked on all inputs I think this dac would be more popular. PEQ functions is a big deal. But I'm not totally sure if it's USB only.
Wow, no Mac support just killed it for me. Do a mobile app, at least. I do have a WinPC for gaming but it’s not connected to my main system. All these ChiFi companies are great with hardware but the talent needed for software is just never there. FiiO, looking in your direction. 👀
Actually not many audio companies are strong with software. Not sure if chifi ones are the worst... Sure Fiio is a bad (good?) example, but you also have wiim, eversolo and the sort. Having strong software is hard, specially for smaller companies like most of the audio ones, it takes a lot of (constant) investment, that not always corresponds to more sales.
Chinese software was not brilliant even for windows, but due to "quite cold" relationship btw US and China I wouldn't wait for Mac software support in closest future. They are pushed out of US market in many spheres so going for EU/Russian market is logical step. And these regions are mostly "windows based".
I have 2 DAC’s, the SMSL C200 and the FIIO K11. I bought the K11 because the USB input on the C200 decided to stop working, and I use that for my phone when streaming. I was very disappointed with the K11, though it is very detailed, it is also very sibilant, grainy and doesn’t seem to have a full sense of scale and doesn’t dig low in the bass region. Very underwhelming DAC. Looking for something that replaces both these DAC’s.
🚨 Good news: I set this next to my Denafrips and it *did not destroy* anything. Everything still in full working order, phew. Guess I must have been lucky.
Gen x here....Was an audio nut back in the day but now want to get into the home theater seen.. What dac do you recommend with hdmi inputs? Are hdmi worth using?
I have 2 different Geshelli J2's on an Emotiva TA1. The DAC in the Emotiva is fine. Each of my J2 DAC's (different op amps) sounds better than the Emotiva.
Hi. I need a DAC and can't decide . If I get the D50 III, maybe for a better performance I will need the P50 linear supply. At the same price as D50 III and P50, it's the Topping E70 which have ESS Sabre 9028PRO inside and ofcourse the power supply built in. What do you suggest to choose? Thanks! Great videos btw!
you do not need the power supply, use an decent power adapter (apple for example) with an usb c cable. if youre gonna spend $100+ for a power supply might as well save and get a better DAC
Are you going to do a separate review of the A50 III amp? Or is it a less notable / less interesting product release than the D50 III such that it doesn't warrant a separate review?
It’s good. Unfortunately, my audience isn’t nearly as interested in headphone related products than in 2 channel products. When I do those types of videos I just don’t get the views. I enjoy headphone products for sure but I have to be very choosy about the products I cover
I'm using Wiim Pro -> Topping E50 -> L50 with DCA Aeon Closed and I can tell you the Wiim pEQ is necessary to tone down the headphones. I'm wondering if its time for a Topping stack upgrade, as I can't keep up with them every time they put out a new DAC/Amp series. These definitely look a bit sleeker than the older ones.
Really, how old was it when it died and what happened? I was thinking of purchasing 3 of their products also. A dac, headphone amp, and audio interface. What did u have that died also?
This DAC doesn't make much sense. It lacks the following inputs that I think are pretty much mandatory: AES/EBU, or I2s (the latter is the best in my opinion). It also does not have XLR outputs; which to me are almost mandatory in a $200+ DAC. I cringe now when I see RCA outs like that -- knowing the type of distortion and yuck that comes with it. With the SMSL d6s in existence, there really is no need to look at this DAC. The only reason to deviate from the SMSL d6s is if you want or need I2s and AES/EBU inputs -- which this DAC you reviewed doesn't have anyway. At that point, move on to the SMSL DO300 or something similar.
@Randy. Very nice and well done video! Nice to see you going back to your roots and reviewing an actually affordable item! While I did have high hopes for this, when you mentioned the Geshelli J2 and the 4493 version and how it still beats it, it does confirm my initial thoughts on DACs as based on many reviews in the past. Not only yours, but others as well. Granted, as you pointed out, the downside is that the Geshelli is only a DAC and I could see having a DAC that could also double as a pre-amp. The D50III could definitely fit that bill, however, what I am waiting for right now, is the release of the Wiim Ultra. I think that unit would cover all bases for me. I am wondering how the DAC in that compares to the Geshelli J2. This brings me to another question in regards to the J2 4499. How does the stock op amp J2 4499 sound in comparison to the J2 4493 with the Sparkos op amps?
I am getting a Geshelli DAC some day. I'm buying a new house at the ripe old age of 67 (stupid) and my new listening room will be 3 times the size of my current one. I need some upgrades badly!!! I'm waiting patiently for Randy's garage sale! LOL
You don't look a day over 66.
@@ptioxon LOL! Thanks!
good for u. if u can afford it no regrets
@@rolandd5397 Thanks!
The house did not come with a free DAC?
I've been using a D50s in my bedroom system, it sits between a 50 year old Sansui AU-517 and my modern sources, USB from a laptop that fetches hi-rez rips on my home server, Optical is connected to a Google Chromecast Audio and Coax is connected to Pioneer Elite CD/HDCD/SACD player. It is a great device and adding a remote volume to a vintage set-up is fantastic.
Sounds like an awesome setup up!!!!!
That very similar to how I use mine.
This channel has turned into a joke. Next up a 200 dollar speaker is going to beat a Borresen speaker 30 times it's price. Oh wait, the SSCS5 does that... my bad...
You know I have always thought I had the latest stuff but I never heard of DACS until this year when I came across your channel learning so much. Thank you.
Makes all the difference. Before my setup cost was 70% speakers, 20% signal (CD) and 10% amp. Now its almost the opposite. You can make some speakers sound so much better with a good DAC (doesn´t need cost much). Even with Spotify its a big difference.
Agree that the Su1 is a great little unit with amazing performace for the price. I recently upgraded it to the SMSL DO100Pro and playing CDs through my oppo UDP - 203 as a Transport which has given me a greater sound stage, lower floor and instruments have a little bit more air. not sure of pricing in the States between the Do100 Pro to the 50III but in Australia the are in the same price point with the later been $100 more. Specs wise it also has two chips like the Topping in the form of the ES9039Q2M chips. Woiuld be really interested of your review on the SMSL DO100Pro at some stage. Keep up the good work.
Nice review. I had the SMSL DAC with the garbled distortion too. Returned for a Topping Velveeta Cheese DAC and all is tasty.
I am using 3 Topping E50's on my disc spinners. The first 2 were $200 and the last one on sale was $159. 3 filter settings and a sample rate display. Audio Science Review loves this DAC. If it has never been measured I won't buy it.
Schiit Modius FTW. Or better yet, the Schiit Modi Multibit for a few bucks more.
The design form of this DAC looks a lot like the Lavaudio DS601, just with some extra connections on the back.
Let me ask you guys something. How would be the aound quality comparing the topping with the built in dac on the wiim ultra, would the extra cost of having a external dac wirth it? Tks!
I'm pretty happy with my Matrix mini pro (2015). It doesn't have the fancy streaming stuff of the newer models but it sounds great! It only cost me $130 too!
Smsl D6s ...please review
I'm kind of curious how this compares to my SMSL SU8s. I find it strange that they're using TRS connectors for the balanced out on the d50III instead of XLR connectors that offer significantly better electrical noise reduction while still being cheap as chips.
If u can get a smsl do 100 pro please compare it to this topping d50 iii
How does this compare the the DAC in the new WiiM ultra in terms of specs? I’m going to run some v3mono’s and a WiiM ultra. Deciding if i need a DAC.
You were the first to mention that there is no Topping Tune version for MacOS. This is a major downside for people who, like me, are not willing to use Windows 10/11 just to tune a DAC. Honestly, I don't believe they will make a Mac version in the future.
I am looking for a DAC to use with TIDAL through my smartphone (Galaxy S21 FE) wired or wirelessly. The SMSL SU-1 failed due to the absence of separate inputs for power and data via USB-C. I had to increase my budget, and the model that seemed most interesting was the SMSL D6S, which comes with a built-in power supply and all the connections I need... and MQA compatibility!
The release of the Topping D50III made me consider this product as the main competitor to the D6S because they are in the same price range and have practically the same connections and sound characteristics. The lack of an included power supply is a downside because we know that the quality of the power supply affects the equipment's performance. Another point that matters to me is the presence of a joystick instead of a rotary knob to adjust the volume.
Although I haven't made a direct comparison between the D50III and the D6S, the comments from colleagues are helping me decide, and I am seriously inclined to go with the SMSL D6S. Thank you, friends!
Why Why Why did you use Max Champion at the 6:31 mark. Been to see Joe Jackson lately ?
Good vid 👍👍
Why use a Weam mini with D50Mark III
Ripple?? My preference is some Mad Dog 20/20 or maybe Night Train only the finest 20% "fortified" stuff. Have an SMSL SU-1 for backup
What about compared to the SMSL D-6S for a similar price?
i'll stick with the dac in my Mission 778x amp & instead save some money & get the Mission 778s streamer when it arrives in the autumn.
Does it work with other topping ir remote ?
Uhm all of Amir's reviews get Pink Panthers.
The question is which one?
Happy Panther is good.
Golfing Panther is top rating...
And if its neither of them... fugitabout it.
How does it compare to the Schiit Modi?
How does it compare to chord mojo's 1 and 2?
Is it comparable to the topping dx 3 pro?
Rolling with denafrips for rest o my days, if my ares keeps working that is
Nice with 12v Trigger. Would like to pair this with A Aiyima A70
I wonder if it gets a signal from optical or USB does it Wake and then send a trigger Oh does it Stay asleep. Thanks for a good video
hey i need a amp to power my subwoofers or just to give them the extra kick they can produce i have one amplifier that i get all the main power from then it goes into a small amp and makes my subs sound amazing but it will cut in and out or the music will cut out totally and i have to turn the amp off and back on i think its because of volt drop its a fosi audio TB10D amp it only happens at high volume and it has the 48v 5a power supply so i either need a new power supply if you recommend one or a new amp
amp specifications i would like
cheep
4 channel
around 100watts rms more or less also it is connected to a other amp too
4 ohms
it would power 4 15inch subs 500watt rms 1000watts peak
Love your channel Randy but please stop saying "destroys". It makes all your posts look the same. Annihilates maybe? lol.
No annihilates either....that's been used to death. I know it's about getting attenion but lately it's all been overused. What happened to this channel that it has come to this?
He's notorious for clickbait, he won't change.
what is the DAC that cost 920 that is crushes?
So, you no longer recommend the Topping E50 for under $230???
If the Topping is slightly more laid back, I would choose the Geshelli.
Nipple volume control 😊
Nice ..
A properly designed DAC cannot sound better or worse than any other well designed DAC by definition as any difference perceptible to a human would immediately disqualify it from being "properly designed".
The electrical differences in competently designed DACs are so infinitesimally small you'd have a better chance of noticing a blade of grass under your pillow at night when going to sleep.
God I love your videos
He’s not a deity. That’s just the Cheap Audio Man!
Cheap Audio Deity
That little jaunty tune should be your official unboxing music for all unboxing and/or installation-related tasks. That's a funny little tune.
Mac snob, you may be a cub fan to lol
I don’t know how to respond to this.
@cheapaudioman stay in the neutral zone, my friend, cheap audio, and loves everything
btw, windows > mac
oh no not another DAC review...
How' bout testing of different hearing aid devices ?? - Even though, your channel, most probably, appeals to the younger segment, still - the old farts, don't always buy, only, most expensive stuff.... And what is the good stuff good for - if your hearing ssucks ??!! 😀😀
So easy😅
You have turned into a seller. Good bye
How many under $xxx categories are there? Apple hasn't branded there pc's macintosh in decades. They'r Macs.
thanks so much for that. I'm typing this reply on my Macintosh computer
@@cheapaudioman great mine is from 1990. It doesn't do internet, or color or sound apart from a few beeps :p
@@cheapaudiomanI'm typing mine on my Personal Computer Computer. I traded in my Babbage Difference Engine for it.
@@cheapaudioman I'm typing this on an IBM-compatible computer
@@jimfarrell4635Ha ha ha ha! Good one!
So, you can get a better DAC for 231 dollars?🤔
I use a Topping D50 in my vehicle, because it runs off 5v. I connect my iphone to it via cable, not Bluetooth, through an adapter. Then connect the D50 to the stereo system by 3.5mm cable. It sounds much better this way, rather than via Bluetooth straight to the vehicle stereo system.
I wished more manufacturers would use 5v supplies. It saves utilising an inverter to supply the 240v (UK) supply of most equipment.
I like the smsl d6s a touch more. The midrange is more pleasing but the topping has better highs 🤷 great review CAM. Maybe a side by side in the future?
This is the impression I got after watching many reviews, IIWIreviews describes the Topping d50 iii highs as “radiant” and Rick Ruiz Audio has a sound test that shows this, while the d6s has been described as having better mid-range in comparison, but from many online reviews the d6s is already relatively a leaner sounding DAC tonally, this made it easier for me to choose the d6s because I valued mid-range rather than the highs in this class of DAC’s.
Appreciate this, as I have a D6s and was thinking of switching, but nope.
More Click Bait titles for Crap Equipment
Randy, would you get D50 iii instead of E50?
Are those extra $30 worth spending?
D50 iii or smsl do 100 pro?
@@muenesume7857Yes. Get d50mk3.
I bought a Topping D50 last summer and my experience wasn't good. I really like my SMSL SU-1 but if I was spending more than the Schitt I'd just go with Geshelli J2. If this was priced closer to the Schitt that would give me pause but if my choices are similar performance and one is domestic and one isn't I'll probably go with domestic.
How does the combination of the d50iii with a basic wiim streamer compare against the wiim pro / plus?
I own a WiiM Pro Plus that I'm using both as a streamer and a DAC. How much better would the D50 III sound compared to the DAC inside my WiiM Pro Plus?
@@MLantier would be a great upgrade.
is there coffee in the cup of coffee anymorre... review good.
Join the dark side... get a PC! In all seriousness though, I have never plugged headphones into a DAC before, so I don't know if I want to spend the money on one or not??? Maybe I will order one from a place that will let me return it since I am not sure if I'll be able to tell the difference between using one or not using one.
There are over 2 Billion PCs in the world. How many Macs are there? 40? 50? It's not Topping's fault if they made a product for VHS and you bought betamax.
FTR, I have an M1 MBP13, but I don't expect anything to work on it. I have useful computers for that.
I bought the Eversolo D6 this time last year. It’s an excellent streamer/NAS device for roughly $900 plus some for adding 4GB solid state storage. Feed it FLAC files with a subscription to Tidal to drive a pair of rebuilt Carver Amazing Loudspeakers and I’m in audio heaven!
More destruction! Will thy mayhem never end? This video destroyed my subscription. We had a good run, cheap aufio man. I can't do anymore of your paid infomercials of destruction.
Will this D50 iii do for my home system (emotiva PT1 and A3 with WiiM Pro Plus) as the Dragonfly Cobalt did for my headphone listening?
What about the Soncoz LA-QXD1???
Funny how you’re the only reviewer that I can find that hates the SU-X. If you have a warm sounding system, the SU-X might just be the ticket? Topping D50 III looks nice, but by time you buy a proper Pwr Supply this makes this alternative around the $500 price range. The D50 III is in the SMSL D100 Pro price bracket. Curious which would sound better?
Randy is a joke and contradicts himself all the time!
Noob question...
Would there be a benefit to using the output control on the DAC rather than using the volume control on my stereo amplifier?
Could I leave the DAC on 100% or is a lower number optional?
I have no idea.
Thanks in advance.
I'd suggest using the DAC to control source volume and using the amp volume more as a gain knob; set at amp at the max you would ever listen at then never touch it again. In theory the Dac can lose quality at lower volumes because of they way they sample but if initial sample rate is high enough it shouldn't matter. An amp can also have channel imbalance at lower volumes too( ex. left louder than right), and using the dac for volume will let you keep the amp out of (above) that zone where there might be channel imbalance.
smearing on the bottom is never a good thing...
You had me chuckling with the filters, Randy.
What about how it compares to the schiit modi
How does it compare to Topping E50 ?
Does the peq work with all inputs? I red somewhere it only worked with usb...
I read the same thing. If it worked on all inputs I think this dac would be more popular. PEQ functions is a big deal. But I'm not totally sure if it's USB only.
Wow, no Mac support just killed it for me. Do a mobile app, at least. I do have a WinPC for gaming but it’s not connected to my main system. All these ChiFi companies are great with hardware but the talent needed for software is just never there. FiiO, looking in your direction. 👀
Actually not many audio companies are strong with software. Not sure if chifi ones are the worst... Sure Fiio is a bad (good?) example, but you also have wiim, eversolo and the sort. Having strong software is hard, specially for smaller companies like most of the audio ones, it takes a lot of (constant) investment, that not always corresponds to more sales.
Chinese software was not brilliant even for windows, but due to "quite cold" relationship btw US and China I wouldn't wait for Mac software support in closest future. They are pushed out of US market in many spheres so going for EU/Russian market is logical step. And these regions are mostly "windows based".
1
I have 2 DAC’s, the SMSL C200 and the FIIO K11. I bought the K11 because the USB input on the C200 decided to stop working, and I use that for my phone when streaming. I was very disappointed with the K11, though it is very detailed, it is also very sibilant, grainy and doesn’t seem to have a full sense of scale and doesn’t dig low in the bass region. Very underwhelming DAC. Looking for something that replaces both these DAC’s.
Andy: Stop bickering and let people get a 100 dollar windows pc so they start enjoing the virtues of Windows.
wonder if it gets a signal from optical or USB does it Wake and then send a trigger Oh does it Stay asleep. Thanks for a good video
🚨 Good news: I set this next to my Denafrips and it *did not destroy* anything. Everything still in full working order, phew. Guess I must have been lucky.
You'll be lucky if it has more than $50 worth of parts. Measurements mean nothing, Its how it sounds. Cheap like all the rest of the cheap Dacs.
Gen x here....Was an audio nut back in the day but now want to get into the home theater seen.. What dac do you recommend with hdmi inputs? Are hdmi worth using?
Surely the L and R outputs are individually mono, so you should use a TS connector. TS being mono and TRS being stereo. Or?
Old school Randy, love it! (but digging the new direction too). I guess you can have it both ways
Does anyone know if this DAC would be good to route a dj controller to my computer speakers?
How about a comparison to Geshelli Dayzee, is the 5x ratio worth the extra hrs of OT at work?
The steel drum version of Body Movin' is one of my Beastie faves.
Why compare anything to the SU-X after you've panned it? Cheap move.
I have a Topping E50. Would this be an upgrade?
Thank you
The new SMSL DO200 PRO DAC is out now 😃
I have it. Offer super quality sound
"I'm no mathematician!" HaHa!!
Great DACs until they fail
Macs have a eq built in
Who is paying you?!
Since my Emotiva BasX PT1 Preamplifier has a built in DAC, Analog Devices AD1955, do I need a separate DAC?
I have 2 different Geshelli J2's on an Emotiva TA1. The DAC in the Emotiva is fine. Each of my J2 DAC's (different op amps) sounds better than the Emotiva.
"Heyyyyyyy, youuuuuu, guyyyyssss" - Goonies... :) Cheers bro!! Nice rundown of the topping..
I remember that phrase from the show ‘Electric Company’!
@MarkBrown-gw4wl I remember both sucked, but the Goonies moreso.
Hi. I need a DAC and can't decide . If I get the D50 III, maybe for a better performance I will need the P50 linear supply. At the same price as D50 III and P50, it's the Topping E70 which have ESS Sabre 9028PRO inside and ofcourse the power supply built in. What do you suggest to choose? Thanks! Great videos btw!
you do not need the power supply, use an decent power adapter (apple for example) with an usb c cable. if youre gonna spend $100+ for a power supply might as well save and get a better DAC
Are you going to do a separate review of the A50 III amp? Or is it a less notable / less interesting product release than the D50 III such that it doesn't warrant a separate review?
It’s good. Unfortunately, my audience isn’t nearly as interested in headphone related products than in 2 channel products. When I do those types of videos I just don’t get the views. I enjoy headphone products for sure but I have to be very choosy about the products I cover
Yuck. Another soulless ChiFi box
Thank you Randy!
I'm using Wiim Pro -> Topping E50 -> L50 with DCA Aeon Closed and I can tell you the Wiim pEQ is necessary to tone down the headphones. I'm wondering if its time for a Topping stack upgrade, as I can't keep up with them every time they put out a new DAC/Amp series. These definitely look a bit sleeker than the older ones.
I find as soon as I engage the eq the sounstage shrinks,even with eq set flat.
There are better DACs then Topping xxxx. All depends on your price range and sound preferences. Topping is a nice value production company
Topping is uter crap. Had 3 their devices die on me ... never again.
Really, how old was it when it died and what happened? I was thinking of purchasing 3 of their products also. A dac, headphone amp, and audio interface. What did u have that died also?
Another great video! You're looking much more relaxed after the Italy trip and it's summer.
This DAC doesn't make much sense. It lacks the following inputs that I think are pretty much mandatory: AES/EBU, or I2s (the latter is the best in my opinion). It also does not have XLR outputs; which to me are almost mandatory in a $200+ DAC. I cringe now when I see RCA outs like that -- knowing the type of distortion and yuck that comes with it. With the SMSL d6s in existence, there really is no need to look at this DAC. The only reason to deviate from the SMSL d6s is if you want or need I2s and AES/EBU inputs -- which this DAC you reviewed doesn't have anyway. At that point, move on to the SMSL DO300 or something similar.
I’m using a D70 for my main system. I love it.
@Randy. Very nice and well done video! Nice to see you going back to your roots and reviewing an actually affordable item! While I did have high hopes for this, when you mentioned the Geshelli J2 and the 4493 version and how it still beats it, it does confirm my initial thoughts on DACs as based on many reviews in the past. Not only yours, but others as well. Granted, as you pointed out, the downside is that the Geshelli is only a DAC and I could see having a DAC that could also double as a pre-amp. The D50III could definitely fit that bill, however, what I am waiting for right now, is the release of the Wiim Ultra. I think that unit would cover all bases for me. I am wondering how the DAC in that compares to the Geshelli J2. This brings me to another question in regards to the J2 4499. How does the stock op amp J2 4499 sound in comparison to the J2 4493 with the Sparkos op amps?
Thanks Randy!