Raw milk: Idaho ranchers on why not to pasteurize
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 сер 2024
- Before the advent of pasteurization, all milk was raw milk. There were also a lot more food-related illnesses. Universal pasteurization was introduced in the U.S. around the same time of rapid urbanization as a way to help control bacterial diseases.
One might think this would be the end of the story, but there's a very devoted group of people who believe that pasteurized milk is "dead milk" and are fighting to make it easier to buy the raw stuff (aka "real milk").
In 1987 the FDA banned interstate shipping of raw milk and today its retail sale is only legal in dozen or so states. Raw milk has such a following that people form secret clubs or buy portions of a cow in order to circumvent state laws regulating its sale.
In March of 2010, Idaho made things just a bit easier for producers of raw milk. A small-herd exemption was passed that allowed farmers with 7 or fewer goats or sheep and 3 or fewer cows to produce raw milk or raw milk products for human consumption.
Critics argue that raw milk is linked to diseases and deaths from bacteria like E. Coli. Proponents argue that there are other ways, besides pasteurization, to test milk (The Idaho small-herd exemption requires tests for diseases like Tuberculosis and Brucellosis).
In this video, the folks at Bellevue Idaho's Cottonwood Ranch milk their small herd and explain why they think that pasteurization "spoils the taste" and "changes the contents into stuff that you may or may not be able to use." Or as 30-year-old Eric Barney explains, why "the bought milk" tastes like "cardboard cow".
On *faircompanies: faircompanies.c...
See also the photogallery on our visit to the Cottonwood Ranch: www.flickr.com/...
My dad argues that raw milk is SO deadly, but my step-mom gets botox shots on a regular basis. 🤦🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔😂😂😂😂🤫🤫🤫🤫
ur dad wants the wifey dead asap is the case
A man can argue with a cow but not a wife
Lmao. Boomers amirite?
I drank raw milk yesterday and two days ago and I'm still alive.
This is my dream. To live on such farm, work hard, be in touch with the nature and animals.
Amen
Same, we are 15 minutes from city borders but there are still houses everywhere side by side but are yards are big here in texas. Iv already gotten chickens and im buying Nigerian dwarf buck and a alpine doe in a few weeks on pickup date. Converting a whole manufactured home as a barn for chickens and goats and the kitchen as a milking parlour :) we do have are own home on the same lot and a fair bit of land for them to roam. about 10k-15k square feet and we have a small open pasture right next door and it has its own horse shelter on it that i want to buy. Or just straight up move even further out but this next option would prolly be cheeper xD
I’m an really wanting to have a farm. If not for selling, at least for my family and whomever I can provide for. A farm and garden is a human right.
Same wow
Yes! The country beats the city in every aspect!
I used to get horrible digestive issues after drinking milk and after switching to raw milk from Jersey cows I can drink as much as I want and not even hear a gurggle from my stomach and the taste is heavenly.
Raw milk all the way. Keep that store crap far away.
Pasteurized milk makes my stomach hurt. Been drinking raw milk for about a week now and feel so amazing
Same I’ve been drinking it and only eating raw dairy and i feel and look so much healthier!
If I haven't drank any dairy can I drink raw milk and not get sick or not feel well? I am also gluten free?
@@lindashepherd8328 Yes you can. Raw milk has little to no lactose in it. It's broken down by the lactase.
@ John Wilson,
Many people that are supposedly "lactose intolerant" are actually pasteurization intolerant, as the important enzymes are cooked out of it. I've see a few people myself, (including me) that stopped using pasteurized dairy and actually started using dairy products again when switching to raw dairy, including cheeses, etc...
Refrigeration and improved hygiene has had a greater impact on improved food safety than any individual has, including Pasteur.
People can be allergic to the milk protein casein particularly from pasteurized milk which has it's enzymes cooked out of it.
2:52 the waiting goat outside couldn't wait anymore , got in and jumped up on milking platform. Thank you God.
Right? But people say milking an animal is rape, Im so sick of stupid people!
@@IVIFII2IC maybe they are talking bout conventional dairy farms
I've been drinking raw milk since my childhood, was so tasty, never been sick !
Till I tried pasteurized milk, now I got nausea if I drink some
Keep doing what you do !
The reason you got nauseous after drinking pasteurized milk for the first time was because you weren't used to it. I drank pasteurized milk my whole life; if I drink raw milk, I'd probably get sick.
@@Legolas2 I drank pasteurized in my childhood, and like the other dude when I had my first taste of raw I never was interested in pasteurized again.
@@explosivesexplode The risk isn’t worth the reward. Numerous studies have shown that pasteurized milk and raw milk have similar nutritional value. So what if you lose some nutrients? Get them somewhere else (without the risk of getting a virus)
@@Legolas2 Everything you said is false 👍
@@explosivesexplode What’s false about it?
I love raw milk. I grew up on it like my whole family did. Dad and Mother had a big farm in Nebraska. I'll be 72 in March. I'd go back to living on a farm just to have it every day. But farm life beats city life anyway. Can't take the country out of anyone. 🙏😇💖💞🐮🐴🐑🐣🐥🐔🐞🐄🐏🐎🐐🐖🐕🐈🐩🐾🐾🐰🐱🐶🐰🐿🌰🌲🌳🌷🌹💐🌾🌼🌱🦃🦆🏞🦋🌻💖💞🙏🙏
To me raw milk is the most delicious food on the planet. And one of the most health giving.
The main reason milk in the store has to be pasteurised, sterilised and homogenised is because one bottle of milk can contain milk from more than a 1000 sick animals that live in horrible conditions. Nothing dangerous with raw milk if you can get it from a farm like this.
NO. Raw milk can contain a variety of disease-causing pathogens, as demonstrated by numerous scientific studies. These studies, along with numerous foodborne outbreaks, clearly demonstrate the risk associated with drinking raw milk. Pasteurization effectively kills raw milk pathogens without any significant impact on milk nutritional quality.
@@bowltube That's a myth.Pasteurization effectively kills raw milk pathogens without any significant impact on milk nutritional quality.
@@bowltube You have no idea about what you're talking about. First of all, Milk had no Vitamin C and Probiotics. Fermented milk products have Probiotics that are added after pasteurization. Things like Yogurt.
@@bowltube You still haven't backed up your claim about the vitamin C and milk products
Pasteurization destroys milk's nutritional value. You don't have to listen to studies. Drink a gallon of pasteurized milk one day and a gallon of raw milk the next day. Then you'll have your answer and won't be asking "the experts."
Soon to be raided by an angry SWAT team.
@RJ Angus what you didn't know that they often get raided
Unfortunately yes. I have my own personal goat. Raw or as it was called FRESH milk is the best
Sadly true by the scum of earth govern ments
the animals look so happy getting milked, I love this video, and they get to drink mommas milk, so cool. I buy raw only and boycott all deadly corporate boiled dairy.
when she said she’ll give the milk with the dust on it to the kids I was like “what!?” hahaha she meant the baby goats.
Baby goats are called kids
City folk that haven't been around might not know this. Today's educators probably don't cover it either. Their mostly commies that tow the party line.
Store milk made my stomach knot up and could hardly drink it. Come to find out it’s not the milk but what is done to it!
I hope more of America gets back to this, small farms, tight knit communities, loving families, living free. Support your local, small farms, get to know them and support them. After this last thing the government is imposing on everyone, it should be pretty clear on where to go and what to do. God bless America, the real America.
Yes. You will be really happy sitting in a bread line or starving because the food supply can’t sustain the population.
Yes ♥️
@@charp150 most food shortages are artificially created. Shorten your supply chain to a minimum as in grow your own stuff and you won't be standing "happy" in a food line
man people are low IQ, they stay in cities living homeless, instead of moving to countryside, asking for help from fellow farmers to work on farm and build some financial backing slowly to buy a farm, re-populating the countryside. NO, they prefer to live on streets.
@@charp150 NO if they are on farms, you dont NEED a "bread-lines" as they are on FARMS that grow food - meats, cheese and other energy dense products.
Only if its GRASS FED raw milk..not grain or corn fed.
Exactly. Raw milk is amazing .
You can smell the milk and tell. If it has that grass smell,.. you know it's good.
@James F Dry it out and smoke it ??
Whats wrong with corn
I'll take the word of ranchers and farmers over big corporations any day
I'm an Idahoan, and proud to say I live in a state where I can legally purchase raw milk.
Raw milk is illegal in my state because of "possible health risks"..... but I can go into almost any store and buy cigarettes! Go figure! I just drive the next state over and get it 🐄🐄
the kids in the kitchen is soo cuute. I am very lucky and thankful to be able to purchase raw milk legally here in NYS. A NY health inspector comes by the farm, checks protocol and it's good from there. Raw, fresh milk is a whole other flavor and feeling in the body than store bought milk. It provides vitality.
Especially when clabbered....
I drink raw goat's milk and I trusted the person who sold these because she was a veterinarian so I knew I was in good hands she answered all my questions and that was the best of the best milk I ever had :-)
I started with eggs and raw yogurt Kefir, after 20 years of veganism, because I started to feel many symptoms of vitamin and mineral deficiency..
I did as well , then found a supply of raw cows and goats milk , my health has improved amazingly .
But evidence suggests being plant based is the healthiest lolol….sarcasm alert
Raw milk is king !
Your goats look so happy! Love raw milk.
In ohio i had to buy a heard share to legally purchase raw milk. I drive 40 miles a week to get it round trip have been doing it for a year the quality is so much better and the taste is so rich and delicious. Ive also noticed decreased joint pain as well.
Thanks for sharing Kirsten! Followed your tiny houses for years. Beautiful that u have goats in your family🤍✨
Everything these guys are saying is true. Raw milk tastes so much better than pasteurized, homogenized milk, keeps longer and can actually make cheese. People don't realize that you need unhomogenized milk to make cheese.
What you get with homogenized, pasteurized milk is basically a dead product that you need to drink more of to see a benefit...exactly the product a large dairy company would want a monopoly on.
In order to get raw milk in Texas, I have to drive 40 minutes both ways and pay $8 - $10 a gallon. I don't have the time or money for that. Raw milk is treated like cocaine in even the most free state in the USA...let that sink and then tell me we're living in a free country and explain to me what my grandad fought for in WW2.
Thanks very much for the part about cheese can't be made with homogenized milk, didn't know that. As far as ww2, that's a good question!
I love the taste of it. I grew up with goat and cow raw milk never had any problems at all.
Just bought my first jug of raw milk. Been looking all over the place for it.
Free Sundae
I need to find myself a good spot in my local area, as well.
I've always been kinda interested in doing a small farm; for only myself sometime in the future. And if that's all there is to straining the milk than I don't know why I thought it was such a complicated process in the first place. I though I had to use cheese cloth and stuff. But that's so simple. Raw milk, here I come. Now. Should I do cows or goats? that is the question.
Its actually pretty easy to handling the milk. I would use a cheese cloth, paper towels, unbleached coffee filter or some sort of filter, more than just the reusable coffee filter.....that is a handy holder though & easy to disinfect. The most "difficult" part of the milking process is to get your animal to cooperate, when they get tired of standing there waiting for you to finish....they will let you know. So, whether you get a goat or cow, use a smaller container to milk into & then a bigger one set off to the side to pour into it, otherwise you might have a hoof that either goes into your container that your milking into or they'll kick it out of the way :)
Depending on your experience with livestock (if you've owned any previously or not) & whether or not its just you or you have a family (kids, spouse),will depend on what you should own. Goat's will give up to a gallon a day (depending on the breed) where as a cow (also generally depending on the breed) can give between 3-5 gallons (sometimes more) a day. So, if its just you....I'd go for a goat. But you can also make lots of ice cream, cheese, yogurt, sour cream, cottage cheese, etc. with the excess or if you have other animals...feed it to them :)
@nicenicenicole
You clearly know nothing about pasteurisation. Let us start your education. The test for successful pasteurisation is the negative phosphatase test. This tests for the complete destruction of the enzyme phosphatase. This alkalysing enzyme is needed for the absorption of Calcium. Here endeth the lesson!
Wow, what amazing and authentic people.
People do NOT need to drink milk. But if you're going to drink milk, raw is the best because it's real food.
+Marta Bergen I do best including milk products in my diet,…. by far.
I've got extensive personal experience. And, the better raised the animals, quality feed, healthy animals,…. the better
+Bond Summers I agree; I'm just saying that not everyone thrives on it or needs it in their diet.
Marta Bergen I respect that.
Well they certainly need it more than they need plants.
Free cheap calories. Can't go wrong with that.
I've often wondered if those people diagnosed as being lactose intolerant are really intolerant to the lactose or if they're intolerant to what processing does to the milk. I wonder how many of these people have tried raw milk. It would be interesting to find this out.
I have since this video gotten my small herd exemption. My milk gets tested by the same inspector that does the big dairies. My E-coli counts have been
Those are some happy goats
I'm drinking mine raw right now.
Started on raw milk and I feel better then I ever have. More energy then I've ever had
Fermented milk is even better.
My parents are Mexicans from Guadalajara a farming community they grow up drinking raw goat milk and cow milk I was born in los Angeles c. a. But every summer my pops took me to learn and I started to drink raw milk till this day I have never had any problem with my stomach it's good better than than the dairy milk they put all kinds of chemicals to pasteurize it some time it starts turning green instead of white I think like this people milk was meant to be drank straight from the udder specially in early mornings natural goodness keep up the good work guys love that style nature provides
Aajonus Vonderplanitz would be proud.
damn nice to see you here. thx for all the AV uploads :-)
i have really strongly disliked milk ever since i can remember. the idea of drinking a glass of milk sounds ludicrous and NAUSEATING to me. i’m starting to think if i tried raw milk i would be singing a different tune🤔
You would. I was the same way my entire life. I would vomit drinking store milk. Then made friends with a kid from my small town in Indiana whose family had a dairy farm.
He started hooking me up with raw milk as an adult when my first child was deathly ill from vaccines, sick all the time, always at the er. So the first time I picked up some raw milk, with the cream still in it, shook it up, tried a taste....omg so good so sweet didn't even need chocolate or anything. My daughter stopped needing inhalers. Stopped being sick all the time. We were drinking like 3 gallons of milk a day every day. So good. Then moved back to texas. I think about raw milk all the time
I love raw milk❤️
My cat loves flying birds😻
These people are amazing. Independent, intuitive, and maybe most of all, Bold....
Thankfully in Massachusetts we can buy it from a great farm, Pine Hill Dairy in Westport. It's excellent.
Until very recently in human history, very few adults could even digest milk. Milk was processed by different kinds of microbes to make it digestible, and to keep you from getting sick if it became contaminated. Unpasteurized milk is a problem when milk must be transported and packaged for use in urban areas, far from the farm.
Pasteurization is essentially cooking the milk. I have seen nothing that convinces me that pasteurization makes the milk of a cow less nutritious to a human.
I also see nothing that says milk harvested in sanitary conditions, and properly handled, is in any way more dangerous than raw meat (for example). I have milked enough cows over the years (by hand and by machine), and drank enough milk (pasteurized and not) to think that either way is fine.
So I can understand the need to have controls on milk based on methods of distribution (dozens of farmers selling to multiple processors, with thousands of customers). I also think that milk being sold by the farmer, directly to the consumer, is of such low risk that it should be allowed with little interference.
From my point of view there is no need for any further justification than "that is the way I like it".
Al Lipscomb There's plenty of research showing how pasteurization destroys the enzymes and vitamins in milk; and how it negatively affects absorption and utilization of calcium to the detriment of bones and teeth, and how it affects cholesterol, if you look for it. Check out a book entitled "Enzyme Nutrition; the research of Royal Lee; Pottingers Cats. And go from there.
There is so much data out there saying how pasteurization corrupts the protein profiles and kills all the good bacteria in the milk. Raw milk also contains lactase which is an enzyme needed to break down lactose. You really need to open your mind and understand that the FDA is NOT your friend. Baby Boomers have been played for fools for decades. Circumcision, pasteurized milk, anti-depressants, birth control, ALL CORRUPTIONS AND POISONS.
Without centuries of raw dairy, northern Europeans would never have survived all those winters.
I always wash the udder with pretty warm soapy water. I rub Emu oil on the teats to relax the goat's udder. Make goat cheese and butter. Love it!
i make kefir with the raw milk i buy, this is so good
Lordy miss fresh milk. We lived on dairy farms growing up. Then when we had to move to the city and tasted store milk it literally made me sick. Stopped drinking milk.
i used to drink raw milk when a kid and never got sick, until it was unavailable and could only get commercial and then problems started, so now only goat milk sometimes.
Pasteurized milk is not a complete product. Raw milk is.
Quite right. Here in Dorset, UK, the last farm selling raw milk has just stopped, government regulations they said. Now I have to mail order, buy too much and freeze it...
The animals are sweet. They actually want to go up there.
Raw Milk is a super food.
African Americans usually have an aversion to milks, dairy products (store); I wonder (& am scared) to try raw products like this; curious though. They scared the tarnation out of us with so many things 😔😔 so sad. But country life is beautiful looking (the urban and modern African Americans don't have this in our radar at all .. (((sigh)))). TY so very much for sharing this beautiful video. 💐☺️🌻
First time I drank raw milk I shat my guts out. Second time was good as gold ✨️
Watching this 11 years later love it! I strive for the same here natural as possible. And nice herd good lookin nubians.
Support local farms
Colostrum is the super food or all super foods, right ?
I live in Charlotte N.C. I want to find out where I can buy sheep milk. Please message me if you know where I can buy from.
This made me smile 🙏🏻😁
I started drinking raw milk about a month ago….I am 70 ! LOL! Love it !
Just remember to keep it cool after milking, 1 week expiry max
Raw milk doesn't spoil, it merely changes form, depending on the temperature.
Old processed milk is harmful.
@@jessicali8594 Raw milk, like all natural food, will eventually go bad.
@@hiqwerty7747 Not as quickly as processed milk does, which was the obvious point. It won't be dangerous either, like old processed milk is. Raw milk left out long after it's soured, but is still nutritious, q.v. Eastern European dairy products with no English names, becomes off putting, not dangerous. Traditionally it was left out with stale bread as a charity in some areas.
@@jessicali8594
True and it's also how raw cheeses can be made! Definitely not harmfull, Unlike poisonous store chalk water "milk"
@@jessicali8594 It will spoil , mine lasts about 10 days at 2 deg celsius .
I grew up on store bought milk. I've had raw. I can't drink pasteurized milk it makes me start wheezing. Raw does not. I'll never drink pasteurized again
That's the way God planned it. I love raw milk. Reminds me of the rich, creamy milk I drank as a young lad.
Yeah. Our ancestors werent living on pasteurized milk for thousands of years. They were living on raw milk and raw honey. If it was that bad for us, the human race wouldve died out many, many years ago
I never used to have any problems with diary, now I cannot consume it without "lacteez" tablets. Thank you for this video.
beautiful family!
Beautiful!! Thank you.
I live in Ga, it’s illegal to sell raw milk. It’s a stupid law. I’m grown, if I want to take the risk, I should be able too.
That's so sweet. I love goat milk and especially goat cheese.
He looks like Odin!
Had to by my own goat here in Montana because I can’t buy raw milk here.
Goats need friends. One goat is torture for them
When you drink it soon after milking then it's fine but when you try and sell it and it sits for a while is when It develops the bacteria that can cause tuberculosis and hay fever....
it can sit for more than a week refrigirated.
and i know people who are leaving it to spoil on purpose so they can drink sort of a raw milk yogurt.
not 100% sure but i think they would heat the raw milk if they want to make yogurt with it.
@@spatrk6634 too bad the people in the times before pasteurization didn't know the people you know so that they wouldn't have gotten terribly sick and or died
@@luismartinez1056 pretty sure people realised pretty quickly that old raw milk gets you sick.
thats where cheese and butter comes from. they tried every way to somehow save the milk during winter
@@spatrk6634 i make my yoghurt with raw milk , just warm it to blood heat . If i heated it to pasyeurize it what would be the point of me buying the milk raw .
I love raw milk!!! Goat and cow Would love to try some of yours Too bad don't l live in Idaho
I had to buy my own goat but I needed it.
I love raw milk
Do you see how happy that goat that jumped up to get milked next looked?
I have a question in regard to cooking with raw milk-Does cooking with raw dairy products such as milk, cream, cheese, yoghurt, butter, etc. negate the health value of those dairy products in their raw form? I wanted to start using raw dairy in baking and cooking recipes, but I am confused as to whether the raw dairy getting cooked in the oven or on the stove would mean that it is no longer considered raw & beneficial to our health. In other words, by cooking with raw dairy are we effectively pasteurizing it? Does anyone have advice for this?
Cooked milk is not beneficial
God bless you all, this is what life is supposed to be
This was interesting. Thanks for posting.
Hello Kirsten!
I am making a video documentary of my own regarding Raw Milk and its benefits to humans. I am searching for audio bites from farmers speaking about Raw Milk and their opinions on it as a product and nourishment vs Pasteurized milk. Would you allow me to use a clip of your video, with your channel and video tagged within my video and description as credit? It would help me greatly in spreading the good and ancient truth about Raw Milk! If you have any questions about the use of any respective clips feel free to reach back out.
Thank you in advance for any consideration, I look forward to hearing back from you!
Patrick Altzner
My dads 84 years old. When he was a young boy him and his brothers used to suckle from the udder or the bucket. The farmer that owned the dairy allowed them to drink as much as they wanted before their work day started.
My dad was strong as a bull.
When did we start pasturizing and why?
as she mentions in the video, a city distribution system where all the milk from 1000 or more cows in unsafe filthy conditions gets mixed together then bottled for sale can be quite problematic left raw, long transport times, rogue bacteria and the history of tainted milk being covered up with borax and other toxic alkalis, spreading bovine tuberculosis which killed countless people in the past. getting fresh milk from a single healthy cow in the countryside is a different situation entirely
Hi, just wondering i did not see you in the video washing your hands washing the goats, etc, and it is ok you drink it without a problem?
ha ha you're obviously one of those Starbucks hipsters. Having worked at an actual retail milk farm I can also tell you that your didn't see puss and blood from a cows udder that's been injured from overuse. You literally have no idea what's in milk from the store, and trust, me you don't want to.
Good video. Hard fighting the milk industry. Would like to see more ppl like u doing this.👍 Same w honey, olive oil, syrup & a number of other so called "natural" products.
I SO AGREE ! I can not drink cows milk so I drink lots of goats milk ! I love it !
The explanation on why they did not get sick it could be that you just developed an immunity on whatever organism is in that milk. Just a theory
>bad stuff being put into milk
What? What do they add to milk besides vitamins. I understand it might lose it's nutritional value due to pasturization but to say they put bad stuff into it seems a bit insane.
Preservatives, artificial nutrients, chemical thickeners in some circumstances, and mainly what they put into the cow
I definitely trust Gandalf over the government.
Where buy raw milk
I wish most people lived like this
If I haven't been consuming anything dairy can I start drinking raw milk? I had to go gluten free it caused me so many digestive problems. I don't know if I can legally buy raw milk in Michigan.
amazing. thanks for sharing
raw milk is comparable to even raw fruit. both foods are designed by nature to be eaten intentionally. do not fear raw milk.
Nice honest farmers that are just providing good karma heathy milk but “THEY” wanna make it illegal and prolly shut their shit down like they were making meth
Thanks
these people are ahead of their time :D
Ooh baby i like it raw. Ooh baby I like it RAAAAAAAAW
ONE QUESTION: I buy raw goat milk for my 12 month old . And my dad took a gallon with him and he says he found several dust looking at the bottom of it and had to use a colander. Now he is worried that it may be poop or just dirt but could cause great illness to my baby. Of course now I am very worried.
Dont be worried , i have found some sometimes , i just strain it out using cheese cloth when i get home , lasts one week in the fridge , but with the temp at 2 to 4 degrees celsius . You will know when raw milk should not be drunk , its smells and tastes off . I have drunken it in that state with no ill effects .
Raw milk and raw milk products is by far best for me compared to pasteurized or homogenized. Best body integrity / best health with raw milk, compared to pasteurized or homogenized. Although cook meat, with rare exception,… same with eggs.