Is it Okay for Christians to Be a Sperm or Egg Donor? | Hard Questions

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 45

  • @lakeside4485
    @lakeside4485 5 років тому +34

    I am a devoted Christian and tend to be conservative in how I feel about most issues, especially social issues. I am taking some issue with the fact that this panel consists of all men... They may be pastors, but they are also men who have no idea what it’s like to be told you have no option to have a child outside of using modern technology.

    • @jenniferhughes2155
      @jenniferhughes2155 5 років тому +2

      Hi there, I'm catholic, TTC for over 5 years and I do agree, this wasn't a great debate. Have you heard of NaPro Technology? Doctors these days are very quick to recommend IVF to every couple struggling to conceive but many times they are just not looking deeply enough into the possible problems and trying to address them. As for my own journey, I've tried lots of things naturally but have just found out that my husband has poor sperm dna fragmentation. We are hoping to try IUI and while I wouldn't do IVF for many reasons, I have become aware of natural cycle IVF which looks interesting though I am not 100% sure about it. I wish you every success in your journey. God bless.

    • @lapris7380
      @lapris7380 2 роки тому +1

      Yeah I agree! I would have like to see some women speak on it as well but I understand why it’s like this

    • @sissyrayself7508
      @sissyrayself7508 Місяць тому

      Men can have fertility issues as well.

  • @toplembo
    @toplembo 3 роки тому +11

    So much personal opinion very few reference to the bible and the question was not answered.

  • @linin3288
    @linin3288 7 місяців тому +2

    It is a form of consensual adultery and even if adultery is consensual it is still bad and it is also a generator of endless fatherless children.

  • @art79red
    @art79red 6 років тому +9

    it’s never Ethical when monies involved

  • @drock5108
    @drock5108 5 років тому +5

    I was raised in a Catholic family but switched to Christian when I got older and heard about all the stuff priest was or are doing to lol kids but now I see the things Christians are willing to overlook in order to please themselves and it opened my eyes to just believing there is a God and he don't need to be any specific religion. Most religions make no sense. Believing in God should be spiritual. That's good enough for me. Most Christians preach love but practice the opposite. Catholics let there priest get away with unholy acts against humanity. I don't need any religion to tell me how I should live. Do other living creatures have religions? Would aliens have religion? I don't think so.

    • @hmt-0764
      @hmt-0764 4 роки тому +8

      *There is only One God and that is the God of the Bible.*
      *Being a Christian is not a religion it's a relationship* *with God our Father through his son Jesus Christ*

    • @yelloe
      @yelloe 3 роки тому +1

      I dont approve of Catholicism and youre right that the Catholic church is taking advantage of the naive and innocent. God does not approve of that and there will come a time and it also has happened centuries ago and will happen again that the Catholic church will fall and the worse punishments will come to the false preachers
      Im a Christian. And the comment above me is right. Christianity is walking with Jesus and following Jesus teachings and lifestyle. Jesus is a reiteous man and were suppose to accept him in our hearts and have faith in him because through him we will be born again and save us.

  • @hollymenager2927
    @hollymenager2927 5 років тому +6

    You can inseminate at home. They have cryobanks. It does not have to be done by invetro. That is only one method.

  • @andrebolt3323
    @andrebolt3323 3 роки тому +21

    i think sperm donation is a sin in itself

    • @LuxuriousLenay
      @LuxuriousLenay 3 роки тому +13

      THANK YOU. FINALLY SOMEONE ELSE WHO AGREES WITH WHAT IM THINKING. BECAUSE YOURE LITERALLY GETTING OTHER WOMEN WHO YOU DONT KNOW PREGNANT THEN BEFORE YOU KNOW IT YOU HAVE ALMOST 30 DIFFERENT BABY MAMAS AND omg. Its disgusting in my opinion, i cant even
      ALSO this is coming from someone who is an Atheist

    • @jordanfgfox7237
      @jordanfgfox7237 2 роки тому

      @@LuxuriousLenay true but with the father and the mother wants child but they can't have a child and they want to go to the sperm bank and do it so is it basically , conception because the, husband and wife allowed it

    • @LuxuriousLenay
      @LuxuriousLenay 2 роки тому

      @@jordanfgfox7237 this was 7 months ago ✌

    • @BloodyBricks
      @BloodyBricks Місяць тому

      I would only donate soerm if it was for a couple who couldn’t have children and they really wanted some but I’m not blindly jerking of into a cup for some random lady

  • @Levitelindo
    @Levitelindo Рік тому +2

    I was hoping the Men of God would reference the Word of God first then then go with I see no problem with that, as Christians it is important that we take the Word of God seriously and use it when it is good and when it is also painful.......Whether i agree with the Word of God but it remains True.....I am still uncertain as to if this is a sin or not according to this talk.I read someone say if this is done by 2 married couple giving consent to each other to help the other couple to have a kid if they cant have ,multiplication according to God is through marriage obviously many of us were born outside of marriage and God forgave our parents....so I am not answered we need another session where they broaden the topic with other guests

  • @SilasAram
    @SilasAram Рік тому +1

    Yea, sperm donor for money is a sin. I believe. Unless you are actually helping someone, but you would have to know who the couple is. If you dont know who the couple is, you can pray to God to reserve your sperm for a special couple, as long as theyre not gay/pagan.

  • @Alpha-Ultra
    @Alpha-Ultra 5 років тому +4

    I think if I was single I'd be dropping loads in to cups I'm helping myself and people with joy I realize they my kids wouldn't grow up with me so long as I'm feeling not prideful but furfilled that I would be helping familes

  • @hollymenager2927
    @hollymenager2927 5 років тому +6

    Also, you can adopt embryos. I think that is pretty awesome! 😊

  • @torix316
    @torix316 5 років тому +13

    Adopt!!

    • @aharrison3022
      @aharrison3022 4 роки тому +8

      Not always that simple

    • @WolverineDevotee
      @WolverineDevotee 3 роки тому +6

      Nope, if my parents did that then I wouldn’t be here.

    • @doctordarcy8385
      @doctordarcy8385 3 роки тому +4

      Unless you are infertile, you really have no business telling a couple what they should, or should not do, on their journey to parenthood. Adoption should not be a "second choice," or a "backup option" relegated to infertile people. Adoption is not their responsibility. It is a unique pathway to parenthood in its own right, that should be a first choice option. To say otherwise, contributes to the very real trauma of adoptees.

  • @KellysGarden
    @KellysGarden 4 роки тому +15

    You men are clearly experts 🙄

    • @Chloe-nw4vj
      @Chloe-nw4vj 4 роки тому +6

      You can have an opinion on something you aren’t an expert in..

    • @SajiSimonOfficial
      @SajiSimonOfficial 2 роки тому +3

      They are pastors

  • @davidsoto4394
    @davidsoto4394 2 роки тому +1

    Excellent video.

  • @merrillbartle4174
    @merrillbartle4174 3 місяці тому

    God ordains that all that happens comes to pass. So if a baby is born of introversion, thank God will control that babies life scripture says he controls everything.✝️

    • @Jenmac-ks9ij
      @Jenmac-ks9ij 2 місяці тому

      Not true. God gave the responsibility to men to procreate and have children, how men go about it is based on their free will. it doesn’t mean this method is God’s way. The scripture says non shall be barren and the fruit of the womb is blessed. The world is changed so many toxins in our food, products that people wear that is disrupting the natural reproductive system this is why there are these problems. Having said that, nothing is impossible with God. He appeared to Zechariah and Elizabeth in their old age and promised them a child.

  • @julianmontoya428
    @julianmontoya428 Рік тому +1

    The bible from God is truth from God! The panel should understand how to answer questions, but the truth is God has holy commandments through the holy prophet Moses! The torah and tanakh was given to the Jewish ✡️ and they have been in the heart of God! Yet those who add or takeaway from the truth from God. The curse from God will fall upon them...

  • @someonelucky9342
    @someonelucky9342 5 років тому +7

    "Before you were born I knew you."...
    ...soooo that means you knew my parents too.
    And if my mother donated her egg and my father's sperm fertilized it to created me, no matter how that egg and sperm met, it still made me. So if selling that egg put some money in the pockets of my biological mother, what's it to you?

  • @lizc3273
    @lizc3273 3 роки тому +1

    Good point

  • @babydii3487
    @babydii3487 7 місяців тому

    💯💯💯🙏🏽