@@goatvxx artists that are good looking but don't sound good at all also don't excel, yeah visuals help you out a bit but you also gotta have the talent.
if you know about vocal...you can really hear so much diffrent in live stage and acappella.... in acappella her singing with real/larynx voice...but in live stage she just want a comfort zone,that why she just singing with nassal skill
What do mys have to do with this. Not the nswers trying to pull aespa down with just a vocal skill. While in reality their fav have never been close to aespa’s place 😊
because there was a loud backtrack, there is another performance (ths one that got viral) where the backtrack wasn't that loud idk why the channel didn't use that
*LILY* They have such a powerful, perfect and stable vocal, without a doubt for me it is one of the best VOCALS of the 4th generation ❤️ thank you for sharing this wonder 😉
they're all so beautiful ngl and while they sound similar i heard some diff details in each version. that's why i liked acapella the most, it shows how well she uses her voice even live (without dancing). and it gives her more freedom too.
Even Twice themselves asked the question “Is Sana gay?” in Heartshaker Sana we need an answer🧐 [ALSO THIS IS ALL FOR JOKES, ITS MISHEARD LYRICS AND IM NOT FORCING ANYTHING ON ANYBODY, AND BTW IM GAY, SO NO HOMOPHOBIC REPLIES please and thank youuuuuuuu] 😂😂😂😂
@@angelaoh4023 The thing is that some blinks call Rose "The best vocalist in Kpop" even though she isn't. Yes, she has a nice voice but it's nothing compared to Lily's and other kpop idols voices.
![[Eng Sub] Asking Haewon and Lily from NMIXX on the possibility of winning the AFC Asian cup 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kTVdx13hZKk/mqdefault.jpg)
Song Tank by Nmixx
dfxc
I know
@@maidarabdulrahman3514 but some people don't.
@@maidarabdulrahman3514 the video isn't just for u hun
lily is so powerfull vocalist
yess
Best in fourth gen
@@maliablossom7340 Indeed!
And haewon my bias is 2nd in 4th gen
Yes
Props to u for not writing “autotune vs. No autotune”!!
ikr !! one of my biggest pet peeves in kpop shorts
@@dannylions same like pro mixers manual tune not auto tune it’s a pet peeve to me when terms are missed used
Lily don't need autotune
its lit the exact same every time 💀
Studio is calming
Live is elegant
Acapella is powerful
Song name please
@@TheQueen-hx4zr Tank by NMIXX
@@Tsireya.Metkayina Oh thank you
The best vocal group of 4th generation
Is Stayc 💋
@@foocas lily & haewon outsing all of aespa but try again! 💋‼️
@@foocasbestie Haewon and Lily r better than Ningning Winter Giselle and Karina try again
@@jisooso6149 Stayc? More like StainC
@@jisooso6149 nmixx vocal >>> stay vocal
Future soloist for sure. Her voice is incredible!
ua-cam.com/users/shorts37VjSbUwhj8?feature=share
@@ryustea soloists have friends yk😭
She won’t excel in that because she lacks visuals
@@goatvxx artists that are good looking but don't sound good at all also don't excel, yeah visuals help you out a bit but you also gotta have the talent.
@@taes_esophagus5106 obviously, to become a soloist u have to be good in visuals in vocals dancing stage presence all that stuff
Not me enjoying lily's "is Sana gay" every three time
YES!!!!
Me too
It's sa ma ge💀
Someone tell us IS SANA GAY
😂😂😂😂
"Is SaNa GaYyY?"
Sana already answer the question bro
Even the 4th generation is asking 💀
YES SANA JUST ANSWER
I hope in next comeback she replies it 😉
Meanwhile Sana in like a fool: I'm so gay
What did she said 😂
Fr everyone is so curious 🤨 We need this mystery solved Sana 😭✋
her voice is like a siren. i think it's time i fully check out nmixx, but to be honest kyujin was already pulling me in 😂
she is so talented❤
ua-cam.com/users/shorts37VjSbUwhj8?feature=share
I will never be able to unhear "is sana gAeEeEe?" 💀
that's why the face "💀"
@@denisty1 Idk💀
ua-cam.com/users/shorts37VjSbUwhj8?feature=share
I hear sama Idk what you hear
이 사막에
if you know about vocal...you can really hear so much diffrent in live stage and acappella....
in acappella her singing with real/larynx voice...but in live stage she just want a comfort zone,that why she just singing with nassal skill
It's head voice
She doesn't even sing on a nasal voice u don't even know what ur talking Abt
It’s her head, not her nose💀
Best vocalist of the 4th generation, and no crying mys
What do mys have to do with this. Not the nswers trying to pull aespa down with just a vocal skill. While in reality their fav have never been close to aespa’s place 😊
@@shannonp1440 but aren’t u bringing down them too..
@@cqiome look, who started.
@@shannonp1440 hoes mad
@@johnnycadeswife5229 so sorry for ur mom.
Acapella gave me chills ngl
same fr
In the live the vocal was the same as the studio. The last 'ge' was exactly the same. Still applause to Lily for singing it so beautifully
because there was a loud backtrack, there is another performance (ths one that got viral) where the backtrack wasn't that loud idk why the channel didn't use that
@@stanbtsforaclearskinLily can sing like the studio version her vocal is perfect. Don't jealous her plz
@@marocsahlesbest1887 what ??
@@marocsahlesbest1887 Jealous of what? lmao I never denied that she can sing, I even mentioned another clip which is better to showcase her vocals lol
Her voice without autotune is like you are hearing choirs from the heaven😭💜🙌!!!!!!!!
JYPe it's a good company, they let Lily show her vocal skills, knowing how good she is.
Perfect singer❤
Omg, this group. Nmixx Lily 4th gen vocal powerhouse. She's amazing. Natural born talent.
The choreography of "mirrior "part is so satisfying 😭❤️❤️ i love the hand flowing❤️❤️
Its actually mirrage and i cant believe its not mirror 😂
ずっと聴いていたい
Neeeee
엔믹스는 라이브가 진국이야 ❤
Marvelous vocals in kpop
The acapella version was my most played video of 2022😭
Amazing taste
Lily's vocals are no joke
I will never get over nmixx hope they make music till the day im around on earth
The first group I've ever followed pre debut and check for new videos everyday. Just finished haewon's Workman episodes
"eEeS sAnA gAaAAAaaY?!" -Lily
It isn't sana but okay🤷🏾♂️
@@Nikacado_ricardoit’s a joke
@@froggyhat354 what joke tbh
@@Nikacado_ricardo Can you just take the joke
@@kitnopsia no can you just shut up
Whenever I hear this part, I suddenly get goosebumps
*LILY* They have such a powerful, perfect and stable vocal, without a doubt for me it is one of the best VOCALS of the 4th generation ❤️ thank you for sharing this wonder 😉
У Энмикс лучший вокал, и вы готовы к этому разговору
i love how she’s so confident in her vocals like yes girl show off
“Is SaNa gAy”✨✨✨ I cant breathe it’s so funny😂😂😂
Sa ma ge там поется
Lily is the best singer of the 4th generation
love her. so good and so adorable
No because I rewatched this so many times now her voice is so majestic I'm in love 🥰🥰❤️
so are we not gonna talk abt how freaking beautiful she is bro bc 😭
That's how Sirens sound like👄
Me encanta su voz🥺😍😍💜✨ es muy hermoso ✨
So proud of my girl💞
its so hard to sing these vocals so singing it effortlessly is just MAGICAL
يا حلاوة الصوت 🎤😭🗣️🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤⚡⚡⚡⚡
It makes sense cuz she is a B or B+ vocalist!My Aussie Lily slayedd!!❤
When the raw vocals sound better than studio. Her vocals are on another level
YOUUU GET CPR A LOOOT
HELP I HEAR THAT TOO-
Her vocals are no joke 😭❤🖐🏻✨
she slay her vocals everytime
The best vocalist in 4th generation
they're all so beautiful ngl and while they sound similar i heard some diff details in each version. that's why i liked acapella the most, it shows how well she uses her voice even live (without dancing). and it gives her more freedom too.
She is literally the queen of 4th generation vocals💅🏼👑
Lily's vocals are too beautiful...) ❤️
Mano eu nunca tinha escutado falar dela, mas ela canta muitoooooooooooo!! Estou de queixo caído real.... (n sou fã de idol feminina normalmente)
Lily's vocals are scarily good and I'm always enchanted by her range and ability
"IsssSS SaaaAnnnNaaaaa GaaaaaAYyyy" will be forever iconic 🙃🙃
Best voice🥹♥️
Su voz es de un ángel la amo
Her voice is music alone what if you add to it music it will be a Bomb😌🎶🔥🔥🔥
POV: you can't not sing Lily's part... But you can do the " iS sANA gAYy"😭
Lily is truly amazing❤
I cant believe jinni left tho😭
EDIT:OMG IM FAMOUS MOM
Second edit:OMG TYSM FOR ALL THESE LIKESSSSS
Me too
fr
me too
Just Lily being one of the best 4th gen vocalists
what I hear:
You get cpr online. Come co oh co mirage. Peed the wind ✨iS sAnA gAeEeEe✨
Sa ma not sana but okay🤷🏾♂️
@@Nikacado_ricardoit's a joke that K-pop Stan's made it started with twice this song heart shaker
I love her
My flex is that I can sing it, but unfortunately not as beautiful as Lily. Lily's my bias anyway
Damn Mbn 😭
Acapella😩💞
All i can focus on is " iS SaNa GAy"
She’s like siren honestly, so captivating
I love Lily' s vocal
I DID NOT KNOW SHE WAS THIS GOOD
perfect voice 😍
The people who are saying "Is sana gay" its cringe like bffr, and the people in the comments are so cringe likeeeee
The last line sounds like that and it’s sounded funny?
@@ivebptwicetheholetrinity3466 no😿
It doesn't even sound sana😭
Clearly sama
@@hehe-fl6vm EXACTLY
She's the best singer of her generation. For real ❤❤❤
GOAT
Even Twice themselves asked the question “Is Sana gay?” in Heartshaker
Sana we need an answer🧐
[ALSO THIS IS ALL FOR JOKES, ITS MISHEARD LYRICS AND IM NOT FORCING ANYTHING ON ANYBODY, AND BTW IM GAY, SO NO HOMOPHOBIC REPLIES please and thank youuuuuuuu] 😂😂😂😂
Nobody said something...
Why you apologizing 🧐
@@bessiegaming8995before ppl start getting bc offended
Her voice in acapella buttur of All in my opinion Because it allows her emotions to show more It shows how pure her voice is
Lily: Is SaNa GaY????
VS
Nayeon: iS sAnA gAy??? (in heart shaker)
Sana: oof 🥴🥴🥴
lily’s voice literally never disappoints
her voice is FIRE
Guys it's not sana it's Sama
Yes
my favorite parts❤️
yall are really stretching this "is sana gay" thing 😭 like you could make it out but it definitely doesn't sound like it lmao
I’ve been wanting to say this 💀
Lily is the definition of siren
😮 I love you Lily 💖❤️♥️💎🌹🎆😍
See blinks no hate but rose vocals arent golden, they not underrated. Lilly's are she has golden and underrated vocals
Why do u have 2 drag blackpink and blinks in
@@angelaoh4023 The thing is that some blinks call Rose "The best vocalist in Kpop" even though she isn't. Yes, she has a nice voice but it's nothing compared to Lily's and other kpop idols voices.
Agree
@@ezclipsie I love your username 😩💗
@@itzzjustkt Thx🤣🤣
Es brillante esta mina, la amo
II iS sAnA a gAy II
No she is not
Love her voice 💗
Best vocalist
😇“you get cpr a lot”😇
that hit hard lily👊🏽😔
''iiissss sannaaa gAYyy??''👁️👄👁️
"iS SanA GaaaEyyy" is always iconic🗿🙏🏻
Lily dont need autotune. Autotune needs her ❤ such a powerful vocalist
This is true star quality!!!
THE ACCAPELA:😍😍😍🔥🔥🔥
sounds exactly the same in all three, woah!
Acapella looks majestic lilys voice are so fine and relaxing❤
It’s just wow❤perfect
Her voice is just 😍😍
My vocal queen lily 👑👑this is why she is my bias ❤️❤️❤️
Her voice is like an angel
Lillys vocals slay. She is the best female 4th gen vocalist
Y’all I got goosebump’s on the acapella version, she slayed