Aarushi case: Talwars - Villains or Victims?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 вер 2024
  • The Buck Stops Here: As the court finds Rajesh and Nupur Talwar guilty of murdering their daughter Aarushi and domestic help Hemraj, we debate on The Buck Stops Here: has justice been served in the mystery murder of the teenager?
    Watch full video: www.ndtv.com/vi...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 235

  • @ehteramsiddiqui8849
    @ehteramsiddiqui8849 5 років тому +180

    I think the primary investigation team of police, shall be punished for their careless and unprofessional approach!

    • @VKlifeenjoy
      @VKlifeenjoy 4 роки тому +2

      Yes

    • @sujeetkakade6053
      @sujeetkakade6053 4 роки тому +10

      Up police seems to be illiterate and careless in many crime cases...they just want to finish any case no matter justice done or not...Recent Pradyumn a 2nd std student case is also one of example of their careless n ruthless approach towards crime case...I think firstly they should punished for not preserving evidence from crime scene in aarushi murder case then the further inquiry could be done

    • @parikabansal3006
      @parikabansal3006 3 роки тому +9

      I think police knows the truth but they r kept silent through bribe.thats india😏

    • @ILM06
      @ILM06 2 роки тому +1

      You are right 👍

  • @vishnukumarkr3499
    @vishnukumarkr3499 2 роки тому +38

    What happened on that fateful night will always be a mystery. Only aarushi and hemraj know what happened and how they were killed.

    • @chapms5053
      @chapms5053 2 роки тому +12

      No.. You are wrong. There were two more people who knew it and they were Talwar's.

    • @sln7839
      @sln7839 2 роки тому +1

      @ChaP M S absolutely

    • @abhishekmp1775
      @abhishekmp1775 Рік тому

      One day it will be proved

    • @Sarahh_28
      @Sarahh_28 Рік тому +1

      @@abhishekmp1775 yes maybe with the advancement of the technology the evidences today will be useful tomorrow. I have seen cold unsolved murder mysteries were solved even after 50 years later

    • @sunshineglow9446
      @sunshineglow9446 Рік тому

      And the killer knows what he/she did

  • @jessejoseph1310
    @jessejoseph1310 5 років тому +54

    I have only one question why did the parents not call police in the first instance instead allowed everyone in the lane into the house

    • @mycreation5314
      @mycreation5314 4 роки тому +8

      yeah and i have only one question too
      that is it possible that two people were murderd in there house and they were sleeping ??????

    • @Sarahh_28
      @Sarahh_28 3 роки тому +5

      It's so shocking to see someone murdered so brutally and it was their own child how do you expect them to be mindful that time?

    • @hojaykajalwa2.036
      @hojaykajalwa2.036 2 роки тому +1

      @@poulo121 the cut off neck was clearly visible .

    • @sadaf2301
      @sadaf2301 2 роки тому +9

      Any parents first reaction on seeing their child injured is to call ambulance or go to hospital asap but talwars dint do anything ..neither they checked her pulse to confirm if she is alive or not . Their first reaction was look what hemraj has done .

  • @devanshsadh8894
    @devanshsadh8894 3 роки тому +11

    Let’s just say for a sec that The parents did it! If you’re a father and you enter the room of your 13 year old daughter and see your servant all over her! Will you protect her at that moment or go to another room and bring a golf stick to hit the daughter and the servant! 2nd Hemraj was found dead on the terrace with his sleepers on! Will Hemraj let the father take him to the terrace let him kill them without anybody noticing? It’s just CBI’s incompetence behaviour and they fucked up with the evidence! I can never believe that the Talwars did it

  • @babin214
    @babin214 9 років тому +66

    It's sad that our police & CID has screwed up this Arushi case beyond reasonable doubt...

    • @sln7839
      @sln7839 2 роки тому +2

      I suspect money would’ve played a part in their acquittal

  • @sudiptabiswas7357
    @sudiptabiswas7357 8 років тому +53

    1- agar narco test ko legally accept nehi kiya ja sakta, to is test ko karne ka faida kya
    2- koi bhi young ladki jo ki well educated or modern hai kyun ek 50saal ke admi se relation rakhega
    3- police ne pehle hi forensic jach kyun nehi karwaya, kis liye govt. unko sallery deti hai
    4- mujhe bura lag raha hai ki ek ladki jo ki mehez 14saal ki thi or ab iss duniya mein bhi nehi hai use lekar ye media or indian judical system kya tamasha kar rehe hai

    • @sujeetkakade6053
      @sujeetkakade6053 4 роки тому +5

      1 narco test court me admissible nhi h evidence ki taur par...parantu us test k jariye investigators ko kuch chizo ke surag mil sakte h jisse unhe evidence dhundhne me madat mil sakati h jisse ki Mujrim tak pahuchne me madat ho Sakti h isiliye ☺️

    • @temslatalks4963
      @temslatalks4963 4 роки тому +5

      Because it might lead to any hidden evidence that the investigators might have missed.

    • @ReallyNig
      @ReallyNig 4 роки тому +1

      @@sujeetkakade6053 Exactly. The narco test could have revealed the murder weapon here, or maybe the post-murder sequence of the murderer which then would lead the investigation further.

    • @sunilbhalerao5468
      @sunilbhalerao5468 2 роки тому

      Mai shuru se hi Manta aaya hun ki murder parents ne nahi, noukron ne kiya hai.

  • @venmic78
    @venmic78 8 років тому +66

    After I have heard indrani mukerjea this case seems posisble that Talwrs may be responsible

    • @yoosufmahees4324
      @yoosufmahees4324 5 років тому +2

      Ven Mic true

    • @user_1abc
      @user_1abc 4 роки тому +9

      @Krishna Swami Servant wouldn't clean up Aarushi's vaginal cavity after murder. Only a medico will do it to eliminate any forensic/DNA evidence that would otherwise lead the CBI to her relationship with a man. Then it won't take much time for CBI to find out who that man was/is. Also, no servant would use a surgical instrument to sever his victims.
      Local cops and some other IOs may have been paid to mislead the investigation and with so much time lost, it's almost impossible to gather clinching evidence.
      If you just go by circumstantial evidence, a high-school graduate will tell with high certainty that Rajesh Talwar killer Aarushi in a fit of rage. Nupur supported Rajesh in misleading the investigation because having lost her daughter, she did not want to lose her husband. That would put her in the worst spot.

    • @shal9366
      @shal9366 3 роки тому

      @@user_1abc why couldnt aaruahi herself cleaned her private parts before going to sleep..and what evidence u have to tell that slit was only by a surgical instrument khukri is also very sharp weapon which can also cause same kind of slit..you told that out of rage he did that..do you think out of rage he went to other room to take a golf stick and then hit..

    • @user_1abc
      @user_1abc 3 роки тому +1

      @@shal9366 _"Why couldn't aaruahi herself cleaned her private parts before going to sleep.."_
      LOL What does that ^ even mean?

    • @shal9366
      @shal9366 3 роки тому +1

      @@user_1abc there are many reason for a girl to wash her private parts..its a part of hygiene..especially those girls who sweats a lot

  • @HarjeetSingh-ev8vk
    @HarjeetSingh-ev8vk 2 роки тому +19

    A good body language expert will tell you, how clearly guilty the Talwars look in all their interviews.

    • @good6043
      @good6043 2 роки тому +4

      Couldn't agree more. SO TRUE.

    • @sln7839
      @sln7839 2 роки тому

      Talwar must have murdered hemraj. Otherwise, why would talwar give money to the police and ask them to search for hemraj in the railway station when asked for the keys to the terrace? Next day hemraj’s body was found in the terrace. This is my clinching evidence that talwar murdered hemraj.

    • @Jasmine-fi2zq
      @Jasmine-fi2zq 10 місяців тому +1

      Exactly what i was thinking, at this point, after so many interviews, I don't think a body language expert is even needed. Anyone can figure this out just by looking at them. It's so fishy

    • @jhoanoff
      @jhoanoff 7 місяців тому +1

      I’ve seen the mothers interviews which everyone seems to be picking apart for no reason talking about how “cold” and “emotionless” she looks. Someone who has never been depressed would think she looks emotionless but as someone who has felt HOPELESSNESS before, she was feeling DESPONDENT. Her child was murdered her husband was jailed and everyone was scrutinizing her family picking it apart and spreading rumors about the family and airing out dirty laundry. Her interviews show a real woman handling her new reality. It’s ridiculous how everyone has been dragging her name through the mud despite having no basis for it, she never says anything that would even me incriminating people just don’t like her vibes (and I think all of you mindless sheep are deplorable) THEY HAVE GONE THROUGH ENOUGH without you people picking them apart for no reason.

  • @ann5159
    @ann5159 4 роки тому +36

    I don’t know why I’m not agreeing that talvars killed Aarushi

    • @zoravarzordar7348
      @zoravarzordar7348 3 роки тому +3

      They did. Look at her face. Disgusting

    • @pgdelhi6511
      @pgdelhi6511 3 роки тому +1

      YOU DON'T KNOW THIS CASE PROPERLY THAT IS WHY YOU ARE NOT AGREEING. RAJESH IS THE MAIN CULPRIT TO KILL HER DAUGHTER THEY DEVIL ON THIS EARTH.

    • @biriaku3363
      @biriaku3363 3 роки тому +8

      Definitely they are as per the circumstances

    • @sakshi5740
      @sakshi5740 3 роки тому +5

      Same! There is a feeling that they don't want to fight for her justice and continue their normal life..but somewhere they are not the reason of her murder!

    •  2 роки тому

      @@sakshi5740 watch the hotstar series plus kk gautam is their family friend as per a toi article dated 18th may 2008 you can read that through archives

  • @NoobMaster-or2jf
    @NoobMaster-or2jf 4 роки тому +16

    Call Benedict Cumberbatch. He'll wear a cap and sweater and solve the case in a minute.

  • @gollusingh007
    @gollusingh007 6 років тому +11

    CBI, Noida police kisi Ko bhi investigate nai karna aata.
    Aarushi ke bf ka bhi Naam aaya to usko ruled out kyu Kara?

    • @manisharyaa5466
      @manisharyaa5466 4 роки тому +1

      He was giving statements against talwars..Anmol was his name.

    • @skfire5832
      @skfire5832 11 днів тому

      @@manisharyaa5466 kb liya uska naam orkya bola usne

  • @topten8716
    @topten8716 2 роки тому +4

    If the router was rebooted twice. Checking the router logs could give the browsing history and ip addresses connected to it..

  • @deadmanwalking9157
    @deadmanwalking9157 3 роки тому +7

    Like sister abhaya case in kerala...the local police first demolished the crime scene....

    • @poulo121
      @poulo121 3 роки тому

      Abhaya case was different. Not a single drop of blood was seen anywhere in the alleged crime scene by any one

    • @deadmanwalking9157
      @deadmanwalking9157 3 роки тому

      @@poulo121 every evidence was there......police and culprits with loha vanished all evidences

    • @poulo121
      @poulo121 3 роки тому +1

      @@deadmanwalking9157
      Please go through the Judgement in Abhaya case. I changed my opinion after going through the Judgement. Don't believe the media.
      Two Asianet TV Channel discussions after the verdict was the classic example of how mistrust was created and how the case was delayed. ( Discussion participating Ex-CJM Raghumath/ Jomon. In the First discussion Jomon was not present)

  • @PrassanaRai-gz2nu
    @PrassanaRai-gz2nu 7 місяців тому +1

    Nupur was dancers women she killed nupur and her husband keeps secret like movie in drisyem..n not it enouf aarushi is not her own blooded daughter

  • @swetagupta7018
    @swetagupta7018 11 місяців тому +3

    I wonder if the parents said 'look what Hemraj has done' after calling and looking for him in the house and not finding him there. If so they could have assumed he is responsible. However if they said that without even looking for him in the house that would be quite suspicious.

  • @JOJO_LFC
    @JOJO_LFC 8 років тому +11

    If the servants and aarushi r in the same room.... Why they did not locked the door. If they doing something they may locked the door so the parents didn't do anything

    • @lovkushkumar
      @lovkushkumar 8 років тому +8

      even if.they lock it can b opened frm outside key

    • @garimasingh1493
      @garimasingh1493 4 роки тому +1

      No andar se bhi door open ho skta tha

    • @abhinavmanan8249
      @abhinavmanan8249 4 роки тому

      @@lovkushkumar kundi lga skte the

    • @lovkushkumar
      @lovkushkumar 4 роки тому

      @@abhinavmanan8249 haan mujhe lagta hain koi x Aadmi hoga joh phn karkay aaya hoga aur naukaron Kay sath paisay ka len den raha hoga and naukaron ki ladai main woh phans gaya baki police nay bakchodi karkay saboot nahi liya scene say

  • @preethidevaraj4756
    @preethidevaraj4756 2 роки тому +11

    Probably hemraj killed aarushi, the parents witnessed it and killed hemraj in a fit of rage. The way aarushi's body was treated after the murder was in contrast to how hemraj was treated,while aarushi's body was covered with a blanket and her dolls were kept near her,but hemraj's body was thrown away. The parents didn't want to find the killer because they know who killed their child.

    • @cricketworld9713
      @cricketworld9713 2 роки тому

      Dont think so.... Because.. As per Postmortem report.. She has vaginal discharge..... It meanssomething else

    • @anjukunwar1634
      @anjukunwar1634 2 роки тому

      Yeah ho skta h

    • @abhishekmp1775
      @abhishekmp1775 Рік тому +2

      That theory is possible

    • @chikkusimbumittumom356
      @chikkusimbumittumom356 Рік тому

      Highly possible

    • @katherineamelia98
      @katherineamelia98 Рік тому +4

      why would hemraj kill aarushi? why wouldn’t the parents say that’s what happened? it’s not a crime if that’s true, it’s self defense

  • @aljoseph2176
    @aljoseph2176 5 років тому +7

    What about this affair with a lady other than satisfy? Aarushys was accidental ... of course killer will not clean up the blood or evidences.. ..only the talwar was in the house..

  • @luckyg3957
    @luckyg3957 4 роки тому +12

    The talwar couple must b laughing at what fools they hv made of public..CBI...court ..judges...giving half baked answers...no emotion in their voice n face ..Arey 3 ya 4 degree punishment do na abhi truth aata hai tumbling out of their mouth..n tgen clise d case

  • @globalglass1475
    @globalglass1475 2 роки тому +2

    Regret, physical examination done n found the details indicates n louds for honor killing.

    • @cricketworld9713
      @cricketworld9713 2 роки тому +1

      Yes.. First they killled Hemraj... And later but sadly they killed there daughter

  • @nandhanav1e272
    @nandhanav1e272 2 роки тому +2

    I think hemraj killed Aarushi and When the parents arrived she was already dead and Hemraj was trying to escape via terrace...Then the parents might have killed Hemraj on the terrace...I don't know it is just my intuition.....I kind of get the vibe of Mohanlal's Drishyam movie.....The parents are not trying get justice for their daughter that clearly means they know something or justice had been carried out by the talwars themselves....It is an engaging case....Since I have heard about it I can't get it out of my head.....

    • @katherineamelia98
      @katherineamelia98 Рік тому +1

      then why didn’t they admit to it? it’s not criminal to murder the man who murdered your child, is it?

    • @Lavish_ChicUSA
      @Lavish_ChicUSA 5 місяців тому

      Then they could have told this to police. Could have called police

  • @bigbulk688
    @bigbulk688 9 років тому +12

    In another 10 years time everyone will forget this case unless nothing better has happened to report....the interim 10 years, most of which will be served outside jail on bail anyways.....once out, they'll simply move out of india, start a practice, and have another child....there you go JUSTICE SERVED!!

    • @SimranMurar
      @SimranMurar 4 роки тому +3

      So true. It’s been 12 years since this case began, and today, nobody cares about Aarushi or Hemraj. This is Indian Judiciary. Justice will never be served to the deceased in this way.

  • @MayurPanghaal
    @MayurPanghaal 7 років тому +19

    Found no motive ? Hello ? Thats exactly why the vaginal swabs were switched and only a dna analysis showed they didnt belong to arushi.Why and who would switch vaginal swabs ? only someone powerful and rich.
    Former Noida superintendent of police KK Gautam, during chief examination told the court that chairman of Noida Eye Hospital Sushil Chaudhry, a friend of slain teenager Aarushi's uncle Dinesh Talwar, had called him and requested him to hide the rape angle in the postmortem.
    However, he said that he refused to oblige Dinesh Talwar, the elder brother of Aarushi's father and accused Rajesh Talwar.
    This is testimony in court !!!

    • @vedhikaprahlad4377
      @vedhikaprahlad4377 7 років тому +3

      Yup , at midnight how come they didn't hear any shouts or screames...

  • @ILM06
    @ILM06 2 роки тому +2

    It was all Police and CBI fault.
    Everyone made their own theory instead of doing unbiased investigation.

  • @Ankona_Vaani
    @Ankona_Vaani 3 роки тому +1

    No comments
    Quite the better
    Baat toh tabh bna " jisna kiya" danki ki chot par bola
    Darpok murderer

  • @MsDowntoearth11
    @MsDowntoearth11 8 років тому +17

    Mr Raghavan: i have not read.....blah blah, as an outsider.......... why was he here?

  • @mirzaeffendi4374
    @mirzaeffendi4374 9 років тому +6

    Indian CBI is considered to be the second best in the world,. at one point our agencies are getting enough evidence of certain underworld don residing in some part of the world, with full details address,. and now the aarushi murder mystery, in our own country, with full force behind us to work forensic help, and the result is controversy, and debate,.

    • @ManishSingh-xo1fb
      @ManishSingh-xo1fb 9 років тому +1

      Yeah thats because the police never isolated the crime scene, media people, were rampaging through out the crime scene. Heck they did not check the terrace even, which investigator never checks the crime scene properly? That too because talavrs said they cannot find the terrace keys. You smell fishy right there. Also best thing was no traces of talwars was found on arushi's dead body. What is your first thought when you see some one dead, and in case "beloved" daughter. I think even hardest people will at least check the pulse. Or breathing. They did not even go near the body. Fyi - every medical person is taught basic of forensics

    • @martinstephen2434
      @martinstephen2434 7 років тому +4

      "Indian CBI is considered to be the second best in the World".
      Yeah, unless the "World" is made up of only TWO countries, India and Pakistan.
      Dude, stop deluding yourself in your Bollywood Dreamland.
      You have a rubbish Government system. Accept it and do something about it.

  • @richardj8853
    @richardj8853 4 роки тому +14

    It clearly points to the parents who managed to very cleverly destroy all the evidence by early morning . They will forever live in guilt and shame .

    • @mukulhaque2695
      @mukulhaque2695 2 роки тому

      But I can't understand why her parents kill her.Please tell me naa.

  • @latchmisugrim2247
    @latchmisugrim2247 4 роки тому +2

    They are not Human they are Beast i know Parents loved their Children parents left themselve and make sure they get the best if it is so they do killed their child

  • @Altamash23
    @Altamash23 4 роки тому +14

    If parents are innocent who did it? How could they not hear when 2 murders happened the night

    • @mycreation5314
      @mycreation5314 4 роки тому +2

      exactly sari investigation chor k unsy yehi poch lty k wo kia kha k soye ty jo unhn pta e ni kch bhi

    • @itzayushbaka7457
      @itzayushbaka7457 Рік тому +1

      The sound of Ac in their room was too loud for outside noise and the CBI also tested it and found out it cancelled outside noise
      The parents may be in deep sleep and couldn't get to know what happened outside

  • @ushasarma4389
    @ushasarma4389 Рік тому +2

    As per present court verdict- the lower court solved it like simple mathematical query- there were 4 people - 2 were murdered and 2 were alive so those who were alive murdered them.

  • @benjaminabraham3506
    @benjaminabraham3506 4 роки тому +10

    This Aarushi Hemraj tangle was based on the information the UP police gathered from either one of Aarushi's friends or Talwar himself... There is absolutely no doubt on that...there was no way the police was going to construct a storyline by themselves on a high profile case as this which was extensively covered by the media.
    UP Police chief Gurudarshan Singh in the first media briefing ever on Aarushi Hemraj murder said the Rajesh Talwar found Hemraj in his daughter's room in objectionable but not compromising position. Who provided him with this information? No police officer ever is going to make such a false claim for he knows the consequences of it.
    The police chief was transferred and his mouth was shut for ever. No one ever asked him who precisely gave him that information. Some said it was Krishna who provided the information but the fact is, it could not be...some of Aarushi's friends who were questioned might have shared some information which they knew or they suspected. A friend of hers was bundled into a Jeep and questioned for a few hours, likewise we don't know how many...
    Rajesh Talwar at first took the blame of the murder which is why the police chief gave such a statement, however Talwar retracted on his words in court, he said he agreed to have committed the crime under duress.
    From there on this case saw media, legal experts, CBI, investigation officers, social media enthusiasts take sides...to the extent that this case has come to a closure with 'No Absolute' suspect.
    Many people believe it to be a botched up investigation...well what if it is not? What if the crux of the finding of the CBI is close to the truth if not fully true.

    • @sadaf2301
      @sadaf2301 2 роки тому +1

      Well explained..what u said about the police person saying about arushi n hemraj sounds correct as there seems to be no other motive for this murder . The only thing which contradict this theory is that if hemraj n arushi were found in compromising position then there should have been hemraj blood sample in arushi room but not even a single blood trace of hemraj was found . And it's not possible to clean blood from a place as slightest of blood can be detected using luminol spray .

    • @benjaminabraham3506
      @benjaminabraham3506 2 роки тому +1

      @@sadaf2301
      Well, by the time they came for such inspection, the room was extensively cleaned leaving no stone unturned.
      Infact the very day in the presence of police officers,even before the postmortem was completed, the room was cleaned.
      BTW, This is from acamdeic point of view, Some of the videos that were there in YT on this vase has been taken off.
      This includes some videos by witness.

  • @koroukhuman8854
    @koroukhuman8854 9 років тому +29

    12:18 to 12:26, if you listen carefully you will be able to hear a whisper which sounds like some one is trying to say something. Is it just random surround sound or is some one trying to say something. curious to know.

    • @drrajeevdahiwal1856
      @drrajeevdahiwal1856 8 років тому +2

      +Korou Khuman i thought only i heard this

    • @sourcehauntings8851
      @sourcehauntings8851 8 років тому +1

      +Korou Khuman No..you are right..I hear a male whispering on the Norco video as well..it is the spirit of the male servant that was killed.

    • @sourcehauntings8851
      @sourcehauntings8851 8 років тому +3

      +Kathryn Quella but in this video it is def the spirit of the girl. sounds just like her

    • @drrajeevdahiwal1856
      @drrajeevdahiwal1856 8 років тому +3

      Kathryn Quella applause !!!!!

    • @slashmary
      @slashmary 5 років тому +6

      Lol it could be any one if the guests on the panel. Arushi's friend maybe...

  • @sln7839
    @sln7839 2 роки тому +1

    No media talked about hemraj murder which holds the case in this murder. Im pretty sure SC would convict talwar again

  • @anandnavghare9037
    @anandnavghare9037 3 роки тому +1

    Useless investigation of first hand police.
    Shame on you, because of you Arushi Hemraj, couldn't get justice.

  • @umarudra
    @umarudra 4 роки тому +9

    I can't believe that Parents can kill their own children!!
    Please help them... They are poor parents!!

  • @chayabalan8504
    @chayabalan8504 3 місяці тому

    First police officers have done all wrong things

  • @dr.jacobpaul4902
    @dr.jacobpaul4902 2 роки тому +1

    First cbi team pressurised Krishna to take the blame as per the Narco test result.

  • @vishwajanakbharat1222
    @vishwajanakbharat1222 8 років тому +31

    Just watched the movie "Talwar" and i am deeply hurt by the kind of probe carried out by our "respected" esteemed CBI, the top notch investigation agency of the country. Didn't expect great from UP police. bUt CBI has done a great job. Shameful act. I spit on CBI. On the basis of mere circumstances, they declared parents guilty. Forensic reports manipulated. Last, they say she was murdered as she was characterless. My heart goes with the parents who lost their only child. And now, only they are going to bear the brunt for rest of their life. JUSTICE is done to Arushi!! F**k this kind of Law and justice.

    • @bloodmariner
      @bloodmariner 7 років тому +12

      Bhai that was the film .. the reason why courts function is so we can take decisions without being influenced.

    • @braingamesballsortgame718
      @braingamesballsortgame718 6 років тому +9

      Please don't think that the events and evidences mentioned in the film is the absolute truth. Read and analyze the real news reports and then try to find by yourself. Initially, the police had lots of evidences, but most of them were willingly allowed to be destroyed especially by the parents themselves like cremating the body of Aarushi in haste and wiping and cleaning up the bedroom and mattress etc. This seems to indicate that the parents may have bribed the police and police allowed and botched up many of the evidences. Just think, if anyone's daughter gets brutally murdered, the parents will be willing and hell bent upon to preserve the evidences and help the police to catch the murderer. Here, the opposite seems to have happened. But still the parents seems to have tremendous love for their daughter, but it happened in the fit of rage..

    • @sujeetkakade6053
      @sujeetkakade6053 4 роки тому +7

      Film is totally made up for saving parents...and nothing other purpose of film...as Irrfan sir in this film roles as a ex cbi officer it doesn't mean that his theory of murder is only truth...😁

    • @meetu7817
      @meetu7817 4 роки тому +1

      Zaruri nai hai ki firm mein sab truth hai. Obviously it was made to defend talwars. I also felt that talwar are not guilty when I saw the film but see their interviews and I feel differently. They could be guilty. Nobody knows except they themselves.

    • @rashmisikka5814
      @rashmisikka5814 4 роки тому +1

      Parents are the only killers. They were responsible for cleaning and tampering all evidences. Otherwise they would have preserved the crime scene if they really wanted justice for their daughter.

  • @Madhuwellness
    @Madhuwellness 2 роки тому +4

    Even if they are not killers (we never know) they are guilty. Could not protect their child from dying, who was sleeping in same house. Giving so much access to the servant who recently joined work?! All keys are with him, they have a teenage daughter 🤷‍♀️

  • @mahalakshmiviswanathanpune4227
    @mahalakshmiviswanathanpune4227 2 роки тому +1

    There are 4 people in a house..
    In the morning 2 are seen dead and 2 in another room in the house. This shows these 2 killed the other 2. If someone else had come at night inside the house and killed the 2, then these 2 must have seen them, isn't it? Then they will definitely tell about the killers.But they dint .But they couldn't tell,means the 1st 2,the parents only killed .Is this not acceptable in court

    • @mrbme
      @mrbme Рік тому

      The AC sound was very high in their room. In 2008 many felt unbelievable but we know how a closed room with high sound AC will be.
      Police also confirmed that there was no sound coming into the room.

    • @Lavish_ChicUSA
      @Lavish_ChicUSA 5 місяців тому

      Jo mar Gia wo criminal nahi na e murderer Aur Jo bach Gia Aur Zinda hain wo murderers hain

  • @Shaikhfarida14
    @Shaikhfarida14 Рік тому +3

    My instinct says parents are not murderer. There is a 3rd person whom Hemant knew. Thats why both went on the terrace .

  • @chayabalan8504
    @chayabalan8504 3 місяці тому

    Some how talwars are responsible

  • @manojammalu
    @manojammalu 3 місяці тому

    Aarushi, the butterfly that was thrown by the savages before it could take flight. Something mysterious happened in the flat that night, either in Talwar's room or in Hemrajs room...Aarushi, this world does not deserved you. See you in the Heaven. RIP

  • @Justice4Soujanya
    @Justice4Soujanya 6 місяців тому

    Modi (Indian Hitler) directly doesn’t involve in corruption; however, one of his cabinet members fully involved in corruption, rowdyism, rape and murder, i.e.; Dharmastala Veerendra Heggade, Harshendra Jain and their gangsters.
    If Modi is really a truthful person he should have taken action to uphold “Beti Bachao and Beti Padao slogan he created for his election campaign”.
    “Justice for Saoujanya…..” fight is not reaching him?
    When a person is trying to clean his past blooded hand he would never see blooded handful persons at Dharmastala, in fact he may give them another cabinet posts in next government because Indians are now with blind folds on. I pray to “Maryada Purishottam Sri Ram” to save India from these power hungry murderers.
    Jai Sri Ram… Justice for Soujanya…

  • @ManishSingh-xo1fb
    @ManishSingh-xo1fb 9 років тому +16

    Parent are innocent because a movie director has put in more thought than hundreds of evidence and a supreme court judge.

    • @ManishSingh-xo1fb
      @ManishSingh-xo1fb 9 років тому +3

      Stupid people. I thought we do not take indian movies seriously

    • @braingamesballsortgame718
      @braingamesballsortgame718 6 років тому +3

      Manish Singh SERIOUSLY... Public so easily believes a bollywood movie rather than evidences and the courts judgment.

  • @jessefernandez2122
    @jessefernandez2122 Рік тому

    Uma rudra ,that was well said.people need to see the truth añd help those parents, by not accusing them ígnorantly,with no real evidence .that will happen only when people behave like human beings
    ..

  • @MayurPanghaal
    @MayurPanghaal 7 років тому +16

    She is lying about the blood of hemraj on krishna pillow.THE GOVT Lab wrote a letter clarifying that it was a typo error.This talwar family has engineered public opinion via books and movies.

  • @AP-do8mi
    @AP-do8mi 2 роки тому +3

    In the US they would be prosecuted. whether they did it or not. because law of nature ordains the parents with child safety not the CBI or police to investigate well after the kid is gone. circumstantially they were right there.

  • @brockbrock2348
    @brockbrock2348 3 роки тому +3

    Why this Kiran bedii is doing so much ovrracting

  • @MrThresher7
    @MrThresher7 5 років тому +17

    Why would the parents kill their own daughter? what is the motive?

    • @montlesb4551
      @montlesb4551 4 роки тому +4

      you have 5 likes for your comment....LOL

    • @supriyasalian3241
      @supriyasalian3241 4 роки тому +5

      Some parents kill there children as honor killing..if they are having a affair with someone

    • @user_1abc
      @user_1abc 4 роки тому +4

      It was not a planned murder. It just happened in a fit of rage. Across the globe there are several cases of spouses killing each other, parents killing kids or vice versa. If one can't control his/her emotions, anything is possible. You can't apply rationale and logic to those actions.
      In Aarushi's case, Rajesh found Aarushi in an objectionable position with Hemraj, and killed her in a fit of rage. Having lost his only daughter, he did not want to spare Hemraj...because he was the reason. Then Nupur having lost her only child did not want to lose he husband.

    • @AnkitaSingh-qg3lk
      @AnkitaSingh-qg3lk 4 роки тому +2

      Some outsiders have done it......

    • @rashmisikka5814
      @rashmisikka5814 4 роки тому +2

      @@user_1abc It was a pre-planned murder .. why they gave Aarushi her birthday gift camera 10 days in advance.
      When Mother had the routine habit of locking daughter's room at night.. how she forgot that particular night?

  • @vandanakumari1463
    @vandanakumari1463 2 роки тому

    I was here to hear Kiran bedi statements, she didn't even get chance.

  • @sreenivasmarka0702
    @sreenivasmarka0702 2 роки тому

    Talwars are the culprits .
    No other.

  • @joycelow2667
    @joycelow2667 4 роки тому +2

    The law is bulls#%t

  • @madhavipeechara2436
    @madhavipeechara2436 10 років тому +4

    Hi

  • @XP_0369
    @XP_0369 5 років тому +5

    The parents were not guilty the servants were guilty as hemraj had got a call around 8 pm from a near by Std and they on the phone must have planned for drinking... And now it takes a turn y did the cbi did not see any cctv footages or any other things nearby roads of the suspect servants... Clear cut cbi will not loose their honor... CBI DID THE HONOR KILLING...also why would arushi and hemrajs phones were stolen and if her mom called up hemraj's phone... The call was accepted and switched off... The phone was damn somewhere very far out from that place... All bullshit... The servant who was working in hospital with arushis dad also was asking for revenge... Omg...also the phone of arushi was taken to the way nepal... Y t f it was in route... The mom and dad were so multi talented???... If there was a test how many hours the mother and father slept y didn't they do that??? If there may be such a test... And if the phone had to be destroyed of Boths... Her father had to go out of the building to atleast get it disposed off... I mean what investigation did these Bullshits do???? In my case the servant killed her and hemraj... Hemraj was made a victim after the death of arushi.... Did the forensics checked hemrajs blood??? No they did not even mention if he was drank that night... All bullshit... The murder did not happen between 12 to 1 am that's too a Bullshit... Arushis father went to sleep closed the door... The servants knows when they sleep they enter they drink the watch the song... The forensics did not test their bloods as well... There was urine in toilets samples were not taken all those shitters peed there... If arushis father had to be blamed hitting both with the golf club... Those cbi noobs did not know??? That the clubs were in hemrajs room... And as they were drinking something bad happened to arushi... While one was peeing outside hemraj went to see him where he is... He must have also grabbed the whisky bottle which was kept on the table... Limited resources for alcohol as they were not highly paid caused the bottle of whisky to come out from the cupboard... So now if they say arushis father can hold hemraj and drag him upstairs on terrace why not those servants??? All bullshit evidences the cbi has investigated...

    • @montlesb4551
      @montlesb4551 4 роки тому +2

      You have been sompletly watching again and again TV news,,,,,and believed

  • @suma2024
    @suma2024 4 роки тому +1

    Villains

  • @bibikhan3353
    @bibikhan3353 4 роки тому +1

    P
    R

  • @fabulousbeyond1857
    @fabulousbeyond1857 8 років тому +1

    .

  • @onmyviews9748
    @onmyviews9748 2 роки тому

    Ye close family sab fake bolegi

  • @PreetSingh-xz4ws
    @PreetSingh-xz4ws 10 років тому +20

    Parents are innocent

  • @KronixAmv
    @KronixAmv 9 років тому +11

    parents are innocent,release them,i feel someone should do something about this...check arun kumars interview on 6 oct 2015.

  • @prasanjitgupta8357
    @prasanjitgupta8357 8 років тому +7

    Barkha Dutt can say anything.. smart clever and know how to make money... democracy is non of her business.. she had shown in 1999 kargil wars.. Plz INDIA get rid of all this journalist who only watns to make money out of journlism... Shame Bharkha Dutt!!!

    • @Indusxstan
      @Indusxstan 5 років тому

      Prasanjit Gupta yes. This presstitute is hard to watch.

  • @ushasarma4389
    @ushasarma4389 Рік тому

    What a caption- nonsense.

  • @jdudbdgs
    @jdudbdgs 4 роки тому +3

    One like for Barkha Dutt 👍

  • @masroorahmedkhan5028
    @masroorahmedkhan5028 2 роки тому

    Arushi is beautiful

  • @aludamdahibara7851
    @aludamdahibara7851 9 років тому +24

    PARENTS ARE INNOCENT

  • @ayushbadoni7388
    @ayushbadoni7388 5 років тому

    Acussed.

  • @chamathas83
    @chamathas83 2 роки тому

    Could it be that hemraj was lured into terrace and killed. Then this person makes his way into the house through hemraj s room. Then he found arushi s room key on the door. Then kills her with the golf stick while she was sleeping. Then parents found her in the morning dead and being concerned about their reputation cleaned her private parts of the girl.

  • @hrishabhdudeja7523
    @hrishabhdudeja7523 2 роки тому

    In my opinion aarushi committed suicide. End of case

  • @rsrai8067
    @rsrai8067 5 років тому +4

    Ye dutt randi ssali

  • @swarnamohanty3121
    @swarnamohanty3121 6 років тому +2

    Justice always right .

  • @reetachauhan8354
    @reetachauhan8354 7 років тому

    Pessimistic NDTV

  • @faizinaeem
    @faizinaeem 9 років тому +6

    Parents are innocent, Parents are the best protector of their children. Please watch Talvar Movie this is all happened because of police negligence.

    • @drrajeevdahiwal1856
      @drrajeevdahiwal1856 8 років тому +5

      +Ef Oberoi talvar is biased movie , dont count on it

    • @faizinaeem
      @faizinaeem 8 років тому

      Yub but also personally know it .....

    • @drrajeevdahiwal1856
      @drrajeevdahiwal1856 8 років тому

      and what makes u so sure?

    • @faizinaeem
      @faizinaeem 8 років тому

      Stay next to his home so i know the truth what is all about happened there....

    • @drrajeevdahiwal1856
      @drrajeevdahiwal1856 8 років тому +2

      Ef Oberoi were u present there on the day of aarushi's murder, i mean in the morning ...?

  • @ShivamThakur07
    @ShivamThakur07 8 років тому +3

    After watching the movie, if that is what has really happened, then I'm ashamed of India and the judicial system. The system in place is a joke. It makes me wonder, may be Afzal guru was also innocent and the students at JNU were right.

    • @rashmisikka5814
      @rashmisikka5814 4 роки тому +1

      Talking about movie Talwar,take an example of Sanju.. how they portrait a terrorist, womaniser and a drug addict in a positive manner. Thats the beauty of cinema.. they leave illusionary impact on public's mind.

  • @Nomadicshunti1963
    @Nomadicshunti1963 8 років тому +2

    Parents are guilty of the murder of Arushi due to following things :
    1)how come the modem switched on and off
    2)how come the hemraj mobile sim was found in Bulandshahr each and thing is framed

    • @rahulbhola1
      @rahulbhola1 8 років тому +6

      +FloxaZoRx modem was automatically switched on and off in front of police on next day.

    • @Nomadicshunti1963
      @Nomadicshunti1963 8 років тому

      Rahul Bhola Each and everything is framed by there parents .

    • @beezlebub9
      @beezlebub9 5 років тому +1

      Based on these 2 things they are guilty? What’s the connection?