A Classic Song That Still Inspires Today | Heroes (Bowie) & cover by Peter Gabriel | The Daily Doug
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 бер 2022
- #Heroes #DavidBowie #PeterGabriel
In this episode of #TheDailyDoug, I'm listening to a classic song by David Bowie with a message that uplifts and inspires. Heroes was written and recorded literally in the shadow of the Berlin Wall and became an anthem during the Cold War. With tensions and strife around the world (and especially in Ukraine), this song can help spark our belief in humanity where it may be cracked or broken. I'm listening to the classic original studio recording by David Bowie as well as a poignant and powerful cover version by Peter Gabriel. I hope you enjoy this #MasterpieceFriday edition of the show. (Episode 353)
Reference Video: • david bowie - heroes (...
Reference Video: • Peter Gabriel - Heroes...
Catch up on my full album reactions at my Patreon!
JOIN THE NEW EXCLUSIVE DAILY DOUG COMMUNITY!
Patreon: / doughelvering
Instagram: / doug.helvering
Facebook: / helvering
Twitter: / helvering
Vimeo: vimeo.com/user146736659
The Daily Doug Directory: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
One of the brilliant things about Peter Gabriel's orchestral arrangements is his use of the strings as a substitute rhythm section. It's a common theme throughout his career, both studio and live.
Fripp did 3 separate takes for this song, told Bowie “one of these should work” and left the
studio. They used all 3 takes simultaneously.
Brilliant.
Classic Fripp
I heard also that he flew a long distance to get to the studio, had practiced on the plane given what he had on the song and the first track was the one kept. Only thing that was changed was done in editing.
I love Fripp!
Fripp created Frippertronics to be able to play it live.
The buildup with Bowie going overboard with his vocals is cruell and brilliant. It grabs you by the balls
Robert Fripp's endlessly sustained guitar notes hooting in the distance, among the rest of the soundscapes, effects and ambiant noise, all supported by the unstoppable rythmic machine moving on and on. Timeless
I'm a fan of Philip Glass and love his 4th Symphony "Heroes Symphony" based upon this song.
One of the few artists whose death made me cry. Especially the first time I listened to this song after his death. Every listen absolutely moves me every time.
Blackstar was an amazing epitaph - especially if you watch the video. His creative power, right up to the end was unbelievable
I remember this getting airplay in 1977. It's been one of my favorite songs by Bowie ever since.
The atmosphere that Fripp created .. really pulled the room together.
Bowie and Gabriel, two of my favorite singers and one of my favorite songs. Those soaring, sustaining guitar lines. Then Peter making his version so Gabriel. Excellence
Those guitars are primo
I believe Heroes became more popular as live performances of it were seen. Truly, the live versions are best with many of his songs. He's far more enjoyable live than in the studio, a rare and wonderful trait considering how great the studio stuff is.
I agree with that, particularly with Heroes (and many others)
Heros is a timeless masterpiece.It's about time someone figured it out that this is a song for any time in history especially now. I give you credit Doug. Means alot for survival of music and man. If you really get it it will drive you to tears.
It is such a powerful song on so many levels
As an artist, PG has loved Bowie's work for his entire career. He and some of the members of Genesis were huge fans of Bowie's record, Hunky Dory. So this tribute to DB and this song has a deep rooted respect that comes over to the listener in powerful fashion. I love both versions very much, and PG really made a crusher version that makes the nose sting and the eyes leak. And I'll point out that his tribute had this powerful effect while Bowie was still alive, but now it's a leveling feeling that leaves us fans in a puddle of tears.
The use of this song at the end of the film, JoJo Rabbit, is masterful to say the least.
I saw King Crimson play this as one of their encore songs at a show (awesome!). Fair enough, as Robert Fripp is on the original.
I was introduced to this song through a cover version performed by Blondie with a guest appearance by Fripp that appeared on a 12" single British import. I heard the Bowie version a few years later. 😎
Both versions amazing - especially Fripp’s guitar. Peter Gabriel reinterprets it brilliantly. Please do also see Peter Gabriel’s interpretation of MY BODY IS A CAGE the Arcade Fire song. It is extraordinary and the orchestral arrangements are to die for. Peter doesn’t read so used a colour coded system and discovered that a chunk of the orchestra were following his chart in preference to the score!
I've always loved Bowie's original version. But my god, with Peter Gabriel's, I had a huge frisson when the orchestra swelled, and I openly was weeping by halfway through.
Yeah! David was inside the Studio when the kiss happen❤❤❤. Brilliant song! And Peter Gabriel sang like a God! Wonderful! Thank you boths!😊😊
When Fripp would come into a session like this, he would often perform without hearing the track first. In this case he recorded one take, and Tony (and maybe Brian and David, I don’t recall), weren’t sure it was the one. Robert asked them for a second take, without listening to the first while he recorded it. He then recorded a third take.
Tony blended the three takes together, and they are drastically different from each other, but blended into that magical part.
Many folks think it was done with an eBow, an electronic device that keeps the guitar string vibrating. But it wasn’t. Just Fripp and a very loud Les Paul Custom. He measured and marked distances from the amp where it would feedback certain notes. I recall reading he was seated (as usual) and could roll to where it would feedback.
Here’s Tony playing parts from the master tape, including bits of all three of Robert’s guitar tracks:
ua-cam.com/video/7Q2scPrc1WE/v-deo.html
The peak of analogue recording equipment was in the 70s ,tape saturation ,the compressors and the desks of the time along with amazing engineers and musicians that really knew their craft ,music had dynamics and depth ,no autotune or protools 😂
David Bowie's Heroes has always had such a special place in my heart and in the soundtrack of life (thanks Geebz). It's one of those songs that transcends the mundane. But, watching Stranger Things back in 2016 and hearing Peter Gabriel's version for the very first time was something else. What a cover. What a song. Now I don't even know which version I prefer anymore.
That episode for me is one of the most impactful marrying of film and music I’ve ever seen.
What a wonderful song to cover, and I am so glad you included Peter Gabriel’s cover; he brings a different and extraordinary emotion to the piece. As an additional point of background, there is an adjacent interpretation of the song, identifying its theme as the struggle to confront magical thinking with clear-eyed reality. It gives the song a very different and darker mood, but still inspiring in its way, and not exclusive of the ideas you’ve identified. Peter Gabriel’s version, with its alternatively ordered lyrics and emphasis, makes this a bit clearer. Thank you as always for these wonderful videos
I am a little biased.. I love David Bowie, but Peter Gabriel has a voice that just strikes a chord in my soul.. always has
Totally agree. I wonder if Doug has ever looked at tracks off 'Security'? If not, that should be in his 'To Do' list.
In PG's voice I find a mixture of fragility and strength, often both at the same time. (I'm also biased as I'm a long-time fan of PG)
I take both Peter and David
The reason recordings from the 1970s sound so good is that they were recorded analog/tape and that the editing/production equipment had reached a peak. The Peter Gabriel version gave me chills - thank you.
There’s a brilliant 15 min video with Toni Visconti the producer in a studio and he shows how the original Bowie track was recorded, built up and constructed. V insightful and enlightening. Check it out on UA-cam
I geeked out on this one about 3 years ago. I love when Tony says he wants to mix it again.
The greatest rock song ever composed and sung by the greatest rock star of all time.
I can think of no one better than Peter to cover Heroes. The song has Always inspired me & I shiver every time I hear it. It’s so simple but builds passionately, pleading, screaming we can be Heroes. Pure genius.
other than the above mentioned Adrian Belew, who toured as Mr. Bowie's guitarist and backing singer several times. No one loves and admires Mr. Gabriel more than I do, but Mr. Belew is sure to have some special insight into what made Mr. Bowie "tick" having played "Heroes" on stage with Mr. Bowie (and I love the goofy grins on Mr. Bowie's face while he watches Ade shred that stratocaster a few feet away from him) so many times.
My favorite cover of this song is done by King Crimson with Adrian Belew on vocals. Adrian gives so much power to this song, I'm sure you would love it.
It's really great.
Best band ever in my opinion!
Love the Mercury Tribute version with Ziggy and Spider guitarits Ronson reuniting on stage after all those years from ” the last show we’ll ever do”.
I was drinking Old Crow and smoking Slap Wagon, as I watched. I love you, man.
Peter Gabriel's classical version of "Listening Wind" by Talking Heads reaches directly into your heart, and paints the most vivid mental pictures!
Peter's whole "Scratch my Back and Ill Scratch Yours"/"Live Blood" album is a masterpiece in every way, with just brilliant and unexpected classical arrangements.
Doug, I’m blaming you for the fact that I’ve been obsessed with Bowie for the last several weeks since you did this review.
So thanks.👏👏👏
Phillip Glass composed an entire collection of Bowie and Eno's Berlin songs. It's amazing!
Wow idk
Philip Glass’s first Symphony used elements of Low in the composition and the 4th similarly used Heroes
Just awesome how the same song can be interpreted in such different ways and sound equally wonderful
Thanks for doing this one!
Really enjoyed this and have thought of this song in the context of today's events. Glad to see someone with better writing thought the same. I really enjoyed playing my bass along with this tonight!
Thank you for your honest perspective of this song 🎵 I do hope you explore more of this genius’s work!
The whole "Heroes" album as well as "Low" album are fascinating listens and highly recommended.
And they were released within 6 months of each other!!!
It never surprises me that the bit of Bowie’s oeuvre I appreciate most is the stuff he did with Brian Eno, a musician and composer who deserves deep exploration.
im germand and i had the honor to see Peter perform his Version in 2014 live in Berlin at the "25th anniversary of the downfall of the berlin wall party". I cried the whole time while singing along!. It was a magical night. They had a line of brightly lit up balloons that traced a 15-kilometre stretch of the former berlin wall and all 7000 balloons were released into the air at the end of the show.
That Peter Gabriel version.. wow.. I'd never heard that before.
I didn't want it to stop.
And talk about the relevance to today.. crikey.
'The shame is on the other side.. we can beat them.. we can be Heroes just for one day'
From his mouth to God's ears.
A stunning cover and fantastic orchestration. So much forward motion! Glorious.
David Bowie changed my life.
Hell yeah....Bopping along in the UK, great Video Doug....and Peter Gabriel as a bonus.....perfect!!!!
I would love to see a video of you covering Peter Gabriel’s Blood of Eden, San Jacinto or Wallflower. That would be so great.
I would love that as well, I would add BIKO
PG is amazing. I wouldn’t mind a review if the entire Passion soundtrack.
I'd add the last part of "PG1" with "Waiting for The Big One", "Down the Dolce Vita" and" Here Comes the Flood" :D
Oh yes blood of Eden please 😍
Bowie really was a unique individual. Such a deep and soulful guy and his vision was unreal. His predictions of the internet back in ‘99 were truly prophetic.
Love his music so much, it would be fantastic to hear you check out more of his. ⚡️⚡️🙏🏻
since you are a classic composer Philip Glass made two symphonies from the Low and Heroes albums in the 90s called Low Symphony and Heroes symphony they are very interesting and a great homage to Bowie (Glass and Bowie were friendly).
by the way Bowie sang this song at the concert for the victims of 9/11 in NY (where he lived) short time after that terrible event with a public of firefighters and police officers. there is a video recording of that event.
Yes, I am bopping along.
I got home to late again for live, but I'm watching right now! Great song pick, Doug! You and your fans always find stuff that's awesome, ofcourse, but THIS ONE; SO NEEDED TODAY!
This one is for the entire Earth!👏👏👏 We ALL need Heros to inspire us to help others. Even in 2022!💜💜💜
We can all be heroes ❤️
Thank you for the great content! The microfone details are revealing and, for me, they fit perfectly the way I think about the song (Bowie is awesome ). I also heard someone talking about the growing dissonance throughout the song, that it could represent the despair situation that turns one into a hero (heroes rising to the task in desperate moments - so current).
I think of a couple in east Berlin ready to say goodbye facing a separation that seemed permanent at the time. In the beginning of the song, using the closest mic, they were still together, dreaming of impossible ways to remain a couple, but confronting the reality (the powers that would separate them). Later in the song (one is in the west and the other in the east), David’s voice is further way and with a dissonance that make you feel the loss. At this point he remembers the kiss by the wall that felt like a last kiss (like nothing could fall ). In the end of the song, more dissonance, voice further way (they are maybe apart by distance and time), they no longer can be heroes, they just ‘could’ be. To finish in a better note, he returns to ‘we can be heroes’ maybe indicating that we cannot change the past but we can learn from it. Very sad, beautiful, inspirational song. Can’t help thinking about the couples (families) separated in Ukraine…
Thank you, for your work and also for your words.
Given the situation we all find ourselves in today - this is the song (Peter Gabriels' version for me), of this moment and is very emotional. All the best from Devon UK, Beamer.
Goosebumps at the end of PG's cover.
Thanks for this Doug.
Beautiful!!
Excellent video Dave.
Great song.
Great video.
Yes, we can be heroes.
Try to love one another right now.
It is the fragility of it that gets me - "We're nothing and nothing can help us. Maybe we're lying; then you'd better not stay. But we could be safer, just for one day"
Thanks Doug. I loved your musings. Great, great song. Gabriel's version is so different, so unique.
A very inspirational reaction, Doug.
The 70"s didn't rely on computers, no Protools, no Autotune, no grids, just talent and ingenuity.
yes I'm bopping!
King Crimson does a great Heroes cover as well, but of course we know about what they feel about people doing reactions to them....
don't forget Fripp plays "that guitar" on this original recording
True, and that is really too bad.
@@estroncio1959 He does, and Crimson's version is pretty close to David Bowie's so I like the choice of Peter Gabriel here
Best way to do reactions to later King Crimson is to react to covers by Adrian Belew or Tony Levin's Stick Men :-)
I have no idea what King Crimson feel about people's reactions to them. Please spill the beans.
OMG , Peter do it so amazing
I feel pretty sure that the real high points in written/recorded music have that meloncholic yet hopeful feel about them... Like this song. Nice one Doug.
More Gabriel please
I always felt that heroes pulled so much from the velvet underground sound especially that underlying rhythm section/beat.
I came here to say that! That groove is right out of "Waiting For The Man".
Here are David Bowie and Lou Reed singing it together in a blistering live version: ua-cam.com/video/W4VEXl4vsq4/v-deo.html
That is because Bowie based this on "Waiting For The Man" - Bowie was obsessed with the velvet underground.
@@Elvin_Pelvin Yes. I think he once claimed to be the first person to ever cover a velvet underground song.
@@TK-fk4po I was trying to find an extract from an article relating an infamous (possibly apocryphal) incident to copy here but I can't find it - so to paraphrase (or para-quote para-reference whatever) - Bowie was in New York circa 1970 / 71? and went to see a VU gig - he was elated to have engaged Lou Reed in conversation after the gig - only later to realise that Lou Reed had already left the band and that it was actually Doug Yule with whom he had conversed.
@@Elvin_Pelvin Lol. Yes I think Lou left in early 70’.
U have no idea how well regarded that song was in its time. (1977)
Music was our oxygen, our currency in those days.
We each knew sh*t from shinola when when we heard it.
Thank you so much for including this classic. This is a song that has been very important to me for a very long time and I probably need to apologise at the start for what I suspect is going to be a bit of a long and rambling response, but hopefully some of it may be of interest to some one!
First though, a quick point about the different single and album versions of the song. The single chops off the first two verses (diving straight into the third "dolphin" verse) and also misses some of the drama of the finale - "We are nothing and nothing can help us. Maybe we are lying; then you'd better not stay. But we could be safer, just for one day" - and personally I think it is a much weaker song as a result. I just mention that, because Peter Gabriel is performing the single version and the "is that it?" element of your response is pretty much my response whenever I hear the single version! Peter Gabriel has taken the trouble to bring together arrangement of this beautiful classic, the orchestral arrangement is lovely and his presence in the performance is, as so often with him, mesmerising. But he only gives us half a song!
I probably first heard this song about three years after it came out when I was an impressionable teenager. My brother's girlfriend had a copy of the album and I think that I was knocked out by this track the first time I heard it. I was learning how to play guitar at the time and I was amazed when I saw it in a music book and realised that it had simple chords that even I could play. I have played it ever since and as I have done so, my understanding and interpretation of it has changed. I agree with all of the things that you say about it but I also think it has many layers to it (in particular, as so often, Bowie's lyrics are multi-layered and I suspect bring together a lot of themes that were going around in that incredibly brilliant brain at the time). It is open to many different interpretations - which is probably why there are so many covers. At the moment, I tend to focus on the tender, fragile beauty of the two lovers, which I think gives us a beautiful "doomed love" theme.
And that is where I would like to add a personal theory about the lovers. I have heard several different versions of the story of the lovers, including the Tony Visconti one, and the first one was that they were two gay men, who came from different sides of the wall. I think that the power of it is that it is such a universal image that it doesn't matter. The point is that their love is real, but fragile and possibly doomed.
And that brings me to wonder about something which was going on in Bowie's life at the time, which is his relationship with a transwoman called Romy Haag, who is often described as his "muse" and whose cabaret act he brought into the video for his Berlin period single Boys Keep Swinging. There are a few places in the Berlin work where there are hints of the sorrow of a doomed relationship (for example the deep sadness of his Low single "Be My Wife"). I wonder whether, as well as their universal meaning, the lovers partly symbolise David and Romy and what, in the context of the 1970s, was a doomed love. If so, there are fascinating parallels to the tender love themes of Lou Reed's Coney Island Baby (inspired by another transwoman - Rachel Humpreys). If so, then amongst all of its other many meanings, Heroes may have a place amongst Bowie's impressive array of trans-anthems, up there with Rebel Rebel. If so, then for me as a transwoman that definitely underlines his position as one of our "Heroes".
The year this album came out I was in a helicopter tipped up on its side looking down on East German guards and their dogs. Love this song and this album.
I’ve always loved this song of course but the sheer power of it hit me during the 2012 London Olympics opening ceremony. It was played during the GB team walk on, the team walked on last as they were the host team and I don’t think there was a dry eye in the stadium. It’s worth watching on UA-cam.
Great background info! I did not know that
We have Gabriel's spin on the song and an orchestra -- I can't imagine a better cover!
To add one more to all these great covers:
Apocalyptica and Lindemann.
It's a beautifully arranged, an emotional rollercoaster, ranging from both Till's vocal vulnerability to justified anger.
They translated the lyrics to German, making it all the more fitting, and to top it off, Lindemann, being from East Germany, makes you understand just how much he knows about what this is song is about.
Peter Gabriel sings powerful songs, I love this one, and Red Rain, and San Jacinto!
What a fantastic channel this is so much knowledge, understanding and empathy for the music and such skill perfect pitch? I guess so… but we are alway greedy for more of your reviews…
Berlin era Bowie is amazing. Low, Heros, and the 3rd Lodger (no one heard of). Low is an amazing album. You cant go wrong when the inspiration comes from German bands like Tangerine Dream, Neu!, Harmonia and Kraftwerk :)
Low and Heros album and the Heros track really got a push forward with it being the Soundtrack of the Christiane F movie. (Christiane F Wir Kinder vom Bahnhof Zoo Soundtrack. Great album.)
Lodger is my favorite Bowie album ever. Yassassin, Look Back in Anger, Red Sails, Fantastic Voyage... I'll never get tired of it.
What a heart warming episode
Definitely one of my favorite Bowie songs. Hard to pick a favorite though.
More or less impossible to pick - there are so many
Bowie was always ahead of the curve!
I graduated HS in ‘77 and loved it when it came out. I was into Bowie before Genesis but not before King Crimson. I was also into Roxy Music before Genesis. Interesting how members of all have been involved here in one way or another.
Miss you beautiful Black Star ... thanks again Doug!
Excellent points about the tremendous sound quality of recordings from the 1970's. Something I notice from not only Bowie's albums from that time but many artists/bands is that they shifted to different studios and went for different approaches based-on listening to other albums from bands they liked. While I imagine this certainly goes on still, now artists/bands seem to find more of a zone and stay within it. Also, digital recordings have really impacted studio sound quality and dynamics in a very negative way, along with squashed drums and 'tinker toy' keyboard tones.
If it weren't for Robert Fripps guitar that song would not have gone as far as it has.
The Gabriel version takes everything implicit in the original and makes it explicit.
Peter sure knows how to get to the essence of lyrics and create a dramatic backdrop to the message. Gabriel brings gravitas and an earnestness that makes this song what we need today. (too short, yes)
I have attended several King Crimson shows where the band played Heroes - the best version after my opinion was done by the last line up though. Saw them in Copenhagen, same year as Bowie died - was really some kind of being reminded of this fantastic song by DB. Love Michael
That Robert fripp guitar it's amazing
Peter is smart. He knows if he did a standard cover it would always be compared to the original. Not a good idea to cover a classic tune like that. Gabriel made it uniquely his own. First heard Peters version as the end credits of a movie called Lone Survivor. Very moving.
I heard a few "glug" sounds form that glorious bottle. Cheers Doug! You have a talent that means a great deal to me. Some people have life paths that lead away from music ...but we never let go of the impact it has on us. Your perceptions are making up for our life's mistakes.
Thank you for your heartfelt words ❤️ The impact that music has on us is immeasurable.
At the end of Stranger Things S1 E3 (I think?) they play this song and holy moly. Talk about yanking on the heartstrings. I love the original but that Peter Gabriel version has some serious power. Also, yes, we need this right now. I wish everyone could take a little puff, pass it around, and listen to good music. We'd all get along so well. 😊
Thankyou for exploring this song for us in this time. I would like to add an Australian icon John Farnham with the song "The Voice" another anthem for this troubled time that would be good to explore.
Thanks for a great and intresting video as always. be safe and skilful. Pinge
In Holland Heroes was a hit from the beginning with a memorable cool performance in the popular Dutch tv program TopPop.
This studio in Berlin was called the Hansa studio's. And some other famous albums were recorded there. Songwise f.e. 'One' by U2 and also 'Lust for life' by Iggy Pop. For the latter they used the natural echo of one of the huge ballrooms to record the drums on this song.
I have a different version that starts with the dolphin verse. I love this song and still listen to it all the time. My favourite live version is David singing it at the Freddie Mercury Tribute concert with Ian Hunter and Mick Ronson accompanying him. Magic.
The single version is an edited down version which misses out the first two verses and starts with the third (dolphin) verse. It also edits out the last verse or so (which I think is the most powerful part of the song). It sounds as though you have the single version, which is on quite a few Bowie compilations. Without knocking that version, it is worth hearing the full version from the album.
When the German version is played at the end of JoJo Rabbit, I am not ashamed to say the tears welled up with joy...
I didn't think that anything would outclass its use in "Perks of Being a Wallflower". I was pleased to be wrong.
Beautiful Doug. I'm cheering you with my Bowen Island Trail Hopper IPA. I Love Heroes. I got the album when it was brand new as a gift. Christmas or birthday can't remember. And I do love the Gabriel version too. We are transfixed by it. I've been playing the song for years but I learned it from an acoustic version that Bowie did. This was a great one. It occurred to me that you might want to listen to some Kinks music and share your thoughts about some of that. Ray Davies is a brilliant song writer one of the Kings of the Kraft.
I have scanned through most of the comments and cannot see this listed. The mix that Aphex Twin did, combining Bowie with Philip Glass' orchestral version. Really well worth a listen.
1977 I was twenty nine years old Was familiar with Frip and Eno and their works together. Listen to the Eno /Gabriel version of, Here Comes the Flood. Was even into Eno Ambient with him since Roxy. Happy they came back together for Heres.
The live version from Berlin 2002 is so f'n good. What a showman.
Wow, Heroes really telegraphs Bowie's later work like Hours, Earthling and Outside... even elements of Tin Machine
PG did a whole series of these slow (deliberately drum-less) orchestral covers, the "Scratch my Back" project, where he would trade cover songs with other songwriters. You end up with some interesting trades. My favorite one of these covers is PG's version of "The Book of Love" (really worth hearing). One of the more interesting swaps was with Paul Simon -- Simon did "Biko".