The Everything-E-Ink Tablet: Boox Note Air 3 REVIEW
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 чер 2024
- This is the Boox Note Air 3, the latest 10.3 inch note-taking E-Ink tablet from Onyx Boox. At first glance, it might seem almost identical to its predecessor - the Note Air 2 Plus -, and honestly, even upon a closer look, they share many similarities.
So, the big questions are: is the Note Air 3 a worthwhile upgrade and does it live up to the legacy of its predecessor?
Let's dive in to find out who this new E-Ink tablet is designed for, what compromises you might face, and why I believe it's an excellent choice for many.
⭐ SUBSCRIBE
/ @chalidraqami
🔗 LINKS
► Onyx Boox Note Air 3 (affiliate): geni.us/sU8GUr
► Onyx Boox Note Air 3 C (affiliate): geni.us/wanrL
► Onyx Boox Tab Mini C (affiliate): geni.us/xXOXy
► Onyx Boox Tab Ultra C (affiliate): geni.us/9mV3
► Onyx Boox Note Air 3 C Review: • Jack of All Trades: Bo...
► Onyx Boox Tab Ultra C Review: • I'm Switching To Color...
► Onyx Boox Tab Mini C Review: • Compact(ish) Color E-I...
Check out the absolutely brilliant LCARS screen by meWho here: www.mewho.com/titan/
🎬 CHAPTERS
00:00 Intro
00:39 Specs, Haptics & Build Quality
04:36 Frontglass & Paperlike Screen Protector
06:06 Pen, Latency, Lag & Writing Feel
08:08 Pressure Sensitivity
09:20 Display Quality & E-Ink Modes
12:57 Frontlight Quality
14:00 Android 12 & User Interface Basics
15:29 Notetaking & AI functions
17:03 Digital Typewriter with a Bluetooth Keyboard
17:21 PDF-Functions & Split Screen
18:29 Reading Regular E-Books
19:15 Text-To-Speech Demo
20:23 E-Book Store & Web-Browsing
20:54 Google Play Store and Installing Apps
21:32 My Data Privacy Concerns
22:12 Battery Life
23:29 Conclusion
🖖WHO AM I
I'm Chalid, and I've been a fan of e-ink technology for a very long time. I've been reviewing e-ink devices since 2010. After more than 100 different e-reader tests for my German website, this channel is dedicated to sharing my experiences with the latest e-readers, other e-paper devices, and sometimes other tech in English as well.
🔗 DISCLAIMER/DISCLOSURE
The tips, tricks and experiences shared are for guidance only; any actions taken based on these are solely at your own risk. Some links in the description contain affiliate links, which means that if you buy something through these links, I will receive a small commission on a purchase at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Thank you so much for supporting the channel.
🔖 TAGS
E-Ink Carta, E-Ink Carta 1200, Boox, Boox Note Air 3, Onyx Boox Note Air 3, Boox Note Air3, Boox Note Air 2 Plus Successor, Boox Note Air 2 Successor
#boox #eink - Розваги
Appreciate your perspective on the many choices available. Thanks!
Thanks for the detail, sir.
I am hoping to get my NA 3 tomorrow. I live in a sunny country and I do want to read outside. I haven't seen any reviewers actually show this screen outside in sunlight.
Thank you for this, very helpful!
Excellent analysis.
Thank you for the review
I have the original Boox note :
Onyx Boox note 10.3 ( plastic screen ) I lost it somewhere in my house , been looking for it for the last 1 years ,finally found it today , still work , charged it and I am updating it to firmware v 3.3.2
Thanks for covering the privacy issues, one of the reasons why I'm rejecting the Scribe (the notebooks are synced with Amazon servers). Sounds as though the Boox allows you to keep everything local, though the contact with Chinese servers is worrying....
I was considering this as my next ereader because of being able to have all book apps in one device but I think I will just be overwhelmed with the options and settings. I am also not fan of the weight. I think I’ll stick with a normal ereader. Thanks for the review. 😊
"overwhelmed with the options and settings"? AMEN, brother! I got a "Max Lumi" and it is ABSURDLY complicated PLUS the manual is WORTHLESS. I can't even figure out how to transfer books from a USB drive to the thing.
Try the kindle scribe, then, and get the premium pen. It's very basic, and excellent. Reading and writing.
Thanks for the review. Does the Boox Note Air 3 support handwriting recognition and/or conversion from non-Latin alphabets, especially right-to-left ones like Arabic or Hebrew? Thx.
Hi - no sorry, there's no handwriting recognition for neither arabic nor hebrew. The following are supported: English, Chinese, Afrikaans, Azerbaijani, Belarusian, Bulgarian, Bosnian, Catalan, Cebuano, Czech, Danish, German, Greek, Spanish, Estonian, Basque, Filipino, Finnish, French, Irish, Galician, Croatian, Hungarian, Armanian, Indonesian, Icelandic, Italian, Japanese, Georgian, Kazakh, Korean, Lithuanian, Latvian, Malagasy, Macedonian, Mongolian, Malay, Dutch, Norwegian, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Russian, Slovak, Slovenian, Albanian, Serbian, Swahili, Turkish, Tatar, Ukrainian, Vietnamese
Vielen Dank für das Video. Hast du schon einmal den Google Chrome Browser getestet und kannst etwas zur Performance auf dem NA3 sagen?
Chrome selbst nicht, aber der vorinstallierte NeoBrowser sieht mir sehr nach einem Chrome-Fork aus. Ansonsten verwende ich Firefox ohne Probleme.
Die üblichen E-Ink-Einschränkungen im Hinterkopf behaltend, gibt's an der Performance aus meiner Sicht nichts auszusetzen. Den "Fast"-Mode finde ich zum Surfen am besten, weil sich Ghosting in Grenzen hält, man opfert dafür allerdings FPS und das Ganze läuft nicht so flüssig wie im "A2"-Modus.
@@ChalidRaqami vielen dank für die schnelle Rückmeldung. Diese Woche soll mein NA3 kommen. Bin schon sehr gespannt und hoffe, dass es richtig war mich gegen das NA3C entscheiden, zugunsten des Kontrastverhältnisses und der Batteriezeit 😊
I have this on order. You mentioned the rub-off on the back of the device. Don't you use a case? I have one on every device I own.
Also, regarding the pen - I have the tab mini C, and tried my kindle scribe premium pen on it and it's great. I'll probably buy one for this device. I journal on my scribe, and love the eraser feature. I'm buying this to partly use as a sketchbook. I often take classes from UA-cam or watch demos. After practicing on this e-ink device, I'll move to a hard copy sketchbook to paint.) 11:51 ❤
I use the case on and off, so that wear on the back was definitely a surprise because I didn't use it any differently than my other tablets. But if it's in the case all the time, I doubt you will have any issues with that.
What’s the Star Trek screen in the background? Love it !
I know I was like OMG love it
You can check it out on mewho.com (not made by me). Best part of making a new video is starting it up and putting it on the TV! :)
Should I get this one or wait for the Supernote A5x2, or get the remarkable 2. For uni note taking and a bit of reading
Depends on how much you intend to read. Personally I'd go for the Note Air 3 in that case, simply because of the frontlight.
If you don't need that, I'd recommending waiting for the Supernote A5X2 before making a decision. I'll do a side by side comparison of the Remarkable 2 and Supernote A5X2 when its available. But honestly, I'd say you can't go wrong with either one.
Note air 3 uses Android and has Google Play store.
Hi, I need an information asap. Does the pen come along with the tablet if i buy through Amazon??
thanks in advance
Yes
Hi Chalid, I was thinking to buy this as my first e-ink reader. I wanted this because it has Android in it which makes it much more user friendly, atleast for me. Should I go with this one? Also, I live in Oman, and by your accent, I think you live in the arab too, so is it safe to order from their site?
Hi, I think it's fine as your first E-Ink device. Just keep in mind, it's not an ereader but a tablet. So you can do a lot more with it, but might need to tinker a bit, depending on what you want to do.
As for buying it: I haven't had any problems with ordering devices from the european Boox webshop. They always ship the devices promptly and without issues. However, I still recommend getting Boox devices from Amazon or a local seller, because I've read stories about people having issues getting warranty repairs directly from Boox. With Amazon that's typically not an issue in my personal experience.
Help please! Need an e ink device asap for heavy writing and note taking purpose. I badly wanted the A5X2 to get launched but its delayed atleast till June. Cant wait that long. Boox NA3 was not in my fav list due to the distractions it has. But if it has a good writing feel (closer to pen-paper than glassy ipad one), i can consider it. Would you recommend it?
It's a good writing tablet with a good writing feel, but as you said, it has much more distractions. The Remarkable 2 comes to mind as well, but that might seem a bit outdated hardwarewise in terms of performance nowadays.
Kindle, Lenovo, Huawei, Bigme and PocketBook tablets don't offer as many note taking functions, and the Kobo Elipsa 2E's latency isn't really suitable for heavy note taking imho.
So I'd say right know either Remarkable 2 or Boox Note Air 3 are good choices for heavy users. The only thing with the Note Air 3 I found to be slightly annoying is the lag after starting to right, I mention in the video.
@@ChalidRaqami thanks for your help. Got my note air3 and so far I'm very satisfied with it.
@@Buzznor have you tried it with OneNote? If so, thoughts?
Weirdly my color doesn't have the tilt with the pen.
Does this device have the "Speech to Text" feature, which converts speech to text, like the Bigme device has?
No, not natively, but you should be able to use an Android app for that
What do you recommend then, in the same price range, of monochrome devices like this for reading/writing/daily planning? Heavy on pdf, epub, onenote?
Would you buy an Air 3 today or would you wait?
I'd get the Note Air 3 with that use case. There's really no competition in that specific field. I suspect Boox will release a Note Air 3 Plus with 300 ppi in autumn, but that's pure speculation on my part and it might be more expensive as well. So I would only wait if you don't need a device right now. Otherwise the Note Air 3 is a great choice.
As much as I LOVE Lower Decks, I do NOT plan on watching any kind of video on an e-paper device... My phone or computer are fine for that purpose. My Note Air 3 was ordered yesterday, and I plan on using it for notes, ebooks, manga, etc.
I have tried the scribe, the tab ultra (twice), the RM2 and the note air 3C.
Now I have the note 3 I know this is the one I will keep.
Why did you choose the note air3 over the note air 3c?
@@SuperNova-bq2ge I could not live with the darkness of the 3C’s screen or the shorter battery life. The colour on the 3C was underwhelming to me and the 3’s screen just seems clearer even though the resolution is less.
would netguard or nextdns help with privacy?
Partially. The problem with those apps is, that the system doesn't allow to autostart the apps. So you need to start the apps manually and until then, it might phone home.
The most reliable way I've found so far is too root it, run AFWall+ and systemize the app for autostart to work.
Where did you get your lcars wall hanging?
It's actually a TV with an "app". Check out the "Titan"-app on mewho.com (not made by me) - it's incredible!
What is the best e-ink tablet for just reading? I don't need notetaking.
Kindle paperwhite
If you want a large screen, than I'd suggest the Kindle Scribe. Otherwise the Kindle Paperwhite is a very solid choice, as @somnambulist6636 already mentioned.
Boox devices for just reading are a bit of an overkill if you ask me.
Android 12 is no longer supported as from 5 February 2024. Isn't that going to be a problem going forward? What if apps like Kindle are no longer supported?
I think you're talking about Android 11?
But either way I'd say it's not a huge deal for the near future. Apps typically support older Android versions for quite a while. If I'm not mistaken the Kindle app still supports Android 8 and they even supported Android 4.4 up until 3 years ago or so.
The main issue with Android support ending, is that it doesn't get any more security patches. But that doesn't influence app-support (directly).
Would you go for Air 3 or Air 3 C ?
Other reviewers [see My Deep Guide or Kit Betts Masters, for example] show the 3 and 3C side by side. There is quite a difference in screen brightness, with the 3 looking brighter than the 3C, such that it seems impractical to use the 3C without the front light. This alone reduces the battery life. This is because the colour screen is like an overlay over the monochrome panel and it attenuates reflected light. I have ordered the 3 as I am not impressed by the colour saturation and prefer longer battery life and higher contrast. That said, you could order both and return the one you don't choose, as there is not a big price difference!
@@impulsesystems but is it worth the difference in performance, ive seen that there is a noticeable difference in drawing latency when using the pen between the 3 and 3C since the 3C has 300ppi vs the 3 that only has 227ppi.. to me battery is very important but i think the latency will bug me like crazy
I have the same dilemma. But will be going with the 3C. The battery life is good enough for me. I will charge it everyday regardless if it can go a week or a day without. I’m not going camping with this thing (and even then a powerbank works just great). The BSR and the color just add that extra.
Yes the screen is more dark, but the benefits outweigh that con in my eyes.
@@Greye_Vernados agreed here, i think yes the battery is a con but its really the only con i can think of for the 3C which makes it easy considering the latency issues and the bad ppi on the 3.. i just ordered the 3C myself
@@impulsesystemsunless you vampire read, or can’t see in candle light. It’s no way as bad as portrayed in some of these videos. With the light set at 50 you can easily read for 24h.
Thanks for good review.. I am also concerned with Chinese server, thanks for clarifying the Air 3 contacts Chinese Servers regardless of settings..
I am AS PARANOID as you 😊
At 4:37 you start talking about the front of the Note Air 3, but mngle your comments with references to the Note Air 2 Plus - and in subsequent comments regarding the type of "glass" surface and the type of screen protector, it is unclear which tablet you are talking about. I've played it over and over and I am still confused. It is an important discussion since the whole point of the the Note Air 3 and 3 C is an emphasis on writing surface as differentiated from the Boox Tab series. Also, other reviewers have distinguished differences between the Note Air 3 and 3 C as well.
To clarify: The Note Air 3 has a paperlike screen protector that gives a good writing feel - but not exactly as good as on the Remarkable 2 imho. The glass underneath that Note Air 3 screen protector is super glossy and shouldn't be removed. And that screen protector is also not as scratch resistant as the screens on the Boox Tab series.
Maybe Boox is using multiple suppliers for those screen protectors, which is why others noticed a difference between the Note Air 3 and 3C. I honestly don't see any differences when comparing them side by side.
@@ChalidRaqami Thanks so much for getting back. I have a Scribe (and love writing on it), but I'm considering going for the Boox system, either the Tab or Note Air lines, because the system is more robust and comprehensive. But I'm unsure how the writing will feel to me - It's something you pay a lot of attention to before purchasing if that is how you are. going to use the tablet.
Would you sell note 2 ?
No, if you got a Note Air 2 or Note Air 2 Plus, I'd recommend keeping it tbh. The Note Air 3 is a great E-Ink tablet, but it isn't that much better than the 2-series imho.
Have you done any ACTUAL REAL WORLD USE videos on the NA3?? I would love to ACTUALLY see someone show the new notebook creation process?? Can someone ACTUALLY load a CUSTOM template in native format (the RM2 would be PNG) what is the native format on the NA3?? Can I add pages that then use a different TEMPLATE than the previous pages in the notebook?? Does the NA3 actually do the obvious things the RM2 doesn't do as far as SUPPORT CUSTOM TEMPLATES that aren't pdf's with their limitations? Are there any "Gotcha's" using the Kindle app? That's one of the VERY few android apps I can see using on the NA3? Can I annotate / write in kindle books?? Is the actual active writing / viewing area the same dimensions the same as the RM2? The overall device appears to be wider and shorter than the RM2. YES I have an RM2 that is disappointing / frustrating me with it's software limitations. Is the NA3 the answer or just a different set of limitations??? How do the built in microphones work? Can it pair to an external bluetooth mic? How does the audio recording work while taking handwritten notes simultaneously?
Music drives
Me crazy
Why do all these tablets come with an already outdated version of Android? Also, it’ll be useless soon when apps no longer work.
It supposedly has something to do with the drivers for the E-Ink screen and because Android isn't prepared for this screen tech. But who knows if those are the only reasons.
I don't think the Android version is a huge issue in terms of app compatibility - at least not with Android 11 or higher. The market share of Android 11 or lower is still around roughly 33% percent and it will be a long time for most apps to drop support for that portion of the market. And Google ended Android 4.4 (kitkat) support only in 2023, so ~10 years after it's introduction.
What I personally think is a bigger issue is the lack of security updates, for these tablets. I'd like to see much more frequent updates for that.
"promosm"
Is boox a serious fucking lazy company?? This seems such a small upgrade
Ok, but not. Without 300 ppm its a toy, not a tool in my eyes. But thanks anyway ❤️
Which e-ink has 300 ppi ? I dont know none
@@psykro8282 color version has 300ppi. But I disagree with your presumption about the lower ppi. Reviewed indicate it's not an issue.
@@johnrallison1876 ok thx, but i think the color one is toi expensive for not that much change, color is useless for my use.
kindle scribe has 300 ppi @@psykro8282
Yes, I just bought one 3 days ago, didnt know thay 227DPI is crazily lagging.
I don't know about the "Air" but the "Max Lumi" has what must be the most WORTHLESS manual ever written. The device itself is absurdly COMPLICATED with icons someone must have thought up while on an acid trip. Why doesn't the company make a SIMPLE do nothing BUT ebook reader. I don't need to write notes, convert text to speech, or surf the internet , etc, I just want to READ books.
It seems you have no idea why Boox exists. Buy a Kindle
@@chiquita683 If Kindle had e-ink, I would.
Though I am Austrian myself, I can't stand Austrian English! Cringeworthy!