Germany Imposes Border Controls: Can Schengen Survive?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 вер 2024
- Sign up to Brilliant for a free 30 day trial and you'll also get 20% off an annual premium subscription: brilliant.org/...
Pick up an 'Every Alliance Explained' Poster: toolong.news/c...
In this video we’ll explain what’s going on with the Schengen area, why it doesn’t seem to be working anymore, and what might happen next.
🎞 TikTok: / tldrnews
💡 Got a Topic Suggestion? - forms.gle/mahE...
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Donate by PayPal: tldrnews.co.uk...
Our mission is to explain news and politics in an impartial, efficient, and accessible way, balancing import and interest while fostering independent thought.
TLDR is a completely independent & privately owned media company that's not afraid to tackle the issues we think are most important. The channel is run by a small group of young people, with us hoping to pass on our enthusiasm for politics to other young people. We are primarily fan sourced with most of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corporations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, engaging and sharing. Thanks!
Having crossed the Polish-German border last week, I can tell you that there was just a police car and an officer watching cars drive by. I'm not sure if that counts as border control.
He looks out for brown people like in Family Guy
They check if the border has moved during the previous night.
We crossed Germany/Denmark and got stopped for control, with a French car.
It will be implemented in the coming days.
@@thomasl6912unclear implement what exactly. So what if they check? Claim Asylum and can’t do anything. At least that’s what they’ve told us before. The others already have a right to travel and EU citizenship. It’s too late. This is all just for show.
How about we defend our external borders so we can have free movement for its citizens?
And take the decision out of the hands of individual state governments. Bad actors like Hungary can ruin it for everyone else.
If the Schengen area is going to work moving forwards, the EU needs to gain control over decisions affecting the external border.
@@BoraCM"bad actor" lmao
@@バカ-l9o Sure, make fun of a 2 word phrase I said instead of having anything meaningful to say about my broader point.
Hungary is the one that want border closing
@@BoraCMHow is Hungary a bad actor?
I believe you can keep free movement inside while keeping a tough border outside
that's already happening
Except countries honestly have very weak borders. Thousands of migrants make it through Spain, through France and into the UK. That's 3 borders and 2 seas they have crossed. You'd think it would be easy to stop, but the system fails regardless.
0:28 what fucking stupied guy
Calling anixety !Thre was stabbing attcks llast week, , and germen police admitted to woleing isralie intelligence ( meana mossad )
it's too late. they let in millions of people from the worst cultures in the world and their own laws are stopping em from commiting to deportation. they would need to seriously change their human rights ruling to allow mass deportation and border enforcment through violent means.
@@jonathan2847yeah agreed , getting uniformity will be difficult
To think that just a few years ago it was Germany tut-tutting everyone about letting everyone in.
Germany: "We didn't think the leopards would eat OUR faces."
@@caravanlifenz Just saying, the vast majority still wants the borders to be open. It's just that in politics we have a rise in autocrats and those parties we voted for, from whom we would expect the opposite, are implementing more and more autocratic and borderline fascist policies.
@@maskharat yes yes just let more immigrants in
@@maskharat There is literally nothing fascistic or autocratic about enforcing strong borders. It's simply a basic necessity of the nation state. People want free movement for EU citizens within the EU, the schengen area is great, but nobody wants anyone and everyone to be able to get in without any proper procedures or background checks, but that's whats been happening for a long time now and people are sick of it. We could have kept the schengen area strong if we had a strong external border, but the political class didn't care because they're rich enough that it doesn't effect them and they don't want to admit they've made a massive and irreversible mistake that could end the EU as we know it.
@@caravanlifenzthe arabs *
Not Swedish gangs, but “Swedish” gangs. How can we solve a problem if can’t openly talk about it?
This channel is part of the problem. Whenever a right-wing party wins he mocks it.
What's the beef between sweden and denmark? We talking old viking rivalries??
@@Swiplys The gangs would rather resemble Saracens then Vikings if you are after a medieval setting.
Yeah I can imagine these blue eyed, blond hair teenagers be like "wtb going to denmark to break some stuff?"
@@robertmusil1107 That's because you're all clowns
"Swedish gangs"
As if we don't know what is it.
I see them roam IKEA all the time
Islam / is / boom.boom
Say it then
😂They are Swedish, nationality is different from ethnicity right? Sweden let them in and gave them a place to stay, you get what you sow
Vikings?
Or am I 1100 years too late?
If we protected the external borders...
All it takes is one uncooperative country.
And there's already at least one thumbing their nose at Brussels.
@@Veritas.0 it's no uncooperative . italy wants to use the force for immigration ? it gets sanctioned till oblivion for doing the right thing then the EU comes up with a "redistribuation plan" but i do not want to see more immigrants from italy to europe that's a disaster for italy and europe . I would like to see immigrants from italy deported to africa and asia with bans for especific countries like pakistan or morocco and then immigrants deported from europe to africa and asia
@@Veritas.0 Yep they are basically saying fuck you to brussels and sending them all there. As a Belgian I don't go to Brussels anymore and pretty much every female living in this country would agree that its not a place where you can walk alone at night anymore.
@@deswill2737 dont for for leftist then.
schengen abolished those borders
"teenagers" and "Swedish nationals" are clear euphemisms of migrants.
Hmm.
it's actually Danish gangs seeking out random swedes via social media, where indeed a lot of the teenagers have ethnically Swedish parents, and where a big issue is how amateurish this consistently means that they are, since it means a lot more injuries in their attempt at crime, is what I can say after having read the two sources cited by the politico article cited by TLDR
The words "Migrant, Migrant-related" and "Crimes" is highly condemnable by ignorants who think neither have anything in common, when in fact the brutal truth is it does. People can choose to remain ignorant for years to come, and crime issues in Sweden and Germany will never be fixed.
Migrants is also a euphemism for invaders.
see also urban, youth, etc
It was AFD gaining decent votes that forced them to do it .... could've done all of that before but by doing it rn gives a win for the AFD narrative
yes
They have to be realistic, that being imposing such controls. If not, they will be wiped away next year no doubt. Even worse than the polls show right now.
what narrative? you mean that everything parties like AfD warned about turned out to be true? not even a big fan of AfD but this whole „giving into their narrative“ is just dumb
Well, Germany hasn't changed since 1945, it would be best if the border in the east was with Russia and the refugees were locked in camps... That's what the Germans think
The people have voted 🗳️
I’m just surprised their gov. actually listened. That’s almost never the case when it comes down to immigration
The assumption was that migrants were all economically valuable people. Having the skills and talents to add economic value. However, most of the migrants did not have the necessary skills for a modern developed economy. They became more of a drain on resources rather than adding resources.
You think that was the assumption, it was never about economics. Tikkun olam and the position of the eternal schemers in our lands, this is the reason.
@@col.barnsby8595 Anti-semite spotted.
@@col.barnsby8595economics was the sole reason. The beauraucrats were too lazy to reform social security and to take a temporary economic hit, so instead they kept arguing for importing more workers to fund social security through taxes. Its just sheer fucking laziness in governing.
Because historically they usually were economically valuable people. I'm speaking from my experience in eastern Germany (formerly DDR) where I grew up. Many guest workers from Vietnam, Turkey or the Soviet Union (like my parents) joined and stayed here, even if not necessarily skilled, at the very least motivated, dedicated and hard working. They build a new existence with their own hands, established their own businesses and integrated legally into a joint society we all call home. That's hardly the case with the recent influx of "migrants" hanging around while the life support keeps flowing. To the detriment of the very few migrants that are actually trying, well meaning individuals.
@@HansWurst-lg1ws the newcomers also vacation in the countries they flee from
1:49 "gradual abolition of Czechs" scary
Scholz thinks they're just Sudeten Germans.
😅
Reminds me of the Austrian painter that a century ago had similar ideas. :P
average german policy
Sudetenland ist deutsch. Get ready.
Germany will do literally anything, but solve the issue where it starts. ON THE OUTSIDE BORDERS. ON THE SEAS. Instead theyll happily endager the entire idea of Schengen and EU like freedom of movement of goods and people, pretending the issue is Czechia, Austria, Poland, Danes...and not hundreds of thousands of little swimmers in Med sea.
I mean, Germany also wouldn't be having so many issues with refugees (which are less about crime, btw, and more about administrative backlogs, lack of housing and funding, poor integration, difficulties deporting rejected asylum seekers, etc.) if the EU as a whole could agree on a fair and equal distribution of refugees across all member states. I think trying to pin this on a single country is missing the point. It's an EU-wide issue that needs EU-wide solutions.
@@neon-kitty How do you fairly distribute tens of millions of migrants?
lets not forget that it was actually the Germans who started this whole mess, or at least took it to whole different level, when they- thanks to Mrs Merkel- unilaterally decided the EU external border, and related EU agreements and regulations, is a joke and invited millions of migrants to walk thru Balkan and across borders of dozen sovereign states to get their social housing and welfare paychek in Germany...
@@BobCassidy send them all to pro-migrant countries. That would be fair.
@@BobCassidy I'm talking strictly about refugees, not migrants in general. Because refugees you legally have to take in. Non-refugee migrants, that's kinda up to each member state's individual discretion. And you distribute refugees fairly by making each country accept the same amount proportionate to its population. I.e. if the EU consisted of two member states, country A with a population of 100 million and country B with a population of 10 million, and there were 1 million refugees entering this two-country EU, then country A would need to accept roughly 909,000 of these refugees and country B roughly 91,000.
When Greece and Italy protect their borders, European politicians blame them for "pushbacks". If Germany wants tight border control, then allow Greece to turn migrant boats back to Turkey. If Turkey disagrees, send the migrants to Libya, to Syria.
Greece has suffered long enough from migration, and Balkan migration route is closed and will remain closed....
also arrest all these NGOs who pick people up in the mediterranean and bring em to european ports. force "rescuers" to go to the southern ports or face Human trafficking charges.
It's not the same people who say these opposing things. I'm from northwest Europe and always thought you guys should have been about to send anyone back, even resort to more drastic measures if necessary.
@@ISAACcookie This NGO need to lose EU citizenship, and let them life in 3rd world countries
You cannot wall the sea. You cannot stop people from entering.
@@PossibleBat agree , but you can guard the coastline and anyone who enters is arrested, and should be deported immediately.
Migrants should think twice before travelling to Europe...
Schengen is working nicely for the people who it was designed for, EU citizens.
Agreed
Not anymore it's not.
schengen is working too well for those not in the eu legally.
As a "legal" EU citizen I wouldn't mind showing my ID to a police officer when crossing a border and I'd still be free to cross it. So, if these new, easy border controls can curb down illegal immigration and be a nuisance to e.g. drug traffickers, I don't have objections.
@@jfrancobelge There's always people who cross the border everyday and also trucks for which I assume would be a hassle to keep being stopped.
We shall see if we can implement a good system that will at the same time cause as little inconvenience as possible.
First, criticize countries defending external EU borders over pushbacks, call use of force a "human rights violation". Then throw a tantrum because the illegals that got through ended up in your country.
Exactly
I feel like this is Germany 2021 to today in a nutshell. You can look at any topic, russia, relations with Poland, France, UK, US, the nuclear power plants, gas, coal, etc. I think Merkel leaving just broke them lol.
@@2727daqwid honestly Merkel was the same. She turned on quite a lot of Points. (Nuclear Energy and Health Coverage Reforms for example) It just didnt get that much global attention for some reason. My Guess would be there is more of a focus on germany since the far right is growing and people get nervous.
Pushbacks ARE human rights violations. It's clearly defined in Geneva Convention. Problem is racism, not the immigrants.
@@InTimeTraveller Not all Immigrants are good because of the culture, ideology, willing to work instead of living off the welfare system like a parasite, or religion where they look down Apon others because of there religion/views or their sex. But the left leaning Politicians look the other way because they keep bringing up race as a factor nothing else. So Racism is a extremely small factor is involved.
'swedish nationals' yeah right
Lol I know. And the line, "we are not saying mass migration is bad". Totally mental lefty brain
Were they not born in Sweden??
@@Amberxxbbunni that does not completely make you Swedish
@@Amberxxbbunniyeah his point is they are only swedish on paper.
@@padishahemperor708yep, deport
"Swedish gangs"
Mohhamad Knutssen 😂
"Swedish "
Ah yes, the Swedish gangs patrolling the Stockholm streets since 1880
They're still Swedish
@@thomastakesatollforthedark2231 There's always one
Can't these politicians just say no to mass migration and illegal migration and stop with their PC nonsense.
No, because they need cheap labour and new "loyal" voters.
@jeffgoldman1735 UK OBR report of that just came out shows that low skilled migrant labour costs the UK tax payer money. And that was just for individual workers with no dependents.
@@jeffgoldman1735stop with your Trump shit. Migrants can't even vote
Don't you think that's a little too easy to say?
Point 1: If you say A, then you must say B. If you're the cause for major pollution and a main cause for global warming (what the EU is) then you must deal with the consequences of "illegal migrants" fleeing to europe because europe is partially responsible for the people losing their homes.
Point 2: There is no such thing as "illegal migration", you can not expect fleeing people to first be able to understand the required documents for legal immigration, second to have the time to wait for local and european authorities to validate and accept the needed documents while you're fleeing your country.
Third, at least in germany, there is no major political party who doesn't want to stop "illegal mass migration" caused by fleeing people, not even the most left party out there.
Forth, the pseudo excuses used for tighter boarders to stop fleeing people ("bad foreigners") are missunderstood crime statistics and succesful populism by right wing media (they provide simple pseudoanswers for complicated problems additionally, many people don't have the knowledge or time to understand these complex problems).
Fifth, the reason many misunderstand the crime statistics is because the crime statistics list up reported suspects for minor crimes and not prosecuted criminals, they also list up the "bad foreigners", tourists and more while only listing up germans as the counterpart. Oftentimes people who don't look german get reported more often for the same crime compared to their german looking counterpart, additionally racisme still plays a major and measurable part in european structures.
This is only a small list and I am sure I didn't express myself clearly, so if you got any questions or unsure of what I was trying to say, feel free to ask.
@@dd-di3mz 1. They aren't coming because of Pollution. They're coming because of teh Arab spring and economic opportunities.
2. Yes there is such a thing as illegal immigration. We can fully expect people to follow the law. Again the ones arriving to teh UK illegal are "fleeing" they're economic migrants. They are arriving from France, France is a safe country, they risk their lives in the channel and some unfortunate drown. That is the polar opposite of seeking saftey, they are going quite literally going into danger. Because they believe their are economic rewards onbthe other side.
3. Germany has done a terrible job with migration and now they are paying for it. Their country is getting less safe, it's why AfD has done so well, not that I agree with most of their policies. Look at Sweden 20% of theor country are migrants or decendants of migrants. They went from the safest country in Western Europe to the most dangerous. Now with left and right see the problem there. Denmark and Poland saw the issue straight away and dint have the same issue. Well Denmark has some as the crime wave is coming across from Sweden. Immigration has to be managed to be successfully, this open boarders, little background checks and illegal and mass immigration policy is harming Europe. This is why so called far eight parties are on the rise. When it shouldn't even be a far right policy, it should be a common sense one.
4. Incorrect crime has gone up where they publish the statistics. In the UK we don't even publish crime by nationality which says it all, you can look at the prison statistics though and certain groups are far higher per population size than others. Even without the increase in crime. Low skilled labour costs the tax payer in countries with high public services like the UK. Countries also have the right to not want people who have antithetical values like many from the ME and NA have.
5. Nonsense PC Apologetics. Also are the religious attacks that seem to be happening in Germany all too often being done by Germans? Where the marches against secularism filled with native Germans?
Schengen is amazing, we have to focus on keeping the external border instead, that's where this problem begins
I don't see what everyone is afraid of by reintroducing borders. Scan your ID card or passport and you're through, what's the big deal? It literally only takes a minute or two.
Keep the muslims out....and Germany wouldnt need to do this.
did you watch the video? they just said how organized swedish gangs are committing crimes in denmark
@@caseypenkSwedish gangs=Syrians,Turks,Afghans and Kurds
@@caseypenk yeah, I did. However, these Swedish gangs seem to be of predominantly non-Swedish ethnicity, don't they?
So are we agreed now slam migration is bad for countries as the cultures don't align?
more of a work thing, all this time they were provided benefits to help find work but some work for migrants is off the books, meaning no return in the form of taxes so this economic gamble failed
It's funny to see leftists suddenly turn into what they called "Nazis". Isn't it?
Hungary: - I'll defend my southern border against illegal immigrants.
EU: - Sounds like sanctioning time.
Germany: - I restore border control everywhere.
EU: - Ok boi.
I think a lot of these border controls are kinda silly.
You wouldn't impose border controls within your own country if people from one region committed crimes in another.
For migration the EU has to act together. If you want less refugees to come to Germany for example it's not going to help to keep them in Austria. Irregular migration has to be stopped earlier at the External border of the EU.
it's the same as them enforcing gun laws upon shengen as a responce to the Paris terror attacks. They were cause by weak borders with importet guns by Muslim migrants. but they can't admit their fuck up so just punish the citizens.
classic EU move, better make things worse than actually adressing the issue.
Nah, you could do that. Iirc, in the USSR, people could only travel across the country only if they had a passport. Otherwise, they couldn't leave their region.
It would be extremely stupid and expensive to do something similar in any modern European country though. And it would fuel "15 minute city" conspiracy people.
@@Yorick257 Yes you could but basically no one in a developed country would ever actually propose implementing something like that.
@@ninjam77 You missing this point. Germany has shitty internal polities, what turned them into migrant haven. Like you get money from government even if you are there illegally! Like WTF! Germany refused to solve the problem and was trying dump it on other EU members, when refusing to support or sometimes downright sabotaging (for "humanitarian" reasons) border countries, what actually did try deal with this.
For comparison, criticized for they migration politics Poland. Reveal to be one of more pro-migration countries. But it is because they actually have rational migration politics, so they do not suffer on same internal stability problems as Germany.
It is also happening in countries like Uruguay, Paraguay, Costa Rica and Colombia with immigration. The same thing happened in the United States and their people do not care about the problems of Mexico, Cuba, Venezuela and Latin American countries, both Democrats and Republicans do not care about having immigration reform and the problem is that immigration is such a big problem for the United States that Americans unfortunately support a mass deportation of immigrants from all over the world including black, Asian, indigenous, white and Hispanic Americans. They support that policy, unfortunately we do not have money to support immigrants coming to the country we cannot even take care of Americans living in poverty, inequality, crime, racism, problems with the criminal justice system and the health system. The same thing happens with American territories seen as second class citizens. And also it is not only Haitians and Central Americans but also Cubans and Venezuelans who have a political, social and economic crisis that is happening there in those countries. But do not emigrate to Chile or the United States, Brazil, Canada, Peru and Mexico, those countries have many problems migrating to countries like Uruguay, Paraguay, Guyana, Trinidad and Tobago, Belize, Suriname, Costa Rica and Panama. There is now a program so that migrants, when they show up at the border between the United States and Mexico, can apply or can be taken to go to Spain, Italy and Canada between those governments. In the future, if Cuba, Bolivia, Honduras, Peru, Nicaragua, Haiti and Venezuela fall into chaos, unrest, civil war or collapse, many refugees will migrate to Jamaica and other countries in the Caribbean and Latin America and the migration crisis will be worse than the other waves of Cubans in the region. And, the entire world. Immigration is always being used as a weapon. And Bolivians, Hondurans, Cubans, Nicaraguans, Venezuelans, Haitians and Peruvians will also have to migrate to places like the Dominican Republic, Belize and other places in Latin America and the Caribbean or European countries if the United States, Canada, Mexico, Chile and Brazil close their doors to immigration from the region in the future.
5:33 "Germany's other neighbours including [...] Slovakia, Hungary, Slovenia, [...] Croatia"?
Did you use a map from early 1941? 🙃
Ai helps write the script for this channel.
lol soon as he said hungary i did a double take wondering which part of germany has a border with hungary
Neighbour =/ bordering
the boy is lying, nothing of what he said is true, Dane here and i just traveled in and out germany and nothing of this is true.
@@NAYRUthunder99 No one says that France is a neighbour to Netherlands.
Oh yes, the legendary Swedish gangs
"Swedish" gangs, not that there's much Swedish about them.
Schengen was based on the idea that internal borders are abolished, whilst doubling down on external border protection.
that sounds like the "concept of a plan", because look at Frontex's budget and staff to protect an entire continent...
This was inevitable…
Maybe, but you don't want to know how many supposedly clever people I have seen saying that any type of border controls are impossible and economical suicide. As if trade pre-Schengen did not exist.
Too many isis attck
Not to mention the 2 millon relgiues turkish muslim
It was perfectly avoidable if they made these decisions 15 years ago
*Strengthen* and *Enforce* the *Outer Collective Border!*
The only reason is migration. Not really sure how you can frame it any other way.
you underestimate the mental gymnastics that the European left capable off. It's probably cause of capitalistic greed or online hate speech, better crack down on that.
@@ISAACcookie you Wish that was the case
@@ISAACcookie Online hate speech should be cracked down as much as possible, no doubts about that
@@ISAACcookie It's already in this thread. They're calling it racism. The same countries that allowed all kinds of people in freely and gave them a tremendously expensive welfare net to support them, and now that they've given their all and want to pull back on the flood. It's racism... not generosity.
There will never be enough in their need, no line is inviolate, no more or ethic strict, no sacrifice too great to give to them. Progressivism allows no pause in the advance of their goals.
@@ISAACcookieno it’s because of economic development, or lack there of.
It’s already hard enough to find jobs, but bringing in hundreds of thousands of migrants without creating the proper incentives that allow job creators to employ them is the real problem. It’s economics, not migration, that is the issue.
just close the EU borders and stop leting them in
yea, shengen is fine when it is white only
Poland calling Germany's decision unacceptable is pretty ironic...
Orban should take Germany to ecj and echr. 😂
The real irony is wanting to keep EU external borders open for non EU citizens, while enforcing internal borders for EU citizens. In my humble opinion that is :/
@@VTh-f5xha ha, he should not be around any judge.
@@albertmaterski1059 The external border of tjhe EU are not 'open' as you claim. But there is an issue with properly guarding that border and dealing with the many would-be immigrants.
@@kimwit1307 true, for the record I'm not against accepting the refugees, I just don't understand the approach of german govt, it seems disengenous to me at best.
Swedish gang in Denmark ??? Trust me those gang members are not Swedish native's !!!!!
Hungary and Poland: We have border control
Germany: nO tHaTs iS rAcIsMuS!!!1
Hungary and Poland: But you just imposed border controls!
Germany: iTs oKaY wHeN wE dO iT
stupid leftis govermnent..
Rules for thee not for me 🗿
"We are not saying mass immigration is bad".. thanks, i spit out my coffee.
I’ve been saying for years. The Schengen area is unsustainable with the migration policies imposed by Brussels. Brussels shot themselves in the foot.
Ah yes the infamous """"Swedish""""" gangs...
You are using the wrong echos, use this ((())). But nice try with antisemitic dog whistle.
Wtf are these “swedish gangs” ? Call them properly
They got all dem melanin, they are filthy rich
"Swedish gangs hire teens to murder people in Denmark". Read this sentence. Think about it. Think about what it means. That is the answer to the question: "Can Europe keep open borders?".
Stop Swedish people from entering Denmark? What are you saying?
@@Joey-ct8bm the thing is they're not swedes
“””Swedish””” gangs
Maybe Europe should keep a common police force with the open borders, so those criminals can't benefit from the borders any more?
Europe either gets federal, or it will disappear from the maps in a decade!
@@Joey-ct8bm "Swedish gangs" migrant islamic gangs "hire teens" hire migrant teens "to murder people in Denmark" to murder Danish people.
It's very convenient to talk about others keeping their boundaries open - just until the problem comes to you. First Brussels scolded Greece and Italy, now it is scolding Hungary, although it is not only Hungary that closes its borders. And most importantly, no one wants to recognize the problems and their sources - uncontrolled migration and criminality among migrants, the unwillingness of a huge number of them to assimilate
Hungary literally does not close its borders, it happily lets in people to destabilize the EU.
‘Refugees’ can just cross border freely where working immigrants must apply for visas to be able to work is craaazzzyyy..
All they had to do was properly police the external borders. But that would have required shared resources and cooperation so it didn't happen. So the whole idea fails.
THe Brussels plan was to let these migrants in
And a reform of the laws of the countries with outer borders as German soldiers or police officers are not allowed to operate in other countries. Once district of Germany once already wanted to do something similar with a Polish district but the Polish government was against it. Also why should Poland accept German soldiers if it could accept German money which they could use otherwise?
Germany just reaps what it sow. Remember their very own Angela Merkel's "Willkommen Migranten!" back in 2015?
do you remember the human situation at the time? Russia bombing Syrian cities to the oblivion, France and UK bombing Libya, approaching families with elderly, kids an babies, captsized boats in the mediterranian, leaving thousands of deperate people dead on trial to Europe. Winter at the doorstep, nobody really caring. I'm still with Merkel at that point. Losing control afterwards is a different story. There Europe as a whole has failed.
And now those aren't Syria's problem, they're Germany's terror attacks and grooming victims.
It was thought as a once in a time measure to get the camping refugees off of trainstations in Austria. It was only planned as a stop gap measure until camps were built in Europes border regions. Unfortunatelly the EU kept argueing about, what the height of compensation from the inner countries to the other countries should be and if and how to distribute migrants when the border camps get full. Mrs Merkel always tried to get a deal about theese issues, but failed.
@@augustiner3821Are you German?
@@DukeOfTheYard yes
Germany introducing border checks with Czechia and Poland because Germany became scared of Syrian and Afghan immigrants was really not on my bingo card :D
Also, good job on finally pronouncing Czechia correctly! Thank you, it means a lot ❤
I mean when you have hundreds of thousands of them coming over, more than half young, unskilled men, you’re asking for trouble.
@@TheJosephPrice Coming over because Angela Merkel invited them and tried to force other countries to accept them. Luckily other countries ignored Germany.
neither Poles nor Czechs wanted these guys, the Germans invited them so they should deport them
Non-criminal migrants don't deserve to be grouped in with criminal migrants, especially since what motivates these disadvantaged youths is their lack of integration within a supportive community. Freedom of movement is a human right.
Well, I'm not surprised. First the problems were ignored, then after a Syrian protest turned antisemitic and with Nazi salutes Germany started to close their eastern borders. Meanwhile, Germany keep having problems with Dutch and Belgian Moroccans committing crimes like blowing up ATMs. So now with more Russian agents active in Germany causing unrest, pro-Palestinian antisemitic semites, thriving cross-border crime, the faltering German industry and a new wave of Islamic terrorism (because Muslims radicalize when the economy goes down) was the final nail in the coffin. Germany won't kill Schengen single-handedly. People have voted more pro-Russian. Extreme left or extreme right, leading to the Netherlands and France closing all their borders as well (Netherlands for immigration, France for left-wing protectionism) and countries closing their borders around Hungary, meaning only Poland and the Baltic states only have open borders. To finish it all off, Russia is sending a fertilizer ship bomb from Norway to the Lithuanian LNG terminal, destroying their energy independence. Unless NATO is finally able to stop facilitating Russian weapons in and over their backyards and stop Russian active measures!
If Schengen area disappears, then Jet Lag the game will be more difficult to play tag across Europe 😢
In the first series, one of the destinations was in the uk, so border checks would have been required. They would probably extend the playing time to compensate.
The coming 10 years will be decisive in determining whether the EU progress across different areas of the last 30 years last or collapse into nothingness.
"Swedish gangs" - you're showing your ideological colours, TLDR......
That poster is 40 euro’s total with shipping to the Netherlands, absolute scam 😭
Border tariffs.🤣
also the new borders tarriefs 🤣
one would expect them to have an EU warehouse, given how many EU viewers they have...alas
its very clear that the schengen agreements were designed to help europeans with EU passports freely move between the major countries on the continent. NOT for anyone that manages to get into Italy, Hungary, Poland, or other border nations, to have free passage anywhere they want.
No.
The whole point is there no border check or passport required.
@@julianshepherd2038 within the schengen. Border checks into the schengen countries from non schengen countries should be fair game.
That's why we have built a wall on a border with Belarus in Poland. It was common sense, it was necessary and as far as I remember... it was used as a political weapon to call us different names. In my personal opinion, European countries should cooperate in this matter, work together to make the external borders stronger. But is seems that we are still too divided for that and it will be the main cause of our potential downfall as a continent with such competitors as China.
@@wojownikwody1804 You're right, in fact this wall should have been financed by EU
@@wojownikwody1804Which is why Russia funds so many anti-EU parties and people. A stronger EU is the only way to get the EU border under control, because lots of countries are unwilling to do it themselves.
Germany a few years ago: All immigrants are invited
Germany now: We're closing the border, rest of you should deal with this mess
😅😅😅
Based Germans lured in the fertiliser for their soil
Solution: We need an EU police force, or at least fluent communication between national polices. A crime committed in an EU country is a crime committed in the EU.
I agree.
We have that, it's called Europol
@@hyperteleXii Europol is very limited in what they can do.
They need to stop hamstringing FrontEx. A lot of this crime wouldn’t have existed if migrants weren’t allowed in Europe.
And who might fund that? Easy to find solution. Much harder to find how to finance that solution.
You can't have open borders unless you can protect the external border. Since we have failed with that for decades, we now must reimplement the internal borders. Mass migration from violent cultures and Russian agents roaming freely is not working anymore.
Quote unquote “violent cultures” yikes thats a far right dogwhistle
This is so fucked up. Calling ukranian refugees „russian agents“ and Afghan women „violent“ speaks volumes about your worldview.
Islamism is not fought, by driving as deep of a wedge between „us“ and „them“ as possible, but by targeted security and integration measures.
Sending a Syrian family back to austria won‘t do shit for German security. Quite the contrary. Budgets for integration measures are stripped in Germany, while at the same time German security forces are getting the burden to guard one of the longest landborders in europe. Ressources are wasted, that could be spent so much better.
This post is intentionally misleading, do not trust it.
@@vaclavkokes6236no its fucking not and treating it as such feeds into the far right.
@@Darkurge666 can Greece turn boats full of migrants back to Turkey and Libya? Because that's the external border of EU.
Didn't Hungary try to close it's border and Germany said no?!
Ah yes, 'Swedish,' gangs...
TL:DR Schengen will NEVER fall. The economic implications are so incredibly high, they are just trash talking and imposing empty threats as always.
Schengen fixes so many problems and gives Europe our strong internal economy, this is something Europe can't go without ever again.
So stop importing non-Europeans
I have croossed the borders between France ande Germany and France and Spain multiple times recently, I have never seen any kind of border controls, not even a single police car.
i crossed Germany and Czech border twice in 1 week and got controlled twice. I think the border control is on the west side
That makes sense for Germany but I think that for France it's just random. Not strict border controls.
No, Romania is not in Schengen because that free airspace movement is nothing. We would be in Schengen IF there would be no border checks with Hungary. Our economy would boom. We would not be second class citizens. Greece would be connected with mainland Europe.
Hungary is supporting you, pal, in joining.
I understand that you'd like Romania become fully a part of Schengen, but you're at least EU citizen and I doubt that border controls are so strict to you like for "third" country's citizens. For example, I had to stop every morning on Croatian border when I went to work there, give my passport, work permission and sometimes get my things checked (imagine your water bottle beeing opened to check for alcohol).
@@brato5270As Flavius mentioned it's not the no border checks for the EU citizens where Schengen shines, but the free movement of goods which helps boost the economy. It is that aspect of the Schengen which Romania is denied. Thus us feeling like second class citizens.
@@FelhasznaloAltalanos-ip6du
So Hungary and Poland as aren't getting along but Hungary is supporting Romania?
We really are living in the upside down.
@@pinkdiamond1847 Yes.
Search for "Romania’s Land Border Schengen Accession Priority for Hungary, Foreign Minister Says"
Honestly the border controls are not that catastrophic for EU citizens and regular migrants.. It's annoying and inconvenient to be stopped at the border, but you can still travel, life, and work everywhere you want
it doesnt have to be inconvenient
Its not about EU citizens, its about business and logistics.
@@mcsroom8930 good, if its not about eu citizens and its reintroduction for time being helps to calm the situation, curb this migration chaos and prevent even just few of those horrible crimes, I as a eu citizen im all for it.
The movement of people isn't the real drag -- though I don't enjoy it --it's the movement of goods. Border controls mean days of time added to freight shipments, which is expensive.
Yeah sure bud, the train to Malmö from Copenhagen takes 2x as long. Commuting has in large part decreased due to this
Turns out Fortress Europe only works if you don't leave the front door wide open.
Been in one of these German border controls recently. It was close to midnight at a small local border point at the German-Swiss border. About 10 vehicles were waiting to *exit* Germany and were held for half an hour. 5 vehicles were *entering* Germany during that time and none of them was held.
Now, one might mention that the 10 vehicles were Swiss, the ones entering were all German. Explanation from the border guard was “We have an immigration problem”.
I was trying to point out that we were all trying to *leave*, and that people with the right to live in Switzerland generally didn’t fancy illegal immigration to Germany but he just didn’t care.
Your story doesn't make sense, because Swiss customs officers are responsible for entering Switzerland. What could be happening is that someone was wanted.
@@nettcologne9186 You’re wrong. Both states have the right to control any vehicle entering or leaving at land border points. A state may want to control an exit point to prevent smuggling or to catch a criminal.
I cross this border every single day, there is no restriction on who they control.
Actually, a border patrol is even allowed to enter the other state when in hot pursuit. (There is probably a limit to how far in they’re allowed to go, I guess 20-30 kilometres as the crow flies)
this is the actual goal and i've seen it too along the border.
Germany doesn't really care about keeping them in France or Poland cause in the end it's still an EU problem. but if they can shove them into switzerland then they don't have to bother with the issue.
Italy refuses to take back migrants that entered the country through them and now germany refuses their entry. They are more than willing to fuck over switzerland if given the chance, we have been a thorn in their side for ages, and if they can reduce the pressure while doing so then that is perfect.
@@venanziadorromatagni1641 Checking cars leaving Germany for Switzerland is anything but routine at that border.
"If you're brown, show your papers" seems pretty reasonable tbh.
"Swedish nationals" is code for Afghan or Somali.
Many of the organised criminals also come from the Balkans. I will never understand the mindset of these leftist liberals. I could of told them, do not let mafia gangsters from Albania or Serbia into your country. Mafia has destroyed many places in the Balkans and left common people in poverty. Like Mafia in Sicily went to New Jersey in the US. Now Serbian mafia is in New York, Albania mafia is in London, Turkish mafia in Germany.
You know we can't have nice things for long, bad people always come over, abuse and destroy them...
These border controls that are being talked about are more like spot-checks. Not every car gets stopped, unlike a classic border control checkpoint with non-Schengen countries. Just thought I'd add that.
So nothing new, the same was during covid and sometimes they’ve done this before randomly
>closes borders
>invites a quarter million kenyans
They're edging the AfD majority vote
You can still visit Shengen area. ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS are not allowed to come to Germany.
"Swedish gangs"
They certainly aren't ethnically swedish lololol
Danish gangs,
ethnically Swedish teens (and sometimes adults) not actually in the gang scene being offered loads of money on social media
Basic 5 minute research
@@aliothspectranet5678 barbara specter?
Some countries never invaded anyone so have no obligation to take anyone in.
Exactly. The “guilt” doesn’t have to be distributed through the EU.
@@Jakjakattack Kinda. It depends if you’re willing to secede conquered territory.
@@Jakjakattack so basically you want your cake and to eat it as well. Welcome to reality… can’t scream “forget about it” when you’re not willing to give back what’s not yours lol.
@@Jakjakattack borders aren’t real. So if you keep the integrity of a colonized border, you are an oppressor - even if you are the child of those that colonized. It’s because you are upholding it. It’s not even a guilt trip, it’s just a fact.
so what if did? the countries where the trash is coming from have a long history of invasion and attmepting to attack Europe. They are owed nothing.
So let me get this straight, members states can collectively deny Russians and Belarusians European entry by applying penalties to Hungary, but cannot collectively stop accepting African and Muslim migrants who caused this internal European distress in the first place ?
Please someone explain to me why European member states don’t unite against the common “enemy” but instead they turn against each other ?
You think immigrants are putting more stain on europe then an active warzone?
You are too smart for this since you don't eat the ideological g-boyslop (w/o b-). This question will never be answered openly because it puts the whole thing under scrutiny (how dare you suggest that we don't care about our people? All those who cross the border are our people too! What is our people even? This term is very problematic!), it's easier just to dismiss it, censor it, etc.
Because EU is controlled by Washington and is not following the real interests of European people. Russia has to be weakened. But why stop accepting African migrants? Those migrants are destabilizing and weaking the EU which is good for the US. The US wants Europe to be an extension of their terriroty and weaponry but not to be an economical rival.
because of the left. They love these Muslim aggressive, entitled, migrant men.
Because they're stupid out of touch rich people who care about looking like they're doing the right thing not actually doing the right thing.
Germans, don't dare to limit the eu citizens freedom of move! It was your "Wilkommen politik" that aided all the imigrants. Send your help to the EU border, Grece, Hungary,Italy,... Do not ever threaten the european unity!
If you invite unwelcome guests to your house you need to start locking the inside doors. Stop inviting guests and you can move freely and safely inside your house
What is needed is better control of the EU's external borders (mostly of the south and east), a way to prevent the border countries from having to carry the burden of this by themselves (Frontex is a start) and to get a proper process in place (and make sure everyone adheres to it) to deal with the immigrants in a way that is fair to all memberstates. Considering the politcal divide on this, that's not an easy thing.
We really need EU wide border controls
we have it , EU border are closed to non EU countries
Allow Greece Italy and Spain to return boats full of migrants back to Africa, or back to Turkey then.
@@user-uf1uq4yn1q hi , please study . this has nothing to do with the EU or the single countries.
That can only work if you also deport the already settled migrants in millions.
@@thedude9014 supposedly.
Why do some people in Europe express discomfort or disagreement with individuals from a religious group known for promoting peace, particularly when those individuals hold views that conflict with LGBTQ rights and feminist principles?😮
bot
"individuals from a religious group promoting peace" not sure which rock you've been living under. Individual Muslims may promote peace but Islam is not peaceful.
@@generaltom6850 brother, it seems like it was a sarcastic comment...
Your reminder that there are more muslim countris than EU countries that have a woman as a head of state at the moment
It’s something like the top 14 designated religious terror grouped are affiliated to one specific religion 🤔 and also a recent crime survey said Bradford was now only one spot ahead of Damascus and behind Bogotá and Mexico City 😂 2 city’s that are scenonimous with cartels crime for decades
Funny thing is this:
-They are in the middle of schengen
- the people are there because they invited them,
-they bullied nations who protected the schnegen bordera
Push-backs should be legalized as they are necessary to protect Europese borders.
Germany can never be trusted.
Perfidious Germania.
Calling the migrant gangs 'swedish' is just lazy.
They ARE Swedish
@@thomastakesatollforthedark2231 only by document, not by heritage; which is unfortunately an important difference.
@@TheZett but they are still Swedish gangs
@@TheZett Fascist
@@PedroCastro-vn8qgBoohoo no one cares. We are sick with political correctness and destruction of our countries.
7:03 ridiculous to make that accusation against Hungary when other EU nations are FAR more loose with who they let in.
other EU nations don't invite countries with express interest in destabilising the EU into the Schengen area as residents.
And before your islamophobia rears its ugly head, do you honestly think Syria has enough of a functioning government to look that far ahead?
It's a different kind of problem. Other countries allow you-know-whats to come in, Hungary allows Russian Intelligence agents in. Neither of those are okay.
@@jabloko992 Then there’s a difference of scale. As for Russian intelligence agents coming in….you think they aren’t coming in among the lax controls of other European nations? How many MSS/Mossad/Aman/GIP/NIO agents have slipped in along with FSB/GRU. Going after Hungary is absurd.
@@jabloko992 Just wait till you learn that the main spying hub for russians is Vienna for the last 60+ years.
As a swede I feel ashamed of our sloppy and indifferent immigration policy and subsequent crime, rape and such. Sorry to my nordic friends :(
The comments full of people shouting that we must defend the external border instead, they are wrong. We must push ahead to a world without borders at all. A higher population should be a GOOD THING!!!
This is the first time in...ever that I've heard of Hungary letting TOO MANY foreign citizens in.
It's like they can't win first. They get fined for not letting in enough and apparently now they're letting in too much like make up your minds Europe.
As a European zoomer, I absolutely hate these new developments. Being able to travel seamlessly between countries is a huge part of my life.
So you absolutely hate to wait 5 minutes to show your passport at a border to prevent people getting in illegal that commit proportionality more crimes, increase housing prices and plunder the welfare state?
Me, me, me, me.....
Unfortunately, the world doesn't revolve around you. Adapt, like everybody else has had to.
@@Evemeister12 That is what the right wing racists are singing. Me me me..
That won't be affected in a radical manner
I just don't understand why these newcomers to Europe would do bad things and make their own lives, as well as the lives of people in their host nations, terrible. It's an oxymoronic dilemma to me.
Poverty. Look at the living standards of these people compared to the native populations. You do a bad job integrating them. The US has a far more extensive history of organized crime from immigrants from violent cultures like italians and the irish.
Most of them don't... you only see those who do in the news.
Because some of them are desparate and exploitable. It's easy to accept some sketchy job for easy cash one time, but then you're easily trapped. My rental bike company has to deal with asylum seekers who had their papers/ID confiscated by a gang that runs some kind delivery work scheme. They show up desparate to get their bikes/repairs against policy, pleading with the employees. You can imagine all sorts of similar/worse scenarios.
@@jacobjones630Poverty does not make people do bad things. also, Immigrating to Europe is not poverty, it is equivalent to being handed a huge stack of cash.
Because they hate the West
Border checks happened sometimes when I lived in Europe in the late naughties. One time I even went from 🇩🇪 to 🇳🇱 through a little town in case 🇩🇪 had a temp control on the autobahn 🤣
Every country within the zone HAS to have a unified policy on immigration from outside the zone. A ridiculous flaw.
Shock not enforcing borders leads to chaos
In light of mass migration from outside of Europe, Shengen has been a complete disaster.
I drove from Slovakia to Austria yesterday. The Austrians are controlling the border.
So they let that white Austrian into Germany who started shooting in Munich. Seems like it isn't working.
" Do you think uncontrollable free movement of people all around Europe might be an issue in the future?". 1985: " eh, it will be fine, don't worry about it!"
Originally freedom of movement was intended for European citizens only but then a case was taken to ECHR. At that point Schengen needed closing down,
This, children, is a perfect example of an old saying, that countries don't have friends, only interests.
The word “anxiety” & “tensions” really get abused so much it is offensive. It’s not “anxiety” when citizens talk about their loved ones being murdered or raped, or when houses of worship get burned down. Those are tragic realities. The politicians of Brussels want people to never talk about those real problems or do anything about it or vote accordingly.
Meanwhile Hungary got fined for not letting migrants in. That is not a double standard , or is it?
Exactly. I don't agree with their government on much but they deserve a refund after this.
3:41 We can all admit it, it is BAD. Especially when they come from the countries we all know but can’t say.
You can say it just fine
Why can’t you say it? LOL.
About a week or two ago I drove through the border check. 2 hours or so extra on a 12 hours drive, I was a bit annoyed initially. Then I went to fill up my tank once more with Polish gas. I travel often to Poland, I've never never never ran into obnoxious people or felt threatened or anything no matter what city or town. I'm a big guy anyways, worst you come across is a drunk guy shouting kurwa every 3 seconds whilst hobbling back home at 23:00 hahaha. But then, people who'd probably be rejected at the border piled up at that gas station. I get out of the car, I immediately get bothered by someone trying to sell me airpods and Gucci, I tried being polite, he wouldn't go away. Then I got angry, told him to piss off, suddenly 5 more spawn in out of nowhere, very angry looking faces, they now were also harassing my girlfriend. I couldn't really place this behaviour.
I paid quickly and drove off, deciding to cross through Słubice into Frankfurt rather than taking the normal route on the highway. I gladly accepted the traffic jam now. It's really needed, first hand experiencing who they're trying to keep out. Really scary stuff
Get Germany immediately to the court. NOW!
The EU needs one centralized immigration policy
Well, depends on what this means. Should it mean, the EU commission decides, then the hell no. Von der Leyen will just say there is no problem and islam is a religion of peace. 😂
Centralized? To be in the hands of globalists who f*ck our countries... What a great idea!
Sweden, Germany and the Netherlands are Directly responsible for this happening and should be financially liable
Also TJD, of course but those are migrants too, just not very recent
Netherlands? What did the Netherlands do?
@@Yodalemos I live in the Nederland's, the place welcomes in everyone and kicks out no one. They just allow them to make up some excuse.
@@tnickknight The Netherlands is one of the only places in Europe that actually locks the migrants up in facilities...
"We're not saying high levels of immigrations are bad". Well, you could have avoided being political by simply saying "inherently bad".
Now you took an ideological stance on a news show.
No they haven't? Just that there's downsides? Like there are with everything
They're not saying therre are downsides, and they're not saying they aren't bad either, are you two stupid? This sentence literally just means ‘I take no position on the subject’. Not saying something is bad isn't the same as saying it's not bad. Go back to school.
If Schengen dies so does the european economy
does no one remember what happened with brexit?
The die has been casted, migration will be the straw that breaks Europe’s back. I bet the Chinese and Russians governments are jumping in joy
The UK wasn’t in the Schengen area. We still had passport control.
@@ZomersetNot true.
@@Yodalemos Not true? The UK definitely wasn’t in the Schengen zone. We needed to go through passport control to enter the Schengen zone. We also needed to go through passport control to come back to the UK.
@@Zomerset Yeah, now. Didn't have to go through passport control before, but now go through it twice, once in the UK and once in the other country, on both the leave and the return.
Schengen area was the envy of the world . As an Indian I couldn’t visit neighboring countries with such freedom due to the hate between each other governments. Schengen was beautiful as once warring countries coming together in peace and economic growth . The fall of Schengen is just such a shame .
6:20 what is the religion of those teen