The Worst Clickbait on YouTube

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 677

  • @ice711real
    @ice711real  Рік тому +243

    Yes, I understand that found and explained talks about the aircraft concept in the video. It’s still not real (constructed and flown), thus why I mentioned it. But yes, they are real concepts.

    • @AntonGermanReal
      @AntonGermanReal Рік тому +1

      k

    • @Sumalee21
      @Sumalee21 Рік тому +7

      But you didnt say it was a concept

    • @RG_aming
      @RG_aming Рік тому +4

      yessir

    • @qsvere1812
      @qsvere1812 Рік тому

      There is a channel that makes clickbait football videos not clickbait (literally)

    • @ijustwantedanameok
      @ijustwantedanameok Рік тому

      ​@@qsvere1812 you knew the comments where coming

  • @Yoshikarter1
    @Yoshikarter1 Рік тому +260

    Thing is, clickbait isn't new, but the addition of custom thumbnails and the hiding of the dislikes counter has only aided those who do the clickbaiting.

    • @BVZTIII
      @BVZTIII Рік тому +7

      ReturnUA-camDislike and voila 👌

    • @Brfxxccxxmnpcccclllmmnprxvclmc
      @Brfxxccxxmnpcccclllmmnprxvclmc Рік тому +2

      @@BVZTIII you know you can download a chrome extension that uncovers dislike counts?
      Extension: Remove UA-cam Dislike

    • @theofficialintruder
      @theofficialintruder Рік тому +1

      ​@@BVZTIIIwhat about... The app?

    • @Redstoneprofi01
      @Redstoneprofi01 Рік тому +1

      @@Brfxxccxxmnpcccclllmmnprxvclmc I'm pretty sure he said that he uses the extension "ReturnUA-camDislike" and didnt say he wants the dislikes back.

  • @LecAviation
    @LecAviation Рік тому +599

    3:44 that actually isn't clickbait, that channel does lots of videos about failed concepts and that was a Boeing concept that, you guessed it, failed, it was very interesting to watch and that channel is really good

    • @F4PhantomGaming
      @F4PhantomGaming Рік тому +82

      rip the creator not doing research

    • @thegeneralofskies
      @thegeneralofskies Рік тому +19

      I was going to say that thanks

    • @ice711real
      @ice711real  Рік тому +143

      Yeah obviously, you could say the entirety of this video was "concepts." I thought that got through in the video...

    • @F4PhantomGaming
      @F4PhantomGaming Рік тому +60

      @@ice711real 3rd time watching it over i still dont see you mentioning anywhere that it was all concepts, still a good vid though

    • @putusancaya9985
      @putusancaya9985 Рік тому +41

      Awwwww man why...........I mean youre still cool but.........Please do some research first because I like Found And Explained
      Edit : Ok, I apologize, I am sorry for my behaviour, but I hope WW3 doesn't start down here, OR MAYBE IT ALREADY HAPPEND.

  • @Tornado2409
    @Tornado2409 Рік тому +138

    "I'm not even going to watch this, this is very straight-up fake."
    Both Found&Explained _and_ the crackhead designer: 😐

    • @randomguyonyoutube4394
      @randomguyonyoutube4394 Рік тому

      Are you special ed? All of found and explained that ice711 viewed was real stuff. This man really just posting this vid to have something to talk about. This poor idiot doesn't even realize u can't Photoshop a clip and calls it that anyways🙄

    • @Tarik360
      @Tarik360 Рік тому

      Who is the crackhead designer?

    • @SR_superior_1000
      @SR_superior_1000 Рік тому +7

      That was an actual plane concept. Never came to life

    • @timcreations8059
      @timcreations8059 Рік тому +5

      I do admit that plane is so absurd I could see how Ice711 would think that some nutcase on UA-cam would have just made the design up out of thin air or grabbed some joke photo off the internet.

    • @theofficialintruder
      @theofficialintruder Рік тому

      But well..... Everyone makes mistakes, right?

  • @RoStudios
    @RoStudios Рік тому +759

    I think you're just living in a world of denial

  • @krio1267
    @krio1267 Рік тому +67

    1:43 emirates' smallest plane:

  • @Zinericks
    @Zinericks Рік тому +108

    3:44 bro Found and Explained is an aviation channel, and it's not clickbait at all, he talks about planes that could exist, interesting designs anf it tells the history of planes that have existed

    • @IndonesiaMajapahitNDPCA
      @IndonesiaMajapahitNDPCA Рік тому +12

      Also failed concepts

    • @EricWulfe
      @EricWulfe Рік тому +10

      ​@@IndonesiaMajapahitNDPCA yeah, just like mustard. both channels have their own pros and cons

    • @TheEvo86
      @TheEvo86 Рік тому +5

      some of theyre thumbnails tho...

    • @darealfibbert
      @darealfibbert Рік тому +2

      🤓

    • @Zinericks
      @Zinericks Рік тому +5

      @@darealfibbert?

  • @transportationfan3156
    @transportationfan3156 Рік тому +30

    3:44 Found and explained actually talks about what is in the thumbnail in his video. Its just a concept aircraft.

    • @rt12.12
      @rt12.12 Рік тому +2

      yeah, it's a concept not a real aircraft

    • @Tornado2409
      @Tornado2409 Рік тому +6

      ​@@rt12.12 just because it's a concept, doesn't mean it's clickbait. Would you say the same about a video about cancelled concept _cars?_

    • @rt12.12
      @rt12.12 Рік тому +3

      @@Tornado2409 oh sorry i know, actually watch f+e quite a lot. but yeah, ik it came across as that i believed it was clickbait

  • @Enzi_Meteori_902
    @Enzi_Meteori_902 Рік тому +34

    0:54 i love how out of scale the a320 is compared to the a380

  • @ImmSpiderman2428
    @ImmSpiderman2428 Рік тому +40

    The Found & Explained video was actually a real Boeing concept, which had failed. He has made a lot of good videos about canceled concepts, his channel is very interesting

  • @Magnus_Caramelo_55
    @Magnus_Caramelo_55 Рік тому +215

    Found and Explained makes great videos about aircraft that were planned/blueprints, and protoypes; he even goes into detail of pros and cons of each aircraft

    • @headwreak1768
      @headwreak1768 Рік тому +17

      found and explained is like the younger but still cool brother of mustard.

    • @C2-GAMES
      @C2-GAMES Рік тому +3

      Agree

    • @robertoroberto9798
      @robertoroberto9798 Рік тому +1

      @@headwreak1768 A bit of holes in the facts though.

  • @ConcordeError404
    @ConcordeError404 Рік тому +10

    *Chances of seeing the world's best player holding a Glock 19 against a certain Portuguese striker are low, but never zero* 3:48

  • @Flexflex744
    @Flexflex744 Рік тому +177

    Found and Explained is actually quite a good channels. Probably one of the only ones in this vid.

  • @PureDhan
    @PureDhan Рік тому +31

    1:42 that ain’t an Airbus A390 that’s the WaterCar B410 💀

    • @Dynamity_
      @Dynamity_ Рік тому +2

      The plane was so aerodynamically unclean. Assuming full passenger and luggage load, that plane won't even be able to take off, and even if it did, the landing gear would break. :/
      Clickbait artists, pls improve your thumbnails.

    • @PureDhan
      @PureDhan Рік тому +1

      @@Dynamity_ “uhm actually 🤓”

    • @Dynamity_
      @Dynamity_ Рік тому +3

      @@PureDhan just saying they need to be realistic

    • @Yilmaz4
      @Yilmaz4 Рік тому +1

      ​@@Dynamity_ if they are realistic, people have no reason to click on them

    • @RorysAdventures2024
      @RorysAdventures2024 8 місяців тому +1

      Nah, that's an A430💀

  • @MrMischievous999
    @MrMischievous999 Рік тому +18

    1:30 gigachad meets plane😂

  • @olivererin3470
    @olivererin3470 Рік тому +28

    Found and explained isn’t clickbait as it is mostly about concepts and experimental planes

  • @rt12.12
    @rt12.12 Рік тому +15

    0:47 made me laugh so hard lol

  • @Purely-Flight
    @Purely-Flight Рік тому +7

    Bros seriously grinding the uploads, respect👌
    Ps nice vid
    Pss how long does it take u to make a vid?

    • @ice711real
      @ice711real  Рік тому +4

      Thank you! An average video length like this takes anywhere from 2-4 hours, some of them I make in one day, some over the course of days.

    • @Purely-Flight
      @Purely-Flight Рік тому

      @@ice711real oh cool that’s more devotion than I have💀 I haven’t uploaded for almost 4 weeks

    • @RoStudios
      @RoStudios Рік тому +2

      @@Purely-Flight get a-load of this guy… 1 year

  • @SoyElLoboGris13
    @SoyElLoboGris13 Рік тому +7

    1:35 7 years old: impossible...

  • @KeepyMiko
    @KeepyMiko Рік тому +3

    0:55 the best proposal ever 💀

  • @TheTrytix
    @TheTrytix Рік тому +5

    I have had a problem when it comes to an interesting direction to take Star Wars the Clone Wars related video thumbnails.
    Like... Most hardcore Star Wars fans can in practicality recognize any scene from the Clone Wars more or less. Every frame of any clone trooper is recognizable to people like us.
    But what I've began to see is UA-cam thumbnails where the thumbnails has a random image of a clone trooper painted in colors and decals that literally does not exist... Likely in an attempt to make people think "Oh! A video containing a clip of a clone trooper I have yet to see? Cool!" Only for them to just get a compilation of clones that they have already seen anyways, and the one in the thumbnail being non-existent pretty much.
    And I do not know why, but for some reason, this sort of stuff annoys me to a pretty high degree.

  • @ThatAustralianBall
    @ThatAustralianBall Місяць тому +1

    3:36 The Boeing RC-1, short for "Resource Carrier 1", was a design for an enormous cargo aircraft intended to haul oil and minerals out of the northern reaches of Alaska and Canada where ice-free ports were not available. It was optimized for short-haul missions only, carrying cargo to locations for loading onto ships, trains or pipelines. Depending on the role, the design was nicknamed "Brute Lifter" or "Flying Pipeline".
    The basic design had a rectangular wing spanning almost 500 feet (150 m), was powered by 12 Pratt & Whitney JT9D engines, and had 56 wheels in the main landing gear. A total of 2,300,000 pounds (1,000,000 kg) of cargo was carried in two under-wing pods and fuselage. The RC-1 would have been roughly twice the size and mass of the Antonov An-225 Mriya, the largest aircraft built, but would have carried about five times the payload.[a]
    The RC-1 was designed in the early 1970s. The rapid increase in jet fuel prices after 1973 caused the project to become uneconomical.

  • @youaremysunshine827
    @youaremysunshine827 Рік тому +25

    2:51 BRO I LAUGHED SO HARD AT THIS PART I DID NOT EXPECT THIS

    • @PotGuy69
      @PotGuy69 Рік тому +4

      Lol same😂😂😂😂😂😂💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀 im dead

    • @radustana
      @radustana Рік тому

      i almost fell out of bed at that one

    • @Endless17589
      @Endless17589 Рік тому

      AN2222222222222222222222222222222225 2:51

    • @Endless17589
      @Endless17589 Рік тому

      AN11111122222222222255555555555

  • @yello480
    @yello480 Рік тому +10

    Kalinan 6 was actually a Russian project
    It didn't fly because it was cancelled but DAMN IT HAD THOSE 2 *BATTLESHIP TURRETS* ON THE TOP AND THE BOTTOM ON THE ORIGINAL BLUEPRINTS

  • @markanthonyflores8616
    @markanthonyflores8616 Рік тому +1

    One time, I saw a battle ship game ad and they lanched a B-2 stealth bomber from an aircraft carrier💀

    • @Ryuu1010YT
      @Ryuu1010YT 6 місяців тому

      was it called "Modern Warships" game? it must be b21 raider on assault carrier like uss enterprise the gerald r ford class

  • @mateoley6630
    @mateoley6630 Рік тому +1

    If 1 clickbait video is the length of 1 nanometer… than all of the clickbait videos combined would make a path way from the earth to the sun

  • @cojanrobert17
    @cojanrobert17 Рік тому +7

    1:13 , that's a real photo if we exclude the redbull plane , it was actualy a photo from a stunt made by a Russian pilot with a Mig17 in 1965 , yep passing under a bridge with a fighter jet

    • @TheBridgerMC
      @TheBridgerMC 4 місяці тому

      Not a real photo, it’s a panting, but yes, a real story

  • @iawodand
    @iawodand Рік тому +11

    i can just imagine swiss using this sound and saying 'yes today we will be looking at the worst aviation videos on youtube' no hate its just funny love ur vids btw

  • @RG_aming
    @RG_aming Рік тому +11

    3:33 its not fake that guy uploads videos about old planes and all and they existed you should have watched it

  • @SoyElLoboGris13
    @SoyElLoboGris13 Рік тому +7

    2:18 stratolauncher moment

  • @lautaromaria6040
    @lautaromaria6040 Рік тому

    That "Airbus A390" is like seeing an A380 suffering a Cancerigenous Tumor. A severe one...

  • @digitaal_boog
    @digitaal_boog Рік тому +2

    2:33 that is a real aircraft. Honestly that scares me more than anything. The USSR was nuts

  • @rileytat123
    @rileytat123 Рік тому +6

    3:39 the video is explaining a plane concept

  • @krush454
    @krush454 Рік тому +2

    You sir, are doing the Internet-gods work. Second of your videos ive seen, i am now subscribed. kudos

  • @ThomasSchulte-kg3mq
    @ThomasSchulte-kg3mq 3 місяці тому +2

    3:38 it was meant to exist but it didn’t left the prototype stage and it was never built but it was meant to exist

  • @okuu_utsuho
    @okuu_utsuho Рік тому +1

    I’m just laughing seeing those ridiculous thumbnails, especially the one with an engine intake on where the cockpit should be and the cockpit on the place where the intake should be 😂

  • @Sam.m6
    @Sam.m6 Рік тому +1

    17K Sub Great Job man your channel has grown so fast

  • @thatoneguyyouforgotthenameof
    @thatoneguyyouforgotthenameof Рік тому +1

    Bro it’s just one stage of grief you don’t need to make a whole video about it

  • @Phoenix308
    @Phoenix308 2 місяці тому +1

    1:29 airbus bluegill

  • @abrahamlincoln1600
    @abrahamlincoln1600 6 місяців тому +1

    0:53 aww they love eachother 🥰 ✈️

  • @shottytheshotgun
    @shottytheshotgun Рік тому +9

    They flipped the image because it was landing instead of taking off 🙄

  • @Bolanio_747
    @Bolanio_747 Рік тому +1

    top 10 youtubers trying not to clickbait on video about aviation:

  • @TanimKabir
    @TanimKabir 5 днів тому

    3:47 the music GOT ME ROLLING 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @MaxLovesNascarOfficial
    @MaxLovesNascarOfficial Рік тому +2

    1:41 youtube kids planes in a nutshell

  • @Elliottblancher
    @Elliottblancher Рік тому +1

    the Boeing Resource Carrier one was an actual plane, well it was a proposed Design in the 70s that was never built because it was uneconomical at the time

  • @thepigeonguy641
    @thepigeonguy641 Рік тому +1

    Man one day i saw a video of exploring plane crashes and the thumbnail was a DC-3 with turbines

  • @countrylover12222
    @countrylover12222 8 місяців тому +1

    "Most clickbait the videos on UA-cam" ice711 Looks at aviation Ignoring the 3am videos

  • @_Qu3so_
    @_Qu3so_ Рік тому +1

    Russian plane manufacturers: how many engines y’all want?
    Russian airlines and cargo companies: *Yes*

  • @blockmaestro1
    @blockmaestro1 Рік тому +8

    4:02
    “Never let them know your next move”

  • @nugget127
    @nugget127 Рік тому +2

    this is a guy who actually made me laugh more than once...SUBBEEDD!!!!!!!!!!! YOO THAT RUSSIAN PLANE MEME HAD ME ON THE FLOOR! 🤣 (2:50)

  • @imtemplar1940
    @imtemplar1940 Рік тому +2

    3:34 DID SOMEBODY SAY OIL 🦅🦅🇺🇲🇺🇲🛢️🛢️💣💣

    • @Ryuu1010YT
      @Ryuu1010YT 6 місяців тому

      lol that boeing tanker was owned by US and sending to canada

  • @Ups_aviation_shorts
    @Ups_aviation_shorts 6 місяців тому +1

    2:05 that was way too loud and cursed💀💀💀
    2:51 my earsszssssss💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀☠️💀

  • @SoyElLoboGris13
    @SoyElLoboGris13 Рік тому +2

    3:48 audio quality 100/10

  • @boomkittyFX
    @boomkittyFX Рік тому +1

    mostamazingtop10... i remember the channel before they decided horror was apparently quality content.

  • @awesometurtle2887
    @awesometurtle2887 Рік тому +4

    3:01 If it's Russian... THEN WHY IS THE USS IOWA'S MAIN CANNONS ON IT?

    • @Ryuu1010YT
      @Ryuu1010YT 6 місяців тому

      lol they are absolutely putting iowa class turret in russia experiment aircraft

  • @robloxgamer5656
    @robloxgamer5656 Рік тому

    Good channel man hope you get a lot of subs!

  • @pfguy.
    @pfguy. Рік тому +1

    This guy is literally swiss001 from 2017 and i love it😭

  • @i-use-4rch-btw
    @i-use-4rch-btw 9 місяців тому +1

    3:41 I watched this, the one by Found and Explained isn’t actually clickbait

  • @FlorG.Studios_Oficial
    @FlorG.Studios_Oficial 5 місяців тому

    1:21 I've searched "Insane planes" and your video appeared lol

  • @AleAv76784
    @AleAv76784 Рік тому +1

    10 year olds are obsessed with the a380, a390 and a3100💀💀💀

  • @jasperow0250
    @jasperow0250 5 місяців тому +1

    2:05 that’s ain’t a plane,that is an alien machine

  • @blazi2293
    @blazi2293 Рік тому +2

    2:56 average arcade shmup boss

  • @Democracyyy
    @Democracyyy Рік тому

    when any non aviation channel makes a video about planes 75% very inaccurate and clickbait

  • @ryalexstudios
    @ryalexstudios Рік тому

    2:18 "WHAT IS THIS?"
    *Stratoplane chuckles*

  • @madelenemartinez8810
    @madelenemartinez8810 7 місяців тому +1

    For some reason when my older family members see these videos thinking that its real make me feel sad or whatever you call it

  • @ariesfaturrahman7982
    @ariesfaturrahman7982 Рік тому

    My response when I saw the thumbnail,
    "Look at that chonky-tall plane, it looks like Jojo Polnareff head. 😂😂"

  • @EricWulfe
    @EricWulfe Рік тому +2

    found & explained is on similar page, if not the same, as mustard in terms of relevancy and factual documentary. there are unique pros and cons coming from both channels respectively
    seeing some people berate the former of riding the latter's coattails and being a copycat just because its videos have slightly lower graphics quality than mustard's makes me disappointed, some people really do judge things by appearance alone

  • @iloveappleyoutube7198
    @iloveappleyoutube7198 Рік тому

    I absolutely hate when there is a clickbait thumbnail that doesn’t show up in the video. I’ve fallen for that a lot, why can’t it just end already?!?

    • @ice711real
      @ice711real  Рік тому

      People want views 🤷‍♂️

    • @iloveappleyoutube7198
      @iloveappleyoutube7198 Рік тому

      @@ice711realyeah but I bet it doesn’t feel good to those people, knowing that they deceived all those people to get views

  • @Jays-World29
    @Jays-World29 7 місяців тому +1

    0:57 AYO!!! ARE THOSE PLANES KISSING EACH OTHER!!!!!!

  • @28ebdh3udnav
    @28ebdh3udnav Рік тому +1

    The other massive clickbait that there is are the videos where they placed titles like, "CHINA SHOCKED. AMERICA MAKES MEGA " what ever

  • @wut827
    @wut827 Рік тому +1

    Why a380 never have fatal crashes?

  • @Ryu1478
    @Ryu1478 Рік тому +2

    If you look to the comments on all LEI Airlines videos, it's just parents saying it's fake *EVEN IF IT IS!!*

  • @The_Cube-aa
    @The_Cube-aa Рік тому +3

    1:38 airbus a1000

  • @supsnail
    @supsnail 8 місяців тому +2

    My a390 ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @maxwellepstein5706
    @maxwellepstein5706 8 місяців тому +1

    1:30 ah yes the Boeing 747-69420, looks like an apartment building. oh wait my mistake, it's an Airbus A630 "SkyWhale".

  • @Bucket_Zombie
    @Bucket_Zombie Рік тому +1

    0:57 what sound was that

  • @idk_I_just_play_Roblox
    @idk_I_just_play_Roblox Рік тому

    I love the tiny shitpost parts that you add in the video lmaoo

  • @Queenofskies747
    @Queenofskies747 Рік тому +1

    1:45 WE GETTIN OUT OF THE A380 OUT OF THIS ONE 🔥 🔥

  • @notgnome1
    @notgnome1 Рік тому +1

    3:37 bro seriously dissed found & explained 💀

  • @axealotlol
    @axealotlol Рік тому +3

    0:40 the second one that was "flipped" was actually the original thumbnail because if you take a look at the upload date the second one is flipped so the first one you showed is the fake

  • @MiJi_29
    @MiJi_29 Рік тому

    The Clickbait itself is like Oggy's Universe Commercial Airlines 💀

  • @ConclusiveLionSecond
    @ConclusiveLionSecond Рік тому

    0:41 cant just said stop laughing😂💀💀💀

  • @ATIMELINEOFAVIATION
    @ATIMELINEOFAVIATION Рік тому +6

    1:55 lol im actually subbed to him cus i like people who push x plane modifications to the limit

  • @Iseonix
    @Iseonix Рік тому

    1:45 can someone tell me where this audio is from

  • @mandoplayz
    @mandoplayz Рік тому

    why are they only football (soccer) thumbnails at the end

  • @loveplane737
    @loveplane737 Рік тому +3

    I remember a long time ago when I always seen this type of videos.

  • @nisarshaikh5664
    @nisarshaikh5664 Рік тому +2

    Finally someone who understands

    • @nisarshaikh5664
      @nisarshaikh5664 Рік тому +1

      No way my favourite channel liked my comment!!!!! 😱😃

  • @josephc.9520
    @josephc.9520 Рік тому +3

    Im positive the plane at 2:36 is real, I forgot the name but it was a ridiculous Soviet bomber design. The thumbnail is obviously clickbait however.
    Edit: Ok you addressed it immediately after but it was real plane, was it not????? So it isn't wrong to use it as the thumbnail

    • @dudemp4
      @dudemp4 Рік тому

      And this plane actually flew for some fucking reason

  • @Aircraftdude-y9p
    @Aircraftdude-y9p Рік тому +2

    0:51 they are ki-----

  • @andrews129
    @andrews129 Рік тому +1

    1:13 The photo is real, but there is a mig-17 instead of a red bull airplane.

  • @enderpenguincpvp
    @enderpenguincpvp Рік тому

    one of the funniest videos I have ever watched, clickbait is hysterical

  • @jayveez4884
    @jayveez4884 Рік тому

    this man just declared ww3 by assuming found and explained is a clickbait channel...

  • @Ryuu1010YT
    @Ryuu1010YT 6 місяців тому

    1:31 there was triple decker plane exists but it's fairly concept and never built one possibly by airbus and lockheed martin and other manufacturers

  • @AH1_f
    @AH1_f Рік тому

    I remember walking down the stairs of a 747-300 when I was a kid and turning around to see it thinking that is how big the average plane was (747s were popular at the time) and I got the same vibes looking at the A380 thumbnail.

  • @WeatherCat_TheCat
    @WeatherCat_TheCat 8 місяців тому +1

    Someone needs to build these in flyout or Kerbal space program lol

  • @harya7517
    @harya7517 Рік тому +2

    My first ever aviation clickbait was a video about ekranoplans, thank god that monster was real!
    Thanks mustard!

  • @SR-071
    @SR-071 8 місяців тому +1

    1:36 Airbus A390 leak

  • @mellovr326
    @mellovr326 6 місяців тому +1

    2:17 oh its just your casual DOUBLE STRATOLAUNCHER.
    (which actually makes sense idk why)

  • @TastelessEngineering
    @TastelessEngineering Рік тому

    That flying oil tanker was only a concept, not a real plane.

  • @alfredplays6589
    @alfredplays6589 Рік тому +1

    The super speed heavy metal name?