I’ve received my copy Saturday, listen to it four times so far. I have to agree with you. It is stunning, and a great work of art for music. All the effects stand out so clearly. I always thought this was Waters best album! On another note, did you see David Bowie’s 50th anniversary of Aladdin Sane only a $25 record. What a disgrace and a shame I was really looking forward to something special! It says it’s a half speed master, I hope to God it’s not Abbey Road!
When Jeff Beck recently passed, I immediately thought of his beautiful playing on this album. He brought real emotion and immaculate tone to it. Beautiful box set.
I have a European '92 release of this. Last year a sealed copy was sold for €499.99 It is a piece of art musically with many great artists including the recently departed Jeff Beck.. One of my favourite Waters records for sure.
Thanks for the inspiration, you guys are going to rock. Decided to invest in the best rega Planar 10 equipment will be a year's savings. It will be extremely difficult to resist all your fantastic recommendations.
I have the 33 and it sounds utterly incredible. This blows it out of the water. Seriously jaw dropping sound! Best sounding record in my collection now. Better than any UHQR or One-step
I've been wanting this album for quite some time but I just never pulled the trigger. I'm glad now that I waited as I have the 45rpm boxset coming in the mail. Thanx for the review!
Thanks, as ever, for the review Michael. One point though…. unless I’m very wrong: it can’t come from the original master tapes as the cover art, and from what I understand the music itself, is 100% the 2015 remix not the 1992 original? Many songs on the remix are VERY different- including Perfect Sense Part 1 where the introduction has been changed completely to include HAL from Space Odyssey (as Roger did when he performed the song live). I love both, but to me the original is the original, and sonically, even on an old (gold) CD with the amazing QSound 3D is like no other record. Am I wrong or is it the 1992 version?
Agreed. I’ve got the original 1992 on CD&HDD and the 2015 remix on vinyl analog sounds. The authenticity, atmosphere, intensity and mix/mastering is better on the original, even though it’s a digital copy. I find the vinyl remix useful hearing other bits and pieces and even though tonally the vinyl is very good it doesn’t have the magic of the original. For the audiophiles I have a Linn Klimax LP12 which does a bang up job and even with it the original version has it. I won’t be buying the 45rpm.
I’m not a mastering engineer, but as far as i know this has Q sound baked in, which is a sound processing algorithm. I don’t know if this could actually be all analog.
@@JBLClassic Joe Cocker's 'Night Calls' and Madonna's 'Immaculate Collection' were AAA and it also included Qsound.... Madonna was specially impressive. Best to me, Sting's 'The Soul Cages', tasteful! That was DDD
Not released until 27-01-23 here in the UK. It's quite pricey so I am not sure I will be getting this one. But wouldn't be surprised if my mind was changed before the end of this video. 😉
Very nice and tempting boxset! I would be so happy if they remastered and released "pros and cons of hitch-hicking", which is even better musically in my opinion... any information available from Chad?? Another 5 years waiting???
My copy arrived today it really is amazing what Roger’s and by extension Pink Floyd’s work does when juxtaposed against a truly black background. They just come alive. Love this recording with every penny(in my case).
Hi michael, i have received today my boxset very very well packed thank you👍. Just for you to know one gatefold is damaged, it's a factory issue as it was sealed. I won't bother to. send back the whole thing if the records are fine. But as it is expansive is there a way to have a replacement just the gatefold?? Even if that take a bit of time. I can email to the shop some photos if you want. Thank you
Personally I would always prefer a 33 1/3 version over a 45 rpm because getting up every 8 to 10 Minutes to turn the discs feels to me too much of a break in the musical flow. But that's only my very personal opinion 🙂.
Finally after 5 years the 45 rpm is here,fantastic news. I own the 33rpm which is stunning in its own right. Michael a great comparison.Some lovely touches with the 45rpm box regarding presentation. If you don’t own this there’s only one choice go with the 45rpm version,which forever will be the No1 sonically speaking. The dilemma is for us guys who own the 33 rpm. What do we do😂 I know we’ll end up with both 😂 Michael a pleasure as always ✊
Albums using digital files can sound great, and high res (96/24 or 192/24) is bested by DSD :))) Audiophile quality and digital can mean the same I guess :)
Interesting release. I have the legacy Productions #classic #BDRush #nowplaying #BD #BDcollection #BDcollector and CD by Guthrie and Plante which is the same mix yes?
Last year I reread Neil Postman's 1985 book "Amusing ourselves to death". I'm not really a fan of any Pink Floyd related stuff, but the book is in many ways more relevant than ever ... even if I don't agree with it all. Food for thought.
A great review. I am not clear nonetheless, why there included a digital step when analog tapes are there. Whilst, I commend AP for being transparent, did they use higher resolution than that by MOFI. The box set looks pleasing to the eye though.
Do you know the review of Vinyl-Check? He misses on the Analogue Production-Versions some essential on the vinyl-version: The software-generated 3d-Sound (which is only on the cd, he said)…..q-sound effects….
The only downside of that beautifull release is to change side every 2 songs that breaks a bit the continuity of the album. Other than that it rules everything
I streamed this first, and have to say, it is not my cup of tea. But hey, music is in the “ear” of the beholder. For me, there is no comparison, musically between Water’s and Gilmour. David has a better voice, and for me is artistically so much better. I was hoping Acoustic Sounds would be able to release DSOTM on vinyl, but I guess the sacd is all we are going to get.
I have not really made up my mind yet whether to attend one of the Roger Waters concerts this year. On the one hand, I generally do not like these "big" events in large halls, on the other hand, it could be the last opportunity to see him live.
@@borissikic8463 Yes! Albeit it was in the middle of the "everything digital" ear, the OG was said to be cut from the analogue master tapes. I will pass this box-set (I have the double 33 RPM, it's already great) and will wait a few years for the remaster only (not remix) and cut form masters. If the tapes are available (not locked in the vault for good) I'm sure Roger will consider this possibility in the future :)
To me the 1992 OG is unbeatable. There are differences in the mix, Roger Waters with James Guthrie changed and added some things. After 30 years listening to the original Doug Sax mastered LP ,that's what I love and used to. Soundwise I think the OG is awesome, on par with the 33 Analogue Prod. (yes I do have the AP 33 Amused to Death) . Imo, the should not have changed the mix.
yeap digital done right, some of the mofi release are done from dsd 64 which was probably acquired from columbia vault and I will say it, it was probably done from Columbia SACD files I may be wrong here, if it was those transfers were done long time ago and right now we have much better adc
Mmmmm, I have an original 1992 direct cut from lacquer Amused To Death on the Columbia label that cost a fortune 31 years ago (and still does if you can find a copy) and the 200g 2015 remastered Analogue Production version, and to be honest the 2015 AP sounds dull and flat compared to the original. I very much doubt I will buy the 2022 45 RPM (basically a half speed remastered version of the 2015 ) because it cannot and will never sound as good as the 1992 original which is a full blown, truely analogue direct from master tape masterpiece. If you ever get the chance to listen to a prestine copy of the original direct cut from laquer you will then understand.
First new Waters I’ve heard since ‘82’s “The Final Cut” and sounds to me that, 10 years on, we find him stirring the stagnant Waters of “The Wall/Final Cut”. Such a shame that such a creative genius can’t free himself from the procrastinations of yesteryears triumphs. All anti war stances are admirable but come on! Hey Rog you did it, now move on.
Streamed it. Sonically amazing, and pretty sure that this 45rpm edition takes it to another level. The production behind this recording is exceptional. The interludes/sound effects are cool. However, musically is too dull/sterile for my taste. No denying that AP did a solid job. This reissue checks out all the boxes for me, except the most important one…the music. Therefore, I’ll pass.
I bit the bullet and bought a copy ( yes I know I said I wouldn't) and to be honest it does sound a little more detailed than the Analogue Production 33rpm version, but still nowhere near as good as the original 1992 on the Columbia label. What really annoys me is the constant getting out of my chair to turn the things over or swap sides. When you look at the amount of unused surface area on each side it makes you wonder why they used 4LP's when 3 would have done or better still 2. Also you lose the continuity of the music, because each track should flow into the next which is lost on this due to the amount of discs used. It's not a bad effort but not really practical for serious listening especially when you have a really comfy chair and a large single malt and all you want to do is absorb the music. For me I think I've wasted my money but at least I gave it a go. For anyone who hasn't got an original then this will be a decent purchase.
No disrespect, this is becoming really repetitive (in my opinion). We know these APs all sound great ladidi, ladida. Wow. Killer. Unbelievable. And, yet, here I am watching this. Again. Ha, ha! : ) : )
Actually my provication is pure envy!!!!! Even me I am a huge fan of the analig world. Congrats for the amazing collection. But obviously unattainable to me.
He also gives a lot away to various charities. Including an apt building which charges nothing when you qualify. Think its in Amsterdam. You sure it’s not his politics that bothers you?
He is caught within a capitalist system. He is rightly criticising it because he has the platform to do so. He also needs to survive and is doing quite well in that regard; you can hardly criticise him for that.
All the redos are getting out of hand - every five years they re-release "Wish you were Animals" and "Dark Side of the Wall" their latest offering is $546, It's good they are releasing the live Wembley concert separately so you don't have to buy the whole thing - I Have a Twentieth Anniversary Edition of "Dark Side" which added nothing and the "Immersion Box Set" that had the very sort after Marbles and Drink Coasters.
I’ve received my copy Saturday, listen to it four times so far. I have to agree with you. It is stunning, and a great work of art for music. All the effects stand out so clearly. I always thought this was Waters best album!
On another note, did you see David Bowie’s 50th anniversary of Aladdin Sane only a $25 record. What a disgrace and a shame I was really looking forward to something special! It says it’s a half speed master, I hope to God it’s not Abbey Road!
they need to stop that half speed nonsense and do analog cut from OMT done by any good engineers like BG, CB or KG
What is a "copy Saturday"?
@@preservedmoose copy of the album we are talking about.
Obviously his management/family/label dont care
I know that album by heart , listening to it regularly since 1993. I only played side A & B and yet i discoverer new sounds it's insane
When Jeff Beck recently passed, I immediately thought of his beautiful playing on this album. He brought real emotion and immaculate tone to it.
Beautiful box set.
Hi Michael, I ordered the box set. I've been waiting for it for a long time and look forward to the copy with great interest.
Thanks for the rundown on this. I honestly didn't think this album could get better than the Analogue 33, but I'm glad to hear it did.
Thank you for sharing Michael, looks lovely. We hav their 33 1/3 copy from 2015 and more than happy with it. If I didn’t, I’d be all over this set.🎧
I have a European '92 release of this. Last year a sealed copy was sold for €499.99 It is a piece of art musically with many great artists including the recently departed Jeff Beck.. One of my favourite Waters records for sure.
Wow was that on eBay?
@@PinkFloydCollectors Discogs
Michael if my house is on fire...........this is the one album I will go back inside to get !!!!
Thanks Michael, I think I've been convinced on this one!
Can‘t wait to get my copy. It‘s my chance to get into the work of Roger Waters as the album is about a topic that is more than ever up to date.
Thanks for the inspiration, you guys are going to rock. Decided to invest in the best rega Planar 10 equipment will be a year's savings. It will be extremely difficult to resist all your fantastic recommendations.
Congratulations, Michael!! Your review of Roger Waters - Amused to Death now sits proudly below the album description on the Acoustic Sounds website.
Nice review. Thanks Michael.
My copy delivered last Sunday. I haven’t found time to listen to it yet. Hopefully I will be able to soon.
Nice review as usual Michael, I am looking forward to mine arriving by the end of the week...danke....
Nice review and thanks to you it's available in europe.
I can't wait to receive mine soon.
It is done michael i just send an email to the shop about my damaged gatefold thank you again 👍
I have the 33 and it sounds utterly incredible. This blows it out of the water. Seriously jaw dropping sound! Best sounding record in my collection now. Better than any UHQR or One-step
I've been wanting this album for quite some time but I just never pulled the trigger. I'm glad now that I waited as I have the 45rpm boxset coming in the mail. Thanx for the review!
Thanks, as ever, for the review Michael.
One point though…. unless I’m very wrong: it can’t come from the original master tapes as the cover art, and from what I understand the music itself, is 100% the 2015 remix not the 1992 original? Many songs on the remix are VERY different- including Perfect Sense Part 1 where the introduction has been changed completely to include HAL from Space Odyssey (as Roger did when he performed the song live). I love both, but to me the original is the original, and sonically, even on an old (gold) CD with the amazing QSound 3D is like no other record.
Am I wrong or is it the 1992 version?
i will get into it
Agreed. I’ve got the original 1992 on CD&HDD and the 2015 remix on vinyl analog sounds. The authenticity, atmosphere, intensity and mix/mastering is better on the original, even though it’s a digital copy. I find the vinyl remix useful hearing other bits and pieces and even though tonally the vinyl is very good it doesn’t have the magic of the original. For the audiophiles I have a Linn Klimax LP12 which does a bang up job and even with it the original version has it. I won’t be buying the 45rpm.
Having the 1992 CD it is not that version it's the 2015 one. Yet it's an amazing record
@@Michael45RPM Did they get back to you to confirm? Seems like it’s not the original master which is a shame. If not, then why Chad?
It looks amazing. I have to try it. Great...
Amazing
Thanks Michael. Please give credit to the solo guitarist in this album..
(the late) Jeff Beck!
you are right... damn
Now, I really have to give my SACD copy a listen.. Kind of forgot I had it... it's been quite a few years now.
This album was originally mixed using QSound. Did they do ground up non QSound mix?
Danke für den prägnanten Vergleich Michael.
I am waiting for my copy in the post. I didn't realise there was a digital step involved. I thought at such a high price it would be all analogue...
I’m not a mastering engineer, but as far as i know this has Q sound baked in, which is a sound processing algorithm. I don’t know if this could actually be all analog.
@@JBLClassic Joe Cocker's 'Night Calls' and Madonna's 'Immaculate Collection' were AAA and it also included Qsound.... Madonna was specially impressive. Best to me, Sting's 'The Soul Cages', tasteful! That was DDD
Not released until 27-01-23 here in the UK. It's quite pricey so I am not sure I will be getting this one. But wouldn't be surprised if my mind was changed before the end of this video. 😉
Mine just got delivered today!
The jackets are not the same as the 33rpm version by AP. The new jackets have matte finish instead of high gloss finish.
Brilliant will share across our social media channels…
one of the best roger waters albums (including the pink floyd stuff)
Very nice and tempting boxset!
I would be so happy if they remastered and released "pros and cons of hitch-hicking", which is even better musically in my opinion... any information available from Chad?? Another 5 years waiting???
I always think Pros and Cons and Radio Kaos get unfair stick. Even from Waters himself. Would love him to remaster them both for 2020s.
My copy arrived today it really is amazing what Roger’s and by extension Pink Floyd’s work does when juxtaposed against a truly black background. They just come alive. Love this recording with every penny(in my case).
Great comparison. By the way the 33 rpm is pressed by QRP. I think my 33 rpm version sounds so brilliant, I will do without the box set.
if I had 33 I would not go for 45, unless I would like to have the best version
I have the 33 as well and I’m thrilled with it. I’m sure the 45 sounds better and amazing. But I will stick with the 33 AP/QRP.
Original master tape, to high rez digital, hmm sounds familiar
but Analogue Orodction says so from the star.. o not that familiar.. but skipping this, makes the comment more spicy... i get it Harry
I could never get into amused to death. I love pros and cons and radio kaos though. Great review as usual
Hi michael, i have received today my boxset very very well packed thank you👍. Just for you to know one gatefold is damaged, it's a factory issue as it was sealed. I won't bother to.
send back the whole thing if the records are fine. But as it is expansive is there a way to have a replacement just the gatefold?? Even if that take a bit of time. I can email to the shop some photos if you want. Thank you
sure you get new jackets those seem splits are a pain sometimes... sorry to hear that
So, if there is an analogue master tape then why are they using a digital step?
Toa make it sound better.
Allow me to say that the 45RPM is far superior to the 33. Received it today and it's an incredible audio experience!
Where do you buy all those cool sweaters?
my wife does for me... it makes life way easier .-)
Personally I would always prefer a 33 1/3 version over a 45 rpm because getting up every 8 to 10 Minutes to turn the discs feels to me too much of a break in the musical flow. But that's only my very personal opinion 🙂.
5 years in the making...this means TDSOTM 50th anniversary we will wait up until 2028? 😥😢😭
On my Analog 33 rpm version, side 4's quality sound wise was well below the rest of the album. Did anyone else notice this?
Finally after 5 years the 45 rpm is here,fantastic news.
I own the 33rpm which is stunning in its own right.
Michael a great comparison.Some lovely touches with the 45rpm box regarding presentation.
If you don’t own this there’s only one choice go with the 45rpm version,which forever will be the No1 sonically speaking.
The dilemma is for us guys who own the 33 rpm.
What do we do😂
I know we’ll end up with both 😂
Michael a pleasure as always ✊
always the same Liam :-)
Yep.., plus the Original AND the MasterSound 1993 US gold CD which should certainly not be underestimated and I really enjoy listening to it 😉
Albums using digital files can sound great, and high res (96/24 or 192/24) is bested by DSD :))) Audiophile quality and digital can mean the same I guess :)
Thank you worry not michael do i need to email to the shop? So you have my order number and stuff and can replace the gatefold easily?
right, did you allready send an email with a photo?
@@Michael45RPM I will tonight
Killer sweater Michael
Interesting release. I have the legacy Productions #classic #BDRush #nowplaying #BD #BDcollection #BDcollector and CD by Guthrie and Plante which is the same mix yes?
I have the original and the 33rpm AP and the original is much much better.
Last year I reread Neil Postman's 1985 book "Amusing ourselves to death". I'm not really a fan of any Pink Floyd related stuff, but the book is in many ways more relevant than ever ... even if I don't agree with it all. Food for thought.
A great review. I am not clear nonetheless, why there included a digital step when analog tapes are there. Whilst, I commend AP for being transparent, did they use higher resolution than that by MOFI. The box set looks pleasing to the eye though.
Do you know the review of Vinyl-Check? He misses on the Analogue Production-Versions some essential on the vinyl-version: The software-generated 3d-Sound (which is only on the cd, he said)…..q-sound effects….
The only downside of that beautifull release is to change side every 2 songs that breaks a bit the continuity of the album. Other than that it rules everything
I streamed this first, and have to say, it is not my cup of tea. But hey, music is in the “ear” of the beholder. For me, there is no comparison, musically between Water’s and Gilmour. David has a better voice, and for me is artistically so much better. I was hoping Acoustic Sounds would be able to release DSOTM on vinyl, but I guess the sacd is all we are going to get.
I have not really made up my mind yet whether to attend one of the Roger Waters concerts this year. On the one hand, I generally do not like these "big" events in large halls, on the other hand, it could be the last opportunity to see him live.
It would be interesting to compare it to the original.
It is veeeery different. Mostly because this new 45 RPM box-set (just like the 33, from 2015) is a remixed version, not a "simple" remaster.
@@Domonkos.Siegfried also, original was all analog.
@@borissikic8463 Yes! Albeit it was in the middle of the "everything digital" ear, the OG was said to be cut from the analogue master tapes. I will pass this box-set (I have the double 33 RPM, it's already great) and will wait a few years for the remaster only (not remix) and cut form masters. If the tapes are available (not locked in the vault for good) I'm sure Roger will consider this possibility in the future :)
Is this the same remaster as the 2015 release? I have that one and like the original more.
Em not Roger Waters guitar - this album is a showcase for wonderful Jeff Beck on guitar. RIP
Is it the same mix as the 33AP and SACD, i.e. does it have the HAL 9000 dialogue?
To me the 1992 OG is unbeatable. There are differences in the mix, Roger Waters with James Guthrie changed and added some things. After 30 years listening to the original Doug Sax mastered LP ,that's what I love and used to. Soundwise I think the OG is awesome, on par with the 33 Analogue Prod. (yes I do have the AP 33 Amused to Death) . Imo, the should not have changed the mix.
..Is avaible in your store?..
Digital step???…
yeap digital done right, some of the mofi release are done from dsd 64 which was probably acquired from columbia vault and I will say it, it was probably done from Columbia SACD files I may be wrong here, if it was those transfers were done long time ago and right now we have much better adc
Mmmmm, I have an original 1992 direct cut from lacquer Amused To Death on the Columbia label that cost a fortune 31 years ago (and still does if you can find a copy) and the 200g 2015 remastered Analogue Production version, and to be honest the 2015 AP sounds dull and flat compared to the original. I very much doubt I will buy the 2022 45 RPM (basically a half speed remastered version of the 2015 ) because it cannot and will never sound as good as the 1992 original which is a full blown, truely analogue direct from master tape masterpiece. If you ever get the chance to listen to a prestine copy of the original direct cut from laquer you will then understand.
First new Waters I’ve heard since ‘82’s “The Final Cut” and sounds to me that, 10 years on, we find him stirring the stagnant Waters of “The Wall/Final Cut”. Such a shame that such a creative genius can’t free himself from the procrastinations of yesteryears triumphs. All anti war stances are admirable but come on! Hey Rog you did it, now move on.
Streamed it. Sonically amazing, and pretty sure that this 45rpm edition takes it to another level. The production behind this recording is exceptional. The interludes/sound effects are cool. However, musically is too dull/sterile for my taste. No denying that AP did a solid job. This reissue checks out all the boxes for me, except the most important one…the music. Therefore, I’ll pass.
Another "great" review.
Mr. Pete-------->
aging hippie
I bit the bullet and bought a copy ( yes I know I said I wouldn't) and to be honest it does sound a little more detailed than the Analogue Production 33rpm version, but still nowhere near as good as the original 1992 on the Columbia label. What really annoys me is the constant getting out of my chair to turn the things over or swap sides. When you look at the amount of unused surface area on each side it makes you wonder why they used 4LP's when 3 would have done or better still 2. Also you lose the continuity of the music, because each track should flow into the next which is lost on this due to the amount of discs used. It's not a bad effort but not really practical for serious listening especially when you have a really comfy chair and a large single malt and all you want to do is absorb the music. For me I think I've wasted my money but at least I gave it a go. For anyone who hasn't got an original then this will be a decent purchase.
Sadly the only box I own is the mail one ☺
Not fair 45 RPM well cut blow any 33 rpm!
Amazing record. This is a nonsense review. It’s a dsd that’s transferred to vinyl. Keep your 33 and just buy the sacd or even the blu ray audio.
No disrespect, this is becoming really repetitive (in my opinion). We know these APs all sound great ladidi, ladida. Wow. Killer. Unbelievable. And, yet, here I am watching this. Again. Ha, ha! : ) : )
what can i do? not do a video, because they nailed it again?
But maybe some day I will found a lot iof money in it ☺
Actually my provication is pure envy!!!!!
Even me I am a huge fan of the analig world.
Congrats for the amazing collection.
But obviously unattainable to me.
Love the album "amused to death", but not that keen on Roger.
It’s kind of amusing, Roger Waters views on consumerism and Americanism, but he relies on both for money.
He also gives a lot away to various charities. Including an apt building which charges nothing when you qualify. Think its in Amsterdam.
You sure it’s not his politics that bothers you?
@@Stonecutter334 : you know , that may be a possibility. It will say it is a damn good Album for sure…!
He is caught within a capitalist system. He is rightly criticising it because he has the platform to do so. He also needs to survive and is doing quite well in that regard; you can hardly criticise him for that.
@@preservedmoose this is true. Still my favorite LP though…
Rogers Waters Amused to Death, very boring album and overrated. But he, it’s Pink Floyd related and it is audiophile...
All the redos are getting out of hand - every five years they re-release "Wish you were Animals" and "Dark Side of the Wall" their latest offering is $546, It's good they are releasing the live Wembley concert separately so you don't have to buy the whole thing - I Have a Twentieth Anniversary Edition of "Dark Side" which added nothing and the "Immersion Box Set" that had the very sort after Marbles and Drink Coasters.