For my ears, 5:20 onwards is where the K3 took the win when I got a dose of emotion that the A3 couldn't provided as it's cleaner sounding (too clean?)
In this comparison, Magico sounds more balanced and handles large scale music more at ease. The Proac tonal balance is a little on the bright side and perfect for vocal and small scale music. Maybe the Proac needs more power to open up
I absolutely hate magico sound but it did sound much more distinct in this comparison. The proac sound like they were missing a lot of body in the violins and were almost veiled because of it. Weird because usually extension makes me think veiled and they didn’t seem like they were lacking inextension
The Magico seperates the instruments better than the ProAc which, at first, gives the music more clarity and forward motion. The ProAc is a totally different experience. The soundstage is larger but the separation is not as defined. This is a matter of taste vs one speaker being better than another. Visually, the ProAc is head and shoulders above the Magico.
Despite the fact that I have ProAc, which I really like, I have to admit that in this case Magico A3 sound more natural and interesting. I think that ProAc did not fit well into this system.
I think you're ears need to be checked if you think that the Proacs didn't fit in here maybe you should read the other comments the proacs were the clear winner.
@@chrisrichards2827people like different things. Just because one person said "proac is the clear winner" on a UA-cam video recording, does not make it so.
The Magico are much more realistic and controlled, the Proac sounds muffled in comparison. As a musician I can say that the A3 is clearly the winner here.
The proacs sound of more natural and real The voice is more human sounding and the piano doesn't have the bright edginess like it did with the magico speakers, The piano on the high notes should have a bite to it but not be bright and edgy and same with the voice that beryllium tweeter is bright in any speaker that I've heard it in.
Best to have a few speakers around to trick your ears because there ain't any perfect speakers out there period. Nothing worse than listening to the same voices day in day out.
Proac clear winner here. Much more open, much better bass articulation and midrange detail.
PROAC respects its mark : PERFECTLY NATURAL ! 😊
Absolutely Proac!
For my ears, 5:20 onwards is where the K3 took the win when I got a dose of emotion that the A3 couldn't provided as it's cleaner sounding (too clean?)
Magico A3 !
In this comparison, Magico sounds more balanced and handles large scale music more at ease. The Proac tonal balance is a little on the bright side and perfect for vocal and small scale music. Maybe the Proac needs more power to open up
Proac for,jazz,rock,metal,magico for classical.
ProAc for sure!
I'm gonna have to go ProAc!🍻
Damn the proac stepped on the a3
That’s very interesting music Marty.
Heard more dynamic range from the ProAc’s
Not even a question. ProAc.
听起来ProAc K3音色比较亮。不过我比较喜欢magico A3够沉稳。谢谢分享！
ProAc
I absolutely hate magico sound but it did sound much more distinct in this comparison. The proac sound like they were missing a lot of body in the violins and were almost veiled because of it. Weird because usually extension makes me think veiled and they didn’t seem like they were lacking inextension
I say Magico, despite I am a proac fan! Owner of d80r
i liked the sound of ProAc more..what r their prices ??proac and magico?
Proac
Magico sounds like metal and ProArc sounds like wood instrument
exactly
The Magico seperates the instruments better than the ProAc which, at first, gives the music more clarity and forward motion. The ProAc is a totally different experience. The soundstage is larger but the separation is not as defined. This is a matter of taste vs one speaker being better than another. Visually, the ProAc is head and shoulders above the Magico.
agree with your assessment
proac k3 the best
Despite the fact that I have ProAc, which I really like, I have to admit that in this case Magico A3 sound more natural and interesting.
I think that ProAc did not fit well into this system.
I think you're ears need to be checked if you think that the Proacs didn't fit in here maybe you should read the other comments the proacs were the clear winner.
@@chrisrichards2827people like different things. Just because one person said "proac is the clear winner" on a UA-cam video recording, does not make it so.
Proac!!!
Proac digs deeper and has bigger soundstaging
The Magico are much more realistic and controlled, the Proac sounds muffled in comparison.
As a musician I can say that the A3 is clearly the winner here.
ProAc win. More musically involving.
PRO A C
ProAC is more natural
Magico make me so tired to listen. Proac more comfort for listening music
Rather similar sounding tone, but definitely Magico A3. Not exactly equal in volume db settings.
Wow😍😎👂👂👂👂👍🏆🏆🏆🏆🥰❤️👌
magico seem so transparent to me and even
and loud passages still can hear everything
Wish you folks also played music us real people listen to. Parsons, Dire Straights, even Taylor you know...
Magico is clearer, crispier but has less impact in the low frequencies than ProAc. We clearly hear the non-ported design vs the ported design here.
Magico A3 : 10
Proac k3 : 6
The proacs sound of more natural and real The voice is more human sounding and the piano doesn't have the bright edginess like it did with the magico speakers, The piano on the high notes should have a bite to it but not be bright and edgy and same with the voice that beryllium tweeter is bright in any speaker that I've heard it in.
Magico A3 performed better, and ProAc K3 accompaniment interfered with Tsai Chin's emotional expression.
Best to have a few speakers around to trick your ears because there ain't any perfect speakers out there period. Nothing worse than listening to the same voices day in day out.
Magico A3 круче
Magico is better
My Piega speakers sounds better both of these
A moje Sonus Faber Amati Homage jeszcze lepiej..
Proac