If this is true she should be ashamed of herself. The fact that she could single-handedly jeopardize the trial outcome, giving that man another shot at freedom… just disgusting!
I dont understand WHY they waited so long to say something ? You would think the people on the jury would have said something WHILE this was happening !😳
IF it is true! What are THEY being offered for coming forward now? The real victims would be the taxpayers who might have to foot the bill for this circus! Wish they had just hung the evil man the next day! Is this Murdaugh power citizens were talking about? Corruption and evil in the low country for sure!!
How could any court clerk be so stupid as to think she could have inappropriate conversations with jurors and not get caught? That's the most baffling part of this whole thing. The only way 13 people can keep a secret is if 12 of them are dead.
Yeah, it is fascinating. Either she was really invested in her book and it made her take unreasonable risks, or, an even scarier thought, she just considers it normal and does similar things all the time. If the latter is true, oh wow, it can open a flood of appeals.
WHY DIDNT THE JUROR(S) REACH OUT TO JUDGE IMMEDIATELY? this would raise giant red flags How can a public servant write a book like this while still in their role? Outrageous.
Well she is judges clerk...people don't know what is she allowed to do as her job. Maybe they thought this is normal. If this jurors are now bribed or....why then AM is not free, surely they could be bribed then...don't know for sure, but this is a mess.
These jurors seems to be super dumb. "18:38 "...which I understood to mean that he was guilty" - and what is your understanding of the reason of having a trial at all, and what do you think your job is in the court room???? Stupidity overload 🤦♀ Some jurors don't care, don't listen, don't THINK. It's super scary to know that the fate of criminals are in the hands of such foolish people. The judge asked them every single day "have you discussed the case with *anyone"* - and they remained silence.
@verabolton jury tampering is common. The apple river stabbing case is rich of it. They pre select the jury who they know will give a predetermined guilty verdict. It's very easy to find a jury who will do that. Read discussions about the case online, know who supports the guilty outcome, then send them a jury duty by mail. That's it. I made a comment about a case on UA-cam and few days later I was called in for a jury duty. Not a coincidence
Miss Becky became overly confident that she was above reproach. She suffered from the “Small Town, Big Fish Syndrome” . I just finished her book and clearly she was enamored with her position and power.
Does she say in the book anything about juror James? The lovely guy who gave an interview right after trial. And is the brother of the first responder on the scene. I remember it blew my mind, that that was possible. Especially when you think, how they messed up the crimescene, with all their big feet walking around Paul & Maggie that night. Waiting for SLED to arrive at midnight. He was juror 530. James McDowell. Brother of first responder deputy Chad McDowell.
Because after finding out about her book they felt used so she can get a guilty verify and sell her book. Why else would she be pushing each individual juror to vote guilty ? And why else would she get a juror kicked off the jury because she felt they might vote “not guilty”.
People have literally bought into this so hard. There is no good evidence he commited this other than him lying about his location which is completely reasonablein his situation imo. He had so many people who hated him, he and his family had been threatened, multiple people wanting revenge on him, no murder weapons located. Like I think he's innocent, but to say he definitely did it is absurd.
@@signalfire6691She’s only being “defamed” if it’s not true and even then, it’s being reported as “if it’s true” and not in the legal CYA sense. They’re legitimately pointing out that it could all be a load of crap.
@Murphlind, what do you mean by "report this"? They didn't know the clerk was lying until the book. The juror tried to say she hadn't made up her mind about the case and the judge didn't realize the clerk had been inappropriately pushing her about that and then lying to him about FB posts.They don't know exactly the job roles of the clerk and bailiff, etc.
@@JessBlake2 The judge asked the jurors every day: "have you discussed the case with anyone?" - and the jurors LIED to the court with their silence. They should be prosecuted. Then, they convicted a man of murder not because of their own understanding of the case, but because of a clerk (allegedly) telling them to pay good attention?! "18:38 "...which I understood to mean that he was guilty" - and what was their understanding of the reason of having a trial at all, and what did they think their job was in the court room???? Stupidity overload
You people do know that vinny left his wife and family for a Mexican guy who has been here under 1 years. He was doing work as a day laborer on his house. Why don’t we talk about what you did to your wife Vinny and stop judging all these people In court and bring it Home and focus on how to win that family back.
People Vinny left his family but talks about others all the time. WTF AMNI THE ONLY ONE WHO THINKSNIT WEIRD HE LEFT THEM FOR A DAY LABOR WHO IS FRESHLY FROM MEXICO
Having watched Harpootlian and Griffin during cross they would often misquote what a witness had just said and then state their misquotation as fact during their next question; I’d be very interested to hear these jurors who have signed affidavits to hear directly from them to ensure that this is not just Poot and Griffin creating a false narrative based on misquotation. I also think whether true or not it is such a sad ending to Judge Newman’s excellent career if 1. Ms. Hill tainted his courtroom, or 2. the allegations are false.
💯💯💯💯💯 Exactly! They lied, misrepresented & misquoted for 28 Days. I’m not going to believe them without more credible sources & information. This very well could just be a ploy by them to throw her under the bus like they did others to get him another trial since they preformed so poorly in the trial.
I think defense made this up. They put on a lousy case. Last straw. We would have heard about these allegations before. Someone else would have said something earlier
Alex probably paid someone to lie about all this. You know he still has that money he stole from his clients somewhere. There is no way he spent all those millions on his drug habit. He would be dead by overdose if he did that much dope.
When I was on a jury..it was a bailiff that helped us out. Meaning asking what we wanted for lunch, if we needed a break, etc. No other kind of chit chat…she was very professional.
I don’t understand how she was able to interact with the jury like that either. I have never heard of anything like this. And she wrote a book! If she did this, she should never be allowed to work for the courts again. Wow!😮
@@shirleychevalier482 and it was only the book that crossed the line for jurors! they violated their oaths too, each and every one of them. The two who gave affidavits under oath should get immunity but everyone else deservers jail for this. They've undermined the entire justice system, every case this lady was involved in should be thrown out.
I really hope this isn’t true…..It would make me horribly sad to think a clerk would have such little integrity. Hope it’s manufactured…. Even that’s horrified
"Low Country Clerk Karen" has an inflated view of her role and power. How many other juries did she improperly influence? Are people on death row because of her comments or observations she shared?
When Jim Griffin said that AM was shaking when they told him about this. Really?? Shaking? Was he shaking when he killed his wife & son ? A cold blooded murder shaking? 🤦🏽♀️
The levels of unethical behavior by the Clerk of Court just gets deeper and deeper. Instead of talking to jurors to get content for her book she should’ve been serving the citizens and doing her sworn job duties especially with such a high profile case. And Becky stay off of Facebook!
Because that’s her strategy not like she’ll admit she committed Jury tampering 😅 I’ve heard it’s 20 years if found guilty so she’ll just have to deny deny deny.
@@julielockett1812exactly with all the money involved in this case I'd say a couple jurors were paid life changing amounts of money for putting this out there just my opinion
If she’s guilty she should spend 50 years in prison for corrupting the court, if she’s innocent she should sue asses off….. anyone who accused her should be jailed as well
No she did it so she can make money off her book. Why else would she get someone kicked off the jury that she thought would vote not guilty ? If anything she would have left the person on the jury so their could me a mistrial. Just accept the fact that she did this for her own selfish gain and nothing more.
Was she put up to possibly facing actual charges of jury tampering, losing her career, & opening the door to every trial she had anything to do with, now having to be double checked? Do you really think she’d be willing to put that all on the line, simply to do a “favor” for the defense?
Then the jurors should be imprisoned too. They were asked every day if they discussed the case with anyone and they kept silent. "18:38 "...which I understood to mean that he was guilty" - and what is your understanding of the reason of having a trial at all, and what do you think your job is in the court room???? 🙄 If jurors can be influenced this easily, they should be ashamed of their own stupidity.
How could Alex point a finger at anyone profiting from a book when he stole from clients he was paid to represent and protect? That man and his defenders are all slime and I’m thinking Buster falls in that catagory as well
Because Clerk Becky is a ELECTED public official and should not profit personally from doing her elected job duties. This was a dumb move on her part AND also greedy
Buster has had no charges and is innocent at this time. The young man lost his mother and brother and his father. He has been accused of horrible things with no proof. It is not his fault that he was raised as privileged by both mom and dad. And now he is being judged because he is having a hard time believing his father killed them..I just hope you are judged as you are judging this young man! Shame on you!!!
The problem is not the book. The problem is that the clerk pushed the jurors to give the verdict that helped her book. She has no business writing any book while on the clerk position.
He did run a tight courtroom for sure, but he might not have known she was doing it. And the jurors probably had no idea she shouldn't have been in there. We don't know when she was going in there. Remember he would go to his chambers during breaks, so she could have gone in there then. In all of the trials I've watched, the bailiffs have been the ones who went to the jury room, collected their notebooks, etc
A fair trial in America? The judges are political appointees, politically and racially biased, and corrupt Epstein travelers to boot. Especially in this particular jurisdiction. The judges are all complicit in Murdaugh's financial perversions
I thought it was really weird. I assumed she was involved in some kind of misconduct. Clearly Judge Newman trusted the clerk. I'm sure he's going to be really angry that she did this.
Someone said that he'd be in a federal prison for those, and that's what he wants because it's better. I know nothing about prisons, though, so I don't know if that could be true. Alec is still getting in trouble in prison. Big surprise! It's clear by all the things he's done that he thinks rules don't apply to him. And they apparently didn't apply to his kids, either. Paul was in trouble for the boat crash, and Buster cheated on an exam and got kicked out of law school. When I see families like this, I'm glad I'm not rich.
What about the trickle effect on every other matter before that court where that clerk was a participant? Seems like every defense attorney who tried a case in that court would be chomping at the bit to get their case reopened because of potential malfeasance…
Doesn't matter if he's guilty or not....one great thing about our country is our rules and protections under the law. This woman is so very arrogant and her book speaks to so much impropriety. She thinks she is above the law ...I hope she gets time for this and that the state freezes her bank accounts in order to pay for a new trial.
It’s not about Guilt or Innocence it’s about the right to a fair and impartial trial. Thanks Clerk Becky for causing this case to be overturned on appeal. Wonder if you’ll be re-elected
People like you make me sick. He deserves the death penalty if found guilty. HOWEVER, we have a justice system and of this is true, there should be another trial. You overlooking that is pretty sad. You need to look inside of yourself and figure out what's wrong.
Ok, so if this is true, the clerk of court should be prosecuted and made to pay restitution to the state or county taxpayers for the cost of the 1st trial. With that said, has it crossed anyone else's mind that these jurors could have been bought off to say these things? I mean, fixing juries, having LE and prosecutors in their pockets, and being corrupt is what this family and their lawyers are known for, right?! Either way, I agree with Vinnie. He is guilty as sin and was caught having been at the scene minutes before the murders occurred and lied about it! That is until he heard himself in court and could no longer tell that lie. However, at the end of the day, everyone deserves a fair trial no matter their guilt.
Rebecca Hill had a relationship with Alex's family. They have known each other for years. Check to see if Alex stole money from her family. Then you would have motive.
Anyone else recently convicted in this court needs to investigate whether she also tampered with their case. I guess now she will have to use the profits from her book for some mighty expensive legal talent.
Well if it’s true she didn’t let them get smoke breaks they may have wanted out asap 😅 so they didn’t say anything until they got their fix. The smokers probably rushed the decision that’s what they’re alleging.
She also called jurors at their home and said do not trust him, and spoke to one juror privately when on a field trip to view the home, everyone witnessed that. This reporter missed some facts.@@lo_2710
What a bunch !! the moral outrage by Alex !! he said he was not there when his wife and son were shot he was there we heard his voice he DID IT !! i wonder what he was doing on the computer to have it taken from him ?
See, I don't think multiple jurors & a random ex-husband who are willing to sign an affidavit and testify under oath could be criminally prosecuted plus, 2 very successful lawyers who have huge law firms willing to risk their careers & possibly even disbarred if it came out this way all a lie. It sounds to me that this clerk knew how high profile this case would be, and she had the book idea from the beginning. If this is all true whether you believe Alex is guilty or not, he deserves a fair trial. Everyone deserves a fair trial.
@@cynthiasnodgrass8071 I would say the same thing in a normal case. Considering decades of corruption with the Murdaugh family and the County, I don’t think it’s a stretch to think there is possibly ongoing corruption.
So he can kill his wife and son, admittedly then instead of accepting his future and responsibility he looks for a way to wriggle out of it? That just says everything! 🇮🇪☘️
Vinnie, Vinnie, Vinnie, you absolutely MUST stop talking over your guests when they speak. Or interrupting them when they are answering YOUR questions. It's rude and uncomfortable to watch, off-putting and unprofessional. Quit it!!
I think Alex killed them at 8:49 then he hosed himself off then changed clothes took the guns to Almeda... where the heck they are we'll never know ...he's guilty as heck even if they retry him he's guilty as heck... I think the defense did a bad job... they opened the door a few times ...all the money stealing coming in and I thought the prosecution team was phenomenal! Love your show Vinnie... you are great Love your show Vinny you are great!
Consider all the corruption that has been exposed in the low country: Could those jurors been bribed/paid off by someone to file those affidavits? Certainly buying people off is not unheard of by the powers that be.
I believe the jurors. No way would they fabricate such a thing. The clerk's action are absolutely egregious, and if true, she should be held responsible. A new trial should be granted.
The problem is, when they select jurors, they don't look at the IQ. Jurors were asked every single day "have you discussed the case with *anyone"* and they kept silent. Shame on them. "18:38 "...which I understood to mean that he was guilty" - and what is your understanding of the reason of having a trial at all, and what do you think your job is in the court room???? 🙄 If jurors can be influenced this easily, they should be ashamed of their own stupidity.
I'm confused...you begin by saying you are very skeptical of this claim and then continue to provide many examples if the clerk's inappropriate behavior that leads to the likelihood that the defense's allegations are true.
The fact that she wrote a book, accompanied certain jurors to New York, and acting like she convicted AM in the interviews that she gives…it tells me that all of this is true.
He faces 900 yrs for his financial crimes. This psycho liar is so desperate. Meanwhile he continues to manipulate his son into believing he's innocent. Man up Alick...will never happen. Pathetic.. This appeal will fail and if he gets a new trial ... another guilty verdict.
Even if one juror in a potential retrial finds reasonable doubt, you're right: his sentencing for the myriad financial crimes will equate to life in prison. It sounds mean, but I hope he gets his hopes built up big time and crashes into dust.
What I am getting is they did not realise they were unduly being influenced by Ms. Hill, until the book came out! Did not a witness state on the stand that when they went to the site that the Clerk and foreperson was off to the side blah blah blah.. this smells
His lawyers, literally, tried to reach out to all of those jurors... like tracking them down, driving down long dirt roads to their homes and knocking on their front doors lol... Desperate sore loser lawyers.?.
If this is true, then why would the jurors go to the defense attorney and not the prosecutor or the judge? Its a little shady to me that this is completely true. Defense attorney speaking in private, who's to say they weren't leading a response from these jurors. And wouldn't the jurors mention something to the judge, bailiff, at the time this was happening?
MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/news/alex-murdaughs-attorneys-seek-new-trial-based-on-discovered-evidence/?
@courttv didn’t AG Allen Wilson personally prosecute AM ? Isn’t that a conflict of interest?
@tommymyers3183 I second that question.
If this is true she should be ashamed of herself. The fact that she could single-handedly jeopardize the trial outcome, giving that man another shot at freedom… just disgusting!
Or maybe you could also hold her accountable for being apparently biased in the first place (no matter how guilty he may be).
She should be fired and barred from other jobs in civil service!
If she did this she needs to be prosecuted.
Don’t overreact! Nobody granted another trial yet.
@@mariapilarme That is irrelevant. So as long as no other trial granted, her behavior is a OK?
I dont understand WHY they waited so long to say something ? You would think the people on the jury would have said something WHILE this was happening !😳
Because it's not what you KNOW, it's what you can PROVE!! Duhhhh
Her book came out...
I’ve been in juries and lots of individuals ignore the rules and at the end just want to get it over.
Because they were paid a lot of money to say it.
Also the clerk was paid to screw up the trial. She knows Alex and his lawyers personally.
IF it is true! What are THEY being offered for coming forward now? The real victims would be the taxpayers who might have to foot the bill for this circus! Wish they had just hung the evil man the next day! Is this Murdaugh power citizens were talking about? Corruption and evil in the low country for sure!!
How could any court clerk be so stupid as to think she could have inappropriate conversations with jurors and not get caught? That's the most baffling part of this whole thing. The only way 13 people can keep a secret is if 12 of them are dead.
Yeah, it is fascinating. Either she was really invested in her book and it made her take unreasonable risks, or, an even scarier thought, she just considers it normal and does similar things all the time. If the latter is true, oh wow, it can open a flood of appeals.
How many other cases, if true!
Always a possibility with these corrupt defence lawyers that she's actually batting for murdaugh team. Money can buy you any kind of fact or 'truth'
It’s all nonsense. 🥹
Is she the one that was in the court?
WHY DIDNT THE JUROR(S) REACH OUT TO JUDGE IMMEDIATELY? this would raise giant red flags How can a public servant write a book like this while still in their role? Outrageous.
Well she is judges clerk...people don't know what is she allowed to do as her job. Maybe they thought this is normal. If this jurors are now bribed or....why then AM is not free, surely they could be bribed then...don't know for sure, but this is a mess.
Intimidation is a well known tactic in SC. Everyone is connected. I’m sure they were afraid to.
These jurors seems to be super dumb.
"18:38 "...which I understood to mean that he was guilty" - and what is your understanding of the reason of having a trial at all, and what do you think your job is in the court room???? Stupidity overload 🤦♀
Some jurors don't care, don't listen, don't THINK. It's super scary to know that the fate of criminals are in the hands of such foolish people.
The judge asked them every single day "have you discussed the case with *anyone"* - and they remained silence.
@verabolton jury tampering is common. The apple river stabbing case is rich of it. They pre select the jury who they know will give a predetermined guilty verdict. It's very easy to find a jury who will do that. Read discussions about the case online, know who supports the guilty outcome, then send them a jury duty by mail. That's it. I made a comment about a case on UA-cam and few days later I was called in for a jury duty. Not a coincidence
Miss Becky became overly confident that she was above reproach. She suffered from the “Small Town, Big Fish Syndrome” . I just finished her book and clearly she was enamored with her position and power.
Interesting comment. I do not intend to buy the book has I do not 2ant to support her, so thank you for a review.
Does she say in the book anything about juror James? The lovely guy who gave an interview right after trial. And is the brother of the first responder on the scene. I remember it blew my mind, that that was possible.
Especially when you think, how they messed up the crimescene, with all their big feet walking around Paul & Maggie that night. Waiting for SLED to arrive at midnight. He was juror 530. James McDowell. Brother of first responder deputy Chad McDowell.
@@belleblaas3843 Its SC, they are all related, not sure what you expect.
Everything else in this County was full of corruption, why wouldn’t this clerk do it too. Why did the jurors wait until now to report it??????
Because her book just dropped!!!
good question.....matter of jealousy?
Because after finding out about her book they felt used so she can get a guilty verify and sell her book. Why else would she be pushing each individual juror to vote guilty ? And why else would she get a juror kicked off the jury because she felt they might vote “not guilty”.
@@feemarieA ‘not guilty’ verdict would have been just as newsworthy and controversial as a ‘guilty’ verdict, in terms of her book sales…
It isn't what you know. It is what you can prove beyond one testimony
This doesn't change the fact that he killed his wife and son.
But the Clerk gave Alex Murdaugh another chance even tho he's guilty.
@@Caleb_Mandrake872yeah exactly to help alex.. One must consider her apart of the plan all along
It doesn’t matter. I don’t like that guy, but If she did this he should get a new trial.
People have literally bought into this so hard. There is no good evidence he commited this other than him lying about his location which is completely reasonablein his situation imo. He had so many people who hated him, he and his family had been threatened, multiple people wanting revenge on him, no murder weapons located. Like I think he's innocent, but to say he definitely did it is absurd.
@@fuzzace6044 What was his reason for lying about being at the location? I literally haven't watched any of this trial (never tickled my fancy).
If this is true, her behavior is a disgrace. I hope the truth comes to light.
It’s not yet.
Meanwhile, she's being defamed on national tv .... and the evidence is two jurors willing to fill out a form.
@@signalfire6691She’s only being “defamed” if it’s not true and even then, it’s being reported as “if it’s true” and not in the legal CYA sense. They’re legitimately pointing out that it could all be a load of crap.
she going to jail
@@signalfire6691 she's going to jail.
Not one of those four jurors thought to report this until she wrote a book. Hmmm
Hmmmmm 🤔
@Murphlind, what do you mean by "report this"? They didn't know the clerk was lying until the book. The juror tried to say she hadn't made up her mind about the case and the judge didn't realize the clerk had been inappropriately pushing her about that and then lying to him about FB posts.They don't know exactly the job roles of the clerk and bailiff, etc.
@@JessBlake2 The judge asked the jurors every day: "have you discussed the case with anyone?" - and the jurors LIED to the court with their silence. They should be prosecuted.
Then, they convicted a man of murder not because of their own understanding of the case, but because of a clerk (allegedly) telling them to pay good attention?! "18:38 "...which I understood to mean that he was guilty" - and what was their understanding of the reason of having a trial at all, and what did they think their job was in the court room????
Stupidity overload
Poor Judge Newman has to be pissed off. He did a wonderful job during that trial. Hoping the allegations are untrue.
I'm sure he's furious. If they are true, and he gets taken off the case, it will be a huge disappointment.
He allowed everything and the kitchen sink in that charade of a trial. Corrupt beyond at least equally corrupt AM
@@nadagabri5783what....
You people do know that vinny left his wife and family for a Mexican guy who has been here under 1 years. He was doing work as a day laborer on his house. Why don’t we talk about what you did to your wife Vinny and stop judging all these people In court and bring it
Home and focus on how to win that family back.
People Vinny left his family but talks about others all the time. WTF AMNI THE ONLY ONE WHO THINKSNIT WEIRD HE LEFT THEM FOR A DAY LABOR WHO IS FRESHLY FROM MEXICO
Having watched Harpootlian and Griffin during cross they would often misquote what a witness had just said and then state their misquotation as fact during their next question; I’d be very interested to hear these jurors who have signed affidavits to hear directly from them to ensure that this is not just Poot and Griffin creating a false narrative based on misquotation. I also think whether true or not it is such a sad ending to Judge Newman’s excellent career if 1. Ms. Hill tainted his courtroom, or 2. the allegations are false.
The interesting thing is that they went and looked for these jurors they didn't just come forward.
💯💯💯💯💯 Exactly! They lied, misrepresented & misquoted for 28 Days. I’m not going to believe them without more credible sources & information. This very well could just be a ploy by them to throw her under the bus like they did others to get him another trial since they preformed so poorly in the trial.
It makes you wonder if she hasn't done this in other cases.
Now you have to consider it.
Exactly.
I think defense made this up. They put on a lousy case. Last straw. We would have heard about these allegations before. Someone else would have said something earlier
Nothing like corrupt lawyers defending a corrupt lawyer!
Murdaugh doesn’t have a criminal attorney, he has a CRIMINAL attorney
EVERYONE deserves a FAIR TRIAL. EVERYONE.
Even woke jokes like you deserve a fair trial, biznatch! Xoxo
Alex probably paid someone to lie about all this. You know he still has that money he stole from his clients somewhere. There is no way he spent all those millions on his drug habit. He would be dead by overdose if he did that much dope.
Don’t like Alec- fine. He has the right to defense lawyers and they have a right to BE defense lawyers.
When I was on a jury..it was a bailiff that helped us out. Meaning asking what we wanted for lunch, if we needed a break, etc. No other kind of chit chat…she was very professional.
In every trial I can remember, it's always been the bailiff.
I don’t understand how she was able to interact with the jury like that either. I have never heard of anything like this. And she wrote a book! If she did this, she should never be allowed to work for the courts again. Wow!😮
@@shirleychevalier482 and it was only the book that crossed the line for jurors! they violated their oaths too, each and every one of them. The two who gave affidavits under oath should get immunity but everyone else deservers jail for this.
They've undermined the entire justice system, every case this lady was involved in should be thrown out.
I really hope this isn’t true…..It would make me horribly sad to think a clerk would have such little integrity. Hope it’s manufactured…. Even that’s horrified
She better not make Alex come back on our screens with his fake snorting. If it's true, he will have another trial.
Isn’t there some sort of law to prevent a clerk from writing a book about a trial????
I was wondering how it’s allowed that someone serving the court can write a book about one of the cases that she presided over right after the case…
Me, too. I think it's a huge conflict of interest.
That's why i think the judge is in on it. He would've said something to her otherwise to protect his own integrity.
"Low Country Clerk Karen" has an inflated view of her role and power. How many other juries did she improperly influence? Are people on death row because of her comments or observations she shared?
When Jim Griffin said that AM was shaking when they told him about this. Really?? Shaking? Was he shaking when he killed his wife & son ? A cold blooded murder shaking? 🤦🏽♀️
I thought exactly the same
Right! He is such a vile pos
The levels of unethical behavior by the Clerk of Court just gets deeper and deeper. Instead of talking to jurors to get content for her book she should’ve been serving the citizens and doing her sworn job duties especially with such a high profile case. And Becky stay off of Facebook!
I can imagine the prosecutions throwing everything inside against the wall!!! WTF…this is a never ending case
Lies, and more lies corrupt lawyers
She shouldn’t have been talking to any jurors at the site visit. She should’ve been off to the side and kept her mouth shut
How can she say it's untrue? When multiple jurors stated it was the case and in separate interviews?
My thoughts exactly
Because that’s her strategy not like she’ll admit she committed Jury tampering 😅 I’ve heard it’s 20 years if found guilty so she’ll just have to deny deny deny.
I'd like to know how much murdaugh paid
@@julielockett1812exactly with all the money involved in this case I'd say a couple jurors were paid life changing amounts of money for putting this out there just my opinion
@@ivansbaby69Absolutely! My opinion too!!!
The only person who should’ve had contact with the jurors is the Bailiff
If she’s guilty she should spend 50 years in prison for corrupting the court, if she’s innocent she should sue asses off….. anyone who accused her should be jailed as well
I wouldn’t want SLED to investigate this either
Wondering how many more trials will be appealed if she was the law clerk in those?
That tells you what the attorney thinks of the jurors. Spending their time on "dirt roads" in whatever county. So arrogant.
This sounds fishy to me! Was she put up to do this by the Defense team-in case they lost????
No she did it so she can make money off her book. Why else would she get someone kicked off the jury that she thought would vote not guilty ? If anything she would have left the person on the jury so their could me a mistrial. Just accept the fact that she did this for her own selfish gain and nothing more.
Was she put up to possibly facing actual charges of jury tampering, losing her career, & opening the door to every trial she had anything to do with, now having to be double checked? Do you really think she’d be willing to put that all on the line, simply to do a “favor” for the defense?
You think the defense made her write a book and go on signing tour also? Tell me you're stupid without telling me you're stupid.
Why did that clerk think it’s their responsibility to do that? They should get some jail time and be fined if it’s true.
Money money 💰 why else come on she's trying to retire it, not like she's going to jail 😮
Then the jurors should be imprisoned too. They were asked every day if they discussed the case with anyone and they kept silent.
"18:38 "...which I understood to mean that he was guilty" - and what is your understanding of the reason of having a trial at all, and what do you think your job is in the court room???? 🙄 If jurors can be influenced this easily, they should be ashamed of their own stupidity.
Does she have that much power to do this? Then she should be held accountable. I never heard about a book deal until this came out.
But then they gonna complain that with a previous guilty verdict and bad publicity Alex can’t get an impartial jury 😂
Few jurors were interviewed after the verdict & did not say any of this sort of tampering occured!
How could Alex point a finger at anyone profiting from a book when he stole from clients he was paid to represent and protect? That man and his defenders are all slime and I’m thinking Buster falls in that catagory as well
Because Clerk Becky is a ELECTED public official and should not profit personally from doing her elected job duties. This was a dumb move on her part AND also greedy
@@amynickerson4258exactly . What part of this can't they understand
Buster has had no charges and is innocent at this time. The young man lost his mother and brother and his father. He has been accused of horrible things with no proof. It is not his fault that he was raised as privileged by both mom and dad. And now he is being judged because he is having a hard time believing his father killed them..I just hope you are judged as you are judging this young man! Shame on you!!!
The problem is not the book. The problem is that the clerk pushed the jurors to give the verdict that helped her book. She has no business writing any book while on the clerk position.
You are justifying her behavior because you feel the defendant is a crook and their samsies?
Did some of that missing Murdaugh money make it to those Jurors? Hmmmm
Judge Newman ruled a tight courtroom. He wouldn’t have tolerated any misconduct.
He didn’t know it was happening !
You know nothing
He did run a tight courtroom for sure, but he might not have known she was doing it. And the jurors probably had no idea she shouldn't have been in there. We don't know when she was going in there. Remember he would go to his chambers during breaks, so she could have gone in there then. In all of the trials I've watched, the bailiffs have been the ones who went to the jury room, collected their notebooks, etc
Even if this man is guilty, this is America and he deserves a fair trial
A fair trial in America? The judges are political appointees, politically and racially biased, and corrupt Epstein travelers to boot. Especially in this particular jurisdiction. The judges are all complicit in Murdaugh's financial perversions
Exactly
idk why people are underplaying this. sworn affidavits from the jurors? this is bad bad. idk what that clerk was thinking
Shame on her!!😢. If there is a new trial, the jury should be requestered and not with that court clerk! Also, everyone needs a break…not just smokers!
If it's true, my guess is she'll be fired.
@@zxy78267I would think so!
Yes, we know who you are!....a very cool Vinnie! I love how you present the cases, evidence, explain the process, etc. Thanks!!
I am sorry for the prosecutors who put their heart and soul in this case. I hope the clerk will never be allowed to walk in a courtroom again. 👎👎👎👎👎
I'll bet they're boiling!
Thanks for bringing the show back boys!
I always thought it was suspect when they switched out that juror last minute.
I thought it was really weird. I assumed she was involved in some kind of misconduct. Clearly Judge Newman trusted the clerk. I'm sure he's going to be really angry that she did this.
Thank you for reporting on these issues
New trial or not , he still gunned down Maggie and her son , who else did ?
This is an indictment on the integrity of the legal system and the collusive culture in THR lowcountry.
Bingo!!
And that's the best he could come up with C'mon Alex be a man you killed your family Live With It
He’s still facing a Lifetime for Financial Criming…
💯 He will die in prison.
Someone said that he'd be in a federal prison for those, and that's what he wants because it's better. I know nothing about prisons, though, so I don't know if that could be true. Alec is still getting in trouble in prison. Big surprise! It's clear by all the things he's done that he thinks rules don't apply to him. And they apparently didn't apply to his kids, either. Paul was in trouble for the boat crash, and Buster cheated on an exam and got kicked out of law school. When I see families like this, I'm glad I'm not rich.
What about the trickle effect on every other matter before that court where that clerk was a participant? Seems like every defense attorney who tried a case in that court would be chomping at the bit to get their case reopened because of potential malfeasance…
I call BS. Hes guilty as hell
Doesn't matter if he's guilty or not....one great thing about our country is our rules and protections under the law. This woman is so very arrogant and her book speaks to so much impropriety. She thinks she is above the law ...I hope she gets time for this and that the state freezes her bank accounts in order to pay for a new trial.
He has the right for a fair trial!
It was! His defense screwed up multiple times!
Becky Hill should hire Mark Tinsley
It’s not about Guilt or Innocence it’s about the right to a fair and impartial trial. Thanks Clerk Becky for causing this case to be overturned on appeal. Wonder if you’ll be re-elected
Very Disturbing about Elected Clerk of Court
Jurors have no reason to lie!!!!!!!! I'll take the word of jurors over the hungry prosecutor's.
dude lies constantly. the evidence shows that he deserves to be in the hole for life.
That's true but did the clerk hurt or help his case
People like you make me sick. He deserves the death penalty if found guilty. HOWEVER, we have a justice system and of this is true, there should be another trial. You overlooking that is pretty sad. You need to look inside of yourself and figure out what's wrong.
Yo homie tell me what evidence :D there's the video when he lied about his location. That's it.
Well if he gets a new trial let's hope they seek the death penalty this time
If they wanted justice done right so badly, why didn't any of them say something at the time? Lawyers.. Lol
Ok, so if this is true, the clerk of court should be prosecuted and made to pay restitution to the state or county taxpayers for the cost of the 1st trial.
With that said, has it crossed anyone else's mind that these jurors could have been bought off to say these things? I mean, fixing juries, having LE and prosecutors in their pockets, and being corrupt is what this family and their lawyers are known for, right?!
Either way, I agree with Vinnie. He is guilty as sin and was caught having been at the scene minutes before the murders occurred and lied about it! That is until he heard himself in court and could no longer tell that lie.
However, at the end of the day, everyone deserves a fair trial no matter their guilt.
Rebecca Hill had a relationship with Alex's family. They have known each other for years. Check to see if Alex stole money from her family. Then you would have motive.
How much is the defence paying these jurors to say this?
Anyone else recently convicted in this court needs to investigate whether she also tampered with their case. I guess now she will have to use the profits from her book for some mighty expensive legal talent.
Vinny you crack me up and love watching you discuss issues.
Well, how that court reporter got away with it to this point, is beyond me. Not one juror said anything? Cray.
It’s the court clerk, not a court reporter. She peer pressured the jurors, biznatch!
Exactly!
Well if it’s true she didn’t let them get smoke breaks they may have wanted out asap 😅 so they didn’t say anything until they got their fix. The smokers probably rushed the decision that’s what they’re alleging.
She also called jurors at their home and said do not trust him, and spoke to one juror privately when on a field trip to view the home, everyone witnessed that. This reporter missed some facts.@@lo_2710
You forgot Fat and destitute....@@bonjovirocks24
Those people that think that Alex is not guilty are the same that think that Trump is not guilty and a good president
Put that woman in jail, ASAP!!!!!!
Not another penny should be spent on this murderer. Both his lawyers are as sleazy as him.
I agree with you Vinnie !! I've watched you way back when your show was with Nancy Grace ❤ I love you both !!! Enjoying your show thank you
What a bunch !! the moral outrage by Alex !! he said he was not there when his wife and son were shot he was there we heard his voice he DID IT !! i wonder what he was doing on the computer to have it taken from him ?
Money talks and bullsh!t walks...smh
If these corrupt allegations prove true, the court clerk better be prosecuted! All the poor witnesses having to testify again it's tragic.
Have you checked jurors' bank accounts?
My thought too
Murdaugh has reputation of jury tampering
Exactly !!
See, I don't think multiple jurors & a random ex-husband who are willing to sign an affidavit and testify under oath could be criminally prosecuted plus, 2 very successful lawyers who have huge law firms willing to risk their careers & possibly even disbarred if it came out this way all a lie. It sounds to me that this clerk knew how high profile this case would be, and she had the book idea from the beginning. If this is all true whether you believe Alex is guilty or not, he deserves a fair trial. Everyone deserves a fair trial.
@@cynthiasnodgrass8071 I would say the same thing in a normal case. Considering decades of corruption with the Murdaugh family and the County, I don’t think it’s a stretch to think there is possibly ongoing corruption.
I wonder why the jurors didn’t speak up during the trial?
A court clerk, advising the jurors???? OMG! Unbelievable. Mind boggling.
So he can kill his wife and son, admittedly then instead of accepting his future and responsibility he looks for a way to wriggle out of it? That just says everything! 🇮🇪☘️
If this is true, why didnt the jurors say anything ? At the time ? .
Vinnie, Vinnie, Vinnie, you absolutely MUST stop talking over your guests when they speak. Or interrupting them when they are answering YOUR questions. It's rude and uncomfortable to watch, off-putting and unprofessional. Quit it!!
I think Alex killed them at 8:49 then he hosed himself off then changed clothes took the guns to Almeda... where the heck they are we'll never know ...he's guilty as heck even if they retry him he's guilty as heck... I think the defense did a bad job... they opened the door a few times ...all the money stealing coming in and I thought the prosecution team was phenomenal! Love your show Vinnie... you are great Love your show Vinny you are great!
I think he had them killed did not actually do it himself.
The guns are buried in the coffin of the father !
oh wow @@laurellynn8496
How ironic. A guy who screwed people his whole life now complaining about being screwed
Is he going to manage crying on demand as last time? Also, don’t forget that Popo thing. It really moved us.
Ugh, that was absolutely annoying. Once was bad enough, but then he just kept on saying it. Cringe
How convenient there’s an “out” for Murdaugh. Something about all this does not pass the sniff test.
Consider all the corruption that has been exposed in the low country: Could those jurors been bribed/paid off by someone to file those affidavits? Certainly buying people off is not unheard of by the powers that be.
That what I'm wondering has some one got to them
I believe the jurors. No way would they fabricate such a thing. The clerk's action are absolutely egregious, and if true, she should be held responsible. A new trial should be granted.
The problem is, when they select jurors, they don't look at the IQ. Jurors were asked every single day "have you discussed the case with *anyone"* and they kept silent. Shame on them.
"18:38 "...which I understood to mean that he was guilty" - and what is your understanding of the reason of having a trial at all, and what do you think your job is in the court room???? 🙄 If jurors can be influenced this easily, they should be ashamed of their own stupidity.
‘If this is true’, it’s appalling and she should face the consequences.
She deserves to go to prison for the rest of her life
Did Becky Hill deliberately fo this out of loyalty to that family?
Well, if Alex didn’t not get a fair trial,
he deserves a fair trial
@@49ersfan834 i don’t think 💭 so 🤔
I'm confused...you begin by saying you are very skeptical of this claim and then continue to provide many examples if the clerk's inappropriate behavior that leads to the likelihood that the defense's allegations are true.
Alex is NOT AN ATTORNEY
He just plays one in prison 🤣
Yes he is!
@@peachpi4025😂
@@linneaberger1925 nope
The fact that she wrote a book, accompanied certain jurors to New York, and acting like she convicted AM in the interviews that she gives…it tells me that all of this is true.
He faces 900 yrs for his financial crimes. This psycho liar is so desperate.
Meanwhile he continues to manipulate his son into believing he's innocent.
Man up Alick...will never happen. Pathetic..
This appeal will fail and if he gets a new trial ... another guilty verdict.
Even if one juror in a potential retrial finds reasonable doubt, you're right: his sentencing for the myriad financial crimes will equate to life in prison.
It sounds mean, but I hope he gets his hopes built up big time and crashes into dust.
Both the guilty and the innocent are entitled to a fair trial.
These attorneys watch too many movies “They want the FBI”
1 trial or 30 trials, still guilty
Vinnie you do a tremendous job on this channel ! Keep it up - watching from the UK x
What I am getting is they did not realise they were unduly being influenced by Ms. Hill, until the book came out!
Did not a witness state on the stand that when they went to the site that the Clerk and foreperson was off to the side blah blah blah.. this smells
His lawyers, literally, tried to reach out to all of those jurors... like tracking them down, driving down long dirt roads to their homes and knocking on their front doors lol... Desperate sore loser lawyers.?.
Alec is having a beef jerky party tonight
I am out of mental and emotional bandwidth for this family. (Yet here I am, I realize this. It’s a sickness.)
This is huge!
If this is true, then why would the jurors go to the defense attorney and not the prosecutor or the judge? Its a little shady to me that this is completely true. Defense attorney speaking in private, who's to say they weren't leading a response from these jurors. And wouldn't the jurors mention something to the judge, bailiff, at the time this was happening?