A Complete Review of Live Action One Piece
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 чер 2024
- After a long wait, the One Piece Netflix adaptation is finally out and it managed to surprise almost everyone with how decent it actually was. But does it succeed at adapting Oda's manga properly to the big screen?
Today we're going to cover all the reasons why it does, and why it doesn't - in a top down, nitpicky, overly lengthy analysis of the first season. Relax and enjoy!
ORIGINAL, UNALTERED VIDEO HERE:
rumble.com/v3frgq0-a-complete...
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
1:24 Visuals and Performances (Positives)
11:11 Visuals and Performances (Negatives)
19:33 Soundtrack
27:03 Storytelling (Positives)
54:58 Storytelling (Negatives)
1:18:29 Thanks for Watching!
This video contains spoilers for the One Piece live action series and manga up to chapter 1090
#onepiece #OPLA #liveaction #onepieceliveaction #netflix
--------------------------------
My Twitter: / thehiddenlsland
The Hidden Island Clips: / @theclippedisland
My Gaming Channel: / @thehiddenarcade
Join my discord: / discord
For business inquiries, please reach out to:
thehiddenislandlive@gmail.com - Розваги
The lack of focus on usopp during his own arc and the handling of arlong park were two of my biggest issues with this adaptation and you nail it on the head the reasons why. Great review!
I went into this live action expecting to laugh at how bad it would be, and by the third episode I couldn’t stop watching. Fantastic adaptation and they nailed the castings, the passion from every actor was so noticeable
I'm the same and want more. I'm so happy kinda tear up how great it was.
I couldn't disagree more every line, frame and second was some of the worst inventions of humanity. Up their with some of the worst crimes humanity has ever committed.
it is absolutely fucking terrible, i mean the Netflix meme is real af with it.
@@-tom-8720
You got an actual comment to make instead of some abstract shit that it was bad? Why did you feel it's bad? How did they fuck it up?
@@atharwamalawade259 (/s) (probably)
"they actually kill people in this"
Pell: chuckle, I'm in danger
It's more explicitly laid out in the manga that Luffy's real reason for destroying Nami's room is because he's trying to destroy the product/memories of Nami's abuse. And if you've already read the manga I could see how you'd think that that wouldn't be clear to a new viewer. But I still think it's pretty obvious. If my first exposure to One Piece was the live action, I'm sure I would still pick up on that. Luffy does it right after looking at the chains, and then us being shown the flashback, etc.
Also something no one's mentioned yet: they never explain how Morgans supposedly captured Kuro but then Kuro is still alive! Like what? That's a straight up plot hole, no?
That’s not a plot hole. They explained and showed that Morgan was corrupt and a liar. The assumption in the LA I suppose is that Kuro simply tricked him or Morgan made the claim for no real reason but arrogance.
this kinda bugs me. a major complaint that I keep seeing is that they're too explicit with all of the messages, but in the one scene where they kind of let you figure out the reasoning for yourself everybody says it wasn't spelled out enough lol
yea hopefully in s2 the dialogue is more nuanced.@@lookatdemijipers
You can also see scars from Capt Morgan's battle with Kuro on his arm in episode 1. They do a close up of his forearm (non axe arm) when he's in battle with Luffy and Zoro.
kid luffy didnt grab the devil fruit randomly, we see luffy hear shanks saying its his most valuable treasure, and then luffy repeats this to makino, so the reason luffy found and ate it is because he knew it was valuable
You’re right I missed that part somehow on my watchthrough, my bad fam
@@TheHiddenIsland- Its weird because everyone I watch had the same complaint, I thought I was the one missing something lol
I will say on the criticism of why Buggy doesn't just separate when tied up, to me this is forgivable b/c even in the manga/anime Nami just ties up all his body parts. We've seen that Buggy can separate himself to basically particle size pieces in Marine Ford vs Mihawk so there isn't really a reason why Nami tying him up would actually work in the original version. So since this is a logical inconsistency in the source material I just let it slide.
Buggy can only control his body a certain radius around his head, and he can't make his feet fly, his power is explained in detail during impel down. So as long as you keep his severed bodyparts far enough away he is helpless
@ManOfTheWeek596 I'm well aware of how Buggys power works. None of what you describe explains why Buggy couldn't separate his bodies further to escape being tied up when we've seen him separate into very tiny pieces during marine ford.
@lavallur no my friend, you are still not understanding the situation. We are talking about in the live action when Arlong ties up Buggy and interrogates him. He has all his parts and can therefore separate. My initial point was that even though this is technically a plot hole I let it slide b/c even in the anime they have this same plot hole. During the fight with luffy, Nami ties up his parts with some rope, which stops him from recompleting himself. Which doesn't make much sense b/c he wasn't far from his parts and should be able to separate more to escape them, since during Marine Ford we saw he can separate into basically small particles when he had to avoid Mihawks slash.
Hopefully that makes sense
Pink panther kuro song woulda been dope
@lavallur I didn't miss his point but whatever dude. Agree to disagree
About luffy going straight for the devil fruit, there's a scene earlier where one of shanks' crew almost drops the box with the fruit and shanks says something on the lines of "this thing is worth more than the rest combined". Luffy hears this and thinks that if he eats the fruit, HE will become worth so much that shanks is forced to take him to the sea. He says as much in a later scene. Does feel like a better reason than "I ate the fruit for dessert" that he comes up with in the manga.
The reason Luffy picked the gum gum chest and the reason he ate it is because he heard Shanks comment to ‘not drop it cause its worth alot’ to Lucky Roux. Luffy even comments how he ate Shanks most expensive treasure. And it makes sense why it is such a treasure with the context of Nika now.
Your points on Arlong Park were right on. Nami/Emily killed the “help me” scene but the payoff wasn’t the same for me.
The only other negative that bugged me was Mihawk instant transmissioning to Baratie, how’d he even know Luffy was there.
To conjure an explanation for Mihawk, if you were hunting Garp’s grandson, you absolutely know where to guess first. They love their food. It’s also like a tavern of sorts, and that’s where people gather to socialise so you’d be able to ask around for a straw hat pirate.
@@Lumpyrox1412 Tru it makes more sense if you consider Baratie to be a popular well known destination, which it is deffs more so in the Live Action. I was still thinkin it's a place you'd luck into finding like the manga.
Observation haki lol
It was hinted that Mihawk saw whats happening in Marejois in the Reverie. In my head canon Mihawk can see a vast distance (hence hawkeye), thats what is special about his Obs Haki,.
@@Mooglatanso you’re just stupid then 👍
If Morgan was like in the manga, it would've set really bad expectations for the series.
Having the first villain be so absolutely evil that he goes beyond the limits of "so evil it's goofy" was bad even for the manga, tbh. Way, way over the top, and in live action it would've been even worse.
I get that it's a negative for people who want most things 1:1 with the manga, and I get it, but personally I think the live action change for Morgan was for the better. He came across as a very strict, egotistical and corrupt marine, and you really didn't need much more than that.
I do think, however, that there should've been a few more scenes of him belittling his own son to get across the idea that he really was a piece of shit, tho.
omg the Epic rap battles of history bit was sooooo fucking good. This is why Hidden is my 🐐
Straw hats dancing in the background lmaoo
It was set up in the bar on shells town that some food and drinks are just blue and green and weird colors in this world. It’s there but super easy to miss
Why isnt this the "greatest" review? 😂
If I could have uploaded the original version I would have done that title 😆
I can’t tell you how much I hated the close up fish eye shots and I skate so like I live fisheye lenses to film with but god it was so distracting in this show, but honestly didn’t have many more complaints I think it captured the spirit of the show so well and I hope they can keep it up also good review my guy
Gum Gum fruit doesn't look natural??
NO SHITT!!
Glad you were able to get it uploaded!
How could you miss Binks Sake in the music section!? When I heard it I felt my heart swell and I thought “This live action feels like home” 🥹
Also just weird how in the manga the fruit was considered important enough that shanks kept it on his person. But in the live action there is a room filled with treasures that isn’t guarded by atleast one person or being checked on, also if he found the fruit gross why did he finish eating it? In the manga he doesn’t eat the whole fruit and lastly (probably the funniest) luffy as a kid is black/white mix with no accent then he grows up and becomes Mexican with an accent?
19:13 y’all, we non fans were deeply moved by this scene. Many reactors seem to tear up at it. It’s so interesting to see impressions and opinions from fans old and new. Those of us with expectations and without.
I just finished it today and absolutely loved it. I have gripes but I'll trade all that to be able to watch One Piece with my family. Plus now my family ACTUALLY wants to the anime One Piece. So yeah huge W.
Hell yeah, that's awesome. I watched it when I was younger and now me and daughter just finished it. Good times
@@ROOSTER333 That's awesome brotherman!
I loved the demonstration of the closeup shots. Made me laugh early in the morning
Instarted watching one piece about 2010, life happened and never read the mangas but the anime was badass. Just watched the netflix series and i was actually really really impressed. And season 1 is always the least budget cant wait for it to keep getting better
great video. your humor gets me man cant count the amount times i laughed lmao
Glad someone else pointed out the cinematography issues with closeups. Really feel amateurish when it’s used so often. 16:00
1:20:13 great video great breakdown of your thought. Don’t agree with everything but you largely explained your reasoning well which is really what’s important.
1:13:49 the map room looks like part of an attic they just left Nami in. Like a dog they want to potty train before letting roam free in the house.
In my opinion, the show effectively conveyed the emotions needed. Again, without anything to compare with? I was wildly invested throughout the whole fight. Just on the edge of my seat, mate. Luffy’s horror at Nami’s imprisonment was clear. I was grinning while Luffy made Arlong destroy himself in response.
His original reasoning does add a lot of sentiment, I do agree there. Just think of it as something people like me get to be surprised and moved by for the first time, just like you did. While reading it. Or watching the anime. In fact, that’s how I feel many of your complaints could be, with all due respect, countered with.
My question is how well did the scene work as a climax for the story told in the live action? Divorced from how it could’ve been in your expectations.
The anime and manga are better at telling the story overall. No denying it. Manga’s the medium Oda in mind while telling the story. Anime is a mostly faithful retelling. If you’d never experienced either first, would your feelings still be as negative? I didn’t find the repetition of “of course I will” to be corny, personally. The whole scene felt so intense to me.
No shade tossing from me. Your feelings are as valid as mine. I can’t help but feel a lot of your criticisms are personal expectation based. Which is completely fair. I know I’ve felt the same about, say, Batman or Spider-Man live action adaptations.
I didn’t really like Toby’s Spider-Man. As I rewatched I realized the jokes just weren’t there. No Way Home Toby feels like how the nostalgia glasses make us remember him. That’s a Tony Spidey I would want more of. Same for the Keaton Batman films. Loved them at the time. Now I’m mostly disappointed. Joker murdered the Waynes? Tim Burton’s Batman straight up killed people. Cat-Woman made no sense. She survived plummeting into an alleyway filled with a bunch of cats and then she’s got, what? Cat powers? Looked like some kinda magical transformation happened with her. Not inspiration like with Bruce and the bat. I liked Penguin more as a cultured criminal. Not sewer penguin Tarzan.
Still, divorced from my wants and desires lies Tim Burton movies from his prime. They’re objectively good. I can’t deny it. They’re not for me any longer. Genuinely loved them as a child. However, I’m happy Batman the Animated Series was made because of them. That’s still as great as I remembered. Better even.
…I went on a bat-tangent. Again. Ha ha! Great review. Subscribed.
Luffy takes the chest with the devil fruit because he heard them say it was more valuable than the rest of the treasure but it’s still awful because now it makes young Luffy look bad stealing shanks most valuable possession and eating it just to spite him. It doesn’t feel like Luffy.
now this is a big fat review. i'll watch it tomorrow morning so you can have my undivided attention.
I hope Matt Owens sees this review specifically!
one of the things I love about Matt Owens is you know that he's watching each and every one of these reviews lol
Moments were definitely abridged or cut for the sake of framing the story and characterization. Sanji not being present for zoro's fight is huge. Everyone besides nami joined because the plot requires it. Almost like a DND campaign. Lots of complaints, but it did so many things well that I appreciate it for what it is.
I watched on rumble, but rumbles interface is goofy sometimes
I think they could’ve maybe had Zoro witness Sham and Buchi bring Merry to the well and then he follows them there and they have a fight scene where he gets pushed in and hits his head really hard or something. They’ll think they’ve killed him but he’s so tough it wasn’t a problem. That would’ve made the Black Cat Pirates look less stupid and Zoro seem more observant and also more strong.
If hidden talks we listen!! enough said. Congrats on the 30k
Thank you!!!
Great job bro, definitely feel you on those close ups hopefully they stay in season 1.
I wanted to defend Luffy being hurt by Arlong's punches with the faint memory of fishman karate being able to strike devil fruit users due to shock waves traveling through their body's water content. However this is just a specific named attack named "Samegawara Seiken" and to my knowledge Arlong doesn't even use fishman karate, he just uses certain moves that are similar. That was indeed a big blunder. What they could have done if they didn't want Arlong to use his nose, teeth and sword for some reason is just to retcon him using a move similar to Samegawara Seiken.
Its way too late for this comment, but they originally wanted to do 10 episodes but had to slim down to 8. The Arlong vs Luffy fight for example was planned as much longer with luffy actually using his fishnet attack and dodging arlongs blade.
They also planned a big fight with zoro and hatchan, where they would fight in the basement and hatchan would fight from the ceiling. They had some plans for a rotating camera.
Good video tho! Iam really curious on how they going to powerscale the crew up. Because if they want to do the big moments in alabasta justice, zoro for example need to tank more then a bottle to the head.
I just finished the Live Action. I pretty much agree with most of what you said. What bothered me was Zoros "Youre not my boss" thing in the first few episodes which is a bit meh. He seemed more loyal in the original where hes just like "Aight fuck it you saved my life, might as well make the best of it".
And also its a bit sad that some side characters were dropped or reduced but I can understand that they obviously couldnt fit in all characters. I think its a bit sad that Nami was reduced to the "actually hated one" in her village whereas in the original everyone knew she was collecting 100million but pretended they didnt know in order to not put any pressure on her.
Also sadge that we didnt see Yosaku and Johny.
Overall I was still rooting for the strawhats tho. The changes they introduced made me excited to see how it would continue. A complete 1:1 copy wouldve certainly not felt that exciting
On Arlong, it felt like they gave him Haki. In the manga we didn't really get any information on Haki for a long time, but just as we're getting more information on Garp and Coby in S1 LA it feels like we're getting teasers for Haki with Mihawk and Arlong. (At least when I watched it).
Maybe Arlong is meant to have Haki, or maybe he's just that strong. It's not easy to hurt Luffy with punches if you don't have Haki, but Rob Lucci managed it in the Enies Lobby arc.
59:00 The reason Luffy picked that specific chest is that Luffy was on the ship when Shanks told Lucky Rou not to drop it as it was worth a lot more than everything else there. So Luffy probably opened it out of curiosity to see what could be such a great treasure in a such a small box.
I didn't notice the cgi but "you ATe it" killed me
I think Garp's different characterization is because of this Luffy/Koby - Roger/Garp parallel they're going for heavy af in the LA. I think that's why they added Garp to Roger's execution too
Oh and also why Koby/Garp/Helmeppo are basically main characters now
My guy the last ten minutes of this is absolute fire and the most developed critique of this show I’ve heard yet and it really captures my detachment at the end of the season!
The writers need to hire you as a consultant!
This is a minor correction that doesn't matter to your critique (which I agree with heavily in regards to the blue soup, and Usopp screentime, and especially with all the Arlong Park stuff, and you didn't even mention the worst bit where they completely rewrote Nojiko's character just to make Nami feel more completely on her own before meeting Luffy and joining the Strawhats when, if she doesn't have that honest emotional connection to her sister who knows the truth all those years why does she even give a shit about the village aaaahh) but the Baratie arc in the live action is not longer because they stay overnight, it's shorter. Luffy's attempt to recruit Sanji is one of the few times the manga explicitly slows down. They loiter at the restaurant for two full days in the manga, four days in the anime! The biggest plot hole in the East Blue is how Zeff didnt go bankrupt/Luffy didnt starve to death in the interim.
But yeah. 5 or 6 good episodes was 5 or 6 more than I could have hoped for, and Orange Town/Buggy was immaculate, so I'm looking forward to season 2!
Inaki's take on Luffy definitely doesn't play into the "Luffy is an 8 year old in the body of a 20 year old" vibe that he gives off in the other versions. I think he's a lot more of a "I'm slightly autistic and don't know social queues or personal space but am just vibin and having a good time." sorta vibe? In a good way. The scene with him and Nami with the safe where he tries to listen to her crack the code is a perfect example I think. I hope he plays more into the childish mentality luffy has overall but i am not holding my breath.
I also think the delivery of some lines by Sanji's kid version was, extremely bad. After Zeff's reveal of his missing leg, his line "You ate your own leg?!" is just, delivered in such a way that is so fucking funny to me because of the accent.
I was watching the first few episodes with family friends and they thought Shanks had a DF because he wasnt swimming. I explained it was something else, a power unrelated that isnt explained for a while, but i just realized how fucking right you are about him not swimming being so important.
Spitting island is back
One of the creators mentioned they didn’t have the budget to do Loguetown and it makes sense given the season got cut from 10 episodes to 8
Great video. Thank you! Totally agree that Arlong Park felt like it didn't fully pack a punch like in the Manga (pun intended). Still a very fun show, but they missed a much stronger finale by the way they did Arlong Park.
Oh snap, here we go!
I wish they toned Kuro's outfit down tbh, his suit looked like shit
Yeah my mother kept saying he looks like a doll. Especially with his uber slicked hair.
Probably my fave review of the show so far. Got some good points across
The close up camera angle reminds of the scene in live action cat in the hat where it shows the neighbor through the peephole angle. The neighbor also got the Coby glasses and it’s just uncannily similar
Hard disagree about the music lmfao... there several full on rock shows with electric instruments and speakers and what not. DJ DenDen Mushi in this bitch!
Off the top of my head theres like atleast one in every movie plus Brooke's concert, Franky uses a microphone and amp and Queen literally raps.. in his way... but hes clearly more influenced by modern music than anything from the real pirate era...
25:15 bro brook is literally a rock star. Hard disagree.
Actually think the fisheye gives the series an Unreal absurd aspect making us supend disbelief easier
59:05 Luffy says later the Gum-Gum fruit was the most valuable treasure Shanks had. Since he ate it? That made HIM Shanks’ most valuable treasure. The reason Luffy ate the fruit was to basically a mix of spite and hope. He overheard Shanks say how valuable that treasure was. So he had a legitimate reason to go after that particular box.
18:29 Joke of the year! 😂
I feel like 1 thing that's missing is you know how in the anime they would have a scene like with shanks giving luffy the hat and then the "camera" pulls back to show a wider frame with a "don" effect. I'm not sure that straight up works 1-to-1 in a live action, but the adaptation could benefit from some equivalent to that
Couldn't agree more with everything you said. Both the good and the bad. Spot on.
1:11:15 absolutely makes sense her turnaround. Nami has been given hope. She’s got people with her. They didn’t have enough time to include Nami in other ways. Adding her to the Walk was economical and made no difference to me as a new viewer. She didn’t feel out of place, is what I mean. In fact, I kinda wish she had originally made the walk with them. I only thought about it after the fact of seeing the anime and live action. At the time I was too busy bawling my eyes out and cheering as the men walked to the park, while those two bounty hunters talked them up like proto Bartolomeos.
I really don’t like how ussop doesn’t really do anything in syrup village. He saves kaya once by shooting kuros hand but that’s it. He didn’t even try to hit his head. Then with the stuff with the marines right after, ussop can’t even load the canon.
It makes Luffy seem even stupider than usual getting this random guy who can’t do anything at all on the crew. And I don’t think he ever mentions being a brave warrior or anything like that.
I loved all of it and watching it with my friends got them into it and now they wanna start the anime
They could very well still do Garp's introduction in Water 7 the same as how it was done originally except for the original four straw hats are freaking out by hearing a very distinct ogre-esque shouting from outside followed by Garp proceeding to blow the wall down and the introduction ensues with the live actions interpretation of how it would play out
nah that epic rap battles of history moment was kino
The epic rap battle had me😂🤣🤣
I am strapped in
I think one reason I think they left Logue town for season two, is they plan to for season two to end before or right at getting to Alabasta. There is no way season 2 can end with Crocodiles defeat
Nice review, regarding soundtracks I disagree on the villains ost I thought kuro and especially arlong’s music was perfect and it got me hype when watching. But overall well done this is a great video
Idk what rumble is but I watched the whole video there
it makes OP feel fresh again
dude good video and all ...
but how about you give us the rest of that ERB Luffy vs Arlong ?!! that shit was good
Posted by popular demand ...
I feel like the writers have more of an opportunity to delve into Luffy's psychology on a deeper level and I want them to take full advantage of that opportunity rather than just skirt pass all that nuance. Like when Nami confronts Luffy and tells him about how captains have to make the hard choices or whatever I love Inaki's response "Why does everyone keep telling me that?" It's so sincere. So pure. Like he genuinely is missing the point. Nami continues and tells him that he let Zoro almost die for the sake of his dream and Luffy of course sticks to his ideology of never getting in the way of others ambitions. Of course, this has consequences. Grave ones. And that is what I want. I want consequences for thinking like Luffy. Thinking like a Shonen protagonist. I don't like how Garp just accepts Luffy's choice to be a pirate. People are who they are but he is dedicated to his job however goofy he might be. Garp would never accept something like that. He'd be happy Luffy is his own man but would not cease pursuing him relentlessly because he is on the wrong side of the law.
I had all the same issues with the show and liked all the same things as well. Only difference is my massive issues with Garp as a whole.
Heavy on the camera being too close. I really dont need to see each hair follicle on mihawk to see its a good costume 😂
I have dancing strawhats PTSD since I watched the whole review.
16:47 I’m gonna say the close ups are meant to invoke the manga. A lot of time dialogue is given just like that in comics overall. Not only manga. To be honest? I just rewatched the first episode with a buddy last night. Still didn’t have issues with the close ups. Never knew people complained about them until watching OP fan reviews. I myself only caught up to the manga because I saw the live action. That was my first exposure to the franchise. Loads of new reactors and reviewers didn’t seem to comment on the close ups one way or the other
I saw the LA at the end of last Nov. Immediately started the anime, dubbed (it was great, the Funimation actors did fantastic work) until there wasn’t any more episodes of that. Then I continued with the sub. I love both casts and think they’re excellent for different reasons. Been weekly there since end of Jan. So I read the manga from the start. My first actual One Piece cliffhanger just so happens to be a freaking break period. Ha ha! Meaning I’m up to date as of the beginning of March. I’m about to experience weekly OP for the first time during Egghead!
Anyway, my tangent aside, I think most new fans don’t mind the close ups. We’re too caught up in an unknown story. People familiar with One Piece may have time to consider more of the visuals. Some undoubted will have relatively negative opinions.
I was gonna watch this expecting to cringe at live action and trash on it, but it was competent and i appreciate that.
Let's go
1:08:56 now these I feel like are not good criticisms making complaints about it not being 1to1 is just not useful. The taking his teeth out to use as weapons would just not work in live action. The nose things similarly just doesn’t fit. More water things certainly would have been nice but that would have been rough on the budget.
1:10:00 strong disagree. The scene worked so well. Luffy places the hat on first Nani’s noggin, then takes a second to say “of course I will.” I felt like that was a deeply moving moment. Nami still has time to realize what Luffy entrusted her with. So to did we in the audience. Tears. Just tears as Luffy’s passion to protect his friend grows, until he’s shouting it for the world to hear.
Your expectations and comparisons understandably color your opinion here. The moment as it was drawn clearly hit hard for you. It’s fair to feel disappointed if you’re hoping for a more accurate adaptation. Personally? I’m annoyed the scene takes place at night. I wish it were the day like in the anime. It looked too dark, like much of modern cinema.
franky breakin down 💃🕺💃🕺
1:00:11 🤓 um, actually 😂 there's a part where Luffy is watching Shanks and crew unloading the treasure that they undoubtedly just finished stealing from Who's-Who, and as Lucky Rou has his arms full and about drops the jewelry box the Gum-Gum fruit is in, Shanks catches it and says it's by far the most valuable piece of treasure of the haul since it's a Devil Fruit, and that he wouldn't drop it if it were a chicken leg, so I'm assuming in Luffy being mad and storming off he recognizes that box and as a way to get back at Shanks since he's a kid and don't know no better ate it and ta-da? I'm not saying it's good but that's what I understood that whole interaction as
34:00
Same with Brook ... until the new world he is only making his standard bone and pantys jokes... but i do not remember when, but Robin made his joke before he could say something and he is pissed -> this was hilarious because he was this two-joke charakter :D
And in Whole Cake Island he was the MVP!
Just watched the One Piece live action everything that took place was in a few rooms and felt claustrophobic instead of this giant world that is One Piece if felt like it everything was in a box.
Na dawg you are nitpicking. You were looking for issues if you saw that sanji green screen
The blue tea was infuriating, it felt cheap, heavy handed and stupid. It is something really absurd for an otherwise reasonable plot.
About Arlong’s theme, I really wonder if they were intentionally using trap/hip-hop for the whole “racism” undertone. Not to say it was a song but if that was their only reason I think the show would be better without it.
Also, wasn’t Papagu the starfish guy like a DJ/fashion designer? One Piece is centuries behind on technology but I think they could probably have dubstep or hip hop.
Future video idea or post. Update us on how the live action is doing monetarily what are other people/sites saying. What does season two look like the. Go in!
i can excuse the zoro bottle scene in syrup village because in real life a bottle to the head is lethal.
not the 4kids dungeon 😂😂😂
Was ur cameo real?
Garp's writing would have fit Sengoku better.
1:02:41
First episode of the series there is blue colored alcohol maybe to establish that foods and drinks in this world are all different colors. But seriously no one in their right mind would drink that blue playdough soup
DONT READ MY COMMENT HAS SPOILERS. I think roger ate the gonu gomu no mi fruit and nika rejected him and that is why he got sick and died. And before he died he told shanks to find the fruit when it revives itself and to give it to the real joy boy that is why shanks had it. But i also believe that the devil fruit are reincarnated souls trying to achieve their dreams and its not the sea making them drown but being cursed to the depths of hell. I also think roger turned evil and came back as fruit and is like a god like nika and that is the man on fire
Hey hidden, been a fan since the very first "devil Fruit origin" theory you posted. Been looking forward to more theories from you but your channel has been quite dry on theory content as of late. Are there any theories in the works? Not trying to beg for content or anything but brother I am starving for a well crafted 20+ minute video with half decent headcannon. Been so tired of the theory videos where they just say completely out of left field shit like "Rob lucci could be a member of the blackbeard pirates!!!??!?!?" Theories that have no substance/no real chance of happening in the story are boring and I think that you have NEVER once put out a theory that felt anywhere close to the trash I am used to . Much love hidden hope you get around to posting some more good content big dog I miss it.
Hey appreciate the nice comment, thanks man! To be honest I just haven’t had any great theories come to mind lately. When it comes to theory videos I find it hard to force ideas that I don’t believe in/have good evidence - which might be why you like them haha
Anyways sorry if the theory content has been lacking bro - once the chapters start coming out more often I should have more fuel to work with 💪
As someone who has read the manga, I have a lot of problems with this. But considering it is a live action, I'd say this is still great and its insane that One Piece actually got a good live action adaptation while so many others which should be much easier to adapt, failed.
no, but actually, what is that copyright dodging footage? lmao it's so distracting i can't watch the video without laughing
1:06:33 I mean I don’t feel like Luffy was really all that hurt in the first fight he was just getting thrown around.
The main issue with Luffy is facial expression. You simply can't portray the anime facial expressions.
You are in the wrong here, one piece is set in a apocolypse set up like when the world gets destroyed and most of our planet is water like the one piece world luffy knowing what a rocket is in chapter 1 franky void century that is supposed to be more advanced is more possible if the world got destroyed and imu make it regress by sharing what information can be shared so yeah totally can be a future set up not before knights and kings set up
For Garp and luffy I think it’s because of the dub. Watch it in the Japanese dub with the og garp voice actor! And we have to remember garp is a vice admiral . We only see him during chill times where we forget he’s still a really dope marine and likely a hell of a strategist
Kobe got too much screentime imo. Wanted more straw hats. Especially sanji, he blew me away, zeff too. Buggy actor also made me smile every time he was on screen.