One of the best war movies I have ever seen. The incorporation of the humanity of the average citizen with the fortitude of the soldiers struggles to defend their homeland, despite the odds of just to simply survive in their situation is remarkable. Totally a classic film.
It's an awesome movie !!! I was born in "43, during the war...I watched a lots of war movies, and realising the infinite misery, cruelty of the war, that has to withstand the population and the solders, defending the homeland so bravely.....The youth of the 21- century can't understand to be patriotic, hero for your country....Thank you.
This is the absolute best “movie with several personal stories that were made life like sharing the difficulties and different stages of Russia’s Great War”. This is simply put, A Great Movie !
This man was a political commissar. Imagine a Catholic priest in the Crusader army who took off his cross and burned it in order to save his life? It's the same with the party card. This is an attribute of commitment. How can you encourage other people to go fight and sacrifice their lives when you are trying to save your own life at any cost? At the cost of shame? Do you remember with what contempt he himself looked at the general, who took off his general's uniform and dressed up in the overcoat of a common soldier? He himself got into a similar situation with a party card. The film is about the importance of commitment, dedication and faith in the right cause for victory.
One of the best films and stories I have ever seen. On par, if not superior to "All Quiet on the Western Front', or the American story "The Red Badge of Courage'. Of technical merit, is the ingenuity to produce the film in black and white, delivering a stunning replication of historical film footage and rivetting dialogue.
The novel “LIVING AND THE DEAD” by Simonov from which is the original source of the movie, is even a better read. A brutally honest yet engaging view of the uncertain times that was 1941. A brilliant effort to make it into a movie and subtitle it as well by Mosfilm...
Впечатляюще снятый фильм, спасибо, что выложили! Хорошо сделанный, наверное, исторически близкий к сюжету, жаль, что нет немецких субтитров и даже немецкого дубляжа. beeindruckend gemachter Film, vielen Dank für's hochladen! handwerklich gut, historisch vermutlich dicht an der Geschichte, schade, dass er keine deutschen Untertitel gibt oder sogar eine deutsche Synchronisation.
Outstanding! (In the last moments of the film, there is a series of tones. Does anyone know the tune? Radio Moscow used to broadcast those notes in the moments leading up to a broadcast. I remember hearing that on my shortwave radio when I was a boy.)
Primeira parte da trilogia de simonov. Guerra e humanidade, Não se nasce soldado e O último verão. A tradução para português é muito ruim Reclama uma revisão essa obra épica pois o filme não consegue abarcar a dimensão dessa epopeia
That fixation with the "party card" is a scary reminder of the awful power of bureaucracies and the absurdity of totalitarianism, where a simple, dirty piece of paper could often have more importance than deeds or human life. Reminds me of the movie Brazil. We are not safe anywhere from these traps, now they are called "digital identity", or even worse, AI.
No one forced anyone to join the ranks of the Communist Party. The Communist Party of the USSR lost three million people killed - the most literate, the most savvy in Marxist theory. And one of the most common wishes of soldiers before the deadly battle was: If I don't come back, consider me a communist.
This man was a political commissar. Imagine a Catholic priest in the Crusader army who took off his cross and burned it in order to save his life? It's the same with the party card. This is an attribute of commitment. How can you encourage other people to go fight and sacrifice their lives when you are trying to save your own life at any cost? At the cost of shame? Do you remember with what contempt he himself looked at the general, who took off his general's uniform and dressed up in the overcoat of a common soldier? He himself got into a similar situation with a party card.
Дело не в бумажке и не в бюрократии. Дело в приверженности и искренности. Закопал партбилет, значит отрёкся. Это же была не партия чиновников. Это была партия фанатиков, готовых отдать жизнь за свои идеалы.
Beautiful camera but scenario good for sleeping. I cannot believe others say 'best movie'. It is a waste of time. 3/4 useless talk. Characters come and go. Persons don't show human contact. Storyline broken 50 pieces without glue. I'm not going to judge by the last 5 minutes. A soap opera has more content.
One of the best war movies I have ever seen. The incorporation of the humanity of the average citizen with the fortitude of the soldiers struggles to defend their homeland, despite the odds of just to simply survive in their situation is remarkable. Totally a classic film.
He is not an ordinary citizen. He is a political commissar and a representative of the regime's ideology.
It's an awesome movie !!! I was born in "43, during the war...I watched a lots of war movies, and realising the infinite misery, cruelty of the war, that has to withstand the population and the solders, defending the homeland so bravely.....The youth of the 21- century can't understand to be patriotic, hero for your country....Thank you.
Terrific movie! Thanks so much for restoring and subtitling in English.
Excellent movie. Thanks for the free movies.
Brilliant, with wonderful portrayals. A masterpiece. Thank you Mosfilm.
This is the absolute best “movie with several personal stories that were made life like sharing the difficulties and different stages of Russia’s Great War”. This is simply put, A Great Movie !
Absolutely a masterpiece…..it captures a time king forgotten
Excellent part 2, thanks again
An excellent film ably performed by outstanding actors. The photography was brilliant & English subtitles very helpful.
This man was a political commissar. Imagine a Catholic priest in the Crusader army who took off his cross and burned it in order to save his life? It's the same with the party card. This is an attribute of commitment. How can you encourage other people to go fight and sacrifice their lives when you are trying to save your own life at any cost? At the cost of shame? Do you remember with what contempt he himself looked at the general, who took off his general's uniform and dressed up in the overcoat of a common soldier? He himself got into a similar situation with a party card. The film is about the importance of commitment, dedication and faith in the right cause for victory.
Thank you for posting this magnificent movie.
One of the best films and stories I have ever seen. On par, if not superior to "All Quiet on the Western Front', or the American story "The Red Badge of Courage'. Of technical merit, is the ingenuity to produce the film in black and white, delivering a stunning replication of historical film footage and rivetting dialogue.
It's just stunning!
Another fine production from the people at Mosfilm . I always look forward to your movies .Kudos .
Thanks Mosfilm for this movie
Very good movie thank you
The novel “LIVING AND THE DEAD” by Simonov from which is the original source of the movie, is even a better read. A brutally honest yet engaging view of the uncertain times that was 1941. A brilliant effort to make it into a movie and subtitle it as well by Mosfilm...
Excellent!
1 and 2 a Treat. Thank's Mosfilms Thank's
Впечатляюще снятый фильм, спасибо, что выложили!
Хорошо сделанный, наверное, исторически близкий к сюжету, жаль, что нет немецких субтитров и даже немецкого дубляжа.
beeindruckend gemachter Film, vielen Dank für's hochladen!
handwerklich gut, historisch vermutlich dicht an der Geschichte, schade, dass er keine deutschen Untertitel gibt oder sogar eine deutsche Synchronisation.
Outstanding! (In the last moments of the film, there is a series of tones. Does anyone know the tune? Radio Moscow used to broadcast those notes in the moments leading up to a broadcast. I remember hearing that on my shortwave radio when I was a boy.)
Василий Лебедев-Кумач Песня о Родине
большое спасибо!@@desser350
Merci pour le film 😊
Сильный фильм. Спасибо!
одличан филм, хвала пуно!
Glory to 27 million Soviet people who gave their Life for us
Primeira parte da trilogia de simonov. Guerra e humanidade, Não se nasce soldado e O último verão. A tradução para português é muito ruim
Reclama uma revisão essa obra épica pois o filme não consegue abarcar a dimensão dessa epopeia
That fixation with the "party card" is a scary reminder of the awful power of bureaucracies and the absurdity of totalitarianism, where a simple, dirty piece of paper could often have more importance than deeds or human life. Reminds me of the movie Brazil.
We are not safe anywhere from these traps, now they are called "digital identity", or even worse, AI.
No one forced anyone to join the ranks of the Communist Party. The Communist Party of the USSR lost three million people killed - the most literate, the most savvy in Marxist theory. And one of the most common wishes of soldiers before the deadly battle was: If I don't come back, consider me a communist.
This man was a political commissar. Imagine a Catholic priest in the Crusader army who took off his cross and burned it in order to save his life? It's the same with the party card. This is an attribute of commitment. How can you encourage other people to go fight and sacrifice their lives when you are trying to save your own life at any cost? At the cost of shame? Do you remember with what contempt he himself looked at the general, who took off his general's uniform and dressed up in the overcoat of a common soldier? He himself got into a similar situation with a party card.
Masha is a good looking woman.
Subtitulada.en español por.favor
Me pierdo esta peli por estar en español
Where is part 1?
look on the channel. everything is there
ردح و فهلوة و لحم حمير....نصاب
First view
First comment
человек или бумажка...а как сейчас в России?
Дело не в бумажке и не в бюрократии. Дело в приверженности и искренности. Закопал партбилет, значит отрёкся. Это же была не партия чиновников. Это была партия фанатиков, готовых отдать жизнь за свои идеалы.
У "цилизованных" еще больше бумажек.
@@veronicaochneva9464 у
У цивилованых в России, или в мире?
Beautiful camera but scenario good for sleeping. I cannot believe others say 'best movie'. It is a waste of time. 3/4 useless talk. Characters come and go. Persons don't show human contact. Storyline broken 50 pieces without glue. I'm not going to judge by the last 5 minutes. A soap opera has more content.
But this is what it is, an ordinary war, without action and special effects. Work, hunger, lack of sleep, loss of friends and acquaintances.
Never see any german soldiers?! Big fail
There are numerous scenes where the enemy is visible.
buenas. noches. traducir. al. español. latino. gracias