The fractured politics of a browning America
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 сер 2018
- The US is getting more diverse. As more Americans realize this new future, it is changing how cultural and political divides take shape.
Subscribe to our channel! goo.gl/0bsAjO
We live in an America where television programs, commercials, and movies are trying to represent a browner country; where Despacito, a Spanish-language song, tops the Billboard charts and where NFL players kneel during the national anthem to protest police brutality. We live in an America where politicians on the right and left appeal to voters, with explicit references to race.
And researchers are now able to pinpoint how these indirect and direct are shifting political ideology.
To learn more, read Ezra’s reporting on the impact of US demographic change: www.vox.com/policy-and-politi...
Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com.
Watch our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
Follow Vox on Facebook: goo.gl/U2g06o
Or Twitter: goo.gl/XFrZ5H
Ezra Klein and Jennifer Richeson discuss white threat and American politics in a recent episode of the Ezra Klein Show. Listen to the full episode here and subscribe to our new channel: bit.ly/2w7hmSx
3 replies to the official channel comment and they are all stupid
You would think if religious beliefs actually played into the white conservative understanding of these shifts they would be a welcomed. Catholic Mexicans and Muslim Middle Easterners share many social conservative values on abortion, homosexuality and even women’s roles in society and the home. But it’s strictly about race. The whole premise of the shift is about race, white Americans aren’t losing the majority just because of immigration, they are losing it because of how they understand race. No black American marries a white American and has white children, they are now black. Same goes for any other race. Whites are going away because of how our system defines race.
I heard Ezra Klein talk to Sam Harris on his podcast , consequently I avoid him like the plague
Sooo... I'm a first generation US born from a family of south american immigrants (legal). Everywhere I go people look and treat me as "white". My first, middle, and last name are Spanish. Our ancestry (23&me) goes back to Spain (Iberia), making me European descent, but "Hispanic". This video discusses a growing "Hispanic" population as the "browning" of America, reducing the percent of whites. So does that mean I'm white? Am I brown? Which side of this am I on? Are European descendants from Spain not white? There's a lot I don't understand about videos and lenses like these. I'm told I'm white but also that I'm browning America for being hispanic... am I not white?
@Vox This video is racist.
America was 100% brown before 1492
Ash Kitt so the african american community doesn't exist
Ash Kitt so children of nigerian immigrants aren't african american
come on now
And they had great civilization! So peaceful, booming industry, universities everywhere, great literature printed on every corner, poetry, art, global trade... They definitely were not warring tribes. They were purrrrrfect.
Some Natives are yellow, me and my mom included.
There were Europeans in America before 1492, look up Leifr Ericsson. And no it wasn’t brown. Read a book
The comment section is going to be great on this one 🙄
I want to be good and see what other people think. Then there is a part of me that just doesn't even want to bother reading the rest of the comments.
Ehh just alot of people in denial
Drink a shot every time you see flame war comment
Diversity is code for less white people
@@arielletolome5036 You're gonna get us killed
we always forget about the native americans
We beat the Native Americans in War, we the Great White People (Christians) took over America and it is well deserved for us. The Great White people (Christians) must STOP the melting pot, all minorities take advantage of such a beautiful country even in 2020 it is time for all minorities to go back to their own continent unless they think they can beat us in a War but until then all minorities must leave America NOW!!!
Surt Andvettsson Native Americans refer to the indigenous people of the continent. You’re just being a clown.
@surt , we were always here, your people just invaded my land and called it your own. You basically burglarized my home.
@Surt Andvettsson If Neanderthals were first to walk the Americas wouldn't this mean Native Americans also derived from Neanderthals making it our land?
@Surt Andvettsson You sound so moronic my gosh-
That's why ppl may like the ACA but hate ObamaCare when they're literally in reference to the exact same thing
The Gamiiics YES, I see that too. Jimmy Kimmel went to the street and asked that very question, they hate obamacare but really like ACA. Sooo obvious.
They also don’t like affordable healthcare because it gives black and brown people a leg up. That’s the reason we didn’t get universal healthcare when every other developed country was doing it. Racism.
Luís Filipe Andrade I’m not sure most people want universal healthcare. Has there been polling on this? I feel like most Americans would like it once it was implemented and benefit from it. But right now, it’s very scary to many because people see it as “communism”.
And the stuff I’m talking about it true. Like 70 or more years ago when many other developed nations were implementing universal healthcare, it was on the table for the US. And it was stopped by racism by the way. It’s historical fact. I’m not playing “the race card”.
Luís Filipe Andrade That’s good, in my opinion. If Bernie Sanders had won the Democratic nomination in either 2016 or 2020, we’d probably already have it or be getting it this year (because polling has shown that Bernie Sanders sweeps Trump in most scenarios). If Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez or someone of her likeness runs in 2024, then we might have a chance, but a millennial Latina radical is probably less palatable to moderates than Sanders. However, she would definitely mobilize young voters and in 4 years there will be even more Gen Zers voting than today.
But, if Biden wins and his presidency goes generally well, I’m guessing that we may see a Harris-Buttigieg ticket for 2024.
i hate both
“Us vs. Them” in a 2-Party System of Democracy is inevitable.
There is not a two party system in America. An unlimited number of parties can run for President.
@@farzana6676 Democrats....
....Republicans.....
Not much else.
Despite the fact that it's been declared many times America is a 2 party system
We have two parties because citizens vote for mostly one of two parties. Our parties aren’t important, relatively, but our candidates are. In other countries, you vote for a party, which chooses it’s leadership. It’s even less democratic.
@LegoGuy87 Lol, so who's fault is it if two parties are the most popular?
You can't blame them for being too popular.
@@farzana6676 it is effectively two party system due to electoral college system in America. No party can be serious threat to those two parties because of winner all take system.
The year is 2043. Latinos have overrun most of the US and Despacito 9 is all that plays 24/7
oh the humanity
@IJ OP Because of everyone listening to despacito
This made me laugh so hard 😂😂😂
this is so sad alexa you know what to do
the horrors
It's human nature to feel threatened, but it's one's responsibility to think rationally and critically even when your feeling is hurt.
@@brandenlee5849 The only reason I vote for the left is because I don't want a president who doesn't address climate change and acts irrationally to foreign leaders or even foreigners for that matter.The left has their problems too. I'm not a leftest but I'm definitely not republican. There is a reason "mixed"(pretty sure you meant colored) people favor the left. That is because the right hates them. Sad fact but true. Mixed (colored people as well i guess)people are in no way supported by Republicans after the Republican party split between the progressives and the conservatives.
Finally someone who sees the big picture
Enotion are your drive.
Logic cAn rationalise everything
@@brandonchan5620 Why do think people on the right hate different races? The idea that someone would support someone on the right and then the person running wouldn't want their support is so esoteric that I think you could find less than 5,000 people in the country who genuinely believe that. The word racism has diluted itself to nothing because people on the left have accused others of it so much without any substance, and the mob of idiots in the media just go with it everytime. Not only that but they want it to be true just to fit their narrative.
@@timvanrijn8239 Lower wages lowers prices to consumers. Increases in population increases demand and creates jobs- it all balances out.
They should have asked the native americans about " whitening " .
Let's Travel source your claim because I’m pretty sure White people weren’t in the Americas until 1492
Nordic white come to USA and make high standard of living. Browning will return usa to stone age as happened to Venezuela and South Africa.
Ahh yes, the monsters who genocided my people and inspired hitler, use my people's suffering today for future atrocities.
Most countries were formed by conquering. That excuse is played out.
Moot point. had the Euros, as in Hispanics, NOT been the first 'conquerers'; I'd lay 100% odds that the Japanese would've been the next wave. Note though since Japanese and most American Indians are phenotype 'Asian'; the former's bloodlines would've disappeared in 2-3 generations.
Hey, here's an idea: maybe we could stop teaching people that race is the be all and end all of identity, and instead actually try to promote King's dream, that we will not be judged by the colour of our skin but by the content of our character. Focus on our common humanity, not our differences.
deadeaded king never said we should ignore racism until it goes away (because it won't if we ignore it)
Americans are so obsessed with race.
That’s fine but then we need to bring back laws that protect against racism. Why is it right now in Georgia they’re selectively closing voting places in areas that are majority black? We have to be able to talk about race when it is to call out racism.
thats a nice idea.. but its human nature for an individual to find a group you identify with.....what you proposed is correct, but it also means we have to remove race-oriented groups like "Black Lives Matter"
Idan Zamir no we're not, we're just more aware of it because race has a daily impact on society whether we like it or not. i'm sure it might be easy to say "americans are obsessed about race" if you come from a country that's like >85% of the same ethnicity
The term 'browning' just sounds a bit odd to me
It doesn't really apply to most minorities anyway.
Ethnic diversification is not as catchy but a lot more descriptive
Not as odd as "people of color"
same here. “more diverse” would have been better cuz you wouldn’t describe asians or immigrant europeans as brown lol
The Maillard reaction of America
I suppose the problem is "people" then.
History of the world, summarized.
Republicans tend to talk about race? Are you kidding me? Democrats talk about race all the time. It’s how they gain power
Democracts love identity politics
Democrat = Race Card.
Both sides do
@@captainrev4959 I know. Democrats attack races. Republicans (non RINOs) defend them.
Yeah but democrats speak of race to point out flaws in our system and trying not to seem racist. Republicans speak of race because of they’re scared brown ppl will replace them, and trying not to seem racist
There is a good reason for the democrats not supporting abolishing ice in the 1990s, it didn't exist until 2003.
What they were saying is that due to more moderate values in the 90's had something like ice existed Democrats wouldn't of been for it's disolusionment. The base has been moving further left though so attitudes have changed, and they'll pander to said attitudes accordingly.
+ This
Lol nice catch.
Came here for this. His sentiment is correct but he really shouldn't be falling into that trap..
merge ice and hls
"A majority minority nation"? America is so strange.
Brendan Skinner
Like every other country.
@@IkeOkerekeNews nah really
Whatg don't u understand
It's historically more common phenomenon than one would guess.
Jaky Mo
You still don't have a point.
The sad truth is that democracy in a diverse country where race gets put above everything else is not a competition of ideas, but an ethnic head count.
* Edited to clear up what I meant
Not everyone of the same race has the same politics!!
Laura Smith but most do, which is the only thing that matters. In a democracy, the majority will always dwarf and outvote the minority/exceptions.
@@laurasmith1078
For all practical considerations, that doesn't matter.
Paul Smith what do you mean? the latino vote is split democrat and republican? plenty of rich whites are democrats? a lot of indians and east asians are republicans? you don’t know what you’re talking about
I mean white people are pretty divided in the US, if the republican party is forced to back down from racism minorities will be the same way
Wonder what Native Americans thought of European "diversity" and the "whitening" of America.
Do you think Native Americans would have said that European peasants and pioneers should go back in Europe and stayed poor?
@J. M. And since it has been done in every country in the world by every other race of people 1000 times over, we're going to stop singling out white people for doing what everyone else has already done.
Since "Native" Americans came to America through Asia, across Alaska, and into Canada/US, they did EXACTLY THE SAME THING that Europeans did, except they came from the other direction. That's why "native" (they're not native) Americans have such a striking similarity to Asian people...... because they have Asian ancestors. So nobody cares who got here first. They didn't have a COUNTRY when Europeans landed here. A bunch of ragtag, warring, disparate tribes does not make for a country. There was NO COUNTRY here until European settlers established one. Period.
@@taekwondotime A few tribes/nations DID have sophisticated societies, in all fairness; Mayans, Aztecs, and a few groups in what's now the USA or Canada as well.
Agreed. lt's absurd how these white snowflakes are worried about dying out. Your time is up darling.
Nobody wants to live in florida in the thumbnail 😂
Only tourist go there
LOl ill be going to Florida here in October i didnt know its black hispanic majorrity
because it will be underwater soon
What ever happens in Florida, should stay in Florida
@@soviet_yoda8820 it's not a black Hispanic majority, well maybe in south florida but trust me the rest of the state is whiter than wonderbread
Stop leaving Delaware off maps.
San Junipero who’s Delaware
Just kidding
Delaware doesn’t exist
There's a conspiracy theory that Delaware does not really exist.
Oh okay... TRUMP FOREVER...
San Junipero if Delaware has Hispanic migration it start to show up on maps lol 😂
“Fear is the path to the dark side…fear leads to anger… anger leads to hate… hate leads to suffering.” -yoda
Great words !!
-Master Yoda 32bby
Hate gives you focus.....It makes you stronger....- Emperor Palpatine
Sorry your quote made me think about the movie.
A child's cartoon?
i am more powerful then any jedi could ever dream of becoming
If anyone wants to see what happens when all politics is based on identity, look at the Middle East and the Balkans.
That's the most ignorant statemen I have heard in a very long time. Actually compared to the US, politics in the middle east can't be any further from being based on identity.
@@msba7 Almost all the conflicts in the Middle East can be linked to religion, race, or tribal identity. The Balkans is Muslims vs Eastern Orthodox Christians vs Catholics where everyone hates everyone.
@@Andrew-jh5kj The Middle East isn't the only diverse place in the world
^^^
@@proton8689 it’s also not the only dysfunctional part of the world with low trust societies. That’s a common factor of all multiethnic nations on earth
I usually disagree with vox because I am a white conservative but I subscribe because all their videos are well thought out and researched. I loved how this video wasn’t just bashing white conservatives but was showing the human side of politics. I think videos like these help educate both sides and let people make their own conclusions about changes in America.
You do know Vox is heavily liberal and extremely bias to the right wing i.e. Gun violence and Abortion.
yes but they do make high quality videos and ignoring them because of their political beliefs is a problem. I try to watch videos of both sides because even if I dont agree I like to view issues from all angles. They also make very educational non - political videos
The Greasy Carrot I used to be the reverse as a liberal with PragerU, but unlike vox, prager shows what I see as the worst of the right and I feel it's disingenuous to normal right people to inform myself of their beliefs through the insane videos I saw there. If Y'all wanna get informed with minimal bias check out the knappily website and app. You'll love it. Who, what, when, where, how, and why, all with many sources #notsponsored
its nice to see a conservative that is open minded to such topics that is more liberal.
@@leslie7872 , i'm not sure how Vox is "heavily" biased when they talk about fact n figures. Actually Vox view on gun violence and abortion are same with most international media views. You should ask yourself why your views are so different with the rest of the world
"Majority minority". Really gets the noggin joggin.
it means that the sums of different minorities makes the majority.
x RednitA x reminds me of south park episode.
I actually think it means that previous ethnic groups once considered a minority of the population, now make up the majority of the overall population
Probably easier to say than "Regression to plurality of native ethnicity" while conveying the same info.
I think the word they're looking for is a plurality.
One interesting point about the train study Ezra doesn’t mention is that the study controlled for two different periods of time. They sent Spanish speakers out to the train everyday for 3 workdays for one group, and every day for 10 workdays for another group. What they found is that those anti-immigrant sentiments were stronger in the 3-day group than the 10-day one, meaning that even though people initially reacted negatively to a diverse environment, they began to accept it more as time went on.
How many people were part of that study? Just to understand the setup?
For America,it's the Race. White vs people of Color.
And for India,it's the Religion. Hindu vs Muslim.
Wednesday 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
unlike whites we hindus have a legitimate reason to fear
remember what happend in kashmir jan 199 95 percent majority Muslims expelled 400000 Hindus and burnt down their temples and homes. fear of mollahs n ..islam is RATIONAL.
BENGALI MARXISTS LIKE COM MAJUMDER HERE CHEER such a prospect
@Брандон Кeллeр where?
@Брандон Кeллeр well, you can stop immigration, but then median age will increase and your country will be covered in debt like japan, what do you want? white country and debt covered economy or mixed country and a rich economy?
Fun Fact : India is the most Racist country.
Hard to abolish ice in the 90s when ice was created in 2003...
You missed the point of what he was saying. He was just using Abolish ICE as an example of a more racially liberal policy that some Democrats support now. He wasn't saying that that exact policy would have been at issue in the 1990s.
FYI ICE existed under a different name-INS
I can't believe 90s kids never got to know what it was like to drink a cold glass of water.
The fact 300+ people liked your comment when you completely missed the point is.........telling, to say the least.
INS was a handful of agents, ICE is an army. the number of deportations initiated by INS in the 90s was at ~50K per year, compared to ~700K per year now.
Great video Vox but be honest.. From the chart you showed the nation isn't becoming more brown it's becoming more hispanic.... The percentages of other groups remain the same
i think the browning is also referring to mixed race people, which is also a fast growing demographic
There has been massive immigration from mexico why is it wrong to have a boarder and sovereignty
jorden durden since 2009, Mexican migration has declined to the US. More return to Mexico than come in. You are regurgitating outdated information:
www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/11/19/456685942/mexican-immigration-declining-more-are-returning-than-arriving
I consider Hispanics brown because some tint in their skin verses a white person 😂🤔
curious how much of those "hispanics" are actually white . lel.
American politics are very diverse. We not only have the Republicans for Giant Corporations Party, but we also have the Democrats for Giant Corporations Party.
You're a disgrace.
I'm from eastern Europe, from the area where Yugoslavia and Austria-Hungary existed very diverse countries, i don't have to tell anybody that they no longer exist so good luck America hahaha
Lol diversity isn't bad lol the state are not ethnic groups so little trenchant
y’all said the exact thing in the 1890s when eastern europeans were coming over
@@KDH-br6hy wrong
@@rudyardwalker9113 your a white nationalist there's no difference between colored people and white people lol
@@KDH-br6hy Still wrong but ok
This is the problem of democracy, people don't vote rationally.
Well....there is no other good alternative, so imma stick with democracy.
@@counc National socialism looks more like selective breeding to me. Anarchy is the system that fosters survival of the fittest.
Especially the blacks
I wonder how that happened
@@samdoesvids1339
I would unironically rather deal with a monarchy, because that would be more transparent, and it would rid us of this shadowy pretense that the people have any meaningful power over their ruling elite. I would rather deal with power that I can see and declares itself openly, over that which is invincible.
"Being told your group is shrinking or that its losing power, it's scary for anyone" - Only if your identity is wrapped up in that group. Learn to identify yourself outside of your skin color or any of the other meaningless groups people tend define themselves with.
All of us are the same race anyway
The human race👍
@Percival Hans , an actually or potentially interbreeding group within a species;also : a taxonomic category (such as a subspecies) representing such a group -meriam webster
Plz explain how in an evolutionary sensee we don't share genetics, and the first definition I gave was legit the Google definition of it
Well that genetic difference is rly rly small, humans share 99.99* percent of our dna with the .01% being height, hair, eye color etc. So if you want to divide humans by that .01% instead of accepting that we are all the same then be feel too
Source-
humanorigins.si.edu/evidence/genetics/one-species-living-worldwide
Found this vid by vox, ua-cam.com/video/VnfKgffCZ7U/v-deo.html
But still "The Great Replacement Theory " is a conspiracy! Right?
I am sad for those beautiful Americans 😭
Which Americans?
@@mariabopACTUAL Americans! All Americans who are either born and raised in the USA or those who immigrated here, sought and received LEGAL CITIZENSHIP!
Natural born citizens or naturalized citizens, those are the ONLY Americans in existence!!
American citizens who are ready/willing to patriotically defend our country from enemies both foreign and domestic! 🇺🇸 ❤🇺🇸🩷🇺🇸
"A browning America" ... that summarises the prevalent mindset
Chris Odukwe thank you! No one else seems to notice that.
Imagine a brownong japan
Because it's true.
When Americans recognize their real enemy is the billionaire class and not people of another race, then we may finally get somewhere.
Right!!
damn this is so spot on
#Bernie2020
Eat the rich
By all means, go ahead if you want America to become Venezuela. But please research what has happened to socialist countries, for all the research I've done it has been very bad. I think human greed will always end a socialist system from working.
I’m just upset no one will remember 80s Rock Music
70s Rock is better
Freddy * Zepplin*
@@freddy6837 Debatable
🤮 the worst music
@@hdexotic1914 you have to be kidding you probably listen to rap now that’s garbage
According to my DNA test, I'm about 80% African and 20% European. I check mixed race on all job apps and health docs.
My skin is honey brown. Am I delusional?
boondockpaint No, you’re not delusional. You are partially mixed race. You are being real to yourself, not living a lie.
Actually most African Americans in the us actually are 25 percent European unless your an immigrant
You are mixed race because you have mixed ancestry.
I’m the same but opposite. I’m like 65-70 percent European and 30 percent native and African. I always put white hispanic on my paper but after my DNA test I just put multi racial. Still don’t know if that’s correct, the Latinos think I’m too white and the white think I’m too brown haha
@@danielhernandez-vo9zc I mean you're of majority European ancestry so ig you're Hispanic White but multiracial seems accurate. What you put on the census and what people think of you are usually different. North Africans put "White" on the census but American society doesn't see them as White.
I'm a 3rd generation Mexican American from Brownsville Texas where there have ALWAYS been Tejanos and I can tell you from experience that we never think about getting rid of White people or trying to over take them or any ridiculous thought like that. On the contrary when Texas was part of Mexico according to real history most Tejanos did not wanted to be a part of Mexico because they felt they were never truly represented or where given the help they needed to strive for a better place to live so when the great migration of Germans flocked to Texas while it was still part of Mexico, Tejanos welcomed them with open arms and if you trace some Mexican Americans and some German Americans lineage in Texas you will find that both sides have either a German ancestor if they are Mexican Americans and a Mexican ancestor if they are German Americans. Even to this point the most mixed marriage is between White people and Mexican Americans/Mexicans so we need to stop all this nonsense because when I was in the Marines we got along just fine. It's always the fear of the unknown that has people acting and saying stupid things. God Bless Texas and God Bless America
Queen Elizabeth II How you stop lying and show some proof.
I never said everything was peaches and cream.. Of course there were many injustices towards Tejanos but at the same time the Mexican government gave no help other than collect taxes. It was just a comment to this video of course there is many other factors to this story. And no one said I had German blood, I said I know lots of Tejanos with part German ancestry. And yes the Texas Rangers when they were first assembled were nothing but thugs who self proclaimed themselves as law men. They tried to take Yturria Ranch down in South Texas away from Mr. Yturria and he had to flee to Mexico to escape persecution. I know there is lots of injustices towards us. All I'm saying is that we've always been here
fame130 we need to keep our stories circulating, now more than ever.
They have always tried to erase our Mexican-American history in this country. Don't let it fade away.
fame130 This is only America if u look at other countries it will be majority China and Africa as they are the ones that will make up most of the people
Ayyyy shoutout from Weslaco😎😎😎😎
Something like ths has happened before; in the 1800s the brown people were Italian and religious divide was between a mostly Protestant US and Catholic immigrants from Ireland and Europe. As the saying goes, history doesn’t repeat itself, but it rhymes.
Skip Ives
Hey that's a cool saying. Hadn't heard it
I’ve heard it stutter
italians are white europeans
Comparing modern immigration to Italians in the late 1800s is so laughably dishonest I don't even know how to respond
the scale, the cultural differences, the social programs we fund to support immigrants (to their detriment i might add)
this is just a terrible analogy.
Of course, they are. So are Irish. yet when too may came at once and many did not want to assimilate as they did between 1880s and 1920 we had problems that went away when they stopped coming and those that had come assimilated and the ones that did not want to become American went back.. The same arguments people had back then we are having today but because today most immigrants are of a different race anti-Americans like to add race to the argument to stop any debate or questions. We should have an immigration moratorium and let those 60 million immigrants that have come here since the 1965 immigration Act assimilate and not be pressured by a constant flow of new arrivals creating a second homeland for them.
"california didn't fall to pieces" this hasn't aged well
You do get California is one of the richest, most prosperous areas on the entire planet, it has an economy bigger than 95% of countries.
@@barnaby4232 And yet they're experiencing a net population decline to the point where they're losing a congressional seat and rank among the lowest in affordability and quality of life in the US. Good GDP doesn't mean a place is good to live.
@@kingkaga898 they are not experiencing a population decline, stop making things up to suit your agenda.
@@barnaby4232 bruh
Isn't California teetering in the brink of bankruptcy too?
Great replacement of our nation
White people have been a minority in Hawaii for a long time and we doing just fine culturally, people from all backgrounds tend to integrate together here too and not stay so separated like they do on the mainland, sequestered into different neighborhoods, and pretty much no one is sensitive about the where are you from/what's your background question
Not to say we dont have our issues, which we do and they aren't small by any measure, but compared to the mainland we seem to have a much healthier relationship with race here
Are whites anywhere near 50% of the population there?
Charlie Chuckles they make up only about 24.7% of the Hawaiian population!!
@@auntmelisa8689 when whites become a minority in the nation our fathers have built for us, the United States will fall.
Charlie Chuckles white trailer parks already look like there failing.
But you will probably blame a nonwhite for not giving them more handouts.
I’m half white by the way.
And I know u will say only full whites should consider them self white but I doubt ur over 99% white. Sorry
Island sociologie is always strange
There are two types of brazil:
**Northern Brazil*
**Southern Brazil*
And Brasilia in between both
quente
Jocelyn Alvarez and *Southern Brazil* is far wealthier than the Northern half. I wonder why 🤔
@@LiveWire276 tell us
Southern brazil is more white thats why
I thought it was a conspiracy theory
white population is actually declining.
The idea that Whites are being "replaced" is the conspiracy. Hold up your left hand. Now hold up your right hand. Did your left hand just get replaced?
@idon'tevenknowanymore this is what they want for some reason.
@@therationalityreport3202 how can ur brain not understand this. Whites have a birth rate of 1.6. Replacement rate is 2.1. That means more whites are dying than being born. And those missing whites will be replaced with brown and blacks.
@idon'tevenknowanymore The problem is that some people think there is a whole agenda and white people are actively being replaced as part of this agenda. There is no grand scheme to replace white people. White people are simply not having enough babies to replace the people that are dying.
Its no ones fault that white people are choosing not to have babies. More and more white women are choosing to have one or two children at most. Some white women choose to remain childless. Compare that to Hispanics who have lots of kids. Over time, the white population will fall and the Hispanic population will increase due to the disparity in birth rates. Its just basic logic. There is no conspiracy to replace white people.
what the hell is a racial conservative or racial liberal?
I know this is a year old, but obviously "racial liberal"= support for affirmative action, open borders, BLM, etc.
"Racist" and "not racist"
As has happened in the american past, I think the definition of "white" will simply expand
Yeah I agree.
It already started with people like George Zimmerman or Ted Cruz...
Actually white hasnt ventured far from its original definition that being a yone originating from the peoples of Europe middle east or north Africa. Black however has come to include a whole broad definition. Not just people originating from subsaharan africa. It includes mixed race, creoles, basically anyone with a high melanin complextion. You dont have to have strong roots to sub saharan Africa.
The defenition for white people and black people dont boil down to you skin pigment, which is bizarre to me.
Yeah I have said this to my friends before. In the 19th century, "whites" were against the irish immigrants, then 20th century they were against italians. Im not going to be surprised if hispanics/latinos are going to be categorized as white in orderm for whites to become the majority again.
MexicanGuppy white does include Hispanic/Latino. Latino just means anyone one black brown white red ect. that come from any county in Latin America. Hispanic is broken down into sub categories, non-Hispanic whites, non-Hispanic blacks, or just simply Hispanic.
My moms Mexican and it has as her race on her birth certificate "Caucasian".
More precisely I think minorities will "whitenize," and as people get wealthier their birthrates decline.
Here's my take: if you're lamenting the loss if the white majority in America, you may be racist. If you're celebrating the loss of the white majority in America, you may be racist. Just keep calm and carry on.
Mike I don't care about skin tone but I do care about culture. I agree with you on the statement but a concern that can come with fearing a loss of white people is that the American culture and beliefs can be lost or overpowered. I believe that people who do move to America should uphold American culture and I'm not even from America. I believe if you should move to China you should uphold their customs, tradition and language. Americans love America and their proud of all that America stands for, they're extremely patriotic. That's why Americans get insecure at the prospect of hearing about how great other cultures are more than hearing about how great America is which is a patriotic "America first" which was prominent through out the 1900's but hasn't really followed into the 20th century. That's my take anyway.
I'm not white and despise how the Government is allowing people from those who aren't from Europe to come in easier.
I only see Civil War in the coming years.
I'm not white, but I don't like how white people are dying out.
Jaden Yager what does that man though?
That was so important to state, people need to stop picking sides.
I do not care what race,religion,sexuality etc you are.Just be a good person
What is good to some might not be good to others.
Maybe just do whatever you want as long as it isn’t hurting you or others
And that's why you'll vanish.
@@rudyardwalker9113 Is there any hope, Dane bro?
@@User-be4fx yes
What policy has "worked out well" in California? From an outsider looking in, nothing has. Same goes for Chicago, new york, and new Jersey. It's really scary to think my state may follow that same road.
The problem is that people indentify with a race and the others are the bad ones. Thats humans in a nutshell
Gustav Vigolo Why wouldn’t people identify with race? It is a real, distinguishable, thing.
So deep. So thoughtful.
Look at central and South America - no I’m not interested in living in those countries...the fear is that America will decline and become a mess
@@theamericanaromantic not really, the only one race is the human race, the only difference between different humans is melanin. There is no biological difference saying that different people from continents are also different species
Where did you get your philosophy degree from. I'm inspired.
I'm sitting here thinking that maybe this is how the Native felt.
yes,lol
@Tattle Boad They must have been surprised when they found out they were members of a minority group.
@Tattle Boad The percentage of Latino Americans who are white is actually much higher than 50%.
Most what most would call Latino are perfusely Native American as well.
@schlomo shekelberg multiculturalstein Are the non whites worried about becoming a minority in Mexico?
It's because of this change we need to drop the race platform and look more toward experience and what will be done for Americans as a whole.
Uh why? So White people can remain ignorant of their declining population?
@@rudyardwalker9113 no. So people can be hired on experience. Not on race.
@@robertkinslow8953 Not gonna happen. Read up on history of other places besides America and you'll see why.
@@rudyardwalker9113 is the most equal way of doing things but ok.
Couldn’t agree with this more. How do we educate these new immigrants on what it means to be “American” and adopt our cultural values?
When you’re both Hispanic and Asian at the same time
So... Filipino?
Well, I guess indirectly most Hispanics are Asian. Because that’s where the native people originally came from, Asia. They were immigrants too.
Me too! Nice to see someone else besides my siblings :D
Asians are honorary white
[WUT] Electric I’m Hispanic and white at the same time. I’m a white hispanic. Spaniard descent.
It's normal for someone of ANY race to be worried about becoming a minority when they once dominated. And this is just subconsciously an unspoken truth that white culture and heritage is decreasing and there is going to be more of a heavy response to seeing black or Latino culture becoming more appealing to people of younger generations. It naturally will make them uncomfortable
Frfr so uncomfortable
JMONEY-4K yes that was said in the video already
It makes you uncomfortable if your identity is deeply ingrained with your racial identity. Lets always remember whiteness is defined by what it is without, the growth of hispanics also ignores that there exist white Hispanic people. You want to jump the number of white people in America, add more people to the group.
I'm pretty sure that native Americans were 'uncomfortable' too when they were victims of mass genocide.
@Брандон Кeллeр oh shut up
2:40 did anyone else notice the picture of The Beatles, just me okay
the term "browning of ameican " is not A CORRECT or professional term to use.
well, now it is
@Snow Cone just stop calling people yellow.
What’s wrong with becoming a racial minority? Are minorities treated poorly in America?
@Luke Whitepill you're kidding right?
Luke Whitepill Africa isn’t a country
@Luke Whitepill you do realize true Americans have been a minority in their own country for centuries now, do you?
whites are openly hated as a majority id hate to see what happens when they become a minority
The real question is, why does race even matter?
Because every brown country sucks... Look around the world, the most successful ones are all white or asian...
@@winfieldk6692 kk good luck with that ideology
@@winfieldk6692 no no someone only ready name a successful black place and you went into denial stfu and stop trolling the comments
@@winfieldk6692 lol! You serious? Brown people make up so much of your technological sector. I wish these people hadn't gone there and contributed to the brown countries, then they would have been more successful.
Because Black and Brown ppl are still discriminated against
Hello there.
While you go through this comment section and see comments that will inevitably upset you no matter where on the political spectrum you are, i just wanna at least give you something positive out of all of this.
The fact that we have people of differing political views is not at all an issue, but a sign that America is still a free place. So, instead of being angry at the other party, take a sec to appreciate them, as it's our differing views that keep us from simply turning into a one party oppressive state.
Hope i could make your day just a little bit better.
I’m all for positivity and respecting others opinions and all that, but I gotta say right now the political climate is that of rage and anger at all opposing sides. Everyone has different experiences so everyone’s entitled to their own opinion, but I feel like hatred and frustration at the other side does not make a net positive effect on the world. Best case scenario, one day in the distant future when we’re all tired of hurling insults, we can sit down, have a rational discussion and come to a compromise that makes everyone happy. Maybe I sound like “unamerican”, but I’d prefer individual opinions with an overall like-minded goal, over dozens of sides fighting and breeding hatred towards each other for the slightest differences.
We are all people, and though we may have differing cultures and beliefs, it does not warrant hurting others to further your own ideals.
Underrated comment
This was...annoying. -_- The title made me think this was about the differences WITHIN these demographics, not between them. Do Hispanics tend to have fairly uniform views? Do blacks? Do whites? Asians? Pretty sure the answer to all of those is no, but what's the breakdown? That's what I clicked to find out. Inter-group differences are cliched old hat, intra-group differences are far, far more interesting.
We mad because we still don't have basic service like universal health care but have a space force
Nope, it will be a democrats non stop term with those demographics
Divided State of America
Dear America, Isn't Hispanic : Anyone who speaks Spanish? Asians can be Hispanics, Hispanic is not a race
Thank you for creating videos from a moderate standpoint that are easily understandable (: I remember not being able to follow with what was happening on the news and around the world but this channel has sparked my curiosity through the roof because now I can understand and actually talk about with others and share my opinions
My reaction to America being more non-white in the future: Ok
Alex Byron everywhere it has happened historically a third world nation had been left in its place. Everywhere from SA to cities like Detroit and states like California.
Alex Byron thank you a normal human being
Intergalactic Lebensraum California has the highest GDP out of all the States. Also the most innovation including the platform your using right now.
@@intergalacticlebensraum2428 California isn't even close to a "third world state." On average, it has better public services, opportunities, and life expectancy than many other US states. Not to mention it's economy is one of the biggest in the world.
Intergalactic Lebensraum To provide more global evidence to this - Hong Kong and Singapore, two city states that are incredibly diverse, also have some of the highest GDP per capita in the world.
Our differences are not what divide us, its our inability to recognize and celebrate those differences that does.
Yea nah our differences will always divide us as it should be.
@@rudyardwalker9113 your ignorance speaks for itself.
USA will fall to pieces and it is my dream to see it.
why would you celebrate differences lol. makes no sense.
If 2 people of the same race are together that's a terrible thing and they are both racist bigots who hate other races, but if 2 people of a different race are together they are beautiful and tolerant people and they should CELEBRATE their differences.
@@Paonporteur BAHAHAHAHAHA
Great objective video which takes into account various perspectives.
Browning American politics might be fractured, but the grey alien race’s political takeover is perfectly calculated. (The greying) Keep asking questions.
That's disgusting, why would we destroy all national/ethnic identities? Why would you mix polar and grizzly bears? Why would you mix sparrows and Robins?
@@nom_de_guerre_ I type in good faith.
Do you honestly take pleasure in replacing my people?
@@anarchoaristocracy8368 yeah
The dude above me is a racist. Aliens ARE people
The greying is inevitable.
I wonder if the threat of an extraterrestrial takeover would unite humanity.
I’m Mexican legally in the US and I completely understand, heck I don’t want to live near my Mexican neighbors, they’re a mess. And it’s not about being racist is just most migrants come from lower strata and with that comes lots of lack of education, crime problems, welfare consumption, etc.. so I completely get it. I know I will get hate from illegals or legal Latinos but it’s the truth. Not all are like this but a great majority. If Latinos we became self sufficient and the new generations hard working instead of popping out babies and living out of the state, I’m pretty sure the attitudes would be much different. Oh and stop being loud. I mean it’s not racism I see how whites live ok with educated Indians and do not fear them. They’re dark. It’s all about education and respect. If we Latinos want to be respected we should offer the same.
Fernando All thats not gonna matter once white Americans hit that 49% minority mark. They are gonna shift attitude no matter the class of person because at that point they will realize that they have become a minority in the nation that they founded and that was spawned from their white colonial settlement in North America and will begin to feel like they are losing their nation. Yes, white Americans feel inside it’s their nation because it came from them and they were it’s supermajority for all of its history. Their attitudes will change and this will lead to a future civil war as the become aggressive over it.
Too late bro, the best you can do is return to home, if you want to avoid the next American civil war...
Fernando However, I will say what you said is correct for the present time. White Americans take better to peoples like Indians (India) because of the reasons you gave. But like I also stated, this scenario has an expiration date when white Americans start thinking their losing their country for real.
FERNANDO, +1.
Are things getting better or worse? I wonder if it's related?
With more diversity, the quality of American life has gotten worse. Let's return to 1950s America when there wasn't much diversity.
Good job discount Vice with graphs and charts.
I'm biracial, my mother is 4th generation Irish American and my dad is 3rd generation freed black American (it's hard to say how long his family has been here without looking through slave trade records) and I'm brown. I'm a great representation of how multiculturalism isn't spooky or wrong. But since I'm brown, I've been told to go back to my own country, I've been complimented on my English, I've had my VERY white European name butchered by trying to force an accent onto my VERY white name. Color DOES matter, it's something people see and make assumptions about and while sure, we're all human, that hasn't stopped genocide, forced relocation, and racial violence. Accept that your ideas of racial blindness are from a point of ignorance, you don't want to discuss how race is important so you pretend to be above race. Racial and colorblindness are ignorant, learning about cultures, asking about cultures, growing as person... That's progress.
well, isn't it natural that people want to stay in power?
It is.
Another study showed that respondents were LESS likely to support reparations for Native Americans after reading about the genocide and discrimination against Natives. There's an empathy factor here - being empathetic leads to feeling pain, and voters may reject the idea that others suffered to ease their own guilt.
How are people alive today supposed to feel guilty for what their ancestors did? It’s literally not a crime to be white
Great reporting!!! Seen this many times 👍🏾👏🏾
So much tension on this little speck of dirt called Earth, between 7 billion puny masses of decaying organic matter.
4 2 soon it will be over!!
Lucas Led how
Wow that was beautiful
@@deadpirateroberts9937 You choose, fire, plague, alien invasion, good old fashioned nuke war, machines rising up and killing humans, i could go on if nothing in this list interests you.
Doomer
Vox never ceases to amaze.
Do you mean it as a good or bad thing?
@Christopher Fairfield that includes Hispanic whites tho
Christopher Fairfield
Are you high? First of all cool it with the caps lock, grammar rules still exist. And second Hispanic and Latino-Americans can be white, yes. But does that really matter? In the end we’re all just people making decisions to try to help people. Immigration is a good thing, we see immigrant consistently out-work native born Americans, therefor adding to the economy. We also see that immigrants have a reduced crime rate compared to that of native born Americans. The notion that immigration is bad, or a mass influx of immigration is going to destroy the country, is absolutely ridiculous. You have to look past that label of immigrants, and judge them based on the merit of what they’ve done, and how they’ve behaved.
@Christopher Fairfield ok
Ignacio Couce
When he says immigration should be merit based he talks about tightening the requirements for immigration. Immigrants should be let into the United States for a number of reasons, asylum is one, based on what they’ve done is another. They should also be given an opportunity to succeed. When they’re born into violent countries with unstable governments, they have a rather slim chance of gaining the prosperity of American Citizens. But when we give these immigrants the conditions to succeed, time after time they do. The solution is more immigrants, because immigrants are good for this country.
Thanks Vox. 😊
"And California didnt fall apart" 😂😂😂
Hey, what do you mean by that?
California is still successful. Can you explain?
@Jacob Mayfield no they destroy new Mexico too look up Albuquerque
Jacob Mayfield Mexicans lived there before any person of full European descent did. There’s a reason why all of California’s cities have Spanish names
thegeruza456 lol Spanish is European creation
It’s a mess. The culture there is insanely far left.
I mean, it’s going back to its original color palette.
But you Blacks still have to leave as well.
DravenWolfe not sure if you understood what is happening. No one is leaving, there are simply more mixed kids and a difference in the rate of demographic growth between cultural groups.
Edit: I don’t live in the US. Also, the “you Blacks”? Come on, this is typical “Us and them” bias, please don’t lower yourself to such basic levels of thinking.
Tessy yeah I'm not fond of typecasting people due to a superficial trait like skin tone.
But I do see what you're saying now, you're referring to a more original Middle Eastern tone
DravenWolfe glad to hear. I abhor it too.
And I meant Native American instead of Middle Eastern, but you see what I mean.
Tessy or Native works for me.
As I've said somewhere else on this video, I don't really care for the superficial skin tone metric in determining the value of a fellow human.
And Fear-mongering videos like this, have a tendency to bring out the troll in me. LOL
Wow, racial conservatives. Dress that wolf in sheep's clothing.
What even is a racial conservative?
@@allison4882 person of color who is a conservative
It would be more interesting if you also asked those people on social and economic issues as well.
Why majority white country need to diversify? Why can't majority Black. Arab and Asian country don't need to diversify?
Africa is lot more diverse than US tho
@@akunlama89 Yes they are theres many African Tribes in Sub-Saharan part. in north africa there is berbers. Arabs etc and there is also few and plenty of white and Asians(Most of them indians and Chinese) in Southern Africa specially in South Africa and Namibia due to Colonialism and Apartied. Black Africans have many similarities and arabs and berbers have many simularities. Same in White Europeans they have Many Simularities.
@@ghhbbgokijuy1142 indeed
Sure is bringing out the racists.
@simon caymer Because you associate the shittyness of South Africa with the race of its people.
simon caymer Yes yes it is. That statement is filled with so much ignorance I can’t even imagine.
@simon caymer - "like South Africa"...what could you possibly mean by this 🤔ua-cam.com/video/dvlk9Fir5SU/v-deo.html
@obemiss So what are you saying?
Everything is racist these days. If you keep saying it in every argument, it loses its meaning
Other countries that don't have this browning are doing better than the U.S.
What countries are you referring to?
@@KuramiRocket Single race and culture majority countries.
@@heru-deshet359 Blame beautiful white women and their aroused desire for non wm 🔥💕
So go there thisnland was stolen from the natives the hispanics and the the blacks where enslaved to help build it and in the end all types of people are allowed to come i support.
Sheesh! I grew up in San Antonio and in the 1950s and 60s it was majority Anglo. in the 70s it shifted and the city didn't descend into race wars. Oh, there were the tiny minority who bewailed the fact, but for most of us there were more important things to worry about.
You’re apathetic about being displaced. Weak.
🤦♂️
this also extends into cultures, if venezuelens or colombians hear that the other is growing in population, they may shift to more conservative views
My reaction: so what’s gonna happen to this whole white oppression nonsense when they’re not the majority anymore
There is going to be a white revolution .
Oh, I'm sure they will still be blaming whites ....even when no whites are left in the USA....As they are starving in third world, brown USA.
They’ll still be the mi Keith with stolen labor from black people, stolen land from natives, and centuries of institutional heritage who will still be oppressing according to the racial hierarchy that they take up less of a space on 🤷♀️
Cato Sicarius Yes, I feel a white civil war is coming. But it probably won’t happen until whites become a minority.
@@IslenoGutierrez its going to happen in the next 5 or 10 yrs
Im a born and raised Mexican-American from California, and Mexicans being the biggest Latino community, we need to value education more in our culture. We can change this country for the better and for humanity.
Paisanos mueven los ciudades de los Estados Unidos, pero necesitamos mover el mente también.
Daniel Ruelas this is media stuff Hispanic are 17% and in 40 years they will be 28% that’s not a majority
You're an American.Not Mexican-American.
Mega melon Baez but he’s american culturally & all. Mexico is his ancestral land.
@@dennis771 No hes just American. An American with Mexican heritage.
Danny Cardona I agreed.
Now you know how the Native Americans felt.
What
Yea you mean when the Spanish came and conquered florida 😂
"California went through all these changes, and it didn't fall apart" LOL, talking about illegal immigration
Yeah that is true. People are leaving to Texas. Hopefully going to make it turn blue
Rip Stephan Karl
Also, was that despacito in one of these first clips?
yes
Stephan karl stephanson you uncultured swine
@@celeste3761 no in Iceland his 2nd name is his family name and surname, not his 3rd name
Forever Lonely Potato This is not what SteFan Karl would want. Spread love, not hatred.
Yes, Ezra Klein cofirmed Despacito 2 after the credits.
California didn't fall to pieces, have you looked at California lately?
im sitting in my shithole apartment that costs 2k a month surrounded by illegal mexicans right this very moment, so yeah, i have
cat lover yes it is
Ken93 no
That's the thing you're calling them illegal like that land wasnt stolen from their ancestors
@@astrogamingyt3133 well, it's illegal now. They lost that land wrongfully, but you can't just give it back now. Our laws make it illegal for them to be here. If you have a problem with that you need to take that up with the law.
If you want to see the browning of America, just look at the places these people come from.
you’re mad cause white people are about be the minority
3:21 how tf do u vote for a demographic graph
How can you say "majority-minority"?
...blame it on Eric Cartman.
he said it that way because the largest race group will still be white but all minorities together will make up the majority (>50%)
@@makari8884 So some whites are hispanic- shows how illogical the whole concept of race is. Any group can be a majority if they use criteria that will include enough people.
“Majority Minority Nation” 😂😂😂
Lol like what the hell XD
That's what America is bound to be. Even some states like Texas(44%), New York(46%), or Florida(43%) have most people as White, but the white population as a whole is less than Non-whites
Mr. Manifesto you’ve never heard that term before?
White 49% everything else 51%
@@MasterCheif-he2oe meanwhile whites are 10% of the world and shrinking
I'm white ... Nothing you have said is in the realm of my experience ... Move out of the cities ... Breath some fresh air ... CA is an example of success??? Did I here you right???
The guy is clearly on something lol.
I hate the whole “Christian heritage” thing !!
I'm pretty sure the Hispanic population is overwhelming Catholic
@@BadBrad46 nah i hope christianity dies soon. It looks like we're headed towards that anyway 😂
@Bennett McCoy "racial caste", you mean white people sticking with other whites in fear of being slaughtered? MY SHOCK.
Marcos Lopez
Christianity is expected to grow by 800,000,000 in the next 30 years... just because you hate Christ doesn’t mean Christ hates you brother.
So, skin color matters?
yes, different people and cultures matter
race is not just skin colour, it's much more than that
It's the only thing that matters to the left, completely useless.
Throughout all of human history diversity has not been a strength. It is merely the potential for conflict and will always manifest in the long term as conflict. The idea that it is a strength is a modern utopian idea that is patently absurd.
@Byebye kavekangs who’s gonna renew you’re food stamps
@Romeo ! you look pretty white man
@Romeo ! Sometimes I can't tell if posts like this are ironic or not
@Byebye kavekangs Then you are evil and will be opposed
India is very very diverse, and these diversity have been our strength.
One thing I never understood about some liberals is that they will say that we need more diversity and that America is too white, yet when you ask them which countries are better than America, they always say, 'Sweden, Canada, Norway, Finland, Holland, and Germany.' To me diversity is great, it can teach you alot about other cultures, but it can also cause division among the vastly different cultures, beliefs, and ethnic groups.