Why SOME beauties are so harsh towards Gayoon?? Is this the first time a cover has been done?? NOPE! I'm a beauty, and I'm sure Beast are really happy to hear their song covered. They're known for being polite and warm... so why beauties are behaving like this??? I would like to say, Gayoon SHOULD have a solo album!!! she's a lovely voice :)
this is a missunderstanding, they are hating cube not gayoon, i don't want relationship between 4nia and beauty become bad because of this, this is so sad...
Why they need to show their discontent towards Cube in Gayoon's cover song?? If there's nothing against her.. why write such comments here?? Can you understand the stupidity if such idea?
I dont think her voice is special enough. Not unique nor techichfully too. Overal its very plain i can say. Maybe hats why many people hating this cover. Bcoz its pretty awful compare to original singer.
Holy.... Oh my god. She did this song JUSTICE!! Wow wow! I'm not even a 4minute fan, but she did a really good job with this song! And I love love love the original. I love the softness of it without the instrumental in the back.
I can't believe I have to say this about my own fandom but man, some of you guys are seriously so childish. The whole "Junhyung made this song for us as an anniversary gift, therefore, nobody else is allowed to sing it" needs to stop. Gayoon only made a cover of the song for fun; she's not going to be promoting it jfc. Honestly, shouldn't we be happy that this song is good enough that CUBE decided to make cover out of it? The people who dislike this video thinking they're doing the right thing; no, it just shows that you do not appreciate BEAST or Junyhung's hardwork. BEAST, as a whole, are probably shaking their heads in disappointment right now.
I feel like if Jonghyun didn't want her to do it, he has enough pull in CUBE to get it to not happen. He's their only in house songwriter of their biggest group lol. I can't believe BEAST fans are being really rude about it. It's not like covers haven't been done in K-Pop before. Didn't everyone and their mother cover Taeyang's song back in the spring? lol.
banamana I'm sure he did agree to it. As a b2uty, I can't believe it either since having been in this fandom for 5 years now, this is the first time that I've been so disappointed. Though, I'm extremely glad that it's mostly Korean b2uties that have a problem with this; international b2uties, on the other hand, don't really care. Yeah, a lot of people covered Taeyang's song because there was an event for it.
It's just few minutes was released. Why so many dislike already. TT.TT please don't hating her guys. I Love gayoon's voice. She's a part of CUBE Family. We should support her. Because she do cover for Beast's Song. If other people watch and love it. I think it'll give good impact to Beast. CUBE and 4Minute. So let's love each other. Just enjoy the music and Song that Junhyung has made it. *TIME IS SO PRECIOUS* So Beast. 4Minute CUBE Good Luck for yaaa.. ♥♡♥
ugie_ B2ST hahahaaa..off course. I've waited it and can't sleep properly. I love the background there. So wonderful. Off course match with Gayoon face. So it reminds me of DRIVE Teaser or Jacket Photoshot. Hahaaa
ugie_ B2ST let's GO..GO..GO..in our dream land tonight. Hahaaahaaa.. and I see delulu Nguyễn Bích Thủy Yenny PP said about Kiyoon Shipper. Hahahaaaa I'm totally agree 10000%. Even Kiki is my husband. T.T I'll give to Gayoon unniee.. haaaahaaa
To be honest is the first time i've heard her sing, and i like her voice, is really soft and goes well with her sorroundings and the feeling of the song
B2UTYs please, don't left any negative comments in here :( CUBE United fans are family, right?? Please don't just because of this issue to burn our relationship so far :( Gayoonie did it very well, we need to support her. Do you think if you do that, BEAST will be happy?? No, they will be sad. Be more generous, comfortable and have positive thoughts, you're truly a beautiful B2UTY :) Remember, "like idol like fan", if we have behave well, it's good for our idol :) P/s: this cover is good and beautiful, I love Gayoon's voice :) she help me to see the other side of this song that just can be made by one female's voice. Good job, unnie *thumb up*
Phương Anh hồi Changsub cover "Good luck" m.n khen lấy khen để mà :( sao đến lượt Gayoon lại thế? :( mà dù sao cũng là gà cùng nhà, mình ủng hộ họ thì họ sẽ ủng hộ lại mình mà e :) nghĩ thoáng 1 chút cho dễ thở nào =)))
Phương Anh thôi được rồi, việc mỗi người thích ai ghét ai thì cũng không thể bắt buộc được :) ss sống theo kiểu cho đi gì sẽ nhận lại như thế, với lại theo ss thì Gayoon làm khá tốt, nếu mình không ủng hộ được thì cũng không nên khắt khe hay tiêu cực quá :)
Ngọc Lan Nguyễn thì em cũng không nói gì. Không nghe, coi như không thấy, không biết gì, làm ngơ luôn đi. Cứ coi như là bận học hành không biết gì thì cũng chẳng ai nói gì mình được
this is freaking beautiful. Gayoon did such a great job I'm a B2uty myself and believe me I was so pissed thinking Cube would let someone else sing this song since it's a gift for us. It's ok if it were Good luck, fiction (btw i love 4minute's version so much), ... but not 12:30. But I love this so much, maybe not less than the origional ver. I think 4minute is coming back soon so Cube did this to promote them and it's such a nice way because Gayoon has such nice voice but she is underated. I hope both K-B2uties and I-B2uties support her and this version of 12:30. You guys don't want Junhyung to see so many dislikes right? he worked on this too remember that
Why is everyone hating in her.. seriously right now I'm disappointed of some of the comments I read of the so call beast fans like really guys?? Why you gotta be like that also if the boys were being treated wrongly at the company like someone said, they have the choice to terminate their contract with cube.. Don't you guys think beast read this stuff?? I'm sure they feel really bad now.
Sunny Love Dear elitist Korean fan, no one cares about your ranting and raving. Just because you're Korean doesn't mean your feelings mean more than "FOREIGNERS"
Let them be. They don't represent the entire fandom and the rest of us who have brains will always support. This isn't just Gayoon's cover, it's Junhyung's song and they're false fans if they dislike a BEAST member's work.
Phytie B2uty I will say what I want as a member of this fandom. I have supported BEAST and 4minute faithfully for four years and this year has been terrible. So much selfish behaviour. Just because they hate CUBE does not mean they can come here and dislike Gayoon's cover and hurt her. CUBE has a Twitter account right? Go scream at them there. Not here.
I think this song suits male voice more so yeah I like beast's version. but hey fellow b2uties it's just a cover please don't be so childish.. Gayoon fighting. 12:30 is always gonna be our boys' song so please keep cool..
Kim Grace why mad at cube? i think GoodLife permitted this cover too.. If not, i dont think this cover will exist.. Hopefully B2utys will be thankful person.. If not because of cube's approval, we wont get this 5th year anniv special album at all.
STOP BASHING TO GAYOON!!!! I'm quite disappointed why some beauties are so immature, as there is NO REASON to mad. This cover just another promotion and 12:30 STILL IS BEAST! I think this song covered by girl side will have more imagination, and it can understand 12:30 completely. Beast & 4minute both are Cube family, so we should support each other, if Beast saw their fans bashed Gayoon, they would feel very sad:( Btw, Gayoon you did a great job
Sorry to interrupt but im a korean beauty and is really surprised at this. Dont u know that beast said this song, the song 1230 is just for beast and beauty ONLY? 1230 is a fan song in its meanings and i dont get that international beauties are acting as if this song is not precious..by these promotions 1230 is losing its meaning of a fan song.. all bc of cube!
박주영 Think the positive way dear.... Maybe its because they think this year is their successful year and they wanna do a line up or something else to get recognized by public? Why don't we think that this is the another present for fans ? Since we cannot change Cube's and Beast's decision on allow other artists to cover this song .... Just accept it with our whole heart... As some B2UTY said, someone cover this song doesn't mean that it no longer for fans.. Plus TaeJoo just said on twitter I think you read it already right?
clover aqua of course we read it we just dont understand of cube actually thinking this promotion in a positive way! No way sorry for being immature...then all korean beauties are being really immature. All big fan sites, fan masters, all adult and wellknown fans are really mad about this. Being emotional, u can say that but the whole fan thing just has to be emotional. Well the thing for sure is that no korean beauty can understand u guys statements...really. im not bluffing or anything but the reaction of korean beauties were just huge..really really reallt angry almost rebellious and all wanting to fight against cube
clover aqua i just cant understand another artist singing a fan song...if ure not angry about this u dont actually get the meaning of fan song and how much beast is dedicated to it..
박주영 Honestly, that way of thinking is so immature that it makes me cringe. How is someone covering the song changes the meaning of it? The fact that BEAST put in so much effort into making this album and promoted it during their anniversary just for the fans who have waited a long time for this ballad album shows that they appreciate us very much; that, is what makes this special, not just the song itself. Plus, if CUBE sees this as good enough for a cover then shouldn't we, their fans, be happy for them? I don't understand how some people can think so negatively when this is actually a good thing.
I hope that the BEAUTYS AND 4NIAS don't fight. I mean we are a Family. Gayoon is also promoting this song covering it because some 4NIAS could have not listen to 12:30. And it also could be in the charts with a higher rank. Anyway I like this cover is different from Beast and she give her personality in the song.
우리가 화난 이유도 모르고 화난 대상이 누군지도 모르는 것 같네요. 5주년 기념으로 팬들만을 위해서 낸 앨범의 타이틀곡이고 준비하면서 멤버들이 트위터에 애착을 제일 많이 드러낸 곡이기도 합니다. 그래서 뷰티들은 큐브 기획력에 존나 빡친거고 엿먹은 기분이다 이겁니다. 말하니까 또빡치네ㅋ 결론은 걍 큐브가 핵이란거요
Beautiful! I love hearing Gayoon sing, because she as a voice of an angel. I hope she considers going solo now she is not in 4minute anymore. Best wishes to you Gayoon if you are reading this, and I meant everything I said.
B2uty....please don't leave hate comment to her....she just covering our b2st song.gayoon fighting...you did so well.awesome!!!I like it.b2uty....keep calm.cube family fighting!!!!
true b2uties support this, only foolish people calling themselves b2uties who are disliking this, mybe they are trolls but their actions are not representative of b2uty fandom, so no worries =)
This awesomeness should not stop here, I hope that the other cube artists would make a cover for this song, love it love it! Gayoon should make a duet with GK, at least for 30 sec on style log hahahahaaa
I agree! Its amazing how she could do this cover beautifully when it was originally sung by 6 people. Cube artists has real talents and they deserve to be called idols ♡.♡
Wow are people being serious right now? I thought as a fandom we were more mature than that...I guess not. Just because Gayoon made this cover doesn't erase the fact that this song is made for us!Mad at Cube?GoodLife has to accept as well so since Junhyung and the other members are okay with it could you just stop this tantrum you're throwing LIKE 5 YEAR OLD CHILDREN and stop disappointing Beast.Cause how do you think they will feel if they see how stupid you're acting?DISAPPOINTED.Stop spoiling our name with your immaturity.This is just a cover and the song is still made for us.It's still special.Geez so childish.
im afraid we have some immature fans in b2uty fandom, or trolls, who knows but let me tell you this is the act of some foolish ppl calling themseves b2uties, but our fandom is not like that, hope u can understand
Good songs will always be covered, have rearrangements, set in different styles and adjusted for the gender of the vocalist. This is really done well by a true artist. As we've seen from time to time Gayoon is more versatile than usually seen with the group. This should be a hit, also
Not calling myself as 4Minute fans,, but still i dun mind,, LOL, i know how it feels when people hate you,, it is hurt,, so i dun want to hate,, just enjoy the music, respect and ofcoz keep loving the boys,, hope they will be healthy and keep create a better music.. :)
Beast and Gayoon are both under contract with Cube Entertainment. Cube approved this 'cover' song by Gayoon of the Beast song 12:30. I wish that Cube would assign song writers to develop music for Gayoon to have solo opportunities. Gayoon has an incredible singing voice and deserves a solo opportunity, if she desires one. Hopefully, Beast fans will not be upset with Gayoon for paying tribute to Beast and their song 12:30. 'Covering' another artists song is the greatest form of flattery. Continue to support Beast, Gayoon, and 4Minute!!
YG artist doing covers of fellow artist new song, YG stans go "WE WANT MOREEEE! WHY NO LEE HI VERSION? WE WANT WINNER VERSION. AKMU PLS" BUT WHAT IS THIS FELLOW B2UTIES BASHING GAYOON? this is a gift to us so only Beast can sing this song? WHAT???
You don`t know what we say. pardon? Yes.Beast made this song for fan. This is fan song. You said only beast can sing? No but you this song is our fan song. I don`t know why cube made this project. Korea b2uty and 4nia says Cube Entertainment is stupid. We just hope Cube publicize our cibe family, don`t made this project.
Beauties never bashing Gayoon. We are Cube Family. All group in Cube always support together. Of course, with some people( may be some beauties) thinks version of Gayoon is not good, but they just give the opinion, they don't bash Gayoon. And this is just a cover. Remember, cover always different from the orginal. I think Gayoon did well. 4nia don't misunderstand Beauties!! ^^
***** Lol why not. I don't see crazy YG stans going crazy on YGE or Akdong or Tablo for covering Taeyang's songs but B2UTIES just had to rise to the occasion
B2utys aren't even bashing on her. Instead we all do love her. Read the first few comments, no one bashed her and suddenly there's comments like "please do not bash her" Our family is united afterall. It's not as worst as other companies
큐브 진짜 대박이다. 비스트가 우리한테 선물해준 곡이에요. 이번앨범 두준오빠 포카에 적혀 있잖아요. 뷰티를 위한 앨범이라고. 저번에 큐브가 기사 낸거 봤는데 재미로 만들었다고 멋대로 기사 내셨던데 대박이시다. 진짜 대단하다. 큐브가 어이없고 웃긴건 알았는데 이 정도일줄은 전혀 예상도 못했네. 선물을 멋대로 왜 망쳐요? 5주년 기념이고 뷰티한테 주는 비스트의 선물인데.. 밑에 댓글 보니까 굿럭노래 창섭이가 커버했는데 왜 가윤이가 12시30분 커버 했다고 화내냐고요? 굿럭노래도 우리한테 정말 소중한 노래에요. 근데 12시30분은 다르잖아요. 소중한것도 소중하지만 비스트 뷰티만을 위한 노래고 선물이잖아요. 이미 올라온 노래고 영상까지 찍으셨는데 내리시라고 할 수도 없고 나 참. 지금 이 짓도 용서 못하는데 더 안좋은짓 안하셨음 하네요. 큐브 대단하신거 인정하고 또 인정해요 !
I keep playing this cover again and again in between with original song..both are awesome..12시30분 are awesome..day by day i started falling in love with Gayoon voice...its really nice to hear.. 12시30분 is the Best..
B2uties, CHILL!! Hates are not needed at this point of time.. Instead, listen to how beautiful the melody is and how well Gayoon sing the song.. This is BEAUTIFUL!! I love it! I want this version to be in my playlist!! Junhyung & Taejoo decided to do something different and there's a reason why Gayoon was chosen to sing this song obviously so why the hates? This is an official UA-cam page of CUBE so please remember that CUBE artists will obviously read all this comments.. Can you imagine how the boys will feel if they were to read all this hate comments? So just stop! BEAST are busy enough with their Japan Beautiful Show & with you guys feeling "disappointed" that it's not BEAST who is in the video above, are you guys trying to make them overworked? Please don't be selfish. Team Good Life & CUBE, awesome job! Gayoon, you're my fashion icon. CUBE FAMILY ALLLLL THE WAAAYYYY!! FIGHTING!!^^
To be honest, I did feel something was off when I saw CUBE's tweet yesterday about "Another" 12:30. Like most B2UTY, I felt that this song was special. It's for their 5th Anniversary. But I knew all BEAST members, including Junhyung of course, knew about this. After I heard Gayoon's voice, although I do still prefer BEAST's version, I really, really, really like when she sang Junhyung's rap part. Never knew it could be done like that. It was lovely and, like what Taejoo said, we heard from new perspective. Plus this means that this song is just so great that CUBE decided to have this version. Would BEAST want B2UTY to be sad because of this? No. Thanks CUBE for the new version! Thanks Gayoon for singing this version! Thanks Good Life team for the great job! Thanks B2UTY who always support BEAST and their works! :)
B2UTY's what's going on? We're supposed to be a United Cube and a United family 4NIA's and B2UTY's are supposed to be close just like B2ST and 4Minute are they're like brothers and sisters so come on let's support everyone and let's keep our reputation of being calm fandoms just like all Cube fandoms are known for, B2ST, 4Minute, and United Cube hwaiting!!
Gayoon's version Is much slower and soothing in a way and I really love it but both versions are great so let's just appreciate them both and I don't know why everyone is hating on Cube and Gayoon one of the members of Good Life Tweeted that it was their idea for the cover because they wanted to give off a different feeling to "12:30" that they wanted to show so there's nothing and no one to be mad at. Haha
4nias, now I'll tell you an honest truth. B2utys not only want Gayoon's cover, we can also look forward to many more 4minute members or other cube's artist's cover. I LOOK FORWARD TO WHOEVER IS SINGING THIS SONG GDI
I am a huge B2UTY and I love this cover. I was excited to hear a cute artist was doing a cover of 12:30 and I a so pleased it was GaYoon I was wondering if it was gonna be G.NA but GaYoon did it perfectly. I don't understand the hate on this cover it was done with perfection. Also my sister who is also a B2UTY also loved it.
if you consider yourself a b2uty and dislike this song, leave this fandom right now cuz you dont deserve to be in it >.> this is a great cover by Gayoon and thats it, there's no reason to dislike this video.
Oh gosh...this is wow. I love Gayoon's voice^^ she complimented the new feminine beat! Team Goodlife, jjang! Gayoon unni, jjang! And why are some people complaining? This is beautiful! I love how she slowly rapped Jun oppa's part! Hihi
I don't get it. Why are there so many dislikes on such an amazing cover? She sounds beautiful, & as always, the song is beautiful as well. What is up with the dislikes? I mean, how can such fans get so butthurt over her COVERING this song? This is a COVER. This is outrageous. Her voice with this song is amazing. Some people don't seem to understand what the word "Cover" means.
I've read a lot of comments on this video, and i didn't see anyone bashing gayoon, although some said they didn't like the cover, they said it really politly, from most of the comments beauties are the ones that are being bash... you see a lot of dislikes.... but i also see a lot of likes, so too everyone, stop saying harsh things about our fandom, about gayoon, and about the video and just enjoy the music
I think her voice sounds really beautiful in this cover. It adds a new feeling. It sounds like a different song in a really good way. It's like hearing it for the first time again. She doesn't hit the high notes like B2ST does but I like the softness and sweetness of this version. I don't understand how people are saying the song doesn't suit a female's voice. It sounds amazing. I could really get into this version. Go Gayoon! You did a spectacular job.
Dea Tolawo i know right! Only Cube stans recognized their talent.. Now wishing for G.Na & Shin Jihoon to do the cover too.. Sounds greedy but Cube artists are jjang,so i'm craving for their voices to cover this b2utiful song..^^
Gayoon, I love your cover of Beast song 12:30. You brought so many emotions and vocals to this song. I can't wait to hear more song from you. So, proud of you!! I know that Beast and the Cube Ent. Fam is proud of you too!! Gayoon Fighting!! >3
Okay... I read most of the comments and I will say my opinion even if nobody cares about it. I'm a B2UTY and a 4nia and I love all CUBE artist and this situation makes me feel really sad. I know 12:30 is a precious present from BEAST to B2UTYS for their 5th anniversary and that some b2utys doesn't accept that an other artist that is not BEAST made a cover of this song. I respect their point of view and their feelings but let's think a little, darlings... To make a cover about this song doesn't make less important the original one, I mean... When Junhyung wrote and composed this song he put all his heart and love in it for us and to allow Gayoon to make her own cover doesn't change the original meaning and feelings. If something was precious to you it will be then and now. I know Junhyung is an artist that loves to experimentalise with music so I see this cover as a second gift from him. He rearranged the whole song to make this another version despite he's extremly busy and tired and I feel so bad to see there's so much dislikes in it. If people really are mad with CUBE, to dislike the video doesn't help the artists, in fact the effect is the opposite, so if people wants to tell CUBE about their disappointment I think is better to write a letter to the company and make signings so CUBE will see the point of view of B2UTYS and how many of them thinks and feels that way. So let's not fight and feel happy to have BEAST's love. Kisses for everyone ^3^
Im a big fan of B2ST, in fact they're my favortie group, and i understand why some people dislike this video, this song was meant to be their 5th year aniversary gift to b2uties, but i find it so immature that because of that no one is allowed to cover it, like wtf people, b2st did their job, they promoted and shared it with us, now they've ended promotion, so let someone else make a cover of this song if they want to, seriously. I like this song and i like this cover too, Gayoon is a great singer!!
why you guys dislike this??? we should be proud as this song is so good that other artists want to make a cover with it. Cube family Jiang! p/s: good job Gayoon unnie ^^, hope 4minute come back soon
Disappointed in you BEAUTIES hating on Gayoons Cover of 12:30. Im a Cube stan and it disgusts me people would hate on Gayoon (4minute member, part of Cube) for making the cover. DONT YOU REALIZE IT WOULD UPSET BEAST IF BEAUTIES WERE HATING ON HER COVER OF 12:30!! YEAH the song is a gift, but its not like we own the fucking song…grown up. We should be proud of Gayoon for singing the song with her own feeling. Music is meant to be shared, loved, and expressed. so hater Beauties comme de fuck down.” - P.S sorry for all the cussing jk sorry not sorry
Why won't you all stop all this, initially there was No hate comments until there's some ppl commenting "please do not bash on her" JUST STOP THIS it's normal for some b2uties to give off their opinions, OPINIONS
Females should do more covers, I love this as well as the original. But after the butt-hurt little kids in the comments trying to defend their "oppas" song, I see why more girls don't cover the male idol groups. Jeesh. Your "oppas" are probably shaking their head out of shame right now. You did wonderful, Gayoon!
some people can't appreciate good things somehow. it's a shame knowing the fact that gayoon is really like really really close to BEAST but some b2uties are hating on her instead just because she's doing a cover.
This song was preaent that beast made for b2uty. fan song. For celebrating 5th Univerary. Please don`t think about that. We just want to protect our fan song. We mad for cube not gayoon.
It may not only be beast's fans disliking this video ... B2UTYS resemble calm fandom. There's surely some fans who are immature in each group. Whether is beast or 4minute, each have their own immature fans. I hope you can think this way, most b2utys here likes Gayoon
first, i appeciate Gayoon hardwork~ second, i really loves how GoodLife team made an such beautiful arrangement for this cover~ third, i don't really get it how KB2uties CAN bashing Junhyung and said he's ruining Beast??!! what are you guys?? a FIVE YEAR OLD child?? how can you be so CHILDISH??! how can you said ALL THAT STUFF to Junhyung, when HE IS THE ONE who makes this beautiful song FOR US!! yes! 12.30 is special for us! thats why Beast really do such a hardwork for making this TIME album for B2uties, especially Junhyung who's need to SUFFER for a days when making this song! and this song is HIS SONG! it's his own decision whether he's want to gave this song for cover or not! Beast themselves think for B2uties a lot, they gave B2uties A LOT OF LOVE AND CARE! 12.30 promotion is already over, but Beast never want B2uties to be sad thinking they can't see Beast perfoming or can't listen to Beast song anymore, thats why Junhyung made this arrangement FOR US and ask Gayoon to sing it since Gayoon voice is perfectly fit with this arrangement! so why a B2UTY, can BASHING and said an AWFUL HARSH WORD TOWARDS JUNHYUNG??? besides, a GOOD SONG always have an cover! you should proud of Junhyung and Taejoo who can make such an beautiful song and got an a lot appreciates! if not, there can't be a cover if that song can't catch a lot love from who's listen to it! think how sad Junhyung felt, he's the one to do a lot hardwork and suffering over all those years making a songs for B2uties and B2uties can't appreciate his hardwork just because this cover, bashing him and said those awful words towards him??! got your eyes and ears open for good B2UTIES!! and don't call yourself an B2UTIES if you can't APPRECIATE AND LOVE BEAST!!
Idk why people hate this Its not supposed to sound exactly the same as the original and its a cover so yeah And cube's artists covers always impress me
Little disappointed to beauty.. Are those dislike is beauty? Remember it , cube is united .. All song together.. If u support beast, u have to support them friend..I thnk beast also love gayoon cover.. So let just support them.. Don't bash anybody.. Just support all.. Love cube
only foolish peple calling themselves b2uties, our fandom is not like that and we have history to prove it, true b2uties wont dislike this song for immature reasons, im a b2uty and i like this song too hope u understand this is just the act of a few, this is not representative of our fandom
When the teaser was out...everybody was like ' omg cant wait for it'...and now it was released...people are arguing about it....its a cover duhhh.....its not that bad in my opinion...gayoon really has a soothing voice...lets enjoy this together ^^
K-B2uties don't care about who covers this song and if it's good or not. They just care about "why the hell another artist is covering this song which is so meaningful for BEAST & B2uties?".
4nias DO NOT WORRY we B2UTYS won't bash on her. We are all a family :) Sometimes b2utys just want our boys to sing bcs afterall it's BEAST's song. Gayoon sang well so don't worry 4nias.
Gayoon eonnie you did very very well!! It have different feeling between original song and this cover. I dont know why some people hate this cover. I like both of them. When she sing junhyungie part, wow !!
woahhh..gayoon , her voice is really beautiful....people who bash her is really jealous with her...who do you think you're ..if you hate her...you think she like you...?? Haha..thinking of that haters..she better than youu..thumbs up for gayoon..👍👍👍
Uwaaaaaah so it's gayoon!!! Haaaaa I love this version sooo much!! Idk if gayoon can rap :"""" but i think this version is match for yoseob's voice hehe
But i really love gayoon's voice too!! she's my bias in 4minute btw haha. This cover is just so awesome!! Idk why b2utys bash her. Pls guys b2utys was never fight with 4nias. Why now? Cmon we're family tho.
Fighting them is that🎉🎊🎉🙆You have power&voice that great,great,great music and media came out,Who wrote the song,He really,really I feel proud of him and I applaud him #Junhyung👏👏👏🙆😊💝 #Gayoon - 12:30
I honestly loved this. I love getting to see other 4minute members doing things outside of 4m's promotions. Gayoon is super talented and I don't think that gets enough attention. It's funny, she gets more attention for her looks and her style than her really nice voice. Anywho, great cover ^^ I hope to see more things like this in the future.
The 'b2uties' that are hating this does not represent us as a whole so I would appreciate if people stop saying "I thought b2uties were more mature or I hate this fandom, or I'm ashamed of being a b2uty" and I'm disappointed that people would even hate her like come on she is part of cube she is like a sister to beast, she is in our family (United cube). I'm a b2uty and I believe that our fandom should not be blamed for ignorance of others. I do understand the sentimental value behind the song because it was from beast to beauties but bashing her would not do any good
I, for one, rlly like it. while all the immature fans go apeshit crazy, let us, relatively more mature b2uties, enjoy the music and not bother posting comments to tell them to calm down, because they wont. (these immature kpop fans are ruining our fandoms sigh) A present for fans doesnt have to be explicitly a video of the boys or anything, i see this as a gift of music and this is a beautiful song indeed. gayoon’s voice is so soothing ;_; very different side of the song and i am grateful for this version. We get to hear a whole different dimension to the song we would otherwise have been unable to experience. i like♥
Anastasia Giannakopoulou no no, thank YOU! yes, i have always prided myself as part of the peaceful and respectful b2uty fandom, i rlly hope it stays that way in the future. im glad there are still fans like you around! now, wouldnt you agree that yoseob singing this version would be pure bliss? ;_;
Im a B2uty and I dont understand why you would hate on her? Her cover is breathtaking! She did a great job. We are all a family we shouldnt be like that. I always thought us B2utys were mature different from other fans guess I was wrong.
Amazing cover, im just blown away by her subtle voice suiting this song so well! Gayoon-ah, as a proud b2uty! I fully support this, you did this song justice & those who think otherwise, don't feel like real b2uties/cube-stan at all + those reffering to all b2uties bashing, not all of us are like that~~
![[Audio] Heo Gayoon - 꿈이라고 생각해 (Poseidon OST Part 4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qYgAdVPGxBU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[defensive stage] 'house cock' - 12:30 복면가왕 20210214](/img/n.gif)
I miss Gayoon so much, please come back to us as a solo singer! One of the best women vocals of kpop in my opinion ♥
Gayoon, my favorite voice of the Kpop world
Mine too.
mee too. i hope she will debut solo under a better company
same
ME TOO
Yes
Why SOME beauties are so harsh towards Gayoon?? Is this the first time a cover has been done?? NOPE! I'm a beauty, and I'm sure Beast are really happy to hear their song covered. They're known for being polite and warm... so why beauties are behaving like this???
I would like to say, Gayoon SHOULD have a solo album!!! she's a lovely voice :)
this is a missunderstanding, they are hating cube not gayoon, i don't want relationship between 4nia and beauty become bad because of this, this is so sad...
Phytie B2uty I really hope this happen will stop asap. This is so sad to see those comments.
Phytie B2uty
hating on cube for this is the dumbest fucking idiot thing ever, these people aren't beauties but raging lunatics
Why they need to show their discontent towards Cube in Gayoon's cover song?? If there's nothing against her.. why write such comments here?? Can you understand the stupidity if such idea?
I dont think her voice is special enough. Not unique nor techichfully too. Overal its very plain i can say. Maybe hats why many people hating this cover. Bcoz its pretty awful compare to original singer.
Her singing makes me miss my non-existent ex.
lol same here!!!
Lmao
How am I only NOW seeing this! Her voice is so beautiful.
Literally one of Cube's best decisions ever. I love this so much. Pretty much anything with Gayoon is awesome.
Let Gayoon have a solo DEBUT.
Holy.... Oh my god. She did this song JUSTICE!! Wow wow! I'm not even a 4minute fan, but she did a really good job with this song! And I love love love the original. I love the softness of it without the instrumental in the back.
And here we have the main vocal talent in 4minute slaying effortlessly
I love her voice. She has one of the best singers in her generation for me.
I can't believe I have to say this about my own fandom but man, some of you guys are seriously so childish. The whole "Junhyung made this song for us as an anniversary gift, therefore, nobody else is allowed to sing it" needs to stop. Gayoon only made a cover of the song for fun; she's not going to be promoting it jfc. Honestly, shouldn't we be happy that this song is good enough that CUBE decided to make cover out of it? The people who dislike this video thinking they're doing the right thing; no, it just shows that you do not appreciate BEAST or Junyhung's hardwork. BEAST, as a whole, are probably shaking their heads in disappointment right now.
I feel like if Jonghyun didn't want her to do it, he has enough pull in CUBE to get it to not happen. He's their only in house songwriter of their biggest group lol. I can't believe BEAST fans are being really rude about it. It's not like covers haven't been done in K-Pop before. Didn't everyone and their mother cover Taeyang's song back in the spring? lol.
banamana true and i was still looking for more people to cover taeyang's song lol I just wanted to hear everyone sing it in their own way
banamana I'm sure he did agree to it. As a b2uty, I can't believe it either since having been in this fandom for 5 years now, this is the first time that I've been so disappointed. Though, I'm extremely glad that it's mostly Korean b2uties that have a problem with this; international b2uties, on the other hand, don't really care. Yeah, a lot of people covered Taeyang's song because there was an event for it.
***** Same here. I feel so ashamed of my own fandom. Never have I felt this angry before.
***** At least the international b2uties are being mature about it. Those are the ones we will most likely be associating with anyway :)
It's just few minutes was released. Why so many dislike already. TT.TT please don't hating her guys. I Love gayoon's voice. She's a part of CUBE Family. We should support her. Because she do cover for Beast's Song. If other people watch and love it. I think it'll give good impact to Beast. CUBE and 4Minute. So let's love each other. Just enjoy the music and Song that Junhyung has made it. *TIME IS SO PRECIOUS* So Beast. 4Minute CUBE Good Luck for yaaa.. ♥♡♥
Yess unnie gayoon voice is nice to hear... don't mind the haters unnie.. waste your energy
ugie_ B2ST hahahaaa..off course. I've waited it and can't sleep properly. I love the background there. So wonderful. Off course match with Gayoon face. So it reminds me of DRIVE Teaser or Jacket Photoshot. Hahaaa
jasmine lover yess unnie... yah the background look relaxing.... let's go there together unnie kekekekw
ugie_ B2ST let's GO..GO..GO..in our dream land tonight. Hahaaahaaa.. and I see delulu Nguyễn Bích Thủy Yenny PP said about Kiyoon Shipper. Hahahaaaa I'm totally agree 10000%. Even Kiki is my husband. T.T I'll give to Gayoon unniee.. haaaahaaa
That girl seriously getting on my nerve..can someone please explain to her that her comment is not good.. jasmine lover Sajidah Sazali
To be honest is the first time i've heard her sing, and i like her voice, is really soft and goes well with her sorroundings and the feeling of the song
B2UTYs please, don't left any negative comments in here :( CUBE United fans are family, right?? Please don't just because of this issue to burn our relationship so far :( Gayoonie did it very well, we need to support her. Do you think if you do that, BEAST will be happy?? No, they will be sad. Be more generous, comfortable and have positive thoughts, you're truly a beautiful B2UTY :) Remember, "like idol like fan", if we have behave well, it's good for our idol :)
P/s: this cover is good and beautiful, I love Gayoon's voice :) she help me to see the other side of this song that just can be made by one female's voice. Good job, unnie *thumb up*
Em chả thíc kiểu cover lại như này 😠 mất cả cảm tình...
Phương Anh hồi Changsub cover "Good luck" m.n khen lấy khen để mà :( sao đến lượt Gayoon lại thế? :( mà dù sao cũng là gà cùng nhà, mình ủng hộ họ thì họ sẽ ủng hộ lại mình mà e :) nghĩ thoáng 1 chút cho dễ thở nào =)))
Ngọc Lan Nguyễn có lẽ vì nam idol được yêu quý hơn nữ idol ? Dù sao thì cũng đã cố rất cố mà kh thể yêu thương nổi 4Min, dù khá là quý APink :|
Phương Anh thôi được rồi, việc mỗi người thích ai ghét ai thì cũng không thể bắt buộc được :) ss sống theo kiểu cho đi gì sẽ nhận lại như thế, với lại theo ss thì Gayoon làm khá tốt, nếu mình không ủng hộ được thì cũng không nên khắt khe hay tiêu cực quá :)
Ngọc Lan Nguyễn thì em cũng không nói gì. Không nghe, coi như không thấy, không biết gì, làm ngơ luôn đi. Cứ coi như là bận học hành không biết gì thì cũng chẳng ai nói gì mình được
가윤 다시 노래해줘ㅠㅠ 음색 너무 좋다♡
this is freaking beautiful. Gayoon did such a great job
I'm a B2uty myself and believe me I was so pissed thinking Cube would let someone else sing this song since it's a gift for us. It's ok if it were Good luck, fiction (btw i love 4minute's version so much), ... but not 12:30. But I love this so much, maybe not less than the origional ver.
I think 4minute is coming back soon so Cube did this to promote them and it's such a nice way because Gayoon has such nice voice but she is underated.
I hope both K-B2uties and I-B2uties support her and this version of 12:30. You guys don't want Junhyung to see so many dislikes right? he worked on this too remember that
đang bash cube hổng có bash gayoon đâu bạn ơi
Why is everyone hating in her.. seriously right now I'm disappointed of some of the comments I read of the so call beast fans like really guys?? Why you gotta be like that also if the boys were being treated wrongly at the company like someone said, they have the choice to terminate their contract with cube.. Don't you guys think beast read this stuff?? I'm sure they feel really bad now.
they are not hating gayoon but cube
Phytie B2uty But not showing their anger here , this is not affecting cube but Gayoon
yeah i know, but this will affect all (gayoon, beast, beauty)...this is just sad...
Sunny Love
thats absolutely ridiculous, and any b2uty who thinks so is not worth being one
Sunny Love
Dear elitist Korean fan, no one cares about your ranting and raving. Just because you're Korean doesn't mean your feelings mean more than "FOREIGNERS"
Gayoon is one of the most beautiful ladies I've ever seen, and she has an amazing voice too :D
My bias singing my favorite BEAST song 😍 miss 4MINUTE & BEAST complete... the best days of CUBE to be honest....
She sings so beautiful her voice is like the early morning of the sun rising
I am a b2uty and before even watching it I clicked on like! Why all this hate towards Gayoon? Thats so stupid, geez
they are not hating gayoon but cube
still ridiculous
yes i know, but they have a reason and we can desaggree about that, lets move on and keep supporting our boys ^^
me 2 :D I love her voice! Beast and 4minute are a Family
YES uri Gayoon is is covering this. this will be so precious. thankyou cube for at lease doing us 4nias something for the 1st time in 5 months
kb2utys disliking our Gayoonie's cover of Beast's awesome song is truly hurtful
Let them be. They don't represent the entire fandom and the rest of us who have brains will always support. This isn't just Gayoon's cover, it's Junhyung's song and they're false fans if they dislike a BEAST member's work.
***** please stop with "have brains or not" and just enjoy the song, keep calm please
they are not hating gayoon but they angry with cube
Phytie B2uty
I will say what I want as a member of this fandom. I have supported BEAST and 4minute faithfully for four years and this year has been terrible. So much selfish behaviour. Just because they hate CUBE does not mean they can come here and dislike Gayoon's cover and hurt her. CUBE has a Twitter account right? Go scream at them there. Not here.
i agree with you but your word just...
CUBE you don't know what have you done disbanding 4Minute...
True...
andzikowa I'm gonna be waiting for them. No matters what💝
It's note cube disbanding them, it's their choice not to renew the contract with cube, except hyuna, so they have to disband.
I think this song suits male voice more so yeah I like beast's version.
but hey fellow b2uties it's just a cover please don't be so childish.. Gayoon fighting. 12:30 is always gonna be our boys' song so please keep cool..
yeah i agree !
Yeah agree.. Thanks for your positive thoughts!! ♥♥♥
4leaffy This is my opinion but I like more the women version😐but I like the male version too, Just one thing to say I'm not disappointed 😂💝
Miguel Sifuentes of course the girl vs boy falsetto, you can see the answer
if b2utys are going to bash Gayoon for any reason i would be so disappointed with my fandom. seriously i thought our fandom was a bit mature
Your fandom? 4minute?Lol
amandapandaBEAST yea i am a b2uty and a 4nias. i support them both equally. is it a crime to be multi fandom?
I really dont want this to mix a war between our fandoms, I am cubeaholic and it breaks my heart to see this. Btw, my gayoon is so pretty here
No one bash~
Kim Grace
why mad at cube? i think GoodLife permitted this cover too.. If not, i dont think this cover will exist.. Hopefully B2utys will be thankful person.. If not because of cube's approval, we wont get this 5th year anniv special album at all.
STOP BASHING TO GAYOON!!!!
I'm quite disappointed why some beauties are so immature, as there is NO REASON to mad. This cover just another promotion and 12:30 STILL IS BEAST!
I think this song covered by girl side will have more imagination, and it can understand 12:30 completely.
Beast & 4minute both are Cube family, so we should support each other, if Beast saw their fans bashed Gayoon, they would feel very sad:(
Btw, Gayoon you did a great job
Sorry to interrupt but im a korean beauty and is really surprised at this. Dont u know that beast said this song, the song 1230 is just for beast and beauty ONLY? 1230 is a fan song in its meanings and i dont get that international beauties are acting as if this song is not precious..by these promotions 1230 is losing its meaning of a fan song.. all bc of cube!
박주영 Think the positive way dear.... Maybe its because they think this year is their successful year and they wanna do a line up or something else to get recognized by public? Why don't we think that this is the another present for fans ? Since we cannot change Cube's and Beast's decision on allow other artists to cover this song .... Just accept it with our whole heart... As some B2UTY said, someone cover this song doesn't mean that it no longer for fans.. Plus TaeJoo just said on twitter I think you read it already right?
clover aqua of course we read it we just dont understand of cube actually thinking this promotion in a positive way! No way sorry for being immature...then all korean beauties are being really immature. All big fan sites, fan masters, all adult and wellknown fans are really mad about this. Being emotional, u can say that but the whole fan thing just has to be emotional. Well the thing for sure is that no korean beauty can understand u guys statements...really. im not bluffing or anything but the reaction of korean beauties were just huge..really really reallt angry almost rebellious and all wanting to fight against cube
clover aqua i just cant understand another artist singing a fan song...if ure not angry about this u dont actually get the meaning of fan song and how much beast is dedicated to it..
박주영 Honestly, that way of thinking is so immature that it makes me cringe. How is someone covering the song changes the meaning of it? The fact that BEAST put in so much effort into making this album and promoted it during their anniversary just for the fans who have waited a long time for this ballad album shows that they appreciate us very much; that, is what makes this special, not just the song itself. Plus, if CUBE sees this as good enough for a cover then shouldn't we, their fans, be happy for them? I don't understand how some people can think so negatively when this is actually a good thing.
I hope that the BEAUTYS AND 4NIAS don't fight. I mean we are a Family. Gayoon is also promoting this song covering it because some 4NIAS could have not listen to 12:30. And it also could be in the charts with a higher rank. Anyway I like this cover is different from Beast and she give her personality in the song.
Yes yes 👍👍👍
exxxxaccctly!!
you're right, I'm a 4NIA and I've never listened to this song before ! x)
우리가 화난 이유도 모르고 화난 대상이 누군지도 모르는 것 같네요.
5주년 기념으로 팬들만을 위해서 낸 앨범의 타이틀곡이고 준비하면서 멤버들이 트위터에 애착을 제일 많이 드러낸 곡이기도 합니다. 그래서 뷰티들은 큐브 기획력에 존나 빡친거고 엿먹은 기분이다 이겁니다. 말하니까 또빡치네ㅋ 결론은 걍 큐브가 핵이란거요
백세영 Sorry but I can't understand Hangul.
Gayoon did awesome in this. I love her so much.
Beautiful! I love hearing Gayoon sing, because she as a voice of an angel. I hope she considers going solo now she is not in 4minute anymore. Best wishes to you Gayoon if you are reading this, and I meant everything I said.
B2uty....please don't leave hate comment to her....she just covering our b2st song.gayoon fighting...you did so well.awesome!!!I like it.b2uty....keep calm.cube family fighting!!!!
We are not don't worry ... we support gayoon unnie
ugie_ B2ST thank you....let's keep support beast and enjoys this song.....
B2UTYFUL for B2ST yupzz don't mind harsh comment about this.. just ignore them ok...
true b2uties support this, only foolish people calling themselves b2uties who are disliking this, mybe they are trolls but their actions are not representative of b2uty fandom, so no worries =)
This awesomeness should not stop here, I hope that the other cube artists would make a cover for this song, love it love it! Gayoon should make a duet with GK, at least for 30 sec on style log hahahahaaa
How do you read my heart unnie???
o.O why 4MINUTE suddenly sing BEAST solo?
Yenny PP owh...yess please.. G.Na..BTOB's vocal line..and also shin jihoon and noh jihoon..
I agree! Its amazing how she could do this cover beautifully when it was originally sung by 6 people. Cube artists has real talents and they deserve to be called idols ♡.♡
Yes!! OMG! BTOB have to cover this song too! omo. I want to hear them sing this song too 😍
Wow are people being serious right now? I thought as a fandom we were more mature than that...I guess not. Just because Gayoon made this cover doesn't erase the fact that this song is made for us!Mad at Cube?GoodLife has to accept as well so since Junhyung and the other members are okay with it could you just stop this tantrum you're throwing LIKE 5 YEAR OLD CHILDREN and stop disappointing Beast.Cause how do you think they will feel if they see how stupid you're acting?DISAPPOINTED.Stop spoiling our name with your immaturity.This is just a cover and the song is still made for us.It's still special.Geez so childish.
oh god! At last someone has said it. I want this to be in the top comment.
I agree I still like the original better, but this was good too:)
Kyla Vlogss Thank you! I just said the truth.This is such an unacceptable behavior from B2UTYs.
I also want to add that Gayoon is their closest friend in 4minute :)
im afraid we have some immature fans in b2uty fandom, or trolls, who knows but let me tell you this is the act of some foolish ppl calling themseves b2uties, but our fandom is not like that, hope u can understand
Good songs will always be covered, have rearrangements, set in different styles and adjusted for the gender of the vocalist. This is really done well by a true artist. As we've seen from time to time Gayoon is more versatile than usually seen with the group. This should be a hit, also
Not calling myself as 4Minute fans,, but still i dun mind,, LOL, i know how it feels when people hate you,, it is hurt,, so i dun want to hate,, just enjoy the music, respect and ofcoz keep loving the boys,, hope they will be healthy and keep create a better music.. :)
The best way to do..good job dear..spread the positive thoughts of yours dear.. ♥♥♥
Haha,, i really hate "HATE",, haha,, my point is just, dun hate if you cant love,,, it is ok to respect others,, :)
Yes..dun hate if you can't love..quiet if your don't like.
Beast and Gayoon are both under contract with Cube Entertainment. Cube approved this 'cover' song by Gayoon of the Beast song 12:30. I wish that Cube would assign song writers to develop music for Gayoon to have solo opportunities. Gayoon has an incredible singing voice and deserves a solo opportunity, if she desires one. Hopefully, Beast fans will not be upset with Gayoon for paying tribute to Beast and their song 12:30. 'Covering' another artists song is the greatest form of flattery. Continue to support Beast, Gayoon, and 4Minute!!
I'm so sad because of the end of 4Minute 😭
YG artist doing covers of fellow artist new song, YG stans go "WE WANT MOREEEE! WHY NO LEE HI VERSION? WE WANT WINNER VERSION. AKMU PLS"
BUT WHAT IS THIS FELLOW B2UTIES BASHING GAYOON? this is a gift to us so only Beast can sing this song? WHAT???
who said b2uties are bashing her?
You don`t know what we say. pardon? Yes.Beast made this song for fan. This is fan song. You said only beast can sing? No but you this song is our fan song. I don`t know why cube made this project. Korea b2uty and 4nia says Cube Entertainment is stupid. We just hope Cube publicize our cibe family, don`t made this project.
Beauties never bashing Gayoon. We are Cube Family. All group in Cube always support together. Of course, with some people( may be some beauties) thinks version of Gayoon is not good, but they just give the opinion, they don't bash Gayoon. And this is just a cover. Remember, cover always different from the orginal. I think Gayoon did well. 4nia don't misunderstand Beauties!! ^^
***** Lol why not. I don't see crazy YG stans going crazy on YGE or Akdong or Tablo for covering Taeyang's songs but B2UTIES just had to rise to the occasion
B2utys aren't even bashing on her. Instead we all do love her. Read the first few comments, no one bashed her and suddenly there's comments like "please do not bash her" Our family is united afterall. It's not as worst as other companies
큐브 진짜 대박이다. 비스트가 우리한테 선물해준 곡이에요. 이번앨범 두준오빠 포카에 적혀 있잖아요. 뷰티를 위한 앨범이라고. 저번에 큐브가 기사 낸거 봤는데 재미로 만들었다고 멋대로 기사 내셨던데 대박이시다. 진짜 대단하다. 큐브가 어이없고 웃긴건 알았는데 이 정도일줄은 전혀 예상도 못했네. 선물을 멋대로 왜 망쳐요? 5주년 기념이고 뷰티한테 주는 비스트의 선물인데.. 밑에 댓글 보니까 굿럭노래 창섭이가 커버했는데 왜 가윤이가 12시30분 커버 했다고 화내냐고요? 굿럭노래도 우리한테 정말 소중한 노래에요. 근데 12시30분은 다르잖아요. 소중한것도 소중하지만 비스트 뷰티만을 위한 노래고 선물이잖아요. 이미 올라온 노래고 영상까지 찍으셨는데 내리시라고 할 수도 없고 나 참. 지금 이 짓도 용서 못하는데 더 안좋은짓 안하셨음 하네요. 큐브 대단하신거 인정하고 또 인정해요 !
I keep playing this cover again and again in between with original song..both are awesome..12시30분 are awesome..day by day i started falling in love with Gayoon voice...its really nice to hear.. 12시30분 is the Best..
where are the manner of beautiful fandom in kpop that you are proud of? I'm beast fan still support for gayoon
B2uties, CHILL!! Hates are not needed at this point of time.. Instead, listen to how beautiful the melody is and how well Gayoon sing the song.. This is BEAUTIFUL!! I love it! I want this version to be in my playlist!! Junhyung & Taejoo decided to do something different and there's a reason why Gayoon was chosen to sing this song obviously so why the hates? This is an official UA-cam page of CUBE so please remember that CUBE artists will obviously read all this comments.. Can you imagine how the boys will feel if they were to read all this hate comments? So just stop! BEAST are busy enough with their Japan Beautiful Show & with you guys feeling "disappointed" that it's not BEAST who is in the video above, are you guys trying to make them overworked? Please don't be selfish. Team Good Life & CUBE, awesome job! Gayoon, you're my fashion icon. CUBE FAMILY ALLLLL THE WAAAYYYY!! FIGHTING!!^^
To be honest, I did feel something was off when I saw CUBE's tweet yesterday about "Another" 12:30.
Like most B2UTY, I felt that this song was special. It's for their 5th Anniversary.
But I knew all BEAST members, including Junhyung of course, knew about this.
After I heard Gayoon's voice, although I do still prefer BEAST's version,
I really, really, really like when she sang Junhyung's rap part. Never knew it could be done like that. It was lovely and, like what Taejoo said, we heard from new perspective.
Plus this means that this song is just so great that CUBE decided to have this version.
Would BEAST want B2UTY to be sad because of this? No.
Thanks CUBE for the new version! Thanks Gayoon for singing this version!
Thanks Good Life team for the great job! Thanks B2UTY who always support BEAST and their works! :)
GAYOON IS THE BEST!!! Her voice is perfect！As a 4NIA, I am proud of her very much！
B2UTY's what's going on? We're supposed to be a United Cube and a United family 4NIA's and B2UTY's are supposed to be close just like B2ST and 4Minute are they're like brothers and sisters so come on let's support everyone and let's keep our reputation of being calm fandoms just like all Cube fandoms are known for, B2ST, 4Minute, and United Cube hwaiting!!
Gayoon's version Is much slower and soothing in a way and I really love it but both versions are great so let's just appreciate them both and I don't know why everyone is hating on Cube and Gayoon one of the members of Good Life Tweeted that it was their idea for the cover because they wanted to give off a different feeling to "12:30" that they wanted to show so there's nothing and no one to be mad at. Haha
was i really the only one excited for this? ;-; that is sad..
No you're not the only one... I was really excited for this cover too and it's amazing
Oh gayoonie unnie is nice to hear your voice BEAST is the best.. 4minute hwaitiii... gayoonie unnie hwaitiii...
4nias, now I'll tell you an honest truth. B2utys not only want Gayoon's cover, we can also look forward to many more 4minute members or other cube's artist's cover. I LOOK FORWARD TO WHOEVER IS SINGING THIS SONG GDI
wow yoseob u're here
Great
Gayoon's voice is really angelic. I really love this version of 12:30 :) Congrats Cube! Really United :)
I am really stunned by this cover!!! Gayoon's voice just suit this song so much:) The high notes are so good!
Love it! OMG. Can BTOB's Vocal line have a cover of this beautiful song too? PLEASE CUBE!!! ♥
that would be awesome!!! ^___^
Jae Shin OMG...kinda hope for it too^^...
BTOB vocal lines,G.Na,shin jihoon or noh jihoon might be perfect too ^^
Omgggg yassss btob vocal line would be amazeballzzzz ;_;
I am a huge B2UTY and I love this cover. I was excited to hear a cute artist was doing a cover of 12:30 and I a so pleased it was GaYoon I was wondering if it was gonna be G.NA but GaYoon did it perfectly. I don't understand the hate on this cover it was done with perfection. Also my sister who is also a B2UTY also loved it.
if you consider yourself a b2uty and dislike this song, leave this fandom right now cuz you dont deserve to be in it >.>
this is a great cover by Gayoon and thats it, there's no reason to dislike this video.
Oh gosh...this is wow. I love Gayoon's voice^^ she complimented the new feminine beat! Team Goodlife, jjang! Gayoon unni, jjang! And why are some people complaining? This is beautiful! I love how she slowly rapped Jun oppa's part! Hihi
I don't get it. Why are there so many dislikes on such an amazing cover? She sounds beautiful, & as always, the song is beautiful as well. What is up with the dislikes? I mean, how can such fans get so butthurt over her COVERING this song? This is a COVER. This is outrageous. Her voice with this song is amazing. Some people don't seem to understand what the word "Cover" means.
I've read a lot of comments on this video, and i didn't see anyone bashing gayoon, although some said they didn't like the cover, they said it really politly, from most of the comments beauties are the ones that are being bash... you see a lot of dislikes.... but i also see a lot of likes, so too everyone, stop saying harsh things about our fandom, about gayoon, and about the video and just enjoy the music
SOMEONE SAID IT
Agree with you unnie... *sigh* why must angry because this cover thing.. gayoon is such sweet personn
Ariana Aziz said what? Harsh things? I guess they did but there aren't that many... just a few
Newlybeauty joker
no, what i meant that you've basically just voiced out my thoughts about the comments hahaha
Ariana Aziz ahhh hahahhahahahhahahah great then hahhaha
I think her voice sounds really beautiful in this cover. It adds a new feeling. It sounds like a different song in a really good way. It's like hearing it for the first time again. She doesn't hit the high notes like B2ST does but I like the softness and sweetness of this version. I don't understand how people are saying the song doesn't suit a female's voice. It sounds amazing. I could really get into this version. Go Gayoon! You did a spectacular job.
i want btob to cover it too cubenim :D CUBE UNITED JJANG.. ^^
Dea Tolawo Oh yes.. They have great vocal line & rap line ^^
That will be perfect too^^
yup.. Cube always perfect in their vocal,, :D
Dea Tolawo i know right! Only Cube stans recognized their talent..
Now wishing for G.Na & Shin Jihoon to do the cover too.. Sounds greedy but Cube artists are jjang,so i'm craving for their voices to cover this b2utiful song..^^
yup i think so..TT
dont forget for ROH JIHOON too, he is one of cube talented artist too, :D
Gayoon, I love your cover of Beast song 12:30. You brought so many emotions and vocals to this song. I can't wait to hear more song from you. So, proud of you!! I know that Beast and the Cube Ent. Fam is proud of you too!! Gayoon Fighting!! >3
Okay... I read most of the comments and I will say my opinion even if nobody cares about it. I'm a B2UTY and a 4nia and I love all CUBE artist and this situation makes me feel really sad. I know 12:30 is a precious present from BEAST to B2UTYS for their 5th anniversary and that some b2utys doesn't accept that an other artist that is not BEAST made a cover of this song. I respect their point of view and their feelings but let's think a little, darlings... To make a cover about this song doesn't make less important the original one, I mean... When Junhyung wrote and composed this song he put all his heart and love in it for us and to allow Gayoon to make her own cover doesn't change the original meaning and feelings. If something was precious to you it will be then and now. I know Junhyung is an artist that loves to experimentalise with music so I see this cover as a second gift from him. He rearranged the whole song to make this another version despite he's extremly busy and tired and I feel so bad to see there's so much dislikes in it. If people really are mad with CUBE, to dislike the video doesn't help the artists, in fact the effect is the opposite, so if people wants to tell CUBE about their disappointment I think is better to write a letter to the company and make signings so CUBE will see the point of view of B2UTYS and how many of them thinks and feels that way. So let's not fight and feel happy to have BEAST's love. Kisses for everyone ^3^
Im a big fan of B2ST, in fact they're my favortie group, and i understand why some people dislike this video, this song was meant to be their 5th year aniversary gift to b2uties, but i find it so immature that because of that no one is allowed to cover it, like wtf people, b2st did their job, they promoted and shared it with us, now they've ended promotion, so let someone else make a cover of this song if they want to, seriously. I like this song and i like this cover too, Gayoon is a great singer!!
why you guys dislike this??? we should be proud as this song is so good that other artists want to make a cover with it. Cube family Jiang!
p/s: good job Gayoon unnie ^^, hope 4minute come back soon
Disappointed in you BEAUTIES hating on Gayoons Cover of 12:30. Im a Cube stan and it disgusts me people would hate on Gayoon (4minute member, part of Cube) for making the cover. DONT YOU REALIZE IT WOULD UPSET BEAST IF BEAUTIES WERE HATING ON HER COVER OF 12:30!! YEAH the song is a gift, but its not like we own the fucking song…grown up. We should be proud of Gayoon for singing the song with her own feeling. Music is meant to be shared, loved, and expressed.
so hater Beauties comme de fuck down.”
-
P.S sorry for all the cussing
jk
sorry not sorry
i read the comment that tthey are not hating gayoon but they are angry with cube, if another song is ok but not this song (5th anniversary gift)
Phytie B2uty There are comments about "Gayoon ruined the song" sth. That's it
yeah i know but maybe the meaning behind the song (5th anniversay) not the cover itself, aaah i just want this to over TT_TT
Why won't you all stop all this, initially there was No hate comments until there's some ppl commenting "please do not bash on her" JUST STOP THIS it's normal for some b2uties to give off their opinions, OPINIONS
God bless you you just nailed that comment
UNDERRATED VOCALIST 😭
Females should do more covers, I love this as well as the original.
But after the butt-hurt little kids in the comments trying to defend their "oppas" song, I see why more girls don't cover the male idol groups.
Jeesh.
Your "oppas" are probably shaking their head out of shame right now.
You did wonderful, Gayoon!
some people can't appreciate good things somehow.
it's a shame knowing the fact that gayoon is really like really really close to BEAST but some b2uties are hating on her instead just because she's doing a cover.
B2UTYS aren't hating on her 😭😭😭 don't make our fandom look bad.. Like srsly did you see a comment like "I hate Gayoon" 😭😭
Yoseob Yang i did... lots of it actually. i've been sitting here only to see how we response to this
oh, and i said "some"
No one gonna bash anyone.. Sajidah Sazali Raena Tan Siti Amirah Shaari the mv is out dear..lets watch it..😍😍
Ooohhh okk!!!!!
Aleeya Ismail gumawo unnie ♥
jasmine loverYoon DoNewlybeauty jokerYenny PPNguyễn Bích Thủy*****Daniela Lopez Nuñez*****princess24eve
Thank you Aleeya Ismail ..had watched it..awesome voice I got a goosebumps heard this song..
Siti Amirah Shaari ikr..but looks like some debate happened here..
I need more from Gayoon and Jiyoon. I miss 4Minute and wish they had never disbanded.
*B2UTY with my fullest heart* -> SUCH A WONDERFUL COVER! Shows how much Gayoon respects Beast. Thank You.
her voice is actually very soothing and comforting to listen to.. I wanna see more of her singing...
Really are people disliking this vidos just because is not Beast? Please tell me that Beauty dont have this kind of stupid fans. -___-
Well, every fandom has one. Others are just good in hiding/controlling it. Recently and unfortunately...sigh. Imma stop there.
/sighs/ not all byuts are like that but.. idk some of them really have to mature up imo
This song was preaent that beast made for b2uty. fan song. For celebrating 5th Univerary. Please don`t think about that. We just want to protect our fan song. We mad for cube not gayoon.
It may not only be beast's fans disliking this video ... B2UTYS resemble calm fandom. There's surely some fans who are immature in each group. Whether is beast or 4minute, each have their own immature fans. I hope you can think this way, most b2utys here likes Gayoon
How did you know b2uty dislike -.- im like who a cover song beast any member . Not b2uty -.- i think its any fans lol
Aww this is amazing. :3 Doojoon must be proud ;)
first, i appeciate Gayoon hardwork~
second, i really loves how GoodLife team made an such beautiful arrangement for this cover~
third, i don't really get it how KB2uties CAN bashing Junhyung and said he's ruining Beast??!!
what are you guys?? a FIVE YEAR OLD child??
how can you be so CHILDISH??!
how can you said ALL THAT STUFF to Junhyung, when HE IS THE ONE who makes this beautiful song FOR US!!
yes! 12.30 is special for us!
thats why Beast really do such a hardwork for making this TIME album for B2uties, especially Junhyung who's need to SUFFER for a days when making this song!
and this song is HIS SONG! it's his own decision whether he's want to gave this song for cover or not!
Beast themselves think for B2uties a lot, they gave B2uties A LOT OF LOVE AND CARE!
12.30 promotion is already over, but Beast never want B2uties to be sad thinking they can't see Beast perfoming or can't listen to Beast song anymore, thats why Junhyung made this arrangement FOR US and ask Gayoon to sing it since Gayoon voice is perfectly fit with this arrangement!
so why a B2UTY, can BASHING and said an AWFUL HARSH WORD TOWARDS JUNHYUNG???
besides, a GOOD SONG always have an cover!
you should proud of Junhyung and Taejoo who can make such an beautiful song and got an a lot appreciates!
if not, there can't be a cover if that song can't catch a lot love from who's listen to it!
think how sad Junhyung felt, he's the one to do a lot hardwork and suffering over all those years making a songs for B2uties and B2uties can't appreciate his hardwork just because this cover, bashing him and said those awful words towards him??!
got your eyes and ears open for good B2UTIES!!
and don't call yourself an B2UTIES if you can't APPRECIATE AND LOVE BEAST!!
Idk why people hate this
Its not supposed to sound exactly the same as the original and its a cover so yeah
And cube's artists covers always impress me
I don't know her, but she has so beautiful voice. This cover is wonderful
she is a member of 4minute main vocal and she decided the outfit style for the group
+Taemii his name is Gayoon, main vocal of 4 minutes
B2utys...hold up your anger..
Gayoon is good too ^^
We need to support because she's from Cube too ^^
Dang!!
She nailed it!!
To the MAX!👆
CUBE should make her a solo debut!
MY opinion 👆👆👆👆👆✊✊✊
There is already 2yoon...
+Abraham Hernandez there's a difference between solo and duo no?
Little disappointed to beauty.. Are those dislike is beauty? Remember it , cube is united .. All song together.. If u support beast, u have to support them friend..I thnk beast also love gayoon cover.. So let just support them.. Don't bash anybody.. Just support all.. Love cube
only foolish peple calling themselves b2uties, our fandom is not like that and we have history to prove it, true b2uties wont dislike this song for immature reasons, im a b2uty and i like this song too hope u understand this is just the act of a few, this is not representative of our fandom
I'm a b2uty, I LIKED this video. I swear
I need gayoon solo 😭
i still hear this until this day I LOVE ALL MY 4M GIRL SO MUCH
I LOVE YOU GAYOONN!!! SINCE 2013 till now 2022 🥰😭😭😭😭😭
When the teaser was out...everybody was like ' omg cant wait for it'...and now it was released...people are arguing about it....its a cover duhhh.....its not that bad in my opinion...gayoon really has a soothing voice...lets enjoy this together ^^
K-B2uties don't care about who covers this song and if it's good or not. They just care about "why the hell another artist is covering this song which is so meaningful for BEAST & B2uties?".
4nias DO NOT WORRY we B2UTYS won't bash on her. We are all a family :) Sometimes b2utys just want our boys to sing bcs afterall it's BEAST's song. Gayoon sang well so don't worry 4nias.
Gayoon eonnie you did very very well!! It have different feeling between original song and this cover. I dont know why some people hate this cover. I like both of them. When she sing junhyungie part, wow !!
I think this is a teaser that Gayoon will make a solo debut. i mean, LOOK!! Her voice! IT'S ANGELIC! IMPOSSIBLE THAT CUBE WILL IGNORE THIS TALENT! ^^
woahhh..gayoon , her voice is really beautiful....people who bash her is really jealous with her...who do you think you're ..if you hate her...you think she like you...?? Haha..thinking of that haters..she better than youu..thumbs up for gayoon..👍👍👍
A voz dela toca meu coração de uma maneira tão fácil é só ela começar a cantar que já surge efeito aqui dentro.
concordo plenamente
A voz dela e muito linda ❤
Uwaaaaaah so it's gayoon!!! Haaaaa I love this version sooo much!! Idk if gayoon can rap :"""" but i think this version is match for yoseob's voice hehe
But i really love gayoon's voice too!! she's my bias in 4minute btw haha. This cover is just so awesome!! Idk why b2utys bash her. Pls guys b2utys was never fight with 4nias. Why now? Cmon we're family tho.
Fighting them is that🎉🎊🎉🙆You have power&voice that great,great,great music and media came out,Who wrote the song,He really,really I feel proud of him and I applaud him #Junhyung👏👏👏🙆😊💝 #Gayoon - 12:30
I honestly loved this. I love getting to see other 4minute members doing things outside of 4m's promotions. Gayoon is super talented and I don't think that gets enough attention. It's funny, she gets more attention for her looks and her style than her really nice voice. Anywho, great cover ^^ I hope to see more things like this in the future.
The 'b2uties' that are hating this does not represent us as a whole so I would appreciate if people stop saying "I thought b2uties were more mature or I hate this fandom, or I'm ashamed of being a b2uty" and I'm disappointed that people would even hate her like come on she is part of cube she is like a sister to beast, she is in our family (United cube). I'm a b2uty and I believe that our fandom should not be blamed for ignorance of others. I do understand the sentimental value behind the song because it was from beast to beauties but bashing her would not do any good
i miss her so much! ♥️
I, for one, rlly like it. while all the immature fans go apeshit crazy, let us, relatively more mature b2uties, enjoy the music and not bother posting comments to tell them to calm down, because they wont. (these immature kpop fans are ruining our fandoms sigh)
A present for fans doesnt have to be explicitly a video of the boys or anything, i see this as a gift of music and this is a beautiful song indeed. gayoon’s voice is so soothing ;_; very different side of the song and i am grateful for this version. We get to hear a whole different dimension to the song we would otherwise have been unable to experience. i like♥
Thank you! I thought we were a mature fandom but suddenly they're being so immature. it's good to see there are reasonable people in this fandom.
Anastasia Giannakopoulou no no, thank YOU! yes, i have always prided myself as part of the peaceful and respectful b2uty fandom, i rlly hope it stays that way in the future. im glad there are still fans like you around! now, wouldnt you agree that yoseob singing this version would be pure bliss? ;_;
스텔라 yes!!Yoseob is my ultimate bias so it would definitely be pure bliss
Anastasia Giannakopoulou Junhyung is my ultimate bias so a performance of this with junhyung at the piano and yoseob singing will be..... ahhh
why many dislike? This is probably one of the best covers I heard!! She have a nice voice!!
Her voice is so angelic. When she hits high I swear I get chills every time. I miss hearing her voice I hope she will release a solo soon. ♥️♥️
Im a B2uty and I dont understand why you would hate on her? Her cover is breathtaking! She did a great job. We are all a family we shouldnt be like that. I always thought us B2utys were mature different from other fans guess I was wrong.
Amazing cover, im just blown away by her subtle voice suiting this song so well!
Gayoon-ah, as a proud b2uty! I fully support this, you did this song justice & those who think otherwise, don't feel like real b2uties/cube-stan at all
+ those reffering to all b2uties bashing, not all of us are like that~~
seeing all of these comments really make me speechless. i dont know what to say. hope everyone can calm down and be positive about it.
Thats right..be positive ♥♥♥
Siti Amirah Shaari yeah. we must
ohmaygod .. this is so so so so so awesome .. i really2 love this version .. thanks cube !!!!!!!!!!
This is great! It's so peaceful and soothing. Her voice is so weightless. She's so talented I don't see how people can hate on her