🙏జై శ్రీమన్నారాయణ🙏 JET WORLD ఛానల్ కి విచ్చేసిన భక్తులందరికీ స్వాగతం. మీ మనస్సులో భక్తి భావాన్ని నింపి, ఆధ్యాత్మిక మార్గంలో మిమ్మల్ని ముందుకు నడిపేందుకు JET WORLD ఛానెల్ ను Subscribe అవ్వండి లైక్ చేయండి & షేర్ చేయండి.
It is a Sin to ask a Saint such uncomfortable questions( egg and milk).His Holiness Jeeyar Swamiji answered devotees questions.Please enlighten devotees to stop asking controversial questions.
No matter how logical and truth the reason is ,there will still be people coming up with variations in questions... because the urge of the tongue is very strong... so is the cycle of birth and death.... Hare Krishna
Very true. May we take shelter of Srila Prabhupada and Rupa Goswami and be granted the use of our tongues for honoring Krishna prasadam and chanting the Holy Names! Haribol
@@TheRforravi by eating menstrual waste of hen is rational Hoe tamsic food it is . Food industry knows some times the effects of food , how these are but after lomg time it exposes due to billions of dolars
@@savithaanjje2328right so called pure blood(milk) will become animals child in future and the mother wants to safeguard her milk for that 😂 . You also became a human from your mother's milk and not by egg. Nice logic, we never knew this.
Excellent analysis. One thing about cows milk. World wide the dairy business has become extremely extremely cruel to the animals. I only wish if some regulation comes and peotects the cows and buffaloes
So true …because of cruelty in dairy industry i quite dairy … i also wish for strict regulations.. but i know its not gonna make any difference, only compassion cn change the situation … these people treat animals as machine not as soul …
thats why buy milk frm local indians who has cow farm.... they get milk using their hand, and less cruel....also calf get their portion of milk as it is. too much milk also will cause watery dung in calf,
Wow. Good question and great answer. Also the milk should be organic that is produced without injecting hormones in to cows. As well as cows should be natural grass fed.
Milk is avoidable if child is consuming all types of food, it helps puberty at natural timing and not early. Milk from industrial farms is one of the possible factors for early puberty🙏
That is the mark of a Hindu saint that separates him from other saints. If a Hindu saint has a quest he will seek answer.He will not just quote from the texts.
Lol. Modern day useless hindu ideas. Where do you get the names Shiva and vishnu from? It's all in the vedas. Nothing more to think about. The problem is that the British have confused you so much that you think something as tatpariya and sadachara when it is not.
👍👍👍 True... Not the full logic of the answer, but your take on Hindu saints. I mean, even Milk now a days is produced by deceiving cows. And bird eggs cannot be directly compared & equated with menstrual secretion, even though menstrual secretion has human egg (ovum) remnants in it.
@SatishSetty "Jaya Srimannarayana 🙏 I've never seen [...] books and present such an answer. Jaya Gurudeva 🙌" =============================== Why did this 'swami' need to look for answers in modern, evidence-based veterinary science? Could he not find the answer in the all-encompassing (pseudo) scientific Hindu (TAN TANAATANI) books like the Vedas, the Puranas, and so on??
@@forest3064 "Hindu Dharma is not [...] egg is not bad to eat". ========================== it is this man of the so-called hindu-dharma in this video who is saying that eating eggs is a sin. so, go and tell HIM that "egg is not bad to eat"; there is no need to tell me.
I am happy my entire family converted to veganism. We never drank our mothers Milk after a year and the cow didn’t ask us to drink her milk. We don’t Need to steal her milk.
😂😅 idiot.... Where it is written in their BRAHMINIC SCRIPTURES.....?? He is not representing HINDUISM, He is representing only BRAHMINISM section of HINDUISM.... HINDUISM is not only BRAHMINISM...but also way of life of BUDDHISM, SIKKHISM, JAINISM, BRAHMINIC SHAIVISM, NON-BRAHMINIC SHAIVISM....
I think this swami is totally un-aware of the milk production in dairy industry. Cow may produce milk in excess which its calf needs, but the intention is not for human consumption. No harm done to anyone if its used by others... But that is not how it works.. Today, the whole industry is about getting max milk with all sort of antibiotics given to the cow & artificially inseminating the cows so they are quickly ready with next calf, just for the sake of milk production.. There is lot more which perhaps is not warranted here.. Most of the people dont care OR want to know about this process.
@@vishnurathore7537 If you just want to classify yourself, its very easy... Do you eat only plant based food (/derivativies)? If answer is yes.. You are pure vegetarian/vegan.. Remember no milk, no butter etc.. But then if you are someone whoc cosume milk based products, then youare lacto+vegan = which is commonly used to define as vegeterian in India.
@@AP-eb8hdswami is giving a logical answer....what your are talking is totally a different topic where animals are abused for getting milk...His whole intention was to clear doubt that getting milk from cow doesnt necessarily mean animal abuse..swamiji very well answered the question in the right context to the ladys question
❤I bow down at the lotus feet of His holiness Chinna jeeyar swami . Love from ISKCON. Hare Krishna hare Krishna Krishna Krishna hare hare Hare Rama hare Rama Rama Rama hare hare
So by this logic we shouldn’t be drinking mass produced milk as the calves are forcibly separated from their mothers and denied from having the milk so the maximum amount can be collected for sale?
Yes you are right. 20 years ago, I stopped drinking milk all together and I was under tutelage of great spiritual master. So he got to know about it asked me why. I explained. Then he said, That is true that is what is going on but if we offer the milk from that cow as an offering to Lord Krishna, then the cow becomes liberated from birth and death. When we put Krishna in the centre, everything becomes auspicious. But the vedic law must be followed. Because now you can ask me another question then what about the meat? Can offer that? Answer is no. Meat eating is strictly not allowed in vedic sastras.
Milk is sattvic but eggs are not. The substance in a egg even if is unfertilized is like meat so it is bad for spiritul life. But today, the way to get both egg and milk is filled with so much suffering so why not go vegan. Ahimsa is the way to walk through life❤ anyway so nice to hear a spiritul leader explain with love. Your blessed India has had countless saints and sages, only a few of them said ok to nonvegetarian food.
Saints say that every being is made of five elements. Only humans have all five active in them. Cows, horses and goats etc has four active. Birds has three. Fish, insects and reptils has two and finally the plants has only one active. This make the difference according to the karma while eating them. The more elements active the heavier load of karma. Therefore saints advice us to eat from from the plant kingdom.
Vegetarian means cruelty free ,but if you see majority of milk comes from commercial diaries which treat cows like machines,there is no limit on cruelty,in this case its good to avaoid dairy .
buy frm local indian cow farm owners, they use hand to extract milk, less cruel and also calf would get its portion of milk. ahimsa milk. yes it is available, be wise. krishna allowed drinking of ahimsa milk
indeed, try getting milk form a local milkman. If u live in cities u can switch to soy milk or coconut milk. I too have stopped regular consumption of milk cuz it got difficult ot digest as I grew up.
@@discovervaishnava that ahimsa which Krishna told is not possible in today's age where dairy is business,if you don't believe then do one thing,go to your ahimsa dairy,and check how many male calf and bulls he has ,he he has less or none then those males have gone to slaughter house,
😂😅 idiot.... Where it is written in their BRAHMINIC SCRIPTURES.....?? He is not representing HINDUISM, He is representing only BRAHMINISM section of HINDUISM.... HINDUISM is not only BRAHMINISM...but also way of life of BUDDHISM, SIKKHISM, JAINISM, BRAHMINIC SHAIVISM, NON-BRAHMINIC SHAIVISM....
Whatever Brahmins say is TRUTH & FACT...in HINDUISM.... Supreme court said HINDUISM is collection of religion like Brahminism, Jainism, Buddhism, SIKKHISM, Shaktism, Tribal tradition... But, Brahmins gurus think only Brahminism is HINDUISM....those who do not believe in the supremacy of vedas are NASTHIK....😅😂
Great explanation. However, the realities of industrial farming is cruel. Dairy cows are impregnated over and over again for the purpose of producing milk for human consumption. The calf is separated from the cow immediately when it's born. If its a male calf, it goes straight to the slaughter house. The milk we consume from industrial farming has puss/blood eventhough deemed suitable for human consumption. Only when one visits such dairy farms, one will know the realities and understand whether we should consume milk.
In Padma Purana - It is been said "VASUDEVAYA VIDMAHE MAHA HAMSAYA DEEMAHI. THANNO VISHNU PRACHODAYAT !! Chant "OM NAMO NARYANANA AAND HAVE A PEACEFUL LIFE!!
Jai Srimannarayana! Beautiful answer by swamiji! Given that all commercial milk is got by not giving anything to the calves, what should we do? I have been vegan for 15+ years for this reason. Would love to see you guiding us all in this aspect. Should we not use any milk that is taken without giving to the calves? What do we do for the abhishekams in temples?
There’s a saying.. “ if you have to choose between being Kind vs being Right, you should always choose Kind and you will always be Right “ Dairy is cruel. Being Vegan in present times is being Krishna conscious.🙏🏼💚🙏🏼
He is sincere all the way! ❤ PS: Also please note - flowers are reproductive systems (analogous to genitals and womb of mammals) of plants and trees. But we do eat them and also use them in pujas. I think his point is good food is produced without harming or stealing or deceiving other living beings...
The swamy also talks about unfertilized eggs. Hens lay eggs as part of their cycle, whether they were impregnated or not. The eggs they produce when they’re not impregnated will never grow a chick.
@@rpaafourever7908 ever heard of unnatural stuff.... Just because humans think they can give hormones tohens and produce eggs that cannot Fertilised doesnot make it right....this is harassment for the hens...if u eat natti eggs then ur a non veg as ur eating the womb of the hen...
Superb reply by Swami, in human female it's 21 days mensurational cycle and birds it's 21 hours cycle. Still to mention either one male or female gamet present and due no mating zygote formation is devoid ,it comes out as an egg with cycle liquid which is unhygienic and in human it's called as ova ( ovulation cycle or heat cycle which needs mating to produce offspring). Thus , swamy Ji is perfectly correct
@@crystal6350 still ovum / egg is product of menstruation, unfortunately in chicken there is no uterus lining like women, chicken still produce egg and thats product of menstruation and meant to create a new living being, thus not for vegetarians. milk cant produce new liiving being directly frm it, simple. dont confuse urself and also others
@@discovervaishnava dude egg is ovulation !! Which is different from menstruation- menstruation is the blood tissue lining of the uterus that sheds! Are you science student? Not offending but m curious
@@discovervaishnava and the uterus of the chicken produces hard shell of calcium which is not consumed! Chicken produces egg every alternative day even though it doesn’t mate so there is only one set of chromosomes!! Which is futile! No life can come out of unfertilized egg! It’s just proteins and one set of chromosomes!! It’s not about the content- milk is sacred because it’s the most important nourishment given out of purest form of love on earth which is why it’s sacred and is also sattvik in nature But egg is tamasik in nature but it has lot of nutrients too! If one wants to avoid the reason should be it’s tamasik nature ! Not because its ovum! It’s basically one cell that too which cannot hatch! Commercially available eggs are unfertilized Milk is also secretion only - it’s animal product Unfertilized Egg is also secretion only - again animal product Only place from which it comes is different but again both are secretions! So don’t form weird ideas menstruation and all! If you get disgusted with source it’s your personal problem! Don’t write stupid things at least! Cycle liquid menstruation! Not comparable!! Totally different things
Pranam Swamiji. How to answer the question that the cows are given hormonal injections to produce milk just like post delivery. The cows are deceived abs same time are suffering. How to avoid such conditions in abroad countries and sometimes in India too.
The very essence of milk in a home is not from other's cows. When you call my home, even the go mata is also central and essential part of it. If you cannot afford to raise a cow, then better dont have milk of a cow raised unknowns....
Also in milking cows , the milk will contain some percentage of blood especially if milking is done in mechanised way in large farms. So diary milk can never be 100% pure milk.
Seed and Fruits are reproductive systems of the plants and trees. Can we eat them? J.C.Bose proved that plants cry out when distressed and experience pain and pleasure like all life forms. This itself just got me thinking how much pain we are giving the plants and trees by plucking, cutting, chopping, threshing their babies. Personally, I feel distressed that we actually powder the seeds (grain), cut the fruit (babies) without caring about their feelings for our own happiness of enjoying and enrichment.
Here are my 2 cents -- Just like excess milk that is left-over after a calf feeds on it is good, those eggs which are not fertilized are good as well..
You didn't understand the whole conversation and you missed the very point of this conversation. There is no point of fertilised or non-fertilised, but the main point is this that eggs comes from the menstruation process and eggs have main function of reproduction, nothing else. Whereas milk has main function to give nutrients to the babies. So, it's the whole main point here that eggs meant for reproduction, doesn't matter if fertilised or non fertilised. And milk meant for nutrients of newborn babies. I hope u may understand now the whole conversation.
@@vishalrao4073 what kind of explanation is this? By this logic one should not be eating any seeds , nuts, fruits as they are reproductive units of plants..
@@AP-eb8hd plants and fruits are meant for eating purpose. Your arguments is very incorrect everytime. See, first you were talking about fertilized and non-fertilized eggs for your approval of eating eggs which was not the main point of this video conversation. When I have clarified you about the exact point of this video conversation, now you started comparing eggs with plants and fruits. But you just want to prove yourself right, that's why you will not accept any logical answering by anyone. Btw, you are free for eating anything, no one is stopping you.
@@vishalrao4073 don't make stupid statements.. just because we eat fruits and nuts, doesn't mean plants make them for eating purpose..they are their off springs..it's evolutionary stuff. this is not veg/non veg thing. I am talking about reproductive units..
@@AP-eb8hd here the one who making stupid statements is only you. See your main comment, you said that if it not fertilised, then it's good for eating. But I informed you about the video conversation that you haven't understood what this monk or guru has said, he simply talked about eating of reproductive product as eggs and eating of nutrients product as milk. But now, you just jumped away from your main statement about non-fertilized eggs and you suddenly started comparing it with plants and fruits. Here, it's proved again that you just want to prove yourself right by jumping from one topic to another. You even couldn't stand firm on your first statement about non-fertilized eggs.
🙏జై శ్రీమన్నారాయణ🙏
JET WORLD ఛానల్ కి విచ్చేసిన భక్తులందరికీ స్వాగతం. మీ మనస్సులో భక్తి భావాన్ని నింపి, ఆధ్యాత్మిక మార్గంలో మిమ్మల్ని ముందుకు నడిపేందుకు JET WORLD ఛానెల్ ను Subscribe అవ్వండి లైక్ చేయండి & షేర్ చేయండి.
Ug
It is a Sin to ask a Saint such uncomfortable questions( egg and milk).His Holiness Jeeyar Swamiji answered devotees questions.Please enlighten devotees to stop asking controversial questions.
P
Can you please translate
@@harinathan3070sanatana dharma permits asking questions. Only when questiones we get answers and got cleared
I am a vegetarian. I am proud of my food habits
I’m a non vegetarian and Iam proud of my food habits..
@@VISHNURAVIDAS-k4vno body asked your fing opinion get out
we r proud of ourselves, no matter what it is we do
Deforestation, contaminating soil with pesticides and forcefully impregnating cows and killing its babies shouldnt make you that proud.
😂😂😂😂😂 hindu gods are all meat eaters you also pray them.....aren't you proud of them......😂😂😂😂😂
No matter how logical and truth the reason is ,there will still be people coming up with variations in questions... because the urge of the tongue is very strong... so is the cycle of birth and death....
Hare Krishna
Very true. May we take shelter of Srila Prabhupada and Rupa Goswami and be granted the use of our tongues for honoring Krishna prasadam and chanting the Holy Names! Haribol
Milk is poison full of antibiotics and oxytocin. Calves are murdered and milk is extracted. Satvik milk is rare to get in cities.
It's not the urge of tongue. But it's human intellect and curiosity to understand the rationale.
@@TheRforravi when does one loose intellect?
@@TheRforravi by eating menstrual waste of hen is rational
Hoe tamsic food it is .
Food industry knows some times the effects of food , how these are but after lomg time it exposes due to billions of dolars
This is one of the LIFETIME ANSWERS which I heard. Very clear explanation without hurting others in an understanble way.
This is like saying don't pluck a flowers because they feed bees. It's not enough for me.
Eating a menstrual egg is a satisfying answer....???and what about milk....pure blood....😂😂😂....
@@savithaanjje2328right so called pure blood(milk) will become animals child in future and the mother wants to safeguard her milk for that 😂 . You also became a human from your mother's milk and not by egg. Nice logic, we never knew this.
@@sunitization haha....so funny....i personally did not like comparison he made....there are so many other ways to say the same....😏😏
@@savithaanjje2328 ok
Detailed explanation that too in impeccable english for new age children and people to understand....crystal clear explanation guru garu🙏
Excellent answer 👍 really loved the way he understood the process of egg..
Excellent analysis.
One thing about cows milk. World wide the dairy business has become extremely extremely cruel to the animals. I only wish if some regulation comes and peotects the cows and buffaloes
yes and the males go to the veal market dairy is very un healthy and cruel
Agreed and it should start with INDIA. Being a nation that promotes Hinduism, it's shameful India remains the world's top beef and leather producer.
So true …because of cruelty in dairy industry i quite dairy … i also wish for strict regulations.. but i know its not gonna make any difference, only compassion cn change the situation … these people treat animals as machine not as soul …
thats why buy milk frm local indians who has cow farm.... they get milk using their hand, and less cruel....also calf get their portion of milk as it is. too much milk also will cause watery dung in calf,
All dairies kill the new born calves and use injections to extract milk.
Beautiful explanation,
Hare Krishna 🙏🏼
Sri Gurubhyo nama:
Thanks you dear Guruji 🙏 for explaining this topics sooo clearly.
Also, thanks to the student for asking such a question.
Wow. Good question and great answer. Also the milk should be organic that is produced without injecting hormones in to cows. As well as cows should be natural grass fed.
Milk is avoidable if child is consuming all types of food, it helps puberty at natural timing and not early. Milk from industrial farms is one of the possible factors for early puberty🙏
That original milk is costly and we are not getting it in cities.
Yes, it should be organic, not the injected one which cause several harmone disorder
Not some eggs... Even in nater if bird does not fertilise... They lay egg
Not my mother. Not my milk.
That is the mark of a Hindu saint that separates him from other saints. If a Hindu saint has a quest he will seek answer.He will not just quote from the texts.
You have been deceived by your conditioning and then this guy puts a stamp on it to make it more real
Rightly said. One has think over what he said and not blindly decive with his speech.
Lol. Modern day useless hindu ideas. Where do you get the names Shiva and vishnu from? It's all in the vedas. Nothing more to think about. The problem is that the British have confused you so much that you think something as tatpariya and sadachara when it is not.
True.
👍👍👍 True... Not the full logic of the answer, but your take on Hindu saints.
I mean, even Milk now a days is produced by deceiving cows. And bird eggs cannot be directly compared & equated with menstrual secretion, even though menstrual secretion has human egg (ovum) remnants in it.
Many thanks for such a wonderful explanation swamiji! Very enlightening!
Jaya Srimannarayana 🙏 I've never seen any other spiritual leader study veterinary books and present such an answer. Jaya Gurudeva 🙌
@SatishSetty
"Jaya Srimannarayana 🙏 I've never seen [...] books and present such an answer. Jaya Gurudeva 🙌"
===============================
Why did this 'swami' need to look for answers in modern, evidence-based veterinary science?
Could he not find the answer in the all-encompassing (pseudo) scientific Hindu (TAN TANAATANI) books like the Vedas, the Puranas, and so on??
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist Hindu Dharma is not pseudo science, the answer is there in Charaka Samhitha, and egg is not bad to eat.
@@forest3064
"Hindu Dharma is not [...] egg is not bad to eat".
==========================
it is this man of the so-called hindu-dharma in this video who is saying that eating eggs is a sin.
so, go and tell HIM that "egg is not bad to eat"; there is no need to tell me.
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist the response is still not convincing..
@@AP-eb8hd For that you need basic knowledge
Wow... Good question and beautiful explanation. Thanks for the amazing wisdom
That was an amazing way to answer, thank you Swamiji.
Beautiful explanation, learned Swamiji! Pranam🙏
Wonderful explanation I bow my head to Swami Ji
I am happy my entire family converted to veganism. We never drank our mothers
Milk after a year and the cow didn’t ask us to drink her milk. We don’t
Need to steal her milk.
Very clearly explained.....thank you Swami....jay srimannarayana
Jai Shreemannarayana Gurujim wonderful explanation to put stop to many allegations from Eggtarians Vs Vegitarians
😂😅 idiot....
Where it is written in their BRAHMINIC SCRIPTURES.....??
He is not representing HINDUISM,
He is representing only BRAHMINISM section of HINDUISM....
HINDUISM is not only BRAHMINISM...but also way of life of BUDDHISM, SIKKHISM, JAINISM, BRAHMINIC SHAIVISM, NON-BRAHMINIC SHAIVISM....
The best answer who always tries to show down the pure vegetarians 🙏🏻💐
I think this swami is totally un-aware of the milk production in dairy industry.
Cow may produce milk in excess which its calf needs, but the intention is not for human consumption. No harm done to anyone if its used by others... But that is not how it works..
Today, the whole industry is about getting max milk with all sort of antibiotics given to the cow & artificially inseminating the cows so they are quickly ready with next calf, just for the sake of milk production.. There is lot more which perhaps is not warranted here.. Most of the people dont care OR want to know about this process.
I'm a vegetarian but I don't which one am I, pure or unpure? Can you help me?
@@vishnurathore7537 If you just want to classify yourself, its very easy... Do you eat only plant based food (/derivativies)? If answer is yes.. You are pure vegetarian/vegan.. Remember no milk, no butter etc..
But then if you are someone whoc cosume milk based products, then youare lacto+vegan = which is commonly used to define as vegeterian in India.
In many other places in world egg+vegan = ovo vegan is also considered pure vegetarian..
@@AP-eb8hdswami is giving a logical answer....what your are talking is totally a different topic where animals are abused for getting milk...His whole intention was to clear doubt that getting milk from cow doesnt necessarily mean animal abuse..swamiji very well answered the question in the right context to the ladys question
fantastic answer swamiji I adore your perseverance
Om Namo Narayana ya. Swamiji namas karams. You have given correct explanation,and clear the doubt.
Crystal clear explanation
Super Logical Brilliant Answer Swamiji❤
Pranams Swamiji😊
❤I bow down at the lotus feet of His holiness Chinna jeeyar swami .
Love from ISKCON.
Hare Krishna hare Krishna Krishna Krishna hare hare
Hare Rama hare Rama Rama Rama hare hare
Jai Sreemannarayana Audiyan Dasoham, Chinna jeeyar Swamy thiruvadigale Charanam 🙏
Very good message 🙏
well this actually make sense! this is the exact answer to have it handy to reply to all those secular Hindus and non vegetarian
Thank you Swamji for clearing the doubt.
So by this logic we shouldn’t be drinking mass produced milk as the calves are forcibly separated from their mothers and denied from having the milk so the maximum amount can be collected for sale?
Many saints or sanyasi do not drink milk these days for the same reason and rather drink herbal tea without milk.
Better keep a cow within the family. No guilts
We are human we exploit whatever we want since like whatever bc
Yes you are right.
20 years ago, I stopped drinking milk all together and I was under tutelage of great spiritual master.
So he got to know about it asked me why. I explained.
Then he said,
That is true that is what is going on but if we offer the milk from that cow as an offering to Lord Krishna, then the cow becomes liberated from birth and death.
When we put Krishna in the centre, everything becomes auspicious.
But the vedic law must be followed.
Because now you can ask me another question then what about the meat?
Can offer that?
Answer is no.
Meat eating is strictly not allowed in vedic sastras.
He said it, did he not?
Thanks for Clarifying Swamiji
Very good answer, only problem is most of the milk for sale is milk which was deprived from the baby calf.
Yes, that is unethical.
Because we all can’t raise cattle and hold a full time job in a city.
WHAT A REPLY AWE INSPIRING I FEEL ENLIGHTENED TODAY......
PRANAM EVAM CHARAN SPARSH TO SWAMI JI
Even I used to think about it .....thanks for the answer guruji
excellent answer by swamiji. pranaam 🙏🙏
Very nice explanation. Thank you Swamiji
Wow...amazed by the answer. Only a learned man can give such an answer
Swamijee, you are jnana murthy and Dayaa murthy. Following your words, save treachery committed by people towards fellow creatures!anantha pranams!
Thank you very much. Detailed explanation to understand.
Milk is sattvic but eggs are not. The substance in a egg even if is unfertilized is like meat so it is bad for spiritul life. But today, the way to get both egg and milk is filled with so much suffering so why not go vegan. Ahimsa is the way to walk through life❤ anyway so nice to hear a spiritul leader explain with love. Your blessed India has had countless saints and sages, only a few of them said ok to nonvegetarian food.
⛳️Milk is not SATVIC
Saints say that every being is made of five elements. Only humans have all five active in them. Cows, horses and goats etc has four active. Birds has three. Fish, insects and reptils has two and finally the plants has only one active. This make the difference according to the karma while eating them. The more elements active the heavier load of karma. Therefore saints advice us to eat from from the plant kingdom.
Wonderful answer. Resting the case for once and for all.
Vegetarian means cruelty free ,but if you see majority of milk comes from commercial diaries which treat cows like machines,there is no limit on cruelty,in this case its good to avaoid dairy .
buy frm local indian cow farm owners, they use hand to extract milk, less cruel and also calf would get its portion of milk. ahimsa milk. yes it is available, be wise. krishna allowed drinking of ahimsa milk
indeed, try getting milk form a local milkman. If u live in cities u can switch to soy milk or coconut milk. I too have stopped regular consumption of milk cuz it got difficult ot digest as I grew up.
@@discovervaishnava that ahimsa which Krishna told is not possible in today's age where dairy is business,if you don't believe then do one thing,go to your ahimsa dairy,and check how many male calf and bulls he has ,he he has less or none then those males have gone to slaughter house,
Thank you swamji always you have been a lamp to lead us with correct facts🙏
*References corroborating carnivorism in Hinduism:*
Manu smriti 5.56
Ramayana 2:20:29
Ramayana. 2:52:89
Ramayana 2:56:22
Ramayana 2:56:35
Ramayana 2:84:10
Ramayana 2:84:17
Ramayana 3:47:22b, 23
Ramayana 3:68:32
Ramayana 3:68:33
Please read to enlighten yourself.
Meat eating is not prohibited in Hinduism
It's just that it's not encouraged
Wonderful explain Guruji🙏
I know a lot of vegetarian (from India), that Egg is OK but other things like meat is not OK!
edit: I've been a waiter in resorts hotels many years.
Bengalis argue Fish is Vegetarian diet....
There are all kinds of people.. we must let them be...
फारच सुंदर उत्तर स्वामीजी.
Excellent. Pranam.🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Brilliant answer....proud to be vegetarian...
Mee tooo
Vegetarians accepting this matter. But Vegans ?
@@RamareddyMallidi-oo6sd difference between vegan and vegetarians...m pure veg...no egg too..
😂😅 idiot....
Where it is written in their BRAHMINIC SCRIPTURES.....??
He is not representing HINDUISM,
He is representing only BRAHMINISM section of HINDUISM....
HINDUISM is not only BRAHMINISM...but also way of life of BUDDHISM, SIKKHISM, JAINISM, BRAHMINIC SHAIVISM, NON-BRAHMINIC SHAIVISM....
Whatever Brahmins say is TRUTH & FACT...in HINDUISM....
Supreme court said HINDUISM is collection of religion like Brahminism, Jainism, Buddhism, SIKKHISM, Shaktism, Tribal tradition...
But, Brahmins gurus think only Brahminism is HINDUISM....those who do not believe in the supremacy of vedas are NASTHIK....😅😂
Great explanation. However, the realities of industrial farming is cruel. Dairy cows are impregnated over and over again for the purpose of producing milk for human consumption. The calf is separated from the cow immediately when it's born. If its a male calf, it goes straight to the slaughter house. The milk we consume from industrial farming has puss/blood eventhough deemed suitable for human consumption. Only when one visits such dairy farms, one will know the realities and understand whether we should consume milk.
Jaisrimannarayan swamiji🙏🙏
Thanks
Hare Krishna Swamy,.
Thank you for clear explanation
Chala baga cheppaaru swamy gaaru....dhanyulam ippati tharam ...swamy oravachanams vibe bhagyam maaku andariki kalugutunnanduku....Jai shree mannarayana
Very good explanation.
In Padma Purana - It is been said "VASUDEVAYA VIDMAHE MAHA HAMSAYA DEEMAHI. THANNO VISHNU PRACHODAYAT !! Chant "OM NAMO NARYANANA AAND HAVE A PEACEFUL LIFE!!
Beautiful reply
Excellent swamy 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Jai Srimannarayana! Beautiful answer by swamiji! Given that all commercial milk is got by not giving anything to the calves, what should we do? I have been vegan for 15+ years for this reason. Would love to see you guiding us all in this aspect. Should we not use any milk that is taken without giving to the calves? What do we do for the abhishekams in temples?
There’s a saying.. “ if you have to choose between being Kind vs being Right, you should always choose Kind and you will always be Right “ Dairy is cruel. Being Vegan in present times is being Krishna conscious.🙏🏼💚🙏🏼
He is sincere all the way!
❤
PS: Also please note - flowers are reproductive systems (analogous to genitals and womb of mammals) of plants and trees. But we do eat them and also use them in pujas. I think his point is good food is produced without harming or stealing or deceiving other living beings...
🤯 mind-blowing answer and first time heard about this type of egg
Great explanation swamy.
Jai Sreemannarayana!!!!!!!!
Hare Krishna 🙏🙏🙏
Hard hitting answer. Dhanyavaad Gurujii.
Adiyen ramanuja dasan🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Great guru 🎉🎉
Thankyou Guruji for clarifying ❤
I'm a proud vegan ✊
Me too! ❤❤❤
The Best answer i heard for this question wow
Great explanation Swamiji
Very simple chick comes from egg so it's basically a life whereas calf does not come from milk... But I do agree Calf should get sufficient milk...
The swamy also talks about unfertilized eggs. Hens lay eggs as part of their cycle, whether they were impregnated or not. The eggs they produce when they’re not impregnated will never grow a chick.
😂 someone missed their biology class.. ever heard the concept of unfertilized eggs?
@@rpaafourever7908 ever heard of unnatural stuff.... Just because humans think they can give hormones tohens and produce eggs that cannot Fertilised doesnot make it right....this is harassment for the hens...if u eat natti eggs then ur a non veg as ur eating the womb of the hen...
He nailed it like hell.
Good & Great explanation
Best explanation.
Superb reply by Swami, in human female it's 21 days mensurational cycle and birds it's 21 hours cycle. Still to mention either one male or female gamet present and due no mating zygote formation is devoid ,it comes out as an egg with cycle liquid which is unhygienic and in human it's called as ova ( ovulation cycle or heat cycle which needs mating to produce offspring). Thus , swamy Ji is perfectly correct
It’s not cycle liquid but egg itself with egg white which is protein! Cycle menses that you are referring is only in mammals not in chickens
@@crystal6350 still ovum / egg is product of menstruation, unfortunately in chicken there is no uterus lining like women, chicken still produce egg and thats product of menstruation and meant to create a new living being, thus not for vegetarians. milk cant produce new liiving being directly frm it, simple. dont confuse urself and also others
@@discovervaishnava dude egg is ovulation !! Which is different from menstruation- menstruation is the blood tissue lining of the uterus that sheds! Are you science student? Not offending but m curious
@@discovervaishnava and the uterus of the chicken produces hard shell of calcium which is not consumed!
Chicken produces egg every alternative day even though it doesn’t mate so there is only one set of chromosomes!! Which is futile! No life can come out of unfertilized egg! It’s just proteins and one set of chromosomes!!
It’s not about the content- milk is sacred because it’s the most important nourishment given out of purest form of love on earth which is why it’s sacred and is also sattvik in nature
But egg is tamasik in nature but it has lot of nutrients too! If one wants to avoid the reason should be it’s tamasik nature ! Not because its ovum! It’s basically one cell that too which cannot hatch! Commercially available eggs are unfertilized
Milk is also secretion only - it’s animal product
Unfertilized Egg is also secretion only - again animal product
Only place from which it comes is different but again both are secretions! So don’t form weird ideas menstruation and all! If you get disgusted with source it’s your personal problem! Don’t write stupid things at least! Cycle liquid menstruation! Not comparable!! Totally different things
Pranam Swamiji.
How to answer the question that the cows are given hormonal injections to produce milk just like post delivery. The cows are deceived abs same time are suffering. How to avoid such conditions in abroad countries and sometimes in India too.
The very essence of milk in a home is not from other's cows. When you call my home, even the go mata is also central and essential part of it. If you cannot afford to raise a cow, then better dont have milk of a cow raised unknowns....
Well said Swamyji 🙏
प्रणाम स्वामी जी ! 🙏
Jai shreeman Narayana.
Om sri gurubhyo namaha
Suppperrrbbbb Scientific explanation💕🙇🏻♂️🙌🏻
Great answer guruji
Jai Sriman Narayana 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽. adiyen
Sree Gurubhyo Namaha 🙏🏻🌺🥭🥥🙏🏻🙇
Hare Krishna
A very good reply to all people esp to hindus who are creating unnecessary confusion (being a non veg) to other vegetarians
Also in milking cows , the milk will contain some percentage of blood especially if milking is done in mechanised way in large farms. So diary milk can never be 100% pure milk.
Pranams swamiji Vasudeva Krishnan😊
Jai Srimannarayana Srimate Ramanujayanamaha Adiyen👏👏👏👏👏👏
All foods are industrialised, which means its not grown the way it’s naturally supposed to. Milk also is not an exception here.
Jai Jai Ramanuja
Jai Jai shri mannarayana
And the debate can be rest here....wonderful answer.
Seed and Fruits are reproductive systems of the plants and trees. Can we eat them?
J.C.Bose proved that plants cry out when distressed and experience pain and pleasure like all life forms. This itself just got me thinking how much pain we are giving the plants and trees by plucking, cutting, chopping, threshing their babies. Personally, I feel distressed that we actually powder the seeds (grain), cut the fruit (babies) without caring about their feelings for our own happiness of enjoying and enrichment.
Jai Shreeman Narayan
Here are my 2 cents --
Just like excess milk that is left-over after a calf feeds on it is good, those eggs which are not fertilized are good as well..
You didn't understand the whole conversation and you missed the very point of this conversation.
There is no point of fertilised or non-fertilised, but the main point is this that eggs comes from the menstruation process and eggs have main function of reproduction, nothing else. Whereas milk has main function to give nutrients to the babies.
So, it's the whole main point here that eggs meant for reproduction, doesn't matter if fertilised or non fertilised. And milk meant for nutrients of newborn babies.
I hope u may understand now the whole conversation.
@@vishalrao4073 what kind of explanation is this? By this logic one should not be eating any seeds , nuts, fruits as they are reproductive units of plants..
@@AP-eb8hd plants and fruits are meant for eating purpose.
Your arguments is very incorrect everytime.
See, first you were talking about fertilized and non-fertilized eggs for your approval of eating eggs which was not the main point of this video conversation.
When I have clarified you about the exact point of this video conversation, now you started comparing eggs with plants and fruits.
But you just want to prove yourself right, that's why you will not accept any logical answering by anyone.
Btw, you are free for eating anything, no one is stopping you.
@@vishalrao4073 don't make stupid statements.. just because we eat fruits and nuts, doesn't mean plants make them for eating purpose..they are their off springs..it's evolutionary stuff. this is not veg/non veg thing. I am talking about reproductive units..
@@AP-eb8hd here the one who making stupid statements is only you.
See your main comment, you said that if it not fertilised, then it's good for eating. But I informed you about the video conversation that you haven't understood what this monk or guru has said, he simply talked about eating of reproductive product as eggs and eating of nutrients product as milk.
But now, you just jumped away from your main statement about non-fertilized eggs and you suddenly started comparing it with plants and fruits.
Here, it's proved again that you just want to prove yourself right by jumping from one topic to another. You even couldn't stand firm on your first statement about non-fertilized eggs.
Great 👌
Brilliant answer. Salutations
Beautiful explanation Swamiji!!
Superb, adiyen adiyen
Jai Shrimannarayana. Nice explanation respectful Acharya.
प्रणाम
Sooopppeeerrr explained