Do Disruptive Protests Work? Extinction Rebellion & Just Stop Oil Debate | Good Morning Britain

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 кві 2023
  • Do Disruptive Protests Work?
    Debating the issue is Extinction Rebellion who have abandoned causing physical destruction and ‘Just Stop Oil’ who continue to adopt more destructive tactics, as they disrupted the World Snooker championship this week.
    Subscribe now for more! bit.ly/1NbomQa
    Broadcast on 20/04/23
    Stream Good Morning Britain live, every weekday from 6am on the ITV Hub 📲 daytimelink.itv.com/WatchGMBYT
    Subscribe now for more! bit.ly/1NbomQa
    Like, follow and subscribe to Good Morning Britain!
    The Good Morning Britain UA-cam channel delivers you the news that you’re waking up to in the morning. From exclusive interviews with some of the biggest names in politics and showbiz to heartwarming human interest stories and unmissable watch again moments.
    Join Susanna Reid, Ben Shephard, Kate Garraway, Charlotte Hawkins and Sean Fletcher every weekday on ITV from 6am until 9 every weekday!
    ITV Hub: daytimelink.itv.com/WatchGMBYT
    Website: bit.ly/1GsZuha
    UA-cam: bit.ly/1Ecy0g1
    Facebook: on. 1HEDRMb
    Twitter: bit.ly/1xdLqU3
    www.itv.com
    #GMB
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 419

  • @philipjohnkaye8890
    @philipjohnkaye8890 Рік тому +88

    It's very hard to sympathise with people who come across as nothing more than passive aggressive and delusional. Unless you agree with them, nothing else matters.

    • @jamafrican657
      @jamafrican657 Рік тому +5

      Can’t most people say that about their opponents 🧐

    • @Darrengriffiths3197
      @Darrengriffiths3197 Рік тому +3

      @@jamafrican657 no

    • @MiniatureDJ
      @MiniatureDJ Рік тому

      because its like smashing your head against a wall trying to convince the general public that civilization is trully in dire straights.
      These people are trying to help by raising awareness, but they are constantly shot down and belittled by the mainstream media, which again is just another tactic from the establishment to keep the status quo and keep their profits soaring far beyond what any human would reasonably need in not one lifetime but hundreds of lifetimes.
      The fact that billionaires exist whilst we have people freezing to death in their homes and struggling to feed their kids is absolutley criminal, but we are told by the media that these are the kind of people we shold look up to and aspire to be like. It's just wrong, and this is why these people come off so passive agressive is because they are trying to keep their cool when the press is trying to poke them to get a rise.

    • @broonie6808
      @broonie6808 Рік тому

      It's all going to be ok. Middle class white people are here to save the world!😂😂

    • @Truth_to_Powers
      @Truth_to_Powers 11 місяців тому +3

      The masses have never thirst after the truth. they turned aside from evidence that is not their taste, referring to deify error, error seduces them whoever can supply them with illusions is easily their master whomever attempts to destroy their illusion is always their victims

  • @thistimeimhere
    @thistimeimhere Рік тому +68

    No. Just makes everyone hate them and their cause.

    • @hgriff10
      @hgriff10 Рік тому +1

      I hate them but I love eating food.

    • @carltheblue.2531
      @carltheblue.2531 Рік тому

      I detest them.. especially the little arsehole in the tie ..

    • @GhostSamuraii
      @GhostSamuraii 10 місяців тому +1

      Not the cause but the execution and method

    • @iulic9833
      @iulic9833 5 місяців тому

      ​@@GhostSamuraiimost people are obviously going to connect the cause they have with the method they used, and will be much less likely to support that cause in the future

  • @shyhistorian
    @shyhistorian Рік тому +43

    Anyone else LOVING these debates?

  • @pauljames77777
    @pauljames77777 Рік тому +19

    The General public will turn on these people physically soon

    • @briankelly5816
      @briankelly5816 Рік тому +3

      I do hope so I want a front row seat remember the tube train in London when the blokes got a good kicking DO IT TO THEM AGAIN BECAUSE WOKE POLICE OFFICERS WONT DO ANYTHING SO ITS UP TO US NORMAL PEOPLE TO DEAL WITH THESE FOOLS!!

    • @rickirocks90210
      @rickirocks90210 Рік тому

      Doubt it.

    • @onebottleofwater9487
      @onebottleofwater9487 10 місяців тому +1

      @@rickirocks90210 And it happened, 3 months after you made your comment.

  • @theultimatefortnitegamer6315
    @theultimatefortnitegamer6315 Рік тому +19

    It was not the paint people found scary, it was a stranger popping out of the blue in the centre of a crowded stadium unleashing an unknown substance in a threatening way. In history there have been appalling attacks involving showing up out of nowhere; releasing dangerous, unknown substances.

    • @rozzgrey801
      @rozzgrey801 Рік тому

      These protests are faked, funded by the government who order the police to protect them to anger people so they can then use this to justify their ban on public protesting.

    • @judasfart3736
      @judasfart3736 10 місяців тому

      Don't forget bombings and shootings

  • @m1zxry_tt832
    @m1zxry_tt832 Рік тому +9

    Ah yes, let's harrass people. Maybe they'll join us!

  • @bradspringer2372
    @bradspringer2372 5 місяців тому +3

    Three blondes were walking through the forest when they came upon a set of tracks. The first blonde said "those are deer tracks." The second blonde said "No, those are elk tracks." The third blonde said "You're both wrong, those are moose tracks."
    The Blondes were still arguing when the train hit them.

  • @deejay7648
    @deejay7648 Рік тому +15

    Will Gail Bradbrook be attending the big one? Will she be driving her diesel car there?

  • @nolonger9112
    @nolonger9112 Рік тому +11

    Dont know where you live but where we collect data those disruptive protests actually have opposite effect. The more those demand stop use fuel the more people want to use more fuel. So we curious if those protests are actually ads of fuel companies.

    • @rozzgrey801
      @rozzgrey801 Рік тому

      The protests are designed to anger people so they will accept the ban on public protests the government will introduce. The protests themselves are fake, government funded to enable this ban to pass.

    • @Livin4Jesus00
      @Livin4Jesus00 7 місяців тому

      Exactly

  • @czhaok
    @czhaok 11 місяців тому +6

    Would have been nice if a presenter bothered to challenge them in the slightest. Anyone? No?

  • @daviel1005
    @daviel1005 Рік тому +39

    It used to be that these types of people would just stand on street corners with signs hanging from their necks that said, 'The end is nigh,' and eventually the men in white coats would come and take them away.

    • @deejay7648
      @deejay7648 Рік тому +8

      Very true. Unfortunately, now they have the internet. A lot of grifters too taking advantage of the vulnerable people.

    • @goodisonblues6176
      @goodisonblues6176 Рік тому +2

      white coats needed for these fruties

    • @Truth_to_Powers
      @Truth_to_Powers 11 місяців тому

      The masses have never thirst after the truth. they turned aside from evidence that is not their taste, referring to deify error, error seduces them whoever can supply them with illusions is easily their master whomever attempts to destroy their illusion is always their victims

  • @100davies
    @100davies Рік тому +2

    Wearing oil based products and clothing won’t help

    • @rozzgrey801
      @rozzgrey801 Рік тому

      Their religious cult embraces hypocrisy.

  • @Wolfways
    @Wolfways Рік тому +4

    Yes, disruptive protests do work... if the objective is to turn people against you and your cause.
    Also, if there's an extinction then the problem goes away.

  • @nickcollins5191
    @nickcollins5191 Рік тому +40

    That woman going on about how the powder was childrens paint and implying that it’s not dangerous. Maybe it’s not, but if I was somewhere and an unknown powder was released, my rage/fear wouldn’t be manufactured, it’d be bloody real, and I’m a 32 year old male! I wonder if she’d feel different if she had kids, was at an event and an unknown substance was released, if she’d still feel any fear was ‘manufactured’ or if she’d be genuinely terrified

    • @dianecameron137
      @dianecameron137 Рік тому +5

      no thing should have been thrown by this idiots why are some excusing what they did beats me

    • @bear4772
      @bear4772 Рік тому +10

      exactly - it's not scary for them because they know what the substance is, but crazy people spraying unknowing substances in a public place is going to be scary to a lot of people

    • @mairiconnell6282
      @mairiconnell6282 Рік тому +2

      I agree wholeheartedly with you.

    • @danielmilbourne880
      @danielmilbourne880 Рік тому +4

      Just like threatening someone with a gun which turns out to be an imitation
      ...their tactics only make regular people hate them more..

    • @onepartyroule
      @onepartyroule Рік тому +6

      Presumably she's never heard of bio weapons like ricin and anthrax being spread through powders, because it's flabbergasting that she can say that when there have been so many stories in recent years of powder being maliciously sent to people.

  • @onepartyroule
    @onepartyroule Рік тому +20

    I think part of the problem is a failure of imagination. What you want is attention to the cause; it isnt disrupion for disruptions sake. But these tactics are either established activist memes, or are just seen as childish spectacles.
    I don't know what the answer is because I havent sat and thought about it long enough, but you need something creative and novel that is going to emotionally provoke in the right way; in a way that causes curiosity and compassion. Traffic jams and throwing paint IS NOT HELPING.

    • @barcelonachair6487
      @barcelonachair6487 Рік тому +2

      I think you have hit the nail on the head when you say "childish spectacles." I wish they would educate the public rather than infuriate them. Perhaps fundraise for their cause and start an ad campaign explaining what the issues are, but that perhaps takes too much work than antics. I hear about the pranks but I don't remember what was its intended purpose. I remember wasting broken eggs in the market or paint strewn on fine art over protected glass but I haven't a clue why. Theatrical protests should have a meaning aside from a tantrum.

    • @Airdel
      @Airdel 11 місяців тому

      @@barcelonachair6487 there has been education for decades, but people doesn't pay attention, our generation is screaming at the people in power to take action because by the time GenZ takes the needed power it will be way to late to try to fucking save the planet, i have tried tirelessly in my city council and neighbourhoods to urge for action from the older generations and people in power to do something, they prefer having a street widened to have more cars than trees for lowering the temperature

    • @Exileonbackroad
      @Exileonbackroad 7 місяців тому +1

      @@barcelonachair6487 I agree with the importance of the phrase "childish spectacles", one needs only watch the rude behavior and arrogant attitude of these spokespeople here to get it.

  • @jamiewyatt1862
    @jamiewyatt1862 10 місяців тому +2

    I'd love to meet him in the pub ! Hahaha

  • @garethmccullough390
    @garethmccullough390 Рік тому +1

    IF MY HOUSE WAS ON FIRE IT WOULD BURN TO THE GROUND BECAUSE THE FIRE BRIGADE WOULDNT GET THROUGH YOUR FREAKS SUPERGLUED TO THE ROAD !!!

  • @nialwestwood
    @nialwestwood 11 місяців тому +1

    I’m sick of these middle class hypocrites

  • @minamoo3035
    @minamoo3035 Рік тому +4

    Did Skeet take advice from his legal team after his clash with Morgan?

  • @minamoo3035
    @minamoo3035 Рік тому +1

    Ask Farrell how much money she was given for her business from donations to extinction rebellion!

  • @emilevanrensburg8094
    @emilevanrensburg8094 Рік тому +6

    The problem is that these guys are making me care less about the planet.

  • @shig.bitz.3205
    @shig.bitz.3205 Рік тому +21

    She's right, a lot of people don't agree with the wholesale disruption and for good reason. It doesn't help anyone at all, there is a difference between being seen and being heard.
    I get what the Just Stop Oil dude is saying, but it's not about emotionally connecting with the cause, I'd say most people these days are quite accepting that climate change is one of the biggest challenges facing our society, but frankly most of us are not privileged enough to be able to step out of their daily responsibilities. Most have other people depending on them, bills etc. Just dropping everything to go and protest, is not an option for the large majority of people. So causing disruption for these people is doing nothing for the cause. Seeing a protester in the road on the way to work isn't going to make them stop what they're doing and join, I just don't understand the logic. There are less disruptive things you could do for more publicity.
    Lastly, Just Stop Oil need to send someone who can interview better. James had a lot to say, but kept interrupting and wasn't really answering questions directed at him, so he didn't come across very well. In addition a lot of what he said was for shock value, making sure he used dramatic sound bitable phrases in the hopes he will scare some people into supporting the group.
    Laura did a much better job, she was level headed and answered her questions directly whilst redirecting the viewers attention to relevant information. In contrast James was argumentative and emotional. I'm sure he's a valuable member of Just Stop Oil, but his idealism I fear makes him poorly suited to PR in this instance.

  • @muddywitch9016
    @muddywitch9016 11 місяців тому +1

    Middle class lad and lass who doesn’t have to worry about paying their bills telling the flotsam and jetsam how to live their lives! 😡
    With no one else on to speak sense and counter their bull🤬!

  • @lumen_anima
    @lumen_anima 11 місяців тому +4

    I love how none of these bozos can answer a straight question.
    Q: "Have you ever seen a parrot?"
    A: "Pandas are an extremely endangered species and it's because..."
    Yeesh

  • @andrzejpaczynski8533
    @andrzejpaczynski8533 7 місяців тому

    "The Government is criminal" - Fight to change the government, riding a revolution/bicycle

  • @davedfrench859
    @davedfrench859 9 місяців тому

    They can’t answer the question so they aren’t committed

  • @richardoshea2071
    @richardoshea2071 Рік тому +2

    That guy is vile, he should be arrested.

    • @__-eo9nu
      @__-eo9nu Рік тому

      Arresting someone for having different beliefs is a pretty facist thing to do.

  • @patricklee6206
    @patricklee6206 Рік тому +3

    That James Skeet is the criminal not the government. All this hysterical hyperbole doesn't help. What it does is irritate and anger.

  • @IanClarke-bi3se
    @IanClarke-bi3se 10 місяців тому +1

    Christ these peoples attitudes are scary

  • @frankiecat795
    @frankiecat795 Рік тому +3

    Netherlands should be under water in 2012 ,where is Netherlands now ? 🤔🤔

  • @nrdify
    @nrdify 9 місяців тому

    A protest that inconveniences zero people is a pretty rubbish protest. Nobody protests a cause that 100% of people agree with.

  • @garymellor5100
    @garymellor5100 Рік тому +2

    No it doesn't come from every expert in the entire world. These people are so blinkered it's untrue.

    • @charlottedowson9460
      @charlottedowson9460 Рік тому

      More blinkered than the climate change deniers?!!! Seriously?!!!

    • @garymellor5100
      @garymellor5100 Рік тому

      @@charlottedowson9460 and what's a climate change denier. Please explain what group of people deny the climate changes because I don't know one person who Denys the climate changes.

    • @garymellor5100
      @garymellor5100 Рік тому

      @@charlottedowson9460 you really need to be a bit more specific when you loosely bandy around the term denier.

    • @Truth_to_Powers
      @Truth_to_Powers 11 місяців тому

      The masses have never thirst after the truth. they turned aside from evidence that is not their taste, referring to deify error, error seduces them whoever can supply them with illusions is easily their master whomever attempts to destroy their illusion is always their victims

  • @henrywilloughby8333
    @henrywilloughby8333 Рік тому +5

    There is an old saying you can’t put nothing we’re there is nothing and these two people have got nothing up there

    • @charlottedowson9460
      @charlottedowson9460 Рік тому

      Are you serious?!! They are educated, articulate & passionate about the biggest issue of our time & you can't even spell "where"! Seriously?

    • @bonysminiatures3123
      @bonysminiatures3123 Рік тому +2

      @@charlottedowson9460 its a non issue wake up and grow up

    • @stephenkirkham4260
      @stephenkirkham4260 Рік тому

      @@charlottedowson9460 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @DANNY35870
      @DANNY35870 Рік тому

      ​​@@charlottedowson9460Educated in what exactly? I hope it's environmental engineering and also hope they've spent their working lives doing things that ACTUALLY BENEFIT THE ENVIRONMENT rather than just pissing everyone off.

  • @ThousandStars1000
    @ThousandStars1000 11 місяців тому +2

    It seems like on these shows the main argument against the protests is circular reasoning, essentially saying "We shouldn't like it because people don't like it". I hear a lot of arguments like that "the public don't like them" or "they are having the opposite effect" instead of giving your own personal reasons why you are against them. The media is extremely good at making you annoyed on someone else's behalf. They put the focus on the tactics instead of why they are using those tactics. Or even as abstract as whether the tactics are effective. To go even more abstract you could discuss whether the conversation over the effectiveness of their tactics is effective. These mind games and distractions are a perfectly understandable response when faced with global catastrophe, as it is a very difficult thing to fully process and allow into your comfort zone. As for the media, most of the billionaire-owned media conglomerates have vested interests in industries like the oil industry. I don't know about ITV but Sky news certainly does, along with every other news company parented by Comcast Corp or News Corp. It isn't a massive conspiracy but there will be systems which favour the hiring of certain types of news presenters and the reporting of certain types of stories. The companies have to do this if they are to compete with one another. It's easy to forget that all of this content is the result of huge companies fighting over our attention. They no doubt have an enormous impact on public opinion. So when you hear "public opinion" being brought up in one of these debates, doesn't that seem a bit circular?

    • @timberho3935
      @timberho3935 9 місяців тому +1

      Throw away your device and pick up trash if you're serious otherwise you're just a walking joke. If y'all got time to protest then atleast clean up after yourselves but y'all just leave your crap in the streets.

  • @garyteeley9637
    @garyteeley9637 Рік тому +3

    James Skeet, you wore that same shirt on Piers uncensoured.....😂😂😂

    • @AJThomasUK
      @AJThomasUK Рік тому +1

      Looks like he slept in it too

  • @patricklee6206
    @patricklee6206 Рік тому +13

    I do like they way they quote "all the experts in the world". What they really mean is all the experts that hold their skewed view of reality.

    • @NaaahBruv
      @NaaahBruv Рік тому

      There are very few "experts" that are on the side of climate denial, and most of those are funded by the fossil fuel industry.

    • @Truth_to_Powers
      @Truth_to_Powers 11 місяців тому

      The masses have never thirst after the truth. they turned aside from evidence that is not their taste, referring to deify error, error seduces them whoever can supply them with illusions is easily their master whomever attempts to destroy their illusion is always their victims

    • @patricklee6206
      @patricklee6206 11 місяців тому +1

      @@Truth_to_Powers What??????

    • @Truth_to_Powers
      @Truth_to_Powers 11 місяців тому

      @@patricklee6206 When examining the statement in relation to climate change, it can be interpreted as a critique of the collective response to the issue. The masses, representing the general population, are suggested to turn away from evidence that does not align with their preconceived notions or personal preferences. In the context of climate change, this could refer to the tendency of some individuals or groups to deny or downplay the scientific evidence indicating the existence and severity of climate change.
      The mention of the masses deifying error and being seduced by illusions could be seen as a reflection of the influence of misinformation or propaganda campaigns that seek to create doubt or confusion around climate change. Such campaigns can be powerful in shaping public opinion and preventing meaningful action from being taken to address the issue.
      The statement also suggests that those who supply illusions or false narratives about climate change can easily become the masters or controllers of the masses. This could allude to industries or interest groups that have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo and resist efforts to mitigate climate change. They may promote alternative narratives or create doubt about the scientific consensus, allowing them to maintain their influence and profit at the expense of effective action.
      Furthermore, the statement implies that those who attempt to challenge or dismantle the illusions surrounding climate change become victims of resistance or opposition. Individuals or organizations advocating for climate action or raising awareness about the urgency of addressing the issue often face pushback from those who are unwilling to accept or confront the reality of climate change.

    • @patricklee6206
      @patricklee6206 11 місяців тому

      @@Truth_to_Powers Well, well, you really have it bad don't you?
      The fact that the earth is going through one of its periodic climate changes is irrefutable. However the fact that it is going to wipe out the human race is quite another matter.
      Not all scientists subscribe to the armageddon scenario as a result of the earths climate changing.
      Over the past 60 years we have had many predictions by the great and good heralding the demise of civilisation.
      For example in 1989 the UN a senior environmental official opined that, GLOBAL WARMING WILL WIPE NATIONS OFF OF THE FACE OF THE EARTH IF CLIMATE CHANGE IS NOT ADDRESSED BY 2000.
      This would be caused by rising sea levels. Also that he added that shifting climate patterns could bring back 1930s dust bowl conditions to the Canadian and US wheatlands.
      Instead global farm production actually rose and more than 1 billion people also rose out of extreme poverty due to economic growth. Yet here we are over 30 years later still being subjected to the same overblown hysterical theories.
      That man was by the way, was Noel Brown director of the New York office of the U.N. environment programme. This same official also claimed that as a conservative scientific estimate the earth's temperature would rise between 1 and 7°in the next 30 years.
      Yet in actual fact between 1989 and 2019 according to NASA it rose by 0.5°Celsius.
      Another example of climate change extolled by a professor Kenneth Watt and endorsed by another scientific luminary British Science writer Nigel Calder that the earth was heading for another ice age and that the earth would be 11° colder by 2000.
      That prediction was made in 1975.
      Back to global warming. In 2006 Al Gore whilst promoting his film "The Inconvenient Truth" said that the earth only had 10 years left before the world would reach a point of no return. Here we are in 2023 some 17 years later being fed the same propaganda with the date for this tipping point being kicked further down the road.
      These are just a few of the overblown predictions of armageddon down the years. The environmentalists are of the opinion that they have to offer up scary scenarios, make simplified, dramatic statements whilst playing down any doubts they may have. One such proponent of this strategy was Stephen Schneider a professor of biology who said in 1989, " each of us has to decide what is the right balance is between being effective and being honest".
      What is closer to the truth about apocalyptic global warming is it's a means of gaining more government control and fear about the environment is one of the tools that is being used at the moment.
      Communism and Socialism have lost respectability, so it's being repackaged as Environmentalism.
      It's a bit like a watermelon green on the outside and red on the inside.
      In conclusion it is self evident that the planet is undergoing climate change, but it has ever been thus.
      In the 1500s in the UK the climate was like it is in the Mediterranean at present. In fact HenryVIII's body exploded in the heat whilst it was being transported up the Thames to Greenwich Palace. Fast forward 200 years The Thames was frozen during winter and people used to ice skate on it. Fast forward another 200 or so years and the UK is warmer again.

  • @Fainkom
    @Fainkom Рік тому +9

    Bring Piers Morgan back..These two host are soft..

  • @robertlonsdale5326
    @robertlonsdale5326 9 місяців тому

    Rich kids with nothing better to do except spoil things for the normal working people in THIS country.

  • @tonymoore3090
    @tonymoore3090 Рік тому

    What did the protesters at St Paul achieve, exactly, what protesters ?

  • @RodKruz
    @RodKruz 10 місяців тому

    This is like a scene taken from the movie "Don't look up", literally.

  • @Paraschivo
    @Paraschivo 7 місяців тому

    So NONE of them can adress the topic huh?

  • @DDawg-qo2yd
    @DDawg-qo2yd 10 місяців тому +1

    I laughed when the JSO guy claimed others had cotton wool wrapped around their heads.
    Literally he does not answer any of the questions posed to him and instead just regurgitates his talking points - it's like he's a robot and not a functional human being.

  • @kathleenweinberg6442
    @kathleenweinberg6442 Рік тому +3

    Good morning 🌄🌞🌄 everyone

  • @robertlonsdale5326
    @robertlonsdale5326 10 місяців тому

    They don't complain about the destruction of the enviroment to get the stuff for batteries? Vast new open cast mines are excavated by Diesel powered plant machinery. Let's start with the batteries and how to charge them.

  • @soumario
    @soumario Рік тому +5

    Could we disrupt the disruptive tactics by arresting those bullies?

    • @simonwolfe529
      @simonwolfe529 Рік тому

      what a good idea......yeah - but i think the Police can't do anything under some stupid law - or just bring the water cannons out as they do in Europe

    • @rozzgrey801
      @rozzgrey801 Рік тому

      @@simonwolfe529 The protests are fake, they're being run and funded by the government precisely in order to anger people so they will then accept a ban on all public protesting.

  • @iSwearToCod
    @iSwearToCod 11 місяців тому

    theyre backing him and hyping him waaayyy too much. shut that neek down

  • @samuelcarnall309
    @samuelcarnall309 5 місяців тому

    Well at least this is better than those horrible interventions Richard Madeley did

  • @ricktaylor640
    @ricktaylor640 8 місяців тому +1

    This guy would be a great politician (dancing around the question 🕺 😂)

  • @paulklein7742
    @paulklein7742 9 місяців тому

    if the disruptive protestors presented solutions, we would listen to them. They don't have solutions. Let them do their homework and promote real solutions, which are being worked on by real engineers.

  • @Livin4Jesus00
    @Livin4Jesus00 7 місяців тому

    You may get awareness but you’re also on the path of provoking the common man to desperation until he’ll say “I’d rather die than support you and your cause”.

  • @moomin3744
    @moomin3744 Рік тому

    Complete and utter hypocrites somewhere down the line... Guaranteed

  • @JuiceMyRandomness
    @JuiceMyRandomness Рік тому +13

    The best discussion I’ve seen so far. Usually the people that represent them are angry and shouty! I changed my mind at 7:46 as they started shouting and seemed more unhinged than ready for a real discussion.

    • @hgriff10
      @hgriff10 Рік тому

      I know the wildfires and extreme heat in London last summer were completely off topic, they just need to find a way to connect what that snooker table looked like after the power was added and the way the grass looked in London parks last August ... it's about joining the dots really

  • @philcrawford325
    @philcrawford325 Рік тому +2

    The two issues are what the protests are about and where and how the protests are done; when asked about the latter, the protesters talk about the former. It's irritating that whenever Kate and Adil ask about the manner of the protests, and whether or not they are designed to anger people or gain support, their guests talk about the reason for them. The point is made early by the guests what the situation they believe we are in is (climate emergency, government, etc), so it is said and doesn't have to be said again and again. The interview moves on to the manner of the protests, events targeted and how effective or ineffective the guests believe those protests are in gaining public support, but the guests keep repeating why they are doing them. Probably most people agree with them to some degree about the situation and the reasons for protesting, but there is an issue of whether or not they are wise about which events it is relevant to their cause to disrupt and whether the nature of their protests is likely to turn people against them or to gain support. When the protesters are challenged about that, they revert to repeating their motivations.

    • @stephenogden5470
      @stephenogden5470 Рік тому +1

      Why are these people constantly being allowed onto tv, pushing their views of doom, but we never seem to get an alternative to their agenda, allowed onto debate them?

  • @An-Alien-On-Earth
    @An-Alien-On-Earth Рік тому +3

    I was an active member of The Animal Liberation Front in 90s we saved countless animals ect and never ruined the lives of everyday people going about their lives . These groups now suck

  • @kjetiljensen2472
    @kjetiljensen2472 Рік тому +1

    Oil is fantastic a fantastic product

  • @karolokuniewicz9705
    @karolokuniewicz9705 11 місяців тому

    Earth warming rate oncreased from 0,18 C a decade with 1,5 C expected in 2050 to 0,27 C a decade with 1,5 scheduled for 2027. Can you imagine the consequences?

  • @JustinOsborne-hw6jy
    @JustinOsborne-hw6jy Рік тому +15

    These kind of protesters motivate me. I promise that every time I see a Just Stop Oil protest, or there is mainstream media coverage, I will do one environmentally unfriendly thing. Today, I’ve decided to but a motorbike with a much bigger engine. Thanks, Just Stop Oil… this is going to be fun!

    • @robec62
      @robec62 Рік тому +1

      I have sold both of mine.

    • @nicetrymate813
      @nicetrymate813 Рік тому

      @@baileyking9 you can’t buy “stocks in oil” 😂

    • @nicetrymate813
      @nicetrymate813 Рік тому

      Nice one Justin, bet you look so cool on your motorbike 😂😂😂😂 🤡

    • @DANNY35870
      @DANNY35870 Рік тому

      This 100%. Everytime I see them make some poor guy late for his job interview during a cost of living crisis it makes me want to never recycle anything again.

    • @Truth_to_Powers
      @Truth_to_Powers 11 місяців тому

      The masses have never thirst after the truth. they turned aside from evidence that is not their taste, referring to deify error, error seduces them whoever can supply them with illusions is easily their master whomever attempts to destroy their illusion is always their victims

  • @russianbear6384
    @russianbear6384 Рік тому

    Wow, they're actually allowing comments

  • @1986nexus
    @1986nexus Рік тому +2

    All he does is say the same talking points instead of giving direct answers

    • @rozzgrey801
      @rozzgrey801 Рік тому

      There's no rational argument possible as this climate crapola is a cult, and just like any religious cult, they just mindlessly chant the same slogans and dogma over and over until they're brainwashed fully indoctrinated zombies for the lost cause.

  • @christinerobin386
    @christinerobin386 10 місяців тому

    They are both attention seeking drama queens.

  • @orangev81
    @orangev81 11 місяців тому

    These actions could un seat Dictators!!!......I don't think so little boy, they would shoot you and make you disappear.

  • @AngloSaxophone
    @AngloSaxophone 10 місяців тому

    id protest if i had a hair cut like that too

  • @frederikdemoor2018
    @frederikdemoor2018 5 місяців тому

    The same mantra over and over again.

  • @scarefest101
    @scarefest101 9 місяців тому

    theses people more concerned about other countries then uk so deluded

  • @zameisie7016
    @zameisie7016 10 місяців тому

    We'll send you some bananas james . It fits with your mentality 😂😂😂

  • @zameisie7016
    @zameisie7016 10 місяців тому

    James needs to give up his home , clothes and cosmetics , wear an animal skin and become a hunter gatherer. Problem solved

  • @soumario
    @soumario Рік тому +1

    This debate is about how much brown-nosing to the government elite we should be doing

    • @Spike123.98
      @Spike123.98 Рік тому +1

      Really?

    • @soumario
      @soumario Рік тому +1

      @@Spike123.98 Demanding more government action is giving more power to the government. Governments love this. Poor people hate it.

  • @tiensimon1263
    @tiensimon1263 Рік тому

    I get them after hearing what they have to say, majorty of people only think of the Now and the past and have the view of if it dosemt effect them immediately they dont care. If this has been scientifiy proven why arent we doing more to help?

  • @beranikotor7197
    @beranikotor7197 Рік тому

    What is the solution to your demand?
    We can also demand that you stop!
    Did you obey?
    If you don't agree with the government then just move out to a country that is to your liking, where the government don't have oil reserve.
    HOW DO YOU STAY WARM? DOES YOUR METHOD OF STAYING WARM CAN BE APPLIED TO OTHERS?

  • @Exileonbackroad
    @Exileonbackroad 7 місяців тому

    I'm in full agreement with everything the climate activists say and want, but why do they always feel the need to lecture and talk down to journalists, people on the street, friends in the pub etc? The Extinction Rebellion woman here starts right in with a big rehearsed speech and it's an instant turn-off.

  • @davidlittlefair9715
    @davidlittlefair9715 Рік тому +11

    As far as I'm concerned, the whole segment was just a way to allow 2 extremists to shout from a larger pulpit. Presenters didn't question hard enough, or didn't care enough about the other side of their arguments. Terrible representatives of that point. Didn't like Piers but he'd at least have pushed them and tried to make them see their own idiocy.

  • @ofurlong
    @ofurlong Рік тому +1

    Heroes

  • @Billy67
    @Billy67 Рік тому +9

    Care in the community at its best.

  • @crafte164
    @crafte164 9 місяців тому

    This is obviously what happens when people grow up thinking bad behaviour is the only way to be noticed. I am not stupid, we are all aware, how do these groups assume that we need to put at risk for people to notice? How arrogant are they? If you hold up a major motorway, a lot of vehicles will leave their vehicles turned on and get annoyed and rev, how can that help fuel emissions?

  • @1upSniper
    @1upSniper 9 місяців тому

    They own cars. Lol.

  • @stephenrodneymay
    @stephenrodneymay 11 місяців тому

    Does she know lock down haircuts are over now.

  • @kevinmurker8980
    @kevinmurker8980 9 місяців тому

    The guys spin around in his chair a lot.

  • @XyZCwP
    @XyZCwP Рік тому

    Paid actors/troublemakers

    • @Truth_to_Powers
      @Truth_to_Powers 11 місяців тому

      The masses have never thirst after the truth. they turned aside from evidence that is not their taste, referring to deify error, error seduces them whoever can supply them with illusions is easily their master whomever attempts to destroy their illusion is always their victims

  • @jamesgilheany9624
    @jamesgilheany9624 Рік тому +10

    Climate collapse is a new one for me. I thought we were in a climate crisis / emergency?

    • @rory7590
      @rory7590 Рік тому +4

      When you deny science, I’d imagine everything becomes novel for you after a while.

    • @jamesgilheany9624
      @jamesgilheany9624 Рік тому +5

      @@rory7590 I can’t hear you under that mask. Speak up science boy.

    • @aethellstan
      @aethellstan Рік тому

      @@jamesgilheany9624 whilst i can't answer for Rory, you just need to look at the evidence. climate change is just one example of how our greed and selfishness is ruining the planet.
      Our rivers and seas are in the news lately because the water companies that have been given £70bn of our money in the last thirty years haven't spent it on their business of drinking water and keeping the environment safe but on salaries for the big chiefs and shareholders who all happen to be foreign companies part owned by foreign governments. so our money is paying to keep their water clean not ours.
      Then we have the soil, a recent government body has been formed to look into what we can do to prevent soil collapse as there is an estimate of @40-50 years left of viable farming in the uk because our our methods. I don't know whether you have seen farmland but it's hard clay and virtually no organic matter. if you look at the land around the farm edges you'll see a much better soil and it's because it is largely untouched.
      then there is the collapse of invertebrates, collapse of our mammals, birds etc.
      all of these issues are part of the climate crisis. hope this helps you understand.

    • @rory7590
      @rory7590 Рік тому +3

      @@jamesgilheany9624 Yes, apparently this medium confuses you too.

    • @jamesgilheany9624
      @jamesgilheany9624 Рік тому +2

      @@rory7590 I assume you are still wearing your mask. Or did the science change?

  • @charlottedowson9460
    @charlottedowson9460 Рік тому +5

    "What will it take for you to emotionally connect with what is happening?". YES!

    • @bethanp3453
      @bethanp3453 Рік тому +2

      Agreed. Good morning Britain has such a smarmy attitude towards guests and is so patronising to its viewers. These types of interviews wind me up mostly because no one shows any willingness to listen and get on the same page. There's nothing to argue about regarding climate change and the media know it but here it is again. Manufactured rage. She's 100% Right. I don't agree with a lot of these tactics and I'm an environmentalist BSc, but these presenters are playing stupid. They sit there pretending to sip coffee out of empty mugs acting like the voices of reason and all they're doing is exploiting the emotional anxiety of desperate UK citizens who dare to challenge this sicko establishment.

    • @bonysminiatures3123
      @bonysminiatures3123 Рік тому +1

      @@bethanp3453 There is everything to argue about primitive theories called climate change

  • @johnniedee5884
    @johnniedee5884 Рік тому +3

    She’s got hair dye🤷‍♂️

    • @charlottedowson9460
      @charlottedowson9460 Рік тому

      Anything to avoid the REAL issue, eh? Avoidance & denial on your part, sadly

    • @johnniedee5884
      @johnniedee5884 Рік тому

      @@charlottedowson9460 the looney left that a handful of people are preaching their crap.

  • @simonoliver5734
    @simonoliver5734 9 місяців тому

    Your tactics aren’t working

  • @yohighness
    @yohighness Рік тому

    If the people in power are not prepared to listen to you, you should do something disruptive. Just ask the South Africans.

  • @josueorgoaway
    @josueorgoaway 10 місяців тому

    Limmy is looking a big rough after he found out a kilogram of Feathers and Bricks weigh the same.

  • @chriscuthbertson
    @chriscuthbertson 11 місяців тому +2

    I was gonna go to the Extinction Rebellion demonstration, but couldn't get there because the road was blocked by a Just Stop Oil protest. ;)

    • @501sqn3
      @501sqn3 11 місяців тому

      Lol 😂😂 👏👏

    • @tabbymrp
      @tabbymrp 10 місяців тому

      lol😂

  • @cucamccusker4898
    @cucamccusker4898 8 місяців тому

    the sky is falling in, who will save the children aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

  • @meddylad
    @meddylad Рік тому

    We all have one choice to make..... should we make the most out of what we have now, or do we leave it for our children, and their children to sort out. Because most of us know climate chance is real.... and the planet is taking its last, biological breath

  • @rob16495
    @rob16495 Рік тому

    Oh London is going. Meh no great loss

  • @robertwhiteley-yv1sy
    @robertwhiteley-yv1sy 8 місяців тому

    To be honest, if the future they say is coming then I can’t blame them for being terrified being the girls hide would be my coat and the guy would be my hat.

  • @deflesh3340
    @deflesh3340 7 місяців тому

    All, of them are weak, Machines, are stronger.

  • @donnalee2983
    @donnalee2983 Рік тому +3

    I don’t need anyone to tell me what to do. I do the best I can for the environment. Vandalism however you auger coat it it not a nice thing to do x

    • @NaaahBruv
      @NaaahBruv Рік тому

      That's the problem, the fossil fuel industry lobbied heavily to make "climate change" a matter of personal responsibility. The small changes people can make in their daily lives have little to no impact. It's about getting the government to stand up to the fossil fuel industry giants that donate large sums of money to their campaigns.

  • @garymasters4515
    @garymasters4515 Рік тому

    i'll be glad when that pair of layabouts are extinct.

  • @robertwhiteley-yv1sy
    @robertwhiteley-yv1sy 8 місяців тому

    The future she fears is opportunity knocking for evolution.

  • @alwoo5645
    @alwoo5645 Рік тому

    No crisis

    • @Truth_to_Powers
      @Truth_to_Powers 11 місяців тому

      The masses have never thirst after the truth. they turned aside from evidence that is not their taste, referring to deify error, error seduces them whoever can supply them with illusions is easily their master whomever attempts to destroy their illusion is always their victims

  • @brimkathstampex2306
    @brimkathstampex2306 Рік тому

    Don't you just love his dinky little ear ring?

    • @sylviabarnes2668
      @sylviabarnes2668 Рік тому +1

      He reminds me of a noddy dog on the back of a car.

  • @tentonfishstick
    @tentonfishstick Рік тому

    Sympathetic to the crisis but these guys make me want to crank up my V8 Dodge and do donuts in a parking lot.

  • @mairiconnell6282
    @mairiconnell6282 Рік тому

    Adil is not for this job. Please get him off our screens. Please.

  • @jinglejazz7537
    @jinglejazz7537 10 місяців тому +1

    CANADIANS WOULD RUN THEM DOWN IN THEIR BIG GAS GUZZLING CARS

  • @strongbow310
    @strongbow310 9 місяців тому

    Hahàh so what is the solution

  • @mmcclean8791
    @mmcclean8791 Рік тому +6

    It works until they go to the wrong place and get filled in. Fingers crossed they come my way