There will be multiple parts of this story, so for everyone concerned about events not mentioned they will be as the series continues, do like, share and support to help me make it faster bigger and better. Thanks for all the support love you ❤
Talking about jana sheen e Rasool saww you skipped the Ghadeer where Rasool Saww announced IMAM ALI as as his Janashen by saying "Man kunto Mola, Fa haza Ali un Mola" jis ka main Mola uska Ali Mola
@@haseebansari3093 Look brother, disagreeing with someone does not mean that he is being insulted and the role of Hazrat Aisha is controversial in Islamic history. You know the reasons.What do you say about Hazrat Nuh's wife? She was also the wife of a prophet.
❤ Excellent & Logical Analysis. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our UMMAT from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! !
As someone who has thoroughly studied the Seerah & the aftermath of our Prophet SAW's demise. It amazes me how much effort you put into this video, everything is so well researched. I am just leaving this comment to appreciate the effort as I know how complex it can be. I am in awe, we need more "influencers" like you. God bless you Mooroo, Aameen.
Probably the first Pakistani content creator who has touched on such a controversial topic so beautifully and mindfully. Subtle, comprehensive and rightly informative!! Kudos, Mooro!
@@lulu22-b4j The writing of this document is not something that Allah enjoined upon him to write or convey at that time. If that had been the case, he (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) would not have failed to do what Allah instructed him to do. It was not permissible for him to abandon writing the document because of the doubts that some had about (its importance). If what he intended to write in the document was something that he was obliged to convey and disclose, then the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) would have disclosed it and written it in a document, and he would not have paid any attention to the view of anybody, for he was the most obedient of creation to Allah. Thus it is known that when he decided not to write the document, the document was not obligatory and it would not have contained anything of religious matters that he was obliged to write at that time, because if that had been necessary, he would have done it. Minhaaj as-Sunnah an-Nabawiyyah
@@lulu22-b4j yar hum ko aek baat to batao ye sab hua phir tum log kehte ho hazat fatima ko bhi qatal kia sahaba ne to phir hazrat ali ne un se jang kyun nahi ki ???
@@mohammad.ssaimm Jo Rasuul(saww) dain woh le lo, jis cheez se mana Karain uss se baaz raho. Rasuul(saww) k saamnay aeaaz oonchi na Karo. Unse Qadam Aagay na berhao. Rasuul (saww) ki ata'at kerne ka hukm hai ya unko wasiyat se roknay ka? Qur'aan aise nafarmaano k baray mein kia kehta hai? Aisa kahan likha hai k Allah ne nhi chaha k Rasuul(saww) wasiyat ka Karain? Loag tou Allah he ki nafarmani kerte hain, jo Allah Unse chahta hai woh nhi kerte, tou Rasuul(saww) ki Kia baat kerte bhi. Jang e Ohod mein pahar se uternay se mana kiya tha? Loagon ka failure hai, jaahil aadmi, loag gumrah ho gaey Allah aur Rasuul(saww) ki nafarmani ker k.
@@syedfaraz5Ali(as) is ummat k Haroon hain. Iss liye jang nhi ker sakay. Jo Haroon(as) na ker sakay, same Ali(as) k saath Hua. Quraan mein daikh lo Haruun(as) ka waqiya.
@@ranaazadarhussainazadarh8862 brother jo insaan quran prr amal krta ho wo kabhi bhi ahle bait ka bugz apne dil main NAHI rakh sakta ye jo log krte hain unn ki rozi deen ke sath ha Bss aur koi baat nahi ha
Allah ki Rassi Sa Murad Kia Ha ? Go and start research on this... Wo rassi Ahlebait hain , zariya hain Allah sa kareeb rehna ka.. Jazakmullah Khaira. ❤
I am a Muslim, and my identity is rooted in Islam as a whole, not in specific schools of thought or divisions. My faith is centered on the teachings of the Quran and the example of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). I choose not to affiliate with labels or sectarian distinctions because I believe in the oneness of the Muslim Ummah. My focus is on understanding and practicing Islam in its purest form, promoting unity, respect, and compassion among all Muslims, regardless of differences. Love for Mola Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is part of my faith, as he is a beacon of courage, wisdom, and devotion. We are all bound by our shared faith, and that is what truly matters
Just goody goody talk it can't be exist in real world Iran killed thousand of sunni Muslim in Syria Iraq Yeman and labnon no Syria is free from Bashar Al Asad and we see shia Iran real face don't be lie to yourself
I have Shia friends (2) we definitely have different opinions but the level of respect is never compromised we eat together, and we go on trips together. I admit them as Muslim brothers. Just because we have differences in opinions does not mean we disgrace and tag each other with Kufr Fatwa, Neither Allah has given us any right to exclude them nor his prophet. Together we grow stronger! Trust me we can conquer if we accept differences in opinion instead of taking things personally!
شیعہ سنی سمیت تمام فرقے مسلک خلاف قرآن ہیں ۔ اور شیعہ ہوں یا سنی سب کے سب قرآن سے نابلد نام کے مسلمان اصل میں منافق ہیں ۔ ان فرقوں کے ٹھیکیداروں نے ان فرقے مسلکوں کو اپنے پاپی پیٹ پالنے کا دھندہ بنا رکھا ہے ۔ جب تک سب نام کے مسلمان صرف قرآن کو دین کی بنیاد بنا کر خلاف قرآن جھوٹی من گھڑت حدیثوں کو اور ان کی بنیاد پر شخصیت پرستی کو ختم نہیں کریں گے ، اللہ کے اس حکم پر عمل نہیں کریں گے واعتصموا بحبل اللہ جمیعا ولا تفرقو تب تک کچھ اچھا نہیں ہوگا نہ دین کا نہ دنیا کا ☝️
@ baat yai uncommon isi liyay hai, ik hi thaali may khana khatay hain log, or nafrat bhi rkhtay hain, Alhamdulillah ham aisa nhi krtay, ham beth kr baat krtay hain na k ik dusray k drmian gaalian or fasaad paida krien. May shia ulma ko bhi sunta hun or unsay ilm deen adopt krta hun. Un may bhi kuch cheezon pr ikhtelaaf hota hai lekin aisa nhi k vo hamaray alim nhi. Dusra bhayi hindu dost kbsay hogayay? Coworker hsoktay hain, classmate hosktay hain, lekin vo hamaray dost nhi hosktay.
Dear Mooroo, I just finished watching Shia vs. Sunni | Documentary | Part 1, and I felt compelled to reach out. The depth, care, and courage you brought to this subject are nothing short of remarkable. You have shed light on an often-sensitive topic with a balance and respect that not only educates but also inspires. Your storytelling doesn’t just inform; it builds bridges, fosters empathy, and invites viewers into a conversation that is too often brushed aside. This documentary isn’t just a piece of content-it’s an invaluable contribution to understanding and unity. I eagerly await Part 2 and thank you for your dedication to meaningful, impactful work. Bravo!
there will no unit at all I guarantee that there would be bigger fight between sunni and shia and sunni will be successful inshallah need Hadith from Alh Sunnah books I will provide you
I am sunni Muslim par aap ki is tahkeek say mujhe and Meri family ko Pata Chala hum kitni bari gumrahi main thy. And Ahlebait (a.s) hi asal rah e nijaat hain. Thank you @mooroosicity
Kisi bhi Sahabi ki niyyat pr shak krny ka matlab ye hy k Huzoor (SAW) Maazallah Sahaba ki tazkiye e nafs ni kar paye... Dusri r sab sy imp bat ye hy k Sahaba k bary me ghalat ghuman ya unke par shak krny sy pura ka pura deen e mashkook ho jata hy jo k asal me bht bari gumrahi hy... Allah Ta'ala hamein seedhy raasty par chalaye rakhy
@@Faran_Ahmed to main nay kab sahaba ko bura kaha bhai. Hamay to Ahlebait (a.s) ka follower banna hai. Jin say bibi Fatima (a.s) naraz Gai woh Meray liya Sahaba hai hi nhi qabiz hain. And Jin say mola Ali (a.s) nay Jung ki woh to hai hi jahanumi.
If Shia Sunni follow the same religion then why don't they intermarry. In fact muslim men prefer to marry Sanatani girls in India rather than their own sects. Even Sanatani girls choose mostly muslim men as their boyfriends and husbands.
man i am crying right now i am shia but my best friend not just a friend he is my brother and he is sunni bhai apny dil may jaga bana li isfitno k dor may lazmi hain ki ap jesa ek banda ho and engr ali mirza bhai jesa yr apna jis tarha story telling ki asa lagraha thai ki ya saray manzar mery samnay horahay hain or love u bhai ki sunni humary bhai hain may totally dil say respect karta sunni ulama or sunni bhaio ki and we have to be proud ki ❤hum sab hazarat muhummad saw k umati hain love you all and be positive❤
born to a sunni family, Alhamdulillah Allah jee gave me enough courage to denounce the faith which was imposed by the islamic establishment on common people (definitely sunni Islam) and embrace the ultimate truth (shia Islam). I couldn't bear the hypocrisy in my believes. Though it was hard to accept the reality over my personal likenesses as a sunni muslim, but Alhamdulillah I did it. All praises to Allah jee for showing me the path of RasulAllah SAWW and his Ahle Bayt AS ❤ اپنی ذاتی پسند پر اللہ جی کی مرضی کو ترجیح دینا ہی اصل دین ہے۔۔
So you became shia..so sad .. have you seen many non muslims became muslim..every day ..but no one is going in religion of shia muslim...every one of them chose sunni islam ..... because Allah know what is better for them ...
In an era where vulgarity and scandalous rhetoric are labelled as "content"; In a country where millions of users consume and prefer that type of content; and where asking difficult questions is discouraged in favour of complacency this truly is a commendable effort. More power to you Taimoor and I hope we get to see more of this type of content by others as well!
Mooroo, believe me or not, whatever I've researched in my around 30 years of life 🧬 you summarized it in 30+ minutes, amazing Bro, you always amaze by your content. Allah Pak apko jaza e khair ata kare, Amin 🕋🤲
I was born in a Sunni family and followed the Sunni faith. During the pandemic era, I started listening to the lectures of Shaykh Hassan Allahyari on UA-cam and verified the information through books. This led me to become a Shia, Allahmdulillah, that I now believe in Imamate and follow the Ahlulbayt (a.s.) ❤ الهم صل علی محمد وآل محمد
@@waqasr786After the All Imams Starting from Imam Ali to Imam Mahdi and more when Imam Mahdi will Arrive they will Lead the Prayers and Prophet Essa will also offer Prayers behind Imam Mahdi.
MORO! WHAT A BEAUTIFUL WAY TO DISCUSS. Amazing story telling. Excellent work, We are waiting for more videos! ❤ Its true that Unbiased stories carries more truth!
what are your thoughts about the time of treaty of hudaibiyah when Ali (RA) refused to erase the word 'RasulAllah' even though the Prophet (SAW) commanded him to do so? You cant pick emotions and intentions just from mere text. As Muslims we believe both incidents occurred out of respect of our beloved prophet Muhammad (SAW). Also, this video is a bit off from some details, according to authentic sources this pen and paper incident happened on Thursday and Prophet (SAW) died on Monday and during which he also got better on Saturday iirc. He could have written it or said it later if it was that important.
what are your thoughts about the time of treaty of hudaibiyah when Ali (RA) refused to erase the word 'RasulAllah' even though the Prophet (SAW) commanded him to do so? You cant pick emotions and intentions just from mere text. As Muslims we believe both incidents occurred out of respect of our beloved prophet Muhammad (SAW). Also, this video is a bit off from some details, according to authentic sources this pen and paper incident happened on Thursday and Prophet (SAW) died on Monday and during which he also got better on Saturday iirc. He could have written it or said it later if it was that important.
@@fatguy9040 You can't compare two different thoughts...At first Imam Ali a.s is (Masoom) and Masoom don't make mistake's. If you have some knowledge! And secondly read again treaty of Hudabiyah you will get ur answer. "Who says to whom!"
I'm Sunni Pashtun Muslim from Balochistan n have my Shia homies in Skardu. The best people I've ever met in my life.I've visited Skardu, been at their homes, never ever felt something odd. Them folks treated me like one of em. Wishing love but nothing to everyone around. Religion n faith is a persona matter to everyone, we should keep it at home(with us) when we go outside. Thats how we're gonna make this world a peaceful n liveable ❤
My dear pashton brother please arrange a channel for pushton brothers to tell them real Islam because mullas had exploited pushton very much even than in non ending fighting between them and others mulla is involved every where.
@@aeymed There is a great need to deliver tachings of Ahlebait (A.S) to pashtoon brothers because their mullas has introduced them bano ommyia due to which pashtoon tradition became blood shedand pashotoon community has not came out from this circle. Sorry brother if my any word had hurt you.
Mashallah very informative and sensitive topic. I am Sunni and very sad that people did not provide pen and paper to Profit Muhammad SAW. 😢 Moula Ali Haq Haq Ali
@@technologyspotlight254 Zakirun ne sunni kitabein likkhin hyn?? Aur ye zakir hi nhi Aalimun nai munazray kar lye, aur kahi huq pakar gumrahi chorkar huq k rasta par agaye.. Tm jese zidd k aqeeday rakhnay walay, jo abao.ajdaad ne sikhaya bus ushi par chalay arhay ho, ... Lols
I am a Sunni, but after reading After the Prophet by Hazleton, I realized it was mostly about political power than the religion. Especially the event at Ghadeer. Maula Ali would have been the successor after the Prophet (SAW). The course of history would have been so different.
@@furryfables09 Bhai ye aap Tou Nahi bataingay kon Sahaba thay kon Nahi jub aap ki kitabain hi alag Hain Quran main bhi aap nay addition Kia hua hai ager aap baghair Takiay Kay maan lain warna Jou Sahaba Hain unki izzat Allah ne momineen Kay Dil main Rakhi hai.
Shias have never instigated hatred against Sunnis, But the Sunnis have always been against the Shias and today it is only the Shias who are raising their voice for Palestine and helping them.The Prophet left the Qur'an and his Ahl al-Bayt to guide the Ummah after him.
Lol you on weed ig,shias has never fought any proper battle against the infidels,but always targeted the sunnis from the start,and attacked them from the back.go read history from the authentic books,rather than social media or shia zakireen😂.
I hope that we all unite on what the Prophet (s) mentioned: - two weighty things: Quran and Ahleybayt and you shall never go astray - Hazrat Umar congratulating Imam Ali on being the Maula? If Maula is a friend then didn’t Hazrat Umar take him as a friend earlier? If you were to connect the dots without any bias, it might make sense
There are many Hadith where prophet said Abu bakar and umar . Ahl e bait and khualafa e rashideen all are jmoortant to us. Even from Shia books it’s evident that Ali ra had good relations with Abu bakar and umar ra. But their scholars have to hide it.
@ , brother, with all due respect. I wouldn’t deny the Hadith references, but the Quran explicitly mentions the elevated status of Ahleybayt on multiple occasions. The event of Mubahala and the event of cloak. (The Hadith references clearly highlight the reference of the chosen ones) Plus, the Prophet (s) told us to follow the Quran and Ahleybayt and we shall never go astray. However, majority of my Sunni brothers aren’t even aware of this Hadith, let alone the saying of Quran and Sunnah and you shall never go astray, doesn’t even exist within the 6 Sahih books. Don’t you think that the right of Ahleybayt is being taken away? Quran holds more precedence than the Hadiths
@@MuhammadAkbar-kc9gw, it was actually Imam Ali (a) who embraced Islam in the men category and even Engineer Mirza acknowledges this but we will find people manipulating it for the sake of it. The event of Dawat e Zul Ashira: ***"And warn thy nearest relations."*** When this verse was revealed, the Prophet organized a feast that is known in history as "Summoning the Family - *Da'wat dhu 'l-'Ashira*". The Prophet invited around forty men from the Banu Hashim and asked 'Ali bin Abi Talib to make arrangements for the dinner. After having served his guests with food and drinks, when the Prophet wanted to speak to them about Islam, Abu Lahab forestalled him and said, "Your host has long since bewitched you." All the guests dispersed before the Prophet could present his message to them. The Prophet then invited them the next day. After the feast, he spoke to them, saying: O Sons of 'Abdu 'l-Muttalib! By Allah, I do not know of any person among the Arabs who has come to his people with better than what I have brought to you. I have brought to you the good of this world and the next, and I have been commanded by the Lord to call you unto Him. Therefore, who amongst you will support me in this matter so that he may be my brother *(akhhi),* my successor *(wasiyyi)* and my caliph *(khalifati)* among you? This was the first time that the Prophet openly and publicly called the relations to accept him as the Messenger and Prophet of Allah; he also uses the words "*akhi wa wasiyyi wa khalifati*\- my brother, my successor, my caliph" for the person who will aid him in this mission. No one answered him; they all held back except the youngest of them - 'Ali bin Abi Talib. He stood up and said, "I will be your helper, O Prophet of God." The Prophet put his hand on the back of 'Ali's neck and said: "*Inna hadha akhhi wa wasiyyi wa khalifati fikum, fasma'u lahu wa ati'u* \- Verily this is my brother, my successor, and my caliph amongst you; therefore, listen to him and obey." This was a very explicit statement because the audience understood the appointment of 'Ali very clearly. Some of them, including Abu Lahab, even joked with Abu Talib that your nephew, Muhammad, has ordered you to listen to your son and obey him! At the least, this shows that the appointment of 'Ali bin Abi Talib was clear and explicit, not just implied.
Quran and Sunnah is only needed . Ahl byat or Shahabas stick to these two . About being Khalifa , it was just a political post not divine so chill !! Real thing is Aqedahs and beliefs. Shias have modified islam very much already
@@wajeehulhussain2058 1. He refers to the Quran for guidance and in order to be not led astray. Then he says "I REMIND YOU OF MY AHLUL BAYT" not "obeying the ahlul bayt is obligatory" 2. That is a weak ahadith from all isnads. He was not congratulated.
MashaAllah, brother! Just amazing work! 🙌 It's not easy to collect such vast information from different sources, nonetheless, the hard work behind it is truly appreciated. 😊
A Muslim believes only in Allah and asks for help only from Allah, and after that, the Hazrat Muhammad ﷺ is considered as the last prophet of Allah, and after that comes the rank of the Caliphs, the Righteous, and the Companions.
Very well-researched and logical video with authentic references that no one could deny. That's the fact Shia's beliefs are clear and logical as compared to our Sunni beliefs. Hadith Saqlain is the Testation of our Prophet Muhammad SAWW, We need to follow the teaching of the Holy Quran and Ahle beyt. There is no comparison of Sahaba and Ahle beyt. Ahle beyt. are much superior.
so what iska mtlb ama ayesha r ashabe pr bkwas krne pr chup rhy ham ajeeb me ajtak kabi ahlebait ya sahaba ka mqam pr kami nai laya mgr mazrt ke sth kch shia dst or log janta jo inthae ghtya bkwasat krty ama ayesha or ashab pr munafiq kahi ke dil krta sar phar do in ghtya lgo ko baz nai aty bkwasat r gustakhi se
only you can put it together in such a beautiful way, very insightful and knowledgeable, eagerly waiting for more parts. Great work! impressive as always
1. Incident at Ghadeer Khumm Event Overview: It raises the question: how can one argue that the Prophet (SAW) did not appoint a successor when, 40 days before his passing, he gathered thousands of Companions (Sahaba RA) at Ghadeer Khumm after his Farewell Pilgrimage? Was such a large gathering merely for companionship, or did it serve a greater purpose? Here, the Prophet (SAW) raised Ali’s (AS) hand and declared, “For whomever I am Mawla, Ali is also their Mawla.” Many interpret this as a direct indication of Ali’s (AS) leadership, highlighting that the Prophet (SAW) held greater authority over the Muslims than they held over themselves, and thus bestowed that authority onto Ali (AS). Can it truly be said that the Prophet (SAW) assembled the Sahaba at Ghadeer simply to call Ali (AS) his friend, or was it to declare a successor? References: Musnad Ahmad (Hadith 946): Declaration at Ghadeer Khumm. Sunan Tirmidhi (Hadith 3713): Ali (AS) as Mawla. Mustadrak al-Hakim (Hadith 4576): Ghadeer Khumm event. Sunan Ibn Majah and Tafsir al-Tha’labi for similar narrations. 2. Unique Virtues of Hazrat Ali (AS) Virtues and Qualities: The Prophet (SAW) repeatedly emphasized Ali’s (AS) unmatched virtues. Ali’s bravery, knowledge, and piety were celebrated in sayings such as, “I am the city of knowledge, and Ali is its gate” (Sunan Tirmidhi, Hadith 3723). It is clear from many narrations that no one shared Ali’s (AS) unique virtues in bravery, wisdom, and taqwa (piety). His roles and attributes earned him the unique designation as a father figure to the Ummah, reinforcing the Prophet’s message at Ghadeer Khumm and beyond. References: Sunan Ibn Majah (Hadith 118): Ali’s bravery and knowledge. Sahih Muslim (Hadith 2404): Ali’s unique status. Jami at-Tirmidhi (Hadith 4087): Prophet’s acknowledgment of Ali’s virtues. 3. Saqifa and Leadership Selection Context and Ahl al-Bayt Absence: If Abu Bakr (RA) was indeed chosen by the Prophet (SAW) as his successor, why did the Saqifa meeting occur? Saqifa involved only a select few individuals (5-6), and notably, none of the Prophet’s family (Ahl al-Bayt) were present. Why were they not included? Instead, key Companions prioritized the selection of leadership over the funeral preparations for the Prophet (SAW), leaving the Prophet’s family to prepare his body. This raises questions: if the Prophet (SAW) had appointed Abu Bakr (RA), why wasn’t that decision unanimously accepted without the need for the rushed meeting at Saqifa? References: Tarikh al-Tabari (Volume 9): Details of Saqifa. Sirah Ibn Ishaq: Examines the gathering’s hurried nature. Tabaqat Ibn Sa’d: Background on Saqifa participants. 4. Incident of the Pen and Paper (Hadith al-Qirtas) Event Description: During the Prophet’s (SAW) final illness, he requested pen and paper to write a will that would prevent any future misguidance. However, Umar (RA) reportedly intervened, saying, “The Book of Allah is sufficient for us,” which led to disagreement among those present, and the Prophet (SAW) ultimately chose not to dictate the will. This incident, known as Hadith al-Qirtas, left some feeling that the Prophet’s (SAW) intended message was not fully delivered. References: Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 114, 4431): The incident of the Prophet’s request. Sahih Muslim (Hadith 1637): Umar’s response during the incident. 5. Absence from the Funeral of the Prophet (SAW) Context: Instead of attending the Prophet’s (SAW) funeral, several prominent Companions, including Abu Bakr (RA) and Umar (RA), were engaged at Saqifa discussing leadership, prioritizing this over the Prophet’s burial. This prioritization of leadership over the Prophet’s final rites is often questioned and debated. References: Ibn Sa’d’s Tabaqat (Vol. 2): Details on the funeral. Tarikh al-Tabari: Describes the proceedings and absence at the funeral. 6. Bravery on the Battlefield Ali’s (AS) Bravery: Ali’s bravery, demonstrated in numerous battles, remains unparalleled. Narrations describe instances where other Companions, including Abu Bakr (RA), Umar (RA), and Uthman (RA), reportedly retreated during battles, while Ali (AS) consistently displayed courage, especially at Khaybar. Where can it be shown that Abu Bakr (RA), Umar (RA), or Uthman (RA) displayed such bravery in any battle? Historical records even mention instances of fleeing, which contrasts sharply with Ali’s (AS) reputation as a fearless warrior. References: Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 3702): Ali’s role in battles. Sahih Muslim (Hadith 2407): Reference to Ali’s bravery. Sunan Abu Dawood: Accounts of battlefield conduct. 7. Legal Dispute Over Fadak (Inheritance) Dispute with Abu Bakr (RA): Fatima (RA) requested the inheritance of Fadak, but Abu Bakr (RA) declined, citing a narration that prophets do not leave inheritance. Fatima (RA) even went to court, where she was reportedly treated disrespectfully, and her claim was ultimately rejected. This decision has been widely scrutinized and remains a point of contention. References: Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 4240, 4241): Fadak and inheritance. Sahih Muslim (Hadith 4471): Abu Bakr’s ruling on inheritance. 8. Bid’ah (Innovations) Introduced by Umar (RA) Examples of Innovations: Taraweeh in Congregation: Umar (RA) reintroduced Taraweeh prayers in congregation, which the Prophet (SAW) had discontinued after a few nights. Such actions by Umar (RA), including other innovations, are frequently debated. Compilation of the Quran: Initiated by Abu Bakr (RA) and later standardized by Uthman (RA), the Quran’s compilation into a single text was unprecedented during the Prophet’s time. References: Sahih Bukhari (Hadith 2010): Umar’s reintroduction of Taraweeh in congregation. Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 4987): Compilation of the Quran. 9. Caliph Uthman’s (RA) Governance and Alleged Favoritism Appointments and Exile of Critics: Uthman (RA) faced accusations of favoritism for appointing Banu Umayya members to key positions, including individuals previously expelled from Medina by the Prophet (SAW). Uthman (RA)’s administration reportedly exiled Companions such as Abu Dharr al-Ghifari for criticism. Many argue that if Saqifa hadn’t taken place, the power granted to the Banu Umayya might have been prevented, which could have spared the Prophet’s family from later injustices. References: Tarikh al-Tabari: On appointments and favoritism. Kitab al-Maghazi by al-Waqidi: Mentions of Abu Dharr al-Ghifari’s criticisms and exile.
If anyone needs to be appointed as a successor the right time was hijjat ul wida where everyone was present and the last imp khutba wa given unlike ghadeer with minimal gathering when they were going back to Madina. It has a history of why it was given and people who have doubts about Ali for certain things it was the answer for them. If Allah needs to appoint the prophet's family to be the leader after them Hazrat Abbas was the choice then or if you talk about son then Allah gave the prophet a son to lead after him. In both cases your assumption relating Ali to the caliph after propjet doesn't stand. At saqifa the leader of the ansar and muhajreen appointed Abubakr and who else is better then them appointed Abubakr as history tells us there are worst situations where a caliph was appointed by the killers of the old caliph. Relating favoritism Ali did appoint his family member and the nominated killers of caliph to the key positions.
@lulu22-b4j if I show you the word maula for any other then ? From my books ? Ali did. The same by refusing Muhammad pbuh when he was instructed to remove the prophet name from a paper
@lulu22-b4j and now with what Ali did Umar and Ali both are in the same situation not obeying the prophet. For him was the Hadith Fatima mere Jigar Ka tukra hai when he was Marrying the daughter of the enemy of Prophet. So ur so called assumption will fit in both cases for Ali and for Umar
speechless.... finally someone took the initiative to preach the Islam to younger generations through new medium as well.... hats off to you mooroo and more power to you
My god Taimoor bhai. This is your magnum opus. I cannot emphasize enough how proud I felt watching this video. This is by far the best topic you've ever tackled on this channel. I'm in awe of your story telling. Allah apko or kamyabi de. Please iss topic par or bhi zyada videos banao.
As a person who is sunni i cant belive people compare Ali with Umer Usman or Abu Bakr. ALI (RA) is way ahead of them.Hazrat Ali shared the same blood as prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Ali was the son of the man who raised Hazrat Muhammad(PBUH). Ali was the 2nd person to accept islam. Ali was raised by prophet muhammad and hazrat khatija. Hazrat Ali never worshipped an idol, even before revelation revealed itself. Holy prophet was the one who raised,and trained Ali. Holy prophet was like afatherly figure to him. Ali was ready to sacrifice his life for Holy Prophet. ali was given the most precious thing Prophet had that is Hazrat Fatima(RA). He was the father of those boys who used to ride on prophets back Hassan and hussain. Ali was given the flag in khybar where prophet said This flag wil be given to the person who is loved by Allah and the holy prophet. It was said about Ali that who considers me their mollah then Ali is also their mollah. In the battle when everyone ran away Ali was there to protect islam and guard Hazrat Muhammad (SAW). It was about Ali that you are to me how haroon was to musa. When prophet went away from this world to jannah, it was ali and hassan and hussain who carried his holy body to the grave and for janazah.While other Sahabi were busy doing politics and choosingeho would become leader, rather then taking part in prophets janazah. Prophet said dogs would bark at my wife and she would be on the wrong side. This is about Hazart Ali vs Muawiah battle where Hazrat Ayesha sided with Muawiya. Prophet said amaar would be killed by a baghi( rebellious) group amar would call them towards islam but this will choose hell. Amar was killed by muawiyas army of whom Ayesha (R.A ) was part of. But Hazrat Ali treated Ayesha R.A with same respect and dignity and sent her safely to makkah. And Hazrat ayesha May Allah bless her accepted her mistake. And i am not writing this comment to degrade any sahabi whatsoever but to deliver truth. Sahabis did alot of mistakes.
Mooroo, you are truly a genius and most amazing at content creation - the quality of your analysis, references and detailed neutral pov on such a delicate topic is phenomenal. I've known about most of these incidences but thank you for explicitly explaining them with reference - especially The Waqiah e Qirtas. Thank you for your hardwork.
@@alixhussain786 Nabi S.A.W has defined who is the companion Narrated Ibn `Abbas: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "If I were to take a Khalil, I would have taken Abu Bakr, but he is my brother and my companion (in Islam). ~ Sahih al-Bukhari 3656
They are except some of them think Ali ibn Abi Talib still help people and say Ali Madad. This is where they are challenging God. This is no different from ghos pak madad etc.
SubhanAllah! Listening to this has torn my heart and brought tears to my eyes. My whole body is overwhelmed with goosebumps, and my soul feels deeply moved. May Allah bless you and guide us all on the straight path. Ameen.
@moorsicity, as a follower of Shia faith, Thank You! Not for just shinning light on a very important topic, but also for being well versed in our ideology. Most of our ideas are misrepresented in Sunni main stream world, and leads to confusion among Muslims. One question, can you also list out the Shia source and scholars you’re using? I would recommend Dr. Ammar Nakshwani as a great source for Shia belief system. Thanks, and looking forward to part 2 :)
Mooroo i really appreciate your efforts I'm watching this with mine dado and she said "i was hooked up till end i really enjoyed it. May allah bless this child"🙏 thanks mooro for such an amazing content where we can revive the lost bond with our elders as well.❤❤
Thank you for sharing content on such an important topic. I’d like to point out a couple of issues with the thumbnail that might unintentionally misrepresent Shia and Sunni beliefs. The current thumbnail seems to show a comparison between the shrines of Hazrat Ali and Hazrat Muhammad (PBUH), but this could be misleading. Both Shia and Sunni Muslims deeply revere Hazrat Muhammad (PBUH) as the Prophet of Islam, so placing 'Shia' on one and 'Sunni' on the other doesn’t accurately reflect the shared respect both groups have for him. Additionally, Shia beliefs generally hold that Hazrat Ali’s actual tomb is in Najaf, Iraq, not Afghanistan. Using the Shrine of Ali in Mazar-i-Sharif could lead to confusion. I’d recommend revisiting the thumbnail design to better represent these views and avoid any unintended implications. Thank you for considering this feedback, and I appreciate your work on this important subject.
Asalam u Alaikum Taimoor, Buhat shukriya Ali bhai ki video link share karne k liye. Hadees e Ifk unhone buhat ache aur wazeh tareeke se samjhai hai. Aap ki koshish bhi achi thi aur yakeenan apki neeyat bhi buhat saaf hogi lekin aap k andaz e bayaan se sansani si create horahi thi kiyoon k mein is waqiye k baaray mein ziada jaanta nahin tha. Jazaak ALLAH Khair
@@Hamza-iv9yiwah bachayy aagye aap yeh BAAT lyy kr woh nabi Paak nay os jagah ya Zameen kyy liye bola hai kyy jis pr Muslims ka khoon baha ho phr Fatah hoi hoo ya os pr Jang kr kyy Fatah Kiya ho yeh jagah nabi Paak ko milli thii Jang Khyber kyy baad or is KY baad NAHI Paak almost 4 saal zinda rahay agr ummat ko deni hoti tou khud dyy detay simple yeh bachon wali batein hamein na sunaya kroo khud jaa kr parhoo pehlay 😂
when ever we face disagreement among each other we should turn back to Allah and his messenger Allah and his Messenger or even Abu bakr or Ali did not say that we are Shia or Sunni because they have read the Quran only call yourself Muslim that's it "And who is better in speech than one who invites to Allah and does righteousness and says, 'Indeed, I am of the Muslims.'" - Quran 41:33 "And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided..." - Quran 3:103 "And strive for Allah with the striving due to Him. He has chosen you and has not placed upon you in the religion any difficulty. It is the religion of your father, Abraham. He named you Muslims before [in former scriptures] and in this [revelation] that the Messenger may be a witness over you and you may be witnesses over the people. So establish prayer and give zakah and hold fast to Allah. He is your protector; and excellent is the protector, and excellent is the helper." - Quran 22:78 "O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result." - Quran 4:59
Deep insights and well Researched Video! Thank you for bringing clarity and depth to such an important topic .Always a fan of your content-truly inspiring 🙌✨ Looking forward to more content like this!
I love the quality of the words you use to explain this. It's good to have different opinion on history but we should neither fight nor kill each others.
Well done, Mooroo. In fact, much better than I was expecting. One thing I wish you had mentioned related to the Mutah portion of your video. The last abrogation of the permissibility of Mutah was done by Hazrat Umar - not in the life of the Prophet - and this is why it is not accepted by Shia Muslims.
واضح طور پر دو جگہ پر رسول اللہ نے اپنا وصی و جانشین قرار دیا تھا ایک دعوت ذوالعشیرہ پر جب اپنے قریبیوں کو اسلام کی دعوت دی تھی اور کارخیر میں مدد کی درخواست کی تھی اور کہا تھا کے جو میری مدر کریگا وہ میرا وزیر، میرا خلیفہ اور میرا جانشین ہوگا اور تینوں دفعہ حضرت علی نے لبیک کہا تھا کہ میں اپکا مددگار ہوں تو اسکے بعد رسول اللہ نے حضرت علی کو اپنا خلیفہ و جانشین بنایا تھا اور دوسری دفعہ حجۃ الوداع سے واپسی پر خم کے مقام پر من کنت مولاہ فھذا علی مولا کہہ کر حجت تمام کر دی اور سوا لاکھ صحابہ کے مجمعے میں علی کو اپنے مثل مولا کا درجہ دیا تھا۔ اب بھی اگر لوگ بغض میں آنکھیں بند کریں تو انکی قسمت
Sorry to say bhai Dunia chand per phonch gae or hum 1400 sal pehly Huey faislon ko ghalat or shai sabit karny per truly Huey hain. Jin hastiyon ko aap or main yeh kehny ki jasarat karty hain k in se ye ghalti hue ya phalan se ye ghalti hue, wo is Dunia se parda farma chkain hain, unko is baat se koi farq nae parta k ap kia sochty hain ya karty hain, lakin hamajn apni zaat or bahesiat e musalman ye zaror sochna chahey k hamry apsi ikhtilifat ka faeda utha kar hamary dushman hamrai ....... Bajaty hain.
@@sniazi3993pyaray Bhai jis tarah Imam Mahdi(as) ko maanna zaruuri hai, inkaar nhi ker saktay, usi tarah ooper tak hai. Kehdo k Adam(as) ko maanna bhi zaruuri nhi, kia faeydah? Duniya chaand per pohonch gaee hai.
@@sniazi3993 دنیا چاند پر پہنچے یا سورج پر، بات یہاں حقیقت کی ہورہی ہے، آنکھیں بند کرنے سے حقیقت تبدیل نہیں ہوتی۔ تمام تاریخی کتب میں دعوت ذوالعشیرہ کے واقعے کا ذکر ہے۔ نبی پیدا ہوتے ہی نبی ہوتا ہے اسکا کسی بھی لمحے کہا ہوا جملہ نبوت کی زبان سے جاری ہوتا ہے اور نبی وحی الٰہی کے علاوہ بات نہیں کرتا۔ تو دعوت ذوالعشیرہ پر مولا علی ع کو اپنا وزیر، جانشین و وصی بنانا مرضیِ الٰہی کے سبب تھا۔ قرآن میں قیامت کے دن کے ایک وقعے کا ذکر ہے کے جب سب حساب کتاب مکمل ہوجائیگا تو کچھ لوگ جنت کیطرف جارہے ہونگے تو آواز آئیگی کے انکو روکو ان سے ایک سوال کرنا ہے اور تفاسیر میں بتایا جاتا ہے کہ وہ سوال ولایت و امامت کا کیا جائیگا۔ آپ نے ولایت و امامت کو کچھ سمجھا ہی نہیں ہے؟ حدیث رسول ص ہے کی علی ع سے محبت صرف مومن کریگا اور منافق محبت نہیں کریگا۔ علی ع وہ میزان ہے جس میں اعمال تولے جائینگے۔ سے مراد یہی ہے کے اعمال اسی کے قبول ہونگے جو علی ع سے محبت کرتا ہوگا۔ اور یہ محبت ایسے ہوگی جیسے محبت رسول اللہ سے ہے، کیونکہ جیسے مولا رسول ص ہیں ویسے ہی مولا علی ع ہیں۔ تم چاند پر پہنچو یا مریخ پر مگر آخرت کی کامیابی محمد وآل محمد ص سے محبت پر منحصر ہے۔
The real divide started from Ghadeer vs Saqifa. It started in Ghadeer (Where prophet announced that After me Follow Quran and my Ahlbayt) and Sunnis rejected the prophet and followed Bani Saqifa (Where they Chose Abu Bakr and Umar instead of Ahlbayt)
@@ali8967 gafire khoom Didn't announced the leader. Gadire khoom just a special stature of Hazrat Ali ra.. Islam is not any concept of monarchy. Ok Ali ra. even accepted the bayat of My dear Khalifas. Now, who are you here? rafidi firka
Us time kon Shia tha? Nabi k parda k foran baad Bani saqeefa ne me voting kisne shuru krwa di k itna intazar na hua k kafan dafan ho jaye@@greenshaheen
"جو کچھ رسول دے وہ لے لو، اور جس سے روکےتو رک جاؤ۔" "اور خبردار رسول ص کے سامنے اپنی آواز کو اونچا نہ کرنا کہی ایسا نہ ہو کہ تمہارے سارے اعمال ضائع ہو جائے" "اور وہ اپنی خواہش سے کوئی کلام بھی نہیں کرتا ہے" "اسکا کلام وہی وحی ہے جو مسلسل نازل ہوتی ہے" "اسے نہایت طاقت والے نے تعلیم دی ہے" اب اگر کوئی کہے دے کہ قرآن کافی ہے تو اسکو میں کیا سمجھو؟
@@abdullahshahid1422 Tareekh study ko mery bhai... Agar aj k circumstances ko dekh k agar samjh naa aaye to... Chalyn maan lety hain shia musalman nahi ... To kahan hain apky musalman kidr chupy bethy hain... Lakho musalmano shaheed kiye jaa rahy hain Kitny begunah bachy bedardi sy shaheed kiye jaa rahy hain kahan chupy bethy hain apky sachy musalman... Agar unka drd mehsus kar raha hai to wo sirf shia hai... Apny chaand jesy leaders qurbaan kar rahy hain sirf apny musalman behen bhaio k difaa me... Un k liye b mumkin tha k baqi musalmano ki trh aankhyn band kar k andhy ghungy ban k beth jaty... Afsos hai k tm jesy choti soch walo ki aankhyn abhi tak nahi khuli... Khuda ny mohr laga rakha hy Tm jeso k dilo par
@RainaBatool-x1d o madam tareekh ap bhi parho shia ko awe non muslims ni kahty koi wajha ha na ab koi hamary nabi kareem (saw) ki biwi ko bura kahy yani hamari maa ko tu hum usy musalman many??or bhi buhat se reasons ha saboot chaye de donga
@RainaBatool-x1d shia kaha dard mahsoos kar raha wo to.matlab parast ha hamy jasy pata ni shuro se shia ny hi islam ko nuqsan puhchya or aj bhi sham iraq me kitny shia ny sunni muslim ko.qalat kiya ?? baki jo.misail iran shia ny mary ham ny bhi dekhe ha kitny bandy mary ha 🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂
واقعہ غدیر خم اسلامی تاریخ کا ایک عظیم الشان واقعہ ہے، جس میں رسول اکرمﷺ نے حضرت علیؑ کی ولایت کا اعلان کیا۔ اس واقعہ کی تفصیل میں آپ نے قرآن کے آیات کو مینشن نہیں کیا ہیں: یہاں قرآن کے روشنی میں لکھا ہے واقعہ غدیر خم حجۃ الوداع سے واپسی کے دوران، جب رسول اکرمﷺ اور ان کے ہمراہ حاجیوں کا قافلہ مقام غدیر خم پر پہنچا تو اللہ تعالیٰ کی طرف سے وحی نازل ہوئی، جس میں نبی اکرمﷺ کو ایک اہم پیغام پہنچانے کا حکم دیا گیا۔ اس مقام پر نبی اکرمﷺ نے تمام مسلمانوں کو جمع کیا اور ایک خطبہ دیا۔ اس خطبے کے دوران، آپﷺ نے حضرت علیؑ کا ہاتھ پکڑا اور فرمایا: “مَن کُنتُ مَولاه فَهذا عَلیٌّ مَولاه” ترجمہ: “جس کا میں مولا ہوں، اس کا علی بھی مولا ہے۔” غدیر خم سے متعلق قرآنی آیات اس واقعہ سے پہلے اور بعد میں قرآن کی کچھ آیات نازل ہوئیں، جو حضرت علیؑ کی ولایت اور اس اعلان کی اہمیت کو اجاگر کرتی ہیں: 1. آیت تبلیغ: • سورۂ مائدہ (5:67): “يَا أَيُّهَا الرَّسُولُ بَلِّغْ مَا أُنزِلَ إِلَيْكَ مِنْ رَبِّكَ ۖ وَإِنْ لَمْ تَفْعَلْ فَمَا بَلَّغْتَ رِسَالَتَهُ ۚ وَاللَّهُ يَعْصِمُكَ مِنَ النَّاسِ ۗ إِنَّ اللَّهَ لَا يَهْدِي الْقَوْمَ الْكَافِرِينَ” ترجمہ: “اے رسول! جو کچھ آپ کے رب کی جانب سے آپ پر نازل کیا گیا ہے، اسے پہنچا دیں۔ اور اگر آپ نے ایسا نہ کیا تو آپ نے اس کا پیغام نہیں پہنچایا۔ اور اللہ آپ کو لوگوں سے محفوظ رکھے گا۔ بے شک، اللہ کافروں کو ہدایت نہیں دیتا۔” یہ آیت اس بات کی وضاحت کرتی ہے کہ اللہ نے نبی اکرمﷺ کو حضرت علیؑ کی ولایت کے اعلان کے لئے خصوصی حکم دیا تھا، اور یہ اعلان دین کی تکمیل کا حصہ تھا۔ 2. آیت اکمالِ دین: • سورۂ مائدہ (5:3): “الْيَوْمَ أَكْمَلْتُ لَكُمْ دِينَكُمْ وَأَتْمَمْتُ عَلَيْكُمْ نِعْمَتِي وَرَضِيتُ لَكُمُ الْإِسْلَامَ دِينًا” ترجمہ: “آج میں نے تمہارے دین کو تمہارے لئے مکمل کر دیا، اور اپنی نعمت تم پر تمام کر دی، اور تمہارے لئے اسلام کو دین کے طور پر پسند کر لیا۔” اس آیت کے نزول کے ساتھ، دین اسلام کی تکمیل ہوئی اور حضرت علیؑ کی ولایت کو دین کا حصہ قرار دیا گیا۔ واقعہ کا پس منظر اور اہمیت غدیر خم کا واقعہ اس بات کی نشاندہی کرتا ہے کہ رسول اکرمﷺ نے حضرت علیؑ کو اپنا جانشین اور مولا مقرر کیا، اور یہ اعلان دین کی تکمیل کا باعث بنا۔ اس واقعہ کو اسلامی تاریخ میں ایک عظیم حیثیت حاصل ہے اور اسے مسلمانوں کے لئے ایک ہدایت و رہنمائی کے طور پر جانا جاتا ہے۔
میرے بھائی حضرت علی علیہ السلام کی بہادری پر سوال مت اٹھاؤ اگر ایسا ہے پھر کیوں حضرت علی علیہ السلام نے اپنا حق نہیں مانگا کہ حضور صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے مجھے حلیفہ مقرر کیا ہے ۔۔۔۔۔
اب مجھے یہ بتائیں یہ اللہ اور علی علیہ السلام کی توہین نہیں ہے، نبوت اور امامت جب اللہ کی طرف سے ہے ، تو پھر مجھے یہ بتائیں، کیا اللہ کی دی ہوئی نبوت کوئی چھین سکتا ہے، اگر نہیں تو پھر اللہ کی طرف سے امامت کیسے چھین سکتا ہے، جواب پلیز
@mabbas0099 ارے بھائی آپ کی مذہب میں تو خلافت منصوص من اللہ ہے اور یہاں بول رہے ہو کہ جنگ نہیں کرتے تھے چلو اگر مان بھی جاے تو اس کے بعد امام حسن اور حسین نے کیوں کیوں نہیں بولا بھائی سچے حسینی بنو یہ آپ کے لیے بہتر ہے
32:22 Hmary pas Quran h Allah ki kitab r hamry liy kafi h...(Un ke jany ka intezar ho rha tha??? ta ke masnat pe betha jay khud ko jan-e-sheen e Rasool kehny waly hi un ki akhari bt nai man skhy)
You are doing something that in pakistan no one is doing your content is really a symbol of respect you are not a molvi and you dont have that knowledge as well but you wanted to unite them well done may Allah protect you and give you health and wealth ♥️
میرے والدین دیوبند مکتبہ فکر سے تعلق رکھتے ہیں لیکن اللّٰہ کا شکر ہے کہ میں کسی خاص فرقہ یا مسلک میں شامل نہیں ہؤا میں خود کو برقہ پرستی سے پاک صرف مسلمان کہتا ہوں 😀 میرے لیے شیعہ سنی وہابی دیوبندی سب مسلمان ہیں۔
شیعہ سنی سمیت تمام فرقے مسلک خلاف قرآن ہیں ۔ اور شیعہ ہوں یا سنی سب کے سب قرآن سے نابلد نام کے مسلمان اصل میں منافق ہیں ۔ ان فرقوں کے ٹھیکیداروں نے ان فرقے مسلکوں کو اپنے پاپی پیٹ پالنے کا دھندہ بنا رکھا ہے ۔ جب تک سب نام کے مسلمان صرف قرآن کو دین کی بنیاد بنا کر خلاف قرآن جھوٹی من گھڑت حدیثوں کو اور ان کی بنیاد پر شخصیت پرستی کو ختم نہیں کریں گے ، اللہ کے اس حکم پر عمل نہیں کریں گے واعتصموا بحبل اللہ جمیعا ولا تفرقو تب تک کچھ اچھا نہیں ہوگا نہ دین کا نہ دنیا کا ☝️
Taimoor, recently I was looking into whether I wanted to be a Shia or a Sunni, and this video came at the exact time when I needed it the most. JazakAllah! it feels like this video was meant to reach me.
@@AliHassan-wc6nb Kindly tell me k Mola Ali As or Ahle Bait As se agar ham direct mangen or niyat hamari beshak yehi hai k Khuda hee denay wali zaat hai or ham Ahl e Bait As se mang Rahe hain q k Khuda nee hee Inko ye maqam diya hai or woh unki sunta bhi hai to is ye Karna kesa hai?
If shias are peacfull and only sunnis are voilent why did shia majority iran and and shia iraq had two wars killIn each other why is iran killi** muslims in syria why did shia iraq attack kuwait and killed muslims
Masoom toh woh hai jinhe lashkar e Usama ke bare Mai nhi pata aur umar ki wajah se apki tabiyat kharab se kharab huwi aur phir umar ne kaha hamare liye Quran Kafi hai qalam kagaz nhi diya jaiga 💔
This felt so real and authentic. May ALLAH help you to create a positive change in the world and especially in our society where we all can accept and respect each other. Amen. Thank you Mooroo!
یہاں مولا علیؑ کی زندگی کے چند اہم واقعات اور رسول اکرمﷺ کے فرامین کا ذکر کیا گیا ہے، جو مولا علیؑ کی عظمت اور ان کے بلند مرتبے کو واضح کرتے ہیں: • پیدائش خانہ کعبہ میں: مولا علیؑ خانہ کعبہ میں پیدا ہوئے، یہ واقعہ ان کی پاکیزگی اور خاص مقام کی علامت ہے۔ • رسول اکرمﷺ کو پہلی نظر میں دیکھنا: روایت ہے کہ مولا علیؑ نے سب سے پہلے رسول اکرمﷺ کو دیکھا، جو ان کے اور نبی کریمﷺ کے درمیان روحانی تعلق کی نشاندہی کرتا ہے۔ • پہلے مرد مسلمان: مولا علیؑ نے سب سے پہلے مرد ہونے کی حیثیت سے اسلام قبول کیا، جو ان کی وفاداری اور دینی عزم کو ظاہر کرتا ہے۔ • رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “حق علی کے ساتھ ہے اور علی حق کے ساتھ ہیں”۔ • ہجرت کی رات قربانی: مولا علیؑ نے رسول اکرمﷺ کے بستر پر سو کر اپنی جان کی قربانی دی، تاکہ رسول اکرمﷺ کو کفار کے حملے سے محفوظ رکھیں۔ • رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “اللہ کی راہ میں کوئی علی کی طرح جان کا خطرہ مول نہیں لیتا”۔ • بدر کی جنگ: مولا علیؑ نے بدر کی جنگ میں شجاعت کا مظاہرہ کیا اور اسلام کی فتح میں اہم کردار ادا کیا۔ • غدیر خم کا واقعہ: رسول اکرمﷺ نے فرمایا، “جس کا میں مولا ہوں، اس کا علی مولا ہے”، یہ علیؑ کی روحانی اور سماجی قیادت کا اعلان تھا۔ • حضرت فاطمہؑ سے شادی: مولا علیؑ کی شادی نبی کریمﷺ کی بیٹی حضرت فاطمہؑ سے ہوئی، جس سے خاندان اور روحانی تعلق مضبوط ہوا۔ • حسنؑ و حسینؑ کے والد: مولا علیؑ امام حسنؑ اور امام حسینؑ کے والد ہیں، جنہیں رسول اکرمﷺ نے “جنت کے جوانوں کے سردار” کہا۔ • خیبر کی جنگ: مولا علیؑ نے خیبر کا قلعہ فتح کیا۔ • رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “کل میں جھنڈا اس کو دوں گا جو اللہ اور اس کے رسول سے محبت کرتا ہے اور اللہ اور اس کا رسول اس سے محبت کرتے ہیں”۔ • علیؑ کا مقام: رسول اکرمﷺ نے فرمایا، “اے علی! تمہارا میرے ساتھ وہی رشتہ ہے جو حضرت ہارون کا حضرت موسیٰ کے ساتھ تھا، سوائے اس کے کہ میرے بعد کوئی نبی نہیں”۔ • قاضی اور عالم: مولا علیؑ اپنے علم و عدل کے سبب مشہور تھے۔ • رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “علی میری امت میں سب سے بہتر قاضی اور عالم ہیں”۔ • خلافت اور حکمرانی: مولا علیؑ نے خلافت کے دوران عدل، مساوات اور اسلامی اصولوں کے مطابق حکمرانی کی۔ • کوفہ کی مسجد میں شہادت: مولا علیؑ کو صبح کی نماز میں سجدے کی حالت میں شہید کیا گیا، جو ان کی عبادت اور دین سے محبت کا عکاس ہے۔ • رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “اے علی! تمہیں سجدے کی حالت میں شہید کیا جائے گا”۔ یہ واقعات اور فرامین مولا علیؑ کی بے مثال شجاعت، وفاداری، علم، عدل اور روحانی قیادت کو ظاہر کرتے ہیں۔
How beautiful mooro has explained everything may ALLAH bless you brother I didn’t realise how 39min went by we really need more intellectuals like mooro🙌🏻
ہاں اگر وہاں سارے صحابہ موجود تھے پھر کیوں کسی نے اس بات پر زور نہیں دیا کہ کاغذ اور قلم لاؤ اگر آپ کے مطابق یہ کوئی دین کا حصہ تھا پھر آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے نعوذباللہ دین نامکمل چھوڑا ہے یا جو ہوا ٹھیک ہوا
![50-MAJLIS : Interview of Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza Bhai [ 21-Questions Recorded on 17-Feb-2019 ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/sUaMFoX0hls/mqdefault.jpg)
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
There will be multiple parts of this story, so for everyone concerned about events not mentioned they will be as the series continues, do like, share and support to help me make it faster bigger and better. Thanks for all the support love you ❤
Good work
@@mooroosicity Bro you should be neutral and find the facts and you are doing a great job, your content is amazing
@@hamzaraza9291 did you accept about the part in this ep 1 regarding Amaan Ayesha R.A, if not brother you are rejected verses of Quran
Talking about jana sheen e Rasool saww you skipped the Ghadeer where Rasool Saww announced IMAM ALI as as his Janashen by saying "Man kunto Mola, Fa haza Ali un Mola" jis ka main Mola uska Ali Mola
@@haseebansari3093 Look brother, disagreeing with someone does not mean that he is being insulted and the role of Hazrat Aisha is controversial in Islamic history. You know the reasons.What do you say about Hazrat Nuh's wife? She was also the wife of a prophet.
❤ Excellent & Logical Analysis. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our UMMAT from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! !
Mashallah ❤️ Ali bhai
علی بھائی کہتے ہیں ان کے پاس موبائل نہیں ہے😅لیکن ہر اس پرح کے وڈیوز پر کمنٹ کرنے پہنچ جاتے ہیں😅😅😅😅آئندہ کہا کریں ٹچ موبائل نہیں ہے کیکن لیپٹاپ تو ہے😂
EMAM❤
@@Daani_75 unki bat phirbhi ghalat nai h k "unk pass mobile nai h"
Mashallah 😍❤
As someone who has thoroughly studied the Seerah & the aftermath of our Prophet SAW's demise. It amazes me how much effort you put into this video, everything is so well researched. I am just leaving this comment to appreciate the effort as I know how complex it can be. I am in awe, we need more "influencers" like you. God bless you Mooroo, Aameen.
I had a question, didn't Nabi S.A.W give a last sermon on top of Kaab'ah after the night of the pen and paper?
So, didn't he say it about Qur'an?
While he’s done an amazing job, it is mainly Urdu translation of the book After The Prophet by Leslie Hazleton
@@maziastro9932 Prophet gave the last fatwa in Arafat on top his camel.
Sooo good mooroo bhai, can’t wait for the next part ❤
Me too
Probably the first Pakistani content creator who has touched on such a controversial topic so beautifully and mindfully. Subtle, comprehensive and rightly informative!!
Kudos, Mooro!
@@lulu22-b4j if that's the case why dont you make a video and tell everyone in a better way
@@lulu22-b4j The writing of this document is not something that Allah enjoined upon him to write or convey at that time. If that had been the case, he (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) would not have failed to do what Allah instructed him to do. It was not permissible for him to abandon writing the document because of the doubts that some had about (its importance). If what he intended to write in the document was something that he was obliged to convey and disclose, then the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) would have disclosed it and written it in a document, and he would not have paid any attention to the view of anybody, for he was the most obedient of creation to Allah. Thus it is known that when he decided not to write the document, the document was not obligatory and it would not have contained anything of religious matters that he was obliged to write at that time, because if that had been necessary, he would have done it.
Minhaaj as-Sunnah an-Nabawiyyah
@@lulu22-b4j yar hum ko aek baat to batao ye sab hua phir tum log kehte ho hazat fatima ko bhi qatal kia sahaba ne to phir hazrat ali ne un se jang kyun nahi ki ???
@@mohammad.ssaimm Jo Rasuul(saww) dain woh le lo, jis cheez se mana Karain uss se baaz raho.
Rasuul(saww) k saamnay aeaaz oonchi na Karo. Unse Qadam Aagay na berhao.
Rasuul (saww) ki ata'at kerne ka hukm hai ya unko wasiyat se roknay ka?
Qur'aan aise nafarmaano k baray mein kia kehta hai?
Aisa kahan likha hai k Allah ne nhi chaha k Rasuul(saww) wasiyat ka Karain?
Loag tou Allah he ki nafarmani kerte hain, jo Allah Unse chahta hai woh nhi kerte, tou Rasuul(saww) ki Kia baat kerte bhi.
Jang e Ohod mein pahar se uternay se mana kiya tha?
Loagon ka failure hai, jaahil aadmi, loag gumrah ho gaey Allah aur Rasuul(saww) ki nafarmani ker k.
@@syedfaraz5Ali(as) is ummat k Haroon hain. Iss liye jang nhi ker sakay. Jo Haroon(as) na ker sakay, same Ali(as) k saath Hua. Quraan mein daikh lo Haruun(as) ka waqiya.
عجب مذاق ہے اسلام کی تقدیر کے ساتھ
کٹا حُسینؑ کا سر نعرہِ تکبیر کے ساتھ
- علامہ اقبال
عجیب تماشا ہوا اسلام کی تقدیر کے ساتھ ،قتل شبیر ھوے نہعراے تکبیر کے ساتھ ۔شاعر علامہ اقبال ۔
یہ شعر علامہ اقبال رحمۃ اللہ علیہ کا نہیں ہے۔
Yah bath allama Iqbal ko pata Hy kah unho na assa koi shair kaha tha 🤔
Ye Iqbal channay walon ny kaha hoga
@@khizerahmed2571 hn mauwiya or yazid ki aulad
"Allah ki rassi ko mazbooti se thamy rakho aur tafarqy me na prho"
(Al Quran)
@@ansibhai5947 tou Bhai sahab iss hadeees ka kya krna hai phr aap btaa dein kyy Meray baad Quran or Ahley bait ko mazbooti syy pkryy rakhna simple
@@ranaazadarhussainazadarh8862 tu unho ne quran ki ayt hi quote ki hai bhai dobara dekh lein
@@ranaazadarhussainazadarh8862 brother jo insaan quran prr amal krta ho wo kabhi bhi ahle bait ka bugz apne dil main NAHI rakh sakta ye jo log krte hain unn ki rozi deen ke sath ha Bss aur koi baat nahi ha
Puri hadith parh
Allah ki Rassi Sa Murad Kia Ha ?
Go and start research on this...
Wo rassi Ahlebait hain , zariya hain Allah sa kareeb rehna ka..
Jazakmullah Khaira. ❤
I am a Muslim, and my identity is rooted in Islam as a whole, not in specific schools of thought or divisions. My faith is centered on the teachings of the Quran and the example of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). I choose not to affiliate with labels or sectarian distinctions because I believe in the oneness of the Muslim Ummah. My focus is on understanding and practicing Islam in its purest form, promoting unity, respect, and compassion among all Muslims, regardless of differences. Love for Mola Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) is part of my faith, as he is a beacon of courage, wisdom, and devotion. We are all bound by our shared faith, and that is what truly matters
Just goody goody talk it can't be exist in real world Iran killed thousand of sunni Muslim in Syria Iraq Yeman and labnon no Syria is free from Bashar Al Asad and we see shia Iran real face don't be lie to yourself
first time in pakistan a man can tell truth about islamic history.As a shia muslim i appriciate your work.thanks allah i have borne in shia family😍
I have Shia friends (2) we definitely have different opinions but the level of respect is never compromised we eat together, and we go on trips together. I admit them as Muslim brothers. Just because we have differences in opinions does not mean we disgrace and tag each other with Kufr Fatwa, Neither Allah has given us any right to exclude them nor his prophet. Together we grow stronger! Trust me we can conquer if we accept differences in opinion instead of taking things personally!
آپ نے اپنے شیعہ دوستوں پر احسان عظیم کیا ہے ان کو کافر نہ مانتے ہوئے ۔
@ Jazakallah, if basis of belief is same, we are same. We are brothers.
شیعہ سنی سمیت تمام فرقے مسلک خلاف قرآن ہیں ۔
اور شیعہ ہوں یا سنی سب کے سب قرآن سے نابلد نام کے مسلمان اصل میں منافق ہیں ۔
ان فرقوں کے ٹھیکیداروں نے ان فرقے مسلکوں کو اپنے پاپی پیٹ پالنے کا دھندہ بنا رکھا ہے ۔
جب تک سب نام کے مسلمان صرف قرآن کو دین کی بنیاد بنا کر خلاف قرآن جھوٹی من گھڑت حدیثوں کو اور ان کی بنیاد پر شخصیت پرستی کو ختم نہیں کریں گے ، اللہ کے اس حکم پر عمل نہیں کریں گے واعتصموا بحبل اللہ جمیعا ولا تفرقو تب تک کچھ اچھا نہیں ہوگا نہ دین کا نہ دنیا کا ☝️
bhai yeh koi khas baat toh nhi, mene toh apne hindu doston ke saath ghuma phira hoon, unke ghar ka khana khaya hai.
@ baat yai uncommon isi liyay hai, ik hi thaali may khana khatay hain log, or nafrat bhi rkhtay hain, Alhamdulillah ham aisa nhi krtay, ham beth kr baat krtay hain na k ik dusray k drmian gaalian or fasaad paida krien. May shia ulma ko bhi sunta hun or unsay ilm deen adopt krta hun. Un may bhi kuch cheezon pr ikhtelaaf hota hai lekin aisa nhi k vo hamaray alim nhi.
Dusra bhayi hindu dost kbsay hogayay? Coworker hsoktay hain, classmate hosktay hain, lekin vo hamaray dost nhi hosktay.
Dear Mooroo, I just finished watching Shia vs. Sunni | Documentary | Part 1, and I felt compelled to reach out. The depth, care, and courage you brought to this subject are nothing short of remarkable. You have shed light on an often-sensitive topic with a balance and respect that not only educates but also inspires. Your storytelling doesn’t just inform; it builds bridges, fosters empathy, and invites viewers into a conversation that is too often brushed aside. This documentary isn’t just a piece of content-it’s an invaluable contribution to understanding and unity. I eagerly await Part 2 and thank you for your dedication to meaningful, impactful work. Bravo!
i fully agree w you here!
there will no unit at all I guarantee that there would be bigger fight between sunni and shia and sunni will be successful inshallah need Hadith from Alh Sunnah books I will provide you
I am sunni Muslim par aap ki is tahkeek say mujhe and Meri family ko Pata Chala hum kitni bari gumrahi main thy. And Ahlebait (a.s) hi asal rah e nijaat hain. Thank you @mooroosicity
Lucky to be Saved from the Wrong Path and Welcome to the Path of Peace and Blessing Pure Islam. 💚
@EagleEye.1200 JazakAllah brother
Kisi bhi Sahabi ki niyyat pr shak krny ka matlab ye hy k Huzoor (SAW) Maazallah Sahaba ki tazkiye e nafs ni kar paye...
Dusri r sab sy imp bat ye hy k Sahaba k bary me ghalat ghuman ya unke par shak krny sy pura ka pura deen e mashkook ho jata hy jo k asal me bht bari gumrahi hy...
Allah Ta'ala hamein seedhy raasty par chalaye rakhy
@@Faran_Ahmed to main nay kab sahaba ko bura kaha bhai. Hamay to Ahlebait (a.s) ka follower banna hai. Jin say bibi Fatima (a.s) naraz Gai woh Meray liya Sahaba hai hi nhi qabiz hain. And Jin say mola Ali (a.s) nay Jung ki woh to hai hi jahanumi.
@@HadiandHiba
May Allah give you hidayah...
People Can Never Digest Reality and Logical Reasoning 💯
Great Work ❤️
34:00 Ali Moula = Ali Master / Leader ❤
❤ Exactly...!! 💯💯
No doubt 💯%
Ali = Companion of Rasoolullah s.a.w and Ahle bayt.
❤❤❤❤❤💯💯💯💯💯
If Shia Sunni follow the same religion then why don't they intermarry. In fact muslim men prefer to marry Sanatani girls in India rather than their own sects. Even Sanatani girls choose mostly muslim men as their boyfriends and husbands.
man i am crying right now i am shia but my best friend not just a friend he is my brother and he is sunni bhai apny dil may jaga bana li isfitno k dor may lazmi hain ki ap jesa ek banda ho and engr ali mirza bhai jesa yr apna jis tarha story telling ki asa lagraha thai ki ya saray manzar mery samnay horahay hain or love u bhai ki sunni humary bhai hain may totally dil say respect karta sunni ulama or sunni bhaio ki and we have to be proud ki ❤hum sab hazarat muhummad saw k umati hain love you all and be positive❤
Ismen koi Shaq naen Beshak Bhai Hum ShiaSuni Aik hen. ❤
لا فتح الا علی لا سیف الا ذوالفقار ♥️
Ya Ali Madad❤
@@aly_hayder05 Hazrat Ali ko peda krny waly ALLAH sy madad q nahi mangty bro? Reason kia hy
Baghair ishqe Ali Zindagi fana hastam❤️❤️❤️@@umerfarooq-ef3fy
@@umerfarooq-ef3fy Aj tak Ali se masla he tum logo ko
Bar Omar lanat @@umerfarooq-ef3fy
born to a sunni family, Alhamdulillah Allah jee gave me enough courage to denounce the faith which was imposed by the islamic establishment on common people (definitely sunni Islam) and embrace the ultimate truth (shia Islam). I couldn't bear the hypocrisy in my believes. Though it was hard to accept the reality over my personal likenesses as a sunni muslim, but Alhamdulillah I did it. All praises to Allah jee for showing me the path of RasulAllah SAWW and his Ahle Bayt AS ❤
اپنی ذاتی پسند پر اللہ جی کی مرضی کو ترجیح دینا ہی اصل دین ہے۔۔
So you became shia..so sad .. have you seen many non muslims became muslim..every day ..but no one is going in religion of shia muslim...every one of them chose sunni islam ..... because Allah know what is better for them ...
MashaAllah!
lol 🤣🤣🤣🤣
There is no sunni and shia Islam Only Islam 🙏🏻.....
You are still blind if you consider yourself shia or sunni. Try becoming a Muslim first which you failed
In an era where vulgarity and scandalous rhetoric are labelled as "content"; In a country where millions of users consume and prefer that type of content; and where asking difficult questions is discouraged in favour of complacency this truly is a commendable effort. More power to you Taimoor and I hope we get to see more of this type of content by others as well!
Mooroo, believe me or not, whatever I've researched in my around 30 years of life 🧬 you summarized it in 30+ minutes, amazing Bro, you always amaze by your content. Allah Pak apko jaza e khair ata kare, Amin 🕋🤲
As a Shia Muslim and Student I want to appreciate you for your unbiased and research based informative documentary ❤
as a shia not muslim you are not muslims ok
I was born in a Sunni family and followed the Sunni faith. During the pandemic era, I started listening to the lectures of Shaykh Hassan Allahyari on UA-cam and verified the information through books. This led me to become a Shia, Allahmdulillah, that I now believe in Imamate and follow the Ahlulbayt (a.s.) ❤
الهم صل علی محمد وآل محمد
Same here but after that I became Quranic Muslim..bcoz both sects are misguided...any history is false
@@user-et1vz2ru6lwatch shaykh hassan allahyari's lectures, it will help you to understand islamic history
@@user-et1vz2ru6lQur'aanic Muslim ho tou Ali(as) he Imam huay aapke.
You need to get psychiatric attention, Motherfucker .Shia are disgusting.
@user-et1vz2ru6l you must also get fucked .So,you mean to say Muhammad saw said nothing in his life .
Maula Ali is greatest after Maula Muhammad ❤
Where do you place all the Prophets of Allah then?
@@waqasr786After the All Imams Starting from Imam Ali to Imam Mahdi and more when Imam Mahdi will Arrive they will Lead the Prayers and Prophet Essa will also
offer Prayers behind Imam Mahdi.
A Very Good initiative by Mooroo! Try to make more videos on current affairs with your unique touch of analysis! We really love it!
MORO! WHAT A BEAUTIFUL WAY TO DISCUSS. Amazing story telling. Excellent work, We are waiting for more videos! ❤
Its true that Unbiased stories carries more truth!
Alhumdullilah shia Muslim Mola Ali As k chanay walon ki khair
mut''ah chahne walon pe azaab
@@alvi957 Kabhi ye dekho ke mutah ke limitations kia hai, kon kar sakh ta ha aur kon nahi kar sakh tah. Aur sahi jaga se pard
Astaghfirullah. You are munaafiq. Try becoming only muslim
یہ متعہ کو برا کہتے ھیں اور ان کے بڑے مسیار کو جائز سمجھتے ھیں یہ بھڑوے خود مسیار کی پیداوار ھیں😂
@@alvi957 israel ka sath dene musalman kehlane walon pe dugna azaab
Baad e Khuda, baad e Nabi SW, Sab sy bara Ali AS.
ali r.a
Ya ali a.s
Abu Bakr 🗿
Umer 🗿
Usman 🗿
Ali 🗿
Those who compare 🤡
AlhamdulliAllah proud to be Shia of Imam Ali (a.s) ❤❤❤
magar musalmaan na ban paya tu munafiq
Alhamdullilah Proud to be a Ummati of Prophet Muhammad Saww and the servent of Ali RA ❤
The actual shia of imam ali are very rare
Very true
@@tahahaider5836
Phala Allah phir Muhammad S.A.W OR phir Hazrat Ali R.A Phir Iman Hassan Or Husain R.A
ماشاءاللہ مورو بھائی۔ بہترین کام ۔ اللہ ہم سبکو فرقہ واریت سے نکل کر ایک مسلمان بننے کی توفیق دے۔
36:53 Rasool e khuda ka hukam na manana mamooli bt h???? hats off to those who belive👏
Shias have nothing to do with Islam
what are your thoughts about the time of treaty of hudaibiyah when Ali (RA) refused to erase the word 'RasulAllah' even though the Prophet (SAW) commanded him to do so? You cant pick emotions and intentions just from mere text. As Muslims we believe both incidents occurred out of respect of our beloved prophet Muhammad (SAW). Also, this video is a bit off from some details, according to authentic sources this pen and paper incident happened on Thursday and Prophet (SAW) died on Monday and during which he also got better on Saturday iirc. He could have written it or said it later if it was that important.
what are your thoughts about the time of treaty of hudaibiyah when Ali (RA) refused to erase the word 'RasulAllah' even though the Prophet (SAW) commanded him to do so? You cant pick emotions and intentions just from mere text. As Muslims we believe both incidents occurred out of respect of our beloved prophet Muhammad (SAW). Also, this video is a bit off from some details, according to authentic sources this pen and paper incident happened on Thursday and Prophet (SAW) died on Monday and during which he also got better on Saturday iirc. He could have written it or said it later if it was that important.
@@fatguy9040 great reply dear, they just follow their desires to change the truth, so that they could feel better about it
@@fatguy9040 You can't compare two different thoughts...At first Imam Ali a.s is (Masoom) and Masoom don't make mistake's. If you have some knowledge! And secondly read again treaty of Hudabiyah you will get ur answer.
"Who says to whom!"
waiting for second part . God bless you , you made this video with so much respect , thankx for making this Documentary for all of us .
Your video made my Shia beliefs more Strong .Thanks a lot!
Proud to be Shia
Well mu'ta is wrong. Isn't it?
@@NarutoAmv-125what about msyaar😁
@@KQuiz-bc2oo what's that? See I consider myself an open container for knowledge. Please elaborate anything yk
@@NarutoAmv-125 don't know, let's ask Asma bint e Abubakar for this guidance
Ok Khatmal
I'm Sunni Pashtun Muslim from Balochistan n have my Shia homies in Skardu. The best people I've ever met in my life.I've visited Skardu, been at their homes, never ever felt something odd. Them folks treated me like one of em. Wishing love but nothing to everyone around. Religion n faith is a persona matter to everyone, we should keep it at home(with us) when we go outside. Thats how we're gonna make this world a peaceful n liveable ❤
Broo Check SURAH TAHREEM ki jo start wali aayat hea wo kis mowy py Nazil huii read urdu TRANSLATION.
My dear pashton brother please arrange a channel for pushton brothers to tell them real Islam because mullas had exploited pushton very much even than in non ending fighting between them and others mulla is involved every where.
pashtoon*
@@aeymed There is a great need to deliver tachings of Ahlebait (A.S) to pashtoon brothers because their mullas has introduced them bano ommyia due to which pashtoon tradition became blood shedand pashotoon community has not came out from this circle.
Sorry brother if my any word had hurt you.
Mashallah very informative and sensitive topic. I am Sunni and very sad that people did not provide pen and paper to Profit Muhammad SAW. 😢 Moula Ali Haq Haq Ali
You are not sunni. You are shia in disguise
Abay jaa na fake waqiya hai yeh jao matam karo jakay
@@technologyspotlight254
Jo sach ka saath deta hy ushay shia hi kaha jata hy..
@@kumailn7662 han bs ye zakiro k ratte Rataaye jumle bol lo. Aqal to he nahi
@@technologyspotlight254
Zakirun ne sunni kitabein likkhin hyn?? Aur ye zakir hi nhi Aalimun nai munazray kar lye, aur kahi huq pakar gumrahi chorkar huq k rasta par agaye..
Tm jese zidd k aqeeday rakhnay walay, jo abao.ajdaad ne sikhaya bus ushi par chalay arhay ho, ... Lols
I am a Sunni, but after reading After the Prophet by Hazleton, I realized it was mostly about political power than the religion. Especially the event at Ghadeer. Maula Ali would have been the successor after the Prophet (SAW). The course of history would have been so different.
ok can you care to explain how?
@@gildartsclive9003 Have you read the book?
حق آشکار ہو کر رہتا ہے
@@saliafzal why should i bother when you are here to explain.
ofc i know the history, its just your ignorance which is shining.
@@gildartsclive9003Well it doesn’t seems like you know the history.
Bro ma bhi sunni hu likin mere khayal ma hazrat Ali jesa sahaba koi nahi likin humy sary sahaba ki respect krni chahiye❤
Salute to you 🫡🙌
Hazrat umar my hero@@Noobilegamerxd_org
Jee bas shart ye hay Agla sahabi (ra) hi ho❤
@@furryfables09 Bhai ye aap Tou Nahi bataingay kon Sahaba thay kon Nahi jub aap ki kitabain hi alag Hain Quran main bhi aap nay addition Kia hua hai ager aap baghair Takiay Kay maan lain warna Jou Sahaba Hain unki izzat Allah ne momineen Kay Dil main Rakhi hai.
Rasool Allah SAW said my Sahaba are like the Stars. Guidance is their for everyone who is willing to have.
Shias have never instigated hatred against Sunnis, But the Sunnis have always been against the Shias and today it is only the Shias who are raising their voice for Palestine and helping them.The Prophet left the Qur'an and his Ahl al-Bayt to guide the Ummah after him.
shut up ahlul sunnah is the truth shiism is just an innovation practiced by millions
As a sunni I can affirm that
@@FMQURAN-hh9cw what a shame of you saying that
Lol you on weed ig,shias has never fought any proper battle against the infidels,but always targeted the sunnis from the start,and attacked them from the back.go read history from the authentic books,rather than social media or shia zakireen😂.
Ahh ! here we go again🙄 pehlai yie sunni shia tou krna choro phir agai ki baat krna
I hope that we all unite on what the Prophet (s) mentioned:
- two weighty things: Quran and Ahleybayt and you shall never go astray
- Hazrat Umar congratulating Imam Ali on being the Maula? If Maula is a friend then didn’t Hazrat Umar take him as a friend earlier?
If you were to connect the dots without any bias, it might make sense
There are many Hadith where prophet said Abu bakar and umar . Ahl e bait and khualafa e rashideen all are jmoortant to us. Even from Shia books it’s evident that Ali ra had good relations with Abu bakar and umar ra. But their scholars have to hide it.
@ , brother, with all due respect. I wouldn’t deny the Hadith references, but the Quran explicitly mentions the elevated status of Ahleybayt on multiple occasions. The event of Mubahala and the event of cloak. (The Hadith references clearly highlight the reference of the chosen ones)
Plus, the Prophet (s) told us to follow the Quran and Ahleybayt and we shall never go astray. However, majority of my Sunni brothers aren’t even aware of this Hadith, let alone the saying of Quran and Sunnah and you shall never go astray, doesn’t even exist within the 6 Sahih books.
Don’t you think that the right of Ahleybayt is being taken away? Quran holds more precedence than the Hadiths
@@MuhammadAkbar-kc9gw, it was actually Imam Ali (a) who embraced Islam in the men category and even Engineer Mirza acknowledges this but we will find people manipulating it for the sake of it.
The event of Dawat e Zul Ashira:
***"And warn thy nearest relations."***
When this verse was revealed, the Prophet organized a feast that is known in history as "Summoning the Family - *Da'wat dhu 'l-'Ashira*". The Prophet invited around forty men from the Banu Hashim and asked 'Ali bin Abi Talib to make arrangements for the dinner. After having served his guests with food and drinks, when the Prophet wanted to speak to them about Islam, Abu Lahab forestalled him and said, "Your host has long since bewitched you." All the guests dispersed before the Prophet could present his message to them.
The Prophet then invited them the next day. After the feast, he spoke to them, saying:
O Sons of 'Abdu 'l-Muttalib! By Allah, I do not know of any person among the Arabs who has come to his people with better than what I have brought to you. I have brought to you the good of this world and the next, and I have been commanded by the Lord to call you unto Him. Therefore, who amongst you will support me in this matter so that he may be my brother *(akhhi),* my successor *(wasiyyi)* and my caliph *(khalifati)* among you?
This was the first time that the Prophet openly and publicly called the relations to accept him as the Messenger and Prophet of Allah; he also uses the words "*akhi wa wasiyyi wa khalifati*\- my brother, my successor, my caliph" for the person who will aid him in this mission. No one answered him; they all held back except the youngest of them - 'Ali bin Abi Talib. He stood up and said, "I will be your helper, O Prophet of God."
The Prophet put his hand on the back of 'Ali's neck and said:
"*Inna hadha akhhi wa wasiyyi wa khalifati fikum, fasma'u lahu wa ati'u* \- Verily this is my brother, my successor, and my caliph amongst you; therefore, listen to him and obey."
This was a very explicit statement because the audience understood the appointment of 'Ali very clearly. Some of them, including Abu Lahab, even joked with Abu Talib that your nephew, Muhammad, has ordered you to listen to your son and obey him! At the least, this shows that the appointment of 'Ali bin Abi Talib was clear and explicit, not just implied.
Quran and Sunnah is only needed . Ahl byat or Shahabas stick to these two . About being Khalifa , it was just a political post not divine so chill !!
Real thing is Aqedahs and beliefs.
Shias have modified islam very much already
@@wajeehulhussain2058 1. He refers to the Quran for guidance and in order to be not led astray. Then he says "I REMIND YOU OF MY AHLUL BAYT" not "obeying the ahlul bayt is obligatory"
2. That is a weak ahadith from all isnads. He was not congratulated.
MashALLAH, topic this sensitive , very few have courage to speak, you shaded light on this topic very beautiful, waiting for PART 2 . BRAVO bro 😍
MashaAllah, brother! Just amazing work! 🙌 It's not easy to collect such vast information from different sources, nonetheless, the hard work behind it is truly appreciated. 😊
Sunni❌
Shia❌
Muslim ✅
Exactly 💯
funny thing is scholars are against this, including our own tariq bkl
A Muslim believes only in Allah and asks for help only from Allah, and after that, the Hazrat Muhammad ﷺ is considered as the last prophet of Allah, and after that comes the rank of the Caliphs, the Righteous, and the Companions.
Sunni are not muslims sorry
U tell us what us sunni's are not Muslims? Please elaborate 😊@@sameerabbas-x1w
Very well-researched and logical video with authentic references that no one could deny.
That's the fact Shia's beliefs are clear and logical as compared to our Sunni beliefs.
Hadith Saqlain is the Testation of our Prophet Muhammad SAWW, We need to follow the teaching of the Holy Quran and Ahle beyt.
There is no comparison of Sahaba and Ahle beyt. Ahle beyt. are much superior.
Don't tell lies, shias rely on liars of koofa for their hadith transmissions
so what iska mtlb ama ayesha r ashabe pr bkwas krne pr chup rhy ham ajeeb me ajtak kabi ahlebait ya sahaba ka mqam pr kami nai laya mgr mazrt ke sth kch shia dst or log janta jo inthae ghtya bkwasat krty ama ayesha or ashab pr munafiq kahi ke dil krta sar phar do in ghtya lgo ko baz nai aty bkwasat r gustakhi se
only you can put it together in such a beautiful way, very insightful and knowledgeable, eagerly waiting for more parts. Great work! impressive as always
It is the first time ever that i heard something worthy on this topic... JazakAllah, you are truly doing an amazing work, please keep it up.
1. Incident at Ghadeer Khumm
Event Overview:
It raises the question: how can one argue that the Prophet (SAW) did not appoint a successor when, 40 days before his passing, he gathered thousands of Companions (Sahaba RA) at Ghadeer Khumm after his Farewell Pilgrimage? Was such a large gathering merely for companionship, or did it serve a greater purpose? Here, the Prophet (SAW) raised Ali’s (AS) hand and declared, “For whomever I am Mawla, Ali is also their Mawla.” Many interpret this as a direct indication of Ali’s (AS) leadership, highlighting that the Prophet (SAW) held greater authority over the Muslims than they held over themselves, and thus bestowed that authority onto Ali (AS). Can it truly be said that the Prophet (SAW) assembled the Sahaba at Ghadeer simply to call Ali (AS) his friend, or was it to declare a successor?
References:
Musnad Ahmad (Hadith 946): Declaration at Ghadeer Khumm.
Sunan Tirmidhi (Hadith 3713): Ali (AS) as Mawla.
Mustadrak al-Hakim (Hadith 4576): Ghadeer Khumm event.
Sunan Ibn Majah and Tafsir al-Tha’labi for similar narrations.
2. Unique Virtues of Hazrat Ali (AS)
Virtues and Qualities:
The Prophet (SAW) repeatedly emphasized Ali’s (AS) unmatched virtues. Ali’s bravery, knowledge, and piety were celebrated in sayings such as, “I am the city of knowledge, and Ali is its gate” (Sunan Tirmidhi, Hadith 3723). It is clear from many narrations that no one shared Ali’s (AS) unique virtues in bravery, wisdom, and taqwa (piety). His roles and attributes earned him the unique designation as a father figure to the Ummah, reinforcing the Prophet’s message at Ghadeer Khumm and beyond.
References:
Sunan Ibn Majah (Hadith 118): Ali’s bravery and knowledge.
Sahih Muslim (Hadith 2404): Ali’s unique status.
Jami at-Tirmidhi (Hadith 4087): Prophet’s acknowledgment of Ali’s virtues.
3. Saqifa and Leadership Selection
Context and Ahl al-Bayt Absence:
If Abu Bakr (RA) was indeed chosen by the Prophet (SAW) as his successor, why did the Saqifa meeting occur? Saqifa involved only a select few individuals (5-6), and notably, none of the Prophet’s family (Ahl al-Bayt) were present. Why were they not included? Instead, key Companions prioritized the selection of leadership over the funeral preparations for the Prophet (SAW), leaving the Prophet’s family to prepare his body. This raises questions: if the Prophet (SAW) had appointed Abu Bakr (RA), why wasn’t that decision unanimously accepted without the need for the rushed meeting at Saqifa?
References:
Tarikh al-Tabari (Volume 9): Details of Saqifa.
Sirah Ibn Ishaq: Examines the gathering’s hurried nature.
Tabaqat Ibn Sa’d: Background on Saqifa participants.
4. Incident of the Pen and Paper (Hadith al-Qirtas)
Event Description:
During the Prophet’s (SAW) final illness, he requested pen and paper to write a will that would prevent any future misguidance. However, Umar (RA) reportedly intervened, saying, “The Book of Allah is sufficient for us,” which led to disagreement among those present, and the Prophet (SAW) ultimately chose not to dictate the will. This incident, known as Hadith al-Qirtas, left some feeling that the Prophet’s (SAW) intended message was not fully delivered.
References:
Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 114, 4431): The incident of the Prophet’s request.
Sahih Muslim (Hadith 1637): Umar’s response during the incident.
5. Absence from the Funeral of the Prophet (SAW)
Context:
Instead of attending the Prophet’s (SAW) funeral, several prominent Companions, including Abu Bakr (RA) and Umar (RA), were engaged at Saqifa discussing leadership, prioritizing this over the Prophet’s burial. This prioritization of leadership over the Prophet’s final rites is often questioned and debated.
References:
Ibn Sa’d’s Tabaqat (Vol. 2): Details on the funeral.
Tarikh al-Tabari: Describes the proceedings and absence at the funeral.
6. Bravery on the Battlefield
Ali’s (AS) Bravery:
Ali’s bravery, demonstrated in numerous battles, remains unparalleled. Narrations describe instances where other Companions, including Abu Bakr (RA), Umar (RA), and Uthman (RA), reportedly retreated during battles, while Ali (AS) consistently displayed courage, especially at Khaybar. Where can it be shown that Abu Bakr (RA), Umar (RA), or Uthman (RA) displayed such bravery in any battle? Historical records even mention instances of fleeing, which contrasts sharply with Ali’s (AS) reputation as a fearless warrior.
References:
Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 3702): Ali’s role in battles.
Sahih Muslim (Hadith 2407): Reference to Ali’s bravery.
Sunan Abu Dawood: Accounts of battlefield conduct.
7. Legal Dispute Over Fadak (Inheritance)
Dispute with Abu Bakr (RA):
Fatima (RA) requested the inheritance of Fadak, but Abu Bakr (RA) declined, citing a narration that prophets do not leave inheritance. Fatima (RA) even went to court, where she was reportedly treated disrespectfully, and her claim was ultimately rejected. This decision has been widely scrutinized and remains a point of contention.
References:
Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 4240, 4241): Fadak and inheritance.
Sahih Muslim (Hadith 4471): Abu Bakr’s ruling on inheritance.
8. Bid’ah (Innovations) Introduced by Umar (RA)
Examples of Innovations:
Taraweeh in Congregation: Umar (RA) reintroduced Taraweeh prayers in congregation, which the Prophet (SAW) had discontinued after a few nights. Such actions by Umar (RA), including other innovations, are frequently debated.
Compilation of the Quran: Initiated by Abu Bakr (RA) and later standardized by Uthman (RA), the Quran’s compilation into a single text was unprecedented during the Prophet’s time.
References:
Sahih Bukhari (Hadith 2010): Umar’s reintroduction of Taraweeh in congregation.
Sahih al-Bukhari (Hadith 4987): Compilation of the Quran.
9. Caliph Uthman’s (RA) Governance and Alleged Favoritism
Appointments and Exile of Critics:
Uthman (RA) faced accusations of favoritism for appointing Banu Umayya members to key positions, including individuals previously expelled from Medina by the Prophet (SAW). Uthman (RA)’s administration reportedly exiled Companions such as Abu Dharr al-Ghifari for criticism. Many argue that if Saqifa hadn’t taken place, the power granted to the Banu Umayya might have been prevented, which could have spared the Prophet’s family from later injustices.
References:
Tarikh al-Tabari: On appointments and favoritism.
Kitab al-Maghazi by al-Waqidi: Mentions of Abu Dharr al-Ghifari’s criticisms and exile.
If anyone needs to be appointed as a successor the right time was hijjat ul wida where everyone was present and the last imp khutba wa given unlike ghadeer with minimal gathering when they were going back to Madina. It has a history of why it was given and people who have doubts about Ali for certain things it was the answer for them. If Allah needs to appoint the prophet's family to be the leader after them Hazrat Abbas was the choice then or if you talk about son then Allah gave the prophet a son to lead after him. In both cases your assumption relating Ali to the caliph after propjet doesn't stand. At saqifa the leader of the ansar and muhajreen appointed Abubakr and who else is better then them appointed Abubakr as history tells us there are worst situations where a caliph was appointed by the killers of the old caliph.
Relating favoritism Ali did appoint his family member and the nominated killers of caliph to the key positions.
your opinion doesn't have any importance when you have no references on your verdict @@SheikhUsman545
@lulu22-b4j if I show you the word maula for any other then ? From my books ? Ali did. The same by refusing Muhammad pbuh when he was instructed to remove the prophet name from a paper
@lulu22-b4j and now with what Ali did Umar and Ali both are in the same situation not obeying the prophet. For him was the Hadith Fatima mere Jigar Ka tukra hai when he was Marrying the daughter of the enemy of Prophet. So ur so called assumption will fit in both cases for Ali and for Umar
@@SheikhUsman545Jahunnam ka petrol hou ap, Munafiko aur jhooti kitaabo ko defend kartay hou
Quran o Ahlebaiet hi Aasal Islam hai yah hi Nabi ka Farman hai.
speechless.... finally someone took the initiative to preach the Islam to younger generations through new medium as well.... hats off to you mooroo and more power to you
My god Taimoor bhai. This is your magnum opus. I cannot emphasize enough how proud I felt watching this video.
This is by far the best topic you've ever tackled on this channel. I'm in awe of your story telling.
Allah apko or kamyabi de. Please iss topic par or bhi zyada videos banao.
i am sunni but i love my shia brothers.❤
@@muhammadzubair4112 you are actually shia and pretend sunni and post this comment nowadays shia are doing this but sunni reject them in everywhere 😔
Same here Sunni and love Shias.
Love you bro
Yeah bro it doesn't really matter to me, my wife is shia, I'm sunni, we're happy with each other
@syedtaqi6005 shia kpr hy 😂
As a person who is sunni i cant belive people compare Ali with Umer Usman or Abu Bakr. ALI (RA) is way ahead of them.Hazrat Ali shared the same blood as prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Ali was the son of the man who raised Hazrat Muhammad(PBUH). Ali was the 2nd person to accept islam. Ali was raised by prophet muhammad and hazrat khatija. Hazrat Ali never worshipped an idol, even before revelation revealed itself. Holy prophet was the one who raised,and trained Ali. Holy prophet was like afatherly figure to him. Ali was ready to sacrifice his life for Holy Prophet. ali was given the most precious thing Prophet had that is Hazrat Fatima(RA). He was the father of those boys who used to ride on prophets back Hassan and hussain. Ali was given the flag in khybar where prophet said This flag wil be given to the person who is loved by Allah and the holy prophet. It was said about Ali that who considers me their mollah then Ali is also their mollah. In the battle when everyone ran away Ali was there to protect islam and guard Hazrat Muhammad (SAW). It was about Ali that you are to me how haroon was to musa. When prophet went away from this world to jannah, it was ali and hassan and hussain who carried his holy body to the grave and for janazah.While other Sahabi were busy doing politics and choosingeho would become leader, rather then taking part in prophets janazah. Prophet said dogs would bark at my wife and she would be on the wrong side. This is about Hazart Ali vs Muawiah battle where Hazrat Ayesha sided with Muawiya. Prophet said amaar would be killed by a baghi( rebellious) group amar would call them towards islam but this will choose hell. Amar was killed by muawiyas army of whom Ayesha (R.A ) was part of. But Hazrat Ali treated Ayesha R.A with same respect and dignity and sent her safely to makkah. And Hazrat ayesha May Allah bless her accepted her mistake. And i am not writing this comment to degrade any sahabi whatsoever but to deliver truth. Sahabis did alot of mistakes.
Kya baat hai sir !!
This comment should be pinned to the top of this chat.
Your opinion is totally perfect!👍
Dil jeet liya Ma Sha Allah ❤
MashaAllah, Nice illustrations bhai.
Bro there is no comparison. All 4 are equal
Beautifully explaned. Didnt skipped a single second. Please continue part 2. Waiting for that.
Same
Mooroo, you are truly a genius and most amazing at content creation - the quality of your analysis, references and detailed neutral pov on such a delicate topic is phenomenal.
I've known about most of these incidences but thank you for explicitly explaining them with reference - especially The Waqiah e Qirtas.
Thank you for your hardwork.
Your video sparked the bulb inside me. I Think The Shias Are on the right side.
JUST ANSWER ME THIS IS IT NOT WRONG TO TALK BAD ABOUT COMPANION OF MUHAMMAD SAW
@@Agent-wf8go Define what makes a person a companion 😂
@@alixhussain786 Nabi S.A.W has defined who is the companion
Narrated Ibn `Abbas:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "If I were to take a Khalil, I would have taken Abu Bakr, but he is my brother and my companion (in Islam).
~ Sahih al-Bukhari 3656
They are except some of them think Ali ibn Abi Talib still help people and say Ali Madad. This is where they are challenging God. This is no different from ghos pak madad etc.
@@Agent-wf8goyes. This is where they are wrong as well
"1 Khuda
2 Raastay"
Is such a powerful line to summarize the Shia Sunni issue 🫡
@@adeelmalik2848 صراط مستقیم کے علاوہ بہت سارے راستے ہیں دوست۔ اللہ کی طرف ایک ہی راستہ جاتا ہے اس کی تلاش کرنا سب کی اپنی زمہ داری ہے
Even in the End Hazrat Muhammad S.A.W think about us. That Allah forgive those who came after me 🥺❤❤🩹
They are quite biased and only cherry pick arguments, due to their hatred of Islam and also favouritism by enemies of Islam.
SubhanAllah! Listening to this has torn my heart and brought tears to my eyes. My whole body is overwhelmed with goosebumps, and my soul feels deeply moved. May Allah bless you and guide us all on the straight path. Ameen.
@moorsicity, as a follower of Shia faith, Thank You! Not for just shinning light on a very important topic, but also for being well versed in our ideology. Most of our ideas are misrepresented in Sunni main stream world, and leads to confusion among Muslims.
One question, can you also list out the Shia source and scholars you’re using? I would recommend Dr. Ammar Nakshwani as a great source for Shia belief system.
Thanks, and looking forward to part 2 :)
I spent the last 2 years studying the same. I look forward to the next video in the series ❤
This video is an absolute gem ✨️
@@JayZ95 Salaam, I can help if you really want something from Qur'aan. On this topic. (behamdillah)
Ya Allah, Ya Muhammad, Ya Ali ❤
Allahumma Salli Ala Muhammad wa Aal e Muhammad
One and only ya Allah qul hu wallah hu ahad Allah hu samad❤
@@ZainMustafa-i9w Allah k piyary Rasool or Rasool k piyary Ali
@@CS06-202RAYYANMUHAMMADKHAN lantiyo agay darod shreef ap ky bap ny purna hy darood pura para karo kutooo
Mooroo i really appreciate your efforts I'm watching this with mine dado and she said "i was hooked up till end i really enjoyed it. May allah bless this child"🙏 thanks mooro for such an amazing content where we can revive the lost bond with our elders as well.❤❤
har door me Etihas Gawah k Ehl E Tashi Ne he Islam k lye qurbaniyan dee hy .. Proud to be Shia ❤️
Han Palestine mai to shia hi maar rahe hai 😂
Thank you for sharing content on such an important topic. I’d like to point out a couple of issues with the thumbnail that might unintentionally misrepresent Shia and Sunni beliefs. The current thumbnail seems to show a comparison between the shrines of Hazrat Ali and Hazrat Muhammad (PBUH), but this could be misleading. Both Shia and Sunni Muslims deeply revere Hazrat Muhammad (PBUH) as the Prophet of Islam, so placing 'Shia' on one and 'Sunni' on the other doesn’t accurately reflect the shared respect both groups have for him.
Additionally, Shia beliefs generally hold that Hazrat Ali’s actual tomb is in Najaf, Iraq, not Afghanistan. Using the Shrine of Ali in Mazar-i-Sharif could lead to confusion. I’d recommend revisiting the thumbnail design to better represent these views and avoid any unintended implications. Thank you for considering this feedback, and I appreciate your work on this important subject.
100 percent agree
That's a very strong point and needs to be considered immediately
I had the same observations
Proud to be among Shian e Ali A.S❤
Asalam u Alaikum Taimoor,
Buhat shukriya Ali bhai ki video link share karne k liye. Hadees e Ifk unhone buhat ache aur wazeh tareeke se samjhai hai. Aap ki koshish bhi achi thi aur yakeenan apki neeyat bhi buhat saaf hogi lekin aap k andaz e bayaan se sansani si create horahi thi kiyoon k mein is waqiye k baaray mein ziada jaanta nahin tha.
Jazaak ALLAH Khair
Mooroo Never Dissappoints . i mean what a documentary man. The Visuals and details that have gone into it jus amazing. waiting for the part 2 . ❤❤
Love your efforts Mooroo bhai ❤
Bagh e fidak? Wala mamla bhi discuss krna tha apko wo bhi eik main reason ha shia sunni mei
But no hate well done mooroo bhai ♥️🤜🏻🤛🏻
Yes you are right, he needed to put all the reasons regarding this conflict.
The Prophet said, "Our (Apostles') property should not be inherited, and whatever we leave, is to be spent in charity."
@@Hamza-iv9yiRead Quran!
@@Hamza-iv9yi and they have right to occupy Bagh e Fadaq what a hypocrite
@@Hamza-iv9yiwah bachayy aagye aap yeh BAAT lyy kr woh nabi Paak nay os jagah ya Zameen kyy liye bola hai kyy jis pr Muslims ka khoon baha ho phr Fatah hoi hoo ya os pr Jang kr kyy Fatah Kiya ho yeh jagah nabi Paak ko milli thii Jang Khyber kyy baad or is KY baad NAHI Paak almost 4 saal zinda rahay agr ummat ko deni hoti tou khud dyy detay simple yeh bachon wali batein hamein na sunaya kroo khud jaa kr parhoo pehlay 😂
So well presented Mooroo !! Kudos
Good Video.
I'm Convert Sunni To Shia
Phir petnay k irada ha ya petwanay ka 😂
@ZainMustafa-i9w matlab???
when ever we face disagreement among each other we should turn back to Allah and his messenger
Allah and his Messenger or even Abu bakr or Ali did not say that we are Shia or Sunni because they have read the Quran
only call yourself Muslim that's it
"And who is better in speech than one who invites to Allah and does righteousness and says, 'Indeed, I am of the Muslims.'" - Quran 41:33
"And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided..."
- Quran 3:103
"And strive for Allah with the striving due to Him. He has chosen you and has not placed upon you in the religion any difficulty. It is the religion of your father, Abraham. He named you Muslims before [in former scriptures] and in this [revelation] that the Messenger may be a witness over you and you may be witnesses over the people. So establish prayer and give zakah and hold fast to Allah. He is your protector; and excellent is the protector, and excellent is the helper."
- Quran 22:78
"O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result." - Quran 4:59
You first convert to islam😅
@@mcwholesalecompany aj kl shia social media pr ... Be like
Me deobndi hu lkn shio ko kafr nai manta.
Me phly sunni tha ab shia hun
😂 Yagudi chaly
Deep insights and well Researched Video! Thank you for bringing clarity and depth to such an important topic .Always a fan of your content-truly inspiring 🙌✨
Looking forward to more content like this!
I love the quality of the words you use to explain this.
It's good to have different opinion on history but we should neither fight nor kill each others.
Rightly said ❤
Well done, Mooroo. In fact, much better than I was expecting. One thing I wish you had mentioned related to the Mutah portion of your video. The last abrogation of the permissibility of Mutah was done by Hazrat Umar - not in the life of the Prophet - and this is why it is not accepted by Shia Muslims.
واضح طور پر دو جگہ پر رسول اللہ نے اپنا وصی و جانشین قرار دیا تھا ایک دعوت ذوالعشیرہ پر جب اپنے قریبیوں کو اسلام کی دعوت دی تھی اور کارخیر میں مدد کی درخواست کی تھی اور کہا تھا کے جو میری مدر کریگا وہ میرا وزیر، میرا خلیفہ اور میرا جانشین ہوگا اور تینوں دفعہ حضرت علی نے لبیک کہا تھا کہ میں اپکا مددگار ہوں تو اسکے بعد رسول اللہ نے حضرت علی کو اپنا خلیفہ و جانشین بنایا تھا اور دوسری دفعہ حجۃ الوداع سے واپسی پر خم کے مقام پر من کنت مولاہ فھذا علی مولا کہہ کر حجت تمام کر دی اور سوا لاکھ صحابہ کے مجمعے میں علی کو اپنے مثل مولا کا درجہ دیا تھا۔ اب بھی اگر لوگ بغض میں آنکھیں بند کریں تو انکی قسمت
Sorry to say bhai Dunia chand per phonch gae or hum 1400 sal pehly Huey faislon ko ghalat or shai sabit karny per truly Huey hain. Jin hastiyon ko aap or main yeh kehny ki jasarat karty hain k in se ye ghalti hue ya phalan se ye ghalti hue, wo is Dunia se parda farma chkain hain, unko is baat se koi farq nae parta k ap kia sochty hain ya karty hain, lakin hamajn apni zaat or bahesiat e musalman ye zaror sochna chahey k hamry apsi ikhtilifat ka faeda utha kar hamary dushman hamrai ....... Bajaty hain.
Musnad e Ahmad mein hadees e khalifteen bhi hai, aur wo hadees bhi mutwatir hai sunni books mein
@@sniazi3993 aap yahan kia ker rahay hain?
Bhai Eemaan ka hissa hai yeh.
@@sniazi3993pyaray Bhai jis tarah Imam Mahdi(as) ko maanna zaruuri hai, inkaar nhi ker saktay, usi tarah ooper tak hai. Kehdo k Adam(as) ko maanna bhi zaruuri nhi, kia faeydah? Duniya chaand per pohonch gaee hai.
@@sniazi3993 دنیا چاند پر پہنچے یا سورج پر، بات یہاں حقیقت کی ہورہی ہے، آنکھیں بند کرنے سے حقیقت تبدیل نہیں ہوتی۔ تمام تاریخی کتب میں دعوت ذوالعشیرہ کے واقعے کا ذکر ہے۔ نبی پیدا ہوتے ہی نبی ہوتا ہے اسکا کسی بھی لمحے کہا ہوا جملہ نبوت کی زبان سے جاری ہوتا ہے اور نبی وحی الٰہی کے علاوہ بات نہیں کرتا۔ تو دعوت ذوالعشیرہ پر مولا علی ع کو اپنا وزیر، جانشین و وصی بنانا مرضیِ الٰہی کے سبب تھا۔ قرآن میں قیامت کے دن کے ایک وقعے کا ذکر ہے کے جب سب حساب کتاب مکمل ہوجائیگا تو کچھ لوگ جنت کیطرف جارہے ہونگے تو آواز آئیگی کے انکو روکو ان سے ایک سوال کرنا ہے اور تفاسیر میں بتایا جاتا ہے کہ وہ سوال ولایت و امامت کا کیا جائیگا۔ آپ نے ولایت و امامت کو کچھ سمجھا ہی نہیں ہے؟ حدیث رسول ص ہے کی علی ع سے محبت صرف مومن کریگا اور منافق محبت نہیں کریگا۔ علی ع وہ میزان ہے جس میں اعمال تولے جائینگے۔ سے مراد یہی ہے کے اعمال اسی کے قبول ہونگے جو علی ع سے محبت کرتا ہوگا۔ اور یہ محبت ایسے ہوگی جیسے محبت رسول اللہ سے ہے، کیونکہ جیسے مولا رسول ص ہیں ویسے ہی مولا علی ع ہیں۔ تم چاند پر پہنچو یا مریخ پر مگر آخرت کی کامیابی محمد وآل محمد ص سے محبت پر منحصر ہے۔
As a Muslim we should all condemn what his companions did with Rasool (PBUH) at his last moment!!
It is called karmo ka fal
The real divide started from Ghadeer vs Saqifa. It started in Ghadeer (Where prophet announced that After me Follow Quran and my Ahlbayt) and Sunnis rejected the prophet and followed Bani Saqifa (Where they Chose Abu Bakr and Umar instead of Ahlbayt)
Sunnis dones't accept it they think it is made by Shias
@@greenshaheen Follow Quran and Ahlbayt is a Sahih Sunni Hadith
@@ali8967 gafire khoom Didn't announced the leader.
Gadire khoom just a special stature of Hazrat Ali ra..
Islam is not any concept of monarchy. Ok
Ali ra. even accepted the bayat of My dear Khalifas.
Now, who are you here?
rafidi firka
Us time kon Shia tha? Nabi k parda k foran baad Bani saqeefa ne me voting kisne shuru krwa di k itna intazar na hua k kafan dafan ho jaye@@greenshaheen
Mooroo You are one of the Best Video Makers Out there. Amazing Just Superbly Amazing.
"جو کچھ رسول دے وہ لے لو، اور جس سے روکےتو رک جاؤ۔"
"اور خبردار رسول ص کے سامنے اپنی آواز کو اونچا نہ کرنا کہی ایسا نہ ہو کہ تمہارے سارے اعمال ضائع ہو جائے"
"اور وہ اپنی خواہش سے کوئی کلام بھی نہیں کرتا ہے"
"اسکا کلام وہی وحی ہے جو مسلسل نازل ہوتی ہے"
"اسے نہایت طاقت والے نے تعلیم دی ہے"
اب اگر کوئی کہے دے کہ قرآن کافی ہے تو اسکو میں کیا سمجھو؟
Best comment of this video❤
Proud to be Shia 😎❤ Ahle sunnat bhaio ko abh bh smjh nahe aya to dubara dekho video or smjho is may apky leye bpht isharay hain ❤
false information shia ko muslim kon manta
@abdullahshahid1422 aap k maan ny sy ya naa man nay say humaray aqeeday may koi farq nahe ata ap apni qabar may hisab dena hum apni may ..
@@abdullahshahid1422 Tareekh study ko mery bhai... Agar aj k circumstances ko dekh k agar samjh naa aaye to...
Chalyn maan lety hain shia musalman nahi ... To kahan hain apky musalman kidr chupy bethy hain... Lakho musalmano shaheed kiye jaa rahy hain Kitny begunah bachy bedardi sy shaheed kiye jaa rahy hain kahan chupy bethy hain apky sachy musalman... Agar unka drd mehsus kar raha hai to wo sirf shia hai... Apny chaand jesy leaders qurbaan kar rahy hain sirf apny musalman behen bhaio k difaa me... Un k liye b mumkin tha k baqi musalmano ki trh aankhyn band kar k andhy ghungy ban k beth jaty... Afsos hai k tm jesy choti soch walo ki aankhyn abhi tak nahi khuli... Khuda ny mohr laga rakha hy Tm jeso k dilo par
@RainaBatool-x1d o madam tareekh ap bhi parho shia ko awe non muslims ni kahty koi wajha ha na ab koi hamary nabi kareem (saw) ki biwi ko bura kahy yani hamari maa ko tu hum usy musalman many??or bhi buhat se reasons ha saboot chaye de donga
@RainaBatool-x1d shia kaha dard mahsoos kar raha wo to.matlab parast ha hamy jasy pata ni shuro se shia ny hi islam ko nuqsan puhchya or aj bhi sham iraq me kitny shia ny sunni muslim ko.qalat kiya ?? baki jo.misail iran shia ny mary ham ny bhi dekhe ha kitny bandy mary ha 🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂
واقعہ غدیر خم اسلامی تاریخ کا ایک عظیم الشان واقعہ ہے، جس میں رسول اکرمﷺ نے حضرت علیؑ کی ولایت کا اعلان کیا۔ اس واقعہ کی تفصیل میں آپ نے قرآن کے آیات کو مینشن نہیں کیا ہیں:
یہاں قرآن کے روشنی میں لکھا ہے
واقعہ غدیر خم
حجۃ الوداع سے واپسی کے دوران، جب رسول اکرمﷺ اور ان کے ہمراہ حاجیوں کا قافلہ مقام غدیر خم پر پہنچا تو اللہ تعالیٰ کی طرف سے وحی نازل ہوئی، جس میں نبی اکرمﷺ کو ایک اہم پیغام پہنچانے کا حکم دیا گیا۔ اس مقام پر نبی اکرمﷺ نے تمام مسلمانوں کو جمع کیا اور ایک خطبہ دیا۔ اس خطبے کے دوران، آپﷺ نے حضرت علیؑ کا ہاتھ پکڑا اور فرمایا:
“مَن کُنتُ مَولاه فَهذا عَلیٌّ مَولاه”
ترجمہ: “جس کا میں مولا ہوں، اس کا علی بھی مولا ہے۔”
غدیر خم سے متعلق قرآنی آیات
اس واقعہ سے پہلے اور بعد میں قرآن کی کچھ آیات نازل ہوئیں، جو حضرت علیؑ کی ولایت اور اس اعلان کی اہمیت کو اجاگر کرتی ہیں:
1. آیت تبلیغ:
• سورۂ مائدہ (5:67):
“يَا أَيُّهَا الرَّسُولُ بَلِّغْ مَا أُنزِلَ إِلَيْكَ مِنْ رَبِّكَ ۖ وَإِنْ لَمْ تَفْعَلْ فَمَا بَلَّغْتَ رِسَالَتَهُ ۚ وَاللَّهُ يَعْصِمُكَ مِنَ النَّاسِ ۗ إِنَّ اللَّهَ لَا يَهْدِي الْقَوْمَ الْكَافِرِينَ”
ترجمہ: “اے رسول! جو کچھ آپ کے رب کی جانب سے آپ پر نازل کیا گیا ہے، اسے پہنچا دیں۔ اور اگر آپ نے ایسا نہ کیا تو آپ نے اس کا پیغام نہیں پہنچایا۔ اور اللہ آپ کو لوگوں سے محفوظ رکھے گا۔ بے شک، اللہ کافروں کو ہدایت نہیں دیتا۔”
یہ آیت اس بات کی وضاحت کرتی ہے کہ اللہ نے نبی اکرمﷺ کو حضرت علیؑ کی ولایت کے اعلان کے لئے خصوصی حکم دیا تھا، اور یہ اعلان دین کی تکمیل کا حصہ تھا۔
2. آیت اکمالِ دین:
• سورۂ مائدہ (5:3):
“الْيَوْمَ أَكْمَلْتُ لَكُمْ دِينَكُمْ وَأَتْمَمْتُ عَلَيْكُمْ نِعْمَتِي وَرَضِيتُ لَكُمُ الْإِسْلَامَ دِينًا”
ترجمہ: “آج میں نے تمہارے دین کو تمہارے لئے مکمل کر دیا، اور اپنی نعمت تم پر تمام کر دی، اور تمہارے لئے اسلام کو دین کے طور پر پسند کر لیا۔”
اس آیت کے نزول کے ساتھ، دین اسلام کی تکمیل ہوئی اور حضرت علیؑ کی ولایت کو دین کا حصہ قرار دیا گیا۔
واقعہ کا پس منظر اور اہمیت
غدیر خم کا واقعہ اس بات کی نشاندہی کرتا ہے کہ رسول اکرمﷺ نے حضرت علیؑ کو اپنا جانشین اور مولا مقرر کیا، اور یہ اعلان دین کی تکمیل کا باعث بنا۔ اس واقعہ کو اسلامی تاریخ میں ایک عظیم حیثیت حاصل ہے اور اسے مسلمانوں کے لئے ایک ہدایت و رہنمائی کے طور پر جانا جاتا ہے۔
میرے بھائی حضرت علی علیہ السلام کی بہادری پر سوال مت اٹھاؤ اگر ایسا ہے پھر کیوں حضرت علی علیہ السلام نے اپنا حق نہیں مانگا کہ حضور صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے مجھے حلیفہ مقرر کیا ہے ۔۔۔۔۔
اب مجھے یہ بتائیں یہ اللہ اور علی علیہ السلام کی توہین نہیں ہے، نبوت اور امامت جب اللہ کی طرف سے ہے ، تو پھر مجھے یہ بتائیں، کیا اللہ کی دی ہوئی نبوت کوئی چھین سکتا ہے، اگر نہیں تو پھر اللہ کی طرف سے امامت کیسے چھین سکتا ہے، جواب پلیز
@@SaifRahman-w4fکیونکہ حضرت محمد ص نے امام علی کو صبر کے نصیحت کی تھی اگر امام علی جنگ کرتے تو اسلام کی بنیادیں کمزور ہو جاتی
@@mr_kabir_Afridiامام علی سے حکومت چھینی گئی تھی۔ وہ اب بھی کروڑو لوگو کے امام ہیں اور پہلے بھی تھے
@mabbas0099 ارے بھائی آپ کی مذہب میں تو خلافت منصوص من اللہ ہے اور یہاں بول رہے ہو کہ جنگ نہیں کرتے تھے چلو اگر مان بھی جاے تو اس کے بعد امام حسن اور حسین نے کیوں کیوں نہیں بولا بھائی سچے حسینی بنو یہ آپ کے لیے بہتر ہے
Been waiting for this video for so long, glad to learn this from someone intellectual like you.
Pakistanis are lacking such intellectual videos thank you Mooroo for taking this initiative plz keep making such content
@@bismabatool1816 🙄
32:22 Hmary pas Quran h Allah ki kitab r hamry liy kafi h...(Un ke jany ka intezar ho rha tha??? ta ke masnat pe betha jay khud ko jan-e-sheen e Rasool kehny waly hi un ki akhari bt nai man skhy)
Good Video
Bohat Honsla chahia hay is mozi pay baat karnay k liaya Good work
You are doing something that in pakistan no one is doing your content is really a symbol of respect you are not a molvi and you dont have that knowledge as well but you wanted to unite them well done may Allah protect you and give you health and wealth ♥️
میرے والدین دیوبند مکتبہ فکر سے تعلق رکھتے ہیں لیکن اللّٰہ کا شکر ہے کہ میں کسی خاص فرقہ یا مسلک میں شامل نہیں ہؤا میں خود کو برقہ پرستی سے پاک صرف مسلمان کہتا ہوں 😀 میرے لیے شیعہ سنی وہابی دیوبندی سب مسلمان ہیں۔
شیعہ سنی سمیت تمام فرقے مسلک خلاف قرآن ہیں ۔
اور شیعہ ہوں یا سنی سب کے سب قرآن سے نابلد نام کے مسلمان اصل میں منافق ہیں ۔
ان فرقوں کے ٹھیکیداروں نے ان فرقے مسلکوں کو اپنے پاپی پیٹ پالنے کا دھندہ بنا رکھا ہے ۔
جب تک سب نام کے مسلمان صرف قرآن کو دین کی بنیاد بنا کر خلاف قرآن جھوٹی من گھڑت حدیثوں کو اور ان کی بنیاد پر شخصیت پرستی کو ختم نہیں کریں گے ، اللہ کے اس حکم پر عمل نہیں کریں گے واعتصموا بحبل اللہ جمیعا ولا تفرقو تب تک کچھ اچھا نہیں ہوگا نہ دین کا نہ دنیا کا ☝️
Great bro. My thoughts are same. We are Muslim.
آپ مسلک اور علمی فخریہ ادرے نام کو فرقے کا نام دیا ہے جیسا کے آکسفورڈ یونیورسٹی سے پڑھے ہوۓ کو اس فخریہ نام کو میں فرقہ کہوں جیسا آپ کہ رہے ہیں ۔
@@kingman3296 we are muslim first and then anything else. Ap k lye deobandi hona zyada important ho ga lekin hmare lye muslim hona important hy.
Bhai burka or hijab ye sab molvio ki baten nahi he pyare Muhammad saw ki hadees hein agr ap apni mrzi k Deen main chalna chahte ho alag Baat he
Taimoor, recently I was looking into whether I wanted to be a Shia or a Sunni, and this video came at the exact time when I needed it the most. JazakAllah! it feels like this video was meant to reach me.
Janu videos choro agar waqie such Janana chatty ho tu Ulema.e.haq talash karoo jo deen k ilfaz k sath manany ki kefiyat bhi dil mien. Utaar dety hien.
Jese taimoor aik aam aadmi hai, min bhi hun, main bhi help ker sakta hun, ager aap chahu tou batana Isi.
جب انسان راستہ تلاش کرتا ہے خدا اس کو راہ دکھاتا ہے
اللہ آپ کو اپنی راہ ضرور دکھائے گا
@@hashirscam mujhse help le lo, sirf Qur'aan aur sihah sitta kaafi hain Shia honay k liye.
@@AliHassan-wc6nb Kindly tell me k Mola Ali As or Ahle Bait As se agar ham direct mangen or niyat hamari beshak yehi hai k Khuda hee denay wali zaat hai or ham Ahl e Bait As se mang Rahe hain q k Khuda nee hee Inko ye maqam diya hai or woh unki sunta bhi hai to is ye Karna kesa hai?
We shouldn't call ourselves shia or sunni
But we should call ourselves a muslim
Mooroo bhai, completely in awe of your content and the research put into it is extremely commendable. More power to you.
mooroo bhai i want you to add paracchinar incidents
Agreed
If shias are peacfull and only sunnis are voilent why did shia majority iran and and shia iraq had two wars killIn each other why is iran killi** muslims in syria why did shia iraq attack kuwait and killed muslims
Yes we need
💯💯💯💯
Parichinar incident were mainly due to pak army
It is such a master piece ....
Many prayers for you
I was looking for proper guidance and I got recommended by you. Just now saw Part 1 and gonna head towards Part 2 soon
Partttt 2??? Deadlyy waitinggggg…
Masoom toh woh hai jinhe lashkar e Usama ke bare Mai nhi pata aur umar ki wajah se apki tabiyat kharab se kharab huwi aur phir umar ne kaha hamare liye Quran Kafi hai qalam kagaz nhi diya jaiga 💔
This felt so real and authentic. May ALLAH help you to create a positive change in the world and especially in our society where we all can accept and respect each other. Amen.
Thank you Mooroo!
یہاں مولا علیؑ کی زندگی کے چند اہم واقعات اور رسول اکرمﷺ کے فرامین کا ذکر کیا گیا ہے، جو مولا علیؑ کی عظمت اور ان کے بلند مرتبے کو واضح کرتے ہیں:
• پیدائش خانہ کعبہ میں: مولا علیؑ خانہ کعبہ میں پیدا ہوئے، یہ واقعہ ان کی پاکیزگی اور خاص مقام کی علامت ہے۔
• رسول اکرمﷺ کو پہلی نظر میں دیکھنا: روایت ہے کہ مولا علیؑ نے سب سے پہلے رسول اکرمﷺ کو دیکھا، جو ان کے اور نبی کریمﷺ کے درمیان روحانی تعلق کی نشاندہی کرتا ہے۔
• پہلے مرد مسلمان: مولا علیؑ نے سب سے پہلے مرد ہونے کی حیثیت سے اسلام قبول کیا، جو ان کی وفاداری اور دینی عزم کو ظاہر کرتا ہے۔
• رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “حق علی کے ساتھ ہے اور علی حق کے ساتھ ہیں”۔
• ہجرت کی رات قربانی: مولا علیؑ نے رسول اکرمﷺ کے بستر پر سو کر اپنی جان کی قربانی دی، تاکہ رسول اکرمﷺ کو کفار کے حملے سے محفوظ رکھیں۔
• رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “اللہ کی راہ میں کوئی علی کی طرح جان کا خطرہ مول نہیں لیتا”۔
• بدر کی جنگ: مولا علیؑ نے بدر کی جنگ میں شجاعت کا مظاہرہ کیا اور اسلام کی فتح میں اہم کردار ادا کیا۔
• غدیر خم کا واقعہ: رسول اکرمﷺ نے فرمایا، “جس کا میں مولا ہوں، اس کا علی مولا ہے”، یہ علیؑ کی روحانی اور سماجی قیادت کا اعلان تھا۔
• حضرت فاطمہؑ سے شادی: مولا علیؑ کی شادی نبی کریمﷺ کی بیٹی حضرت فاطمہؑ سے ہوئی، جس سے خاندان اور روحانی تعلق مضبوط ہوا۔
• حسنؑ و حسینؑ کے والد: مولا علیؑ امام حسنؑ اور امام حسینؑ کے والد ہیں، جنہیں رسول اکرمﷺ نے “جنت کے جوانوں کے سردار” کہا۔
• خیبر کی جنگ: مولا علیؑ نے خیبر کا قلعہ فتح کیا۔
• رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “کل میں جھنڈا اس کو دوں گا جو اللہ اور اس کے رسول سے محبت کرتا ہے اور اللہ اور اس کا رسول اس سے محبت کرتے ہیں”۔
• علیؑ کا مقام: رسول اکرمﷺ نے فرمایا، “اے علی! تمہارا میرے ساتھ وہی رشتہ ہے جو حضرت ہارون کا حضرت موسیٰ کے ساتھ تھا، سوائے اس کے کہ میرے بعد کوئی نبی نہیں”۔
• قاضی اور عالم: مولا علیؑ اپنے علم و عدل کے سبب مشہور تھے۔
• رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “علی میری امت میں سب سے بہتر قاضی اور عالم ہیں”۔
• خلافت اور حکمرانی: مولا علیؑ نے خلافت کے دوران عدل، مساوات اور اسلامی اصولوں کے مطابق حکمرانی کی۔
• کوفہ کی مسجد میں شہادت: مولا علیؑ کو صبح کی نماز میں سجدے کی حالت میں شہید کیا گیا، جو ان کی عبادت اور دین سے محبت کا عکاس ہے۔
• رسول اکرمﷺ کا فرمان: “اے علی! تمہیں سجدے کی حالت میں شہید کیا جائے گا”۔
یہ واقعات اور فرامین مولا علیؑ کی بے مثال شجاعت، وفاداری، علم، عدل اور روحانی قیادت کو ظاہر کرتے ہیں۔
Imam is always best options for all Muslim rather than khilafat
Indeed
who are u to say this? ur opinon doesnt matter, Prophhet Muhammad saw apointed the caliphs. Are you saying he did a bad decision?
@@a7i_. Who are you to say this? Your opinion doesn’t matter. It’s your opinion that Holy Prophet S.A.W appointed caliphs.
@@ahmadkhandreshak Its not my opinon its written in sources that even the shia think are authentic
@@a7i_. I don’t think so.
Caliphs were chosen by common people not by Prophet S.A.W.
Excellent use of AI and the vdo quality is top notch and sounds are amazing eagerly waiting for part 2❤
How beautiful mooro has explained everything may ALLAH bless you brother I didn’t realise how 39min went by we really need more intellectuals like mooro🙌🏻
حدیث: کاغذ قلم دے دو۔۔۔۔۔
قولِ عمر: کاغذ قلم نہ دو۔۔۔۔۔
نبی محمد ﷺ تھے یا عمر ۔۔۔۔ کس پر عمل کرنا ہے انسان خود عقل رکھتا ہے۔۔۔
ہاں اگر وہاں سارے صحابہ موجود تھے پھر کیوں کسی نے اس بات پر زور نہیں دیا کہ کاغذ اور قلم لاؤ اگر آپ کے مطابق یہ کوئی دین کا حصہ تھا پھر آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے نعوذباللہ دین نامکمل چھوڑا ہے یا جو ہوا ٹھیک ہوا
@@SaifRahman-w4floag naferman hain. Unke Amal se Rasuul(saww) k Deen mukammal ya na mukammal chhornay ka Faisala thori hona hai.
shia ye kia kya 🤣 shia wo qufi log hain jo qarbala ma bhaag gye thy aur uzeed se dar gye thy inshallah qayamat tak matam karte rahe ge 🎉
@@AliHassan-wc6nb میں سمجھا نہیں بھائی کون نافرمان ہیں
@@SaifRahman-w4f wohi naferman hain jo kaghaz qalam dainay se rok rahay thay.
Each and every second was goosebumps. Eagerly waiting for part 2.