If you think about it, the Harmonies in all their songs are genius, even when they performed live! I love how Victoria support the lower notes with Mel B!
They don’t always lip sync. The footage of Their performance in Istanbul was actually dubbed but they performed completely live. In their Spiceworld 1998 and 2019 tours, they didn’t lip sync. They didn’t lipsync in the Christmas in Spiceworld tour either. They were only forced to lip sync for some TV performances.
There's a video on UA-cam of the mic feeds at ROTSG and they were actually singing this song live! For some reason their mics were all just on mute so you can't hear anything.
This is the album version. The vocals are edited differently on the radio/single version, in that version Mel B doesnt lead vocals, and instead the other vocals are louder and more blended in.
@@maikoltorres9991 la pregunta hasta me ofende, muero por acabar Spice y empezar con Spiceworld, es mi album favorito de ellas. Además Spiceworld está mejor distribuido que Spice, asi que es más interesante ver quien se lleva el álbum, pero solo se algo, hay una canción donde Victoria es #1 y *NO* me refiero a Spice Up Your Life. 😋
Me encanta tu trabajo. Felicidades! Tengo una duda en esta canción. En el pre-chorus qué voz hace exactamente Victoria? Y Geri? Ambas hacen la voz baja que va con Emma? No me queda claro... Gracias! :)
people, good luck! You don't have the channels to separate the voices, and therefore know the participation of each Spice in the song. These filters nullify and mask. Nothing matches the reality of what was recorded.
Siempre creí que la voz más grave era Mel B en esta canción... pero me resultaba menos "pastosa" como es la de ella... la oía algo mas suave y con más aire... y claro, era Victoria, que a la vez hace otra voz un poco más aguda.
the one who sings the melody of the song in the chorus..e.g who sings the full chorus or has the most prominent voice - (not to be confused with ad lib, belting or high harmony). The rest provides harmony vocals with higher harmonies (a few octaves higher than the melody) and / or lower harmonies (a few octaves below the melody). If everyone sings in the same note pitch or octave range, it is called unison.
You're welcome. Lets give an example for this. E.g. Viva Forever consists of 4 way harmony. Geri: lead vocal (melody) Emma: 2 layers of voice (lead and high harmony) Victoria: middle lower harmony Mel B: active low harmony Mel C: does not sing the chorus only ad lib
If you think about it, the Harmonies in all their songs are genius, even when they performed live! I love how Victoria support the lower notes with Mel B!
Yes that's true these ladies has technique on how to play their harmonies ☺️
Geri and Victoria were the lower notes.
Absolutely and the fact they did a lot of it on their own
That sustained high note during the pre-chorus....that has to be Emma. Her sweet, soft soprano really stands out.
it is. im not sure how the creator got that one confused
that high note was actually Mel C's. Emma is doing lead on that part
It was Melanie C doing that high note.
@@GabrielC_TTV Really?!?! Wow. Ok. Thanks!
The "who" note is Melanie C
I love how the adlib segment is just Mel C punching you with her voice.
Love your Channel! Please do Viva Forever vocal stems, especially for the chorus. I know Geri's harmony is in there, but it's hard to hear. Thank you!
Wow there is an insane amount of vocal mixing in this song. No wonder they always lip sync this one. It’s impossible to replicate live.
Sean R live in the spice world tour and Earls court concert
@@Joshieyspicex Earl's Court seemed live. Spice World tour had a backing track in the chorus and bridge.
They don’t always lip sync. The footage of Their performance in Istanbul was actually dubbed but they performed completely live. In their Spiceworld 1998 and 2019 tours, they didn’t lip sync. They didn’t lipsync in the Christmas in Spiceworld tour either. They were only forced to lip sync for some TV performances.
Indeed. They could never do it like the album. but earl's court was live and, to me, was a good live version of the song.
There's a video on UA-cam of the mic feeds at ROTSG and they were actually singing this song live! For some reason their mics were all just on mute so you can't hear anything.
YASS ONE OF MY FAVOURITES BOPS OF THE SPICE GIRLS!!!!!
Spice Girls you ladies are the very best and greatest female performers ever always truly enjoy your music love ya ladies always peace
Did anyone notice that this song featured Mary Pearce who was the additional singer? That was written in the sleeve of Spice album
Victoria 😍😍
I only came across these videos the other day and I’m so happy I did!😀. Keep them coming 👍🏻xx
LOVE these vids! Thank you!
So, it's Sporty that hits that high note in the pre chorus...That F#5 in the Whoooo part????
That has to be emma...100%
Yes, it’s Sporty, baby spice sings lead in that part
It’s baby spice
Who else could do that?
@@Naksi247 Emma was doing the lead for that part.
Love this so much.!! Great work. ❤️ Please do Love Thing please 🙏🙏
I love it😱❤
ly. 💙
Victoria sang the bass part on this record but Mel B is the one who sing it live in concerts. In earls court she sounded horrible
I never think victoria e geri are backs on bridge😱.And Mel b is a lead vocals 😱
Amigo , cuando mel b canta su voz sola , la voz bajo no es victoria o me parece?
This is the album version. The vocals are edited differently on the radio/single version, in that version Mel B doesnt lead vocals, and instead the other vocals are louder and more blended in.
I’m obsessed with this channel
Mel C 💛
Emma 💖
Victoria 💜
Geri ❤️
Mel B 💚
❤️❤️❤️❤️
Pensaba que Mel B cantaba todo el coro y la voz de Victoria y Emma crean la voz de ella (Mel B) a mi parecer. Exelente y maravilloso trabajo 💪❤
gracias. 💙
pues si, la verdad es algo rara las vocals de la canción. ;P
@@DDP121 También Realizaras el álbum Spice World?
@@maikoltorres9991 la pregunta hasta me ofende, muero por acabar Spice y empezar con Spiceworld, es mi album favorito de ellas. Además Spiceworld está mejor distribuido que Spice, asi que es más interesante ver quien se lleva el álbum, pero solo se algo, hay una canción donde Victoria es #1 y *NO* me refiero a Spice Up Your Life. 😋
@@DDP121 estaré esperando la distribución de partes de cada canción del álbum. Y me alegra lo de Posh, es mi favorita. Saludos ✌
@@maikoltorres9991 muchas gracias. 💙
y que interesante, la mia es baby. 💕
y ten por seguro que haré el álbum, ya voy a acabar Spice. 🤷♂️
Me encanta tu trabajo. Felicidades! Tengo una duda en esta canción. En el pre-chorus qué voz hace exactamente Victoria? Y Geri? Ambas hacen la voz baja que va con Emma? No me queda claro... Gracias! :)
An update? Can we hear all the harmonies and individual background vocals? :)
people, good luck! You don't have the channels to separate the voices, and therefore know the participation of each Spice in the song. These filters nullify and mask. Nothing matches the reality of what was recorded.
Please something with VIVA FOREVER
Apparently, a background vocalist called Mary Pearce was credited for this song according to Wikipedia. I wonder what she sang in, like which parts?
Behind mel c's adlibs in the last chorus
Wow mel b make 2 voices in chorus
Victoria is the low voice in the chorus, not Mel b
Me cuesta un poco entender el video xD No soy experto en música, por eso no comprendo tan bien lo de la distribución de partes.
No hay que ser experto
Who sang that Oh-oh! in pre-chorus? Vicki or Emma? I know it's Vicky, am i right or not?
the two sing, but the lowest note is victoria
does Mel C sing both the melody and high harmony in the chorus?
Siempre creí que la voz más grave era Mel B en esta canción... pero me resultaba menos "pastosa" como es la de ella... la oía algo mas suave y con más aire... y claro, era Victoria, que a la vez hace otra voz un poco más aguda.
Mel b is the octave lower in the chorus
my prediction is
MEL C ⚽
EMMA 🍭
VICTORIA 💎
GERI ❤
MEL B 😾
Wait this is emma with mel 0:41
is Geri + Mel C, Emma sing this part in Lead Vocals.
What is a "lead vocal"?
I understand is the base of the song. The harmonies and ad-libs are sung "around" the lead vocals.
the one who sings the melody of the song in the chorus..e.g who sings the full chorus or has the most prominent voice - (not to be confused with ad lib, belting or high harmony). The rest provides harmony vocals with higher harmonies (a few octaves higher than the melody) and / or lower harmonies (a few octaves below the melody). If everyone sings in the same note pitch or octave range, it is called unison.
@@patdrox22 thank you for the comment
You're welcome. Lets give an example for this. E.g. Viva Forever consists of 4 way harmony.
Geri: lead vocal (melody)
Emma: 2 layers of voice (lead and high harmony)
Victoria: middle lower harmony
Mel B: active low harmony
Mel C: does not sing the chorus only ad lib
at 00:45 Emma is singing. and mel b is singing the chours. this was a fail man
you have to watch the whole video
I could tell u didnt watch the whole video lol
This is wrong.
Mel C's got one *LONG* ad-lib (like Jade in "The Cure" except I'm pretty sure Mel's ad-lib is longer than Jade's)