Is the Georgian Language Banned in Abkhazia's Schools? - Abkhaz Perspective
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- Since the beginning of a new school year, schoolchildren in the Gali/Gal region of Abkhazia, where ethnic Georgians reside, no longer study in Georgian - the last, 11th, grades, which until now had such an opportunity, switched to the Russian language, thus completing the transition of the local schools to the Russian-language program, with separate Georgian language courses. Jam News brings you reporting from both sides of the issue.
Read the full article here:
jam-news.net/i...
JAMnews offer latest news about the developments in the region in five languages, reporting exclusively verified data from Georgia, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Russia, Turkey, as well as from the disputed regions of Abkhazia, South Ossetia and Nagorno Karabakh. We offer professional and impartial analysis on the major trends and developments, thus seeking to help people from different regions of the Caucasus to get to know each other better.
Do you want to stay informed? Subscribe to our newsletter: jam-news.net/c...
Find JAMnews on Facebook - / jamnewsinenglish
Find JAMnews on Instagram - / jam_news
Follow JAMnews on Twitter - / jamnewscaucasus
Subscribe to our channel - / @jamnewsinenglish
Support JAMnews - jam-news.net/s...
Abkhazia is Georgia 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
Абхазия это Абхазия
@@Федерико-щ4м🤡
Abhazya abazalarindir ❤❤❤
Semoga anak2 ini akan menjadi pemimpin negara nya kelak
I am Mexican but it makes me sad to know the enormous conflicts that exist in that part of the world, I hope one day the world will find peace.
As a neutral Mexican, I love Georgia, Abkhazia and Russia equally.
🇲🇽🤝🇬🇪🇷🇺♥️💚🤍
You can't love Georgia if you love Abkhazia, what they don't say is that the population of abkhazia before separatism had more than twice more Georgian people than "apsuan". And "apsuan" people themselves are not from the ancient Abkhazia roots, they were forced to move to abkhazian land by russia, and then they started robbing Abkhazians, now those "apsuan" people, call themselves Abkhazians, and took over the actual history of Georgia . during 90s there was a MASSIVE ethnical cleansing thanks to russias help. Remember that abkhazia is forever georgia and that Russia is not the good guy.
@@notilia man learned history in kfc
bro if you love Georgia how do you love Russia?like they occupied 20%of our land and started war in Ukraine
And I, I want to learn Abkhaz and Georgian :l
@@tea1424Abkhazia and South Osetia are independent. And if you should hate Russia because it started the war in Ukraine, then you should hate Georgia
This abhkaz it’s georgia 🇬🇪
Abkhazia is Georgia
მოვა დრო და საქართველოს ტერიტორია რომელიც გაქვთ მიტაცებული ისევ საქართველოს დაუბრუნდება მერე ნახეთ როგორ მოგექცევით მოღალატეებს
Sul male Cota Darcha proji ukakalebs abxazebs 🤣🤣🇬🇪🇺🇦💪
მაგათმა რაც ქართველებს გაუკეთეს არ შერჩებათ !
Yes Abkhazia and Osetia is Georgia support Georgia From Azerbaijan 🇦🇿🌹🇬🇪
sul chichie chmorebi iyvnen turebi chichurulad iyvnen sul kacuris da vajkacuris araferi icodnen mamachemis bidziam daaaayara sochashi restoranshi dauwyes raxac kleobebi da aman kide miaxveta stoli iseti cema
ხალხო ნუ იმუქრებით. ოკუპანტ რუსეთსაც ეს უნდა. ხომ ხედავთ აფხაზებს აჯერებს რომ მათ გარეშე ვერ იარსებებენ და რომ აფხაზეთი რუსეთმა გადაარჩინა და ჩვენგან იცავს.
Აფსუურ ენას როგორ ატენიან ამ რეპრესიებში მყოფ გალელ ხალხს.
sparsuls ?
This region of Georgia is under ongoing occupation of Russia. Now we're facing deep-rooted process of Russian imperialism & Russification process. Every empire is doomed to fail simple as that. Georgia is eternal itself...I know this & our enemies know that. გაუმარჯოს ერთიან საქართველოს!
Abkahz and Ossetia is Georgia
Love and Support Georgia
Greetings from Azerbaijan
🇦🇿✌🏻🇬🇪
@@samirtalibov37 çok teşekkür ederim canım
You are blaming Russia for forming and empire. Abkhaz people don’t want to be part of Georgia, by pushing Abkhaz to be part of Georgia, Georgia is trying to build a Georgian empire.!
@@samirtalibov37 Hey Azeri kardeş, Abhazların başına ne geldiyse Gürcüler ve Ruslar yüzünden geldi. Rus Osmanlı savaşında, Abhazlar Türkleri desteklediği için Abhazya’nın 60% Türkiye’ye sürgün edildi. Abahzya SSR Gürcü Stalin tarafından ASSR’a değiştirildi.
@@rogueprince0 Probably you're right. I believe the root causes of this date back to early ussr days. Unfortunately most of the former ussr states were formed with ethnical instability in mind. This was done so unified nationalist movements for independence were harder to form when there is not single ethnic unity.
This great, they get to learn Abkhaz, Georgian and Russian
With more than 20 languages in the caucasian region i dont know where i must begining😣😩
You cannot go wrong with the cradle of Caucasian culture. With respect to other Caucasian languages , the only language with its own alphabet and uniqueness from any other language in the world, and not defiled by "Russianification", and thousands of years of incredible literature, songs and poetry... Learn Georgian, it's not even a competition.
With nothing. These languages are very hard and spoken by a really few people. The best way is to learn Turkish and you'll be understood in Azerbaijan, or Russian and you'll be understood everywhere from Lithuania to Tajikistan
@@pwzone3132Turkish is not a language in Caucasus though.
@@theguybehindyou7418 I know, but Azerbaijani is. And they’re almost the same
Abkhazeti is Region Of Georgia 🇬🇪☦️❤️
Free abhasien meine heimat abhasien ❤
We should be United, there is no other way , we never going to recognize Abkhazia. As a autonomy in Georgia yes why not . Culture is almost same even last names same . We shuld forgive each other’s past wrongs and move forward together.
The seizure of power by the Bolsheviks following the Russian Revolution in 1917 granted Abkhazia a certain degree of cultural and political autonomy, and a bloody war, the Sochi Conflict. In 1919 the region proclaimed its autonomy and in response, in 1921, it was occupied by the Soviet army. In 1922 it became an autonomous republic, until 1931, when Stalin made it an autonomous republic within Soviet Georgia: despite its nominal autonomy, Abkhazia was in fact subject to the heavy central control of Tbilisi and a policy of assimilation. forced. Georgian became the official language, the Abkhaz language was banned and cultural rights were repressed, while thousands of Abkhazians were killed during the Stalinist
@Ethnic Nationalist these people go there to find jobs and save up a little money since most of them come from poor areas in russia or central asia, most of them dont stay there for more than a few years. thats according to my family members who live there. they have many armenian, kazakh russian and even georgian neighbors and they are some of the mst friendly people I ever met.
@@frenchfatfather blaming what happened during the soviet union on Tbilisi is stupid. During 1921 abkhazians and Georgians lived peacefully without any problems the forced Georgofication of the region is a blame of soviet government not Georgian. Just because stalin and beria were Georgians doesnt mean that what they said was the Will of the People no one asked Georgians. Blaming Georgia for these events is like blaming austria for holocaust hitler was austrian right?
@@ok5183 this wasn't the work of the soviets but it was the georgian authoroties who did it under soviet rule. georgia was an independant SSR back then with a considerable amount of autonomy from the centralised soviet state. although stalin and beria played a huge role in genociding the abkhazian people and their culture, it was mostly the work of the georgian local authoroties. this massacer of culture and language continued on until the last few years of the soviet union. abkhazians were asking for an independant SSR inside the soviet union since the death of stalin. after paitiantly waiting for more than 40 years, in 1989 the abkhazians decided to rebel against the georgians and organise their own government
@@frenchfatfather that is exactly what i am saying whoever were the "Georgian authorities" in Soviet union is irrelevant they were people placed there by kreml not by Georgians. i am repeating this Georgian people had no say in what happened to Abkhazia during the soviet union. neither did they had any say to what happened to Abkhazia during Russian empire. blaming these on Georgia is wrong however what happened during 1992 was a huge tragedy on both sides and i admit that Georgian militants did many terrible things so did Abkhaz, but that was a different time 90s in post soviet countries was a time of instability, total economical collapse and disregard of any human life this is what such a terrible system as soviet union creates. now everything is different, Georgia is trying to become a democratic country Abkhazia and Georgia has same goals. if abkhazia wants to get out of Russian sphere they should at least start negotiating with Georgia i don't see any other way.
Дай бог мир и всех благ этим ребятам!
ქართულის მასწავლებელი რო რუსულად ლაპარაკობს 🤦♂️
Gavartyi kvelas didian patarianad🤣🤣 gaumargos georgia 🇬🇪 Abkhazia is georgia
რა ქნას საწყალმა. რამე რომ დაემართოს არ უშველოს ჩვენმა ხელოსუფლებამ მყისიერად. ალბათ იცით, გალელმა ბიჭმა რამდენიმე წლის წინ აფსუების დროშა დაწვა და დღემდე ციხეშია საცოდავად მიტოვებული. არ გვინდა ჩვენი ისედაც გაუბედურებული ხალხის წიხლის კვრა.
I wish peace Between Georgians And Abkhazians from Armenia..I don't see the point of keeping Abkhazia as an independent country it can be autunomous republic inside Georgia.Abkhazians have simillar culture with Georgians Both practice Orthodox church.Unlike Armenians And Azerbaijanis who don't share any serious cultural religious aspects
Bro, Abkhazians don't even realize that they have chosen the Russians, they think they are independent and the Russians are their allies, but the Russians hold Abkhazia in their hands. The Abkhaz language exists and is officially protected. There are even studies conducted by the Georgia, but it's ignored that Abkhazians speak Russian. "They are making us forget our own language" was slandered. Why don't these people who are against the genocide talk about the genocide, especially the Circassian genocide? I would never consider myself superior to a Georgian, Abkhazian who sees me as his brother, they are my brothers, but the truth is they are not open to discussion. I am half Abkhazian and I am aware of the truth. Abkhazians think they are collaborating with the Russians and ignore what the Russians are doing to little children. What they did to children in Ukraine. It is clear that Russia has plans to reach fertile geographies for them. Abkhazians think they are free, but the Russians are taking everything from them, we don't do the same, if we did, they would not remain so silent. They always talk about conflict, but they don't know it. Georgia wasn't yet fully governed, it was like a gang country. While this conflict was happening for different reasons, the course of the issue changed with the question of who would fill the Abkhazia region. Most of them don't know what I'm talking about, they may have been brainwashed by Russian channels. They call us fascists, we protect their language, they call us fascists, we protect the history of the assimilated Laz. I don't think that we will even oppose the current flag of Abkhazia. The Crusader Flag of the past was displayed on the Flag memorial day and they forget that that flag was a gift from the King of Bagrat who united us. we didn't expel these peoples, but they expelled our people before us, they do not even have the patience to live together without saying old or children. Abkhaz man said this on social media, they can not deny the issue of conflict there is evidence. We aren't hostile to every Ossetian or every Russian.
So is Artsakh
Many abkhazians are muslim too
Abkhazia is Georgia 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
@Reator632 how abt the fact that all of the people shown in the video have georgian mingrelian last names?
Abhasien gehort Abhasien meine heimat ❤❤❤❤❤
@@envercelik8733mein georgischer bro 💯❤
მთელს გალის რაიონშია 18 ქართული სკოლაო და ამას გვამადლიან. ჯერ 400 000 დევნილი უნდა დაბრუნდეს და მერე ვილაპარაკოთ სად რა ენაზე უნდა იყოს სწავლება.
You don't need to study, you need to speak.
სასაცილოა ყველას მეგრული გვარები რო გაქვთ და ვითომ არავის ესმის ქართული
Tqveni dedebi movtyan, amtkicebt rom qartuls astsavlit da ert adamianmac qartulad situva ar tqva 😡
Rom davbrudebi abxazedshi me Vasavli kartuls magenma tu ician dedis tyvna mamis shimshili ras nishnavs.tuarada Vasavli rusi mutels anoparebuli abxazebs 💪🇺🇦🇬🇪😁
🤣🤣 xuieba nu eta Familia tqvwni dedebi movtyan
Џ
Bi lingual New generation, there architects and builders of bridges between us !
What is the difference between abkhazian and georgian language?
@@ludmilasu7752 in Georgia we have regions were they have there own language . Some of the words looks sounds like but all together is deferent . Like megrelian, svan and Abkhazian , they all from Georgian language family grup. Even culture is defrent each region .
@@iraklishurgaia7690 Abkhazian language is not kartvelian
@damnmodebadze are you banned from google ,or any information sources ? Abkhazian language is abkhazo-adygean language family
These kids from the Gali region are Mingrelians and their native language is no more Georgian than the native language of the Catalans is Spanish.
We’ll be back! ✌🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
don't worry you'll be under Russia soon
@N1kson bruh your the one having fantasies about taking back ossetia and abkhazia 💀
Kartvelians Never Forgive Never Forget We Will Take Our Historical Lands No Matter What 🇬🇪☦️❤️🦅⛰️
first there are not abkhazians there are Adyghe-circassian people (Apsuas) tribe. Second, the history of Georgia begins in 1300BC and you can see that there is no "independent" Abkhazia, these 2 pretended states are military bases of Russians, nothing more
მეცნიერები ამბობენ რომ საქართველოს სახემწიფო თითქმის სამიათას წელზე მეტი ყოფილა შემოგევლე
@@კარლომეგრელიშვილი Genacvale Dzmao Jan Yvelaferi Kargad Iqneba Bolos Gamarjveba Gvelodeba ☦️❤️
Yes. My wife is very mixed from that region. We did a full genome sequence. Her DNA matches closely with Circassian samples and Abkhaz samples.
What s the difference in language between the georgian and the abkhazian language?
big difference. 1. Abkhazians use the Cyrillic alphabet while Georgians use their own alphabet. 2.abkhazian is form the abzagi language group and Georgian is from the kartvelic language group.
@@frenchfatfather so there s no common words or common syntax between them? An abkhazian cannot understand a georgian or the other way round?
@@ludmilasu7752 We can't understand each other. As it was mentioned in the previous comment those two languages belong to different language groups.
@@ludmilasu7752 no similarity, it's like comparing Chinese and English. very common case in the Caucasus, languages or even language groups may differ from city to city. like Dagestani and Circassian for example, their bordering Russian republics but they come from totally different language groups.
@@frenchfatfather dagestani is not a language group.. There is about 57 languages in dagestan that are not mutually understood by others.. Officially the number is smaller but in reality it is greater. The caucasus has many small national groups. Georgians are a bigger group and were favoured under stalin.. Who was a georgian.. Surprise surprise..
Abkhazian and georgian are unrelated languages from two different language families the abkhazian is related to adyghe language and cannot be understood by a georgian as they sre not related. It would be like comparing norwegian to Malaysian. Nothing can be understood from the other and the linguistic rules and language structure is totally different. The early greek colonies mention both the abaza and apsyn people (apsyn is the name the abkazians use.. Abaza are another circissian tribe just north of them) genetically abkhazians are intermixed with georgians, greeks and mediterranian people where as their north caucasus brothers are not so much.. You cannot tell a georgian apart from an abkhazian.. Maybe afew more blonde or fair haried abkhazians.. But a chechen or an a circassian from the north caucasus looks many times distinct.. Abkhazians are mixed with georgians and share alot of their personality.. Where as the "pure" north caucasus tribes are much harsher and more spartan culturally.. There would be no surviving georgian settlers in a north caucascan nation if they expelled them, they would beheadedraped sold as slaves ect.. I feel south caucasus people are more messy, more emotional, more compromising and also enjoy comfort more.. Abkhazians east food like the georgians.. The north caucasus tribes eat boiled meat with their hands like the mongols.
No doubt the abkhazians culturalky would have no clash with georgians and see them as common friends but georgians lusted after their land and disrespected them and tried to wipe them out.. And for no good reason. Just greed and ego.. Not a religious or cultural clash.. Just stalins gift.. Georgians should clear their minds and think if they would like others to do this to them..
Georgian Languange Banned in Georgia's Schools ?
Abkhazia is not Georgia. Georgia is state of USA
Abkhazia is Georgia
@@giorgijioshvili9713 not, it is fact.
@@AdamIPA source?
@@giorgijioshvili9713 30 years de facto. and before that, Abkhazia was part of the USSR and Georgia was not an independent state in order to have any grounds for claims. Abkhazia was not once Georgia.
@@AdamIPA Abkhazia united Georgia in 1008 and it was part of that kingdom until 1490 do you know how many Georgian churches are there that is sadly bieng destroyed? 300 000 Georgians were forced to leave there homes but Georgian culture will never be erased from Abkhazia also nobody recognise there indepwndence lol even Belarus
Now answer me this fake news- are Georgian Orthodox priests banned in Abkhazia?
Male chamoval da mogetynebad tqveni aqotebuli abxazuri dedis muteli
ასე უნდა ზუსტად🖤
Georgians are communist colonists.. They should leave.. Or become abkhazian if the abkhazians let them...
მალე მოგადგებით აფსუებო
genacvale abaraaa
In historical context, it is essential to acknowledge that the individuals currently claiming to be Abkhazians are, in fact, Apsua people. This distinction stems from their migration to Georgia from the North Caucasus, an event known as "The Great Descent of the Mountain." The impetus for this migration was the Mongolians' arrival from the northeast. It is worth noting that a complete assimilation of the Abkhaz and Apsua people never occurred due to notable cultural differences.
Remarkably, accounts by Georgian historians from the 15th and 16th centuries shed light on the repercussions of this cultural divide. These historical records attest that valuable treasures and Christian icons, highly significant at the time, were transferred to other regions. The reason behind this relocation was the divergence in religious beliefs and cultural practices between the local Apsua people (who had already emerged as a distinct group) and the Georgians.
Supporting this notion, merchants utilizing maps from Venice during the same period consistently depict the city of Akua (known as Sukhumi in the Apsua language) situated on the northern side of the Caucasus Mountains, rather than its actual geographic location. This peculiarity can be attributed to the fact that the Apsua people referred to their capital city in the North Caucasus as Akua during that era.
As a historian, it is crucial to analyze these historical accounts and artifacts, considering their historical context and the cultural dynamics of the time. Such examination allows for a deeper understanding of the complex interplay between the Abkhaz, Apsua, and Georgian communities, shedding light on the historical trajectories and cultural identities of these groups.
Abkhazia is not Georgia. Georgia is state of USA.
Georgia it's a mean -saqartvelo
Georgia is the country but America has the state called Georgia, one is state and one is country.