Depending on where this story takes place, Vivian wouldn't have a right to keep the ring after the engagement broke off. In fact, if the receiver tries to keep the ring, the giver can take legal action to force its return.
It's a conditional gift, laws vary. In some places, it is a gift. In others, it's a token given with marriage in mind. In yet others, it depends on who broke the engagement. If the giver decides to not marry, the receiver keeps the ring. Is cheating a tacit agreement to call off the wedding? Then yes, she needs to give that ring back. Usually cheaters are also thieves, so you may have to write off that $99 Walmart ring.
Depends on the courts decision. Judge Judy says that the ring is in contemplation of getting married which is a contract and since the contract was never fully executed then the ring is to be given to the purchaser (btw it doesn’t matter who caused the marriage to not happen in her view) but I’ve seen some lawyers argue against that claim because the ring is technically a gift and once a gift is given then there’s no legal claim for it to be returned-for example if I give my fiancé a stereo then we break up a month later, I can’t get it back. So it’s a difficult decision to just say he should get it back.
After growing up with toxic parents, I vowed I would never get married nor have children. Then Halloween 1993 I went to a party. I met a guy there and just knew I wanted to spend my life with him. By February 1994 we were married. We now have 3 awesome kids and will be celebrating our 31st anniversary in February 2025.
![【Apple】Toxic mom harasses my fiancée to buy this and that. I can't stand it anymore![Jumbo]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/H_sxKRSGSJQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Depending on where this story takes place, Vivian wouldn't have a right to keep the ring after the engagement broke off. In fact, if the receiver tries to keep the ring, the giver can take legal action to force its return.
right, she broke the agreement by cheating, legally the ring should be returned to him. he shouldve sued her.
It's a conditional gift, laws vary. In some places, it is a gift. In others, it's a token given with marriage in mind. In yet others, it depends on who broke the engagement. If the giver decides to not marry, the receiver keeps the ring. Is cheating a tacit agreement to call off the wedding? Then yes, she needs to give that ring back. Usually cheaters are also thieves, so you may have to write off that $99 Walmart ring.
I think it should be a law that engagement rings be returned upon the breaking of engagements, or at least the cost repaid
You're not just waiting around for two years to have a wedding. You're planning it and saving up money for it.
He definitely should get the ring 💍 back. She caused the breakdown of the relationship.
Depends on the courts decision. Judge Judy says that the ring is in contemplation of getting married which is a contract and since the contract was never fully executed then the ring is to be given to the purchaser (btw it doesn’t matter who caused the marriage to not happen in her view) but I’ve seen some lawyers argue against that claim because the ring is technically a gift and once a gift is given then there’s no legal claim for it to be returned-for example if I give my fiancé a stereo then we break up a month later, I can’t get it back. So it’s a difficult decision to just say he should get it back.
After growing up with toxic parents, I vowed I would never get married nor have children. Then Halloween 1993 I went to a party. I met a guy there and just knew I wanted to spend my life with him. By February 1994 we were married. We now have 3 awesome kids and will be celebrating our 31st anniversary in February 2025.
The first story man Carl is a terrible brother for doing that to him.
We are repeating again? I would think with the AI tools you could easily write scripts BUT this is one of the better ones. Vivian cracks me up.
Carl is 30!?
I thought he was under 25 maybe even closer to 20 , with the way he was talking
Carl and Vivian are a joke, I feel so bad for the baby.
God, what a frustrating man-child Carl is. Ick.
Vivian you chose Carl
So you can deal with the consequences of those actions. The poor baby has two fools for parents
esh
I'm third 🥉💫
So what?
Congrats!!! Love and Kiss from me from the Netherlands
I'm second 🥈✌
So what?
Haha 🎉 congrats!!..it all depends where you live when they release the story!!!
Love and Kiss from me from the Netherlands
I’m 1st 🥇💋
Congratulations, your life has peaked. It's all downhill now.
“This time!” Hahahaha
LOL it all depends where you are in the world when they release the story😂😂😂.!!!
Love and Kiss from me from the Netherlands