CSI ETABS - 04 - P Delta Analysis (How to include P-delta effects) | Part 1

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 85

  • @civilmdc
    @civilmdc  5 років тому +5

    To make a RELATIONSHIP, Don't forget to press the subscribe button with bell icon to get the latest notifications. My channel :)
    ua-cam.com/channels/w9kSuR1bTFBmaMEyD_DXvQ.html

    • @backtomovie5382
      @backtomovie5382 5 років тому +1

      How about collector element in Etabs?

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  5 років тому

      @@backtomovie5382 Dear, that is we have to decide that whether for transfer of lateral forces, collector members required or not.
      2nd , the way you ask,,,,,, i think.. you are asking ... if collector elements are missing, then definitely forces effects will be more.

    • @backtomovie5382
      @backtomovie5382 5 років тому

      @@civilmdc , i meant,if this building have to check toward collector element, how can input and calculate also output the result in Etabs?

    • @civilstuds9488
      @civilstuds9488 4 роки тому

      Can you please share an ASCE 7-16 Pdf file.?

  • @bharatchand7637
    @bharatchand7637 4 роки тому +2

    Whoever you are, i just want to thank you for your selfless efforts here!!!...It's Just amazing stuff man....all of them...

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  4 роки тому

      Welcome..
      A small favor from your side...
      Kindly share with colleagues and friends.
      Here is the full course link
      ua-cam.com/play/PL0h14oMuZXQ5PXbux0l80ox-8gPwcBl5c.html

  • @kunalpatil7146
    @kunalpatil7146 4 роки тому +2

    You are teaching so well. Its a humble request, I would like you to make all these explanatory videos using IS codes too.

  • @md.giasuddinchowdhury5196
    @md.giasuddinchowdhury5196 4 роки тому +2

    You are a very best teacher compare to others.

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  4 роки тому +1

      Welcome
      And thanks for your valuable feedback.....
      Stay blessed....
      A small favor from your side, Kindly share with your friends and colleagues

    • @md.giasuddinchowdhury5196
      @md.giasuddinchowdhury5196 4 роки тому

      @@civilmdc Ok Sir

  • @engrgep
    @engrgep 4 роки тому +5

    The modifier for service condition of the slab is 0.35 as per code your input is 0.5. FYI. Thnx.

  • @understandislam6682
    @understandislam6682 4 роки тому +1

    thank you so much sir for detail information about p delta and excel sheet.

  • @SajjadAhmad-gw7sp
    @SajjadAhmad-gw7sp 3 роки тому

    You are Superman with this explanation plz do all etabs

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  3 роки тому

      Here is the full course link on CSI ETABS
      ua-cam.com/play/PL0h14oMuZXQ5PXbux0l80ox-8gPwcBl5c.html

  • @md.shohagmiah1727
    @md.shohagmiah1727 4 роки тому +1

    Assalmualikum Brother .....thanks for your great initiatives.....

  • @deebdahdouli830
    @deebdahdouli830 Рік тому

    Thank you for the video. How you calculated delta x in the excel sheet ?

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  Рік тому

      Welcome... please see excel formula

  • @civilengineeringwitharas4776
    @civilengineeringwitharas4776 Місяць тому

    You should eliminate (I and Cd) in the P-Delta (Theta) equation, because your result displacements from Etabs is not amplified. that is very important

  • @MohammedAldulaimy-f5l
    @MohammedAldulaimy-f5l Рік тому

    is this condition of stiffens modifying related of steel building ?

  • @JAKE-vr7iu
    @JAKE-vr7iu Рік тому

    @civilmdc Please update the links..There is no excel file to download

  • @naiba996
    @naiba996 4 роки тому +2

    Thank you for the video sir, I have two questions: 1. do we need to modify property modifiers to "1" in "Define--section properties--sections" first?
    2. At 9:26, the stiffness modifiers should be 0.35? since your model is rigid diaphragm assigned as shell.

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  4 роки тому

      We need to apply modifiers at service conditions...
      Because P Delta is applied at service loads

    • @naiba996
      @naiba996 4 роки тому

      @@civilmdc let me change a way to ask,first i understand we gonna use service load. In previous video, when you "define" a beam section, you had entered a modifier. in this video, you go to "assign" and entered the other modifier(this is for service load). what is the difference between this two place ("assign" and "define":)? because in last model, when I right click beam, there is a beam information comes out, the property modifiers are all "1". but in this video, it changes. and gain, thank you for you replying.

  • @Innotutorial
    @Innotutorial 2 роки тому

    Please how can i get the service condition stiffness modifier? from which code? and what page? Thank you.

  • @jasonbxt
    @jasonbxt 4 роки тому +1

    Hi, bro, I follow your video to check the P-D effect, but, when I choose the analysis -> results-> structure results-> story forces, I right click at "Load case/comb", there is only Ex Max, Ey max and Wind_x and Wind_y, no other load, what's wrong? No dead, no live , no other load cases, only lateral force, seismic and wind, why ? Do you know what's wrong with that ? I can't read P, the vertical load, I can't find it .

    • @PG-zc7gm
      @PG-zc7gm 3 роки тому

      Which etabs version u r using

  • @AHMADSHAHEEN-t7u
    @AHMADSHAHEEN-t7u Рік тому

    When I click on the link for the download process, I do not find the Excel file. Please update the links

  • @abdulzahiraliyi8675
    @abdulzahiraliyi8675 4 роки тому +1

    THANKS BRO
    what is the reason for saving the model while entering the stiffness modifier?
    2. let say I entered the stiffness modifier while modeling or defining sections, then I changed it for the reason of I am using service condition for the P-Delta check, and there was NO P-delta. do I have to proceed with service conditions modifier or what?

  • @m.shaihanayub7179
    @m.shaihanayub7179 5 років тому +1

    V. Informative video.. keep it up

  • @MrSuperkilla
    @MrSuperkilla 3 роки тому +1

    You are amazing!!!

  • @deku7727
    @deku7727 2 роки тому

    The formula of DeltaX in excel is DeltaX = ((UXabove - UXbelow)*Cd)/I. If you insert the DeltaX formula in stability coefficient formula, Cd and I will get cancelled. Therefore we didnt use I and Cd if the equation. Kindly give clarification on the computation of DeltaX

  • @asadsadiq2804
    @asadsadiq2804 4 роки тому +1

    Great efforts

  • @mazharkhan9229
    @mazharkhan9229 5 років тому

    From where we can find shear demand and shear capacity for calculating beta (B) for determining teta max.

  • @mostafasultan3840
    @mostafasultan3840 4 роки тому

    if wind load is critical how can i use p-delta with wind load and what is the value of cd in this case?

  • @aboodjou7262
    @aboodjou7262 3 роки тому +1

    hello sir, the excel sheet result is a "redesign" with me, could you explain why?

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  3 роки тому

      Dear it is simple check....
      If you need to include p delta effects ...
      Then enable p delta option...
      Your model automatically incorporate ... These effects.

  • @rahulladse9091
    @rahulladse9091 2 роки тому

    Nice information sir.

  • @vigneshwaran8237
    @vigneshwaran8237 3 роки тому

    THE BELOW LINK OF EXCEL SHEET FOR P-DELTA IS NOT OPENING..PLS FIX THE ERROR BROTHER....

  • @md.mehedihasan361
    @md.mehedihasan361 4 роки тому

    Assalamualaikum brother, could you told me when we are using crack wall and un-crack wall.

  • @BashirAhmed-jo4zq
    @BashirAhmed-jo4zq 3 роки тому

    Appreciation bro

  • @dailyhacks2244
    @dailyhacks2244 4 роки тому +1

    Hai bro, bro is this procedure same for IS codes

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  4 роки тому

      Dear Bro. I did not have confirmation with IS CODE. (Suggestion: I think it will be same.)

    • @dailyhacks2244
      @dailyhacks2244 4 роки тому

      @@civilmdc ok bro, tq for the reply🙂🙂

  • @mohiyuddinchanegaonkar5508
    @mohiyuddinchanegaonkar5508 2 роки тому +1

    CAN SOMEONE GIVE ME THE LINK OF CODE BOOK ASCE7-2016

  • @skillhnter1303
    @skillhnter1303 Рік тому

    JAZAKALLAH

  • @jijmr2013
    @jijmr2013 5 років тому +1

    You made a great job,one more query if u plz,dose Etabs v17's crack works?

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  5 років тому +1

      Dear, friend, ETABS 2017 is not perfectly on many computers,,,, some have analysis issue... some have crack issue, ,,,I personally recommend to you ... the use ETABS 2016..... that is present at www.civilmdc.com

  • @Emma_Junaid_Claire
    @Emma_Junaid_Claire 5 років тому +1

    Salam Bro! I don't know but I can't download your this video in 720p. Same was the problem with your last video. I can't download it in Hd.

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  5 років тому +1

      ARE YOU Trying to download with IDM?

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  5 років тому

      From this website, you can download video in HD..... keepvid.pro/download?video=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2FS4rQ03lcwUs

    • @Emma_Junaid_Claire
      @Emma_Junaid_Claire 5 років тому +1

      @@civilmdc Yes am downloading with IDM

    • @Emma_Junaid_Claire
      @Emma_Junaid_Claire 5 років тому +1

      @@civilmdc Yes am downloading through IDM

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  5 років тому +1

      @@Emma_Junaid_Claire dear... Try the above link for online UA-cam video download

  • @suhaibkhan7356
    @suhaibkhan7356 Рік тому

    This is which code you are explaining

  • @zubiaasghar9076
    @zubiaasghar9076 Рік тому

    why do we have to do all these calculations? doesnt etabs calculate it on its on?

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  Рік тому

      ETABS.. don't count automatically.. we have to select p delta , if needed as shown in the video...

    • @zubiaasghar9076
      @zubiaasghar9076 Рік тому

      @@civilmdc but as per FEMA we have to consider P delta effects in all buildings.

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  Рік тому

      @@zubiaasghar9076 the check in have applied is as per ASCE 7

    • @AHMADSHAHEEN-t7u
      @AHMADSHAHEEN-t7u Рік тому

      ​@@civilmdcUnable to download excel files sir

  • @Emma_Junaid_Claire
    @Emma_Junaid_Claire 5 років тому +1

    Hey bro! My whole tricks failed in downloading your this video in HD...Don't mind but upload it again so that I can download it in 720p Hd...don't mind

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  5 років тому +1

      Dear, for you, i will upload this video on google drive and share the link with you.... (Dear but i will take some time...)

    • @Emma_Junaid_Claire
      @Emma_Junaid_Claire 5 років тому

      @@civilmdc Okay Thank you...GOD bless you (Amen)...

  • @Emma_Junaid_Claire
    @Emma_Junaid_Claire 5 років тому

    Yar es video ko khuda keleye dobara upload karo...ye 720p me download nahe hota...saray tricks apply kar deye...pls...isko dobara upload karo...aor playlist ko order me arrange karo...pls don't mind bro

  • @siveribrahim-bf2lu
    @siveribrahim-bf2lu 8 місяців тому

    👏

  • @haimanotbelay2643
    @haimanotbelay2643 4 роки тому

    hi sir how can i find excl spread sheet....

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  4 роки тому +1

      Each excel sheet download link is given in the description of the video..
      I hope you will get.

    • @AHMADSHAHEEN-t7u
      @AHMADSHAHEEN-t7u Рік тому

      ​@@civilmdc When I click on the link for the download process, I do not find the Excel file. Please update the links

  • @mdshahebaz9567
    @mdshahebaz9567 5 років тому +1

    Assalamualikum warahmatullahi wabarkathu sir
    Can u give me the password to unlock the excal sheet

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  5 років тому +1

      Dear ... It's simple... No password needed..... I have checked myself... Right now..
      Only 2 steps
      1- click the link in description of post Of youtube video.
      2- Press RED download button...
      That's it
      If you still face any issue please let me know

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  5 років тому +1

      W. Salam

    • @mdshahebaz9567
      @mdshahebaz9567 5 років тому +2

      @@civilmdc alhamdulillah i got it

    • @mdshahebaz9567
      @mdshahebaz9567 5 років тому +2

      Jazakallahu khaira

    • @civilmdc
      @civilmdc  5 років тому

      @@mdshahebaz9567 You are welcome

  • @rodolfoorler6495
    @rodolfoorler6495 3 роки тому

    excelente video colegas, buen trabajo, claro. Dejo un enlace de video propio que puede agradarles, espero. ua-cam.com/video/KFygJbrU4Z8/v-deo.html