Xinjiang Wars | 3 Minute History
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- / jabzy
Thanks to Xios, Alan Haskayne, Lachlan Lindenmayer, Victor Yau, William Crabb, Derpvic, Seth Reeves and all my other Patrons. If you want to help out - www.patreon.co...
/ jabzyjoe
www.facebook.c...
Are we talking about the state which always joins the Comintern when I play as the USSR in HoI?
That's the one. But on that game its called Sinkiang.
Yeah it's got like 3 names, Sinkiang, Xinjiang, East Turkestan
I've noticed in some playthroughs Sinkiang gets annexs by the KMT like all the other warlord states. Since I didn't know about the history of that area well could it be safe to say that this is the result of the German Reich decisively beating the Soviet Union in a war and before Sinkiang Joins the Comintern?
Depends on what HoI. In the earlier HoI games, its insignificant unless you choose a decision to forming the Chinese United Front earlier than historically, where it and along a bunch of other warlords will join your alliance at the cost of losing Communist China as an ally and a massive dissent hit...
Jihadi Jesus I only know hoi 4
All these China videos are complex, I like it that way. Good work Jabzy
Why is Kashmir apparently under Soviet in the map?
When the other Central Asian Turkic countries got their independence in the 1990s, did that encourage nationalism in Xinjiang?
David Harrison the only recent nationalism movement I heard is Taxis independence movement, USA into 2nd civil war over Trumps election, we encourage exercise of freedom by American people of all color and culture with Europe own ethnic states. E.g. German decedents, Irish decents, black, white brown, mixed all should have their own states. That is the true principle of self governing. We will encourage it, funding it, grow it, one day it will become so real.
Not really, Central Asians are extremely divided and don't see each other as related people often.
@Atilla YURT These central asian states have been independent for three decades. You are welcome to set up shop over there to preach pan-turkism. But the way I see it, it's not gonna work at all, because its fascist and revisionist and biased historical and racial interpretation.
Nation state itself is a purely European idea that happened to be the out come of two thousand years of conquest and consolidation, and it also closely followed the geography of the land creating natural borders at bottle necks. Historically, there was no pure race or ethnic or anything like that, people moved relocated all the while getting mixed all the time. And the spread of language may run parallel to that or not. The people of central asia used to speak Indo-european languages, the Tajikis still do. The people of Turkey only have about 5-10% central asian admixture. Pan-turkism is asking these people to remember their one turkic grandpa, but forgeting that they have nine other grandpa who are not turkic.
Even when you put aside historical revisionism. The problems are just too many. The turkic council always had a turkey pushing for a standard turkic language, but so far no work had been done what so ever, all turkey said is just adopt roman alphabet. When the chinese uyghur asked for children text book, turkey just sent their own text book straight from Turkey. What can the uyghur do, forget their own dialect of turkic, the possibly earlist recorded turkic in any sufficent volume? There goes the hope of them ever adopting a latin script, unless they get help from china, cause turkey offered no real help what so ever. Just empty words and empirial dream. Thats just one exmple, a standard dialect and supposedly the most easy problem for a pan turkic state, I mean have people of turkey even heard of fergana valley? Have they offered anything to solve the issue? Telling them they all turic brah isn't gonna do thats for sure. Real brahs fight for inheritance all the time... What is pan-tukism doing to unite them?
@@bljones9383 actually, some provinces in turkey has on average almost 20% east eurasian and just 1% of turkish people are above the former number
Rick K Are you insane ? 10 cents army. Deplorables. A second American civil war will be the most beautiful things in the world. Think about it, you will get the chance to practice 2nd amendment as much as you can.
Lots of nice touches with the art there, clearly I appreciated the Panzer IV's ;)
I very much like this China series, thanks.
As a non-english speaker, I got some issues to follow you since you're speaking at a quick pace with a lot of informations and foreign words (in this video, I'm talking about the chineses names read with your accent) to swallow. So, would you mind to put your script on the videos you're making in order to use the youtube subtitles tool ?
I think it would be a great thing for us and improve the attendance here. But anyway, keep up the great work !
I'm trying to put subtitles on my videos, it just takes ages.
Yeah.. Totally agree. Would really appreciate if subtitles are available.. It is quite hard to catch MOST words said 😭
I know it’s been like 5 years but you can slow down videos to different speeds.
Voice is utterly bad for such documentary!!!
thanks you work, it is the clearest history of XinJiang I have ever seen
I dunno why but Xinjiang has always fascinated me but I dunno where I can find info on it
Funnily enough Xinjiang and Iran are two of the nations I find most interesting 😂
( i know i comment late ) Latelty i am doing some research about Xinjiang because it just interests me that a communist han chinese is in control of most turkic related people.
@@kuzudestroyer7586 I'm more interested in Kurdistan, because it always interested me how turkey can control kurdistan.
Happy New Year Jabzy. God bless you and may He give you the strength to continue this channel.
Happy new year, Jabbzy!
Thank you! This explained alot and I learned something new.
I always lose out on the names of the people
Would be nice if there were official subtitles at least so you can see the names. Otherwise the auto-gen definitely misses some of them.
Make a video of tibet
An interesting topic
Keep calm let the Russians rule - but Nooo! they had to go Allahu Akbar
Han Chinese ruled xinjiang 2,000 years ago, when there were no muslims，Since 200 BC, millions of han Chinese soldiers have died in xinjiang
You better read your history where’s huanghe where’s xinjiang
@Rimskiy Korsakov In 80 BC, the Han government established effective jurisdiction in Xinjiang. At that time, the residents were all Aryans who believed in Buddhism, and there were no Turks or Muslims.
Would you be interested in doing a video about the Welsh wars, the glyndwr rising etc?
I hope someone makes a game based in this period.
I actually think that you predicted HoI4 Waking the Tiger
Jabzy can you do the Greek revolution(1821-1827) or the Greek civil war(1946-1949) theyre both intressting please answer!
Not really. Boring as shit actually. You got indepdence because the powers of the Holy Liga decided that you should.
@@bordoenes6217 a little buthurt aren't we
@@Dourios_96 Considering we still hear Greeks crying about Istanbul to this day, you tell me...
@@bordoenes6217 OH, YOU GOT HIM GOOD LMAO
This China videos are so confusing... I don't understand who's who, or what's going on
Not complete and omitted important historical facts.
OMG history is sooooooooooo complicated...
Nothing is simple.
doesn't help that there aren't any official captions or subtitles...
What about Isa Alptekin and the PRC invasion of East Turkestan?
John Csukás . Lol east Turkestan never existed
So the Chinese Muslims are the oned to blame for Xinjiangs Misery
jabzy, is that terrorist group known as ETIM?
That's the one.
Jabzy Only learned that because of the central Asian history class! Great videos Jabzy! I have watched every one!
I think they have been renamed the TIP - Turkestan Islamic Party. Some of their fighters have joined ISIS in Syria.
@@Bournetolive true
Make a video about the Sengoku Jidai...
Check out Extra credit they did a 6 part video about that!
but be warned extra credit are pretty racist against white people and western culture.
Идёт Геноцид Уйгурий.
Could you please indicate water bodies on your maps? It's sometimes hard to tell countries from lakes and oceans.
There are no major ones near Xinjiang.
Here, I'm referring to your pan-turkism map.
The map used in the video seems to depict, from left to right, Mediterranean Sea, Black Sea, Caspian Sea
You should do the Italo-Turkish war soon man
It was one of the first ones I did - ua-cam.com/video/7lv9f5EkP9g/v-deo.html
Jabzy Oh nice! I'm really liking these chinese vids you're doing since not many people know about the wars around that time in China. I'm guessing you'll be doing the later wars China fought in Korea plus the one against against vietnam & the India one.
So, are you sure that the warlord era ended in 1928?
+anonymous anonymous you saw my videos on it?
Jabzy Yes I did. The Beiyang government ended in 1928, but I wouldn't say that the warlord era ended with them.
they usually consider the end of the Warlord Era to be synonymous with the beginning of the Nanjing decade, that is the moment when the ROC government was based in Nanjing. However they definitely were still fighting against warlords after this point, such as the Central Plains War in 1930.
After reading the comments n history, I think Rich muslim nations should stop instigating poor muslims to go against thier countries n live in peace n harmony, halal, haram, takawiyah, jihad , superior ness should be abolished from all countries, live n let live
awesome video!
MOAR!!
China will soon be the most powerful state in the world so please learn something about its history. It will be very important
+Rick K I personally hope it will be and end western dominance which i dont think will actually happen. I would rather have a government that speaks directly than one which is full of hypocrisy like they do in the west. They talk about human rights while fucking up other countries and causing death everywhere.
***** haha yh i know they're both bad but i just cant stand the double speak they use in the media and they've exported this nonsense to their allies in the gulf and want to export it everywhere. Like imagine how annoying it is hearing CNN, FOX, BBC, al Jazeera continue to talk about human rights when they're literally bombing places everywhere and arming/funding insurgents. Its much more bearable listening to propaganda services like xinhua, RT, Press TV since their attempt to conflate the importance of their own country and the wrongs of their enemies is much simpler and their role as a propaganda channel is much more obvious.
***** you shouldnt believe everything FOX or anti-china propaganda channels in youtube tell you like 'China Uncensored'. You're reducing a complicated comparison between 2 giant governments to an accusation of organ trafficking. You may be right but there are many flaws on both sides which need scrutinising. China's human rights problems are mostly domestic while the US has a lot to account for in foreign countries. As a non chinese who's country has been destroyed by the US, i would prefer China over the US any day of the week.
Rick K i think all political systems are flawed so i dont know which is better. I think judging a country based on its political system is stupid. Just because the US is a democracy doesnt mean it cant be evil and just because China is communist doesnt mean its always evil thats what the US wants you to think to justify invading non-democratic countries.
Important as hell if you for once willimg to remove the communist regime
Very well made. I hope more people can see your videos!
Whats the name of the song in the background? Its beautiful
Very relevant today, hope more people will see this.
Shanxi is best warlord
Change my mind.
I knew it he is reading the book CHINA WARS
Afraid not - I tend not to base any of these videos from 1 book or source
Too complicated by far.
Northern Xinjiang was sparsely populated steppes which were historically contested between Han Chinese and Mongols or other nomadic people.
Uyghurs are native to Southern Xinjiang in the Tarim Basin and the Chinese government forbids any Han migration into the region. The Chinese government only encouraged Han migration into the Northern area Xinjiang which was built up by Han Chinese. Urumuqi used be referred to as a Han Chinese outpost in Xinjiang because it was mainly founded by Han Chinese and some Hui traders.
The Chinese government in recent years have actually encouraged Uyghurs to migrate to northern Xinjiang as well, encouraging them to migrate to cities traditionally inhabited by Han and Hui.
tru
Bullshit. The steppes of Central Asia have always been inhabited by Altaic people(Turkic and Mongolic), its entire fucking reason why you build the damn wall. Stop trying to justify your cultural and geographical genocide of the Uyghur people with such a lame ass excuse. Chinese didnt even conquer East Turkistan until the Tang Dynasty, which was many centuries after other nomadic empires conquered and people inhabited the areas. The Gokturks, The Xiongnu, The Sogdians, The Uyghurs, The Tartars all came before you.
Enes Demir it doesn't matter who came there first. Russia doesn't give a shit about how they occupied the entire Far East part. Syria, Iraq, Turkey,and Iran don give a fxxk about how they split "Kurdistan". Cuz they can't survive independently as a severeign state anyway. If chinese did not take xinjiang , Russia would definitely take it . It can't be a independent nation. Even though All these central Asian countries nowadays r independent sovereign nations, that's because USSR abandoned them at 1991, they can't independent from ussr.
What in gods name are you talking about. You are making lame ass excuses all over the place. The very notion of "Kurds" as an ethnic people didnt even exist until early modern history, let alone the very notion of "Kurdistan". However the Turks of East Turkistan have had many empires and cultural heritage within the region for many centuries, the Uyghurs even had their own script and traditions which was so renowned among other nomads that Genghiz Khan himself wanted his empire to be run by them. If Mongolia can be independent, then East Turkistan and Tibet can be independent. Maybe if you showed a little more respect and good faith, you wouldnt need to worry about Uyghur seperatists. But what can we expect from Han Chinese who ethnically cleansed Inner Mongolia and Manchuria with the same cowardice tactics.
Enes Demir as ur logic , buryats should be independent , Kalmyk should be independent , Tuva should be independent, Tatar Yakutsk .... they all should independent
How many more episodes of Chinese history until full reunification occurs in 1949?
it could have been a million more
If everything is as interesting as this episode, yes more please, more chinese game of thrones
Who else has MUN??
Supposedly I'm related to osman batur
бляяя где на русском найти
Will you or have you do a video on world war 2?
East Turkestan is not Xinjiang
cope
In Hindi
Welcome to "3 minutes of low legitimacy"
You got many facts wrong, too many to count here.
Free Turkestan
Free Kurdistan
@@edwardsnowden8821 okey
And then genocide happened.