Should we window the impulse response?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 7

  • @MrPilarek
    @MrPilarek Рік тому +2

    Hey Nathan! I was wondering if there's any chance you could record Crosslite online training.

    • @nathanlively
      @nathanlively  Рік тому

      Yes! I've done several. Last year I tried to sell a training, but there was not enough demand, so maybe we'll see in the future. If you just search my channel for CrossLite, you'll find them.
      www.youtube.com/@nathanlively/search?query=crosslite

    • @nathanlively
      @nathanlively  Рік тому +1

      Also check the official channel www.youtube.com/@FMonteiroScience/videos

  • @ToastOnToast
    @ToastOnToast Рік тому

    Thank you so much Nathan for going further into my question. I appreciate the time and effort you have taken to look into this suggestion.
    To be honest, windowing came about to me as a result of desperation and frustration with "noisy" traces.
    As you said, the Relative/Absolute method is still the best method, and Sub Aligner remains the ultimate tool for the job in the field.
    Thank you to you, and the good folk(s) over at CrossLite for the answers.
    Looking forward to the next live stream!

    • @nathanlively
      @nathanlively  Рік тому

      You're welcome! Hey I'd love to get more of your questions and thoughts on this topic. Would you be down to chat? If so, here's a link to my scheduling page: nathanlively.as.me/qa

  • @NackDSP
    @NackDSP Рік тому +1

    Yes. Always apply a window. There is actually no way to avoid a window. No window is essentially a box car window. The width and type of window will determine how the response is shaped. I expect the manual for any software will describe the effect each window type has on the measurement.

    • @nathanlively
      @nathanlively  Рік тому

      Thanks Nack! I believe I covered this by saying, "The minimum window necessary to perform the FFT." In this video I'm focusing on applying further windows specifically to perform kinds of noise reduction.