The Future of Counsel of Trent (Live from Catholic Answers Conference)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
  • Help us build the future of The Counsel of Trent: give.catholic....
    Answering Orthodoxy: www.amazon.com...
    Join Trent live from the Catholic Answers Conference! He'll be sharing exciting updates about the future of this channel and how you can get involved. Don’t miss out!
    [NEW] Counsel of Trent merch: shop.catholic....
    Be sure to keep up with our socials!
    / counseloftrent
    / counseloftrent
    / counseloftrentpodcast

КОМЕНТАРІ • 351

  • @TheCounselofTrent
    @TheCounselofTrent  11 годин тому +1

    If you want to support our efforts, be sure to check out this link: give.catholic.com/campaign/617272/donate

    • @Repented661
      @Repented661 9 годин тому

      Why sponsor paganism. No way REPENT!!!

  • @GospelSimplicity
    @GospelSimplicity День тому +60

    Excited for the future of your channel, Trent! Can't wait to be able to say, "I was there when Trent was recording with a laptop on a cardboard box" when you have an incredible studio in the future.

    • @Fred-t2w
      @Fred-t2w День тому

      Why waste money on a studio?

    • @freda7961
      @freda7961 18 годин тому +1

      @@Fred-t2wWhy would you consider it wasting money?

  • @Qohelethful
    @Qohelethful День тому +40

    A discussion with Jordan Peterson would be interesting if you haven’t already done one.

    • @JezuesChavez
      @JezuesChavez День тому

      Jordan Peterson is the dumb man’s genius.

  • @bygonerenewal6278
    @bygonerenewal6278 День тому +34

    I would appreciate conversations with Orthodox: Fr. Josiah Trenham, Fr. Peter Heers, Jonathan Pageau to name a few

  • @kylej.reeves4268
    @kylej.reeves4268 День тому +29

    I would also love to see a collaboration with Ferris Murdoch from How to Be Christian. He does amazing Catholic exegesis, and has really helped me along as I have come home to Rome.

  • @TheJmlew11
    @TheJmlew11 День тому +59

    would love for you to talk with Wendigoon. Not an explicitly Protestant channel, but he is a faithful Christian who seems to be pursuing truth. I would give to see that.

  • @nicholasroman940
    @nicholasroman940 День тому +28

    Suggestions for future guests:
    -Barrel Aged Faith
    -Jonathan Pageau
    -Jordan Cooper
    -Calvin Robinson

    • @JoshYng
      @JoshYng 15 годин тому

      Jordan Cooper is a good choice

  • @Liam-Carlson
    @Liam-Carlson День тому +41

    I’d like to see Ray Comfort and Trent Horn having a discussion. That’d be quite a watch.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому

      Ray Comfort is a polemicist, and polemisicts, if they are worth their salt, will never let themsleves be exposed to enquiry by a knowledgeable opponent.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +2

      Polemecists worth their salt will never let someone knowledgeable like Trent question them.

    • @Christine-d7t
      @Christine-d7t 22 години тому +2

      I don’t think Ray Comfort has the ability to have an intellectual conversation about faith. He plays it safe and plays games when he talks to people.

    • @sheylamercado9801
      @sheylamercado9801 6 годин тому

      I’d pay money to see that! Like a PPV event lol

  • @TruthHasSpoken
    @TruthHasSpoken День тому +64

    Would be interesting to have a discussion with a Rabbi on their beliefs on who Jesus was, and their understanding of Old Testament prophecy of the Messiah (and that OT prophecy is not referring to Jesus)

    • @telephonebear21
      @telephonebear21 13 годин тому +1

      He has response videos to Tovia Singer at least

    • @AlexE5250
      @AlexE5250 13 годин тому +1

      I know Ben Shapiro doesn’t really do religious apologetics, but considering he’s had Trent on the Ben Shapiro show a couple times, maybe Shapiro would be willing to do a dialogue with Trent.
      Or even make it a 2v2. Trent and Michael Knowles defending the divinity of Christ, and Shapiro and a Jewish apologist defending the Jewish perspective.

    • @BensWorkshop
      @BensWorkshop 11 годин тому

      There is a Jewish lawyer in New York called Rob (or Rod) Coleman who on Timcast IRL said the Catholic Church was set up by people who really understood Jewish law. That would be a very interesting conversation.

  • @emiliobazzarelli4270
    @emiliobazzarelli4270 День тому +37

    The mormons spamming these comments to debate the immaculate conception are kinda dumb. Why would you debate something where there are so many degrees of difference? I can’t stand debates like this where there are obviously multiple degrees of difference between what both sides believe and what they are debating, always debate the first point of divergence on a question not the fifth

  • @butrflyspirit
    @butrflyspirit День тому +11

    The moment someone put doubt in my head on my Catholic faith, I quickly took RCIA classes at 17 years old. Those studies were one of the best things I could have done. No one has ever been able to confuse me or take me from my faith.

  • @ethanselander3601
    @ethanselander3601 День тому +15

    Would love to see you debate Robert Boylan on the immaculate conception.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому

      An account that started 9 years ago and the first comment asking for a Boylan debate with Trent. Lmao is your arm chair QB ready to get off the couch?

  • @microsoftpain
    @microsoftpain День тому +10

    Would like to see Trent talk to Wendigoon (Isaiah Nichols). He has a bunch of popular videos about biblical topics (angels, etc.). Not explicitly a Protestant channel, as others have said, but I think he would be interesting to have on.

    • @AlexE5250
      @AlexE5250 13 годин тому +1

      I’d love to see Wendigoon and skinny Akin sit down together. They can bond over Bigfoot, aliens, and conspiracies!

  • @JB12JB
    @JB12JB День тому +8

    I would really like to see more discussion on Eastern Orthodoxy and the Oriental Orthodox churches. I think Eastern Orthodoxy has definitely been growing on UA-cam and I would like for you to rebuttal some of their claims that they are the true church

  • @mikeq922
    @mikeq922 День тому +6

    Thank you Trent for your channel with great apologetic content to always help and strengthen our faith 🙏

  • @kylej.reeves4268
    @kylej.reeves4268 День тому +5

    Please reach out to Dr. Leighton Flowers of Soteriology 101, and Dr. Frank Turek of CrossExamined. I would love to hear them dialogue with Trent!!!

  • @Chili7Voodoo
    @Chili7Voodoo День тому +5

    I recently (within the last 5 years) turned back to the faith after 25+ years away. I went looking for educators, and after sifting through 20 or more personalities, I've circled around what I consider my "Cabinet of Catholic Counselors". It's you, Joe Heschmeyer, and Alex from Voice of Reason. I look every single day to find content from you guys, and your information has more than made up for a lack of studio.
    I'm thrilled to see you growing and reaching more people, and you deserve all of your success and more. I'm not wealthy, but I did donate a small amount when I saw this video. I don't say that to pat myself on the back, but rather to tell you that you are only the second person I've ever donated money to online. It's a hard thing for me to do, but I believe in you and your work.
    God bless you, your family, and your team!

  • @brendansheehan6180
    @brendansheehan6180 День тому +16

    I don't think you should talk to Robert Boylan (jk. Who on earth is Robert Boylan?)

    • @DanielTovar-v6t
      @DanielTovar-v6t День тому +6

      Ex-Catholic apologist who wrote a book on Catholic mariology and has been offering to debate trent horn on the immaculate conception for years

    • @brendansheehan6180
      @brendansheehan6180 День тому

      @@DanielTovar-v6t What is his current belief system?

    • @DanielTovar-v6t
      @DanielTovar-v6t День тому +2

      @@brendansheehan6180 Converted to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints while getting his degrees in theology and anthropology at a top catholic institution in Ireland(Maynooth)

    • @brendansheehan6180
      @brendansheehan6180 День тому +2

      @@DanielTovar-v6t oh ok. Well, that must have felt exotic.

    • @fre7717
      @fre7717 День тому +8

      so, he went to a top University and still believed everything that joseph smith said- about places and people in north America, where archeologists haven't found anything. not to mention the saga of the stone tablets, unfulfilled prophecies. JS also predicted his own coming by writing about it himself- very excellent stuff!! being a former catholic doesn't give him any special knowledge- kind of reminds me of the one that Allie-Beth Stuckly had: A former catholic who blames the church for not having read the bible at all. i am catholic and i read the bible (both testaments) when i was 12 yrs old.

  • @MatthewCofer-p1g
    @MatthewCofer-p1g День тому +5

    Could you and Gavin Ortlund team up again? I wanna see you two take on a common enemy again like you guys did with the two atheist biblical scholars.

  • @dwong9289
    @dwong9289 День тому +6

    Thanks for the shoutout at 26:51 Trent! God bless ❤️

  • @AnonCatholic13
    @AnonCatholic13 День тому +17

    the mormon spam in these comments 😂😂😂

  • @carakerr4081
    @carakerr4081 День тому +4

    Thank you Trent and crew! Very blessed by your channel. From this content I now have two Protestant friends becoming Catholic! My husband and I converted to Catholicism this past Pentecost we were confirmed all glory to God! I will pray with my husband about donating hoping on a monthly basis you are such a high quality channel!!! 🙏🙏

  • @SimmyKenz
    @SimmyKenz День тому +4

    Trent Horn x Richard Dawkins would be legendary 😭😭
    praying that many step up to support !

  • @ericktibaijuka7493
    @ericktibaijuka7493 День тому +12

    Trent, am ur big fan, i enjoy ur content. Much love all the way from Cameroon (Africa)

  • @blancabibriesca4939
    @blancabibriesca4939 День тому +5

    Looking forward to your new channel. I am not a Catholic but currently learning about the faith. I just started RCIA classes. I Left the mormon church in 2016 after being a member for 25+ years. I identified as an atheist for about two years, then started to read the Old Testament attended a Protestant church for a while, but what brought me to The Catholic Church is the Eucharist. I have a lot to learn.
    Will be supporting you for sure 👍🏼

    • @HaleStorm49
      @HaleStorm49 17 годин тому

      When you give up eternal marriage, Exaltation, and Temple worship - what are you looking to trade those for exactly?

    • @HaleStorm49
      @HaleStorm49 17 годин тому +1

      25 years? What were you doing all that time?

  • @zemneo6485
    @zemneo6485 День тому +3

    Ricky Grevais, Bill Mahar, Genetically Modified Skeptic (you tuber), Justin Peters, Mike Winger, Allen Parr, or Jonathan MacArthur. Any one of these would be interesting.

  • @grandpalarry7776
    @grandpalarry7776 День тому +3

    There are two individuals with whom I would like to see you have a discussion.
    Dennis Prager of Prager University for a Jewish perspective
    Bishop Craig Bates Patriarch of the International Communion of the Charismatic Episcopal Church. FYI, the ICCEC is not an offshoot or a schism of the Episcopal Church. We are a Church formed primarily of former non-denominational church members seeking a fuller expression of Christianity. The ICCEC combines Sacramental-Liturgical, Evangelical, and Charismatic experiences in a single Church under an Episcopal governmental structure.

  • @Cyborg_queen
    @Cyborg_queen День тому +9

    Trent actually reaffirmed my belief in god with his philosophical arguments. Absolutely need to do an interview with Jordon Peterson and show these arguments

    • @33legion
      @33legion День тому +2

      Cool, just make sure you capitalize the "g" in God.

    • @Cyborg_queen
      @Cyborg_queen День тому

      @@33legion bro chill out 😂

    • @33legion
      @33legion День тому +1

      @@Cyborg_queen I'm relaxed.

    • @Cyborg_queen
      @Cyborg_queen День тому

      @@33legion don’t seem so spell correcting minor spelling errors lmao it’s such a virtue signal

    • @33legion
      @33legion День тому +1

      @@Cyborg_queen 1. It's a capitalization error, not a spelling error.
      2. I said it jokingky, not that big a deal.
      3. But you really should capitalize the "g" in God.

  • @CharlieMarno100
    @CharlieMarno100 День тому +3

    It’s a decent background. Kind of bland and uninspired.

  • @TitusConstantine
    @TitusConstantine 16 годин тому +3

    I've got a great number of individuals that would make a great discussion. Please consider a dialogue with:
    Gravantus/The Tabellion
    Sam Hyde
    Charls Carroll
    Bible Illustrated
    Nicholas Kotar
    Jonathan Pageau
    Wendigoon (as another commenter said)

  • @RLord017
    @RLord017 15 годин тому +4

    Debating a Mormon on the Immaculate conception sounds like a horrible idea when Mormons reject the doctrine of Original Sin. Especially since in Mormon Theology that God willed the Fall to happen. That without The Fall, the human species couldn't exist.
    This kind of debate would be horrible.

    • @smartismarti4049
      @smartismarti4049 15 годин тому

      Right. I would like to see Trent discuss the creation and the fall with a Mormon. Maybe as part of a long discussion about who God is, comparing "plans of salvation".

    • @RLord017
      @RLord017 14 годин тому +1

      @@smartismarti4049 I mean there are plenty of other better topics to go over than a mariology topic with someone who isn't even a Christian, I mean the official Catholic teaching is that mormons aren't Christian.

  • @zakedmonds4354
    @zakedmonds4354 День тому +10

    Not Catholic but a big fan of Trent Hornt and the show. Rarely miss an episode. I'm excited about this evolution.

    • @sandywilliams5898
      @sandywilliams5898 14 годин тому

      Doesn't Trent do a great job of showing us how to debate, discuss with love and charity when u disagree. We could all learn from Trent

  • @ashleyargall8791
    @ashleyargall8791 День тому +2

    - Follow up interview with Redeemed Zoomer
    - Mike Gendron (if he’ll agree haha)
    - follow up conversation with Allie Beth Stuckey

  • @braydenblack296
    @braydenblack296 День тому +10

    I think it would be pretty worthwhile to debate Robert Boylan on the immaculate conception. Both of you are highly expertise in your range of knowledge and specific studies and I think it would go really well

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +1

      An account that started 4 years ago and the first comment asking for a Boylan debate with Trent. Lmao is your arm chair QB ready to get off the couch?

  • @sparco108
    @sparco108 14 годин тому +3

    hellooo from Singapore, just wanted to let you guys know that your content has reach to Asia (South East Asia ) as well! God Bless

  • @anhgiangho
    @anhgiangho День тому +2

    I was your fan for a longggg time, probably since 2015 when your videos were still look dark and scary 😂. I’m happy that your growth. Back then other non-Catholic apologists have like 200k-500k views and yours were like 5k-10k. I was praying your chanel become bigger. Because you always speaking the truth and well researched…again, big fannnn. God bless you , Trent

  • @joyhenry-dp8nd
    @joyhenry-dp8nd День тому +2

    A few others-
    -N.T. Wright on the Eucharist or the papacy
    -Carl R Trueman maybe on something like beauty and truth? (I have heard him chat about the many Protestants joining Catholicism due to beauty..)
    -Francis collins on the dignity of human life in all stages. He needs to be further exposed to the evangelical world with his beliefs and what he has done under the name of a so called Christian.

  • @coinfishmedia
    @coinfishmedia День тому +2

    Love the content (with the exception of the one video when you pushed back on Fr. Mike’s MMA video)!
    Catholic UA-cam needs more channels like this.
    Note: The audio has kind of a reverb sound on this video.

  • @RomingAroundTown
    @RomingAroundTown День тому +4

    Calvin Robinson for a opposing interview, How To Be Christian for a Catholic interview

    • @MatthewCofer-p1g
      @MatthewCofer-p1g День тому

      Last I checked on Calvin Robinson he was a Nordic Catholic. Although I may be wrong.

    • @telephonebear21
      @telephonebear21 13 годин тому

      @@MatthewCofer-p1g He's Anglican and of a high church persuasion. Because they have bishops and priests and traditional vestments etc a lot of Anglicans don't see themselves as protestant, they see themselves as a third branch of the Church along with Catholic and EO, but that Catholics and EO have errors.

  • @Cyborg_queen
    @Cyborg_queen День тому +2

    Dude we should have a show where it’s like “An event” like a “every month with Jordon Peterson”. That would be awesome to bring up new arguments for theism

  • @thatblissguythatblissguy9703
    @thatblissguythatblissguy9703 День тому +5

    I'm donating.

  • @tagarikamaruza8263
    @tagarikamaruza8263 День тому +4

    hey, I know you would like to interview non-catholics and non-Christians however I think it would be great if you interviewed fellow Catholics who seem to be a bit at loggerheads with you like Dr. Marshall. I think as Catholics we woyld benefit from your dialogue

    • @domanicvaldez
      @domanicvaldez День тому

      He kinda did this when he spoke with Anthony from Avoiding Babylon.

    • @tagarikamaruza8263
      @tagarikamaruza8263 День тому +2

      @@domanicvaldez I will definitely check this out. I guess as more of a Marshall and Trent watcher I would have liked to see the thought leaders I pay attention to iron things out. Thank you for the recommendation though

    • @domanicvaldez
      @domanicvaldez 19 годин тому

      @@tagarikamaruza8263 I gotcha. It would definitely be a good episode.

  • @nickihey8618
    @nickihey8618 День тому +2

    I would love to see a collaboration with Laura Horn, her videos are best!!❤️❤️

  • @PattiS3
    @PattiS3 День тому +2

    Congrats, Trent. Sounds like good plans for new directions.

  • @friendlyolbum
    @friendlyolbum День тому +7

    Wishlist for future guests
    James White
    Mike Winger
    Douglas Wilson
    Keith Foskey
    Wise Disciple
    Jeff Durbin
    Alex O'Conner
    Bart Ehrman

  • @BYUApologeticsClub
    @BYUApologeticsClub День тому +8

    Debate Blake Ostler on the Nature of God and Robert Boylan on the Immaculate Conception... both would be debate of the decade candidates

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому

      An account that started 2 weeks ago and the first comment asking for a Boylan debate with Trent. Lmao is your arm chair QB ready to get off the couch?

  • @danb3378
    @danb3378 15 годин тому +2

    Mark Wahlberg, Kirk Cameron, head of Assemblies of God, Brant Pitre.

  • @asimhussain8716
    @asimhussain8716 День тому +2

    Trent, love your content despite not being Christian myself. Would you be willing to do an in-depth exploration and defense of the resurrection? I've seen a few of your debates and have been thoroughly impressed. However, I have to say I was somewhat disappointed in your debate with Matt Dillahunty (and I don't even like the guy lol). I was not particularly compelled by your arguments as I have been in your defense of rationalizing our way to the necessity of a God by means of purely logic.

    • @TheCounselofTrent
      @TheCounselofTrent  11 годин тому

      Thanks for this suggestion and your support! -Vanessa

  • @MrPhillipbraden
    @MrPhillipbraden День тому +2

    Proud of all your success here on UA-cam

  • @rachelpops9239
    @rachelpops9239 17 годин тому +2

    God bless your apostalate Trent! We need JOY in this reaction-based, negative soaked media world

  • @jozekz82
    @jozekz82 День тому +3

    Thanks!

  • @jeremyboyce7518
    @jeremyboyce7518 День тому +25

    Debate Robert Boylan on the immaculate conception!!

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +1

      An account that started 10 years ago and the first comment asking for a Boylan debate with Trent. Lmao is your arm chair QB ready to get off the couch?

    • @thegentlemanly6299
      @thegentlemanly6299 День тому

      @@alisterrebelo9013 You need a new joke

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +1

      ​@@thegentlemanly6299 I'm not laughing, as it was a statement of truth, not a joke. And we can see the coordinated attempt pretending to be a natural occurrence.
      The only debate I've known Robert do, is a 2v2 against some third rate Protestants. Can you point me to any of his other debates?
      I recall Robert turned down a debate on either on PWA or Capturing Christianity in 2022 or 2023 when he found out he was going to face Jimmy Akin.

  • @padraicbrown6718
    @padraicbrown6718 День тому +1

    I would really love it if you held discussions or debates with alternative Catholic voices: the so-called "rad trads", sedevacantists, etc. So, SSPX, the Palmarians, followers of Vigano. Perhaps bring in their more orthodox or non-schismatic counterparts. Here in the online space, it's groups like Palmarian Catholic Church that are have been and are going to siphon off some of our more traditionally minded brothers and sisters.
    I would also love it if you held discussions with serious Protestants that are perhaps closer to us on many issues: GAFCON, Anglo-Catholics, Anglican-Catholics and the like.
    Also, please dialogue with some good Ethiopian, Assyrian and Oriental Orthodox theologians or apologists! (I left out Eastern Orthodox, only because so many people aren't even aware that these other Apostolic Churches exist!)
    And of course, Ray Comfort! A good choice! I would love to hear you dialogue with Fr Calvin Robinson & Fr Brett Murphy & An Anglican Catholic Priest --- solid former Anglican priests!
    Bring in some KJVO UA-camrs as well! And maybe even some DROs!
    I think a conference is a great idea! Apart from the big names like Reason and Theology, get some of the smaller channels involved too. There's some young guys out here like Jaiden Forrest (not Catholic) and Cameron Riecker (Catholic) who are really making some awesome content and I think really have good hearts and are not afraid to think about their faith. It would be interesting to see Believing Thomas (a devotee of the SSPX) and Anthony Stine involved and Matt Whitman (an open hearted Protestant) and Ready to Harvest and TJ McCarty and of course Gospel Simplicity! There are loads of others!
    It would be a really spicy conversation, but Sam Shamoun would be an interesting interview as well!

  • @newglof9558
    @newglof9558 День тому +6

    Some Discord is organizing a spam war with Trent w/ debating Boylan on the Immaculate Conception.
    Hey LDS boys: Robert Boylan should debate Christian B. Wagner on Trinitarianism. He's having a weekend where he defends the Trinity against unitarians. You all should call in.

  • @shannonmaria22
    @shannonmaria22 День тому +6

    By “no ads,” I’m not sure if you mean no ads period, or no “sponsored during the episode” ads. Just in case it’s the former, I feel the need to say this as a fellow content creator. If you do not run ads on UA-cam, you are leaving A LOT of money on the table. UA-cam runs the ads no matter what. But if you keep ads “off,” the only difference is that it all goes to UA-cam’s pockets instead of both of your pockets. All of this to say, if the ads are turned off, I would prayfully reconsider if you haven’t already. This is money that would allow the channel to advance much faster. There is no shame in Catholic Answers getting paid for something that the team works so hard for. Especially if it’s all just getting invested back into evangelizing. Either way, thank you Trent and team for all the amazing work you do. 🙏🏻

  • @HeraldOfTheChange
    @HeraldOfTheChange День тому +1

    I love the Counsel of Trent. I discovered this channel when earlier this year after I finally decided to stop being a legacy Catholic and actually get back to Church. There's not much local Catholic resources online in the country where I live so this channel has been a fundamental resource for me. I have learnt so much now and I truly appreciate the work you have done. Thank you Trent (and your team!).

  • @Mike-bn7kr
    @Mike-bn7kr День тому +1

    It would really be interesting. Seeing you do interviews of other interesting Catholics and non-Catholics alike. I think you have so much potential to tap into. please put plenty of prayer into where the Holy Spirit wants to take your ministry and your support of all of us Christians. You are a fantastic apologist and not only that you’re very well read on all kinds of literature that could be very interesting and beneficial and helping build faith. Thank you for your hard work and commitment to those out there who are needing somebody to help lead them correctly in Catholicism and what it is to truly be Christian. It would be very interesting to see you bring on some regular ordinary amazing Catholics from around the country. Who are doing interesting projects and their own parishes or communities. And how they accomplished some of the things they have done in their local areas. Some of these people are amazing and are not noticed or recognized by anybody.

  • @Mike-bn7kr
    @Mike-bn7kr День тому +1

    I run a small Catholic Men’s Group at my parish. I would love to see you do 15 minute shorts that could help people in men’s groups or women’s groups or whatever kinds of groups that are out there. Or even CCD teachers. Where it’s short enough that you can have time to have discussion time within an hour or two an hour hour and a half and watching your video at the same time. That would be really awesome if you could do some things like that.

  • @mortensimonsen1645
    @mortensimonsen1645 День тому +1

    Yes, CoT must continue to grow. I needed just a small nudge to become a monthly patron. Thanks for all you have given me, I would like others to receive it as well. Kind regards former Prot

  • @Isaiah53-FL
    @Isaiah53-FL День тому +1

    I think with how dark the world is becoming, it may be time to pivot away from ecumenical debates or dialogues and focus on the lost. The ecumenical stuff, while beneficial, sometimes comes across as friendly fire.

  • @ThomasBrownLDS
    @ThomasBrownLDS День тому +9

    I would love to see Trent have a dialogue and/or debate with Robert Boylan on the immaculate conception. He is an ex-Catholic turned LDS, and many in the LDS church consider him the most qualified to discuss this topic

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +1

      An account that started 5 weeks ago and the first comment asking for a Boylan debate with Trent. Lmao is your arm chair QB ready to get off the couch?

    • @ThomasBrownLDS
      @ThomasBrownLDS День тому

      @@alisterrebelo9013This isn’t the first comment I’ve left since having this account.
      If Robert is an “armchair QB” then it should be fun for Catholics to watch Trent dump on him. They should be in support of making that happen.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому

      ​@@ThomasBrownLDS Perhaps it would have been better for you to ask me WHY I called Robert an armchair QB. I don't go around calling people such terms, but Robert does deserve it from my perspective.
      Reason 1 - Are you aware that Robert had accepted a debate on either PWA or Capturing Christianity in 2022 of 2023 to debate a Catholic? And when Robert found out some days later that the opponent would be Jimmy Akin, that Robert cancelled?
      Reason 2 - Robert has only debated once (that I know of), but feel free to correct me. It was a 2vs2 against some third rate Protestants, and Robert used a lot of Catholic arguments against Sola Scriptura in that debate.
      When Robert had a chance to debate a top Catholic apologist, he cancelled, and when he does debate, it's never solo and always against questionable opponents. Hence my labelling him as an armchair QB. He simply doesn't have any track record of speaking to a diverse group of knowledgeable opponents.
      If Trent has the time, and inclination, I hope he does take on Robert, and opens your eyes to the lies you speak of the Catholic Church.

    • @ThomasBrownLDS
      @ThomasBrownLDS День тому +1

      @@alisterrebelo9013
      >Perhaps it would have been better for you to ask me WHY I called Robert an armchair QB. I don't go around calling people such terms, but Robert does deserve it from my perspective.
      Whatever the reason you think Robert is an "armchair QB" is irrelevant to what I said in the original comment. So no, it would not have been "better" to ask you why.
      >Reason 1 - Are you aware that Robert had accepted a debate on either PWA or Capturing Christianity in 2022 of 2023 to debate a Catholic? And when Robert found out some days later that the opponent would be Jimmy Akin, that Robert cancelled?
      That's incorrect. Robert originally spoke with Jimmy Akin in 2020 and offered to do a debate on The Book of Abraham, but Jimmy and Matt Fradd refused and instead wanted the debate topic to surround the entirety of the uniquely-LDS scriptures. THAT is the point where Robert refused to debate, citing that the debate topic was unreasonable due to how unfocused it would be. Each book in the LDS scriptural canon is unique from one another in both their content and in their translation, and each requires a significant amount of depth to explain and defend. Expecting an LDS apologist to debate the veracity of ALL of the scriptures in a single debate setting is ridiculous, and Jimmy and Matt know this. In an email exchange, Matt even cited Robert's concerns as "reasonable", and yet did nothing.
      Fast-forward to 2023 and Robert is once again invited onto PWA due to requests from Latter-day Saints to have PWA talk to Robert. Upon contact, Robert once again requested to have a focused debate on ONE of the uniquely Latter-day Saint scriptures, and Jimmy once again declined for the same reason. Jimmy again wanted to force Robert to have to defend the entirety of the LDS scriptures. So once again, Robert backed out, citing the unreasonable debate terms.
      The fact that Robert originally offered to debate The Book of Abraham and Jimmy refused, and THEN Jimmy later tried to deflect and make it look like Robert is the one who is scared to debate is absurd.
      >Reason 2 - Robert has only debated once (that I know of), but feel free to correct me. It was a 2vs2 against some third rate Protestants, and Robert used a lot of Catholic arguments against Sola Scriptura in that debate.
      I'm unaware of how many debates Robert has done formally, but I know for a fact that he has offered to debate James White, Jeff Durbin, Jimmy Akin, Bill McKeever, Eric Johnson, Lynn Wilder, Micah Wilder, "Pastor Jeff" (Hello Saints), and It's Me Jessie. ALL of the aforementioned individuals are critics of Mormonism and have produced content that has amassed views on social media ranging anywhere from hundreds of thousands to tens of millions. And not a single one has accepted Robert's offer.
      >When Robert had a chance to debate a top Catholic apologist, he cancelled,
      See my above comment.
      > and when he does debate, it's never solo and always against questionable opponents. Hence my labelling him as an armchair QB. He simply doesn't have any track record of speaking to a diverse group of knowledgeable opponents.
      He would have a better track record if the above-mentioned opponents of Mormonism actually had the guts to put their money where their mouth is, but they don't. They're not actually interested in having a dialogue with an informed Mormon. They just want to talk down to us and tell us we're wrong.
      >If Trent has the time, and inclination, I hope he does take on Robert,
      I have a modicum of respect for Trent for talking to Jacob Hansen, but Jacob is just an internet personality. My respect for Trent would skyrocket if he actually debated Robert. Or if not Robert, I would respect Trent for debating an actual LDS scholar, like say, Blake Ostler.

  • @brittanyduben9984
    @brittanyduben9984 День тому +1

    Would love to see a debate/conversation with John Piper from Desiring God!

  • @miguelacosta123
    @miguelacosta123 7 годин тому +1

    Does purchasing merchandise support the channel?

  • @kevinphillips150
    @kevinphillips150 День тому +6

    Instead of bringing in Protestants, bring members of the SSPV, SSPX, CMRI, etc.

  • @alleydi8120
    @alleydi8120 День тому +1

    Trent have you considered debating Bobert Roylan ?

  • @thegentlemanly6299
    @thegentlemanly6299 День тому +20

    Debate Robert Boylan.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому

      An account that started 8 years ago ago and the first comment asking for a Boylan debate with Trent. Lmao is your arm chair QB ready to get off the couch?

    • @thegentlemanly6299
      @thegentlemanly6299 День тому

      @alisterrebelo9013 I've used this account for 8 years, buddy. Boylan would crush Trent, which is why Trent hasn't done a debate with him.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому

      ​@@thegentlemanly6299 Can you tell me why Robert ran from a debate that he agreed to do with either PWA or Capturing Christianity last year or 2022, when he found out he would be facing Jimmy Akin?

    • @thegentlemanly6299
      @thegentlemanly6299 День тому

      @alisterrebelo9013 No, because I don't speak for Robert. I am aware of his credentials and arguments. Have you read any of his books? Particularly on Mariology or Sola Scriptura?

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому

      ​@@thegentlemanly6299 The next time you try and insinuate Trent is running away from your armchair QB, be ready with an answer for how your man has ran from Jimmy.
      I've read Robert's blog more than the average non-LDS person would, over the last 2 years. The way he presents his arguments, is incoherent and unprincipled - something that will get exposed out in a formal debate. So no surprises, he has avoided debates for most of his career in the public eye.
      The typical way he critiques an opposing view for example a Catholic doctrine, is to cite the opposing view from every single person he can find regardless of their theological background, i.e. orthodox, secular, athiest, Protestant etc. This is called cherry picking from other groups, without a substantive understanding of the basis of their opposition which would also demolish LDS doctrines.

  • @noahairmet9546
    @noahairmet9546 День тому +84

    Your debate with Hansen on the Book of Mormon is already one of the top ~75 most viewed videos on Pints with Aquinas, which is impressive considering their volume. A debate with Robert Boylan on the Immaculate Conception would be 10x better-- both of you are 10x more knowledgable on the subject. Let that sink in.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +3

      Robert Boylan taking any debate, and in particular against Trent Horn is on nobody's bingo card. The man by all appearances is an arm chair QB.

    • @Will-ge7ri
      @Will-ge7ri День тому

      Yeah, but I bet a ton of those views are Mormons thinking the LDS guy won. That debate will be used by Mormons to prove the validity of their faith for years. Horrible topic choice.

    • @noahairmet9546
      @noahairmet9546 День тому

      @@alisterrebelo9013 You must have missed the time that Akin refused to debate Boylan in anything other than a blatant Gish gallop-- Boylan even offered to defend the BoA in a debate(by anyone's admission, the hardest book in LDS extra canon to defend) and Akin wouldn't do it. He's got them cornered.
      Also, see Thomas Brown's refutation of the same point you were trying to make about Akin. He kept better receipts than you did. 😉

    • @SuperOverlord999
      @SuperOverlord999 День тому

      ​@@noahairmet9546The BoA is a forgery.

    • @bitterclinger8964
      @bitterclinger8964 20 годин тому +1

      I hate to admit it as a Christian, but Hansen mopped the floor with Trent.
      It's much better when more knowledgeable Christians like Sam Shamoun or Jay Dyer deal with LDS folk.

  • @BelieverinChrist4ever
    @BelieverinChrist4ever День тому +1

    Good bless! I hope this channel goes as far as God allows ❤

  • @SpaceMason_02
    @SpaceMason_02 День тому +23

    You should really consider debating Robert Boylan. There's much more to win against an LDS apologist who focuses on Catholicism than, say, Hansen.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +4

      An account that started 1 week ago and the first comment asking for a Boylan debate with Trent. Lmao is your arm chair QB ready to get off the couch?

    • @Gabagoober
      @Gabagoober День тому +1

      @@alisterrebelo9013yeah what is with these guys? Bots?

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +2

      ​@@Gabagoober Having communicated with a few of these NPCs, it seems that Robert Boylan has finally decided to debate a Catholic, that is after he cancelled a debate he signed up with PWA or Capturing Christianity 1-2 years ago, when he found out it was Jimmy Akin he would be debating.
      These guys are Robert's fan girls come out here to put pressure on Trent.

  • @robertdean741
    @robertdean741 День тому +1

    How about bringing on Dr Robert Sungenis ??

  • @tc9459
    @tc9459 День тому +14

    Love to see you debate Pope Francis

  • @greypilgrim9967
    @greypilgrim9967 День тому +5

    I fully agree with and share Vanessa's sentiment about being encouraged by what Trent is doing to reach out or engage with or talk to non-Catholics (and learn how to do that well).

    • @TheCounselofTrent
      @TheCounselofTrent  11 годин тому

      You guys inspire us so much! So, thank you! -Vanessa

  • @shlamallama6433
    @shlamallama6433 День тому +1

    Mormon spam in the comments

  • @marrth649
    @marrth649 День тому +1

    Debate Robert Sungenis on geocentrism

  • @oshynnobmann4950
    @oshynnobmann4950 День тому +18

    I would love to see a debate with Robert Boylan on the immaculate conception.

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +1

      An account that started 3 years ago and the first comment asking for a Boylan debate with Trent. Lmao is your arm chair QB ready to get off the couch?

  • @TitusConstantine
    @TitusConstantine 16 годин тому

    35:45 "A jew that does jew jutsu" congratulations you have become a South Park character

  • @DanielTovar-v6t
    @DanielTovar-v6t День тому +20

    Love your content! PLEASE debate Robert Boylan on the immaculate conception!

  • @snookieg2409
    @snookieg2409 День тому

    Clearly, because the channel is growing, you have tapped into a real need. Thanks be to God!!! However, I will probably tune in less, I really don't enjoy the dialogues and debates. I am already Catholic, so I may not be your target audience, but I am so glad you are producing content that may sway non-Catholics, that is amazing. I miss the old days when you would do 1.5-2.0 hours of taking apart and explaining why a protestant is incorrect about Catholicism. I was poorly catechized when I converted and those videos were SO EXTREMELY HELPFUL figuring out how to explain the more complex teachings of the faith. I always get excited when it is a video like that, even if it is short. I am certainly not going to unsubscribe and I will be praying for you and the channels success, but it does make me a little sad that I may not be consuming as much of your content in the future. Good luck and God bless all of you!

  • @NatePewsAndQs
    @NatePewsAndQs 6 годин тому

    Donated. I hope everyone can donate $1-$10. There's so many of us that a 20k goal is nothing we can't reach.

  • @PrestonNielson-je9mh
    @PrestonNielson-je9mh День тому +16

    Hey Trent have you ever debated Robert Boylan?

    • @alisterrebelo9013
      @alisterrebelo9013 День тому +1

      An account that started 1 year ago and the first comment asking for a Boylan debate with Trent. Lmao is your arm chair QB ready to get off the couch?

  • @joyhenry-dp8nd
    @joyhenry-dp8nd День тому

    I am excited to see what the Lord will do with this channel and the changes to come.
    - What about a discussion with a late term abortionist who still performs them?
    - Or Jillian Michaels (Matt Walsh was just on her podcast and they discussed God, marriage, sex, family and the need for both fathers and mothers… she came at all of it in good faith and respect and openly says she knows very little about Jesus Christ).
    - Or one of our non Catholic Christians like Dallas Jenkins, the creator of the Chosen?
    - I would love to see more discussions regarding birth control, especially for Protestant Christians (Louise perry, Sarah hill, Scott klusendorf, Patrick Coffin, Stephanie grey Connors and Mike gaskins come to mind as people with different views and perspectives).

  • @scotthurban8200
    @scotthurban8200 День тому

    I know a channel cannot be everything and this channel seems to emphasize outreach to our 'seperated brethren,' but I wonder if there could be some outreach to the culture in general. I know Trent, you have done this in regards to pro-life issues, but the America I love has been changed from a life affirming culture to the "Culture of Death." Scriptural references are often lost on the younger generations. I taught in public schools and the knowledge of Judeo-Christian tradition is near non-existence. One would need to reason with such lost sheep as St Paul did to the Athenians with the 'unknown God." Can more of this be done?

  • @sarasofiacastro6750
    @sarasofiacastro6750 День тому

    Trent, i really love it when you have commentaries on the culture. Like what you think of modern superheroes and animation. Maybe a free for all fridays collab with other cultural commentators also? Regards to Laura! We miss her! God bless your ministry.

  • @Matthew_Prescott
    @Matthew_Prescott День тому

    Great work guys, and congratulations on the growth. I look forward to even more quality content, and seeing what you have in store. As far as suggestions for interviews, I'd like to see you speak with Jordan Peterson.

  • @ThomasRiches
    @ThomasRiches День тому

    Thanks Trent for everything you do! The expansion plans sound great, I hope your wisdom can continue to educate many more people on Catholicism

  • @scratchdatoff4abog
    @scratchdatoff4abog День тому

    I’d like to see discussions with catholics you disagree with as well. you made a video about catholic fundamentalism and you had critics of that video that are willing to dialogue. You can have very deep topics to go into about the Church

  • @Patrick_Bard
    @Patrick_Bard День тому

    Was this the same webinar scheduled to 3:15 pm PST? (now: 2:56 pm PST)

  • @OxyCleanForYourBrain
    @OxyCleanForYourBrain День тому

    I've purchased your books, and I'm gifting them as well.

  • @SamuelMartinez-io1hg
    @SamuelMartinez-io1hg День тому

    Do you have any merch on your website? If not, I hope you make some soon, I love your content and wish you nothing but the best! God bless 🙏

  • @RGabeDavis
    @RGabeDavis День тому

    If the Church is ever to come back together in one communion it will be the debating and fellowship that is spoken about here that will bring that closer.

  • @hismajesty6272
    @hismajesty6272 День тому

    Channels like this one and Redeemed Zoomer got me from non denominationalism to planning on becoming Anglican. God bless.

  • @sumrchick600
    @sumrchick600 День тому

    Would love to see you vs Andrew Wilson with the growth of his channel and Eastern Orthodoxy

  • @marionladdwilliams5003
    @marionladdwilliams5003 День тому

    The new logo is great. I do still like the Trent cartoon guy. Definitely hope I can help in the future.

  • @Being_Joe
    @Being_Joe День тому

    I'm a fan of Brad Warner of Hardcore Zen. I would love to see a conversation between you two.

  • @AbrahamRodriguez-gi1wk
    @AbrahamRodriguez-gi1wk День тому

    Thanks for you effort , Counsel of Trent team very appreciate that yall are open to us the financial supporters.

  • @1ccortez
    @1ccortez День тому

    Kirkland Sparkling Water grapefruit flavor!

  • @Platosrepublican
    @Platosrepublican День тому

    It would be cool to have Alex O’Connor on to have a dialogue

  • @davidfunk6698
    @davidfunk6698 День тому

    I funny. Lol dicy group, lots of young Christian tho

  • @DavidJasonHarper
    @DavidJasonHarper День тому +16

    Debate Robert Boylan on the Immaculate Conception, and debate Blake Ostler on the Nature of God! Come'on man, professional apologist like you can handle em! Don't let these Mormons scare you!

    • @faiths6597
      @faiths6597 День тому +3

      A better idea would be to start a dialog with them, then perhaps they will eventually debate. Just dialog would be a great start.

    • @DavidJasonHarper
      @DavidJasonHarper День тому +5

      @@faiths6597 that would work, too! Just like how he dialogued with Hansen before their actual debate.

    • @faiths6597
      @faiths6597 День тому +4

      @@DavidJasonHarper yes it’s easier to debate someone you’ve at least met and talked to. It lessens some of the stress.

  • @Foxie770
    @Foxie770 День тому

    JONATHAN PAGEAU
    JORDAN PETERSON
    FTHR JOSIAH TRENHAM