CRITICAL OR ATTACK SPEED MELISSA: WHICH BUILD IS BETTER?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 чер 2023
  • Which Build is Better for Melissa? Trinity vs Critical Build
    Hey guys, what's up? In this video, we're going to be comparing two different builds for Melissa: the Trinity Build and the Critical Build. We'll be testing both builds to see which one comes out on top in terms of damage, durability, and utility.
    The Trinity Build
    The Trinity Build is a more balanced build that focuses on giving Melissa a good mix of damage, durability, and utility. It consists of the following items:
    Cursed Needle
    Demon Hunter Sword
    Scarlet Phantom
    Windtalker
    Blade of Despair
    The Critical Build
    The Critical Build is a more damage-oriented build that focuses on maximizing Melissa's critical hit chance and damage. It consists of the following items:
    Berserker's Fury
    Scarlet Phantom
    Windtalker
    Blade of Despair
    Immortality
    Which Build is Better?
    So, which build is better for Melissa? It really depends on your playstyle and the enemy team composition. If you're looking for a more balanced build that will allow you to do a little bit of everything, then the Trinity Build is a great option. However, if you're looking for a more damage-oriented build that will allow you to burst down enemies quickly, then the Critical Build is the way to go.
    Which Hero Builds Should We Compare Next?
    In the comments section below, let us know which hero builds you would like us to compare next. We're always looking for new and interesting builds to test, so we'd love to hear your suggestions.
    Notice: This content is created based on Moonton’s Material and complies with Derivative Content Policy, Moonton does not endorse this content.
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 320

  • @justinmartinez2345
    @justinmartinez2345 Рік тому +196

    I'm always using critical Melissa and I can't wait for the adjustment of haas claws and scarlet

    • @maktummasrooramyo6997
      @maktummasrooramyo6997 Рік тому

      ​@@Goruden_4407minga

    • @cewkie
      @cewkie Рік тому +3

      @@Goruden_4407 the natalia buff was so unexpected

    • @benjaminlim1205
      @benjaminlim1205 Рік тому

      ​@@cewkieI instantly knew it by seeing her channel name Golden_4407, report it

    • @Terrano4
      @Terrano4 Рік тому

      ​@@Goruden_4407 wp on the bait

    • @jillvertes4096
      @jillvertes4096 Рік тому

      Can you tell me ur build please?

  • @ken_dough
    @ken_dough Рік тому +38

    I like this comparison videos. Though these tests are only for late game builds, might be worthwhile to also compare their early to mid game and their item powerspikes

  • @tgeiii3554
    @tgeiii3554 Рік тому +31

    The tower push test will always favor the atk. speed build since Scarlet’s passive doesn’t work on turrets.

    • @waaahhhvishhh9408
      @waaahhhvishhh9408 Рік тому +2

      ​@HappyTauras usual those troll developers got our hopes up

  • @satsuki697
    @satsuki697 Рік тому +1

    Really wanted know this .. thanks Elgin ✨️

  • @axgbb
    @axgbb Рік тому +1

    Yay finally, I was one of those that suggested this comparison when the Moskov comparison video came out. Please try out Zilong or Argus next

  • @OlBlO2l2lllZ
    @OlBlO2l2lllZ Рік тому +19

    If DHS is added with the Crit build the results with a tanky target may differ.

  • @icession4872
    @icession4872 Рік тому +17

    At this point might as well adjust the build according to enemy but...
    When the new adjusted items comes maybe Crit might have the upper edge a bit because of Haas claws. But that's just me although you gotta admit that passive can be clutch from time to time so maybe this video will need a small update.

  • @Monkey_Luffy01
    @Monkey_Luffy01 Рік тому +62

    It depends on the enemy line up. If most heroes on the enemy are squishy, go for the crit. But if there is more tanky hero, then go for attck speed.

    • @phoenixboygaming9981
      @phoenixboygaming9981 Рік тому

      yup, i was abt to comment that lol :)

    • @jellynone2291
      @jellynone2291 Рік тому

      So u got here first huh?

    • @cake3397
      @cake3397 Рік тому

      You can dash more with trinity than crit. There will always be tanky heroes in high ranks. Against squishy heroes both builds kill them very fast so imo it doesn’t matter whether the enemy line up has more squishy or tanky heroes and that trinity is just better just my opinion of course

    • @captainnyan-nyan2005
      @captainnyan-nyan2005 Рік тому

      ​@@cake3397which is the reason there's the need for the buffing for critical builds.

    • @wilmatomalon4949
      @wilmatomalon4949 Рік тому

      I prefer both😅

  • @josephconradisidro
    @josephconradisidro Рік тому +10

    you should also consider other factors such as
    cost effectiveness, crit build is slightly cheaper by 90 gold, not that much difference.
    which will help you farm better in the early, mid and late game. - early game, building tier 2 like swift corssbow and vampirr mallet can make a difference.
    Item effects can help on one on one and laning - corrosion scythe can help in chasing, while DHS has lifesteal for lane sustain

    • @youagain8447
      @youagain8447 Рік тому +1

      For Melissa specifically, the crit build has one other advantage, that being Windtalker's passive helps you clear lanes so much faster than other MM thanks to her passive (25% more dmg against non-hero units). This can reduce how long you show on the map, which means you'll be safer against ganks
      For sustain with crit build, i personally think the base lifesteal stat you get from MM emblem is more than enough (you can even double down on it by putting stat points in lifesteal too). She's usually used with Inspire too, so i think it's more than enough.

  • @iTwist24
    @iTwist24 Рік тому

    the comparison that we need

  • @jasphervillarasa9455
    @jasphervillarasa9455 Рік тому

    Hi elgin. Been watching all your videos. As far as I know, normal skin has +8 attributes.

  • @suskun4892
    @suskun4892 Рік тому +24

    Comparing Argus with both builds might be interesting.

  • @sarcastyt8654
    @sarcastyt8654 Рік тому +2

    Compare which better build for guinevere, tank build or mage build next due to her recent buff/adjustment

  • @_simj
    @_simj Рік тому +2

    I preferred
    -attck speed boots
    -corrosion scythe
    -wind talker
    -Bersekers fury
    -scarlet phantom
    -rose gold/demon hunter
    I usually used this when Im facing less tanky heroes and I especially like to use this because of the movement speed lol

  • @cutegirlcaloocan8547
    @cutegirlcaloocan8547 Рік тому

    Maraming salamat po natutunan nya ako mahalin dahil dito

  • @ewkaris
    @ewkaris Рік тому

    Finally this video is for me because I am Melissa main

  • @Malenia_BladeOfMiquella
    @Malenia_BladeOfMiquella Рік тому +14

    If you're not sure what yo build, just build hybrid with Corrosion,DHS,Windtalker and Berserker's fury..remove the Golden Staff that negates crit..then just adjust accordingly (build WoN/Haa's or whatever 1 defensive item u want)..this is how I build Argus almost all the time.

    • @Yuri-21
      @Yuri-21 Рік тому

      That's how i use Melissa

    • @albertcelzo8103
      @albertcelzo8103 Рік тому +1

      Well, thanks for this. Love from PH 🇵🇭 bro 😊

    • @albertcelzo8103
      @albertcelzo8103 Рік тому

      How about the boots? Is swift boots the default for melissa and argus?

    • @Malenia_BladeOfMiquella
      @Malenia_BladeOfMiquella Рік тому +1

      @@albertcelzo8103 Yeah, attack spd boots, you can go defensive boots though, it just really depends on you , I'm just sharing what I do..based on experience 👍

    • @justanormalperson5909
      @justanormalperson5909 Рік тому +3

      Id say scarlet is better than windtalker bcs more crit rate and atk and almost the same atk speed

  • @ilovemlbbandgenshin_42069
    @ilovemlbbandgenshin_42069 Рік тому +1

    I use atk speed build except instead of staff i use scarlet phantom and i must say its worth a try!

  • @DaaaaamnDaniel
    @DaaaaamnDaniel Рік тому +1

    4:20 Video length. Nice 👍🏻

  • @kiefwyndham6150
    @kiefwyndham6150 Рік тому

    You should review Arlott, because right now I mainly use Arlott at full tank build items, he is way more efficient at gameplay, but perhaps u should review 😅

  • @flashyred9125
    @flashyred9125 Рік тому

    Thank you for doing it 🙏☺️

  • @lam-angwren2129
    @lam-angwren2129 Рік тому +23

    Going crit usually means she gets punished *hard* by blade armor. As if dhs build doesn't already suffer from it, crit is just too risky.

    • @thats_not_breezyshes_soo_windy
      @thats_not_breezyshes_soo_windy Рік тому

      More like vengeance

    • @lam-angwren2129
      @lam-angwren2129 Рік тому +1

      @@thats_not_breezyshes_soo_windy Vengeance returns a part of all the damage dealt. Blade armor only returns part of the main basic attack (excludes dhs) and a percentage of physical defense. So dealing more crit -> taking more damage

    • @justineespeno5408
      @justineespeno5408 Рік тому

      And dhs has lifesteal so it can sustain back the blade armor damage

  • @francisnielsaing3812
    @francisnielsaing3812 Рік тому +3

    How about you include survivability? It is one of the factors which build to use in a clash

  • @bruh_gamingOffical
    @bruh_gamingOffical Рік тому

    Hey Elgin can you make a video about popal and kupa which build is better?

  • @SimonSahara-zl9ck
    @SimonSahara-zl9ck Рік тому

    Can you make another which build is better video with Argus next time? Pls I'm just curious

  • @davesimpas2046
    @davesimpas2046 Рік тому +1

    Please do a 3way between tank, damage, and hybrid lancelot.

  • @sachinbhandari6708
    @sachinbhandari6708 Рік тому

    Eligin, I have a request for you
    can you start the camparion with two or three items and then increase the items gradually
    it will be more helpful to know which item set can help farm fast
    thank you, love you

  • @firstername
    @firstername Рік тому

    old thamuz spellvamp build vs current attack speed thamuz build would be cool

  • @avaavocado8840
    @avaavocado8840 Рік тому

    I love using attack speed honestly, she is so good to play as. as long as u have good teammates, u might even have a chance to have a savage in ranked

  • @TugsTuks
    @TugsTuks Рік тому

    finally build guide for melissa

  • @arvinkhurt2502
    @arvinkhurt2502 Рік тому

    Could you try next video about Zhask Magic Build?in which build is better?
    Because Zhask is my main mage and favourite hero Thanks

  • @SoloMonYamashita-Hermit
    @SoloMonYamashita-Hermit Рік тому

    What about comparing the builds with the inspire spell? Inspire spell probably is the most used spell on her.

  • @sammagtaos799
    @sammagtaos799 Рік тому +1

    I hope when you do test like this without skin for both cause skin have a little attribute like dmg or hp for tanky hero(s)

  • @kafkawanter.
    @kafkawanter. Рік тому

    I think next patch crit build will be better for Melissa especially with Haas claws revamp

  • @winmar2623
    @winmar2623 Рік тому

    Karrie next I wanna see juat curious

  • @MrElfblade
    @MrElfblade Рік тому

    I want to see ZL comparison next.

    • @MrElfblade
      @MrElfblade Рік тому

      @_._Real_Elgin My ass you fucking Scammers.

  • @lilmemer2193
    @lilmemer2193 Рік тому +2

    Do a Edith build guide, you will be surprised how many builds there are for edith

  • @shree5studios298
    @shree5studios298 Рік тому

    I think u should wait for the new hasses claw and sacarlet phantom before making another video 😊

  • @87P13
    @87P13 Рік тому +1

    I think the Golden staff is better with her for cdr of her dash/basic atk

  • @louie555
    @louie555 Рік тому +1

    Hey Kuya Elgin, I wanna know your thoughts about the different builds for edith, like Attack speed, High Defense, or High Hp build.

    • @aquacancergames
      @aquacancergames Рік тому +1

      high defense for ult form damage increase
      high hp for the initial form of edith

    • @louie555
      @louie555 Рік тому

      @_._Real_Elgin weeeeeh

  • @aaronandrade7528
    @aaronandrade7528 Рік тому

    Can You Try Badang Trinity Build vs Badang Penetration build Thank You

  • @havoc9969
    @havoc9969 Рік тому +3

    Bro the basic skin has +8 physical attack.

  • @tiramisu3636
    @tiramisu3636 Рік тому

    I'm usually use windtalker, dhs and berserkers for crit and hp based damage

  • @eugenequek6797
    @eugenequek6797 Рік тому

    I main mage/tank if I get forced to off pick marksman/fighter/assassin what heroes are the most versatile?

  • @Terrano4
    @Terrano4 Рік тому

    With the new scarlet phantom shed have decent mobility even without boots

  • @yuranuS7
    @yuranuS7 Рік тому

    U can combine the 2 build types
    Go scarlet,dhs,berserker,malefic,wind of nature
    U can easily kill squishy heroes at the same time melt tanks.

  • @dhrumilkotad1856
    @dhrumilkotad1856 Рік тому

    Please make a video on wanwan after her Nerf please

  • @biteall8590
    @biteall8590 Рік тому +1

    Test argus aspd vs high pen build

  • @elmiratoribio9074
    @elmiratoribio9074 Рік тому

    depends if the users are good at using melissa of any build that it can put

  • @GinsuSher
    @GinsuSher Рік тому

    Edith build guide please. There's a lot of Edith users in solo queque that dont freaking understand her passive and build magic items first.

  • @Yaying_jack
    @Yaying_jack Рік тому +5

    Isn't it the skin 😅

  • @elainnatividad104
    @elainnatividad104 Рік тому

    I wanna know which of these build is better for Hanabi.

  • @draconicrayquaza9106
    @draconicrayquaza9106 Рік тому +1

    Miya next with attack speed vs critical build

    • @ceyx1201
      @ceyx1201 Рік тому

      Crit is better, her passive is enough for attack spd

  • @healerdance7
    @healerdance7 Рік тому +1

    You should always go for attack speed on MM as one of the main roles is to push the objectives. It's not that big difference between the killing time on the crit and attack speed but when it comes with towers, crit cannot even compare with attack speed.

    • @dreii16
      @dreii16 Рік тому

      Some MMs don't take advantage of Attack Speed build. Yes they're one of the main roles to take down towers but they're also the main damage dealer in the team aside from the mage. Some MMs prefer critical build such as Irithel, Moskov (Although he prefers a hybrid build), Miya, Layla etc. because they can't capitalize on the items in the Attack Speed build (DHS only being advantageous for multiple attacks at once, Golden Staff requiring you to have atleast some sort of enabler etc.). The main reason why Attack Speed build even works is because of the survivability and sustainability you gain in exchange for damage and that cannot work well with MMs who's main strength IS their offence capability.

    • @healerdance7
      @healerdance7 Рік тому

      @@dreii16 Yeah, on some of them crit build works better because they have no benefits from the attack speed. But Moskov for example is, for me, better with the attack speed as it reduces the CD on his spells, therefore he can dash more frequently. So again, it's not that big difference between crit and attack speed build for the heroes that he's showing in these videos, so, for them attack speed build is just better

    • @vrdrpg1490
      @vrdrpg1490 Рік тому

      @@healerdance7 one of the problem i encounter usually when i use moskov atk speed build is ur guaranteed to lose against enemy mm with crit build. unless you ambush them or managed to stun with ur 2nd, he has lower basic attack range compare to others

  • @yedhu9456
    @yedhu9456 Рік тому +1

    Do miya next😅😅

  • @mhh4700
    @mhh4700 Рік тому

    With attack speed build you can dash upto 3 times if enemies are linked with 2nd skill. Soo that's a perk

  • @Mikey-tc9qv
    @Mikey-tc9qv Рік тому

    I prefer combining both builds, atk speed kills tanky heroes faster because of the demon hunter, so my default build is {corrosion scythe - demon hunter - scarlet phantom (instead of golden staff) - berserk fury - malefic roar (or wind if necessary)}

  • @darknaufil
    @darknaufil Рік тому +2

    When I use millisa I do hybrid build critical plus demon hunter and malefic roar or crimson scite I'm bad at spelling even though I'm gr 7 😅

  • @mibadi2631
    @mibadi2631 Рік тому

    I'll go for the Critical with scythe

  • @hanzrobertbeladas5386
    @hanzrobertbeladas5386 Рік тому

    Can you try argus for the build?

  • @krewfamandbeansforlife4853
    @krewfamandbeansforlife4853 Рік тому +1

    Im using atk speed but i think in the build adjustment i will have to use crit build now

  • @TheOneAndOnlyKafka
    @TheOneAndOnlyKafka Рік тому

    Can you do miya or karina?

  • @jacerebil
    @jacerebil Рік тому

    it really just depends if the enemy has a good tank(s) or not

  • @ggdebubusgm1230
    @ggdebubusgm1230 Рік тому +1

    Uhh remember skin can add 8+ physical attack

    • @Ichiro_Manlalaro
      @Ichiro_Manlalaro Рік тому +2

      After purchasing a skin, you will still get the attribute when even using the default skin.

  • @endyedru
    @endyedru Рік тому

    I refer a semi build instead
    Like using corosion scyth and scarlet phantom

  • @Mars-td7pb
    @Mars-td7pb Рік тому +1

    Ah wait, you should use both with skin, it adds +8 physical attack though.

  • @Val99.
    @Val99. Рік тому +2

    Trinity build is better if u want to utilize her first skill, you can use two dashes with one 2nd skill.

  • @ezabellaa
    @ezabellaa Рік тому

    Try critical build with DHS, works every time 😮‍💨

  • @justinegonzaga8174
    @justinegonzaga8174 Рік тому

    I pick both except I'm not using golden stadd

  • @Ssenikrum
    @Ssenikrum Рік тому +1

    Novaria: burst or cd reduction?

  • @Lucarioux
    @Lucarioux Рік тому

    seeing the kill times were very similar means that Trinity is overall better since it gives more lifesteal and slow than crit

  • @alnlsr
    @alnlsr Рік тому

    DO NATAN NEXT

  • @zagster1859
    @zagster1859 Рік тому

    Do a build test with Alpha!
    Attack Speed Build
    or
    Common Damage Build

  • @DrewSoquita
    @DrewSoquita Рік тому

    First baka naman HAHAHA😂

  • @alucardmorningstar2296
    @alucardmorningstar2296 Рік тому

    hi, i think I've seen that elimination effect in the hero skins event? anyone might want to clarify what is it? thank you

  • @nguzhitaocaydenspringfield76

    I want to see if critical build or attack speed build suits for Zilong

  • @verncent
    @verncent Рік тому

    You know I was thinking adding Corrosion Scythe & Demon Hunter Sword to the Crit build just remove the Golden Staff or make the Demon Hunter Sword as a.... I think when I just build it when I have many tanky enemies
    (I'm really bad at English vocabulary lol 😂)

  • @danielbudiono7232
    @danielbudiono7232 Рік тому

    haas claw update will reduce blade armor effect on critical build.
    i think critical build will be better once the update come

  • @BL4NK_-
    @BL4NK_- Рік тому

    next hanzo plss

  • @gon9768
    @gon9768 Рік тому

    Blade armor counter demin Hunter sword?

  • @karlthemuffinman
    @karlthemuffinman Рік тому

    Try Ixia next

  • @theslightlytiltedcat
    @theslightlytiltedcat Рік тому +1

    Brody Fast Attack with Crits vs Slow Attack with CRITS.

  • @raini9593
    @raini9593 Рік тому

    Maybe Freya too, better speed atk or crit?

  • @ardhisan1469
    @ardhisan1469 Рік тому

    Wait Elgin, the left one doesn't use skin so that will create a HUGE gap time of killinv.

  • @meowteaaa
    @meowteaaa Рік тому +2

    can we all appreciate layla for sacrifying her life for this experiment?

  • @ogdrak3n652
    @ogdrak3n652 9 місяців тому +2

    Skin mellisa have +8 physical attack advantage yk

  • @animeworld783
    @animeworld783 Рік тому

    How about mixed build?

  • @viridian8786
    @viridian8786 Рік тому

    Use the speed squad
    Crit speed with dhs and corrosion scythe

  • @ricoachacoso9678
    @ricoachacoso9678 Рік тому

    Fierce

  • @Ppp_ppp69
    @Ppp_ppp69 Рік тому +1

    The real question is which one is cheaper

  • @jhomarbello697
    @jhomarbello697 Рік тому

    its depend on situation more tanky hero trinity build . for non tanky build use crit buuld

  • @lakepu5385
    @lakepu5385 Рік тому

    Skin 8+attack?

  • @TheGamerSiddharth
    @TheGamerSiddharth Рік тому

    do for layla

  • @eksp0
    @eksp0 Рік тому

    Test hybrid build: tanky MM with atk spd (DH shred/GS) + Lifesteal
    I TELL YA - UNKILLABLE

  • @abraham8178
    @abraham8178 Рік тому

    Same experiment but with wanwan

  • @namelesssturdy4676
    @namelesssturdy4676 Рік тому

    That's how op scarlet phantom is.

  • @mr.archer4119
    @mr.archer4119 Рік тому

    can you try miya with those build?

    • @mr.archer4119
      @mr.archer4119 Рік тому

      Elgin, can you make a vid about this guy? Got him in screenshot

  • @choolwemujibelo1650
    @choolwemujibelo1650 Рік тому

    Both

  • @noobkingchou2010
    @noobkingchou2010 Рік тому

    Next can u do moskov

  • @Daily_short_machine
    @Daily_short_machine Рік тому

    balmond tank build vs balmond dmg build(crit)