Because there were better singers at the time like Raina and Jung Ah, and more popular members like Uee and Nana. It’s a shame we didn’t get to hear more of E-Young’s voice. Her character was also shy and reserved so maybe that’s why. Ka-Eun even though she came later she was somewhat more popular because she was more outgoing. I think E-Young was still adored by true fans nonetheless :)
Marabou I know Kaeun -> with Lime and Uji in a MV OC -> catallena Uee -> End promotion of Golden Rainbow Jung ah -> beauty bible and red carpet events jooyeon -> instagram and red carpet E-young-> no where to be seen... I hope everything goes well *knocks on wood* she better not graduate at next comeback.
I know it scares me, sometimes I think that she will graduate too. I really hope she stays, if After School loses her I won't know what to do with myself anymore. I hope we will get a selca or something from her soon, I need a sign that will show me that she is alove and well.
Oh my god Joo yeons part at 1:28. I have NEVER ever heard her sing that loud, it's awesome. Her parts in all the AS songs sounds so effing weak you can barely hear her.
She does sound great here, I hope their next tour also have great microphones and soundsystems so that her voice will be loud and clear. Still waiting for that one After School song where Jooyeon will shine, luckily she gets to rap in Because Of you these days which I found to be really nice.
I don't think Jooyeon sings that part normally, I'm pretty sure Jungah does. But I really wish Jooyeon got more vocal parts. Since she wasn't the best singer, I don't think they really knew what to do with her voice. Her parts are always the autotuned electronic parts. Even in the Japanese songs where they split into two groups: "Broken Heart" had the vocal girls, (except for Lizzy) Raina, Jungah, E-Young, & Nana. "Miss Futuristic", the electronic sounding one, has Kahi, Lizzy, Uee, & Jooyeon. I think they just kind of left her hanging as the visual with nothing else to do. And tbh she couldn't even milk that for all that it was worth because Nana joined the group and became super popular.
Pledis did E-young so dirty. Half of 2017 is nearly gone and she has not had a solo schedule since 2015. Even her fansite lost faith in Pledis, they said that they would never close down yet they did.
I know I feel you, I feel we are like the 2 absolute E-young fans! she was seen in a recording studio recently tho... who knows lets hope for something good for our e-young :)
I hope whatever that picture was that it means something. I am worried it is just a university project and that we will never hear it. :/ I wish we could see her more often. :( But it was nice that she updated her instagram two days in a row. :)
She has been one since 2012 but I have no idea how long an education as a bass major is but she should have graduated by now. It is possible that she is producing somehting for her old university.
Thank God!! Kahi saved the day!! i was a bit worried. who's gonna take bekah's part. Because uee, eyoung, jungah and juyoen they're not really good at rapping. but today, kahi has graduated. Who's gonna save AS????
+MultiAstroz I think that if they bring in a new member (which I don't think they need right now) they should bring in a rapper. Somebody like Bekah, a main rapper and sub vocal. They really don't have anyone right now who's really good at rapping. Sure, Nana and Lizzy have their raps here and there, but it's really not as great as Kahi or Bekah. The rapper order is probably like this right now: *1. Lizzy* (Raps in Flashback, but shes more of a vocal. She gets most of Bekah's old raps) *2. Nana* (Also more of a vocal. Had 2 raps in Flashback, and gets some of Bekah or Kahi's raps) *3. Kaeun* (She subbed for Nana's Flashback rap once, it was okay) *4. Jungah/Uee* (Uee kinda "talk raps" sometimes, and I think Jungah's voice would sound good rapping) *4. Raina/E-Young* (I 've never heard Raina or E-Young rap. They both lean more to the vocal parts in songs.)
Joey Perez in most recent performance ( 2014 ) when OC is missing, eyoung raps in diva and in the new version of Because of you raina replace kahi's rap now
+windlife I think there are better clips of Uee singing this song. Her voice sounds way more modified here then this song calls for. As for E-Young, I think this was a cool decision to put her in here. It's not like she's in a sub-unit like Orange Caramel, so its cool to see her in here. Plus, shes probably one of the better dancers in the group.
This is when kahi being generous and let eyoung to sing more than 1 line AND being center in one of the chorus. What a rare occasion
You said that as if Kahi is a bad person. Weird.
Eyoung is a decent vocalist idk why shes so underrated
Because there were better singers at the time like Raina and Jung Ah, and more popular members like Uee and Nana. It’s a shame we didn’t get to hear more of E-Young’s voice. Her character was also shy and reserved so maybe that’s why. Ka-Eun even though she came later she was somewhat more popular because she was more outgoing. I think E-Young was still adored by true fans nonetheless :)
Always feel proud of E-young standing strong with her unnies :)
She is strong but underrated by pledis
Seeing Kahi let Eyoung to stomp and killed this debut song of AS. Ah this feeling.
0:44 URGHHH E-young I miss her so much she's been MIA way too long, I wished her fanbase was bigger D:
I miss her so much too! I have heard something from every A.S. member recently except E-young, it makes me so sad, she has completely disappeared! :(
Marabou I know
Kaeun -> with Lime and Uji in a MV
OC -> catallena
Uee -> End promotion of Golden Rainbow
Jung ah -> beauty bible and red carpet events
jooyeon -> instagram and red carpet
E-young-> no where to be seen... I hope everything goes well *knocks on wood* she better not graduate at next comeback.
I know it scares me, sometimes I think that she will graduate too. I really hope she stays, if After School loses her I won't know what to do with myself anymore. I hope we will get a selca or something from her soon, I need a sign that will show me that she is alove and well.
Oh my god Joo yeons part at 1:28. I have NEVER ever heard her sing that loud, it's awesome. Her parts in all the AS songs sounds so effing weak you can barely hear her.
She does sound great here, I hope their next tour also have great microphones and soundsystems so that her voice will be loud and clear. Still waiting for that one After School song where Jooyeon will shine, luckily she gets to rap in Because Of you these days which I found to be really nice.
I don't think Jooyeon sings that part normally, I'm pretty sure Jungah does. But I really wish Jooyeon got more vocal parts. Since she wasn't the best singer, I don't think they really knew what to do with her voice. Her parts are always the autotuned electronic parts. Even in the Japanese songs where they split into two groups: "Broken Heart" had the vocal girls, (except for Lizzy) Raina, Jungah, E-Young, & Nana. "Miss Futuristic", the electronic sounding one, has Kahi, Lizzy, Uee, & Jooyeon. I think they just kind of left her hanging as the visual with nothing else to do. And tbh she couldn't even milk that for all that it was worth because Nana joined the group and became super popular.
I remember watching this live when I was off uni in the Uk. Bare in mind the time difference!! I was sooooo happy seeing this!! Xx
Almost 2019 and missing them PlayGirlz ❤ :')
EYOUNG SO PRETTY !!!!!!
YAsssss My E-Youngie in Ah!!!
the only member remaining from this performance is e-young... uee just graduated.
Pledis did E-young so dirty. Half of 2017 is nearly gone and she has not had a solo schedule since 2015. Even her fansite lost faith in Pledis, they said that they would never close down yet they did.
I know I feel you, I feel we are like the 2 absolute E-young fans! she was seen in a recording studio recently tho... who knows lets hope for something good for our e-young :)
I hope whatever that picture was that it means something. I am worried it is just a university project and that we will never hear it. :/ I wish we could see her more often. :( But it was nice that she updated her instagram two days in a row. :)
Is she really back to school ?
She has been one since 2012 but I have no idea how long an education as a bass major is but she should have graduated by now. It is possible that she is producing somehting for her old university.
Eyoung 🤎🤎❤️
what an unbelievabel live stage performance, have a look on this and remember with me on !!!!!!!!!
Uie Uie Uie I really Miss you 😘😘😘😘
Too excited seeing eyoung
woooooo I love this sung
Get it Eyoung!
uee canta genial
those were the days
가희없는 방과후는 있을 수 없다
Jooyeon 💕
They had a good run.
日本で、もっと、売り出せば、人気がでたと思いますけど、歌も、ダンスも、素晴らしい、２０２４年でも、ノリ、ノリです
Vee muy bien
Omg more lines for Juppal
0:33 0:46 Jooyeon part ♡
Thank God!! Kahi saved the day!!
i was a bit worried. who's gonna take bekah's part. Because uee, eyoung, jungah and juyoen they're not really good at rapping.
but today, kahi has graduated. Who's gonna save AS????
+MultiAstroz I think that if they bring in a new member (which I don't think they need right now) they should bring in a rapper. Somebody like Bekah, a main rapper and sub vocal. They really don't have anyone right now who's really good at rapping. Sure, Nana and Lizzy have their raps here and there, but it's really not as great as Kahi or Bekah. The rapper order is probably like this right now:
*1. Lizzy* (Raps in Flashback, but shes more of a vocal. She gets most of Bekah's old raps)
*2. Nana* (Also more of a vocal. Had 2 raps in Flashback, and gets some of Bekah or Kahi's raps)
*3. Kaeun* (She subbed for Nana's Flashback rap once, it was okay)
*4. Jungah/Uee* (Uee kinda "talk raps" sometimes, and I think Jungah's voice would sound good rapping)
*4. Raina/E-Young* (I 've never heard Raina or E-Young rap. They both lean more to the vocal parts in songs.)
Joey Perez in most recent performance ( 2014 ) when OC is missing, eyoung raps in diva and in the new version of Because of you raina replace kahi's rap now
이노래생각이남ㅋㅋ
3:00 why is Kahi's head shaved? 😥
Oh wait that's just blonde hair -_-
Lol 🤣🤣🤣🤣
LMFAOOO
They could have a promising career in Japan...it's all because of the stupid managing company Pledis😠😠😠
True… i hate PLEDIS so much
it's true when kahi said that AH is no joke...only original member can sing this song....uee and eyoung voice not suitable for this song....
I think of all the members we have right now, Uee and Eyoung suits with this song the most.
+windlife I think there are better clips of Uee singing this song. Her voice sounds way more modified here then this song calls for. As for E-Young, I think this was a cool decision to put her in here. It's not like she's in a sub-unit like Orange Caramel, so its cool to see her in here. Plus, shes probably one of the better dancers in the group.
No babe eyoung killed it
she sounds fine, idk what ur talking abt...😒🙄
@ct jjhy I hate you
Instead of eyoung & Uee Nana & Raina should’ve gotten in without pitched voices
Adopt me please KAHI UNNIE !!!!