Gotta disagree on this one. Hermione is definitely the more knowledgable with different types of magic, but Harry has proven to cast more powerful attacks. And while for the most part I agree that skill beats power, in this case Harry, in my opinion, is actually on par, if not more skilled in duelling than Hermione. While before their prime, the fact that Harry managed to get an O in his DADA OWLs while Hermione managed to get a E, suggesting that Harry is in fact more knowledgable in the Dark Arts than Hermione. I disagree that Voldemort laying claim to Harry's life reduces Harry's feats. Stunning spells are equally as effective at ending a fight as the Killing Curse, and Harry has very rarely been hit by curses or spells. Neither has Hermione admittedly, but I believe Harry's more agressive style was enough (along with Siruis Black) to put Lucius Malfoy and Antonin Dolohov on their back foot, the later of which I find comparable to Snape and Bellatrix in duelling skills. While Hermione may be the faster of the two, Harry's shield charm is sufficient to block her spell, allowing him to retaliate with greater force. Last but not least, power. Bellatrix herself said "You have to mean it." All the knowledge in the world is no good if you dont apply it effectively. While Hermione is certainly determined in duels, Harry has that bit more of a killer's instinct. If they go all in, friendships not mattering at all, Harry will be the more overpowering of the two. Alas, like yourself, this is all my opinion.
I have read the book about 5 times and hermione got her O and harry got a E but everything is good except that Bellatrix said be smart is not always a good thing but she is one of the Enemy’s in the story.so I don’t agree on it but some things I do
Yeah I don't agree. I think Harry is waaayyy stronger. Even the spells he knows are enough to defeat Hermione. Harry is the only person who survived all 3 unforgettable curses. No one else had. Harry had so much inner strength that made his simple spells more powerful then ever. Harry knew the fighting tactics which are not learnt by books. It's natural. While Hermione would think about next spell to cast, cuz Harry knows only a handful, and useful spells he would've prevailed. Harry Could've taken on Hermione and Ron together at once. But Hermione was very close to Harry's skills. Technically Hermione is the better. Only after Harry though.
Spandan Dholakia not really there is no spell that Harry knows that Hermione does not and Hermione does is not lacking when it comes to dueling she may not be as powerful but overall skill she beats Harry not saying that it would be easy it would be very close but I don’t see Harry throwing anything out that Hermione could not counter.
@@masonguthrie1257 Agreed. But just knowing the spell is different than performing it. For eg, Lupin said Patronus is a very advanced spell. Students of Harry's age normally couldn't do it but bcz Harry had strong magical soul, he did it. Harry had a stronger magical power inside him than Hermione. She was the brightest witch, not necessarily strongest.
Spandan Dholakia yes but I feel by book seven that her dueling abilities have grown enough that with her extra knowledge she could beat Harry it would be close though.
Haven’t seen the video, but I say that Harry Potter wins if we take books and movies into account. 1. He was elected to be the leader of Dumbledore’s army. 2. He was able to fight Voldemort and combat his Avada Kedavra with a mere Expelliarmus spell in DH P2. 3. He got an outright better grade in DATDA, a combat oriented class, than Hermione in their 5th year. 4. He was able to repel dozens of dementors as a 13 year old. Hermione never cast a patrons until 2 years later.
almost all spells harry has mastered, hermione already learned them like ten years before harry. she is a GREAT fighter and harry couldnt beat voldemort if it wasnt for their connection. i accuatly think that bellatrix could take harry down hermione is also the smartest of them three and even serius black (sry if spelled wrong) she is the brightest witch of her time
but she would make him work its like minerva vs snape in the begining hermione will be winning she like minerva keep him off his toes but then harrry will throw her off balence and win but it would be very very hard.
That's not really true. Yeah obviously Harry would defeat hermione with easy. But even in potion class Harry is technically better than her. Of course he is a better pilot with his broom. I always find it weird that the fanbase think just because hermione is a book worm, she must be automatically the best in everything. Not only compared to Harry, because that's pretty much unfair, this guy was fighting dark wizards and basilisk as a child, I might remember that she also isn't a talented duelist in general.
Hermione is a better than Harry at knowledge of spells, but Harry destroys her at dueling. He has faster reflexes, can think quicker and can make up super fast desicions.
This is interesting and honestly I’m not sure. Harry has always been a natural at duelling but Danco raises some very good points about Hermione. Hmmmm.
Any who think Hermione has any chance of winning this is fully mad. Hermione fully outshines Harry schoolwise, but it isn’t by much. The thing that people who only watch the movies fail to realize is that Harry was a genius too, albeit not as much as Hermione. Harry, got N.E.W.T.S in almost all his tests. This is a mad feat of magic knowledge that is matched by few. Hermione was wiser then Harry, almost on another level. She knows more spells, but the thing we have to ask ourselves is; Can she perform them in battle? Harry is 1 of the best duelers in the verse. He was able to combat multiple older and mightier foes at a very young age, and became the Head Auror at the age of 26. He is the youngest Head Auror and never even graduated Hogwarts. He has fast reaction times, has a madly strong Protego, 1 that was able to fully block an unstable Fiendfyre, Something that we have only seen once. I can guarantee you only 2 characters in the series can even come close to this. His Stupefy was able to K.O. foes on its 1st strike, he was able to make a Patronus at the age of 13, something that we have never heard of before. He is extremely skilled in Charms and the best in his class for the subjects Defense Against the Dark Arts, and Transfiguration. He was the only 1 in his class that was able to edit his eyebrow's color in Transfiguration.In Defense Against the Dark Arts, he had a natural affinity for battling Dark Magic. He was the only 1 in his class to defy Moody’s Imperious Curse, something that not even Hermione managed. Did I forget to mention the Imperious Curse is the strongest Mind Curse there is? He also excelled in Charms class, only 2nd to Hermione. Harry was also gifted in Dueling. He knew when to strike and when to Shield, Dodge, Etc… Hermione was just wise. She knew many Charms, Jinxes, Hexes, Curses, Spells, but she was all bad. Her weakest point was dueling. While she knows many spells that are hard to reverse, like Silencio which can take away foes' more complex spells, she lacks the magic raw power and talent Harry has. Harry has a fighter's instinct, while Hermione is more analytical. She has no impressive dueling feats. thanks 7o7o7o7
how can he get the best N.E.W.T.S. if he did not graduate also its been explained hermione has a faster reaction time, and harry actually while smarter than most would give him credit for was no where near hermione. and as we see later in the books hermione has no issues dueling so. also hermione while she would know some darker spells would not use them and honestly i could see her overwhelming him with charms and transfiguration since he would not be able to counter it as easily if at all.
oh please litsen hermione isnt weak exeeds expectations isnt bad at all i agree in a 1 vs 1 dues harry would win (but not by much) you saw what she did to ferrir greyback and atonio dolohov ron even said she is the best at spells she by far the generally better and well rounded at transfigureation charms potions and far smarter this could give her an advantage.
No. Hermione has the knowledge but not the experience like Harry. Harry has fought way more characters and defeated them. Harry even got the control of the elder wand. With that he can kick Voldemort's ass whole day. Harry is just way more powerful, experienced. Skills round will go to Hermione but still skill isn't enough to beat cunningness of Harry. Harry wins this.
Great video! I really enjoyed it. In my opinion, Harry would win. Here's my ranking of the top young wizards in Harry Potter. 1. Harry Potter 2. Hermione Granger 3. Draco Malfoy 4. Ron Weasley 5. Neville Longbottum
ISHFLY Yeah those scenes show he’s a great duelist! There’s definitely a strong case for him being 2nd behind Harry. I think Draco vs Hermione would be a brutal battle and it’s honestly a toss up.
henry liu sure and what else does he know I mean a disarming spell is really simple and I don’t think that it was as useful if the books as it was in the movie. Especially since nothing can block the killing curse.
@@masonguthrie1257 You sound like Smith. Harry has a variety of things he can throw at Hermione. Hermione has even more, but it would be harder for her because shes less quick and would take longer to figure out what spell to use.
I agree. Hermione to me is the best witch. She just knows more spells than Harry. Knowledge is power. Dumbledore, Voldemort, Snape, McGonagall were all super knowledgeable. Talent alone is not enough. Hermione fought Bellatrix using Bella's wand and she managed to keep her at bay. Harry has more raw power, but Hermione has become good at duelling ans overall she is the most complete wizard of the 2
@@sonalipaul874 sure, but it doesn't mean that Hermione is gonna stand her and watch Harry cast the spell on her. Maybe she could conjure a shield and protect herself from the spell, who knows...
BigBadApe 005+ No Harry won because he was the true master of the Elder Wand. The horcruxes being destroyed only allowed Voldemort to be properly killed, it didn’t make his duelling skills any less.
See, no offense, but focus on the point that Harry has the wand of Voldemort, who no doubt would've killed Hermione easily as he's not to mention not called Dark Lord for no reason. Keeping in mind, Hermione got more skills, but not really too much more than Harry does, as he's clever in the way he uses spells as well, and has more power along with the power of Voldemort's wand being more powerful than the one Hermione posesses. So, tbh, Harry would win this one even though Hermione got more skills and knowledge in spells cuz Dumbledore VS Grenderwald was a whole another matter being honest.
Hassan Atros I wasn’t talking about hulk.... Do you know who hercules is? He has more strengh AND much more battle experience. There is no one who has more battle experience than him, he has fought for a millenium, so he lacks nothing on beating the jugg
Arc7X Angel no Harry could not throw anything at Hermione that she would not know the counter to her knowledge outclasses his slight dueling advantage.
Game Zone besides Voldemort hermione has basically fought with Harry in every battle. They both fought high level deatheaters and did well. Also I am talking about year 7 hermione every other year except 1 and 2 Harry would win but hermione got a lot more practical practice in her later years especially book 7
@@masonguthrie1257 though Hermione was with Harry but Harry have way better feats. In the second part he was worthy to find Gryfindor's sword. He killed basilisk. In the third part he defeated an entire group of Dementors alone. Harry has way more experience in different situation. Like in the 4th part he cleared every challenge of the Triwizard cup. In the 5th part he defeated Bellatrix. Even Voldemort was saying you know the spell, kill her. Bellatrix was the one who fought Hermione, Luna and Ginny alone and was winning. It was the 7th part from which Hermione was with Harry in battle. Harry is a far better duelist than Hermoine.
Game Zone with almost all of those Harry got really lucky not saying he was not skilled but he had lots of help and luck. I’m not saying it will not be close I am just saying I can’t see Harry throwing hermione off.
Or in a 3-way battle: Lucius Malfoy vs. Star Lord vs. Cad Bane Mace Windu vs. Grindelwald vs. Malcolm Merlin Darth Maul vs. Iron Spider vs. Bellatrix Lestrange Neo (end Matrix 1) vs. Ebony Maw vs. Dumbledore Abomination vs. Black Obsidian vs. Wonder Woman Kingsley Shacklebolt vs. Dark Anakin vs. Black Panther Minerva McGonagall vs. Old Ben vs. Red Skull (~First Avenger) Nightwing vs. Sirius Black vs.Chirrut Imne (Rogue One blind force user) Morgain le fey vs. Dr. Strange (MCU-b4 loop w/ Dormammu) vs. Darth Zannah Jason Borne (movies) vs. Captain America (movies but no shield) vs. Serpentor (Cobra leader)
II 神の怒り II honestly not so sure because while Harry did get better Hermione was so far ahead that he would have to be a dueling prodigy which I don’t see him as. Not saying Hermione is but she knows way to much to count her out in the later years.
Combative magic is ok but in a real battle, wont be enough. Remember the battle between voldemort and dumbledore they didn’t use any of those spells that used in general combats. I think harry would lose.
JKR literally said that Harry was already a better duelist than Hermione at the end of PoA, way before he actually started getting real combat/dueling experience. So yeah, this isn't even all that close - Harry is a natural genius when it comes to dueling and fighting in general, has way better combat feats and can put more power behind his spells; Hermione being more knowledgable and versatile simple isn't enough here. In a duel with certain rules I'm giving Harry the edge 8 times out of 10. In a real, morals-off fight he wins every single time.
@@appetizingly I mean with the death eaters she also faced when she was with Harry who had to be kept alive by command of Voldemort. The only time Harry is in real danger is against Voldemort and he loses which is fine that is op but like hermione was fair game to the death eaters and by book seven she was faster to the draw than Harry so while Harry is naturally gifted hermione was able to work hard and catch up.
@@masonguthrie1257 Not that it makes that much of a difference to the discussion but in OotP the Death Eaters didn't use lethal force against any of the students as long as Harry was around them which was the case for Hermione until Dolohov got her and she was out of the picture. In HPB the only combat experience she had was undemonstrated and with the added protection of Felix Felicis. And in DH literally every fight involved lethal force and they both pretty much got the same amount of combat experience. Not that all of the above matters when we have a direct quote from the author where she already favoured Harry before he had any real experience or started applying himself. Also, how was Hermione "faster to the draw"? If you're referring to the tent scene, that would be a circumstantial non-combat scenario where she was the observer - that doesn't really mean much, if anything at all. Like, give me a single feat of Hermione that puts her fighting skills above Harry's. Don't get me wrong, Hermione is damn good and second only to Harry amongst their age group but his natural combat instincts and raw power were literally his greatest strengths aside from Quidditch.
@@appetizingly uh the diner is a good scene her against beletrix I mean she had back up from Luna and Ginny but still that is a pretty huge deal. I don’t really count Beletrix’s death against molly as a downfall just because it was very lucky above all else just as a side note. I can understand why people choose Harry because he is the protagonist and so he should be the strongest but from looking at the evidence and doing a little guess work I just agree that hermione would win overall.
I would disagree because if Hermione was put in Harry's situation to fight off Voldemort she would stand the chance because of her lack of knowledge against the dark arts. With the death eaters and that drama Harry was supposed to be killed by Lord Voldemort because was Harry was his biggest threat considering he wanted to kill him as a baby. Voldemort did not want Harry to be killed by the death eaters because he wanted to finish what he started. Harry was a bigger threat than dumbledoor because of the prophecy. Let's also take a look at Harry's earlier school years where he had perfected spells some adult wizards and hermoine could not even perform at his age. I got to admit Hermoine did know some spells that Harry did not know but Harry knew more affective spells that he perfected at a young age. Even Hermoine could not perform those at that age. Just to add to the death eaters scenario Harry would be able to fight off them even if it was threat for his life. So in my opinion Harry is the more powerful wizard and effective wizard
Harry has less knowledge than hermione about the dark arts everyone knows about the unforgivables and they are pretty rudimentary curses in comparison to true dark arts. Also as the years went on Hermione shot up in actual dueling to the point where she would win though it would be close.
How about NO!!! Harry has far more natural Magical Power!! Creativity is pretty. It’s like saying a NFL team is a finesse team, they will be playing a team with a taller, stronger arm quarterback and 2 1,000 yard season running backs, and unflinching Defense. Your conclusion is pretty, has lots of finesse, but lacks logic. Best student rarely translates into best person in their chosen field. They languish in a culture that has different confusingly different. Harry takes down, in 1:00 minute or less in 1,000 out 1,000 times‼️🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼
I mean besides book four she has been there for everything and as previously stated she did not have the shield of being kept alive to be killed by the dark lord himself.
Come on DanCo do this tournament: all main Spiderman villains vs batman with prep time and all main batman villains Round one Tombstone vs mad hatter scorpion vs poison ivy Kraven the hunter Vs Ra’s al Ghul carnage Vs batman Sand man vs firefly kingpin Vs The penguin and solomon Grundy Rhino Vs bane electro Vs Clay face vulture Vs killer moth venom Vs killer croc lizard Vs mr freeze dr.octopus Vs death shot and Riddler green goblin Vs man-bat and two-face and cat woman Shocker Vs Joker and scarecrow Mysterio Vs Harley Quinn
Bro your point is harty is not powerful because he is not knowledgable in books even dumboldor said that knowledge is not everything and he has recognised Harry Potters potential very easily
While hermione knows more about magic, Harry is just a straight up better dueler, it’s something he is just natural at. Harry knew many spells but mainly use expelliarmus and stupefy obviously, while hermione used more spells I don’t think she would win in a fight against Harry. I forget if it was Jackie Chan or Bruce lee but they said he would fear a man who practiced one kick 1,000 times than 1,000 kicks one times, while I’m not saying hermione only practiced spells once, Harry is just more proficient with the few spells he uses, having one of the best shield charms which would probably block most of hermione’s spells. IMO Harry would win in a fight but hermione is a better wizard/witch.
being a natural only takes you so far and while harry did learn a lot hermione was too superior for him to win solely on natural talent. it would be close but hermione would throw something at him he could not block. also remember in book three hermione only had trouble with a boggart.
@@masonguthrie1257 He was born a natural fighter, but then he honed his fighting instincts over the course of his 7 years at hogwarts and became an auror. Hermione wasn't as gifted when it came to fighting and has less experience fighting. She might know more spells but that doesn't matter when facing someone that knows fighting like Harry
@@meetra5073 that’s fine if that’s your opinion but I just felt like people are sleeping on Hermione’ own dueling abilities I mean she really progressed from book 5 to book 7 and she is faster than Harry also I can see her leaning into charms and transfiguration since Harry is not near her level and she could throw an indirect charm at him.
@@masonguthrie1257 Let me put it this way. I think if they make a date to duel to come up with strategies to fight the other (like some kind of dueling club). Hermione would probably win if things go according to plan. But if it is out of the blue (in the wild, real life or death situation), Harry would win because he has better instincts while fighting, having survived multiple duels against Voldemort and other top death eaters, more so than hermione.
@@meetra5073 yeah but I feel like Hermione knows Harry too well not to just already know to use more charms than defense like you said Harry only knows a few spells Hermione blocks all of them and again it would be close I’m not saying it would not be but I feel Hermione has the upper hand.
Ron gets knocked out first the it's a battle between Hermione and Harry and I think Hermione would win due to not just her knowledge but her power and skill
@@ttydt maybe the quality of strength for spells since he has a much more powerful wand but I think hermonie has varies spells up her sleeves besides the common used ones. It’d definitely be a close battle if not a tie in my eyes
@@ttydt Harry doesn't have that much skill trust me. He is powerful yes due to him having the 4th most powerful wand in the wizarding world which is bound to give him a big edge. I've often found him not versatile with his spells at all. You instantly know that Harry is going to shoot Expelliarmus on you. Also in the half blood prince when he duelled with Malfoy, Malfoy kept the duel going for a while. If Malfoy can for that long then I think Hermione can defo beat Harry. Like sure Harry beat Voldemort but he did it out of raw luck with the elder wand, Voldemort's oversized ego, his mother sacrificing herself for him, Voldemort using Harrys blood making Harry immortal to Harry, plus the wands twin cores. (Harry could also speak Parsel tongue etc as a bonus). If one of these things didn't happen Harry would of died. If Voldemort attacked Harry like he did with Dumbledore, Harry would of died within the first minute. Why didn't Voldemort attack Harry like that then? -Because of his inflated ego that he could beat Harry with the killing curse even though he knew about Harrys mother protection. Harry is valiant in a duel and has alot of mental strength. He doesn't care if he dies as he wants to see his parents. I dont see him being that powerful though especially in the DH when everybody else was fighting for their lives whereas Harry wasn't. If I were to mould Harry I would honestly say Harry is 40% luck, 50% courage and 10% skill. Hermione however is alot more versatile with her spells and knows spells years above Harry. She can always predict what Harry is going to do as he uses the same spells whereas she has more versatility and the ability to perform advanced magic that Harry would of not been able to counter. She can also perform spells without saying the which gives her a massive edge. The reason why she wouldn't be able to kill Voldemort was because Voldemort knew even more advanced spells than her making her useless in that sector. However if she had the same lucky circumstances as Harry plus the brain that she has I am quite sure Hermione would of beaten Voldemort alot easier than what Harry did. Personally I dont see how this is even a debate. I really wished they did this duel as I'm pretty sure Hermione would of easily beaten Harry. Remember, just because Harry beat Voldemort doesn't mean he is "all powerful" he had so many things going for him that a normal person didn't have. Hermione would easily outsmart him in a duel and would be able to get in his head a bit as she is more creative and has a more variety of spells that Harry wouldn't of dreamed to counter.
Bro obviousley Harry Potter is the winner. He is actually smarter than Hermoine but just that he doesn't want to show it...and when it comes to dueling no one stands a chance against Harry Potter.
If I put everything simply if there both put in a box and forced to duel Harry would win as he is more powerful at combat magic but Hermione is powerful at magic in general. Harry had a Outstanding in D.A.D.A while her lien had a exceeds expectations. Also as bellatrix once said also dumbeldore that in duel...knowledge isn’t useful unless you can use it effectively which is referring to magic. So in a scenario where they have to fight Harry’s spells are way powerful and he would win but one has to admit hermione is a bit more knowledgeable at magic in general than Harry
Harry will win as he has mustered some of the most powerful curses and charms at a very small age like imperius curse, patronus ;moreover, he is much experienced in duel than hermione.
Harry doesn't have that much skill trust me. He is powerful yes due to him having the 4th most powerful wand in the wizarding world which is bound to give him a big edge. I've often found him not versatile with his spells at all. You instantly know that Harry is going to shoot Expelliarmus on you. Also in the half blood prince when he duelled with Malfoy, Malfoy kept the duel going for a while. If Malfoy can for that long then I think Hermione can defo beat Harry. Like sure Harry beat Voldemort but he did it out of raw luck with the elder wand, Voldemort's oversized ego, his mother sacrificing herself for him, Voldemort using Harrys blood making Harry immortal to him, plus the wands twin cores. (Harry could also speak Parsel tongue etc as a bonus). If one of these things didn't happen Harry would of died. If Voldemort attacked Harry like he did with Dumbledore, Harry would of died within the first minute. Why didn't Voldemort attack Harry like that then? -Because of his inflated ego that he could beat Harry with the killing curse even though he knew about Harrys mother protection. Harry is valiant in a duel and has alot of mental strength. He doesn't care if he dies as he wants to see his parents. I dont see him being that powerful though especially in the DH when everybody else was fighting for their lives whereas Harry wasn't. If I were to mould Harry I would honestly say Harry is 40% luck, 50% courage and 10% skill. Hermione however is alot more versatile with her spells and knows spells years above Harry. She can always predict what Harry is going to do as he uses the same spells whereas she has more versatility and the ability to perform advanced magic that Harry would of not been able to counter. She can also perform spells without saying the which gives her a massive edge. The reason why she wouldn't be able to kill Voldemort was because Voldemort knew even more advanced spells than her making her useless in that sector. However if she had the same lucky circumstances as Harry plus the brain that she has I am quite sure Hermione would of beaten Voldemort alot easier than what Harry did. Finally remember that Hermione did more subjects than Harry and got Os in all subjects apart from Defence where she got an E. Harry on the other hand had a mixture of passes and fails with only 1 O in DADA. You are not telling me that this 1 O is going to outweigh Hermione's 9-10? She could just transfigure Harry into a toad. I dont even see how Harrys 1 O is going to be used here to its full extent as it seems extremely unlikely that both of them will ever resort to dark magic. Personally I dont see how this is even a debate. I really wished they did this duel as I'm pretty sure Hermione would of easily beaten Harry. Remember, just because Harry beat Voldemort doesn't mean he is "all powerful" he had so many things going for him that a normal person didn't have. Hermione would easily outsmart him in a duel and would be able to get in his head a bit as she is more creative and has a more variety of spells that Harry wouldn't of dreamed to counter.
Uh, I kinda don't agree with this. Yes Hermione does know more spells than harry and is more strategy based I feel like harry would stand a lot better chance because if harry uses avada-kadavra he could defeat Hermione if she does not act quick enough.
@@Krazy346 Yes but as we know Hermione is faster with the wand than Harry and Ron combined. It is shown multiple times in the books that Hermione is faster on the uptake than both of them. Same would apply here as anybody could do avada kedavra and the other person would be killed. (Remember that Harry was only immune to avada kedavra by Voldemort only however with anybody else it would be a simple kill).
finally someone with a brain. i really hate that people keep using the "harry has more experience" card. like bruh sorcerers stone shouldnt even count. and in the chamber of secrets, i wouldnt really call that a duel. in the prisoner of azkaban, they were all pretty equal in what they experienced... like bruh. hermoine is better than harry in pretty much every way
Guys, yes Hermione is faster more creative but what if Hermione looses because of this: Battle Experience. Because harry is more vengful while Hermoine is more creative. So I think harry would stand a better chance then what he explained this is just a opionion.
Harry has more experience with dark magic up until book 4 at least, havent read the books for a while but im not sure hermione has had to defend herself as much. Even fight really, would come down to little things if they did duel
Harry: Power Ron: Luck Hermione: Skill I better get all the likes for this ... oh and I think Hermione would win! Also the Twlight movies were Everything!
Harry has both skill and power. Harry has more experience and has actually USED more spells than Hermione. Harry has duelled more skilled people than Hermione has. Harry is much more Better at combat then Hermione
One thing I would refute is the notion that if you can cast an unforgivable you have a high knowledge of the dark arts. While those spells are very dark I would not say they are hard to learn.
I've listed 10 Characters who can beat the living tribunal Oblivion First Firmament The Word Infinity Man Takion Synnar Zauriel Primal Monitor Pralaya The Source And i've also listed 10 Characters who can beat Dr. Fate Multi-Infinity Abraxas Nebulous Ivory Kings Pre-retcon Molecule Man Divine Superman Roma Protege Tiger God Mandrakk
Knowledge in no way can overpower cunning and the natural will in a fight. Hermione, while book smart, plays it by the book when it comes to her style. Any deviation or personal twist to a spell or even a movement can throw her off. The opponents she's faced are predictable, and rely to much on dark spells that tend to have similar goals in mind. That's the kind of mindset she trains herself to combat. Death Eaters play dirty, but the majority of them throughout the series have predictable movesets, Bellatrix being the exception ( who could easily deal with her due to her sheer skill and unpredictable nature.) Harry is similar to Bellatrix in a more subtle way, which may be fitting since I can imagine him getting in some lessons from Sirius. Please don't forget the situations he dealt with, from Basilisks to Dragons. Harry is just way too practical to be beaten by Hermione's tight nature, especially with her inner doubts on what she can do. I'm honestly sure he could get an emotional reaction out of her, but even then, again, he's much too unpredictable and has found himself facing smarter and more powerful people and creatures. In the end, Hermione is smart but too uptight. Harry is more fluid, and more focused in a dueling situation, even proving dangerous at his angriest.
ZombieTex ghost rider solos them easily and 1 ghost rider would use his penance stare at black adam for killing Shazam and then he crumbles to dust and 2 ghost rider would just stomp etrigan easily
Accually this is not true. I love your videos but i gotta say this. J.K Rowling has ben asked the question whos most powerfull of theese three and who would win in a duel of theese three, she answered Harry
Nika Nasaridze Harry is one of the least dangerous wizards in the series, with his expelliarmus spamming nonsense. Magical ability is linked with knowledge, creativity, and cunning, in all of which Hermione surpasses Harry
@@Ntimidation actually no , hermione only superpassing him by knowledge but he had more experience, superior magic ability for creating the impressive patronus in a very young age and he is very skilled in duelling in the 5th book he remained fully uninjured during the battle of the ministry with a dozens of death eaters , he defeated them all by himself he is cunning too
Dan I understand what you are trying to say but come on now , according to JKR herself, from end of POA, Harry could easily mop the floor with Hermione in a duel, due to superior skill in DADA,sharper reflexes and survival instincts, and overall having a better defense-offence strategy
that was at the end of POA which is year 3 and I would agree that all the way up to the HBP or even DH that harry is a better duelist but I would say it switches once we get to those last two books because everyone is focused on the war and so Hermione focused on more pratical skills like dueling. Also the fact that Harry was probably the safest in the duels against death eaters because Voldemort wanted to kill Harry himself makes his achievements a little less impressive. Don't get me wrong he is an amazing duelist and had to be to survive for so long but I would say it would be fair that by book 7 hermione had surpassed him so much in other dueling subjects (Charms and Transfiguration) that her being a little behind in DADA is not enough for Harry to win. not to mention her draw speed as well. I do want to make it clear that it would be very very close. out of 10 fights I would put it at 6-4 or even 5-5 with hermione winning in the end.
You know I don't hate this. Harry has a lot more raw power than Hermione, but Hermione is far more skilled. Hermione does not get the credit she deserves.
Silver Surfer vs Captain Atom And Superman Green Lantern Corps And Nova Corps Vs First Order Star Wars Divine Spawn Vs The MCU Human Torch Vs Suside Squad Galactus Vs Justice League
Justice League (if the Avengers ir only the FF can win against galactus so does JL) GL Corps and Nova Corps (they stomp if the guardians help them) SS wins against Superman Kind if easy and he wins against CA after a good fight but if both of them work in team they might win the fight
Wrenny North 10. Lifebringer galactus he would beat him easily 9. Dark Phoenix she would burn him to ashes 8. Darkseid anti life equation he would decimate him 7. Superman prime 1 million he would obliterate anti monitor 6. Ultra instinct goku he would dodge and punch him 5. The one above all he would erase him 4. The upside down man he would erase him from existence 3. Trigon he would stomp him 2. Brainiac he would shrink him 1. Golden frieza he would death beam him
Ron would win hands down. He performs non-verbal magic at age 12. He`s able to hit a moving target on a broom while being on a broom himself. He`s a good shot. Hermione is good at memorizing but gets flustered under pressure. Knowing spells is not the same as using spells. They both got the same grade on their defense OWLs. Ron is simply better in a fight. Harry would use Expaliarmus which Ron would see coming. Harry is just to predictable and Ron knows that.
This question is totally unrelated, but I'll answer it anyways. The first thing you should know is that they're called muggles, which means they have no magical blood. Thats why not all muggles can use magic, if they could, there would be no such thing as 'muggles'. The reason some muggles can use magic is because they have a descendant somewhere in their family tree that has a bit of magical power in them. Mainly squibs who married a muggle.
If I put everything simply if there both put in a box and forced to duel Harry would win as he is more powerful at combat magic but Hermione is powerful at magic in general. Harry had a Outstanding in D.A.D.A while her lien had a exceeds expectations. Also as bellatrix once said also dumbeldore that in duel...knowledge isn’t useful unless you can use it effectively which is referring to magic. So in a scenario where they have to fight Harry’s spells are way powerful and he would win but one has to admit hermione is a bit more knowledgeable at magic in general than Harry
Bro Harry has made potrasus in the age of 13 , he has defeated voldemort no one execpt him defeated voldemort even dumboldor said in books that he escaped from voldemort but he cant defeat him , Harry to has conquered death two times
Gotta disagree on this one. Hermione is definitely the more knowledgable with different types of magic, but Harry has proven to cast more powerful attacks. And while for the most part I agree that skill beats power, in this case Harry, in my opinion, is actually on par, if not more skilled in duelling than Hermione. While before their prime, the fact that Harry managed to get an O in his DADA OWLs while Hermione managed to get a E, suggesting that Harry is in fact more knowledgable in the Dark Arts than Hermione.
I disagree that Voldemort laying claim to Harry's life reduces Harry's feats. Stunning spells are equally as effective at ending a fight as the Killing Curse, and Harry has very rarely been hit by curses or spells. Neither has Hermione admittedly, but I believe Harry's more agressive style was enough (along with Siruis Black) to put Lucius Malfoy and Antonin Dolohov on their back foot, the later of which I find comparable to Snape and Bellatrix in duelling skills.
While Hermione may be the faster of the two, Harry's shield charm is sufficient to block her spell, allowing him to retaliate with greater force.
Last but not least, power. Bellatrix herself said "You have to mean it." All the knowledge in the world is no good if you dont apply it effectively. While Hermione is certainly determined in duels, Harry has that bit more of a killer's instinct. If they go all in, friendships not mattering at all, Harry will be the more overpowering of the two.
Alas, like yourself, this is all my opinion.
Good review
I have read the book about 5 times and hermione got her O and harry got a E but everything is good except that Bellatrix said be smart is not always a good thing but she is one of the Enemy’s in the story.so I don’t agree on it but some things I do
@@kadenb3759 Hermione and Ron got E`s, Harry received the O.
Nah Danco spot on with his
Since Harry is the main character, I honestly like to think he's the strongest out of the three.
Harry is better at combative magic, Hermione is good at magic in general. I think Harry wins.
She can do the unexpected and knows how he thinks.
Hermione
@DOAMA Harry couldn't use Legilimency or Occlumency which was a major plot point in the Order of the Phoenix
nope
it could happen but he would have to work very hard its like minerva vs snape
Ron is definitely out of his depth here
ahah ye
YASSSSSSSSSS
True mate
I'm not trying to down play Ron, but I think most people here knew that the real question was who would win between Harry and Hermione
U forgot the one whos best in chess
Yeah I don't agree. I think Harry is waaayyy stronger. Even the spells he knows are enough to defeat Hermione. Harry is the only person who survived all 3 unforgettable curses. No one else had. Harry had so much inner strength that made his simple spells more powerful then ever. Harry knew the fighting tactics which are not learnt by books. It's natural. While Hermione would think about next spell to cast, cuz Harry knows only a handful, and useful spells he would've prevailed. Harry Could've taken on Hermione and Ron together at once. But Hermione was very close to Harry's skills. Technically Hermione is the better. Only after Harry though.
I agree
Spandan Dholakia not really there is no spell that Harry knows that Hermione does not and Hermione does is not lacking when it comes to dueling she may not be as powerful but overall skill she beats Harry not saying that it would be easy it would be very close but I don’t see Harry throwing anything out that Hermione could not counter.
@@masonguthrie1257 Agreed. But just knowing the spell is different than performing it. For eg, Lupin said Patronus is a very advanced spell. Students of Harry's age normally couldn't do it but bcz Harry had strong magical soul, he did it. Harry had a stronger magical power inside him than Hermione. She was the brightest witch, not necessarily strongest.
Spandan Dholakia yes but I feel by book seven that her dueling abilities have grown enough that with her extra knowledge she could beat Harry it would be close though.
@@masonguthrie1257 dunno
Haven’t seen the video, but I say that Harry Potter wins if we take books and movies into account.
1. He was elected to be the leader of Dumbledore’s army.
2. He was able to fight Voldemort and combat his Avada Kedavra with a mere Expelliarmus spell in DH P2.
3. He got an outright better grade in DATDA, a combat oriented class, than Hermione in their 5th year.
4. He was able to repel dozens of dementors as a 13 year old. Hermione never cast a patrons until 2 years later.
But it was Hermione's idea and hermione planned all his lesson s
Hermione actually was not able to perform the patronus until the DH (according to books)
@@chloemorris8884 and she also said that Krum admitted Harry could do things that Krum didn't knew of even after being a final year at Drumstang
almost all spells harry has mastered, hermione already learned them like ten years before harry. she is a GREAT fighter and harry couldnt beat voldemort if it wasnt for their connection.
i accuatly think that bellatrix could take harry down
hermione is also the smartest of them three
and even serius black (sry if spelled wrong) she is the brightest witch of her time
subhi bano Hermione would of been powerful enough to perform the patronising charm, it’s just that she may not have had a powerful happy memory.
Dueling is really were Harry shines and Hermione isn't the best at, so yeah Harry takes this one.
nope
@@leomendelsohn2622 Yep!
but she would make him work its like minerva vs snape in the begining hermione will be winning she like minerva keep him off his toes but then harrry will throw her off balence and win but it would be very very hard.
@@leomendelsohn2622 don't spam in every comment feminist
That's not really true. Yeah obviously Harry would defeat hermione with easy. But even in potion class Harry is technically better than her. Of course he is a better pilot with his broom. I always find it weird that the fanbase think just because hermione is a book worm, she must be automatically the best in everything. Not only compared to Harry, because that's pretty much unfair, this guy was fighting dark wizards and basilisk as a child, I might remember that she also isn't a talented duelist in general.
Hermione is a better than Harry at knowledge of spells, but Harry destroys her at dueling. He has faster reflexes, can think quicker and can make up super fast desicions.
True
This is interesting and honestly I’m not sure. Harry has always been a natural at duelling but Danco raises some very good points about Hermione. Hmmmm.
Magically strongest of the three: harry
Intelligent of the three: hermione
Physically strongest of the three: ron
Any who think Hermione has any chance of winning this is fully mad.
Hermione fully outshines Harry schoolwise, but it isn’t by much. The thing that people who only watch the movies fail to realize is that Harry was a genius too, albeit not as much as Hermione.
Harry, got N.E.W.T.S in almost all his tests. This is a mad feat of magic knowledge that is matched by few. Hermione was wiser then Harry, almost on another level. She knows more spells, but the thing we have to ask ourselves is; Can she perform them in battle?
Harry is 1 of the best duelers in the verse. He was able to combat multiple older and mightier foes at a very young age, and became the Head Auror at the age of 26. He is the youngest Head Auror and never even graduated Hogwarts.
He has fast reaction times, has a madly strong Protego, 1 that was able to fully block an unstable Fiendfyre, Something that we have only seen once. I can guarantee you only 2 characters in the series can even come close to this.
His Stupefy was able to K.O. foes on its 1st strike, he was able to make a Patronus at the age of 13, something that we have never heard of before. He is extremely skilled in Charms and the best in his class for the subjects Defense Against the Dark Arts, and Transfiguration. He was the only 1 in his class that was able to edit his eyebrow's color in Transfiguration.In Defense Against the Dark Arts, he had a natural affinity for battling Dark Magic. He was the only 1 in his class to defy Moody’s Imperious Curse, something that not even Hermione managed. Did I forget to mention the Imperious Curse is the strongest Mind Curse there is? He also excelled in Charms class, only 2nd to Hermione.
Harry was also gifted in Dueling. He knew when to strike and when to Shield, Dodge, Etc…
Hermione was just wise. She knew many Charms, Jinxes, Hexes, Curses, Spells, but she was all bad. Her weakest point was dueling.
While she knows many spells that are hard to reverse, like Silencio which can take away foes' more complex spells, she lacks the magic raw power and talent Harry has. Harry has a fighter's instinct, while Hermione is more analytical. She has no impressive dueling feats.
thanks 7o7o7o7
how can he get the best N.E.W.T.S. if he did not graduate also its been explained hermione has a faster reaction time, and harry actually while smarter than most would give him credit for was no where near hermione. and as we see later in the books hermione has no issues dueling so. also hermione while she would know some darker spells would not use them and honestly i could see her overwhelming him with charms and transfiguration since he would not be able to counter it as easily if at all.
oh please litsen hermione isnt weak exeeds expectations isnt bad at all
i agree in a 1 vs 1 dues harry would win (but not by much) you saw what she did to ferrir greyback and atonio dolohov
ron even said she is the best at spells
she by far the generally better and well rounded at transfigureation charms potions and far smarter this could give her an advantage.
No. Hermione has the knowledge but not the experience like Harry. Harry has fought way more characters and defeated them. Harry even got the control of the elder wand. With that he can kick Voldemort's ass whole day. Harry is just way more powerful, experienced. Skills round will go to Hermione but still skill isn't enough to beat cunningness of Harry. Harry wins this.
I would say Harry's more skilled in this aspect of magic.
@@redwolf344 yes
Actually really liking the Harry Potter fights would love to see some more
I agree ☝️Hermione is that Witch 🧙🏻♀️
ye
Harry Potter gotta win
As he is the best when he had a elderly wand
Great video! I really enjoyed it. In my opinion, Harry would win. Here's my ranking of the top young wizards in Harry Potter.
1. Harry Potter
2. Hermione Granger
3. Draco Malfoy
4. Ron Weasley
5. Neville Longbottum
In my opinion, Draco is 2nd Cuz he was kind of equal to Harry. Remember the duel in chamber of secrets. And the starting scene of half blood prince.
ISHFLY Yeah those scenes show he’s a great duelist! There’s definitely a strong case for him being 2nd behind Harry. I think Draco vs Hermione would be a brutal battle and it’s honestly a toss up.
@@ManuManiac93 yup
Neville at fifth? Like I like Neville, but at fifth? come on
@@ManuManiac93 Yes
Harry could outsmart Hermione andcast the dismarcharm better than Hermione and he could doge the spell with ezzz and then Hermione with a stun spell
Cus he is a better duelist
King Kong maybe in their earlier years but they are a lot closer near the end of the series and after so that is not going to save him.
@@masonguthrie1257 The disarming spell saved him from Voldemort, stop it
henry liu sure and what else does he know I mean a disarming spell is really simple and I don’t think that it was as useful if the books as it was in the movie. Especially since nothing can block the killing curse.
@@masonguthrie1257 You sound like Smith. Harry has a variety of things he can throw at Hermione. Hermione has even more, but it would be harder for her because shes less quick and would take longer to figure out what spell to use.
Naw Harry should’ve took this win
JOHN CONSTANTINE VS LORD VOLDERMOURT ?.
The Immortal Super Being johnny boi
Yes please
voldermort stomps, medium difficulty
Voldemort win
@@MrInzombia Constantine stomps so hard and so does Strange and Doom Voldermord has so little spells he can use
Now, the real battle is approaching...
GANDALF VS DUMBLEDORE
ye lol
Gandalf
I agree. Hermione to me is the best witch. She just knows more spells than Harry. Knowledge is power. Dumbledore, Voldemort, Snape, McGonagall were all super knowledgeable. Talent alone is not enough. Hermione fought Bellatrix using Bella's wand and she managed to keep her at bay. Harry has more raw power, but Hermione has become good at duelling ans overall she is the most complete wizard of the 2
Hermione didn't knew a thing about sectusempra
@@sonalipaul874 sure, but it doesn't mean that Hermione is gonna stand her and watch Harry cast the spell on her. Maybe she could conjure a shield and protect herself from the spell, who knows...
@@sonalipaul874 Harry wouldn't ever use it on her though as its an extremely dark spell.
Wrong again DanCo
Hermoine could not have dueled Voldemort..
and it’s fair to say Voldemort is a better duelist than Hermoine..
Harry wins..
Chaddo Morrow +
Yes but Harry would have lost without being the master of the Elder Wand
@@justinanderson2460 He was the master for a reason.
Arc7X Angel+
Correct, because he disarmed Draco Malfoy. Who had become the master after disarming Dumbledore by sheer blind luck. What’s your point??
Chaddo Morrow didn’t Harry won because the Horocruxes were destroyed?
BigBadApe 005+
No Harry won because he was the true master of the Elder Wand. The horcruxes being destroyed only allowed Voldemort to be properly killed, it didn’t make his duelling skills any less.
obviously Harry would win
Jxndr1 why?
See, no offense, but focus on the point that Harry has the wand of Voldemort, who no doubt would've killed Hermione easily as he's not to mention not called Dark Lord for no reason. Keeping in mind, Hermione got more skills, but not really too much more than Harry does, as he's clever in the way he uses spells as well, and has more power along with the power of Voldemort's wand being more powerful than the one Hermione posesses. So, tbh, Harry would win this one even though Hermione got more skills and knowledge in spells cuz Dumbledore VS Grenderwald was a whole another matter being honest.
Doctor Doom vs Doomsday
Hercules vs Juggernaut
To me its.
DOOMSDAY He is basically a more powerful Hulk.
&
HERCULES Being half God plus having much more experience and a better skill set.
Camurai92 dr doom stomps
Hercules
Hassan Atros do you actually know how strong hercules is?
Hassan Atros I wasn’t talking about hulk....
Do you know who hercules is? He has more strengh AND much more battle experience. There is no one who has more battle experience than him, he has fought for a millenium, so he lacks nothing on beating the jugg
Hassan Atros and this is why hercules is underrated, you clearly don’t even know his feats
Harry Potter has a battle IQ but Hermione has IQ
Hermione is my favourite.......
But I think Harry's gonna win.
Y'all know he's the chosen one.
You’re crazy. Hermione is a goddess but Harry would still win
Ed SR why there is nothing Harry could do that Hermione would not counteract.
@@masonguthrie1257 lol. In a interview Rowling was asked who would win in a duel between these 3. She answered Harry. Anything more to say.
Game Zone I take everything Rowling says with a grain of salt
@@masonguthrie1257 there is not much more to say after the creator herself says.
@@masonguthrie1257 so what the creator of the universe days that's wrong so by your logic you are wrong because the creator made Hermione
In a Fight Harry Potter who is more skilled Hermione
Pppffttt 😂😂😂😂This dude will make anyone sound like they're in the fight. Harry wins this. It's really not even worth thinking about.
Arc7X Angel no Harry could not throw anything at Hermione that she would not know the counter to her knowledge outclasses his slight dueling advantage.
@@masonguthrie1257 Harry has fought way more powerful enemies. Hermione hasn't. Harry will definitely win.
Game Zone besides Voldemort hermione has basically fought with Harry in every battle. They both fought high level deatheaters and did well. Also I am talking about year 7 hermione every other year except 1 and 2 Harry would win but hermione got a lot more practical practice in her later years especially book 7
@@masonguthrie1257 though Hermione was with Harry but Harry have way better feats. In the second part he was worthy to find Gryfindor's sword. He killed basilisk. In the third part he defeated an entire group of Dementors alone. Harry has way more experience in different situation. Like in the 4th part he cleared every challenge of the Triwizard cup. In the 5th part he defeated Bellatrix. Even Voldemort was saying you know the spell, kill her. Bellatrix was the one who fought Hermione, Luna and Ginny alone and was winning. It was the 7th part from which Hermione was with Harry in battle. Harry is a far better duelist than Hermoine.
Game Zone with almost all of those Harry got really lucky not saying he was not skilled but he had lots of help and luck. I’m not saying it will not be close I am just saying I can’t see Harry throwing hermione off.
Love this!!!
How about Alasor Moody vs. Qui Gon Jinn? Severes Snapes vs. Obi-Won? Or dare I say, Darth Sidious vs. Lord Voldemort?
Or in a 3-way battle:
Lucius Malfoy vs. Star Lord vs. Cad Bane
Mace Windu vs. Grindelwald vs. Malcolm Merlin
Darth Maul vs. Iron Spider vs. Bellatrix Lestrange
Neo (end Matrix 1) vs. Ebony Maw vs. Dumbledore
Abomination vs. Black Obsidian vs. Wonder Woman
Kingsley Shacklebolt vs. Dark Anakin vs. Black Panther
Minerva McGonagall vs. Old Ben vs. Red Skull (~First Avenger)
Nightwing vs. Sirius Black vs.Chirrut Imne (Rogue One blind force user)
Morgain le fey vs. Dr. Strange (MCU-b4 loop w/ Dormammu) vs. Darth Zannah
Jason Borne (movies) vs. Captain America (movies but no shield) vs. Serpentor (Cobra leader)
More likely no one can see this than only one person likes it, right?
Ebony Maw v Dumbledore is actually wuite a fun idea!
All Star Wars characters stomp, especially Sidious
Casey Henry Old Ben solos them easily
Danko no Harry was better than Hermione because Garri is man !!!
Hermione would win from book 1,2,3 and maybe 4. But by order of the Phoenix up, harry would win, Ron is weakest here
Yeah, I don't even know why Ron was included in this.
II 神の怒り II honestly not so sure because while Harry did get better Hermione was so far ahead that he would have to be a dueling prodigy which I don’t see him as. Not saying Hermione is but she knows way to much to count her out in the later years.
Combative magic is ok but in a real battle, wont be enough. Remember the battle between voldemort and dumbledore they didn’t use any of those spells that used in general combats. I think harry would lose.
So stupefy isn't a combative spell?
JKR literally said that Harry was already a better duelist than Hermione at the end of PoA, way before he actually started getting real combat/dueling experience. So yeah, this isn't even all that close - Harry is a natural genius when it comes to dueling and fighting in general, has way better combat feats and can put more power behind his spells; Hermione being more knowledgable and versatile simple isn't enough here.
In a duel with certain rules I'm giving Harry the edge 8 times out of 10. In a real, morals-off fight he wins every single time.
yeah but hermione clearly caught up by book 6
@@masonguthrie1257 She very clearly didn't. Idk where that even came from considering Hermione has literally zero real combat feats in HBP.
@@appetizingly I mean with the death eaters she also faced when she was with Harry who had to be kept alive by command of Voldemort. The only time Harry is in real danger is against Voldemort and he loses which is fine that is op but like hermione was fair game to the death eaters and by book seven she was faster to the draw than Harry so while Harry is naturally gifted hermione was able to work hard and catch up.
@@masonguthrie1257 Not that it makes that much of a difference to the discussion but in OotP the Death Eaters didn't use lethal force against any of the students as long as Harry was around them which was the case for Hermione until Dolohov got her and she was out of the picture.
In HPB the only combat experience she had was undemonstrated and with the added protection of Felix Felicis.
And in DH literally every fight involved lethal force and they both pretty much got the same amount of combat experience.
Not that all of the above matters when we have a direct quote from the author where she already favoured Harry before he had any real experience or started applying himself.
Also, how was Hermione "faster to the draw"? If you're referring to the tent scene, that would be a circumstantial non-combat scenario where she was the observer - that doesn't really mean much, if anything at all.
Like, give me a single feat of Hermione that puts her fighting skills above Harry's.
Don't get me wrong, Hermione is damn good and second only to Harry amongst their age group but his natural combat instincts and raw power were literally his greatest strengths aside from Quidditch.
@@appetizingly uh the diner is a good scene her against beletrix I mean she had back up from Luna and Ginny but still that is a pretty huge deal. I don’t really count Beletrix’s death against molly as a downfall just because it was very lucky above all else just as a side note. I can understand why people choose Harry because he is the protagonist and so he should be the strongest but from looking at the evidence and doing a little guess work I just agree that hermione would win overall.
I would disagree because if Hermione was put in Harry's situation to fight off Voldemort she would stand the chance because of her lack of knowledge against the dark arts. With the death eaters and that drama Harry was supposed to be killed by Lord Voldemort because was Harry was his biggest threat considering he wanted to kill him as a baby. Voldemort did not want Harry to be killed by the death eaters because he wanted to finish what he started. Harry was a bigger threat than dumbledoor because of the prophecy. Let's also take a look at Harry's earlier school years where he had perfected spells some adult wizards and hermoine could not even perform at his age. I got to admit Hermoine did know some spells that Harry did not know but Harry knew more affective spells that he perfected at a young age. Even Hermoine could not perform those at that age. Just to add to the death eaters scenario Harry would be able to fight off them even if it was threat for his life. So in my opinion Harry is the more powerful wizard and effective wizard
Harry has less knowledge than hermione about the dark arts everyone knows about the unforgivables and they are pretty rudimentary curses in comparison to true dark arts. Also as the years went on Hermione shot up in actual dueling to the point where she would win though it would be close.
How about NO!!! Harry has far more natural Magical Power!! Creativity is pretty. It’s like saying a NFL team is a finesse team, they will be playing a team with a taller, stronger arm quarterback and 2 1,000 yard season running backs, and unflinching Defense. Your conclusion is pretty, has lots of finesse, but lacks logic. Best student rarely translates into best person in their chosen field. They languish in a culture that has different confusingly different. Harry takes down, in 1:00 minute or less in 1,000 out 1,000 times‼️🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼
Harry would win because he has the experience Even though Hermione has the knowledge but she does not have the experience of Harry
I mean besides book four she has been there for everything and as previously stated she did not have the shield of being kept alive to be killed by the dark lord himself.
Come on DanCo do this tournament:
all main Spiderman villains vs batman with prep time and all main batman villains
Round one
Tombstone vs mad hatter
scorpion vs poison ivy
Kraven the hunter Vs Ra’s al Ghul
carnage Vs batman
Sand man vs firefly
kingpin Vs The penguin and solomon Grundy
Rhino Vs bane
electro Vs Clay face
vulture Vs killer moth
venom Vs killer croc
lizard Vs mr freeze
dr.octopus Vs death shot and Riddler
green goblin Vs man-bat and two-face and cat woman
Shocker Vs Joker and scarecrow
Mysterio Vs Harley Quinn
Bro your point is harty is not powerful because he is not knowledgable in books even dumboldor said that knowledge is not everything and he has recognised Harry Potters potential very easily
While hermione knows more about magic, Harry is just a straight up better dueler, it’s something he is just natural at. Harry knew many spells but mainly use expelliarmus and stupefy obviously, while hermione used more spells I don’t think she would win in a fight against Harry.
I forget if it was Jackie Chan or Bruce lee but they said he would fear a man who practiced one kick 1,000 times than 1,000 kicks one times, while I’m not saying hermione only practiced spells once, Harry is just more proficient with the few spells he uses, having one of the best shield charms which would probably block most of hermione’s spells. IMO Harry would win in a fight but hermione is a better wizard/witch.
being a natural only takes you so far and while harry did learn a lot hermione was too superior for him to win solely on natural talent. it would be close but hermione would throw something at him he could not block. also remember in book three hermione only had trouble with a boggart.
@@masonguthrie1257 He was born a natural fighter, but then he honed his fighting instincts over the course of his 7 years at hogwarts and became an auror. Hermione wasn't as gifted when it came to fighting and has less experience fighting. She might know more spells but that doesn't matter when facing someone that knows fighting like Harry
@@meetra5073 that’s fine if that’s your opinion but I just felt like people are sleeping on Hermione’ own dueling abilities I mean she really progressed from book 5 to book 7 and she is faster than Harry also I can see her leaning into charms and transfiguration since Harry is not near her level and she could throw an indirect charm at him.
@@masonguthrie1257 Let me put it this way. I think if they make a date to duel to come up with strategies to fight the other (like some kind of dueling club). Hermione would probably win if things go according to plan. But if it is out of the blue (in the wild, real life or death situation), Harry would win because he has better instincts while fighting, having survived multiple duels against Voldemort and other top death eaters, more so than hermione.
@@meetra5073 yeah but I feel like Hermione knows Harry too well not to just already know to use more charms than defense like you said Harry only knows a few spells Hermione blocks all of them and again it would be close I’m not saying it would not be but I feel Hermione has the upper hand.
Hey danco can you pls do spider man vs deadpool I really want to see who wins
Harry solos..
nah man
@@Ntimidation I think so
@@ericpena7418 did you not watch the video and/or read the HP series? Hermione wins it's almost of no doubt
@@Ntimidation naw
Ron gets knocked out first the it's a battle between Hermione and Harry and I think Hermione would win due to not just her knowledge but her power and skill
She is far less powerful than Harry, and Harry has more skill and experience in combat than Hermione
@@ttydt maybe the quality of strength for spells since he has a much more powerful wand but I think hermonie has varies spells up her sleeves besides the common used ones. It’d definitely be a close battle if not a tie in my eyes
@@ttydt Harry doesn't have that much skill trust me. He is powerful yes due to him having the 4th most powerful wand in the wizarding world which is bound to give him a big edge. I've often found him not versatile with his spells at all. You instantly know that Harry is going to shoot Expelliarmus on you. Also in the half blood prince when he duelled with Malfoy, Malfoy kept the duel going for a while. If Malfoy can for that long then I think Hermione can defo beat Harry. Like sure Harry beat Voldemort but he did it out of raw luck with the elder wand, Voldemort's oversized ego, his mother sacrificing herself for him, Voldemort using Harrys blood making Harry immortal to Harry, plus the wands twin cores. (Harry could also speak Parsel tongue etc as a bonus). If one of these things didn't happen Harry would of died. If Voldemort attacked Harry like he did with Dumbledore, Harry would of died within the first minute.
Why didn't Voldemort attack Harry like that then? -Because of his inflated ego that he could beat Harry with the killing curse even though he knew about Harrys mother protection.
Harry is valiant in a duel and has alot of mental strength. He doesn't care if he dies as he wants to see his parents. I dont see him being that powerful though especially in the DH when everybody else was fighting for their lives whereas Harry wasn't. If I were to mould Harry I would honestly say Harry is 40% luck, 50% courage and 10% skill.
Hermione however is alot more versatile with her spells and knows spells years above Harry. She can always predict what Harry is going to do as he uses the same spells whereas she has more versatility and the ability to perform advanced magic that Harry would of not been able to counter. She can also perform spells without saying the which gives her a massive edge. The reason why she wouldn't be able to kill Voldemort was because Voldemort knew even more advanced spells than her making her useless in that sector. However if she had the same lucky circumstances as Harry plus the brain that she has I am quite sure Hermione would of beaten Voldemort alot easier than what Harry did.
Personally I dont see how this is even a debate. I really wished they did this duel as I'm pretty sure Hermione would of easily beaten Harry. Remember, just because Harry beat Voldemort doesn't mean he is "all powerful" he had so many things going for him that a normal person didn't have. Hermione would easily outsmart him in a duel and would be able to get in his head a bit as she is more creative and has a more variety of spells that Harry wouldn't of dreamed to counter.
Hermione is my favourite.
Harry wins 👍🏻
Bro obviousley Harry Potter is the winner. He is actually smarter than Hermoine but just that he doesn't want to show it...and when it comes to dueling no one stands a chance against Harry Potter.
You do realise many witches and wizards could beat harry right ?
Btw harry is not smart
He does things on impulse
Many of his plans go wrong because he was stubborn or didn't think things through
And why would he hide that he was smart
Sorry this is a really touchy subject for me 😥
If I put everything simply if there both put in a box and forced to duel Harry would win as he is more powerful at combat magic but Hermione is powerful at magic in general. Harry had a Outstanding in D.A.D.A while her lien had a exceeds expectations. Also as bellatrix once said also dumbeldore that in duel...knowledge isn’t useful unless you can use it effectively which is referring to magic. So in a scenario where they have to fight Harry’s spells are way powerful and he would win but one has to admit hermione is a bit more knowledgeable at magic in general than Harry
Agreed
Can you do 10 DC or Marvel heroes or villains who can beat Cthulhu (Cthulhu Mythos)? 56th attempted request.
RedDusk369 anti monitor stomps Cthulhu because he can solo the legends verse easily and destroy everything in that earth
Harry will win as he has mustered some of the most powerful curses and charms at a very small age like
imperius curse, patronus ;moreover,
he is much experienced in duel than hermione.
Thor vs Batman
Spiderman vs Superman
Doomsday vs Iron Man
Hulk vs Black Panther
Dr.Doom vs Dr.Octopus
Do Harry Potter vs Aang vs Percy Jackson
Harry doesn't have that much skill trust me. He is powerful yes due to him having the 4th most powerful wand in the wizarding world which is bound to give him a big edge. I've often found him not versatile with his spells at all. You instantly know that Harry is going to shoot Expelliarmus on you. Also in the half blood prince when he duelled with Malfoy, Malfoy kept the duel going for a while. If Malfoy can for that long then I think Hermione can defo beat Harry. Like sure Harry beat Voldemort but he did it out of raw luck with the elder wand, Voldemort's oversized ego, his mother sacrificing herself for him, Voldemort using Harrys blood making Harry immortal to him, plus the wands twin cores. (Harry could also speak Parsel tongue etc as a bonus). If one of these things didn't happen Harry would of died. If Voldemort attacked Harry like he did with Dumbledore, Harry would of died within the first minute.
Why didn't Voldemort attack Harry like that then? -Because of his inflated ego that he could beat Harry with the killing curse even though he knew about Harrys mother protection.
Harry is valiant in a duel and has alot of mental strength. He doesn't care if he dies as he wants to see his parents. I dont see him being that powerful though especially in the DH when everybody else was fighting for their lives whereas Harry wasn't. If I were to mould Harry I would honestly say Harry is 40% luck, 50% courage and 10% skill.
Hermione however is alot more versatile with her spells and knows spells years above Harry. She can always predict what Harry is going to do as he uses the same spells whereas she has more versatility and the ability to perform advanced magic that Harry would of not been able to counter. She can also perform spells without saying the which gives her a massive edge. The reason why she wouldn't be able to kill Voldemort was because Voldemort knew even more advanced spells than her making her useless in that sector. However if she had the same lucky circumstances as Harry plus the brain that she has I am quite sure Hermione would of beaten Voldemort alot easier than what Harry did.
Finally remember that Hermione did more subjects than Harry and got Os in all subjects apart from Defence where she got an E. Harry on the other hand had a mixture of passes and fails with only 1 O in DADA. You are not telling me that this 1 O is going to outweigh Hermione's 9-10? She could just transfigure Harry into a toad. I dont even see how Harrys 1 O is going to be used here to its full extent as it seems extremely unlikely that both of them will ever resort to dark magic.
Personally I dont see how this is even a debate. I really wished they did this duel as I'm pretty sure Hermione would of easily beaten Harry. Remember, just because Harry beat Voldemort doesn't mean he is "all powerful" he had so many things going for him that a normal person didn't have. Hermione would easily outsmart him in a duel and would be able to get in his head a bit as she is more creative and has a more variety of spells that Harry wouldn't of dreamed to counter.
Uh, I kinda don't agree with this. Yes Hermione does know more spells than harry and is more strategy based I feel like harry would stand a lot better chance because if harry uses avada-kadavra he could defeat Hermione if she does not act quick enough.
@@Krazy346 Yes but as we know Hermione is faster with the wand than Harry and Ron combined. It is shown multiple times in the books that Hermione is faster on the uptake than both of them. Same would apply here as anybody could do avada kedavra and the other person would be killed. (Remember that Harry was only immune to avada kedavra by Voldemort only however with anybody else it would be a simple kill).
finally someone with a brain. i really hate that people keep using the "harry has more experience" card. like bruh sorcerers stone shouldnt even count. and in the chamber of secrets, i wouldnt really call that a duel. in the prisoner of azkaban, they were all pretty equal in what they experienced... like bruh. hermoine is better than harry in pretty much every way
Guys, yes Hermione is faster more creative but what if Hermione looses because of this: Battle Experience. Because harry is more vengful while Hermoine is more creative. So I think harry would stand a better chance then what he explained this is just a opionion.
@@Krazy346 what do you mean?
Harry Potter wins! He's the main character.
Harry has more experience with dark magic up until book 4 at least, havent read the books for a while but im not sure hermione has had to defend herself as much.
Even fight really, would come down to little things if they did duel
Harry: Power
Ron: Luck
Hermione: Skill
I better get all the likes for this
... oh and I think Hermione would win!
Also the Twlight movies were Everything!
Harry has both skill and power. Harry has more experience and has actually USED more spells than Hermione. Harry has duelled more skilled people than Hermione has. Harry is much more Better at combat then Hermione
Trishan 7569 is magic all about combat?
@@ttydt what if Hermione uses stupefy, petrificus totalus, and more stupefy?
@@a_person890 he can do the same lmao. Dueling in Harry Potter doesn’t make much sense anyway, but I’m still sticking with Harry.
@@ttydt I think if Hermione had more experience then it would be Hermione who would win.
One thing I would refute is the notion that if you can cast an unforgivable you have a high knowledge of the dark arts. While those spells are very dark I would not say they are hard to learn.
I've listed 10 Characters who can beat the living tribunal
Oblivion
First Firmament
The Word
Infinity Man
Takion
Synnar
Zauriel
Primal Monitor
Pralaya
The Source
And i've also listed 10 Characters who can beat Dr. Fate
Multi-Infinity
Abraxas
Nebulous
Ivory Kings
Pre-retcon Molecule Man
Divine Superman
Roma
Protege
Tiger God
Mandrakk
Agreed
CHEESE BURGER FREDDY 👍
Agreed except first firmament
For the person who can beat living tribunal u missed presenc
@@aidanbrennan6487 Well yeah that's a given, lol
Harry Potter vs Hairy Armpits
*"NUFF SAID"*
Y'all forgot who was the best in chess 😀😀
RONALD WEASLEY
Knowledge in no way can overpower cunning and the natural will in a fight. Hermione, while book smart, plays it by the book when it comes to her style. Any deviation or personal twist to a spell or even a movement can throw her off. The opponents she's faced are predictable, and rely to much on dark spells that tend to have similar goals in mind. That's the kind of mindset she trains herself to combat. Death Eaters play dirty, but the majority of them throughout the series have predictable movesets, Bellatrix being the exception ( who could easily deal with her due to her sheer skill and unpredictable nature.)
Harry is similar to Bellatrix in a more subtle way, which may be fitting since I can imagine him getting in some lessons from Sirius.
Please don't forget the situations he dealt with, from Basilisks to Dragons. Harry is just way too practical to be beaten by Hermione's tight nature, especially with her inner doubts on what she can do. I'm honestly sure he could get an emotional reaction out of her, but even then, again, he's much too unpredictable and has found himself facing smarter and more powerful people and creatures. In the end, Hermione is smart but too uptight. Harry is more fluid, and more focused in a dueling situation, even proving dangerous at his angriest.
Harry wasnt the owner ontell he disarmed voldemort and harry also has a good knowledge of magic so I say harry won that fight
Harry actually disarmed draco
Hermione could disarm him easily
I disagree, Harry wins. ESPECIALLY if hermione gets him mad
Hermione is obviously the winner :).
Superman & Shazam vs King Hyperion and Sentry
Black Adam and Etrigan vs Ghost Rider and Spawn
Team Marvel
Team Demons
Super man vs all of them superman would win
ZombieTex Superman solos both of them easily
ZombieTex ghost rider solos them easily and 1 ghost rider would use his penance stare at black adam for killing Shazam and then he crumbles to dust and 2 ghost rider would just stomp etrigan easily
Accually this is not true. I love your videos but i gotta say this. J.K Rowling has ben asked the question whos most powerfull of theese three and who would win in a duel of theese three, she answered Harry
No one gives a shit about what that old hag thinks. If the facts contradict what Rowling says then I'll go with the facts.
What?
Source?
o k u are so dumb since this did happen and Harry would win u dummy so shut ur stupid mouth up and go a cry
@@detectivegrinch This 'old hag' wrote the books and planned everything in the series, what are you even saying?
Green Lantern VS Hulk with Venom symbiote
Marks Bot's hulk
Hulk smash.
Lmao. Hulk would rip gl with the symbiote
He'd win even without the simbiote
Imagine Hulk with the red-lantern ring, lol we'd need much more than just Superman to stop that
Harry win
Can any of them beat Voldemort? N... Oh sorry, Harry can, so he's gonna win this. Yeah Hermione is smart and skilled but Harry is more dangerous
Nika Nasaridze Harry is one of the least dangerous wizards in the series, with his expelliarmus spamming nonsense. Magical ability is linked with knowledge, creativity, and cunning, in all of which Hermione surpasses Harry
@@Ntimidation actually no , hermione only superpassing him by knowledge but he had more experience, superior magic ability for creating the impressive patronus in a very young age and he is very skilled in duelling in the 5th book he remained fully uninjured during the battle of the ministry with a dozens of death eaters , he defeated them all by himself he is cunning too
technically, its harry's mom that's beating voldemort lol
Harry is definitely gonna win because experience outranks everything
Anyone that thinks Hermione should NOT have won, what’s happening inside your head?
What's happening to you cuz it is Harry who defeated the dark lord not Hermione :)
Let’s go hermione that’s my girl
I really liked this video
Dan I understand what you are trying to say but come on now , according to JKR herself, from end of POA, Harry could easily mop the floor with Hermione in a duel, due to superior skill in DADA,sharper reflexes and survival instincts, and overall having a better defense-offence strategy
that was at the end of POA which is year 3 and I would agree that all the way up to the HBP or even DH that harry is a better duelist but I would say it switches once we get to those last two books because everyone is focused on the war and so Hermione focused on more pratical skills like dueling. Also the fact that Harry was probably the safest in the duels against death eaters because Voldemort wanted to kill Harry himself makes his achievements a little less impressive. Don't get me wrong he is an amazing duelist and had to be to survive for so long but I would say it would be fair that by book 7 hermione had surpassed him so much in other dueling subjects (Charms and Transfiguration) that her being a little behind in DADA is not enough for Harry to win. not to mention her draw speed as well. I do want to make it clear that it would be very very close. out of 10 fights I would put it at 6-4 or even 5-5 with hermione winning in the end.
Come on DanCo do this:
the sinister six or all Spiderman villains vs batman and all batman villains
Ethan Lawrence sinister six easily because mysterio solos the rogues easily
You know I don't hate this. Harry has a lot more raw power than Hermione, but Hermione is far more skilled. Hermione does not get the credit she deserves.
Hyperion vs Hercules
Rocket vs Yoda
Prometheus vs Deathstroke
Hyperion
Hyperion
Yoda
Deathstroke
Hermione off course she knows so much she can out do Harry and Ron with her shear knowledge.
The Immortal Super Being Harry is better at combative magic, at least I think so. Hermione would admit this herself.
The Immortal Super Being Ron is the only one who doesn't have a chance.
Harry stomp both Ron and Harmonie
@@Ghsportsshorts How ?.
@@theimmortalsuperbeing549 this guy have defeated dragons, giant snake, voldermot and more, I think Harmonie and Ron will be a piece of cake
Silver Surfer vs Captain Atom And Superman
Green Lantern Corps And Nova Corps Vs First Order Star Wars
Divine Spawn Vs The MCU
Human Torch Vs Suside Squad
Galactus Vs Justice League
Justice League (if the Avengers ir only the FF can win against galactus so does JL)
GL Corps and Nova Corps (they stomp if the guardians help them)
SS wins against Superman Kind if easy and he wins against CA after a good fight but if both of them work in team they might win the fight
Silver Surfer
Team Corps
Divine Spawn stomps
Human Torch
Galactus stomps
Superman and captain atom
Green lantern corp and nova corp
The mcu
Suicede squad
JL
Do ten characters who can beat the anti monitor please
Wrenny North
10. Lifebringer galactus he would beat him easily
9. Dark Phoenix she would burn him to ashes
8. Darkseid anti life equation he would decimate him
7. Superman prime 1 million he would obliterate anti monitor
6. Ultra instinct goku he would dodge and punch him
5. The one above all he would erase him
4. The upside down man he would erase him from existence
3. Trigon he would stomp him
2. Brainiac he would shrink him
1. Golden frieza he would death beam him
Ron would win hands down. He performs non-verbal magic at age 12. He`s able to hit a moving target on a broom while being on a broom himself. He`s a good shot. Hermione is good at memorizing but gets flustered under pressure. Knowing spells is not the same as using spells. They both got the same grade on their defense OWLs. Ron is simply better in a fight. Harry would use Expaliarmus which Ron would see coming. Harry is just to predictable and Ron knows that.
Spot on. Hermoine for the W
Batman with Prep VS Silver Samurai and Wolverine
Marks Bot's I think Silver Samurai and Wolverine
It's a bit unfair to give Batman prep not the others.
Batman with prep vs Tony stark with prep
@@ericpena7418 To me Iron Man greater knowledge more powerful weapons and Armour.
@@theimmortalsuperbeing549 Yeah I'd give the edge to iron man when it comes to tech.
Cable vs Winter Soldier
Kevin Chavis cable stomps
Are we ever going to get some more video game characters in Battle arena?
Danco do one about archie sonic that would be dope
You should do red skull vs red hood
Leticia Freeman red hood stomps
Ron just dies straight off😭
I don't think they should even have a duel
Bleez(Red Lantern) vs Betty Ross(Red She-Hulk) as Betty's anger will only make the ring more powerful. Pleeease make this match @DanCo
Juan Tafoya bleez stomps
@@jayjaysworld7110 maybe.
Meh, Darth Maul could solo them all
JOAN JOSEPH CASTILLO wrong universe bro
Hermione du to her skills. She is better than her teammates, specially with enchantment magic
You said Ron and hermione were both Harry’s best friend
I still don’t get why some muggles can use magic but not all muggles
This question is totally unrelated, but I'll answer it anyways. The first thing you should know is that they're called muggles, which means they have no magical blood. Thats why not all muggles can use magic, if they could, there would be no such thing as 'muggles'. The reason some muggles can use magic is because they have a descendant somewhere in their family tree that has a bit of magical power in them. Mainly squibs who married a muggle.
henry liu thank you for clearing that up
Darth Sidious vs Voldemort
Edward Elric vs Harry Potter
Cosmic Creeper Edward Elric stomps
Ron shouldn’t even be here lol I can’t think of a single spell he has cast that actually worked 😂
Hermoine!!
Yes hermione would win
If I put everything simply if there both put in a box and forced to duel Harry would win as he is more powerful at combat magic but Hermione is powerful at magic in general. Harry had a Outstanding in D.A.D.A while her lien had a exceeds expectations. Also as bellatrix once said also dumbeldore that in duel...knowledge isn’t useful unless you can use it effectively which is referring to magic. So in a scenario where they have to fight Harry’s spells are way powerful and he would win but one has to admit hermione is a bit more knowledgeable at magic in general than Harry
Bro Harry has made potrasus in the age of 13 , he has defeated voldemort no one execpt him defeated voldemort even dumboldor said in books that he escaped from voldemort but he cant defeat him , Harry to has conquered death two times
Sauron vs Superman and wonder woman
Joel Whitaker Superman solos Sauron easily
In light of the the dbs movie coming out in January could you do goku vageta and broly vs Superman Wonder Woman and Martian manhunter
Jeremiah Smith Martian manhunter solos them easily