I think the reason Winter will always be my bias is that she performs for her fans, she smiles, winks and aknowledges us in the audience. Hard to do for an introvert but she puts aside her personality for the fans!!! I Love you Winter!!!
@@sevenkpink2894 I didn't mean to dismiss her improvement, but that just how she has been grown up as an artist. I don't like how ppl always have misconception about introvert.
One thing I love most about Winter is that she takes her concept character in every comeback seriously. Like she's really into it in every inch of detail. As a fan it always excites me to look forward to whatever activities she's having because she always manages to go beyond expectations.
Actually some people call winter a stage genius because not only does she kill the dance and stage prescence, if you watch their behind yhe scenes for choreo she always makes some adjustments to the choreo , formation and stage in general. She's very detail oriented too For spark she recently shared that she only had a month to prepare for the stage and sha had sleepless nights she organized everything herself from the lyrics to the outfit to the stage and choreo. She even shared that she styled herself from next level era till now she has a book where she puts things she wants to try later. She's sooo 🥰🥰🥰
One of the reasons Winter is my role model is her unwavering determination and constant drive for self-improvement. She didn't give up despite facing rejection from SM three times, and since day one, she has consistently sharpened her dancing skills. If SM manages her well, there's no doubt she can also grow significantly as a vocalist. I can't wait to witness her evolution. P.S. For anyone tempted to argue that the other girls are hardworking and share similar traits, let me remind you: this isn't about them. This is about Winter and my solid opinion of her.
NingNing has come a long way and she nailed her performance perfectly!!! It sucks that we have four amazing girls on stage and are forced to pick a bias.
"I feel sorry for anyone who isn't into K-pop, especially aespa." ~ Esosa 2024 Because same. They ate with this Whiplash comeback. 2024 has been definitely their year. Bop after bop after bop ❤
Did you know Winter is Waackxxxy’s student, she was on swf2 for the mega challenge and they talked about how she was her student that’s why she has such good lines especially with her arms. That’s why I absolutely loved Sparks choreo, and I think this one suits her as well.
*you guys should react to their second performance where they were the solider theme outfit bc their stage presence was sooo good there and mama 2023 performance too and upload it on YT bc I can't afford patron I am student* 😢😢😅
dancer here!!! nine times out of ten (refering to the comment about karina's styling) the bottom part will be sown into the shorts or just pinned on the inside so that they don't have to tie/or snap at the crotch. because they/we wear multiple layers, they would consider that,. it also is/can be preference of the performer! but because she has to wear (i'm assuming) some sort of seamless panty/underwear, plus safety shorts AND her outfit shorts, they wouldn't make her snap the crotch due to honestly possible injury. so it's probably stuffed in there and pinned or sown! (also crotch snapped clothing is not beneficial for quick changes! so if they had to be somewhere after they def didn't snap.)
OMGGG im loving sooo much all this aespa content, thank uuu queenssss, u guys should definitely watch other performances like the ONE TAKE(theres pinkselle hairography, ningning and karina ponytail and winter cunty red bob, with insane outfits) and the last one they did taday(there is karina with bangs and ninning CURLY HAIR)!!! lots of love from brazil
I just want to say that Winter is best member in terms of expressions from day 1. She knows what concept and song requires what expressions and I noticed it from Dreams come true era. This was era where their concept wasn't ai ,it was fun,lovely and fairy concept era so it means they have to smile often with lyrics and here only Winter was the one who actually embodied that concept fully. Karina and Giselle were also good but Ningning was worst. Ningning really has to improve in this aspect bcs her facial expressions are always same in every song whatever the concept is. She has fierce expressions always. She has great stage presence but when it comes to embodying concept and acting according to it, she is worst. Giselle and Karina are on and off and Winter is best. I know many fans would think I am hater or biased but I am an ot4 bias and I have really noticed this thing from their debut era. People think Winter has improved in terms of expressions. No she was always good at it ,what she actually improved is in her dancing skills being sharper than before. Now her strength doesn't seem weak
Those who don't know, Giselle gave Ning a kiss as this was her birthday and she just surprised her with it during their rehearsals ☺️ the Ningselle crumbs
10:21 I thought I was the only one who noticed that Giselle loves either looking down or seducing the camera whenever she performs that's why I love her lol
![[#2024MAMA] aespa-Bored!+Spark+Dopamine+UP+Supernova(MAMA ver.)+Whiplash(MAMA ver.) | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_LyRdiHwyFA/mqdefault.jpg)
Winter's bob hair looks so good and natural, it doesn't look like a wig at all.
Winter popping is so good
It was ningnings birthday so giselle gave her a kiss😂😂
I think the reason Winter will always be my bias is that she performs for her fans, she smiles, winks and aknowledges us in the audience. Hard to do for an introvert but she puts aside her personality for the fans!!! I Love you Winter!!!
Being an introvert has nothing to do with that. Not all introvert are shy. Idol is literally their job. Fyi, most of Kpop idol are introvert.
She has improved a lot as a performer since their debut, now she's one of my favorite performers ❤️ the facial expressions are soooo good!
@@pinkbloodsquad7766obviously it’s their job but we can acknowledge the improvement and we love to see it
@@sevenkpink2894 I didn't mean to dismiss her improvement, but that just how she has been grown up as an artist. I don't like how ppl always have misconception about introvert.
@@fredflint8399 lmao as if karina, giselle and ningning don’t perform for their fans, THE SHADE lol
karina is such a performer bro ughh i love her sm , u guys should deff watch her drama fancam , it’s one of her iconic one it’s a must watch
One thing I love most about Winter is that she takes her concept character in every comeback seriously. Like she's really into it in every inch of detail. As a fan it always excites me to look forward to whatever activities she's having because she always manages to go beyond expectations.
GG and NingNing got some serious visual/singing time on this song!!! I am so happy for them because this song is a serious banger!!!
I can’t with Giselle like I can’t idk what it is she is just so gorgeous and so pretty like my god I love her
Ningning is everything, her stage presence, visual, dance, rap and vocal are all A tier in the industry.
Aespa confirmed today in a fan meeting they will have a solo stage during the MAMA awards , i can’t wait to see your reaction on it
OMG, I was dreaming about it that they are performing their solos in red dresses and half of it has come true. WOW 🔥🔥
Omg this is beyond next level ❤❤❤❤
@@vaanshichauhan9868 is it all the solos that will be performed??
@@JuliaSilva-gv4qq omg fr???
Winter really took the ‘boring performer’ criticism. She’s has my fave fancams to watch-😭
Actually some people call winter a stage genius because not only does she kill the dance and stage prescence, if you watch their behind yhe scenes for choreo she always makes some adjustments to the choreo , formation and stage in general. She's very detail oriented too
For spark she recently shared that she only had a month to prepare for the stage and sha had sleepless nights she organized everything herself from the lyrics to the outfit to the stage and choreo.
She even shared that she styled herself from next level era till now she has a book where she puts things she wants to try later. She's sooo 🥰🥰🥰
One of the reasons Winter is my role model is her unwavering determination and constant drive for self-improvement. She didn't give up despite facing rejection from SM three times, and since day one, she has consistently sharpened her dancing skills. If SM manages her well, there's no doubt she can also grow significantly as a vocalist. I can't wait to witness her evolution.
P.S. For anyone tempted to argue that the other girls are hardworking and share similar traits, let me remind you: this isn't about them. This is about Winter and my solid opinion of her.
Winter ain't give any second, 🥶 if cyberpunk 2077 were real winter would be the status ❤
NingNing has come a long way and she nailed her performance perfectly!!! It sucks that we have four amazing girls on stage and are forced to pick a bias.
Winter short hair🔛🔝🛐💕
Ningning & Giselle are OWNING this era!
Can't wait for you guys to learn their personalities they're really funny and cute😌😌❤️ winter's duality is mind blowing
"I feel sorry for anyone who isn't into K-pop, especially aespa." ~ Esosa 2024
Because same. They ate with this Whiplash comeback. 2024 has been definitely their year. Bop after bop after bop
❤
It’s Winter’s world and we’re just living in it
Ningning has such a strong aura on stage its actually insane, born to be an iconic performer QUEEEEEEN
NINGSELLE JUST OWNED THIS ERA
not you guys getting into my two ults skz and aespa at the same time i love life😭
@@222natix me
Did you know Winter is Waackxxxy’s student, she was on swf2 for the mega challenge and they talked about how she was her student that’s why she has such good lines especially with her arms. That’s why I absolutely loved Sparks choreo, and I think this one suits her as well.
Ningning’s stage presence is insane, she eats every comeback… and Aespa girls are the true IT girls
Bro we are both a Winter bias! I was giggly when you said you are a Levul Girly 😭❄️🔥 her aura and stage presence is insane!
clicked faster than anyone!! like a whiplash!! thankyou for the reaction guys!!
winter is insaneeeeeee
가수를 최고로 빛날때 찍어주는 저 카메라감독님들의 능력도 대박인거 같아요.
국뽕같겠지만 진짜 직캠영상은 한국에서 배워가야한다고 봐요.
동감입니다
그런데 무빙이 부장님 무빙이 아니에요 ㅠㅠ 부하직원 무빙이네요
*you guys should react to their second performance where they were the solider theme outfit bc their stage presence was sooo good there and mama 2023 performance too and upload it on YT bc I can't afford patron I am student* 😢😢😅
@@ningningisthenextitgirlinthewo yes 🙌🏻
Winter is so perfect in this stage everything is perfect ajdgkaiqyehsjkakqkqkq
Winters groove is nastyyyy i love watching her dance one of my fav performers in kpop
Their outfits at all the music shows during the whiplash promotion are very nice and beautiful😍💗
Winter’s isolation goes CRAZY 😭 She’s improved so much. I swear I can’t have a bias in Aespa it changes like every week
이번 컴백 무대들은 여러 팀들이 돌아가면서 우리를 놀라게 하는 중 입니다. 최고. 최고. 최고. 최고.
모든 팀들이 아주 작정하고 컴백을 했어요.
가장 치열한 시기인 거 같아요. 우열을 가리기가 너무 힘들어.
금년은 에스파의 해인 것 같아요. 연말에 보면 알겠지만.
aespa is so pretty
Bruh, I unknowingly started saying "AESPA! WE GOT AESPA!" because of Esosa lmao😂
NINGNING the woman you are ! she's stunning she's everything look at her facial expression ..... on fire
I LOVE YALL SO MUCH❤😭
THE DANCE IS ON FIRE 🔥🙇🏻🙌🏻
26:47 ESOSA YOUR SO RIGHT ABOUT PEOPLE NOT BEING INTO K-POP BECAUSE THEY ARE MISSING OUTTT
loving the extra aespa content 😁 Hoping you do more and more of them 🤩
ningning is insane
와 무대 리액션도 해주는거야??) 내 밥 반찬….
I feel so lucky to have one of the same biases as yall bc the parts yall want to zoom & see again are the same for me😂
finally a i see a reaction that sees winter as i see, she is sooo goood!
YOU NEED TO SEE AESPA MMA 2023. THEY GOT THE BEST PEFORMANCE
이건 예술이야 너무 아름답다!!!
Reactions were too real, yall should deffo react to the full 5th mini album...💗💗
Karina is THAT girl of aespa 🎉
Ningning looks unbelievable this era
Winter is the one, the only one you know what I am saying crazy good
Not gonna lie I wasn’t feeling the choreography something just felt missing but I can definitely appreciate the stage presence especially from winter
dancer here!!! nine times out of ten (refering to the comment about karina's styling) the bottom part will be sown into the shorts or just pinned on the inside so that they don't have to tie/or snap at the crotch. because they/we wear multiple layers, they would consider that,. it also is/can be preference of the performer! but because she has to wear (i'm assuming) some sort of seamless panty/underwear, plus safety shorts AND her outfit shorts, they wouldn't make her snap the crotch due to honestly possible injury. so it's probably stuffed in there and pinned or sown! (also crotch snapped clothing is not beneficial for quick changes! so if they had to be somewhere after they def didn't snap.)
Thank youuuuu cause it stressed me out 😭
Please react to dance practice to
It's hard to believe sometimes that Winter is such an introvert
OMGGG im loving sooo much all this aespa content, thank uuu queenssss, u guys should definitely watch other performances like the ONE TAKE(theres pinkselle hairography, ningning and karina ponytail and winter cunty red bob, with insane outfits) and the last one they did taday(there is karina with bangs and ninning CURLY HAIR)!!!
lots of love from brazil
Я смотрю уже десятую версию исполнения и мне никогда не надоест😂
плюс
Winter goes mad MAD this comeback
hi im a big fan, i request you should watch every fancam of whiplash cause it's so good!
My Winter. I adore you.
I love u guys reaction SM !!! WISH U REACT TO THEIR BSIDE THO❤
Good song and performance 👍👏😍
SP ningninģ always number one, gosh
More aespa please, we love it 🥰😍🥰😍
I rewatch this every 3 hours i can't wait for a new video 😭😭😭❤️❤️
@14:15 im crying 😭 that was so funny but so REAL
thank you so much girlsss....
리액션 맛집~~!!!
winter drives me crazy
I LOVE THEM SO MUCH BROOOOOOOOOOO THEY ARE THE PERFECT DIVAS
man they really are Next Level that was a warning
Ningning could really be a model she really has a killer look
YES, ALL THE ERAS. I'm so seated for this oh yeah 🥹
I'm in a room full of Winter's army! 😘😘😘
im still in SHOCK i finally get to see my fav group live in LA SOOOONNNN AHHHH
Loving the aespa reactions ❤😂
please give us aespa series it will be crazyyy
pls do more aespa fancams❤️
Winter
NingNing is tooooo captivating 🔥 if you watch other eras you HAVE to watch her drama fancams!!
I just want to say that Winter is best member in terms of expressions from day 1. She knows what concept and song requires what expressions and I noticed it from Dreams come true era. This was era where their concept wasn't ai ,it was fun,lovely and fairy concept era so it means they have to smile often with lyrics and here only Winter was the one who actually embodied that concept fully. Karina and Giselle were also good but Ningning was worst. Ningning really has to improve in this aspect bcs her facial expressions are always same in every song whatever the concept is. She has fierce expressions always. She has great stage presence but when it comes to embodying concept and acting according to it, she is worst. Giselle and Karina are on and off and Winter is best. I know many fans would think I am hater or biased but I am an ot4 bias and I have really noticed this thing from their debut era. People think Winter has improved in terms of expressions. No she was always good at it ,what she actually improved is in her dancing skills being sharper than before. Now her strength doesn't seem weak
Ningning！！！omg！what can I say, slay queen❤
Denied being into them since Drama era and I’m finally ulting them and watching all their content… they’re such stars
It was legit Ningning's birthday that day hence the kiss lmao
I have an idea, AESPA tiktok's, i just know y'all are going to die when you watch them especially, Esosa with the Winter edits 😭
Finally 🎉
Love from Kurdistan part of Iraq ❤
You should check out Whiplash - album !!
2 new fancams released for whiplash inkigayo one take sbs and another one with good camerawork I think you'd go crazy
ouh yall should watch ningning’s npop drama fancam!
I'm number 1 subscriber here.
omg u guys need to watch the other songs fancams too like they are are breathe taking specially the latest ( Drama, Armageddon, supernova)
NingNing My Love❤
AESPUHHHHHH
🗣️ AESPUUUH
ESOSA IS MEEE FR WINTER WE FREAKING LOVE YOU.
Those who don't know, Giselle gave Ning a kiss as this was her birthday and she just surprised her with it during their rehearsals ☺️ the Ningselle crumbs
They do be giving me whiplash just watching them 😭
Winter is always perfect
진짜 에스파 춤노래 너무 쇠맛너무좋아!!!
02:28 love that reaction
So good so cool 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
i love theeeeem😭
10:21 I thought I was the only one who noticed that Giselle loves either looking down or seducing the camera whenever she performs that's why I love her lol
AAAEEEUUUUUSPA FANCAMS YES