I just had a weird feeling like nothing was real. We are some creatures trying to analyze our world from within it. Think about a blood cell trying to see what your face looks like. Or a fish that has never been outside of a bowl trying to see what is outside the house and around the block. That's basically what we are trying to do. Life is a very odd and weird thing.
Does anybody watch these vids while they're in bed? edit: wow, forgot about this comment. Didn't know it had so many upvotes. I wrote it a long time ago when I was in college and I was falling asleep in bed. I was kinda retarded back then but I graduated college with a science degree at 35 years old. So if I can do that, just about anything is possible. 🙂 Anyways, since you're reading this, everything will turn out okay in your life. Just make sure you have a plan and stick to it. There's too much craziness going on in the world. Baby steps count too so don't beat yourself up over not achieving your dreams within a few months or years. Greatness takes time so stay positive. I hope you all achieve your dreams, no matter how big or small!
Years ago, in Central Europe, I simultaneously interpreted (as in translated in real time from English to Czech), a debate between Richard Dawkins and Lawrence Krauss. I was 22, was still a student of interpreting, but did all I could to make it a good job. Later during the same festival, I met Dr Krauss and Prof Dawkins, as they were receiving awards, the ceremony of which I also interpreted. Prof Dawkins was very distant and cold (understandably, he has tons of people approaching him). Dr Krauss immediately grabbed my arm and insisted on taking tons of pictures with me, telling me that he had heard from his fridnds I had done a great job. Might not sound like much, but it was a life-changing moment, as he was my hero. At that moment, I decided I wanted to make people happy in life and also, that I want to be the one who’s interpreted, not the one interpreting. I owe a lot to this man, who will probably never know how much he changed my little perspective.
I'm starting my training as a simultaneous translator in a month and your story is so inspirational. This Lawrence guy is awesome but your comment just made me rethink of my year long training at school - that I've made the right choice. Moments like these are so magical. I'm training Eng-Korean to Eng and never have I expected to share a valuable experience of a translator in Czech thousand miles away. I don't know why I'm feel so much in connection😆 Thank you for sharing your amazing story, and one day I too wish to be translated in the future.
I think what he means is space is unpredictable, not many believed in Black Hole existence until we finally got a picture of one. You can also use theoretically a wormhole to fast travel.
@@javierlandaverde4108 honestly with the Gimbal craft that Commander Fraser filmed you don’t need one. Because someone/something has built a machine that can bend space......
@@lesbiantrump4230 Thanks for your great contribution to the discussion! We have documented footage of craft that can travel in ways that appear to break the laws of physics. You saying nonsense doesn't change that fact.
My brain starts to hurt every time I think about space being infinite. Humans have a hard time accepting there are things that exist with no beginning and no end.
Thank you Joe Rogan for inviting people like Lawrence Krauss to your podcast. These people deserve an audience, and your platform is a great help in giving it to them.
Vic Limited people can say whatever they like. You have to earn credibility and respect. Lawrence Krauss is a professor of theoretical physics and cosmology and an author on the subject, spending his life dedicated to the study. Highly respected and awarded from scientific institutions. That’s why I asked who you were to discredit him.
@@ninjacouch9351 it appeared to be working until the us applied heavy sanctions. Castro was a dictator that everyone hated, unless you ask the Cuban people
Put 2 dots on a balloon, inflate the balloon. The dots them selves do not move, they move on the expanding space(balloon) , this is analagous to the galaxies moving away from each other. Its the "fabric" of space expanding.
Anyone overthink all of this stuff so much all the time? Then constantly think how it is insane that we’re worrying about things so trivial and small? Sometimes it motivates me, and sometimes it makes me think why the fuck should I care about anything aha
I suggest stop caring about anything and go around and be a threat to society because the human population is nothing but a local insignificance in a cosmic scale. So go nuts
Ever consider it with an opposing viewpoint? That no matter how much we study or seek answers we may never find them so instead of dwelling on the potential forever unknown...you focus on the small and trivial and find meaning in your temporary life and try to enjoy your existence. Gratitude can be good for you. The other stuff is way beyond us and w exam humble ourselves to not know everything. The universe is greater than what the human mind can conceive.
There are a few basic questions about the source of the universe, for example, A. Is the concept of abstract reality rational? B. Could there be different universal rules or laws of physics, many universes (multiverse)? C. Is spacetime finite or infinite? D. Is the source of energy from a quantum field or a cyclic universe? E. And did something “just exist” or was it created? This video, ua-cam.com/video/Emf6h8KwAdM/v-deo.html, provides a framework for a logical discussion of these “philosophical” issues. It defines what precedes the big bang in terms of nothing plus four somethings (universal rules, laws of physics, spacetime, and energy). This description provides a reference point for philosophical questions related to the four somethings (8 minute video).
@@aram7863 Why did you bring studying into this? The original comment and replies were about learning science, much like the video - not something arbitrary
@@aram7863 His idea of a multiverse is 'pockets' matter moving so fast away from each other (expansion from the big bang, for example) in space that nothing can bridge the gap, effectively creating a seperate universes - the observable one and the none-observable one(s). Since nothing from these regions can interact with other regions, they could have varying laws of physics yet all exist upon the same plane of reality
“so we can say logically in that picture, the reason the universe looks like the way it does is because we’re here to measure it.” You could say that the we are the universe experiencing itself. It's not a stretch.
broshaman exactly my thoughts. We are basically the universe finally being able to become self aware of its own existence. Alan Watts(British philosopher) teaches this.
Yes, but Krauss is entirely boring about it, because he only thinks about it. Buddha (and many others) experience the reality of it. That's the gamechanger. More and more I think it's not about whether god or religion "exist", it's about what our capacity as humans is to experience. Because its clear we are the universe experiencing itself as a separate being, but since that separate being has no essential existence apart from that universe, it's quite logical that we should all be able to experience the reality of oneness with that absolute. It's really just our ignorance about being a separate being that prevents us from seeing it.
This is total b*******if you want to know the truth watch my videos about accelerating expansion of the universe... Dark matter is creating the illusion of accelerating expansion! if something has three dimensions than it has mass you can't give something three dimensions and say it has no Mass... Light cannot escape a black hole because it is fundamentally three-dimensional therefore it has mass and cant escape. dark matter is absorbing energy forms that passed through it breaking off bits of its strings to compress them into more hooks... This process is exponential growth and it creates the illusion of accelerating expansion! scientist came to the conclusion that objects can travel faster than light!!!! That makes absolutely no logical sense at all even when you break it down! My solution solves all the problems with the current standard model! Unifies everything! Preserves numbers and explains irrational completely illogical nature of the universe as observed through human eyes.
@@Bigbywashere that's fine it's your reality draw whatever conclusions you wish because it's easier for your brain to not to make a new category and classify something as unknown... It's okay to stay in your bubble that's natural. Lu anyways 😘😘😘
@@MartinP95 exactly, one scientists theory may be another scientists joke so just because you are scientifically literate doesn't mean you would understand their talk ..
This is total b*******if you want to know the truth watch my videos about accelerating expansion of the universe... Dark matter is creating the illusion of accelerating expansion! if something has three dimensions than it has mass you can't give something three dimensions and say it has no Mass... Light cannot escape a black hole because it is fundamentally three-dimensional therefore it has mass and cant escape. dark matter is absorbing energy forms that passed through it breaking off bits of its strings to compress them into more hooks... This process is exponential growth and it creates the illusion of accelerating expansion! scientist came to the conclusion that objects can travel faster than light!!!! That makes absolutely no logical sense at all even when you break it down! My solution solves all the problems with the current standard model! Unifies everything! Preserves numbers and explains irrational completely illogical nature of the universe as observed through human eyes.
I remember in high school always debating hard against the universe being infinite. I’d always try to get the other person to truly grasp what it would mean if space was always expanding. It was a mind blowing thing but I never thought it to be true. I’d explain that if space was expanding infinitely then there is literally infinite possibilities. there is an infinite amount of yous out there, there is an infinite amount of replicas of our earth and our sun and our solar system as a whole. that’s when I learned of the multiverse and started venturing deeper into my mind, expanding on what I once thought to be absurd! Life, space, and time is truly mystifying 😁
yes but also no i think. Because there are orders of infinity. Could be totally wrong just like the theory of rebirth (expansion/contraction) it is just a theory that cant be proven as of now.
For anyone having a hard time understanding the concept if you drive a car and pass a sign at 50 MPH, you would say that the sign is moving away from you at 50 MPH right? now let’s introduce a second car but going in the opposite direction, this car is ALSO going 50 MPH so, 2 cars driving away from each other at 50 MPH would be separating at a rate of 100 MPH even tho neither car is going that fast. Now for the last part of our little thought experiment, we’re going to replace the cars with universes and instead of 50 MPH we’re going to say like 75% the speed of light (obviously not the correct speed just a number to use) NOW the rate at which these universes are separating is FASTER than the speed of light without either universe actually breaking light speed
I think it relates more to distance than speed. If new space is always popping up between things the further away you get the faster you are moving away. At some point you get so far away that not even light can reach us then it's outside of our universe.
Kurious Yeti imagine how Joe Rogan feels, talking with these scientists and getting knowledge and the next day he is with Eddie listening to him about space being fake.
Lawrence Krauss walks into an eyeglasses store, a smiling clerk approaches and asks, "May I help you find something in particular sir?" Lawrence Krauss relies "Do you have anything that says, modern day Mad Scientist?" Clerk, "Yes sir, I have just the thing!"
After your set-up I assumed it was gonna be a great joke with a killer punch. I was sorely let down :( could have at least made a better description haha
7:12 Krauss: “so we can say logically in that picture, the reason the universe looks like the way it does is because we’re here to measure it.” Joe: *Mindfuck*
You can see and hear Krauss’ passion about these topics . He uses simple analogies to help interested non-scientists (like me) better understand these concepts, so I can read further and use critical thinking to understand even further. As a boy growing up in the rural South, I would spend hours in an open field at night, gazing up at the awe and majesty of the Milky Way, and wondering. Fifty years later, that awe, wonder, and interest has not diminished. On a sad note, among those numerous nights over many summers, I never saw anything that looked extraterrestrial. Hey Aliens: you had your chance. I was waiting! 😁 👽
Szaam.Have you considered that you may have more than two options? I sympathise though.When you can think of nothing else but this other person & the thought of them rejecting you is the worst thing you can think of.You have to ask yourself what's worse.Your current uncertainty,confusion & pain.Or the definite pain & humiliation of rejection.The first option is a never-ending torture.The second option would hurt but you'd at least get closure.However,we've missed one possibility.The recipient of your affection may say yes.Hell,they might even be waiting for you to make a move.However it pans out I wish you well.Best of luck from one existentially confused human to another.☺
This is total b*******if you want to know the truth watch my videos about accelerating expansion of the universe... Dark matter is creating the illusion of accelerating expansion! if something has three dimensions than it has mass you can't give something three dimensions and say it has no Mass... Light cannot escape a black hole because it is fundamentally three-dimensional therefore it has mass and cant escape. dark matter is absorbing energy forms that passed through it breaking off bits of its strings to compress them into more hooks... This process is exponential growth and it creates the illusion of accelerating expansion! scientist came to the conclusion that objects can travel faster than light!!!! That makes absolutely no logical sense at all even when you break it down! My solution solves all the problems with the current standard model! Unifies everything! Preserves numbers and explains irrational completely illogical nature of the universe as observed through human eyes.
I'd love it if Joe did a series where he interviews many brilliant scientists - like the series where he debunked absurd things, but with legit scientists. I suppose I'll include Lawrence Krauss in that list, although his explanation for the basics of Inflationary Cosmology could be expressed far more clearly than it was here. Even though Brian Greene is not necessarily held in high regard by large swathes of the physics community (most especially those who think that physics must remain an experimental science to be considered physics at all), his descriptions of inflationary cosmology for a pop-audience have a great deal of clarity and eloquence. He's a brilliant speaker and there are numerous lectures to be found on line. He wrote a book called "The Hidden Reality" that describes 10 different versions of how the universe could be infinite. He glazes over a number of details that really fill out the picture and bring it into focus, but if you read "The Fabric of the Cosmos" first, most of that stuff is given a clean explanation. This field is profoundly deep and worthy of your time, Joe Rogan. Hope you find out about it.
Lawrence is a brilliant mind, yet he is able to e plain things to the average Joe like myself. Thats why I love to listen to him. Thank you Lawrence and thank you Joe for having him on for a talk.
Joe Rogan frequently has his mind blown when listening to people who have studied things besides a rear naked choke and the bathroom wall in Middle School.
@@lijingsua7691 Because we as humans can not experience the universe fully, we experience it through our senses, thats why an universe outside our own perspective seems like an illusion or not as real as what we can experience on our own.
Lemon Haze agreed. We can only see so much of the color spectrum, hear between certain frequencies, only feel so much through our tactile senses, only smell so many scents, only taste so many flavors or find them appealing. Granted, that’s still a lot to experience. Like Zen, if you’re actually in the moment, you can heighten/sharpen your senses. I think the closest we can get to experiencing all the Universe has to offer is by being like that ^^^ or somehow reaching higher dimensions by meditating or by taking psychedelics/hallucinogenics such as DMT, psilocybin mushrooms and LSD.
ACID one small difference...nobody needs to memorize any of it,and his book does not judge,or incites people to kill...there's no sunday scientism school....oh wait,that's more then one difference....and there are so many many more.....
@@airfun5001 i'm the opposite side of what you believed in pal' I was an Atheist / Science dogmatic dude before. I just wake up one day and found out that they are all the same lmfao.
Lawrence is a great physicist and he knows how to play the philosopher too and he has the decency and humility to qualify "that it could be" and "might be".
He does NOT know how to ''play the philosopher''. He is perhaps most guilty of sloppy arguments. Just look at David Albert (a physicist AND philosopher) and his takedown of Krauss' book.
I like that last thing he said, the reason our picture of our universe looks like it does is because we’re here to measure it. I AGREEEEEE on so many levels!
In his defense this is some heavy material and they are going over it with no visual aids or mathematical models. That would make actually understanding these concepts a lot harder to parse the first time you are being introduced to them.
Not really. It's the start to making space travel more feasible. If space travel is feasible on a massive scale, humans don't have to compete for precious resources on Earth. It could end useless wars.
i mean whatelse are you gonna die saying you witnessed old folks got the moon we got mars and i'm not ready to give up on this generation's breakthrough cause it's just tiny
Gian Santillan we can easily solve the resource problem by switching to a circular economy where all products are recicled. Scientific exploration a mich better reason to go on Mars. With that said, you completely missunderstood my comment. It feels so meaningless as a first step. Such a big deal today in science and space exploration is nothing compared to what this guy just said about the whole universe.
The weird part about realising how huge and endless the multiverse is, is that we are all so incredibly unimportant. Celebrities and icons that people look up to and believe to be special or maybe we see ourselves as being special when none of us truly are. Their are endless celebrities, icons, people in each period of time in each area of the multiverse. The amount of living and dying is unthinkable and an unfathomable number. It will continue for eternity also which drills my point home. Endless earth like planets, endless human like beings. Which makes it even more profound. This is of course just my opinion and my view on space but to me, it is the most logical explanation, which was explained brilliantly by Krauss.
He's not feeding your brain. He's washing your brain. Practically everything he said was either self contradicting or based on pure fantasy and speculation
When you learn the mysteries of universe you'll realize you should've just stayed on the couch watching TV and getting drunk. You can't do anything with the answer.
Hey guys, some questions (I'm not a physicist, so I would appreciate an answer that is relatively easy to understand. Thanks!): How do you call the space that contains then all the universes? Is there even something like that? Are there limits for space? Can it really expand infinitely? Thank you!
It's called the universe. It would have been better if physicists had not adopted the multiverse terminology but instead had called it something like a "multi-domain universe". That is both mathematically and scientifically far more accurate. Personally I like the term "foliation" but it happens to be used already for a very different kind of phenomenon. At the end of the day, though, what's in a name? A rose by any other name smells just as sweet.
Remember hearing a theory of a pain of glass that light takes 5 years to travel through... So you'd be seeing everything through the window that happened 5 years ago like looking into the past...
@@magnusjonsson7303 infinity is time expantion is space the 2 are diffrent time and space what you can say is the space is expanding come on man the dude wrote in his book the universe come from nothing again i quote nothing
@@magnusjonsson7303 hhhhhhh a cunning question you didnt accept the fact that you time and space are 2 diffrent thing but if your asking if im a thiest then yes i believe in a first cause that generatod the universe a creator a real infinite one
This comment section is cancer. People have no clue what Krauss is even saying here. They literally think that he's saying that the multiverse is a scientific theory, and nobody seems to understand that "universe" in science has a completely different definition.
What is that definition of universe? ... and what does he mean by multiverse other than different bubbles of nothing filled with something with their own set of physics separated by nothing or something? Literally... the multiverse is a theory? Explain what you mean by that
The classification of a universe in science is when the expansion of space accelerates non-locally at a higher rate than the speed of light outside of the center of expansion. That's how a new universe is classified. The laws of physics could be different in a different universe, which isn't hard to imagine since the laws of physics can differ within one universe, black holes for example. There's no evidence of another universe; at least not yet, but we can calculate how a finite universe could exist elsewhere based on the expansion of this universe. It's impossible to see another universe with our equipment because we rely on light, and there's no way light from another universe could reach us. The mutiverse is not a theory, it's a hypothesis. A theory is a well-substantiated explanation of the natural world through testing, experiment, and observation. Nothing in science is more demonstrable than a scientific theory; they are ranked higher than scientific laws. For example... the law of gravity could be debunked tomorrow, but the theory of gravity would remain the same because it's not debatable. The mutiverse is not even remotely close to being a theory.
exactly. these UA-cam scientists amuse me. he's merely offering a possibility that he thinks is likely. nothing he said indicated this to be the case. Joe asked how and he explained a possibility. that's it. I hate stupid people who refuse to listen.
EVERYTHING HAS A DIFFERENT MEANING IN SCIENCE, RIGHT? IF YOU WANT TO WIN AN ARGUMENT, JUST TELL PEOPLE THAT SCIENCE IS CORRECT, BECAUSE WORDS MEAN SOMETHING TOTALLY DIFFERENT IN SCIENCE, THEREFORE WE WIN! Sorry, your science cult beliefs don't hold water either.
I’m glad I already knew all of this, but I remember when I first did research on this, and my mind was blown like Joe’s. It’s still hard to wrap my head around us in the distant future not being able to see any other galaxies except for those in our local group.
1 He speaks too fast 2 he does not pronounce properly 3 he mumbles 4 he does not create structured sentences 5 he does not use analogies correctly in structured sentences. Communication is more important than the idea in your brain.
Don’t worry, this cocky guy is dumb. He’s giving his interpretation of measured data as truth, while accusing everyone else to be dumb. What an idiot. His most stupid statement is: universe created its self from nothing. X->Y (fine). But X->X is extremely stupid. :)
It’s simple. Two galaxies are each moving at a little over half the speed of light away from each other. I love his last line “because we’re here to measure it.” All measurements are based on our perceptions, and our perceptions are based on our very limited five senses. 99% of people cannot even begin to grasp those concepts.
how to make a yeah, the amount of ignorance in the comment section is heart breaking. Those guys don't bother to look at the paper and see the complicated math at all.
kenflowfohsho03 it’s fine. everybody in the comment section are too dumb for it too. Difference is they want to act like they know what they are talking about.
No, to admit you don't know is the first step to advancing your learning. Ask a question and be a fool for 5 minutes....never ask and be a fool for life.
our "observable universe" expands because of dark energy. metaverse is around our universe and expands at inflationary expansion rate (alot faster). thats the theories.
@@alimotai5749 its what Einstein called the cosmological constant. It is energy inherent in the fabric of space itself. It has a repulsive force (pushing), so its expanding the fabric of space.
That makes total sense but the only problem is what about quantum entanglement? Isn’t possible that two subatomic particles could be entangled across a horizon since they are entangled in this universe? If so, we could potentially bridge a gap to another universe across a horizon.
I just had a weird feeling like nothing was real. We are some creatures trying to analyze our world from within it. Think about a blood cell trying to see what your face looks like. Or a fish that has never been outside of a bowl trying to see what is outside the house and around the block.
That's basically what we are trying to do. Life is a very odd and weird thing.
Uncle Fkr nice
Uncle Fkr nice
Uncle Fkr nice
Lol what's up with the nice?
Uncle Fkr you're just deeply confused lol
Does anybody watch these vids while they're in bed?
edit: wow, forgot about this comment. Didn't know it had so many upvotes. I wrote it a long time ago when I was in college and I was falling asleep in bed. I was kinda retarded back then but I graduated college with a science degree at 35 years old. So if I can do that, just about anything is possible. 🙂
Anyways, since you're reading this, everything will turn out okay in your life. Just make sure you have a plan and stick to it. There's too much craziness going on in the world. Baby steps count too so don't beat yourself up over not achieving your dreams within a few months or years. Greatness takes time so stay positive. I hope you all achieve your dreams, no matter how big or small!
feslerae she I'm currently dropping deuce so large I might bleed.
jake5344 I believe in you.
feslerae In bed watching it now. Always do.
feslerae that's all I ever needed to hear.
David Jimenez me too :)
Years ago, in Central Europe, I simultaneously interpreted (as in translated in real time from English to Czech), a debate between Richard Dawkins and Lawrence Krauss. I was 22, was still a student of interpreting, but did all I could to make it a good job.
Later during the same festival, I met Dr Krauss and Prof Dawkins, as they were receiving awards, the ceremony of which I also interpreted. Prof Dawkins was very distant and cold (understandably, he has tons of people approaching him). Dr Krauss immediately grabbed my arm and insisted on taking tons of pictures with me, telling me that he had heard from his fridnds I had done a great job. Might not sound like much, but it was a life-changing moment, as he was my hero.
At that moment, I decided I wanted to make people happy in life and also, that I want to be the one who’s interpreted, not the one interpreting. I owe a lot to this man, who will probably never know how much he changed my little perspective.
Constructive achievement luck to you man 💚 keep going 👍
wow
As a fellow translator, i love translating.
I'm starting my training as a simultaneous translator in a month and your story is so inspirational. This Lawrence guy is awesome but your comment just made me rethink of my year long training at school - that I've made the right choice. Moments like these are so magical. I'm training Eng-Korean to Eng and never have I expected to share a valuable experience of a translator in Czech thousand miles away. I don't know why I'm feel so much in connection😆
Thank you for sharing your amazing story, and one day I too wish to be translated in the future.
B E A utiful story! We are nodes in a network. You never know the power of the smallest of actions. Really beautiful example of that. This made my day
Joe Rogan is the luckiest celebrity, he's friends with all these cool smart people that he can chat with for hours
It’s hard work not luck you dumb commie
@@thomascarrigan6215 mix of both you overly aggressive beta
@@lordorochimaru2800 he’s real quiet after that lmao
@@lordorochimaru2800 hell yeah
@@thomascarrigan6215 I’m so sorry if I at all hurt your feelings
" the universe is under no obligation to make sense to you"
I'm going to put that on a t-shirt
🤔
In fact, I think I'm gonna get some stickers made up too! 🤗
It was a Neil DeGrasse Tyson quote
@@Edward-qe8xg indeed. astrophysics for people in a hurry a novel by Neil Degrasse Tyson👍💯👨🎓
*sense* (ironically, you misspelled the word)
@@kevinl3298 thank u
"but space can do whatever the hell it wants" broke something in Joe.
I think what he means is space is unpredictable, not many believed in Black Hole existence until we finally got a picture of one. You can also use theoretically a wormhole to fast travel.
@@javierlandaverde4108 honestly with the Gimbal craft that Commander Fraser filmed you don’t need one. Because someone/something has built a machine that can bend space......
@@khimaros nonsense
@@lesbiantrump4230 Thanks for your great contribution to the discussion! We have documented footage of craft that can travel in ways that appear to break the laws of physics. You saying nonsense doesn't change that fact.
Lol
This man did a good job trying to break these ideas down into layman’s terms, but damn, I was still barely holding on.
idk wtf he's trying to talk about right now. Fk this sht im out
@S S ua-cam.com/video/wG6hMxPNzII/v-deo.html
@@taylorbrad111 thank you but im a guy fknut
@@zazarays pretty sure he’s talking to the commenter
@@viaredzagames ...i dont think so
He explained this theory incredibly well. Im sitting here nodding like "mhm mhm, yes sir I do concur" like I studied this entire life 😂😂😂
Pretty good indication u would believe anything
@@southernindianaexplorers9520 hence, FLAT EARTH🤷🏻♂️
IDK but I'm hungry
ME 2 - lol
My brain starts to hurt every time I think about space being infinite. Humans have a hard time accepting there are things that exist with no beginning and no end.
Everything has a beginning and end.
Brandon Cruz my point exactly. It’s hard to comprehend. But space is infinite.
@@nicklarson801 What about time? Are you saying space and time are one?
Brandon Cruz no, I am saying time is a made up concept by humans. It applies to most things, but not everything.
@@nicklarson801 Like most, I'm fascinated by this stuff but I think nobody, alive or dead, will ever know the answer... ever...and/or (forever LOL)
Thank you Joe Rogan for inviting people like Lawrence Krauss to your podcast.
These people deserve an audience, and your platform is a great help in giving it to them.
Thomas R - Krauss can not prove a word he says. It's quite funny.
and when someone threatens what he has been told or what he has read - he gets aggresive and rude - like a child.
Vic Limited okay... who are you?
@@walrusgumboot its not about who you are.....its about what you say.
Vic Limited people can say whatever they like. You have to earn credibility and respect. Lawrence Krauss is a professor of theoretical physics and cosmology and an author on the subject, spending his life dedicated to the study. Highly respected and awarded from scientific institutions. That’s why I asked who you were to discredit him.
"Inflation is eternal.."
*Venezuela has entered the chat*
Lol! Indeed.
Zimbabwe: hold my beer ...
So true I’m best friends with 3 of em and they hate their government
The only reason socialism hasn't worked is because we haven't tried it'd in the USA
/s
@@ninjacouch9351 it appeared to be working until the us applied heavy sanctions. Castro was a dictator that everyone hated, unless you ask the Cuban people
I miss THIS Joe Rogan, where he was just curious about things and had cool and interesting people on all of the time
Exactly. Now he mostly has fringe pseudoscientists on :(
This comment has honestly aged like a fine wine. The podcast has went downhill since the move to Texas
@@GoldenMinotaur Not sure if it was Texas or Spotify. I couldn't tell you. I don't pay attention anymore since he's no longer on UA-cam.
Golden era of the podcast. Once a month browse through to see if any interesting guest, rarely is since his move.
Nobody wants to go and visit Texas, that’s why 😂 at least none of those type of guests.
That guy is so smart that his brain pushed back his hairline just to make more room. Brain-pattern baldness...
I can't stop laughing, but it's so wrong!
Hahahaha
Maquina Ghost 😂😂😭😂😂
@Jason Strom LMAO
@Jason Strom You sir should volunteer in his Dabates
part of me wants a podcast where joe gets high on psychedelics and gets scientists to explain stuff to him to blow his mind.
Thats not much different than the JRE
The JRE's with Graham Hancock and Randall Carlson are pretty much what part of you wants :)
That pretty much sums up this podcast.
Except those two are not scientists. Real science explained by experts in their craft is a thousand times more mind blowing than mythicists.
Bro! You're fuckin right!
Put 2 dots on a balloon, inflate the balloon. The dots them selves do not move, they move on the expanding space(balloon) , this is analagous to the galaxies moving away from each other. Its the "fabric" of space expanding.
Fucking finnaly. Someone isn't calling it bullshit with no evidence. Thank you for being smart
good one👍
@@iamcancer3298 I think I have you.
lol...have me?
@@iamcancer3298 yes. I think I have you.
Krauss is amazing. Glad to see him on JRE.
The Simpsons scientist had to have been based on this guy
Lawrence krauss might look sort of nerdy but he's actually pretty funny and charismatic from the videos I've seen.
more like futuramas scientist
@@grmanuel11 Mas del Futura!
Looks nothing like him and speaks nothing like him
@@grmanuel11 WERNSTROM!!!!!
Anyone overthink all of this stuff so much all the time? Then constantly think how it is insane that we’re worrying about things so trivial and small? Sometimes it motivates me, and sometimes it makes me think why the fuck should I care about anything aha
I suggest stop caring about anything and go around and be a threat to society because the human population is nothing but a local insignificance in a cosmic scale. So go nuts
Ever consider it with an opposing viewpoint? That no matter how much we study or seek answers we may never find them so instead of dwelling on the potential forever unknown...you focus on the small and trivial and find meaning in your temporary life and try to enjoy your existence. Gratitude can be good for you. The other stuff is way beyond us and w exam humble ourselves to not know everything. The universe is greater than what the human mind can conceive.
We can humble*
Never stop thinking
Ya causes me to be depressed, and also at times creatively brilliant. Unfortunately I cannot decide if the good times outweigh the bad
he looks like professor farnsworth on futurama... good news everyone!
I'm rewatching the show. He really does look like a young Farnsworth 😂
Bruh.
We finally renamed Uranus!
Now I can't un-look that! :)
My brain hurts!
There are a few basic questions about the source of the universe, for example,
A. Is the concept of abstract reality rational?
B. Could there be different universal rules or laws of physics, many universes (multiverse)?
C. Is spacetime finite or infinite?
D. Is the source of energy from a quantum field or a cyclic universe?
E. And did something “just exist” or was it created?
This video, ua-cam.com/video/Emf6h8KwAdM/v-deo.html, provides a framework for a logical discussion of these “philosophical” issues. It defines what precedes the big bang in terms of nothing plus four somethings (universal rules, laws of physics, spacetime, and energy). This description provides a reference point for philosophical questions related to the four somethings (8 minute video).
For those people that though science,physics was boring,its a matter of how its taught.
@@aram7863 But I did learn something. I learnt about a new theory of a multiverse that has not once crossed my mind before
@@aram7863 He did explain it
@@aram7863 What does that have to do with this? Sounds like someone has hurt you
@@aram7863 Why did you bring studying into this? The original comment and replies were about learning science, much like the video - not something arbitrary
@@aram7863 His idea of a multiverse is 'pockets' matter moving so fast away from each other (expansion from the big bang, for example) in space that nothing can bridge the gap, effectively creating a seperate universes - the observable one and the none-observable one(s). Since nothing from these regions can interact with other regions, they could have varying laws of physics yet all exist upon the same plane of reality
So space is like the end of the month and light is my paycheck
If you are in communist universe everyone's paycheck is like that.
jigrodrigues man this analogy 😂
This is sad...
That was funny. : )
Seems paycheck is much faster then light. 😀
very confusing..im gonna go drink multi beers at my local pub
In another universe "multi confusing im pub..my drink gonna beers at go very local"
Better hurry before it recedes away from ya
At the multi pub😅🍻
Do you have a “multi thirst”?
all ears99 😂😂😂👍🏽
The surfer, ocean, and shoreline analogy was perfect. I completely understood what he was saying at that point
Can u make me understand i couldn't understood
my belly expands faster than the relative consumption of beer.
get the liver checked
Probably fart gas.
Thanks
On multiverse.
Joe: "how is that even possible?"
Laurence:"of course it is possible!"
Joe:"I'm not questioning it."
He wants to know how, not whether it is possible or nah
2 NPCs in oblivion
Look into it
Because he will never understand. I wouldn’t ask either
123QBKid wanting to know how is still asking a question lol
“so we can say logically in that picture, the reason the universe looks like the way it does is because we’re here to measure it.”
You could say that the we are the universe experiencing itself.
It's not a stretch.
broshaman exactly my thoughts. We are basically the universe finally being able to become self aware of its own existence. Alan Watts(British philosopher) teaches this.
wow original thought woa so cool wow you're original. (Alan Watts)
Buddhists had this figured out way before scientists . Kinda crazy
Yes, but Krauss is entirely boring about it, because he only thinks about it. Buddha (and many others) experience the reality of it. That's the gamechanger.
More and more I think it's not about whether god or religion "exist", it's about what our capacity as humans is to experience. Because its clear we are the universe experiencing itself as a separate being, but since that separate being has no essential existence apart from that universe, it's quite logical that we should all be able to experience the reality of oneness with that absolute. It's really just our ignorance about being a separate being that prevents us from seeing it.
We are a way for the cosmos to get to know itself. Quote from Carl Sagan that blew my mind already 20 years ago.
This will always be on my mind… haven’t forgotten it since the first time I saw it 4 years ago
“But that’s the simple version”💀
U think?
This is total b*******if you want to know the truth watch my videos about accelerating expansion of the universe... Dark matter is creating the illusion of accelerating expansion! if something has three dimensions than it has mass you can't give something three dimensions and say it has no Mass... Light cannot escape a black hole because it is fundamentally three-dimensional therefore it has mass and cant escape. dark matter is absorbing energy forms that passed through it breaking off bits of its strings to compress them into more hooks... This process is exponential growth and it creates the illusion of accelerating expansion! scientist came to the conclusion that objects can travel faster than light!!!! That makes absolutely no logical sense at all even when you break it down! My solution solves all the problems with the current standard model! Unifies everything! Preserves numbers and explains irrational completely illogical nature of the universe as observed through human eyes.
@@AquarianSoulTimeTraveler Bill Gaede's explanation, is it?
@@AquarianSoulTimeTraveler i only read the first 2 sentemces of your comment and im covinced you are delusional
@@Bigbywashere that's fine it's your reality draw whatever conclusions you wish because it's easier for your brain to not to make a new category and classify something as unknown... It's okay to stay in your bubble that's natural. Lu anyways 😘😘😘
His hairline is expanding faster than his hair can grow.
no, his hairline is retracting faster than his hair can grow, eventually it will become a blackhole
Yoster Schnauss learn to laugh gees
😂😂😂
I guess that would make me the exception to the rule ;)
Lmao
I haven’t smoked enough weed to listen to this
I did.greatings from Amsterdam
Fabio Marziali greetings from Connecticut
Physics is better than any drug. And it is beautiful.
@@veranochick drugs are physics too
yaggle fraggle calling people dumb on the internet?? You’re quite the tough guy lmao
Best explanation of the multiverse I've heard. The surfer Analogue made so much sense.
Can someone just give Krauss some weed?
No he needs DMT
Hey uh Krauss, yea want some muffins dude? 😂
Hey Krauss, want some crack cocaine? Or you want some DM fucking T ?
Mushrooms
@@XPCREEPER looking like he does doesn't mean he does, or how do you know? Were you one of them?
I'm stoned, walking downstairs to get food... I'm now stuck on the stairs, mind blown! Love this!
$5 says he's still there, place ya bets 😂
I can’t stay focused
Im stuck on your stairs
This Checks Out!
Funni
Sounds like me talking to the wife while she's trying to watch her favorite show
Probably a stupid reality show right?
😂
hahahaha thats my parents
When a speaker says "right" at the end of his sentences, he doesn't believe what he is saying, he's only looking for agreement.
He could literally be saying anything he imagines and we would never know the difference
unless of course you are scientifically literate.
@@talgmar not really... these are just theories
Gravity is a theory
@@MartinP95 exactly, one scientists theory may be another scientists joke so just because you are scientifically literate doesn't mean you would understand their talk ..
Ammar Anwar How do you feel you illiterate fuck? Talgmar can fucking read science bitch
Here in argentina, inflation is eternal.
jajajajjajajajajajjajaja true fact, i am from uruguay and its a pretty regular activity here too
Our economy lives in a constant big bang state lol
*Venezuela has entered the chat*
This is total b*******if you want to know the truth watch my videos about accelerating expansion of the universe... Dark matter is creating the illusion of accelerating expansion! if something has three dimensions than it has mass you can't give something three dimensions and say it has no Mass... Light cannot escape a black hole because it is fundamentally three-dimensional therefore it has mass and cant escape. dark matter is absorbing energy forms that passed through it breaking off bits of its strings to compress them into more hooks... This process is exponential growth and it creates the illusion of accelerating expansion! scientist came to the conclusion that objects can travel faster than light!!!! That makes absolutely no logical sense at all even when you break it down! My solution solves all the problems with the current standard model! Unifies everything! Preserves numbers and explains irrational completely illogical nature of the universe as observed through human eyes.
@@65333Amit
Physics is too hard for you. I can tell.
“We call that a horizon”
Joe’s face: 😨😨😨
I'll name my kid horizon
It’s terrifying
@@yobitch4569 אופק
Gotta love the wild enthusiasm of a human that believes he has the answers
Why not?
what are you suggesting.
A lot more answers than *beliefs* could ever suffice... *lol*
He's definitely a lot smarter than you, Rube Wilde. And more successful.
He has no answers for answers… everything is always is nothing. It’s unfathomable to the human mind.
Absolutely fascinating stuff. Never had a problem with infinity. The way he explains multiverses makes sense and puts it into perspective for me.
I remember in high school always debating hard against the universe being infinite. I’d always try to get the other person to truly grasp what it would mean if space was always expanding. It was a mind blowing thing but I never thought it to be true. I’d explain that if space was expanding infinitely then there is literally infinite possibilities. there is an infinite amount of yous out there, there is an infinite amount of replicas of our earth and our sun and our solar system as a whole. that’s when I learned of the multiverse and started venturing deeper into my mind, expanding on what I once thought to be absurd! Life, space, and time is truly mystifying 😁
And maybe there used to be dragons.
@@JRobbySh there were
yes but also no i think. Because there are orders of infinity. Could be totally wrong just like the theory of rebirth (expansion/contraction) it is just a theory that cant be proven as of now.
Lawrence Krause has got a brain the size of the multiverse, the enthusiasm of a young child and the passion of Carl Sagan.
Pale Blue Dot
For anyone having a hard time understanding the concept if you drive a car and pass a sign at 50 MPH, you would say that the sign is moving away from you at 50 MPH right? now let’s introduce a second car but going in the opposite direction, this car is ALSO going 50 MPH so, 2 cars driving away from each other at 50 MPH would be separating at a rate of 100 MPH even tho neither car is going that fast. Now for the last part of our little thought experiment, we’re going to replace the cars with universes and instead of 50 MPH we’re going to say like 75% the speed of light (obviously not the correct speed just a number to use) NOW the rate at which these universes are separating is FASTER than the speed of light without either universe actually breaking light speed
I think it relates more to distance than speed. If new space is always popping up between things the further away you get the faster you are moving away. At some point you get so far away that not even light can reach us then it's outside of our universe.
I bet Lawrence Krauss has crazy dreams
rofl at this one
His dreams are just endless games of pong
He dreams in multiple universes.
He dreams of dreams dreaming different dreams.
His dreams are no more different than yours or mine
And then we have Eddie Brah' on the other side yelling "Fake Space".
Lol
Kurious Yeti imagine how Joe Rogan feels, talking with these scientists and getting knowledge and the next day he is with Eddie listening to him about space being fake.
behzad mastoor LMFAOOOOOO
behzad mastoor I mean, until you go there, you don't really know.
@@aamesworld so you have to physically go somewhere to know it exists? Do you believe in other countries or towns then?
I love thinking about things like this. It tickles my brain.
Terrifying
same the only thing makes me really exciting about life
It makes me bask in a crippling anxiety, yet also slight curiosity.
I like Lawrence's "Right?"s. As if nothing could be more obvious than what he just said and maybe 0,1% of humanity really, truly understands.
Lawrence Krauss walks into an eyeglasses store, a smiling clerk approaches and asks, "May I help you find something in particular sir?" Lawrence Krauss relies "Do you have anything that says, modern day Mad Scientist?" Clerk, "Yes sir, I have just the thing!"
the right answer is "say no more!"
After your set-up I assumed it was gonna be a great joke with a killer punch. I was sorely let down :( could have at least made a better description haha
They must have a barber there, too. lol
He’s the professor from Futurama. “GOOD NEWS!”
Or a 40s German Mad Scientist.
7:12
Krauss: “so we can say logically in that picture, the reason the universe looks like the way it does is because we’re here to measure it.”
Joe: *Mindfuck*
explain please i dont get it
Also 2:20
Carlo Torres I don't either 😂.
That doesn't even make sense. It's smart sounding but the substance of everything he says is fantasy and self contradicting.
This needs joe Diaz and a cocaine story woven in somewhere.
😂
You can see and hear Krauss’ passion about these topics . He uses simple analogies to help interested non-scientists (like me) better understand these concepts, so I can read further and use critical thinking to understand even further. As a boy growing up in the rural South, I would spend hours in an open field at night, gazing up at the awe and majesty of the Milky Way, and wondering. Fifty years later, that awe, wonder, and interest has not diminished. On a sad note, among those numerous nights over many summers, I never saw anything that looked extraterrestrial. Hey Aliens: you had your chance. I was waiting! 😁 👽
flat earther be like surfers don't exist man its all CGI.
They don't...
definitely CGI dizzle
lol.. flat-earthers, the only group so daft that even Scientologists mock them...
The best explanation of wierd flat earthers ever !
I don't know whether to tell someone I love them or kill myself.
Tell them you love them.
If you have to choose make sure you do it in that order.
Szaam.Have you considered that you may have more than two options? I sympathise though.When you can think of nothing else but this other person & the thought of them rejecting you is the worst thing you can think of.You have to ask yourself what's worse.Your current uncertainty,confusion & pain.Or the definite pain & humiliation of rejection.The first option is a never-ending torture.The second option would hurt but you'd at least get closure.However,we've missed one possibility.The recipient of your affection may say yes.Hell,they might even be waiting for you to make a move.However it pans out I wish you well.Best of luck from one existentially confused human to another.☺
Szaam unrated comment
Lmao. I can relate to this comment.. All in all.. It does seen it comes down to those.. I'm just seeing how much more I can take..
I like how he's charging up his tri-beam in the thumbnail.
Diksaca Yehovah underrated comment 😂
Or a dome shape 😉
This is total b*******if you want to know the truth watch my videos about accelerating expansion of the universe... Dark matter is creating the illusion of accelerating expansion! if something has three dimensions than it has mass you can't give something three dimensions and say it has no Mass... Light cannot escape a black hole because it is fundamentally three-dimensional therefore it has mass and cant escape. dark matter is absorbing energy forms that passed through it breaking off bits of its strings to compress them into more hooks... This process is exponential growth and it creates the illusion of accelerating expansion! scientist came to the conclusion that objects can travel faster than light!!!! That makes absolutely no logical sense at all even when you break it down! My solution solves all the problems with the current standard model! Unifies everything! Preserves numbers and explains irrational completely illogical nature of the universe as observed through human eyes.
@@AquarianSoulTimeTraveler hmmmm ✨🙆maybe
Kikoho
Don't smoke before Krauss speaks.
2:41 "we'll never be able to see it, we'll never be able to interact with it, we'll never be .. ok"
Why am I crying? That's a very good question.
2:21 the exact moment Joe's brain explodes
Excellent timing my man.
I'd love it if Joe did a series where he interviews many brilliant scientists - like the series where he debunked absurd things, but with legit scientists. I suppose I'll include Lawrence Krauss in that list, although his explanation for the basics of Inflationary Cosmology could be expressed far more clearly than it was here. Even though Brian Greene is not necessarily held in high regard by large swathes of the physics community (most especially those who think that physics must remain an experimental science to be considered physics at all), his descriptions of inflationary cosmology for a pop-audience have a great deal of clarity and eloquence. He's a brilliant speaker and there are numerous lectures to be found on line. He wrote a book called "The Hidden Reality" that describes 10 different versions of how the universe could be infinite. He glazes over a number of details that really fill out the picture and bring it into focus, but if you read "The Fabric of the Cosmos" first, most of that stuff is given a clean explanation. This field is profoundly deep and worthy of your time, Joe Rogan. Hope you find out about it.
Lawrence is a brilliant mind, yet he is able to e plain things to the average Joe like myself. Thats why I love to listen to him. Thank you Lawrence and thank you Joe for having him on for a talk.
07:01 - 07:04 "There are hot big bangs happening in many regions" is the future's answer to "There are hot singles in your local area"
Joe Rogan frequently has his mind blown when listening to people who have studied things besides a rear naked choke and the bathroom wall in Middle School.
Lol
And yet he has done so much better than you. Sad really. For you...
2:20 When the edibles kick in
This is the best Joe Rogan episode. Bring Lawrence backc
Krause certainly has some intelligence but it's a shame he behaves like a predator around younger undergrads.
“We are eternal,
All this pain is an illusion”
Makes no sense
@@lijingsua7691 Because we as humans can not experience the universe fully, we experience it through our senses, thats why an universe outside our own perspective seems like an illusion or not as real as what we can experience on our own.
Lemon Haze holy shit dude... I’m getting a headache just thinking about that.
Lemon Haze agreed. We can only see so much of the color spectrum, hear between certain frequencies, only feel so much through our tactile senses, only smell so many scents, only taste so many flavors or find them appealing.
Granted, that’s still a lot to experience. Like Zen, if you’re actually in the moment, you can heighten/sharpen your senses.
I think the closest we can get to experiencing all the Universe has to offer is by being like that ^^^ or somehow reaching higher dimensions by meditating or by taking psychedelics/hallucinogenics such as DMT, psilocybin mushrooms and LSD.
TOOL!!
Its really amazing and scary how vast and mostly lonely the Universe is.
Larence Krauss is the High Priest of Scientism
ACID one small difference...nobody needs to memorize any of it,and his book does not judge,or incites people to kill...there's no sunday scientism school....oh wait,that's more then one difference....and there are so many many more.....
@@airfun5001 i'm the opposite side of what you believed in pal' I was an Atheist / Science dogmatic dude before. I just wake up one day and found out that they are all the same lmfao.
@@airfun5001 what
Lawrence is a great physicist and he knows how to play the philosopher too and he has the decency and humility to qualify "that it could be" and "might be".
He thinks it's ok to shag your mom too.
He does NOT know how to ''play the philosopher''. He is perhaps most guilty of sloppy arguments. Just look at David Albert (a physicist AND philosopher) and his takedown of Krauss' book.
I like to think this guy and Brian Cox have space battles. Like rap battles but pure space talk.
I like that last thing he said, the reason our picture of our universe looks like it does is because we’re here to measure it. I AGREEEEEE on so many levels!
🤯
Damn homie
He actually helped me see a realistic infinite universe in my head. Nice.
mission complete.
I keep coming back to this channel for the way "Joe's making it up"!
Lol joes dmt's experiences definitely influence his multi-verse theories i love it haha
Ryannn lotta people in Denver too Lol.
yupp & beyond & within
Dave Goffredo what?
your dmt comment is very true
In his defense this is some heavy material and they are going over it with no visual aids or mathematical models. That would make actually understanding these concepts a lot harder to parse the first time you are being introduced to them.
Going to Mars never felt so meaningless.
Not really. It's the start to making space travel more feasible. If space travel is feasible on a massive scale, humans don't have to compete for precious resources on Earth.
It could end useless wars.
Exploring Uranus still sounds like fun though....
it's a step
i mean whatelse are you gonna die saying you witnessed
old folks got the moon we got mars
and i'm not ready to give up on this generation's breakthrough cause it's just tiny
Gian Santillan we can easily solve the resource problem by switching to a circular economy where all products are recicled. Scientific exploration a mich better reason to go on Mars. With that said, you completely missunderstood my comment. It feels so meaningless as a first step. Such a big deal today in science and space exploration is nothing compared to what this guy just said about the whole universe.
This dude looks like Dr.Steven Greer..
And it's scary that they look so alike
Phew, I'm not the only one
I thought it was him, so that is why I had clicked 😂
Is this evidence in favor of the parallel universe theory !?!
The weird part about realising how huge and endless the multiverse is, is that we are all so incredibly unimportant. Celebrities and icons that people look up to and believe to be special or maybe we see ourselves as being special when none of us truly are. Their are endless celebrities, icons, people in each period of time in each area of the multiverse. The amount of living and dying is unthinkable and an unfathomable number. It will continue for eternity also which drills my point home. Endless earth like planets, endless human like beings. Which makes it even more profound. This is of course just my opinion and my view on space but to me, it is the most logical explanation, which was explained brilliantly by Krauss.
Joe’s eyebrows are moving faster than the speed of light away from his eyes
HAHA 😂
Thank you for feeding my brain, Mr. Krauss.
Yea feeding ur brain bullshit this man got crushed by hamza zorzi bro check it out
He's not feeding your brain. He's washing your brain. Practically everything he said was either self contradicting or based on pure fantasy and speculation
When you learn the mysteries of universe you'll realize you should've just stayed on the couch watching TV and getting drunk. You can't do anything with the answer.
Not from the couch you can't.
Nah dude there's space coke to be discovered
Hey guys, some questions (I'm not a physicist, so I would appreciate an answer that is relatively easy to understand. Thanks!):
How do you call the space that contains then all the universes? Is there even something like that?
Are there limits for space? Can it really expand infinitely?
Thank you!
It's called the universe. It would have been better if physicists had not adopted the multiverse terminology but instead had called it something like a "multi-domain universe". That is both mathematically and scientifically far more accurate. Personally I like the term "foliation" but it happens to be used already for a very different kind of phenomenon. At the end of the day, though, what's in a name? A rose by any other name smells just as sweet.
Remember hearing a theory of a pain of glass that light takes 5 years to travel through... So you'd be seeing everything through the window that happened 5 years ago like looking into the past...
He sounds so much like the "inconceivable" guy from a princess bride
Explains why Joe's head keeps getting bigger. The space on his head keeps expanding.
Joe Rogan + any physicist = best of UA-cam
2:57 "Space could be infinite, just our simple space that we know of, and love, could be infinite in extent"
buddy this guy is actually dumb how can space be infinite if big bang started it contradiction
@@youneskhouloud2504 When the universe is expanding faster than the speed of light I believe you could say that space is infinite.
@@magnusjonsson7303 infinity is time
expantion is space the 2 are diffrent
time and space
what you can say is the space is expanding
come on man the dude wrote in his book the universe come from nothing again i quote nothing
@@youneskhouloud2504 Where were you before you were born?
@@magnusjonsson7303 hhhhhhh a cunning question you didnt accept the fact that you time and space are 2 diffrent thing but if your asking if im a thiest then yes i believe in a first cause that generatod the universe a creator a real infinite one
This comment section is cancer. People have no clue what Krauss is even saying here. They literally think that he's saying that the multiverse is a scientific theory, and nobody seems to understand that "universe" in science has a completely different definition.
What is that definition of universe? ... and what does he mean by multiverse other than different bubbles of nothing filled with something with their own set of physics separated by nothing or something?
Literally... the multiverse is a theory? Explain what you mean by that
The classification of a universe in science is when the expansion of space accelerates non-locally at a higher rate than the speed of light outside of the center of expansion. That's how a new universe is classified. The laws of physics could be different in a different universe, which isn't hard to imagine since the laws of physics can differ within one universe, black holes for example. There's no evidence of another universe; at least not yet, but we can calculate how a finite universe could exist elsewhere based on the expansion of this universe. It's impossible to see another universe with our equipment because we rely on light, and there's no way light from another universe could reach us.
The mutiverse is not a theory, it's a hypothesis. A theory is a well-substantiated explanation of the natural world through testing, experiment, and observation. Nothing in science is more demonstrable than a scientific theory; they are ranked higher than scientific laws. For example... the law of gravity could be debunked tomorrow, but the theory of gravity would remain the same because it's not debatable. The mutiverse is not even remotely close to being a theory.
Scott Hunt More like the definition of "theory"
exactly. these UA-cam scientists amuse me. he's merely offering a possibility that he thinks is likely. nothing he said indicated this to be the case. Joe asked how and he explained a possibility. that's it. I hate stupid people who refuse to listen.
EVERYTHING HAS A DIFFERENT MEANING IN SCIENCE, RIGHT? IF YOU WANT TO WIN AN ARGUMENT, JUST TELL PEOPLE THAT SCIENCE IS CORRECT, BECAUSE WORDS MEAN SOMETHING TOTALLY DIFFERENT IN SCIENCE, THEREFORE WE WIN! Sorry, your science cult beliefs don't hold water either.
what's more interesting is that this man can say all that in a way where I can understand what he's talking about. Lawrence Krauss
respek birdman no you can't
Leandro Valderrama Oh...I didn't realize.
Yeah I feel the same, thats why i loved this podcast.
I am a 15-year-old from The Netherlands and I understood this perfectly fine.
+NewsGap That's Nether here nor there.
I’m glad I already knew all of this, but I remember when I first did research on this, and my mind was blown like Joe’s. It’s still hard to wrap my head around us in the distant future not being able to see any other galaxies except for those in our local group.
‘Non trivial semantics’ means I know what I’m talking about, it’s a shame no one else does.
I can only imagine 1500 years from now what we will know... if you are watching this then, I am laughing too now. We dont know. Jesse 2/6/2021
Lawrence Krauss's thoughts are moving away from ours faster than ours can catch up.
1 He speaks too fast 2 he does not pronounce properly 3 he mumbles 4 he does not create structured sentences 5 he does not use analogies correctly in structured sentences. Communication is more important than the idea in your brain.
When I try to throw my 2 cents into the conversation and just say “I like turtles”.
What about tortoises ?
I really didn't think I was dumb, then I watched this video.
Don’t worry, this cocky guy is dumb. He’s giving his interpretation of measured data as truth, while accusing everyone else to be dumb. What an idiot. His most stupid statement is: universe created its self from nothing.
X->Y (fine). But X->X is extremely stupid. :)
4:20 this is the ultimate eureka moment
It’s simple. Two galaxies are each moving at a little over half the speed of light away from each other. I love his last line “because we’re here to measure it.” All measurements are based on our perceptions, and our perceptions are based on our very limited five senses. 99% of people cannot even begin to grasp those concepts.
We are all inside a giant intergalactic squid
Supported by four elephants standing on a giant turtle, right?
im too dumb for this
Still sir you are 100 times better than ignorants who won't admit that they don't understand, yet trying to discredit it.
Rizki Yanuar true. But I'd disagree that it's only 100 times. He's a billion times better
how to make a yeah, the amount of ignorance in the comment section is heart breaking. Those guys don't bother to look at the paper and see the complicated math at all.
kenflowfohsho03
it’s fine. everybody in the comment section are too dumb for it too. Difference is they want to act like they know what they are talking about.
No, to admit you don't know is the first step to advancing your learning. Ask a question and be a fool for 5 minutes....never ask and be a fool for life.
So the Universe expands? What does it expand in? And how Can something be outside an eternal universe? Theories explaining theories, just beautiful!
This guy is delusional. He thinks he figured out everything.
It’s like reading fiction novels.
our "observable universe" expands because of dark energy.
metaverse is around our universe and expands at inflationary expansion rate (alot faster).
thats the theories.
@@talgmar What is dark Energy and why does is make space expand?
@@alimotai5749 its what Einstein called the cosmological constant. It is energy inherent in the fabric of space itself. It has a repulsive force (pushing), so its expanding the fabric of space.
That makes total sense but the only problem is what about quantum entanglement? Isn’t possible that two subatomic particles could be entangled across a horizon since they are entangled in this universe? If so, we could potentially bridge a gap to another universe across a horizon.