ralfy review 1031 - Glen Scotia Double Cask @46%vol:
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 чер 2024
- / ralfy . This is my Patreon channel, for videos released 24 hours early and with an extra weekly 'Update' video. Every month there is also a 'BothyLive' 90 minute live-stream from the bothy with a Q&A.
My Books 'Search For A Whisky Bothy', 'Stories From A Whisky Bar' and 'Life, Death & Whisky' are all on sale at Amazon and proper book shops.
www.oswa.co.uk - An online democratic award programme identifying the best spirits worth buying for each year.
For more whisky info & stuff, SUBSCRIBE to 'ralfydotcom'
Subscribe to my other UA-cam Channel 'Fitter Philosophy'
This video represents a personal opinion and perspective only.
To comply with Google Adsense policy this video is an independent non-profit review and is not knowingly selling or linking to a site that sells the product being reviewed.
'Ralfydotcom' is brought to you by The Irish Sea Trading Co: Ltd:
A British TV licence is NOT required to view my videos or almost every other video on UA-cam.
ALL items reviewed have been bought from a retailer at market prices within the U.K. unless specified by the presenter. No 'samples', 'free stuff', or gifts are accepted, so please do not try to send them, thank you.
NOTE - This Channel is not empowered and delivered by A.I. technology yet.
I WILL NEVER CONTACT YOU DIRECTLY THROUGH THIS CHANNEL except to reply to comments. Anyone who contacts you pretending to be me is a FAKE , and probably looking to SCAM and DEFRAUD you. Beware of imposters.
You are independent. You don't follow the herd. You are not afraid to say what you think. You are honest and transparent. In short, you are the cat of whisky reviewers.
He’s The OG & The 🐐
@@tweezerjam And the 🥃🐈
He likes to stand in doorways?
@@RaunienTheFirst Yes, and leap onto tables.
A tasty dram indeed!
I've had a bottle of Glen Scotia in 2023 and thoroughly enjoyed it. Bottled in the beginning of 2022. Sweet, syrupy, nicely balanced. Cask influence is undeniably there but the spirit character hasn't been bulldozed by it. Last week I had the opportunity to taste another batch, this time from 02.02.2023 and it was even better. Slightly less sweet, more savory and briny, still beautifully dense and substantial. The major difference though was that the more recent bottle had distinctive smoky notes. Very gentle but compared to the previous batch I have tasted the smoke was significantly more present.
As for value, Glen Scotia Double Cask is among the best single malt whiskies in Bulgaria. Currently I can have a bottle of it on special sale for the equivalent of roughly 23 pounds!
Cheers!
Here in Germany it's mentioned that the Double Cask is coloured. Cheers from a pat-pal
Just wrote this - then discovered you already did ...
Many of the Glen Scotia Whiskies are marked as coloured at German providers' websites. Only the sherried ones aren't.
A fan of some years in Ukraine. Thank you for insightful info on whisky, whiskey and other spirits.
Love Glen Scotia .. my favorite whisky…it’s nice to know it’s just down the Loch as I live on Loch Fyne ..tried a taster of this one in Callander at a whisky shop and bought a bottle before we moved here..managed to pick up the 15 and a first fill bourbon cask at 56.5 % which the George hotel in Inveraray had a barrel of divine really shows what great whisky it is..prefer it more than Springbank and tried a few of those can assure you ..great review
Glen Scotia is already better than Springbank, in my book anyway. I adore Glen Scotia and it’s not being hoarded and price jacked by snobs. Plus I like the whisky better, flat out.
I like your side-by-side comparison, demonstrating “Scotch mist”.
Very good review Ralfy , I totally agree ,fantastic whisky and really good value for money .
Glen Scotia my fav distillery , character at each level each release …without the crazy prices .
I got a bottle of this whisky about 10 years ago and was a bit disappointed as it had a sulfur note that didn't go away for nearly 6 months of patiently tasting and letting it sit for a few weeks before testing it again. Perhaps it's time to give this one another chance.
*_Edit_* This evening I purchased the Double Cask and I'm very impressed with this current bottling. The nose has notes of butter-scotch, vanilla and a faint oakiness. The flavors on the palate really are very well balanced between the influences of the bourbon casks and the PX casks, so plenty of citrus, pineapple and honey along with some darker, more savory fruit flavors as well. The finish is medium-long and drying.
For a NAS whisky, this is really good stuff. There's practically no "young whisky bite" in evidence. If given a dram of this in a blind tasting, I would guess its age to be 10 to 12 years, and for all we know the majority of the spirit might actually be that old. I may have just found my new "everyday" single malt. Thanks for reviewing this, Ralfy!
Once I had a miniature of Victoriana. I took a sip and it was bitter as hell. I left it sitting on a shelf for a year. After that it was superb. It improved so much and no trace of bitterness at all.
And Double Cask is a very nice and competent malt too.
Same for me. I thought I was wrong with the bitterness but yes, another one here that had the same experience
How odd, did you put a dab of water with it? It’s definitely harsh otherwise, it’s cask strength.
@@vincevirtua Yes I put some water in it. It was the miniature set and the 15yo was bitter too. Those batches were probably like that.
I bought this back in 2021 and was impressed with how good it was for the price. Just checked the latest pricing and it has only increased by about $5 NZD since I bought it. Nice to see Billy cat again. He certainly knows where the treats are kept. Cheers!
Be happy you aren’t in America… our government has been busy building the crazy inflation the past 3-4 years.
What website did you check?
@@PoriruaWhiskySociety Whisky and More $78, Whiskey on Line $79.99. I paid $74 back in 2021.
@@SimonneNZ $75 from Tax Free Spirits
Finished 3 bottles of this since 2020, a very good whisky indeed. Full, round, warm. I would love to see this one at 7 years old for some reason. Glen Scotia 7 Double Cask. Oh yeah bring it
I tried Glen Scotia Double cask at the whisky experience in Edinburgh and definitely the whisky that opened me up to the wider whisky world away from what you get in the supermarkets, tasty stuff.
Ralfy! I finally understand what to look for, re: Scotch Mist! Thanks! :)
Good Morning 😊 Awesome Review👌🏽 Thanks for sharing Mate 👏🏼 Have a great day & Greetings From South Africa 🇿🇦
So glad you reviewed the double cask. I honestly believe this is a huge sleeper bottle. I’ve had this blind with much higher priced malts and enjoyed this more. This is a shelf staple for me.
Greetings Mr Ralfy and thank you for another informative review. I always have one of these or newer entry-level ones, Harbour, in my stock. The price is between AU$82 to AU$89 here, and in fact, I wanted to buy another one lately but found Deanston 12 yr old on sales for the same price. I have reached my whisky purchasing limit for this month, so it has to wait. By the way , there is a whisky live thing going on at the moment in Australia, and I was tempted to buy a ticket, which is AU$155 but after checking the distilleries coming to there, I decided not to do it. It is hard to really taste whiskies in less than 3 hours. Cheers, and have a great week.
Right now i enjoy the Double Cask with the Rum Finish.
Deliciously dirty.😋
The One you review here is waiting unopened in the Stash, next to its Brothers😅.
I really like Glen Scotia because over the last 10 Years their Quality increased very much since they had these colourfull Metaltins around the Bottles.
The Double Cask Standard is now (June2024) available here in Germany for 39€.
Greetings from Germany😎🤘
I bought a bottle of the Double Cask 3 years ago and really really liked it. I was my first time trying a Campbelltown whisky and it didn’t disappoint. I got the viscosity, resinness, and richness I had been hearing about. I got a mini bottle of the Double Cask last year and it seemed a lot thinner and blander to me. Not sure if there was something going on with my palate or if they really do fill their minis with a different liquid.
Have to say Billy is a very nice cat!! Maybe he could be a feature ..testing whisky aromas or something 🤩
Although it's the equivalent of about 60+ pounds here in Western Canada, it was one of my fav Scotches when I tried it. I don't see it around anymore but the 10 year old is now available and it's 15 pounds cheaper. It leads me to believe there is either some older whisky in the Double Cask or they are using their very best casks for it.
what a lovely bottle label presentation
Lovely dram! For me, one of the best budget NAS whiskies. In Bulgaria it usually costs around EUR 30; however, I bought a bottle at Metro at EUR 22, which is a ridiculously low price for such a good whisky.
Excellent review dear Ralfy. A fine purchase for sure. Many thanks and my kindest regards,
Sandro.
I love this dram its always been a go to for a daily dram. Delicious toffee and caramel and its blended with sherry and american oak to perfection. I will say older batches were slightly better juice.
Ralfy, you mentioned "price pumping", well I've just noticed that on the Glen Scotia website, that they are offering a free Glencairn glass with the bottle. BTW, thanks for the great review, all true!
Now I can see the scotch mist. It was hard to see it before because there wasn't anything to compare it to. Thanks Ralfy.
Love the 15. The only downside is that there is a little colouring added. They don't in the 18 though.
£34 on Amazon ralfy, just ordered a bottle.
Great review.
Well done Glen Scotia 🥃 I have been very lucky to have tried a few whiskies from GS, they have some cracking stuff 😁🥃
Picked up a bottle from your favourite... Amazon...
This could very well be Ralfy’s whisky of the year. He clearly really impressed and with great value like that, it really seems like it could be his choice. Just sayin 😉
I keep loving your reviews. So keep them comming Ralfy. If it is possible one a day haha.
glen scotias presentation is really nice puts me in mind of arran
Hopefully someday I'll see more varieties of Glen Scotia. Currently the only thing I can ever find is the Victoriana.
Love this stuff. Value for money!!!
Good job Ralfy!
Here Is something it made me think:
I drink scotch for over 35 yrs now (not always the best one) but I frankly never heard about whisky mist marketing stuff from somebody drinking scotch
I have heard beginners saying it is sweet or it is easy to drink or not too strong (ABV)…. but never too misty
I agree that a reason for filtration coming from producers but is it really coming from consumers demand?
IMO I am not sure that Glen scotia had to filter a bit its double cask to please the traveler or the beginner about mist
Maybe GS wanted instead to create an easy drinking stuff and for instance get rid of a funky tasting note that doesn’t fit with beginners palette and is loved by enthousiastes …
Cheers 🥃
Available for 30€ in Germany. Excellent value!
I quickly became a big fan of this bottle. One thing I’m confused about though… by all accounts I see it’s unpeated, but I swear I taste peat in the background. Anyone else? And this isn’t my first go-around, I’ve been at it for a number of years now. I don’t know, perhaps they reuse some casks that formally held peated malt, or maybe it’s just the way the briny and oak char notes commingle on my palate.
Once you give them the treats, in fact, they do not go away. They just want more.
All Glen Scotia bottlings are pretty interesting and decent, even 40%. Unfortunately, everything with dye.
But it still beats any mainstream whisky at tastings.
Master of Malt have it on offer at just shy of £35 plus the postage
Definitely not " affordable" at 70 dollars here in Oregon USA 😬 Can get something with a considerable age statement for that price!
" they don't mention that it's natural colour " That is because colourant has been added.
I saw it in the co op today for £45.
$65.oo here on the west coast of Florida. Definitely not worth the price. Thin, sour, and colored.
Years ago the 15 was a superlative whisky. And now they color that.
i didnt like it either but victoriana was very good
I generally like Glen Scotia, but if I’m gonna pay their premium (but not outrageous) price I save for the older stuff. Because their slightly older stuff is actually a good value for the quality and age compared to other distilleries. Of course, in the US all alcohol is suffering in inflation more than most the world.
The 16 is brilliant
@@PoriruaWhiskySociety my thoughts exactly 👍
Lone voice of dissent: I've a bottle of this and I just can't seem to enjoy it was much as others here. It does get better with a little water added to open it up but before that I just don't find it that enjoyable. Sorry malt mates!
got one , and i like it a lot
greetz people
Hi Ralfy. I have been following your channel. Your videos are very informational. You recently mention you will be putting up videos with regards to independent bottlers and what a good idea! I have always interested why IB bought the whisky from well known distilleries and yet when the IB bottled them, the whisky are not as good as the original bottling? Also, if the IB bought different casks from a single distillery and blended them, does this malt regard as a Single Malt?
Ralfy ,is there any reason why you haven't reviewed the Glasgow 1770? The peated cask strength and the original cask strength are pritty decent for young whiskies.
Ralfy, when you say "it's a hell of a good whisky for the price", I wish you would say the price since prices vary so much in different regions/countries. I've seen prices on bottles differ by as much as 100% from one place to another. So it would be good to know what you think is a good value based on your actual numbers. Thanks!
O yes there he is!!!
I've noticed on amazon that whiskey is starting to get discounted. Do you think the whiskey loch is getting full
Just today bought the 15 year old, really curious about it.
Realizing you aren’t using Glencairn anymore. Wondering why? And what is that new glass you use now?
One could argue they are transparant, because there is some colouring added tot the whisky (at least in The Netherlands). Not much, but still. So, if they would have stated that it was natural colour, they would be telling a lie.
Its my go too dram, now that Bunna 12 is overpriced here in NZ.
Tax Free Spirits in NZ has it at a great price.
Everything in nz is overpriced 'pulls out bottle monkey shoulder, in tears'
@@peterfinucane8122 shhh
I noticed you don't use Glencairn glasses lately: is there any reason for that?
Can’t find 1031 Extra.
Anybody get the spring bank latest release I haven’t even seen it online
Only Glen Scotia I've tried so far is a sample of the 15 year. Did not agree with me, too funky/tangy and orange for me. Don't get what the fuss is about tbh, ah well, will leave it for others to enjoy
Here in NZ malted grain has gone up in price by 25%. Because of the Ukraine war with Putin. The price of malted barley is controlled by the world market. 20 minutes up the road NZ grown and malted barley has gone up 25% .It totally sucks. My homebrew store is absorbing the price rise to keep his customers. Customers like me are paying more too. The prices, ralfy are going to rise more. This whole my whisky is worth more than yours is going to change. Economics on the world market is going to hit harder than ever before. Excise tax, malt prices .and hops are killing the industry . Even home brewing is not so cheap anymore. Cheers mate😎👍
Nz based as well. Absolutely agree
What kind of glass is that Ralfy?
@sachinkainth9508 It's called a 'copita' glass, typically used for nosing and tasting sherry but also spirits, such as whisky. Glencairn does put out a version of this, though sometimes you can find them in vintage, thrift, or antique shops. Hope that helps...cheers!
Marian 🇨🇦
"It's not even a rant..."
Well... 😝
After all the PRAISE, you gave it a score of 83? WTFruit Ralphy?
ralfy is your bro ok
Double cask or victoriana?
Victoriana won the best single malt a couple of years ago on the Online Scotch Whisky Awards.
double cask is rubbish victoria is superb
@raycroal Yeah, I agree with the Victoriana being better.I've tried all the versions,and found the 51.5% better than the 54.8% and 54.2%,but they were all good,just my opinion.
Ralfy 'malty.. barley smokey.. peaty'... single malt.
I just wish the whisky manufacturers would educate their customers about 'Scotch mist'. I think they're doing a great disservice to the drinking public. It's a horrible case of form over function. Other than the effects of the alcohol, whisky is about taste. Why would you strip away taste? It's like Porsche putting off road tires on a 911 because some uneducated drivers think they look good. I'd be happy to take the lead of this campaign. Cheers, mates.
They have to filter, you don’t want to have wood chips in your mouth…
Rally - How come distilleries don’t make more of the non chill filtered and no artificial colour issues, I know you’ve mentioned this a few times in your videos, but just can’t figure out why it isn’t standard, most food and drink industries tend to go barmy for this sort of ‘marketing’ but it doesn’t seem to be used as a selling point for the Whiskey world, although I am by no means an expert in this.
Probably because passive consumers associate filtering with improvements in quality. To say something is not filtered, implies it's not as pure as it could be.
Who else came here via Whisky Whims? 😂
Gonyirsel Ralfy. For us long time followers of your whisky reviews, your recent malt mark.changes are baffling.
I think either you do a full video on what your new scoring system means or leave the puzzle why a bottle of blended Johnny Walker beats this bottle of Glen Scotia. The internet is forever.
Have ye thought of recalculating your reviews by some approximation and annotating your old videos with a realistic mm?