I love the too face better than sex found out the waterproof version was out so I returned the 1st one for the waterproof one... Big mistake it's to sticky and heavy feeling on the lashes. Also doesn't give me as much length and color payoff like the original. I'm so torn because I love the original it's my fav but I have eyes than tear up a lot so it smudges and flakes off if I put more than one coat of it on. I don't know what to do now
SMALLZZZ SMALLZZZ weirdly for me it's the opposite, the normal one is very clumpy and sticky and the waterproof is great. But maybe it's because I've just bought it. But the normal one was sticky and clumpy from the beginning I got it. Weird...
I filmed a video comparing the Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara with the Lancome Monsieur Big Waterproof Mascara, so it's nice to see what others think of the mascara too!!! 💛
i love that u love cruelty free products...ive heard a lot about this better than sex mascara, I need to purchase it looks like this item works wonders can't wait to try it out..😼😺😻
Honestly when i first bought the original it was super clumpy and took me about a month of using it to get it to look beautiful (its now my favorite), I REALLY want the waterproof one so I'm hoping the same thing happens.
It definitely can be clumpy! I think the waterproof one is good, but like you said it takes a while to get it to work right! And the formula is definitely different than the original so its like starting from square one.
The deluxe sample for the original has always gone on differently for me than the full size. My sample never went on clumpy but my full size always leaves me with some clumps. So I am not sure if it is necessarily different formulas in waterproof vs. original. I think it has something to do with the smaller brushes for the samples. Maybe try a deluxe sample in the waterproof!
i think you might get better, less clumpy results if you twist/roll the brush (per the instructions) as you apply! that said, bts is my favorite and i dont think ill be trying the wp version.
I also own the travel size original one & I LOVE IT but it smears like crazy after a couple of hours so I wanna try the waterproof version & I play on buying the other one to help remove it cuz that's the only reason why I don't like waterproof mascaras
I love this formula, but I use a different brush. The original brush in this is soo messy I use loreal butterfly intenza mascara wand. It has a great brush on it. I tried a different mascara wand from loreal and the brush broke off from extracting it from the better than sex mascara. God bless and if you don't like the brush,try a different one!
I'm not a fan of the Better Than Sex mascara, but I'm usually always happier with a waterproof formula! I'd love to get a sample of this just to try :)
+paigeyeahh Oh really? Its so funny how things work for different people! I love that one so much! What's your favorite mascara? I'm sure they will be coming out with a sample size soon!!!
Yeah I prefer a more spidery look! My fave is Maybelline The Rocket! I just have never been super impressed with any higher-end mascara I've tried, which I guess is a good thing haha
+Angel Batten It so hard to pick a favorite, I love them all! I did a full review on it too if you want to check that out!!! It's such a great palette!!!
I've been wearing the original for almost a year now and the only problem I have with it is it tend to flake, like I'll notice fallout on my cheeks from it. Does the waterproof formula do this as well?
+Ashley Worthen I just got my hands on the waterproof. I'm not very happy with it. It tends to flake off under my eyes way faster than the original formula. I'm very disappointed.. don't waste your money..
+Katie Grace It was very hard to remove, I thought i mentioned it in the video but I might have cute it out... it was hard to remove even with eye makeup remover. But like you said that's pretty typical with waterproof mascaras! :)
+wolfyrocks Well yes, if you need a good waterproof mascara and you like this formula, and you don't mind a little clumpiness! If you don't need a waterproof mascara, then no I wouldn't recommend it.
+Autumn Hawkes I haven't had this problem, I'm so sorry that you are experiencing that! I have heard others complain of the same thing but I haven't experienced transfer with either formula!
Hi guys! Here is an update of my thoughts on this mascara, as well as my review of the Too Faced Mascara Melt-Off! ua-cam.com/video/RGYOPNWrLsI/v-deo.html
The Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara is definitely my #1 favorite mascara! I agree. The original version looks nicer than the waterproof version ☺️💗
The original is one of my FAVES!!
With the water proof you must remove excess mascara on top of tube to get a non clumpy nice look.
I had a little flaking :( I was so upset but water proof formulas tend to do that......well at least on me haha
Love it! Short and sweet, great comparison video, just subscribed!
+Nancy Silver Aw thanks so much I'm so happy to hear that!!!
I just bought both of them today, and i agree. i love the pink tube! best mascara ive gotten honestly
Very good review!! Love how u compared the two side by side
+AlwaysonKieu Thank you so much for saying that!! It definitely helped me form my opinions as well!
I love the too face better than sex found out the waterproof version was out so I returned the 1st one for the waterproof one... Big mistake it's to sticky and heavy feeling on the lashes. Also doesn't give me as much length and color payoff like the original. I'm so torn because I love the original it's my fav but I have eyes than tear up a lot so it smudges and flakes off if I put more than one coat of it on. I don't know what to do now
SMALLZZZ SMALLZZZ weirdly for me it's the opposite, the normal one is very clumpy and sticky and the waterproof is great. But maybe it's because I've just bought it. But the normal one was sticky and clumpy from the beginning I got it. Weird...
SMALLZZZ SMALLZZZ how about get a a new one
I love this mascara :)! & it's cruelty-free!
+Charlie's Lifestyle Yes definitely!!!!! :)
I filmed a video comparing the Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara with the Lancome Monsieur Big Waterproof Mascara, so it's nice to see what others think of the mascara too!!! 💛
i love that u love cruelty free products...ive heard a lot about this better than sex mascara, I need to purchase it looks like this item works wonders can't wait to try it out..😼😺😻
+Jessica gray I love the original BTS mascara!!!!
Great, honest review, thank you so much!!!
+aprilshowers70 You are so welcome, thank you for the kind comment!
I Need to try this!
+Jasmine Airedale Definitely!!!
Great review beauty
+Anna Greek Phoenix Thank you so much!!! :)
Honestly when i first bought the original it was super clumpy and took me about a month of using it to get it to look beautiful (its now my favorite), I REALLY want the waterproof one so I'm hoping the same thing happens.
It definitely can be clumpy! I think the waterproof one is good, but like you said it takes a while to get it to work right! And the formula is definitely different than the original so its like starting from square one.
Try the melt off mascara remover by too faced,it will help you remove the waterproof mascara
+Z Shen Thanks for the tip!
The deluxe sample for the original has always gone on differently for me than the full size. My sample never went on clumpy but my full size always leaves me with some clumps. So I am not sure if it is necessarily different formulas in waterproof vs. original. I think it has something to do with the smaller brushes for the samples. Maybe try a deluxe sample in the waterproof!
+Christina Brong The deluxe sized sample brush was the exact same size as the full size! But that is really interesting! Who knows! :)
Wich one best
Which one holds the curl better? I'm thinking about getting one of these
I don't normally curl my lashes, but I imagine the Waterproof one would.
i think you might get better, less clumpy results if you twist/roll the brush (per the instructions) as you apply!
that said, bts is my favorite and i dont think ill be trying the wp version.
I also own the travel size original one & I LOVE IT but it smears like crazy after a couple of hours so I wanna try the waterproof version & I play on buying the other one to help remove it cuz that's the only reason why I don't like waterproof mascaras
The waterproof mascara takes forever to dry and its kind of clumpy. I got the full tube the day it came out 😩
+Cheyenne A (CheyenneL0ve) i have the smaller tube and it works fine for me it dries quickly and doesnt come out clumpy
Love this review
+Linda Mayvic Thank you so much!!!!
First comment :D love your reviews
+Jessica Broster Thank so much Jessica! I appreciate hearing that!!!
+Liz Williams (WildflowerLiz) thank you so much for replying I love it when you tubers take time to reply to their subscribers :D
Thanks for the share & review
Great review :)
I love this formula, but I use a different brush. The original brush in this is soo messy I use loreal butterfly intenza mascara wand. It has a great brush on it. I tried a different mascara wand from loreal and the brush broke off from extracting it from the better than sex mascara. God bless and if you don't like the brush,try a different one!
I'm not a fan of the Better Than Sex mascara, but I'm usually always happier with a waterproof formula! I'd love to get a sample of this just to try :)
+paigeyeahh Oh really? Its so funny how things work for different people! I love that one so much! What's your favorite mascara? I'm sure they will be coming out with a sample size soon!!!
Yeah I prefer a more spidery look! My fave is Maybelline The Rocket! I just have never been super impressed with any higher-end mascara I've tried, which I guess is a good thing haha
Love the video I see you got the peach pallet as well what's your fav shade.
+Angel Batten It so hard to pick a favorite, I love them all! I did a full review on it too if you want to check that out!!! It's such a great palette!!!
I've been wearing the original for almost a year now and the only problem I have with it is it tend to flake, like I'll notice fallout on my cheeks from it. Does the waterproof formula do this as well?
+Ashley Worthen I just got my hands on the waterproof. I'm not very happy with it. It tends to flake off under my eyes way faster than the original formula. I'm very disappointed.. don't waste your money..
+klb374money dang really? that sucks ugh
I already ordered it with the hopes it wouldn't flake like the first one..
+Ashley Worthen I didn't notice any flaking, but I didn't have flaking with the original either, so I guess it works differently for different people!
how hard was this to remove!!?? i always find waterproof to be so difficult to remove!
+Katie Grace It was very hard to remove, I thought i mentioned it in the video but I might have cute it out... it was hard to remove even with eye makeup remover. But like you said that's pretty typical with waterproof mascaras! :)
Liz Williams oh i must have missed it haha! but true its pretty typical!
I had the better than sex mascara for like 2 months and it was amazing but than when i bought the waterproof it was horrible
+alicia Solis Yeah its pretty different from the original unfortunately!
Do you think it's worth it even though it's hard to take off?
+wolfyrocks Well yes, if you need a good waterproof mascara and you like this formula, and you don't mind a little clumpiness! If you don't need a waterproof mascara, then no I wouldn't recommend it.
do they hold curl well?
+Alexa Barcenas I don't normally curl my lashes, but it keeps the curl I have!
great review
+Mia Dudney Awesome Mia! I will check it out for sure!!!!
This mascara transfers, can I stop it from doing it??!!??
+Autumn Hawkes I haven't had this problem, I'm so sorry that you are experiencing that! I have heard others complain of the same thing but I haven't experienced transfer with either formula!
Hi guys! Here is an update of my thoughts on this mascara, as well as my review of the Too Faced Mascara Melt-Off! ua-cam.com/video/RGYOPNWrLsI/v-deo.html
Too faced😍
+Septia Rizky Asti One of my favorite brands!!!!
Honey, if you're going to be crying on your wedding day, that's a great time to wear falsies. The go back to your mascara after.
+Brittney Caraway That is a great idea! But I would probably put some mascara on over the falsies :) but I will definitely keep that in mind!
Your beautiful I love you lipstick
Thank you so much!!!