My last video on him was 5 months ago. But since he’s still talking, and miserably failed trying to refute my video on Bukhari, I feel the need the release a video I’ve had archived for a long while. A compilation of his arguments, including his recent ones on my video, refuting them whilst putting all relevant sources on screen. Stay tuned for the video, it will be a long one inshallah.
Im watching this 15ish hours video, it's definitely worth watching. جزاك الله خيرا For making it easier for other people to watch by making smaller clips
This issue is so clear. Nearly every book of Aqeedah of the Imams of the Salaf and those who follow them mention the prohibition of rebellion. The more you read and learn mutoon the more evidence builds up for this. A person who opposes this is just following desires.
Bro Hajji and the likes of him are just following their whims and desires . May Allah show us the haqq and grants us the tawfeeq to follow it as well as to show us the falsehood and abandon it.
@@sanguemtripz1592 bro ahlul bidah are filthy people they unite people who have kufri aqeedaha, but keeps attacking people of ahlul Ilm(Ahlu-Sunna-waljamah )
Bro haji Since you VERY rarely focus on tawheed You talk the talk Why not walk the walk Go to such places like Syria or Palestine , then we can know how much you use that mouth of yours over there
And he’s wrong, are we to take him over the the early muhadditheen and fuqaha? Also it’s not just the ijma claim, it’s also Bro Hajji recommending rebellion, Assim Al Hakeem doesn’t recommend it rather he speaks against it.
@@yooshatarique019 It’s not just my opinion, the ijma has been transmitted from the early scholars. Here’s one example: Ibn Abi Hatim said: I asked my father and Aboo Zur`ah radiyallaahu `anhumaa about the positions of the Ahlus-Sunnah (the People of the Sunnah) regarding the fundamentals of the Religion, and what they found the scholars upon in all of the cities, and what they held as their creed in that regard, so they both said: We found the scholars in all of the cities: in the Hijaaz, in `Iraaq, in Egypt, in Shaam, in Yemen, so it was from their position that: *And we establish the obligation of the Jihaad and the Hajj along with the rulers of the Muslims in every age and time; and we do not hold rebelling against the rulers (nor fighting in time of discord) and we hear and obey whomever Allaah the Mighty and Majestic places in charge of our affair, and we do not remove our hand from obedience; and we follow the Sunnah and the Jamaa`ah, and we avoid isolation, differing, and splitting.* أبو محمد عبدالرحمن بن أبي حاتم قال: سألت أبي وأبا زرعة عن مذاهب أهل السنة في أصول الدين وما أدركا عليه العلماء في جميع الأمصار وما يعتقدان من ذلك ؟ فقالا: أدركنا العلماء في جميع الأمصار ـ حجازاً وعراقاً وشاماً ويمناً فكان من مذهبهم: ونقيم فرض الجهاد والحج مع أئمة المسلمين في كل دهر وزمان. ولا نرى الخروج على الأئمة ولا القتال / في الفتنة ونسمع ونطيع لمن (ولاه) الله عز وجل أمرنا ولا ننزع يداً من طاعة ونتبع السنة والجماعة ونجتنب الشذوذ والخلاف والفرقة.
@@ibmsulaymani Also, I have one more question. Why do the salafis get angry when any of their imams of the 21st century get criticised like albani, etc etc. But they insult Abu hanifa so badly, who is an actual salaf. Even Ibn taymiyyah, who is Shaikh al Islam according to u also, but u do not follow him, for Ibn taymiyyah highly praised Abu hanifa
@@yooshatarique019 Abu Hanifa received heavy criticism for his take on khuruj and other issues, you’ll find many salaf speaking about him. Even Mohammed Hijab admitted that the salaf declared Abu Hanifa an innovator.
off-topic: Can you explain about the kalaam regarding ibn jurayj? he's a mudallis yet I see some muhaddithoon take his hadith. And others might even accept with shawaahid. I'm confused
Salam alaikum brother. I have a question regarding our Aqida of the salaf which I was thinking about for a while. When we assume a round earth, how can we say Allah is above since everyone on the globe has another direction of above? There is this picture from that ashari you posted today on twitter. I know the evidence from the sunnah and quran is clear, so how do we respond to this issue from the perpective of salafi aqidah? Baraka Allahu feek
I wouldn’t recommend getting into these discussions if you haven’t grounded yourself in tawheed and aqeeda, doubts will be thrown at you without any way to respond. I would recommend signing up for MSG or something similar and study under a teacher. As for what you mentioned, this video addresses it. ua-cam.com/video/MxolrMKbZqQ/v-deo.html
Also يا أخي الكريم there is a difference between magnetic north and true north. No matter where you are in the world the North Pole is north of you. Think of this if a ring was above the planet earth it would be still above everyone no matter where you are. Look because you on the planet earth then anything above the earth is also above you and everyone else. I hope you understand this and your doubts are cleared.
@Fate Zero - it is true regardless of where you stand, tell the Asharis to stop thinking physically like Mujasima regarding the Quran... Nonetheless, Sh. Tahawi answered it from a salaf view, do you need a reference?
Aqida Tahawi : The Throne (al-‘arsh) and the Footstool (al-kursī) are true. (Allah) **He is independent of the Throne and whatever is beneath it.** **He encompasses all things & He is above it, & what He has created is incapable of encompassing Him.** References - Quran 2 : 255, 267 & Quran 4 : 126!
Jabir bin Samura: Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) saying, "There will be 12 Muslim rulers (who will rule all the ummah?)." My father said, "All of them will be from Quraish." - Bukhari 7222, Book of Judgement/Ahkaam It has been narrated on the authority of Jabir b. Samura who said: I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺpeace and blessings be upon him) say: Islam will continue to be triumphant until there have been twelve Caliphs. Then the Prophet (ﷺpeace and blessings be upon him) said something which I could not understand. I asked my father: What did he say? He said: He has said that all of them (twelve Caliphs) will be from the Quraish. - Sahih Muslim 1821d The word used in Bukari is Amir but the word usd in Sahih Muslim is (twelve) Caliphs (عَشَرَ خَلِيفَةً) this is evidence there will be righteous Kings after the 40 year successive Calipha!
Madkhalis Compare this to leaders that were placed by the British and the French after colonialism. The worst Muslim caliph is better than the best Muslim leader today. Who rule by models of governance placed by the west. كلمة حقًا اريد بها باطل
Bro Hajji believes in rebelling against legitimate Muslim caliphates that are oppressive, that’s our main issue. As for today’s rulers, the rulings apply to those who are muslim.
bro batini kariji ikwanis, he will take advantage of ppl's ignorance like the tyrant he claims to oppose and misquote like the rah-byes in Medina, May Allah guide us and him or disable him for his lies and make it an example for the haqq to spread!
My last video on him was 5 months ago. But since he’s still talking, and miserably failed trying to refute my video on Bukhari, I feel the need the release a video I’ve had archived for a long while.
A compilation of his arguments, including his recent ones on my video, refuting them whilst putting all relevant sources on screen. Stay tuned for the video, it will be a long one inshallah.
Allahumma barik, it always amazes me to see how Ustadh is so knowledgeable, may Allah make hus affairs easy and grant him more ilm that is beneficial
امين
Aameen
Im watching this 15ish hours video, it's definitely worth watching.
جزاك الله خيرا
For making it easier for other people to watch by making smaller clips
Videos like these on Sunni creed in English are necessary for the corrective dawah in the West. Jazak Allahu khayran
Asalaamualaikum brother it’s been a long time
This issue is so clear. Nearly every book of Aqeedah of the Imams of the Salaf and those who follow them mention the prohibition of rebellion. The more you read and learn mutoon the more evidence builds up for this. A person who opposes this is just following desires.
Bro Hajji and the likes of him are just following their whims and desires . May Allah show us the haqq and grants us the tawfeeq to follow it as well as to show us the falsehood and abandon it.
Castrated Hajji is upon the manhaj of Mr Daddu (he ignored all those books of Aqeeda of salaf and went extreme over their Sufis and Deobandi elders)
Prohibition of rebellion against the Muslim ruler is clear however the crux of the issue is whether or not they are Muslim to begin with.
@@sanguemtripz1592 bro ahlul bidah are filthy people they unite people who have kufri aqeedaha, but keeps attacking people of ahlul Ilm(Ahlu-Sunna-waljamah )
@@Libanf are you a khariji?
Did Ustadh memorise Majmoo’ Al Fatawa as he spoke word by word from the text. Sub'han Allaah
He might have memorized a page or two.
He's reading form a screen
@@sufyanalthawri1257 bring your proof
@@sufyanalthawri1257 husn dun
Underrated channel akhi. May Allah make it a means of Jannah for you
Bro haji
Since you VERY rarely focus on tawheed
You talk the talk
Why not walk the walk
Go to such places like Syria or Palestine , then we can know how much you use that mouth of yours over there
Beautiful! Ma sha allah
Even Shaikh Assim Al Hakeem believes there is no ijma on rebellion being haram
And he’s wrong, are we to take him over the the early muhadditheen and fuqaha? Also it’s not just the ijma claim, it’s also Bro Hajji recommending rebellion, Assim Al Hakeem doesn’t recommend it rather he speaks against it.
@@ibmsulaymani but it is your opinion that he is wrong. According to him, he is right. 2nd part u spoke the truth
@@yooshatarique019 It’s not just my opinion, the ijma has been transmitted from the early scholars. Here’s one example:
Ibn Abi Hatim said:
I asked my father and Aboo Zur`ah radiyallaahu `anhumaa about the positions of the Ahlus-Sunnah (the People of the Sunnah) regarding the fundamentals of the Religion, and what they found the scholars upon in all of the cities, and what they held as their creed in that regard, so they both said:
We found the scholars in all of the cities: in the Hijaaz, in `Iraaq, in Egypt, in Shaam, in Yemen, so it was from their position that:
*And we establish the obligation of the Jihaad and the Hajj along with the rulers of the Muslims in every age and time; and we do not hold rebelling against the rulers (nor fighting in time of discord) and we hear and obey whomever Allaah the Mighty and Majestic places in charge of our affair, and we do not remove our hand from obedience; and we follow the Sunnah and the Jamaa`ah, and we avoid isolation, differing, and splitting.*
أبو محمد عبدالرحمن بن أبي حاتم قال: سألت أبي وأبا زرعة عن مذاهب أهل السنة في أصول الدين وما أدركا عليه العلماء في جميع الأمصار وما يعتقدان من ذلك ؟ فقالا: أدركنا العلماء في جميع الأمصار ـ حجازاً وعراقاً وشاماً ويمناً فكان من مذهبهم:
ونقيم فرض الجهاد والحج مع أئمة المسلمين في كل دهر وزمان. ولا نرى الخروج على الأئمة ولا القتال / في الفتنة ونسمع ونطيع لمن (ولاه) الله عز وجل أمرنا ولا ننزع يداً من طاعة ونتبع السنة والجماعة ونجتنب الشذوذ والخلاف والفرقة.
@@ibmsulaymani Also, I have one more question. Why do the salafis get angry when any of their imams of the 21st century get criticised like albani, etc etc. But they insult Abu hanifa so badly, who is an actual salaf. Even Ibn taymiyyah, who is Shaikh al Islam according to u also, but u do not follow him, for Ibn taymiyyah highly praised Abu hanifa
@@yooshatarique019 Abu Hanifa received heavy criticism for his take on khuruj and other issues, you’ll find many salaf speaking about him. Even Mohammed Hijab admitted that the salaf declared Abu Hanifa an innovator.
off-topic:
Can you explain about the kalaam regarding ibn jurayj? he's a mudallis yet I see some muhaddithoon take his hadith. And others might even accept with shawaahid. I'm confused
Study mustalah al hadith, you need a teacher not asking video editors like me.
Salam alaikum brother. I have a question regarding our Aqida of the salaf which I was thinking about for a while. When we assume a round earth, how can we say Allah is above since everyone on the globe has another direction of above? There is this picture from that ashari you posted today on twitter. I know the evidence from the sunnah and quran is clear, so how do we respond to this issue from the perpective of salafi aqidah? Baraka Allahu feek
I wouldn’t recommend getting into these discussions if you haven’t grounded yourself in tawheed and aqeeda, doubts will be thrown at you without any way to respond. I would recommend signing up for MSG or something similar and study under a teacher.
As for what you mentioned, this video addresses it. ua-cam.com/video/MxolrMKbZqQ/v-deo.html
Also يا أخي الكريم there is a difference between magnetic north and true north. No matter where you are in the world the North Pole is north of you. Think of this if a ring was above the planet earth it would be still above everyone no matter where you are. Look because you on the planet earth then anything above the earth is also above you and everyone else. I hope you understand this and your doubts are cleared.
@Fate Zero - it is true regardless of where you stand, tell the Asharis to stop thinking physically like Mujasima regarding the Quran...
Nonetheless, Sh. Tahawi answered it from a salaf view, do you need a reference?
Aqida Tahawi : The Throne (al-‘arsh) and the Footstool (al-kursī) are true.
(Allah) **He is independent of the Throne and whatever is beneath it.**
**He encompasses all things & He is above it, & what He has created is incapable of encompassing Him.**
References - Quran 2 : 255, 267 & Quran 4 : 126!
Can i take ilm from faraz rabbani?
What's with the music!
Not music
Jabir bin Samura:
Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) saying, "There will be 12 Muslim rulers (who will rule all the ummah?)." My father said, "All of them will be from Quraish."
- Bukhari 7222, Book of Judgement/Ahkaam
It has been narrated on the authority of Jabir b. Samura who said:
I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺpeace and blessings be upon him) say: Islam will continue to be triumphant until there have been twelve Caliphs. Then the Prophet (ﷺpeace and blessings be upon him) said something which I could not understand. I asked my father: What did he say? He said: He has said that all of them (twelve Caliphs) will be from the Quraish.
- Sahih Muslim 1821d
The word used in Bukari is Amir but the word usd in Sahih Muslim is (twelve) Caliphs (عَشَرَ خَلِيفَةً)
this is evidence there will be righteous Kings after the 40 year successive Calipha!
Akhi get rid of that background noise sounds too much like Music
Ustadh Abdurrahman Hassan حفظه الله has used background nasheeds in his videos, he said there isn’t an issue with them.
@@ibmsulaymani Brother, the issue isn’t the Nasheed, it’s that it sounds eerily like music.
@@Kardu3 Ustadh Abdurrahman Hassan حفظه الله uses similar in his videos. ua-cam.com/video/e8SQgftZQN8/v-deo.html
@@ibmsulaymani do you know whether he specifically asked for it to be there? Or was it just edited it in without his consent per say.
Madkhalis Compare this to leaders that were placed by the British and the French after colonialism. The worst Muslim caliph is better than the best Muslim leader today. Who rule by models of governance placed by the west. كلمة حقًا اريد بها باطل
Bro Hajji believes in rebelling against legitimate Muslim caliphates that are oppressive, that’s our main issue. As for today’s rulers, the rulings apply to those who are muslim.
@@ibmsulaymani and which of those are Muslim ?
@@Libanf Why not answer who isn't?
bro batini kariji ikwanis, he will take advantage of ppl's ignorance like the tyrant he claims to oppose and misquote like the rah-byes in Medina, May Allah guide us and him or disable him for his lies and make it an example for the haqq to spread!