Doctor REACTS To Mindhunter | Dr Elliott
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- #doctorreacts #drelliott #hannibal #psychiatrist #mentalhealth
Check out my reaction to Bojack Horseman: • DOCTOR REACTS TO BOJAC...
It's a Sin reviews: • DOCTOR REACTS TO IT'S ...
If you enjoy my doctor reacts videos on Hannibal then you will LOVE this one. I'm looking at episode 1 of Mindhunter, all about the FBIs changing approach to investigating violent crimes by understanding psychology as part of motive. There are lots of aspects of forensic psychiatry and mental illness to talk about so I know you'll learn a lot.
This episode covers psychosis, delusions, Sectioning, medications, the law, violence and much more.
Let me know what you think!
SUBSCRIBE for new videos every Sat and every Wed: / @doctorelliottcarthy
Connect with me on socials:
Twitter: @elcarthy
Instagram: @dr.elliott.carthy
the ed kemper episodes were the best. one of the most intenense scenes in all of television
I loved this series. They picked such good actors.
i definitely agree with you, especially since he has such repeated appearances. my favorite person they interviewed was Richard Speck. him throwing that bird into the fan then delivering the coldest line. "It just wasn't their fucking night."
I love this show so much and I am so disappointed that there won't be any more seasons.
WHAT HAPPENS TO BILL'S SON I HAVE TO KNOW!!!!
Omg and who killed the lady and her son in the small town!! I need to know! The show is so unfinished ! @netflix please bring it back!!!
I'm from the future, now it's being considered on returning
@@thegamingcook785wait, really?
Man, please do more Mindhunter. There's so much good shit in this show, and the way these characters respond to the people they're interviewing and how they slowly like-- realize that in order to be effective at what they do they have to employ empathy, and that requires a look in the mirror and facing versions of themselves that they'd never EVER indulge, but need to understand.
Bill Tench's arc in this show is SO good. I won't spoil it for you, but Mindhunter is one of my favorite-est shows ever.
I loved this series! I was disappointed that they only did two seasons.
BTW: Love the new hairstyle.
I think Netflix cancelled it. So disappointing, I loved it as well!
@@missnandorfrom what I heard the creator wanted to move on and put it on hiatus because it took so long to make each time. More information was dripping out as to why though.
Also, now one of the cast members is going to be in Doctor Who
@@Char10tti3 It was also very expensive.
I only watched the 1st season and I thought it was an amazing show. They really stayed true to life and the characters and ideas explored were definitely very nuanced. Nice reaction, hope you continue
I'm so hyped to see a professional react to this series, especially since one of the characters (who also happens to be queer) is a psychologist. It'd be really interesting to hear your thoughts!
which character?
@@emmanuelucrosacosta1845Wendy Carr
Plus, we have Jonathan Groff as the main lead being a openly gay actor not being typecasted for being out (just chosen to portray gay characters)! Huge fan of the production!!
I'm so happy you decided to watch this show. It is really one of the best shows I have ever seen and there is so much to cover. Thank you and hope to see more episode reactions!
Great video! really hope you make more reactions to Mindhunter. It's so intresseting to hear an actual psychiatrist talk about it instead of remembering stuff from highschool psych class
PLEASE do more on MindHunter!!!
Mindhunter season 1 was outstanding. I thought season 2 wasn't as great, but I'm still upset it's not coming back.
This is one of my favorite shows. It can be hard to watch, but definitely worth it. I'm still crushed that it was dropped.
This series is so underrated
Need more of this show on the channel, so sad that it got cancelled
The interviews are honestly amazing but I love the series in general.
Loved this show and would love so many reactions to it, especially as I don't really know first had how the origins of these forensic works are still in practice today.
Shame its on hiatus, but I hope it will come back strong if they decide to
I don't know if you play any video games or if you'd have time to do so for the channel, but I'd really really LOVE to hear your thoughts on the portrayal of Senua in "Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice" as she's a character that suffers from psychosis and the game in my opinion does a good job at taking an empathic view of her character and does really well to immerse the player in her world and see and experience the world as she does! If you don't play games or don't have the time to play the entire thing, I am certain there are compilation videos of the cutscenes from the story and stuff like that which could work as reaction material!
i love these reaction vids to the dramas and your balanced, informed take on the salient issues
Yes. YES!!!!!!!!! Pleeeeeeeease do the whole show, its unbelievably excellent 🤩
I didn't get hung up on technical terms or descriptions of mental health in the context of the show because it's set in the '70s, I figured they were trying to use the terms of the time. I could, of course, be wildly wrong. Love your videos.
The problem with psychosis and violence being associated is a cognitive bias where we only recognize or remember people who are psychotic when they become violent.
Well, when you are schizophrenic, normally people don't see you at all, either. Then if you have a rare person who does fester, then the only reference point they have is the violent act.
More please. Love this show.
I’m so excited you’re reacting to this series!
I loved this series, great video as always. Hope you keep reacting to Mindhunter. Another one worth coming back to is Ginny and Georgia, just watched the second season and it have a lot to discuss.
I would love to see you cover the rest of this series. I always learn something from all of your react videos, and it's very enlightening. Have you ever thought about reviewing/analyzing "The Patient" with Steve Carell? I feel like that would be very informative.
Man, this show was so good.
More Mindhunter!!! I am so so upset Netflix stopped this show. They were supposed to do 6 seasons and it’s so unfinished now. It needs to come back!!!
Another great video! Mindhunter is such a great series. Too bad Mr. Fincher can't return to do another season.
My mother had severe mental health issues, icluding BPD, depression and also alcohol and psychopharmaca abuse. I can't count all the times thnigs got really bad and we had to intervene.
I clearly remember one particular time, when she had (another) car accident while dos (she had such crazy luck that she never had all too serious injuries from these, and never involved another person being injured). My sister and I followed the ambulance to the hospital. My mother did not want to stay (she hated being in psych wards with all her guts and I can partly understand that from her perspective) although it was very necessary to monitor her at least for 48 after the accident. She had lots of bruises, and a bump on her forehead. Nobody knew how exactly she was injured in the crash, and she could not tell.
At that point it was the only time that the circumstances to admit her against her will were met. It was my sister who signed the papers for that.
When we wanted to eplain to her and say goodbye, she completely snapped, running to my sister, trying to strangle her. I'll never forget the "mad" look in her eyes when she realized and yelled "THAT WAS YOUUUUU!!!!!" at my sister. Two male nurses immediately got hold of her and we just rushed out of the room.
Mother was diagnosed with a "psychotic pisode", but released herself by the minute the legal time to hold her againts her will was over.
We've seen A LOT with her over the years, but that moment was really terrible.
She attemped to strangle me once too. She was once more really drunk and drugged, but wanted to drive somewhere. We sisters obviously would not approuve. So I took the car keas and hid them. In a fit of anger she attacked me. My sister intervened and in the end, mum got her car keys out of our helplessness.
It#s likely not surprising that I myself have very severe mental health issues too.
We were young adults these times. I was around 16 when mother's mental health started to spiral downhill.
It was bad before, but her diagnosis came after divorce. She then got psychopharmaca added to the alcohol, and the stress of maintaining a job made it worse I guess.
Sorry for the long comment.
Clearly the way to respond is to have 10 cops screaming 10 conflicting orders at him, then to shoot him 0.42 seconds later for noncompliance.
Finally…we’re at Mind Hunter. Let’s go!
Please, do more Mindhunter episodes! I watched this show like 10 times 😘
You are becoming one of my favorite UA-camr.
You are the reason I will be watching Mindhunter. Thanks.
I’m hoping we get more videos about Mindhunter. It’s an incredible show and well worth exploring.
Hoping for more Mindhunter videos, so much here I’m curious for your input on!
so excited abt this!!
Maybe change the color of when you’re giving definitions or info to the audience. Like maybe a blue tone or something the red feels like you’re trying to give a warning or something idk it just feels strange.
I loveeee this show. Thank u for reacting to it❤❤❤
Love mindhunter 💕. Bingewatched it in a couple of days
Please do the whole series
This is amazing show. Too bad we won't get another season.
This show was phenomenal. I really wish they hadn't canceled it. A treasure trove 9f psychological insights!
yeh would love to see more episodes, this show's great and the casting is insane they really capture the real life perpetrators
Just commenting to boost the algorithm. I need more of this!!
Ill never forgive Netflix for canceling this show. It deserved better
As a Fan of both Mindhunter and The OA, I feel your pain. Believe me.
Oh how I have missed you doing stuff like this. I hope you do more of this and more hannibal/red dragon type content. I just adore your channel. I wonder what you would have to say about Yellowjackets as well.
Can you speak on the fact that people with psychosis/mental disorders are more likely to be subjected to violence than to perpetrate it? Because I feel like people who've had a lifetime of media portrayals of people with mental illnesses being violent hear that and think it's like a platitude or a cover-up.
But if it can be connected to something people understand à la "Some people see individuals with mental troubles as being more vulnerable, unable to defend or advocate for themselves", etc. it can make the realities a little bit clearer.
Oh i will enjoy this series 🙌🏻
Oooh I'm always happy when this amazing show gets more attention
Great video, though there's also so much to say in other episodes... I would kill to see you react to them, no pun intended
There is still such a difficulty in pushing psychology as real and valid. I know that isn't the focus of this episode, but there are points that are so similar to the view today.
"That is all nonsense." "Stop being a headcase" "Stop overthinking, some people are just crazy."
I wish we could accept nuance and study more easily to the mainstream.
im really interested to hear your point of view on studies associated with the use of psilocybin on depression, because it changed my life. i know its different for everyone but im really curious to hear your views as i absolutely love your videos!! :)
Also it's cases like Nicholas Salvador, what he did was abhorrent but he is also clearly VERY unwell, but was he worthy of wrath? Especially after "justice" was served and he'll be in a psychiatric hospital "indefinitely"
14:58 is that General Grevious?
Wonderful video! One of my favorite shows!
Would love to see more of these
i liked it, do more please :)
Yes, please do more of Mindhunter!!!!!
Mainly from you mentioning Hannibal and the fan crossover, but have you thought about reacting to In the Flesh?
Basically zombies are an allegory for a few different kinds of minorities and discrimination in the UK and the main character is queer and deals with his death by suicide because of the loss of his boyfriend.
The second series focuses a lot more on the political landscape and medicalisation of issues and further discrimination and radicalisation.
From what the creator said the third would have gone a lot more into the political side of it all, but since it was cancelled in 2013, it's been talked about coming back through crowdfunding a couple of times and the actors are still interested.
Yes! I second him taking a look at In The Flesh. It's so good! And the allegory used is great. A bit on the nose sometimes but I still think it was really good! I will forever be upset that it didn't get a season 3. 😭
@@AnxietyRat
yeah I love it! I was in a little group that had a live message group for when the episodes aired. For a pretty small cult fanbase there are a lot of very creative people too
I think by the second series it had fully decided to drop any subtlety 😅 For something coming out in 2013 and what the creator said on twitter, it would have done a pretty good job at predicting the creation far right movements and governments as well.
Hope you do more videos on Mindhunter!
She was saying "He might have stopped" and had the mans pills.
I would love to see ep 2 with Ed kemper
I love Mindhunter. One of the best shows I've seen.
please keep doing this show
i love this sjow &I know that this was based on real people but my head canon is Holden will turn out to be a serial killer in the future 😂
The serial killer that murdered my best friend's daughter was born evil. I won't relate what he did to her and her body afterwards. He had no history of abuse, was the only child of an aviation millionaire. He acted in his own defense at the trials of his victims. He is serving a life sentence; may he rot in hell.
Anyone interested in gaining skills to deal with people in crisis, get a job in debt collection. I started my psych degree because i realised im really good at handling those situations. There have been so many situations outside of work where those skills ive learnt have come in very handy.
The book the show is based on is a very good read.
MORE MINDHUNTER!!
I'm finding the red filter on the zoom ins a bit weird -like you're talking about something sinister, but you're not
I wish police had to take this de-escalation training, I’ve had many encounters with police in different countries while working on street performances and they actually often intend to do the opposite so they can get some kind of ticketing opportunity, it’s infuriating and I always keep calm because I’m not about to let a disturbed cop ruin my life but so many people can’t and it escalates and people get hurt, police should not just be trained but also have that training enforced
YES ITS FINALLY HERE
😮😮😮 you're doing mindhunter!!
You should comment on the fiend vs Cena match at WrestleMania
Mindhunter was a top tier show
What does "typical" and "atypical" mean in the context of psychiatric medication here?
Good question. The antipsychotics are divided into first generation (or typical) and second generation (or atypical) with each having a slightly different mechanism of action
Dr Elliott, I wanted to ask you - with homosexuality and conversion therapy being included in past editions of the DSM, do you ever find yourself questioning what's in the current editions? Do you ever think maybe in the future we won't view mental disorders you diagnose now, as mental disorders?
Great question! I always question our current diagnostic practices. I do think there is enormous value in getting a diagnosis but there are some that I hugely question e.g. the new diagnosis of intermittent explosive disorder and how we continue to overmedicalise the diverse ways grief manifests just to name a couple.
Love this serie ! A shame it was cancelled...
There is ep of dog with a blog where stan(the main character) deals with depression please do it
I believe it's season 1 ep 15
More mindhunter please 😊
“Let’s crack on”
Is there a filter on this video?
Also not to be too personal but I hope the hair wasn't to hide your skin ❤ Some comments were particularly mean on the shorts but they're arseholes x
💖
Mindhunter is so good. What's the psychology behind Netflix canning its best shows, haha
My Mad Fat Diary please :)
oh i only watched the first episode or so of that but yeah would be cool to go back to an old british show like that with fresh eyes
113th
So, coming both from a customer service (helpdesk) background, and as someone with autism, I've found that the biggest source of frustration comes from poorly set expectations. I always make it a point to let my customers (and coworkers) know what to expect, up front. Even if that means telling them about delays or complications, or things that haven't been decided yet, if they know that something is going to take a week, they won't get all bent out of shape at five days of not seeing anything happen. Also, a power that I have, as Tier 4 support, is that I can give my name and contact info to the customer and be their single point of contact. If they know that there's an actual person who is responsible for resolving their issue, and that they can get ahold of that person and get regular updates, they feel more secure.
It's all about building a rapport of trust, and about properly setting expectations. I realize that a lot of customer service people do not have these privileges, but when you can provide that level of continuity, it can make all the difference.
There's a guy on a related team to mine (my company makes software, and while I am assigned to a single customer, my colleague works directly for the programming team), who is even more accountable than me. Especially on new products or new features, where the product's reputation (and therefore the company's reputation) is on the line, he'll get sent to a customer site, with instructions to stay and work with them until the problem is fully resolved. Unlimited travel account, and full authority to re-task programmers to investigate / write whatever needs fixing.
That goes a long way to de-escalating anybody's frustration with tech support. I realize that this isn't quite the same context as talking down someone with a gun and a hostage, but in both cases the key is convincing the person WITH YOUR ACTIONS that you are hearing them, that you are taking their concerns seriously, and that you are trustworthy. If you can do that, it's likely they'll give you the time and space to resolve their problems. If they don't believe you're listening and honestly going to help them... things get out of control.
I really enjoyed Mindhunter and watching your reaction and explanations. I would love to see more of these.
❤
This is a great series. I would love to see further analysis. Please keep going with it and creating fantastic content!
I *LOVE* Mindhunter! Have watched it multiple times and hope they do more seasons (though not holding my breath at this point, lol)
Oh boy... We're getting closer to reacting to Prodigal Son. Maybe some day. Whitlys are quite a mental mess.
This is a fantastic show and I hope you review more Mindhunter episodes!
only watched first episode? It's based on a true story and naturally it evolves, they don't start off as pros
This show was great. Shame Netflix didn't renew it.
Please watch more 🙏🏼