5 Reasons Why Generative Fill will NOT Replace You... Yet | Photoshop

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 245

  • @cjlister8508
    @cjlister8508 Рік тому +46

    Generative fill has helped me loads in my retouching. But its a tool like no other. Ive found its great for smaller jobs. eg: I did a model shoot and I had grey fringing from the backdrop around the hair and I couldnt get a good cut out. I got it close, then use generative fill to tidy it up and remove the fringing. Looks great now. Basically used it as a fancy "remove" tool.

    • @hadensnodgrass3472
      @hadensnodgrass3472 Рік тому +6

      AI is a great tool, but people mistake its versatility for excellence. A craftsman is only as good as his tools, but a novice with the best tools can't replace a craftsman that has mastered his.

    • @cjlister8508
      @cjlister8508 Рік тому

      @@hadensnodgrass3472 Exactly. I was saying to a friend recently that this PS update means we will see a lot more great but also alot more bad Photoshop jobs. As those who are already skilled will be able to make stuff quicker and better, but so many people will just use the AI and call it a day without putting in the extra work needed.

  • @zvkvhs3818
    @zvkvhs3818 Рік тому +18

    During a recent photoshoot, I discovered a fantastic tourist attraction as my backdrop. These tools allowed me to clean up imperfections and add elements that were missing during the shoot. They took my images to a whole new level, providing me with creative possibilities I could only dream of before, that would’ve been hours spent in editing. These tools served as a time-saving solution for tasks like compositing and editing. Going forward, I plan to continue using this AI tool to complement my artistic vision and editing style, even if its capabilities evolve over time.

  • @TheOrsonLord
    @TheOrsonLord Рік тому

    This has to legitimately be the best thumbnail designed yet

  • @BlahDepartment
    @BlahDepartment Рік тому +63

    No AI can ever replace humans, creative mind and logical thinking at the moment os out of AI's knowledge... Maybe it'll be also introduced in future but the can never fully replace artists and editors, they can make the work easier for sure

    • @somusamba6118
      @somusamba6118 Рік тому +25

      See you in 2 years

    • @rushikeshpabalkar6943
      @rushikeshpabalkar6943 Рік тому +8

      It can

    • @BlahDepartment
      @BlahDepartment Рік тому +6

      @@rushikeshpabalkar6943 How many AI bots have you developed to pass this comment ? How much is your knowledge in AI development field ? Are you the one watching Reels and UA-cam related to AI and then deciding on the basis of that with zero on ground knowledge ?

    • @rushikeshpabalkar6943
      @rushikeshpabalkar6943 Рік тому +2

      @@BlahDepartment I am learner of machine learning and deep learning.

    • @ravisaharan4072
      @ravisaharan4072 Рік тому +4

      ​@@rushikeshpabalkar6943it's only going to make things easy as of now or it will create more jobs somehow but that new job is definitely going to replace alot of jobs

  • @Perceivedshift
    @Perceivedshift Рік тому +3

    Yup, after working with it for a few weeks, its a fantastic tool, can be a huge time-saver. But it ain't replacing anybody anytime soon.

  • @greimocreatives
    @greimocreatives Рік тому +64

    The fear of being replaced by AI is a significant concern for some designers.

    • @The_CGA
      @The_CGA Рік тому +5

      The companies that demur to employ designers for things like vector logos and branding…will reap what they sow. AI is currently all about churning out an “average” of human output-nothing original or unique comes out of it.
      Hard to stand out from the crown and develop branding that way_

    • @CyberwizardProductions
      @CyberwizardProductions Рік тому +8

      thsoe designers had better learn how to use AI then, because they ARE in risk of losing their jobs. but not to AI itself, to someone that knows AI and can do their job better than they can, and charge less to do it.

    • @blackislepeastoo
      @blackislepeastoo Рік тому +1

      @@CyberwizardProductions and that is the truth.

    • @D0nKeY
      @D0nKeY Рік тому +3

      But all the points in this video are based on the current Beta. Which is obviously the worst it will ever be. Most likely all these points that are mentioned are " fixed " within 1 or 2 versions. the resolution will get better, etc.

    • @joshuaborner
      @joshuaborner Рік тому

      ​@@D0nKeY Most of the problems he mentioned have not or just barely improved in any generative tool. Precision for example is basically unreachable for AI. And it is really not clear how that could even be achieved at all. It will get better of cause but "fixed" within one or two versions? We'll see about that...

  • @marnix1
    @marnix1 Рік тому +1

    As always amazing content sir keep creating 🙏🙏

  • @vishalrai11
    @vishalrai11 Рік тому +2

    I totally agree with you Unmesh, Generative Ai can't replace us, it's just the part of the Ai ability. But certainly it will affect some jobs. I think we should learn how to use it for our own benefit.

  • @sthJuniorPK
    @sthJuniorPK Рік тому +8

    A solution to the piece by piece continuation problem could be to fill the entire area getting the continuation you like, then piece by piece going back over it with the smaller fills.

    • @PiXimperfect
      @PiXimperfect  Рік тому +12

      I tried that, that’s good thinking. However, when you do that, Gen AI assumes the reference image to be “blurred” and creates blurry results.

    • @kpopgirl824
      @kpopgirl824 Рік тому

      I can't find the option...can anyone pls tell me where it is in Photoshop?

    • @shubhamvashishtha
      @shubhamvashishtha Рік тому

      @@PiXimperfect That's what I thought too..😀

    • @sthJuniorPK
      @sthJuniorPK Рік тому

      @@kpopgirl824 Make sure you're using the Beta version, then you'll find Generative Fill in the Edit menu dropdown

  • @stalk05
    @stalk05 Рік тому +6

    So many think Ai is going to be a 1 click solution. I hear people saying that ANYONE can now do the stuff that we took years to learn. I think that is a false statement, Ai is a tool for us to use in our workflow, but it will never be 100% accurate or do exactly what we require. Also the main stumbling block for people who don't know the basics in Photoshop, is when a client wants a certain part changed, if they try to recreate it in Ai, they won't get the exact image they 1st produced, so now they will be stuck on how to fix the issues

  • @AnaM-dh3vn
    @AnaM-dh3vn Рік тому

    I'm from Portugal and I love your videos. I love creative photomontages and I learn a lot here. thanks.

  • @Fiddler4real
    @Fiddler4real Рік тому +1

    I really like how you are so positive and support us with your experience and your words, indeed you are my best teacher. ❤️🔥

  • @Ian_Walsh
    @Ian_Walsh Рік тому +2

    You are spot on as always. Right now its "The Kings New Clothes" Once its out of Beta you can bet you are going to be paying for just as you pay to use Stock Photography. Paying clients want perfection not something almost right.

    • @mcbean1
      @mcbean1 Рік тому

      a few clients will want perfection (good luck getting them seeing as every photographer will be fighting you) most want something usable for the lowest price, with the advances in AI, the cost will easily beat out paying for a human.

  • @markcasebeer8273
    @markcasebeer8273 Рік тому +2

    A lot of examples of why it's a beta. Let's wait and see how it progresses. Thanks for all of your videos on these new features. I enjoy learning, you demonstrated skill is still needed.

  • @africanhistory
    @africanhistory Рік тому +1

    They always show the success never how crazy it gets most of the time

  • @MrLionelrichtea
    @MrLionelrichtea Рік тому

    Your thumbnail! Finally an answer to how you’re so good at photoshop…

  • @ed61730
    @ed61730 Рік тому +2

    Tbf this feature is in beta and is getting better by the week. Give it two years and i'll be interested in your thoughts. Saying that they will always need a creative to use these tools. A retoucher will be using generative fill 1.0 and beyond to help their workflows.

  • @RobAlfieInostrozaLindley
    @RobAlfieInostrozaLindley Рік тому +2

    I think if you do it piece-by-piece it might still take less time by doing it also might not. If you can maybe do square pieces to create a column then merge the layers and then do it again so he knows its continuation

  • @GuanoLad
    @GuanoLad Рік тому +1

    "Yet" is definitely the word to use. But I agree on all the imperfect results, which I have gotten with my own experiments with Generative Fill. And like you, I have had to go in and tweak things with extra work a lot of the time.
    I really don't know why it fills empty spaces with distorted people all the time - that should be eliminated from all results, nobody wants people added in when they're so mutated. Just inanimate objects and nature, please.

  • @waynelytton7517
    @waynelytton7517 Рік тому +1

    I tried many times to get Generative fill to work but it was far to frustrating for me . I will wait for the regular release version and hope it's better

  • @Perceivedshift
    @Perceivedshift Рік тому

    Thank you for adding a non-subscription option to your plugin!!!

  • @TomWindeknecht
    @TomWindeknecht Рік тому

    Great tutorial and in-depth review. Plus, your thumbnail for this video is hilarious! 😆

  • @SirConfusion
    @SirConfusion Рік тому +3

    Thank you for your work! ❤️

  • @user-qm1te4om2b
    @user-qm1te4om2b Рік тому

    Bhai Aaj hi Plan liya maine Specially AI photoshop ke liye .... Dekho ye samajho ye sirf suruaat hai ... Mid journey bhi use kar raha hu mai starting se jab se free tha tab se ... Things takes time ... Jaise mid journey ne bhi almost 1.5-2 saal le hi liye tab jaake itane aage aaye hai ye log ... Adobe is king of Graphics and photo industry from last so many decades.... Lao Lao competition lao... Ye bhi karenge update jakh marvake

  • @pjsingh9293
    @pjsingh9293 Рік тому

    I am also 22 years in the graphic and web industry and when i saw many youtubers are readily uploading videos with thunbs like AI can do this and that, i was worried that time because we are getting the good payroll because of good experience and commands plus speedy work. But now i m relaxed because I checked most of the Ai tools and they were helping the designers and developers, not replace the human beings because even for AI, a tech person can do creative stuff. The only cons is that like many clients and companies thinking that they can hire low level budget interns because they now thinking that anybody can do this work but soon, everone will realise that god made the humans and humans still facing all the challenges and so called AI will be fall badly

  • @Bro-qr9fz
    @Bro-qr9fz Рік тому

    You are right my friend ❤ make videos on colorgrading in camera raw and any tricks to colorgrade wedding photos cohesive and consistent ❤

  • @OberonZg
    @OberonZg Рік тому +1

    Solution for 1 and 2...just first generate low rez image of the whole gap, than generate sectional high rez squares with full information (how to continue) on other 4 sides, instead of 1 or 2...

  • @TanChoonHong
    @TanChoonHong Рік тому +5

    As always, an incisive and eye-opening video. Yes, the pros have no fear, but they must not rest on their laurels. Newbies using AI would leapfrog and edge out the laggards. Therefore "Keep calm and keep on learning."

  • @BrunoSantos-vi9fi
    @BrunoSantos-vi9fi Рік тому

    Nice aproach bro! By the way what's your keyboard? tks

  • @corypropp8333
    @corypropp8333 Рік тому +1

    I’ve had fun playing with it -especially to make my kids laugh (they still like liquify better, though). BUT, I still end up using my own work. It’s more satisfying and accurate.

  • @_tanzil_
    @_tanzil_ Рік тому

    Not yet, but will for sure 😊

  • @rajhansyewale409
    @rajhansyewale409 Рік тому

    Make the video on same topic after Adobe released stable version of this AI or after 1.0 or 2.0 version release.😊

  • @Stmotivations445
    @Stmotivations445 Рік тому

    Make video about quality control solar curve

  • @fj198
    @fj198 Рік тому

    Hello sir, i wanna learn to make game topup pricelist, which video or playlist should i watch? Thanks

  • @FinalStigma
    @FinalStigma Рік тому

    Got to say, there's certainly 1 thing that A.I hasn't failed to do for me yet. And that's making me laugh. XD I laughed so much just from watching his reactions to the A.I generations in this video.

  • @nbaua3454
    @nbaua3454 Рік тому

    Hey brother... You're on spot.. AI apne ko nahi replace karr rahaa..hum logg hi AI ke pichhe paagal hai..😅

  • @martinnelson1552
    @martinnelson1552 Рік тому +1

    Nice work sir
    🎉

  • @momsartroom
    @momsartroom Рік тому

    Hi! As always thank you so much for the awesome videos and tutorials!! But this Beta Photoshop, we can’t use an images that generated from Photoshop Beta for a commercial, is that true? For instance we can’t use a model with a scene that generated from Photoshop Beta for a packaging, advertisement, or print on a product, is that true?

  • @fandel8790
    @fandel8790 Рік тому

    "Yet" is the right word :D

  • @ag-rl6ov
    @ag-rl6ov Рік тому

    Thank you

  • @OKKCmedia
    @OKKCmedia Рік тому

    Thanks for the laughs this morning, some of those AI generations were so funny!

  • @frankyflowers
    @frankyflowers Рік тому

    you could fix all that with stable diffusion if photoshop is using that for the plugins maybe they will let us add our own models and extensions. using stable diffusion along with photoshop is so awesome for me.

  • @blueghost4121
    @blueghost4121 Рік тому

    Is generative fill available on the Pirate Bay yet???

  • @cserannie80
    @cserannie80 Рік тому

    When I made a cover it was useless but for fine toning is good

  • @Rob_van_der_Linden
    @Rob_van_der_Linden Рік тому +2

    Just found it funny when I see people like you do great things with it, but when I try it whatever I ask PS to generate it looks awful, and not just awful, too awful to make anything of it with some editing, for example I "asked" for a flock of birds in a sky, and all it came up with is a bunch of resized bird decals, like you see on windows, also asked for a shark and it was a very cartoonish shark, and no matter what I tried it just got worse :-)

  • @sjey8665
    @sjey8665 Рік тому

    0:31 "Yet" The most important part 😂

  • @naveenms7741
    @naveenms7741 Рік тому

    nice thank you sir

  • @dinoproductions6901
    @dinoproductions6901 Рік тому

    Generative Fill will not replace photo editor but will help him,and will help someone that is new in photoshop and will be fun

  • @laiquekhan10415
    @laiquekhan10415 Рік тому

    Great bro.

  • @garvitkalla5230
    @garvitkalla5230 Рік тому

    It's just a matter of time,it will get powerful someday,If it can do such things which was unexpected in the past,So in the future it will be more powerful.

  • @Anjocally
    @Anjocally Рік тому

    can you make a tutorial for tiktok/instagram reel video quality? 🙏

  • @stanleycurtis6140
    @stanleycurtis6140 Рік тому

    Yup!The only way it just help you sometimes quickly.And you still got creat subjects by yourself.

  • @fardinislam3132
    @fardinislam3132 Рік тому

    hey unmesh ! i'm an old fan of yours , i started watching your vedios about 2 years ago , but i didn't had any device , now i am practicing through your vedios , they are really helpful but i often face problems about the practice files you provide , most of them there are girls picture in it , so when i m practicing my mother interrogates me that who is she , my mother doubts that she might be my girlfriend , how do i fix this issue , today she told me how many girlfriends do you have ? its kinda emberrasing tho ,, btw thanks for the precious content out there

  • @pismaniye9717
    @pismaniye9717 Рік тому

    Interesting tools

  • @Freshy_brain
    @Freshy_brain Рік тому

    Sir, i think those who not purchase the beta will not get realistic generative fill, i select every where and generative fill not looks like you i confused

  • @benoitcorvol7482
    @benoitcorvol7482 Рік тому

    He won't replace people only the way of how to work, it will definetly have an impact on it, that will just make the process faster

  • @astagajeem2003
    @astagajeem2003 Рік тому

    Since i’m more in motion graphics world i can speak only about that. For example roto brush 2 is life changing . But will my clients buy After Effects just to use it? And what after that. There is 1000 steps after that so it’s usable for professional purposes. So i think ai stuff is here to help us. And even if it’s easy for clients i don’t think everyone have that much time to make their own commercials or stuff.

    • @mcbean1
      @mcbean1 Рік тому

      no they might not buy AE, but they might offer you less money if they know there is less and less 'work' required.

    • @astagajeem2003
      @astagajeem2003 Рік тому

      @@mcbean1 yes but less money for clients is usually more clients in the future. So you will work easier but you will produce more content and in the end you will have same money

    • @mcbean1
      @mcbean1 Рік тому

      @@astagajeem2003 the amount of clients is finite, I would imagine that if you polled every graphic designer now on average they would wish they had a few more clients today. So you if require every designers to increase the number of clients when there is already an insufficient amount, the only outcome will be that some % of graphic designers will have to quit.

  • @tobycat7
    @tobycat7 Рік тому

    I will try to do something as simple like remove text from a poster, and it will say "Content removed due to user guidelines". As soon as I saw that, i knew for a fact- This is replacing nobody!

  • @forpeaceachreyswordlastresort

    Thanks 🙏👍

  • @anwerbilal836
    @anwerbilal836 Рік тому

    What will happen when its possible to generate high res images

  • @vikramstudioagra
    @vikramstudioagra Рік тому

    sir a video made of costume design in photoshop

  • @Mohim_Mohim
    @Mohim_Mohim Рік тому

    Plz Make Video With Generetive Fill How To Use--Face Beard Remove, Beard White Hear Change Black, Face Skin Retouch, Skin Color Tone Correction, Face Dodge and Burn

  • @frankyflowers
    @frankyflowers Рік тому

    is that a plugin to use stable diffusion? they have a extension that fixes hands. i have it down.

  • @Lahturudek
    @Lahturudek Рік тому

    For expert editor maybe not but for beginner and Intermediate maybe replace

  • @anwerbilal836
    @anwerbilal836 Рік тому

    This is start. Who knows what will come in future. Imagine ps old versions and now...

  • @MahediHasan-er3bj
    @MahediHasan-er3bj Рік тому

    Enjoyed ❤

  • @waynelytton7517
    @waynelytton7517 Рік тому

    It's definitely reasy for Prime Time.

  • @i_lost_in_mountains_
    @i_lost_in_mountains_ Рік тому

    Umesh bhai❤️

  • @WelcomeToTheGoldenPage
    @WelcomeToTheGoldenPage Рік тому

    I can't understand why they made it so we need to generate in 1024 sections for a clear fill instead of just having Photoshop automatically generate each of the small sections and merge when an area is large, all behind the scenes

  • @Zenzdesign
    @Zenzdesign Рік тому +1

    That Lil Uzi reference 🤣

  • @crazyindiananimator1593
    @crazyindiananimator1593 Рік тому

    can anyone plz tell me the name of the song he used at the end (outrow)

  • @Riste.R
    @Riste.R Рік тому

    Thank you :D

  • @_abdul
    @_abdul Рік тому

    In Short, "We're Safe". Thanks for the Hope dear brother.

  • @maxstepaniuk4355
    @maxstepaniuk4355 Рік тому +1

    SOme of these problems can be solved by Stable diffusion and upscaling. Wait another year and they will be fixed in PS natively.

  • @LazyDesigner
    @LazyDesigner Рік тому

    While AI and automation technologies have the potential to replace certain tasks and processes, they are more likely to augment human capabilities rather than completely replace jobs. AI excels at repetitive, data-driven tasks, while humans bring creativity, emotional intelligence, critical thinking, and adaptability to the table. As a result, many job roles will evolve to focus on tasks that require human skills, allowing you to adapt and collaborate with AI systems rather than being replaced by them.

  • @Seafox0011
    @Seafox0011 Рік тому

    Generative fill seems best at out of focus textured fills, and the more defined the object the less control one has over the result. AI is really an ‘identikit’ system and completely dependent on what original artwork it has scraped off the internet or from stock libraries. That is why the more it is used the more locked into fixed ‘looks’ its output becomes. Variety is not originality.

  • @amanghosh7617
    @amanghosh7617 Рік тому

    I think most of the things you pointed out would be solved eventually and we know how AI tech is evolving, but obviously everyone won't loose job like a person like you would always benifit from it

  • @Brotacon
    @Brotacon Рік тому

    Also, I had to talk a client through exporting a PDF once. We massively underestimate just how tech and design illiterate 90% of clients are.

  • @amantv9326
    @amantv9326 Рік тому +1

    *_Bro MAKE A VEDIO with EXPERIMENTing with ""MIDJOURNY V5.1_* ❤

  • @TheCynicalNihilist
    @TheCynicalNihilist Рік тому +1

    I imagine all these issues will be fixed by photoshops 2024 release

  • @Cineinsaner
    @Cineinsaner Рік тому

    That "Yet! " is so scary man

  • @mainwilly
    @mainwilly Рік тому +1

    put "yet" in the title

  • @anwerbilal836
    @anwerbilal836 Рік тому

    You are a gem 💎 bro

  • @jaroslavrichters953
    @jaroslavrichters953 Рік тому

    I haven't played with AI generative fill much yet but yeah sometimes it does weird things

  • @craigburton4447
    @craigburton4447 Рік тому

    When AI works perfectly : WOW, look how amazing this is!
    When AI isn't perfect: SEE?! Your job is safe!

  • @istuff4137
    @istuff4137 Рік тому

    I really hope they improve the resolution soon. I wanted to use it to replace the need for searching for images in composites. As of now it's not good enough because the images are fuzzy.

  • @liverpoolpictorial
    @liverpoolpictorial Рік тому

    "Yet."😄

  • @tiaoat2013
    @tiaoat2013 Рік тому

    Thanks for talking people off the edge. Generative Fill is interesting but has a long way to go. Seems better at deleting things than anything else! 😮

  • @PahelBrunis
    @PahelBrunis Рік тому

    "Yet" is the keyword here.😊

  • @tief1975
    @tief1975 Рік тому

    That's a small Hope, generate fill still on beta, give it another 6months or 1years and we will see

  • @jeff__w
    @jeff__w Рік тому

    11:56 “What in the world is happening in the corner?”
    So…Adobe enforces “user guidelines” for some image that is completely uncontroversial and SFW 7:56 but Adobe Photoshop can generate some questionable content when _it_ wants (and which is totally unnecessary since the generative fill could obviously just continue the beach and the vegetation). Got it.

  • @O.LEO.N
    @O.LEO.N Рік тому

    I hate the fact that you can't even create something cool or badass like John Wick or any game that has guns in them. It's WAY too restrictive.

  • @timrosenthal46
    @timrosenthal46 Рік тому +1

    The sad part of Ai especially Midjourney is people on platforms like 500PX, Vero etc are creating and posting images and claiming them as their photography and so many people are falling for it. Ai has it's uses for sure, but it is now causing trust issues and I don't like it.

  • @yesrjt
    @yesrjt Рік тому

    Love you my perfect brother ❤.
    inspiration for millions 🫂.

  • @plesmo.
    @plesmo. Рік тому

    Compare it with dall e

  • @maykd4481
    @maykd4481 Рік тому +1

    Lil Uzi comparsion got me.
    His forehead looks like messed up AI too.

  • @amitnegi7340
    @amitnegi7340 Рік тому

    sir a am album desingner 1 want sir 1 photo in a file ( i paste 2nd photo in file 2nd photo automatic convert 1 photo same size )

  • @graphcpu
    @graphcpu Рік тому

    WOW MY HERO ALWAYS THINK LIKE ME

  • @Jdikmen
    @Jdikmen Рік тому

    Reason #6 - No machine on the planet has the patience to work with "my" clients!

  • @boybergamo76
    @boybergamo76 Рік тому

    Whwn Generative AI will reach Midjourney Version 5 quality for everything will be incredibile using it! ❤️❤️❤️❤️