ORADOUR-SUR-GLANE 4K (New Aquitaine, France). 1944 massacre memorial town.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 150

  • @clare9637
    @clare9637 Рік тому +33

    My husband and I visited Oradour-Sur-Glane in 2015. Having visited several of the war memorials it was somewhere we felt it was important for us to visit. Nothing prepares you for the atmosphere it still holds. Visiting Oradour had an impact on us that we still talk about often. The honesty and simplicity of the town says more than any purpose built memorial could. Thank you for taking the time to film and share your video.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +5

      Thank you Clare for your very kind comment. Indeed, it was an unforgettable experience.

    • @woodenseagull1899
      @woodenseagull1899 Рік тому +4

      My wife too, only ventured a few steps onto the site, and then had to turn back...It is a very upsetting experience...!

    • @doodlermcm3092
      @doodlermcm3092 5 місяців тому

      Ĺĺĺĺĺĺllĺĺĺĺĺlĺlĺĺĺĺlĺĺĺĺĺĺĺĺlĺĺĺĺĺĺĺĺĺĺllĺĺlĺlĺlĺlĺlĺĺllĺĺlĺllĺlĺlllĺlllĺĺlĺlĺlĺlĺllĺllĺllĺlĺlĺlĺĺĺlĺlĺlĺlĺĺlĺĺĺlĺĺĺĺĺĺlĺplppp00000😊p0​@@woodenseagull1899

  • @mariekesuur9246
    @mariekesuur9246 5 місяців тому +3

    Wij zijn hier als gezin enkele jaren geleden geweest.
    Zeer aangrijpend.
    Het laat me niet meer los.
    Bedankt voor deze ingetogen weergave van deze plek.

  • @jenniferlaverty9791
    @jenniferlaverty9791 Рік тому +10

    Thank you for sharing. Blessings from Australia 21/06/23

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +1

      Australia is in my bucket's list! Thanks for posting a comment Jennifer.

  • @gandigooglegandigoogle7202
    @gandigooglegandigoogle7202 Рік тому +8

    your video is like a memorial...the silence and your steps...it is well filmed and the emotion grips us. How is it possible to burn 200 children alive?!...by god, how is that possible?.........
    I really like the ending scene...this river is like a clearing in the stupidity of men.
    thx you !

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +2

      Thank you for your comment. It's great hearing such a positive feedback. Indeed, it's unbelievable how humans can commit such horrific war crimes.

  • @ellencattan
    @ellencattan 2 роки тому +15

    Thank you very much for choosing to share with us Oradour-Sur-Glane. The WWII massacre should never be forgotten. It’s heartbreaking to think how evil we as humans can become to be able to perpetrate such horror. I’m thoroughly enjoying your beautiful travel videos, this video though was very special. Mercy beaucoup.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  2 роки тому +1

      Ellen, thank you very much for your kind comment. Indeed, it's a very touching place, I will never forget being there. And I'm glad you're enjoying some of the videos!

    • @suzyqualcast6269
      @suzyqualcast6269 7 місяців тому

      And here we are, 80 years on, seeing exactly this Slaughter being repeated, again, in a land far away by the very descendants of those who claimed such suffering in this very same conflict.
      So much for learning from hands on experience....

  • @osowiecwalking9434
    @osowiecwalking9434 Рік тому +13

    i feels like time has stopped there. It is still 1944 in this place where hundred of souls are still roaming in agony and pain.

  • @olivierhaussaire2590
    @olivierhaussaire2590 Рік тому +4

    Merci, pour votre vidéo,🙏🏻 sobre et respectueuse.
    Pour ne jamais oublier, pour les futurs générations..plus jamais ça...

  • @winksmt01
    @winksmt01 5 місяців тому +2

    I visited Biirkenau in Poland walking through the gates my hairs stood up on my body. I would imagine this village does the same. Great video.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  5 місяців тому

      Thanks for your kind comment. It was just as you say. Never been to Birkenau though.

  • @mariannewilliams6566
    @mariannewilliams6566 Рік тому +5

    I've been to Oradour found it very moving this should never be forgotten thank you for sharing

  • @paulclifton7566
    @paulclifton7566 3 місяці тому +2

    Truly an act of obscene evil. The ruins of Oradour-sur-Glane serve as a memorial to the victims of this needless massacre. I visited the Auschwitz-Birkenau museum in July 2024 and would like to see Oradour-sur-Glane as well. Thanks for the video.

  • @harvester24-7
    @harvester24-7 Рік тому +5

    Thank you for a beautiful and respectful video of such an awful travesty.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +1

      Thanks Teresa for your very kind message. Best regards from Chile.

  • @didierbordereaux5898
    @didierbordereaux5898 2 роки тому +3

    Merci pour ce reportage plein de simplicité et de silence respectueux. Vos courts écrits résument bien ce qui s'est passé à Oradour. Quelle bonne idée d'avoir filmé votre arrivée dans la campagne et d'avoir terminé cette vidéo avec cette rivière si symbolique. Merci.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  2 роки тому

      Didier, merci beaucoup pour votre commentaire. Je suis heureux que vous ayez trouvé la vidéo bien dans le contexte du drame survenu à Oradour.

  • @nonicknamefornow
    @nonicknamefornow 2 роки тому +6

    Merci Felipe, j’apprécie le format de tes vidéos et le choix de tes visites. J’espère que tu vas continuer

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  2 роки тому

      De rien Jonathan! Merci beaucoup pour ton aimable commentaire.

  • @sandacathan9787
    @sandacathan9787 Рік тому +3

    Thank you. Recording this must have been very difficult for you. I found it extremely hard so I can only imagine what it must feel like actually walking through the village and the emotional ties with the stones of the buildings. Once again thank you.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +1

      Thank you very much for your kind comment. It is really an unforgettable place to visit.

  • @helenawarsinnak
    @helenawarsinnak Рік тому +2

    Thank u so much for making/posting this video!! For many yrs now I have been extremely interested in WW2...this has ALWAYS been one place I wanted to go to, to see first hand and to pay my respects to all of those innocent victims 😢....and I know I most likely will never have the chance to be able to go there.....so I truly ty so very much for this video!!!💜

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +2

      Thank you Heather for your very kind comment. A very special place indeed. I hope you'll have the chance to go there, sometimes the unexpected happens!

    • @helenawarsinnak
      @helenawarsinnak Рік тому +1

      @@felipedibarrart9853 thank you so very much Hun!! 💜
      And u are so right....sometimes the unexpected can happen!!🤞
      **But thanks again and best wishes to you!!😊

  • @velouris76
    @velouris76 Рік тому +3

    This video is so respectful and moving.

  • @Victoriabrickland
    @Victoriabrickland 2 місяці тому

    Thank you Felipe for this video. It’s extremely sad and heartbreaking to see knowing what happened there. Its hard to put into words from someone who has visited many war memorials, this stands out the most. RIP to all those poor souls.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  2 місяці тому

      Thank you Rachel for your kind comment. Indeed, it goes beyond words.

  • @kevinalman5660
    @kevinalman5660 Рік тому +6

    Visited this place 3 years ago. Was very moving. It's like time has stood still. This tragedy is mentioned in opening scene of the epic TV series world at war. Must of been awful for the victims. Very sad.

  • @silvioneves2378
    @silvioneves2378 2 місяці тому +1

    well , i had the most astonish feeling visiting this place , i didn not expect to fell anything but as i was watching inside a house , a bakery a think, i felt ike being there at that time . I cannot explain in words what i felt, could feel the suffering myself , stared crying whitout control . i cant explain till today what happend.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  2 місяці тому +1

      Thanks Silvio. Indeed, it's an experience that's impossible to describe. Kind regards.

  • @coco.g5567
    @coco.g5567 4 місяці тому +1

    C'est toujours très émouvant. Comment des êtres humains ont pu faire ça à d'autres êtres humains. Quand j'étais petite c'est le silence qui régnait j'y suis retournée il y a quelques temps et le chant des oiseaux était présent une sorte d'apaisement enfin. Dommage que Monsieur Hebras n'ait pas été là cette année pour le 80eme anniversaire et la visite historique en français d'un président allemand.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  4 місяці тому

      Merci pour votre commentaire. Je me souviens beaucoup du chant des oiseaux.

  • @marie-christinelange131
    @marie-christinelange131 2 роки тому +4

    Très très difficile à commenter en effet... Ce n'est sans doute pas la meilleure visite que vous avez faite en France ! Très courageux de votre part : MERCI
    Malheureusement, il y en a eu d'autres atrocités comme celle-là, notamment aux Lucs-sur-Boulogne en Vendée, pendant la Révolution Française ! Les Républicains ont brûlé tous les habitants (femmes, enfants et hommes) de ce petit village car ils étaient vendéens, catholiques et contre les idées de la terreur (une guerre civile, en somme, car entre français) Souvenirs très douloureux, toutes ces horreurs

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  2 роки тому +1

      Merci beaucoup Marie-Christine pour votre commentaire. Oradour est un endroit inoubliable, le plus "puissant" que j'ai visité en France. J'apprécie votre contribution au sujet historique. Avec honte je me rends compte que j'ignorais la terrible situation des Lucs-sur-Boulogne. Je vais enquêter davantage sur cette période historique. Merci!

  • @LBG-cf8gu
    @LBG-cf8gu Рік тому +2

    well done! this video is exactly what i was looking for. excellent videography. many thx. new sub.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +1

      Thanks for your kind feedback and for subscribing! Best regards.

  • @morrisson2641
    @morrisson2641 7 місяців тому +2

    Impresionante vídeo pero muy triste lo que pasó , nuevo seguidor saludos👍

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  7 місяців тому +1

      Muchas gracias por el comentario y subscripción. Muy triste en realidad, es un lugar inolvidable.

  • @snolakliprika8904
    @snolakliprika8904 3 місяці тому

    Danke für Ihr Video. Ich hab schon einige gesehen. An Grausamkeit sind die Gräueltaten dieser deutschen Bestien nicht zu überbieten. Wie konnten Menschen das nur diesen Einwohnern antun ?! Ich verstehe es bis heute nicht und schäme mich für die Taten meiner damaligen Landsleute.
    Immer wieder muß ich weinen, wenn ich Videos von diesem schrecklichen Massaker sehe.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  3 місяці тому

      Vielen Dank für deinen tollen Kommentar. Tatsächlich geht es über das menschliche Verständnis hinaus. Viele Grüße aus Chile.

    • @snolakliprika8904
      @snolakliprika8904 3 місяці тому

      @@felipedibarrart9853 Vielen Dank und viele Grüße nach Chile.

  • @Url89009
    @Url89009 10 місяців тому +1

    Thankyou for an incredible video its very moving.

  • @charlottebakker5580
    @charlottebakker5580 9 місяців тому +1

    Very impressive video. I hope to visit it one day.

  • @SIG442
    @SIG442 Рік тому +1

    I do see changes from when I visited, I was only 8 I think. So that is about 38 years ago. It left a deep impression on me.
    There are a lot less cars and other metallic objects then I remember, less trees as well.
    Also remember a fountain or something that had running water that dropped into a stone box of some kind under a tree, haven't seen that either in any recent video.
    And the old memorial is clearly no longer in use which is rather sad to see.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому

      Thank you very much for sharing your experience. I was not aware of the existence of an old memorial.

  • @m1stergold
    @m1stergold Рік тому +2

    thanks for making this video

  • @didierlacroix6488
    @didierlacroix6488 5 місяців тому +3

    life stopped in Oradour sur Glane on june 10 th 1944. 642 innocent people were massacred there. remember : that is what fascism looks like and its consequences

  • @vilhelmhammershoi3871
    @vilhelmhammershoi3871 2 місяці тому

    Very touching video. Respectful and inviting to profound reflection. Minute 10:07, shouldn't the Latin read, Requiescant-in-Pace (since it's plural)?

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  2 місяці тому

      Thanks for your very kind feedback Vilhelm. I'm very glad you liked it. My knowledge in french is survival-mode only! So i'd need help with your question.

    • @vilhelmhammershoi3871
      @vilhelmhammershoi3871 2 місяці тому

      @@felipedibarrart9853 Yes. The Latin expression ''Requiescat in Pace'', applies to the third person singular form. ''Requiescant in Pace'' would be the plural they form of Latin, as far as I understand. Greetings from Mexico.

  • @StephenLuke
    @StephenLuke 5 місяців тому +2

    RIP
    To the 643 French civilians who were murdered by the Waffen-SS under Adolf Diekmann and Heinz Lammerding in the Oradour-sur-Glane massacre

  • @matta.5363
    @matta.5363 Рік тому +2

    My father, Emery, was a WW2 paratrooper with the 101st Airborne Division, 506 PIR. He jumped on D-Day near Carentan and then fought across France, in Bastogne against the SS, and then into Germany. I'm so very proud of how he fought to destroy the wicked Nazis army that destroyed this innocent village.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому

      Thank ypu for sharing Emery's amazing story. I would be very proud to have known anyone that jumped on D-Day. What to say if he was your own father! Best regards.

  • @danieleparenti7661
    @danieleparenti7661 Рік тому +2

    Ogni commento è vano al cospetto di tanta efferatezza nei confronti di quelle povere persone che hanno pagato solo per il fatto di trovarsi lì. Possano questi assassini criminali che hanno perpetrato tanta malvagità ardere nelle fiamme dell inferno come hanno fatto a questa povera gente, ma per l eternità! Silenzio, rispetto e preghiera per questo luogo e per queste anime che hanno perso la vita in un modo così atroce.

  • @johnsometimesoffandsometim8933

    I visited many years ago. Very moving experience

  • @alexandraromanov7904
    @alexandraromanov7904 10 місяців тому +1

    Thank You

  • @charlottebakker5580
    @charlottebakker5580 6 місяців тому +1

    It is said that people who walk through the village can still smell.the fire and burnt wood. The church seems to be haunted.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  6 місяців тому

      Thanks Charlotte for commenting. I did not smell anything like that. The perception is a feeling of respect from all the visitors.

  • @minislayer2010
    @minislayer2010 Рік тому +1

    On my bucket list. It's easy to dismiss the rusted old cars as just piles of rusty metal. But every one of those vehicles served a purpose. They were somebody's work truck or family runabout, and then, one day. They just weren't anymore. and left for all time, right where they stood. Very sad.

  • @shawnastephens1536
    @shawnastephens1536 8 місяців тому

    Seemed like a quaint little quiet town. This was a sad story.

  • @brianward9674
    @brianward9674 Рік тому

    Whent 20 years ago and I had tears and a lump in my throat it's very sad

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому

      Thanks for your comment Brian. Indeed, a very emotional place to visit.

  • @markgc1316
    @markgc1316 2 місяці тому

    As an historic wartime incident, about which great detail has come to light, an entire German Army Detachment has been identified as responsible. This means that Germans alive to day, when asked what their Great Grandfather did in the War, will have to admit to unspeakable acts of atrocity being committed by close family members.
    It must be very difficult for Germans as a people to think about the War. It is inconceivable that anyone could commit crimes against people in that way ( and yes, I concede that War Crimes have been committed by countries other than Germany too), but had the Germans WON the war, the whole of Europe would have been a totalitarian regime under Nazi rule and Oradour sur Glane would not be commemorated as an atrocity.

  • @lynnralph8373
    @lynnralph8373 Рік тому +2

    Has Germany ever apologised for this deliberate atrocity? These were unarmed innocents. A tragedy.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +3

      In 2013, German Pesident Gauck became the first German head of state to visit the village of Oradour-sur-Glane. Thanks for your comment.

    • @woodenseagull1899
      @woodenseagull1899 Рік тому +1

      ​@@felipedibarrart9853 It took the Germans a very long time to apologise! Leaving it so long is meaningless, worthless..They are people, without a soul.....

    • @danieleparenti7661
      @danieleparenti7661 Рік тому +1

      The fact is that, moreover, hardly anyone has ever payd for what they have done!

    • @wolfgangemmerich7552
      @wolfgangemmerich7552 Рік тому

      @@danieleparenti7661 .... incl. the maquise rouge with its leader Georges Guingouin in the Tulle area nicknamed ,, petit russie" by the french natives .

  • @NGC7000
    @NGC7000 5 місяців тому

    Looking at this and seeing where we stand today, it seems that we never learn from history

  • @devonthemaskeddevonaire9471

    great video

  • @yurborisovichpinhasik8039
    @yurborisovichpinhasik8039 Рік тому +2

    И почти никто из участников этой акции не понес заслуженного наказания! Все в лучших традициях того времени! ФРГ не выдала, амнистия, большинство убийц спокойно дожили свой век у себя дома, в комфорте, в окружении своих семей.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому

      Действительно, несколько дней спустя несколько человек были убиты в бою. Всего несколько дней назад Нормандия была восстановлена. Спасибо за ваш комментарий.

  • @Micha_RS
    @Micha_RS 11 місяців тому +1

    I visited Oradour as German Soldier..2015.

  • @vedatcakir5170
    @vedatcakir5170 10 місяців тому +2

    Acının katliamın trajedinin dini dili ırkı olmaz kim insanlığa suç işlerse onu şiddetle kınıyorum Zalimler için yaşasın cehennem

  • @Coolerman565
    @Coolerman565 4 місяці тому +1

    Pure evil visited that village that day, it was just 4 days after D-day and the French resistance and British SOE had been ambushing Das Reich as they headed north to engage us in Normandy, they punished that village and the poor people who lived there.

  • @mikegoodwin9739
    @mikegoodwin9739 7 місяців тому +1

    On the 9th of June the day before this my grandfather Fabien David was walking to the store to get my mother some milk she was 6 mons old the nazis just happened to be coming down the same road as my grandpa they shot him to death for no reason. My mom never met her dad and I was only told this story from my grandma and great grandpa

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  7 місяців тому

      Thanks for posting and sharing your personal experience. It's very sad to hear that. I always think of the thousands of untold stories related to WWII that may exist.

  • @laurentdudouit2485
    @laurentdudouit2485 3 місяці тому

    after i visited this town,i began to learn what led to this horrific event
    The nazis were in transit to normandy,they were under constant attacks by the french resistance
    it make them angry,so they picked this village known for the absence of what they called "terrorists" as an exaction
    it also was said it was a mistake,because there's another town,Oradour sur vayres
    but no,Oradour sur glane was specifically targeted

  • @awhisperinthewind4253
    @awhisperinthewind4253 2 роки тому +1

    I remember my visit so sad and a reminder of mans inhumanity to man

  • @jimmillward3505
    @jimmillward3505 Рік тому +1

    your heart must be in your mouth treading in a place of such tragedy. How truly horrifying to realise that out of all those german troops not one of them had the humanity and courage to step forward and say no to committing a war crime and followed the order to gun down and burn innocent people to death.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +1

      Indeed, in fact most of the killes were not brought to proper justice. Thanks for your comment.

  • @BertiOnTour
    @BertiOnTour 6 місяців тому

  • @ace-x6m
    @ace-x6m 11 місяців тому

    The bullet holes in the WWI memorial was symbolic. If you think history doesn’t repeat itself, think again.

  • @MaxRockatansky78
    @MaxRockatansky78 Рік тому +2

    Грустно. Понимаем, каково это. С небольшой поправкой - в СССР они сожгли тысячи деревень

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому +1

      Большое спасибо за ваш комментарий

    • @olivierhaussaire2590
      @olivierhaussaire2590 Рік тому +1

      En tant que français 🇫🇷🙏🏻j'ai une pensée,pour les milliers de Oradour
      Incendiés dans lex URSS 🙏..et ses victimes de la barbarie.. Merci..

  • @richardque4952
    @richardque4952 Рік тому

    During the war crime trial.most of german troop carry out the killing were from alsace.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому

      I was not aware of that. Thank you for commenting.

    • @olivierhaussaire2590
      @olivierhaussaire2590 Рік тому +1

      Bonjour,vous faite une petite erreur
      A Oradour c'était une unité de la dass Reich, ukrainiee,qui remontée
      Sur le front de Normandie..
      Les plus jeunes avaient 17ans.il y avait 13 soldats alsacien, effectivement
      Les autres,Alsaciens étaient plutôt sur le front est,avec la division Charlemagne.
      Merci de votre attention.🙏🏻.

  • @suzyqualcast6269
    @suzyqualcast6269 7 місяців тому

    Wasnt this tragic event more to do with the abduction of SS Major/General Kampfe who ended up dead in a pig pen and his truppens inability to find him?

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  7 місяців тому

      Thanks for your post. Indeed, it was a 642 x 1 retribution, involving women and children. To me, the SS General death is only incidental, given the magnitude of this horrific massacre.

  • @fatherbewithme
    @fatherbewithme Рік тому +1

    Eerie surreal

  • @paulbrasile8654
    @paulbrasile8654 Місяць тому

    Very sad .

  • @charlottebakker5580
    @charlottebakker5580 9 місяців тому

    The last survivor died in February 2023.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  9 місяців тому +1

      Indeed. Robert Hébras, he was 97. He was around 19 at the time of the massacre. Thanks for your comment.

  • @av8tore71
    @av8tore71 Рік тому

    So sad

  • @AkshayKumar-xh2ob
    @AkshayKumar-xh2ob Рік тому

    Just watching this video is so haunting, it was an abominable act.

  • @yurborisovichpinhasik8039
    @yurborisovichpinhasik8039 Рік тому

    Интересно, существуют ли в современной Франции политики, которые говорят, что уже прошло много лет, зачем лишний раз вспоминать все эти ужасы войны, надо думать о будущем, не за чем прошлое ворошить? Надо понять, простить и забыть?

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  Рік тому

      Хороший вопрос, спасибо, что поделились своими мыслями.

  • @fidelcastro6104
    @fidelcastro6104 7 місяців тому

    Four years later, survivors of Nazi barbarism committed a horror as macabre as this one. A few thousand kilometers from here in Deir Yassin.
    Not only is this massacre is not known but even its remains were razed by bulldozers to build another village and settle a population coming from far away. Thus the village of Deir Yassin does no longer exists, the new village is called Givat Shaul.
    Another detail, none of the killers went to prison.

    • @felipedibarrart9853
      @felipedibarrart9853  7 місяців тому

      Indeed, more than one hundred Palestinian villagers, including women and children were killed. Thank you for your insight.

  • @davidbradshaw3107
    @davidbradshaw3107 Рік тому +1

    This would be an ideal place to try Putin for his war crimes.

    • @olivierhaussaire2590
      @olivierhaussaire2590 Рік тому +1

      Veuillez respecter svp,la mémoire
      Des martyrs d'Oradour,,ce n'est pas le lieu pour faire des commentaires politiques.merci .

    • @davidbradshaw3107
      @davidbradshaw3107 Рік тому +1

      @@olivierhaussaire2590 Bien sur. Pardon.

    • @olivierhaussaire2590
      @olivierhaussaire2590 Рік тому +2

      @@davidbradshaw3107 merci pour votre compréhension 🙏.