What If The US Joined The Central Powers? | Alternate History
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
- What if the United States, rather than align itself with Great Britain and the Triple Entente during the First Great War, instead joined Germany and the Central Powers? Perhaps most curiously, why would the US become a Central Power?
_____________________________________________
#AlternateHistory #MonsieurZ #WWI
New Videos Every Wednesday At 2:30 PM EST
Donate To The Channel: / @monsieurdean
______________________________________________
Website:
USofZ.com
______________________________________________
Music Used: No.4 Piano Journey, At Odds, Dance of the Uboat
We have new videos every Wednesday at 2:30pm EST. Don't miss them, and please like & share the video if you enjoyed it!
Become a channel sponsor: ua-cam.com/channels/QR_kmeb0lBEk1Zj_9LWDHA.htmljoin
Join our "Discord Server": www.usofz.com/forum
Pick up a copy of our novel: www.amazon.com/Am-Uncle-Sam-Dean-Mosley-ebook/dp/B07WNG95QH
I have a question, What if the Japanese won the imjin war?
Mr.Z what do you think ww2 would have been like if the red baron survived
I need to relearn WWl
Had Germany had a little foresight they may have been able to strike a deal with media mogul W.R. Hurst who was of Irish decent and had no love for the Brits. A soft propaganda campaign of pro German/Irish anti Brit may have been strongly received by not only German immigrants of the time but also the large amount of Irish in the US.
what if Robert Kennedy survived his assassination and won the 1968 presidential race
We need a Part 2,3,4 and 5, an actual scenario up to the modern day.
Leonidas Midas absolutely
So much this.
Agreed.
Yes
YES
mfw when the colony which rebelled against you around 120 years ago starts upsetting the entire balance of world power that you’ve worked for multiple centuries
Otl or Atl?
*YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE!*
@Rory Mulligan *cries in free native american states*
@Rory Mulligan Not France and Russia. The US still is close with France to this day and was close with Russia until WWII.
Eagle J. The US and Russia never had good relations. Even before WW1 and WW2 they had neutral relations at best.
What if in 1939 Germany had chose to stay allied with Nationalist China instead of allying Japan.
Yes
AH: oke boi lets make sure things cool off over danzig. I need you to save china.
HH: wait why.
AH: we will flank the communist in a continent wide encirclement (mad laughing)
Hoi4 germany picking befriend china instead of japan
@@cherrykmy7336 Man of Culture I see
@@Bahns007 yes, Yes i am.
Britain : Make the German population starve
Everyone : I sleep
Germany try to do the same to Britain
Everyone : real shit.
@@Void_Wars so if i were to order a taxi and use that taxi to deliver arms to enemy forces in war zone, i shall be let pass freely, if someone does even so as approach me I am ordered to attack them, but they are still not allowed to attack me because I am inside this taxi. Makes sense.
@Stephen Jenkins if you transport war supplies on a cruise ship, it's hardly a *cruise* ship anymore
@@itsKarlDesigns you forgot that you're allowed to shoot at the enemy unprovoked while on the taxi
@@itsKarlDesigns international logic
@@NeverEverClever oh yeah that too, but they cant shoot you when provoked
USA: exists
Britain: *starts smashing chessboard after trying to balance things for centuries
I dont know if Mons. Z already did this, but I would like to watch a scenario where this happens:
America: "No taxation whitout representation!"
Britain: "Fair point. Choose some representatives to go to London for we to discuss this."
@Rory Mulligan G. Washington pulls a full Hannibal and crosses the Atlantic in winter.
@Amber Hoke Wat
@@VikingMuayThai Nope
@Xander Smith He isn’t stfu
This is why the best alt hist scenarios aren't WW2, but WW1.
Such interesting worlds can be created, and really there are only a few unchangeable constants.
1. France will always be against Germany.
2. Austria will always be against Serbia.
From there you have crazy scenarios where neutrals join in on either side (CP Sweden, Allied Spain, etc.) to full on swapped sides (CP Russia, Allied Ottomans).
Some are less likely than others 100%, but there's so many variables to play with in WW1 because it was really a neutral war where no side was really in the wrong, and staying true to its neutrality as a war, it even almost ended in perfect stalemate, one small scale tip and everything changes.
PS. If you can find a believable Central Powers France scenario, that'd be impressive.
i think it would be more accurate to say each side was in the wrong rather than no side was in the wrong
@@zwilder1 Why? The central alliance was just an ally backing up an ally, and the Ottoman Empire trying to re-establish their power. The Entente was simply people trying to defend their allies.
I actually started working on a Google doc where France joined the central powers because of this comment. I haven’t finished yet but it’s coming along well
"the ottomans were holding strong against the entente" yeah definitely
😆
???? Gallipoli?
They weren't initially, but as soon as Ataturk took the reigns both Russia and the Brittish empire were both successfully repelled.
Other events probably altered entente troop deployment
In our timeline the ottomans had almost captured the suez and had successfully repelled an attack on gallipoli only after the british pooled troops, started two new offensives, and created the arab uprising that turned the tides in the middle east
Germany When USA Joins Their Side:"Yeah, It's All Coming Together"
Thanks for screwing the west, Woodrow Wilson!
Germany: "FUCK YEAH, now we win"
@@nero7469 they still lose everything to the russians, like, even D-Day seems like a scartch to what the russians did
@@catrielmarignaclionti4518 We're talking about WW1 not 2
@@nero7469 they still joined at the end and took the credit
That would be one hell of a bruh moment
😂
🗿
On god dude imagine
Fuggin based
🅱️🗿
USA: *Joins Central Powers*
Britain and France: 👁👄👁
Surprised pikachu face
Rory Mulligan ha... tough luck
Thx ya just got me screamed at Rory mulligan :(
👁👄👁
N👁🗨rmie
That just sounds like Kaiserreich but with extra steps
Should say better outcome for U.S. Get to annex part of the hat and loans that U.S. had with the European powers would be paid. Just wondering how the Entante butthurt would manifest. lol
@@AdventuringMind Facist Britain/France?
@@charmyzard i'd reckon a communist france, not sure about britain, but assuming italy does the thing again it could go fascist.
*Clemenceau and his staff meeting in Paris *
Clemenceau: So Jacques, what is the news?
Jacques: The Americans have joined the war.
Clemenceau: Hon hon hon, that´s good, the Kaiser will hate that.
*Jacques sweating nervously*
*Clemenceau hearing Preußens Gloria playing from the Champs Elysées *
Clemenceau: Please, tell my I´m having a bad dream.
United kingdom: *any good news solider?*
Solider: *no the french are being pushed back and the USA joined the war*
United kingdom: *insert surprised pikachu*
:0
Remove "the"
@@maxstone2380 No, thats correct 😅
@@OddZodd no, it's wrong. the would be used in the right context if it were "French" instead of France and had "are" instead of "is".
@RavnDream Solitaire, Bond girl from "Live and Let Die".
Just imagine a crew of German submariners docking in New York in 1916 or 1917 and being welcomed as 'Steuben's boys'. I would imagine there would be a deluge of propaganda art emphasizing Steuben and the Hessian mercenaries from the Revolution.
Yeah some old photos of some Americans and Germans in front of a U-boat i can see it in history books.
What if the Soviet Union joined Tannu Tuva instead of the opposite
Hi fat kimmy 3
No
BRUH
What do you mean what if?
Tannu...what?
So, your telling me that if the USA had sided with the German Empire my dreams of annexing Canada would have been fulfilled long before I was even born.
Well, I guess I know what I'm going to do when mankind builds a time machine.
@@grandmarshallsteve8183 and me
@@Joseph_417 I will also come… then find a way to change our WWII, with America joining the axis powers.
@@Emperordgualica yeah no
@@Vienic2 what? I want to see what happens.
@@Emperordgualica You would have to change a LOT of aspects of either the US or the Axis Powers to even begin to contemplate such an alliance.
I’d love to see a part 2 of this scenario! Hints of a second Great War would be cool to see how it plays out
It would basically be France, Britain, and Italy as the Axis, with Germany, USA and the Ottoman Empire along with the Yugoslav states as the Allies. Japan may even join in for round 3 against Russia and China. Would be super weird.
Z: “...Nationalistic Revenge” Oswald Mosley: “Allow me to introduce myself!”
It really would have made just as much sense to ally with Germany. The Germans were desirable trading partners and didnt work against us. Germany gets a lot of the blame for the war , but French aggression was largely to blame. The French started the Franco-Prussian War, as well. Also we'd previously been at war twice with Britain and several quasi-wars with France. The big reason to join the central powers would have been the total arrogance of the blockade of Germany. Blocking our trade with Germany and Austria is something we should have stood up to and stopped. And then there was Canada, which we still wanted.
Ideally yes, but Wilson was making bank trading with England early on.
Looking back at the effects of the peace, both the US and Japan would’ve been better off either neutral or allied with the Central Powers.
I love it! And here are the lists that I want to see the future video.
1. What if Korean Empire never fails.
2. What if Korea becomes the colony of France?
3. What if Japan becomes the colony of the USA?
4. What if Xinhai Revolution failed?
5. What if Two Sicilian Empire had a colony or refuse to united with Italian Empire?
6. What if USA failed in the Spanish American war?
7. What if Ethiopia was the superpower in the African continent?
8. What if Park Chunghee survives in the 10/26?
me what if germany, austria, neatherlands, denmark, and sweden become big world powers and screw spain, britan, france, and portegul
What if t the south rose again
Actually i think if the US just stopped trade with the Entente they would have lost WW1. The amount of weapons and ammunition as well as food and other recources the US shipped to France the UK and italy made it possible for them to hold out until the end of the war. I think they would not even have had to actively fight to decide the conflict this way.
US wouldn’t have lost the war
@@firestriker3580 I never claimed that. (may i suggest you to read my comment again?)
What i claimed (in short) is that if the US would not have supplied the Entente, this would have been enough to decide the conflict against the Entente.
@@nirfz i think its a spam bot
@@LandoBando-pj5ox you could be right with that.
Na
What if Nicaragua won the Google Maps War
as a nicaraguan, yes, lets do it
No
What's a Nicaragua? Lol,...murica
@@oscargurdian9389 Como costarricense dire: Fokiu Nica 🖕 (es broma)
@@conservative_Redskin Funny guy
Here's a question:
What if William Henry Harrison live longer?
Tippecanoe and…
WHO??!
@@Perririri Tyler too
William Henry Harrison died early,
“Who?” “I’m Henry Harrison man, legendary president.” “*confused face*” “guys?”
USA conquers the world in 3 months
USA: "joins the war"
Britain: Glad to be fighting alongside ya
USA: "takes over canada"
Britain: no no no, what are you DOING?!?!?
USA: I'm becoming your doom
not in 1918 Britain was a lot more powerful than the US. literally the height of it's empire, thousands of royal navy ships the most advanced navy in the world at the time
No lol uk is more powerful
Delete this comment its so unsensible,stupid,dumb and biased
@Amber Hoke
Apart from US can field men faster, would Canadian army become smaller every time they took casualty while US Army grow bigger with each passing week?
That certainly how it went down in WW2 Pacific theater, where Japan had no replacements for every loss they took.
@@thetechoasis2179 No it wasn’t a lot more powerful than the US dumbass. The US was WAY more powerful than Britain in 1918
Austria & Serbia: Start the war
Entente: "Germany did it!"
Germany: Attempts to negotiate a white peace and return to status quo in 1916
Entente: "Germanys a warmonger!"
This needs a sequel, please make one.
Much of this plot-line will return in the remake of "What If Germany Won WW1".
@@MonsieurDean where is it
Honestly we should’ve fought with Germany
that would change history
Everyone in holocaust therapy session:-*cringed tom face*
yes
@@Jerry-tg7zx That fixes that problem. If Germany wins WW1, that means no treaty of Versailles, which means no Hitler rising to power.
@Jerry-tg7zx you do know ww1 and ww2 are 2 different wars
This was a interesting one, did you find anything interesting on What if the Ottoman Empire joined the Entenete instead of the Central Powers?
Bulgaria would be fuged.
Can they gain anything from that?
It wasn't exactly happened because the British declared war on the Ottoman empire for there oil in territory.
How about, "What If The Ottoman Empire Collapsed In The 1880s And Was Replaced By A Modernizing Republic?" [or even just a forward-looking dictatorship?]
@@johnburt7935 that sounds interesting, would the dictatorship keep the legacy of The Ottoman Empire ?
If only Germany could have *proven* that the Lusitania was carrying munitions, which was discovered to be definitely the case nearly a century after the fact, things might have been very different.
Then USA Might Have Joined The Central Powers During WW1 In 1917 (or 1915)
Imagine that if the US really joined the Central powers
A greater United States could have been created, with all of Canada, And the caribbean colonies
We truly live in the darkest timeline
But hopefully this is not the 'dumbfuckistan' version of the US, right?
Maybe if somehow the confederates won the civil war? I think Harry Turtledove wrote a series on that, but idk
@@madmarvshighwaywarrior2870 Not likely
you think America could win against the British in 1918? at the height of it's empire, the Royal Navy was colossal at that point in time. the British in 1918 are very different from the British in 1770's strong enough to subdue 1/3 of the planets landmass and population just remember that.
Isn’t it crazy how the Germans, Austrians/Hungarians and Turks all lost their empires during WW1? Rest In Peace to one of the greatest alliances in the world!
Germans: Omg the Treaty of Versailles was so unfair! I cant even militarize the Rhineland!
What bout you Austria-Hungaria?
Austria: Huh?
Hungary: Huh?
YugoSlavia: What?
Czechoslovakia: Huh?
Germany: Well damn...
@@neat4217 check Treaty of Sevres Lmao
@@neat4217 austria hungaria
@@kasadam85 Imagine whining at the German actions in Belgium but not at the Treaty ofServes lol - US failing at plausible deniability.
@@charmyzard but it’s there fault they started le war
• What if Germany was dismantled/Balkanized after either WW1 or 2?
• What if Habsburg Mexico survived?
• What if the USSR returned to dictatorship/Stalinism in the late 70’s or early 80’s prior to Gorbachev being able to take office?
The ussr was already a dictatorship
Britain: "Destroy this mad brute!"
also Britain: *holds most of the world hostage*
Epic timeline! Imagine how interesting the Old Canadian West would be!
In my humble opinion, this needs a couple more episodes!
Many Americans, especially those of Irish and German ancestry, were opposed to the US entering the war, especially on the side of England.
Woo!
First I think.
Nice concept for a video! How about “What if America and Britain became a dual country.” You’ll probably need to clean up the title, but it’s basically like Britain and America split the world between them. It would also more likely ally them more closely with Germany.
@@skorpthememer1601 *LONG LIVE THE AMERICAN EMPIRE!*
@@skorpthememer1601 No
@Nathaniel Grauel No
@@ls200076 No
Baltimore had a very large German population, with a German language paper, as well as the City Council minutes being published in German. An interesting book loosely connected to this is "The Baltimore Sabotage Cell: German Agents, American Traitors, and the U-boat Deutschland During World War I" by Dwight Messimer. It is about a then active German plot in the city during the war with German-American Sympathizers.
As a Marylander who likes history, I didn’t know this
The reason Baltimore did have a German cell was due to Baltimore being a supply hub for ships supplying Britain. Not because of its German-American population, which wasn’t even that big. It’s ridiculous of you to claim or even just suggest that the German-Americans would have plotted against the USA in an attempt to help the German Empire. Their homeland was America - and especially German-American had been among the greatest American patriots. And don’t forget that the Germans did leave Germany BECAUSE of the fact that Germany was being ruled by a monarchist feudal system and to some extent even because it was ruled/controlled by Prussia. But the German-Americans of course were not sympathetic to the whole unconditional anti-German propaganda hysteria since they themselves did become victims of that (This anti-German propaganda actually generalized all german-americans as being potential German agents simply for being of German ancestry - similar to what you’re saying in your comment - simply because they wouldn’t declare that Germany would be evil like the mainstream media of the time did and also still spoke their native tongue of German).
And to refer to those Americans that did help the German cell as American traitors seems a bit far-fetched considering that the US hasn’t even entered the war at that time and still continued to declare itself as being neutral. And they solely sabotaged privately owned and british ships. I mean what about those Americans did support their respective countries of ancestry other than Germany?
Monsieur Z: "But what if that changed?"
Domino's Ad: "Go on, mix it up a little!"
...well okay then, I see Domino's is a fan.
“And I think to myself: what a wonderful world”
Yeah!!! Another remake of my old WW1 favourites.
USA + central powers = paradise.
Why?
The good timeline
@horacioelconserjeopina3956 well the British and French empires would have been obliterated
Have you ever considered doing a 'What if the Knights Templar colonized America'?
Last time I was this early south africa collapsed after apartheid
It still is. Horrible place. They’re burning down farms now. 😢
@@lucasvanvuuren5619 :(
This the one of the world that I wished to live in. :)
Same
British Empire ball Yep. :D
Typical cuddled westerners. You dont even know how horrific it is to live in an authoritarian fascist state. Its insane you would all say this smh.
@Nathan Santoro Yeah lets live in an authoritarian dictatorship and have no rights so there will be no SJWs wow what a great trade off... idiots. Typical useful idiots that would give up all their hard earned freedoms for basically nothing. The founding fathers would spit on you.
Not me
I wanna go to this timeline and hear whatever album Sabaton writes about it.
Screaming Eagles 2.0
Wilson would never act against Britain, his main adviser Colonel House, had major ties to British officials. House was also the son of a British block runner for the CSA; and not to mention that he was in England at the time of Wilson’s inauguration.
Based on this video, it sounds like the US should have sided with Germany in WWI.
If wilson had more say in negotiations like you mentioned I dont think a reverse versailles treaty would happen. Wilson did not like how crippled it made germany and had made its own separate negotiations so I think the same could be applied to this alternate history.
This is a couple of years old, but I just watched it for the first time. Really enjoyed it.
Wilson wanted to enter the war. The banking cartels that installed him into office wanted war because financing the American War machine would've been very profitable for them. The banking cartels were funding both sides of the war already and the US entering and needing to ramp up war efforts would be a wind fall. The same strategy was followed in WW2. The US waited, funded both sides until it decided to join the side that owed us the most money.
God I love this channel so much. This man puts so much time and effort in his research and picks some of the most interesting time periods and events. I have so much respect for you keep it up!
Glad you enjoy our work!
Great video. I appreciate it how you explained all facts of the Lusitania-incident and not only the Entente version.
Thank you! Commonly misunderstood moments like those deserve total explanation.
Ah, now that seems like a good ol' American victory to me bois
France: we have made several advances,we may stand a chance in this war!
*Stars and stripes starts playing*
France: aw fuck-
"What if 2001 Indian Parliament attack was successful?"- trust me this scenario could'hv reshaped geopolitics forever, in Asia and in elsewhere.
What would happened in alternate timeline apart from forever killing peace between Delhi and Karachi?
Certainly would like to see a part two
The Empire of Japan vs. The US
The Pacific War
pacific war would’ve happened regardless
we shouldve been in the central powers, we would've been way more powerful
Based
The Central Powers were the real good guys
No good or bad guys in ww1 but in ww2 its obviously the axis
@w h y my man spitting fact Here
Those good guys caused war and killed like 17 milion or so peoples in just 4 years
@@vuktodic1356 yeah it's war
@@moonagaming6068 that could be avoided
Nobody asked germany to support austria in whatever the hell they were doing in balkans
They did that so they could make a war
Russia would back up serbia let them to deal with austria alone and then austria gets some sence knocked into them
Let russia to grow for decade or two and you get industrialized gigantic sized country that can beat up germany
Either way germany is a sore loser if they do not do something and that something had to happen then and there
Russia was maybe doing poorly for some decades but by 1910 or so they were growing something like china these days
It was german fear russia literally had 100 milion more peoples in 1914 and their population was growing faster just like economy was and they were getting industrialized
They were predicting it good by 1930 s russia would have like population of like over 250 milion peoples their industry just like economy would be bigger than german and their army like navy would be modernized with infrastructure germany had no hope to win the war against russia after that
Germany did not have anythint with austria and serbia only thing they worried about was french and russia growth (mainly russian) which would put them in a bad position
They could not let russia to simply eat up austria because then germany would be alone against russia and france who would be stronger
What if William Jennings Bryan was elected President of the United States in 1912?
That's so horrifying I don't even want to think about it in anyway shape or form.
@@adamhauskins6407 Why
@@robertisham5279 free silver mostly, plus focusing on being an agrarian state instead of an industrial one plus a lot of other stuff like prohibition
Wow, a scenario where someone could actually see Willson as a "good guy"... ah, who am I kidding, he probably still did all the stuff that people gate him for today.
Still, I like this outcome. While the future looks grim as another world war is guaranteed, I see that this world has less far-reaching downsides. Things like the PRC, Islamic Terrorism, and a massive Cold War between Democracy and Communism can never really happen to the scale that it happened in our timeline. I can be said that this would is slightly better, as there is less unrest in the wider parts of the world, but that entirely depends on who wins this new second world war.
@Stephen Jenkins You are correct in that there would be a second world war due to radical ideologies in France and Britain, I was going for "there would be no cold war where both sides have nukes"
A few things I would bring up is that Britain relied heavily on their imports from their colonies, thus with the loss of influence over their colonies either due to their freedom after the war or them distancing themselves from Britain after the ideological shift (which I will admit is unlikely as the entire Empire would share similar sentiments without US interference to bring say Austrailia into their sphere of Influence)
For France the case is more severe, as compared to their Land rival of Germany, their raw resources and industry pale in comparison even if they undertook a Stalin-like plan for massive industrialization, raw resources are sparse without trading with other powers, which they would with Britain.
Should the Ottoman Empire collapse (eventually it would) it will end up splitting along ethnic lines, compared to France and Britain drawing lines on a map and saying good. I recognize that there is the possibility for radical ideologies to mix with their religious nature, and to cause problems that way, but I was probably going for the "it's not a natural powderkeg area" route as there isn't countries with mixed ethnic groups fighting each other constantly.
For US isolationism, yeah that would be a problem. And without very strong economic ties to Germany in terms of helping fund their war effort and getting caught in the crossfire, they are even more unlikely to join than in our world's US.
In the end, this world would only be slightly different from our own, its merely a matter of perspective on how you think the world will carry on from this point.
Wilson wasn’t a good guy dude
Na
This reminds me a lot of the Southern Victory series by Harry Turtledove, an alternate history series that diverges from the American Civil War and sees events very similar to what you described here happen.
That's true Only this Scenario The US is United not divided like in Turtledoves Series With the Confederate States being Allies with UK and France Russia and USA North joins the Central Powers and wins
So it would be a Easy Win for the US since 1917 Everyone was Exhausted from War
Think about it Hitler or his American Counterpart Jake would have never Rose to power since their Countries would have won
One of the biggest misunderstandings of people of our time is confusing the Germany of world war I and the Germany of world war II.
What if America stad neutral during the whole war
That's what we should've done and the same for ww2.
Farhan Mckinnons yea
@@Tatusiek_1 Uh no
@Вук Тодић Entente wouldn’t have won and German wouldn’t have gotten beaten up
@Вук Тодић WW2 would still most likely happen
Britain: you were supposed to destroy the Germany not join them! Bring balance to the europe, not leave it in ruins! You were by brother us, I loved you
Us: haha us go stronk
Wilson's points were set in the context of the US joining the Entente. Wouldn't it make more sense for the US to propose different points targeted toward Britain and France?
No it wouldn’t
The New Prussia map is fucking hilarous! Did the person who made it really think Germany would name cities Götterdämmerung(...?), Wienerschnitzelplatz, Hoch (up in the north) and Prosit or did he just run out of more realistic names?
6:19
Germany still has a monarchy. Britain's monarchy reduced in stature. Austria-Hungary would still split (again). More high school students would be taught German. No Hitler, no Holocaust. Lusitania would still be sunk.
I still stand with this scenario, What if Germany was broken up after world war 1?
I’m honestly surprised that didn’t happen in real life. It would seem like the logical thing to do. If not at that time then certainly after WW2.
Because it breaks the balance of power. France and russia would dominate the small states.
England does not like strong empires on the continent. German or french.
@@timvanrijn8239 The Romans left us with a sour taste...and now we have the European Union...Or is that the 4th Reich?
@@timvanrijn8239 I mean, your talking about realism here, And when it comes to Alternate history, there doesn't need to be any. I just thought it would be a fun scenario.
@@morsecode980 Just imagine you would split the USA into all of its states, don't you think it is clear that they will try to become a country again? The majority were proud to be German. After the First World War it would be likely that someone like Adolf Hitler would try to fight for reunification again.
There would also be a risk that Germany would have continued to fight the war, because that way they would lose everything anyway. After the Second World War, it is the same situation, but you also wanted a strong trading partner against the Soviet Union. Germany clearly lost the war and there was no longer any need to split it up.
Greetings from Germany :)
I just clicked and I'm already pleased
Simply stopping all trade going to the Entente would be a crippling enough blow to the war effort. Britain could try and blockade America which wouldn't work on a country which produced 90% of its own goods.
How come every video you make would make a great Hearts of Iron IV overhaul mod, with enough worldbuilding and more parts to this scenario or ones like it, mods like kaiserreich would have nothing on your scenarios
Well thanks, pal! If you know any mod makers, I'd like to reach out to some, and make the bigger scenarios something people can play.
Britain has dominated so much of world history that all alternative timelines basically just come down to "but what if the british lost?"
So many chances to have a better future(except ww2 ofc) then lol
15:04 what I'd probably see is Britain, France and Italy going Communist together with Soviets because especially in France and Italy Communism and Socialism were widespread and popular ideas in our timeline and now with them losing the war the last thing keeping the Revolution at bay would be lost. The Revolutions would probably happen across the 1920s as Germany, America, Austria and the Ottoman Empire would partition the remaining colonies among themselves in the chaos.
Anglophile Wilson is never turning on the British
What if Alexander Hamilton was never killed in the duel with Aaron Burr? And became president?
America: 7 Bitches Gonna Die Tonight
Entene: *Screeming*
I just noticed that your voice has gotten deeper and more serious compared to you more light hearted and critical voice from before.
For April fools or just for a fun video, you should do "What if The German Empire lost the Weltkrieg"
Like, from the perspective of a Kaiserreich scenario of if they won, discussing a Fuherreich-like scenario of if they lost the war
This is a good alternate history and I would enjoy a few more episodes going through the Depression (if it happens), the Cold War up to Covid-19.
May I make a request?
May you reupload your "What if Rapture from Bioshock was real" video please?
Would you kindly?
I can't find it anywhere anymore I believe it was deleted at some point.
It would be nice to see it again.
What if Hong Kong became America's 51st state
Mathieu Leader YES!
If it was that easy, Taiwan would already be the 51st state.
@@maninredhelm the only thing stopping it is the international community and congress failing to do it's job. annexation is not legal but referendum for joining other countries is legal as well as succeeding from countries by referendum .
@@Maulstrum97 I dont think Taiwan wants to be a state of the US
@@arandomlanguagenerd1869 Sure beats the other option of returning to China though. Region should stay independent.
Are we going to ignore how dope that flag is?
How about this? Central Powers strategy is to initially fight a purely defensive war on the Western Front, allowing the British and French to sacrifice as many men against German trenches as they want, while focusing the offense against Russia in the East. Russia is defeated by before the end of 1916.
Germany then decides any gains in the West would come at a steep price, or maybe the USA threatens to enter the war if Germany doesn't agree to peace. The war ends with a Central Powers victory over Russia and a draw in the west.
What does the peace settlement look like? What happens the rest of the 20th century?
0:30 caption says: “The meeting of the glorious Hungarian and Bulgarian armies at Kladovo on October 27, 1915”. :D
One idea I came up with involved the explosives on board the Lusitania to go off in an American port. The Germans had put out a notice in the papers that the ship wascarrying munitions and was therefore a valid target. With the explosion and evidence from any investigation made, relations with Britain would be seriously hurt. The Germans if they were smart would try to gain sympathy by pointing out that they had warned Americans of Britain's violation of their neutrality.
*USA allied with Germany*
UK: It was a prank Germany I don’t want war with you
Germany: yeah... A prank by starving my people by blockade... Very good one🗿
Tl;DW : The world would be a MUCH better place if America had joined the Central Powers.
If America lost the revolution it would be a utopia
@@rubycooly2009 No it wouldn’t
Wtfdym
Nah
US should have sided with Germany in WWI.
USA: *Joins Central Powers*
USN, IJN, and KMS: it’s boat tim
RN: *Chuckles* I’m in danger
The novel series Southern Victory does have the United States as an ally of the German Empire in response because Britain and France allied and recognized the Confederate States of America as an Independent Nation and does fight on the side of the Central Powers-resulting in a Central Powers victory.
Royal Navy would quickly devastate the US east coast. A large, battle-hardened combined empire force would land in Canada against the US. Germans take Paris and negotiate a separate peace like they did with Russia. Possibly of British armistice favouring German European and colonial uptake. British empire faces down the US through 1919.
I dont think the royal navy would completely stomp the us navy that easily, even back then
the us navy was quite large in ww1 the British still need to keep up the blockade
@@gottliebgamer2783 do you have a source about the strength of the us navy? I know the army was pretty weak back then but i know the us navy was second only to the royal navy back then
To adress OPs accessment, the UK would have a two front naval war to contend with in the event of the us joining the central powers. It would not be easy for the royal navy to control the us's side of the atlantic
@@DylanJo123 The US Navy had only recently started a rapid expansion in 1916. However training standards was at such a low point that the British Navy actively refused to allow US ships to sail alongside the Grand Fleet's blockade until they were trained up to British standards.
The US had 14 Battleships and Germany had 24. Britain alone has 42. France, Italy and Russia adds in 13. Japan adds in 8.
This is only in capital ship numbers, if we go into light ships then the US was woefully unprepared having absolutely no long range cruisers for scouting, and severely lacking in any destroyers.
In the interwar period it seems like both the US and UK's plan was for Canada to fall to the US and fight to a draw otherwise. Canada had ambitious plans of its own doomed to failure.
What if napoleon bonaparte accepted the frankfurt proposals in 1813 after the battle of Leipzig
The coalition would have declared war three month after, as always
America joins the war: War time
Entente: (silence) Help.
What if Stonewall Jackson had survived to serve under Robert E. Lee at Gettysburg?
Sounds good to me.🎉
Maybe we should've joined the Central Powers...
yes
You should do a mega alt history scenario like the mcu but for alt history with a bunch of different scenarios combined into one big scenario.
Also what if barry goldwater won in 1964
1:33 Oh wow I was at that castle during my trip to Ukraine a few years ago. It’s called Kaminets Podilsky. I had no idea that this photograph existed or even that so many German soldiers walked down that same bridge I crossed.
For anyone wanting to straight come to the point :
Skip to 6:30
Thx