Carl Sagan on UFO’s - “Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 195

  • @dannykrinkle4726
    @dannykrinkle4726 Рік тому +210

    Still the gold standard of critical thinking in a world that's getting dumber by the minute. Sagan was a true treasure.

    • @skepticalbeliever5001
      @skepticalbeliever5001 9 місяців тому

      Just wait until you learn he actually knew it was true the entire time. Can't help but wonder if you'll still have him on a pedestal after that.

    • @TruthDissident
      @TruthDissident 8 місяців тому

      ​@@skepticalbeliever5001Bullshit. Show some proof please.

    • @PurpleNoir
      @PurpleNoir 5 місяців тому +15

      @skepticalbeliever5001 Bro……..you literally provided a fine example of what the OG commented just said.

    • @Loralanthalas
      @Loralanthalas 4 місяці тому

      You're speaking of a time when blondes were airheads and women would ACTUALLY be proud they didn't know how to do anything but raise kids and shunded anywomen who would even TRY to have an opinion on something. Go to Oklahoma: you can still find this shit.

    • @Tenebrous227
      @Tenebrous227 3 місяці тому +6

      ​@PurpleNoir Lol they really did

  • @SUPREME-SCIENCE
    @SUPREME-SCIENCE Рік тому +52

    THE BEST TEACHER I NEVER HAD.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @user-oy7oq2pw8h
    @user-oy7oq2pw8h Рік тому +35

    Carl always says interesting and purposeful things.

  • @ethzero
    @ethzero 3 місяці тому +3

    Nostalgic for the time when empirical evidence was respected and debate was honest and open. Hopefully humanity will circle back to that one day.

    • @Bluesmiley05
      @Bluesmiley05 2 місяці тому

      Science is important but winning elections is importanter

  • @user-qs1ii5br7f
    @user-qs1ii5br7f 3 місяці тому +2

    “A stolen logbook of the ships, captain” this guy is amazing. Love and respect his intelligence..

  • @DMC1982
    @DMC1982 Рік тому +25

    RIP one of the greatest minds ever

  • @Rhodri101283
    @Rhodri101283 Рік тому +61

    The contempt in his voice when he says the word ‘abducted’ is a thing of beauty.

  • @joyceroberts6979
    @joyceroberts6979 Рік тому +20

    Carl Sagan was magnificent, concise, thorough and to the point no matter what he was saying! What a treasure he was!

  • @kreb7
    @kreb7 Рік тому +31

    Despite everyone carrying a camera with capabilities unthinkable in his time still no evidence.

    • @bunnyban5365
      @bunnyban5365 Рік тому +2

      You must be dumb as a rock
      cameras we have right now are not good at capturing fast moving objects

    • @ViceZone
      @ViceZone 11 місяців тому +3

      Try taking a close-up photo of a fly in mid-flight. That's how hard it is to photograph UFOs.

    • @kreb7
      @kreb7 11 місяців тому +11

      @nextgengaming2077 don't you think a bit strange with the exponential increase of available camera phones and quality improvements that they is less "evidence" now than they used to be.

    • @bunnyban5365
      @bunnyban5365 11 місяців тому

      @@kreb7 camera phones are absolute shit quality please do not speak if you don't know

    • @SmartAss4123
      @SmartAss4123 9 місяців тому

      Idk why people think their phones can hold up to actual military satelites systems and fucking NORAD tracking.
      Which one do you think is more likely to catch anything screwing around our solar system let alone on the planet itself

  • @eugenedegeorge5084
    @eugenedegeorge5084 3 місяці тому +2

    Carl sagan was the best. I've always said.
    If there are intelligent beings capable of flying through space, they would want to make themselves known.Just as when we send explorers into space we don't try to hide behind rocks and things we are out there looking to make contact.

    • @featofclay2295
      @featofclay2295 2 місяці тому +1

      Or perhaps, if they’re “intelligent”, they don’t want to make contact because they’re aware of the malice and egomania that plague the human race. If I were a visitor from another world, I sure as shit wouldn’t want to park my spacecraft within any proximity of a repugnant human.

  • @novakingood3788
    @novakingood3788 Рік тому +18

    Yes, it's good to have an open mind, but not so open that your brain falls out.

    • @wildgoosedreaming1
      @wildgoosedreaming1 11 місяців тому

      Or is taken out.
      And served on crackers with olives and little toothpicks.

    • @johngavin1175
      @johngavin1175 6 місяців тому +2

      Like the flat earthers?

  • @user-em9tb2ob9c
    @user-em9tb2ob9c 9 місяців тому +11

    Would love to hear Sagan's thoughts on the current UFO situation. I'm sure they would be fair and insightful.
    Edit: I understand that UFO does not mean alien. :)

    • @ClickDecision
      @ClickDecision 4 місяці тому +2

      Ufo ≠ aliens

    • @pb5640
      @pb5640 3 місяці тому +3

      I’m sure his opinion it would be the same! The “new stuff” is not compelling either.

    • @deehlgrm9379
      @deehlgrm9379 2 місяці тому +1

      UFO doesnt mean Alien .

  • @echoecho3108
    @echoecho3108 Рік тому +32

    I miss Carl Sagan, and his Cosmos.
    NDT canNot touch him.

    • @johnvestil3789
      @johnvestil3789 Рік тому +7

      NDT and Druyan continued Sagan’s Cosmos, and by no means wanted to be better than the original. It’s a continuation.

    • @mofire5674
      @mofire5674 Рік тому +3

      Well yeah Sagan seems like someone who'd actually listen to you in a conversation v.s NDT who clearly just wants to one-up everyone.

    • @eldino1504
      @eldino1504 Рік тому +2

      But I miss Carl Sagan and cosmos as much as you

    • @echoecho3108
      @echoecho3108 Рік тому

      @@mofire5674 😊👍

  • @ramibhaf1
    @ramibhaf1 Рік тому +4

    This great to hear you. Thank for peace of mind!?

    • @HxTurtle
      @HxTurtle Рік тому

      he can't hear you anymore, though. 😉

  • @clownhands
    @clownhands 3 місяці тому +1

    I miss Carl and also wonder what he would have said of the David Fraver “tic tak” story and video.

  • @orvarino
    @orvarino 9 місяців тому +2

    Sagans Standard - one of the Razors to know, in conjunction with Hitchen's and Occam’s. If I was to teach my two daughters three things - thees would be the three mind rules I would pass on.

  • @whitworth5s248
    @whitworth5s248 Рік тому +6

    This man once blew up the earth simply because a baker made him a pie that was too crumbly. If the man says there's no aliens, don't argue with him.

    • @wardog5537
      @wardog5537 Рік тому +1

      He never said there weren't aliens. He just said that there is insufficient evidence for him to believe so; and that was in regards to "if we have ever been visited". The man believed in aliens. He helped convince Congress to send a satellite out into space with messages embossed in gold from Earth greeting any species that would find it

    • @mail2cmuthu
      @mail2cmuthu Рік тому +3

      he isn't talking about existence of aliens lol... he is talking about alien visits to the Earth!

  • @JC-zw9vs
    @JC-zw9vs 3 місяці тому

    Interesting fact Carl Sagan was lead singer of Talking Heads.
    Lol

  • @MrVin247
    @MrVin247 3 місяці тому +2

    Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence

  • @-Kailinn-
    @-Kailinn- 3 місяці тому +1

    But my great great great great grandfather's dog was abducted by aliens and he'd never lie!

  • @davep8221
    @davep8221 3 місяці тому

    If only everyone back then had been carrying megapixel cameras with full video recording capability we'd have all the proof we need... wonder why they stopped coming.

  • @garrisonthad
    @garrisonthad 3 місяці тому

    Brilliant guy.

  • @Sleepingbear2222
    @Sleepingbear2222 Рік тому +5

    I wonder what he would have thought of watching the U.S. Navy fighter jet in 2014 filming a tic-Tacom shaped object flying through the sky and water?

  • @mohamedmekawy5044
    @mohamedmekawy5044 Рік тому +3

    ❤️❤️

  • @dan797
    @dan797 3 місяці тому

    👍🏼rest in peace

  • @denverbeek
    @denverbeek 5 місяців тому

    Turn on like visibility.

  • @Machistmo
    @Machistmo 3 місяці тому

    Legendary

  • @JazzzMonsterr
    @JazzzMonsterr 3 місяці тому

    Look at the size of those monster ears

  • @Aaron-og2wx
    @Aaron-og2wx 3 місяці тому +2

    That's exactly what a alien living amongst us would say! 😮

  • @tcuisix
    @tcuisix 3 місяці тому

    I believe aliens exist out there. But we'll never make it out of this solar system to meet them

  • @DeuceGenius
    @DeuceGenius 3 місяці тому

    I like what he said when he was much younger. But ya, what he said

  • @loisfolk5492
    @loisfolk5492 6 місяців тому

    Later, he said in an interview, I think on Johnny Carson that it would be arrogant to think that we are the only ones in the universe. I think the government stifled him.

    • @junethanoschurchill6750
      @junethanoschurchill6750 3 місяці тому

      Both can be true. It is very likely that there is life in other parts of the universe, however it is also very unlikely that they have been able to visit us. The universe is a mind-bogglingly big place, and life is probably just spread too far apart to visit each other.

  • @tonyharris7953
    @tonyharris7953 3 місяці тому

    Opinions lay between knowledge and ignorance.

  • @kentdavies1988
    @kentdavies1988 3 місяці тому

    Clearly this man has never watched Ancient Aliens

  • @thill9k
    @thill9k Рік тому

    Well... no one's perfect 😂

  • @Saganswrld2190
    @Saganswrld2190 7 місяців тому

    If only you were with us today Sagan! You would be in for a surprise

  • @daveken9936
    @daveken9936 3 місяці тому

    Apply this to every religion on earth if you dare..not one would survive.

  • @UXSpecialist
    @UXSpecialist 6 місяців тому

    I like how he talks 😂

  • @nazimsayed4834
    @nazimsayed4834 Рік тому

    Did Carl sagan just say "god knows what else"????

  • @MitchSwanson
    @MitchSwanson 3 місяці тому

    And the United States Government Military denied the fact that UFO's existed for over 70 yrs and now we now different. Perhaps Carl Sagan was under pressure to say this about that then :)

  • @stancartmankenny
    @stancartmankenny Рік тому +5

    They did get the logbook. It's called "to serve man". Which proves they just want to help us.

    • @jasondauenbaugh9060
      @jasondauenbaugh9060 Рік тому +3

      To serve man was a great episode.

    • @_JustinCase_
      @_JustinCase_ Рік тому +3

      You are traveling through another dimension, a dimension not only of sight and sound but of mind.

    • @MrT------5743
      @MrT------5743 Рік тому +2

      Aliens write in English?

    • @wildgoosedreaming1
      @wildgoosedreaming1 11 місяців тому +3

      ​@@jasondauenbaugh9060Originally a short story by Diamond Knight. First published in late 1950.

    • @wildgoosedreaming1
      @wildgoosedreaming1 11 місяців тому

      ​@@MrT------5743 No. The man who stole the 'log book' learned the alien's language and he and a colleague translated it.

  • @RedWinePlease
    @RedWinePlease 3 місяці тому

    With millions of cameras --- almost every adult and most teens own and carry cameras everywhere they go, yet, none has taken pictures of the Loch Ness monster, Yeti's, Sasquatch, Lizard men, floating gurus, flying saucers, ghosts. There should be thousands of photos of each.
    All myths, like angels, devils, gremlins, mystical healings, the sun stops it's movement, giants are made up to satisfy man's need to imagine the unreal.

  • @billmitchell2080
    @billmitchell2080 3 місяці тому

    A light-year is quite far in time and space to a human. We live in the countryside of our Galaxy, if we lived near the center of our Galaxy things may be different.

  • @DLQ33..
    @DLQ33.. Рік тому

    Wow

  • @Bob-cj6zm
    @Bob-cj6zm 6 місяців тому

    I wonder what he would say about the recent videos and photographs released by the US military. The truth is out there 🛸

  • @chiapagringa
    @chiapagringa 3 місяці тому

    Crummy claims, folks!

  • @deeda3332
    @deeda3332 6 місяців тому +1

    Such a great thinker and so interesting to listen to but Let me explain where he is wrong in this instance and i make this claim based on his own thinking.
    First let me tell you a short story as someone who used to deer hunt. When finding a spot in the woods to set up your tree stand you look around and visualize where deer might come in from and set your tree stand angle up accordingly. Yet so often that deer comes in from an area you never dreamed it would and is on the wrong side. Well if the deer steps up to your bate pile good for you but this doesn't always happen. With that said, Carl and many other so called experts have all said we probably wouldn't understand anything about any intelligence that may have the ability to visit us. To make a long story short, Carl is making 2 mistakes. First he is imagining what a visitation would look like and he is deciding that those who have made claims to have witnessed something they believe to be alien are mistaken. I've never seen anything i considered to be a ufo or alien but i did see a bird fly above me that was the size of a small plane with its wings spread out. Everyone says you must be mistaken but i know what i saw not because i wanna believe it but because i did indeed see it. It was just above the trees and was just about 50 feet high so low enough to certainly comprehend what it was and how large. We can never be sure what an invasion or simple visitation would look like or where or how it would come. I hope someone understands this because it may help to see things outside the box and when you can see outside the boxn your vision is much better.

  • @SuperAlienGhost
    @SuperAlienGhost 3 місяці тому

    Mr. Square

  • @RolieVerSinganon-es8lr
    @RolieVerSinganon-es8lr 3 місяці тому

    I believe that there are other beings somewhere in the universe, but I think that they are just so so far away from our planet, and when they'll reach our solar system earth is already gone..

  • @tagquasar8791
    @tagquasar8791 3 місяці тому

    When intelligence wasnt called woke

  • @xLakai.
    @xLakai. 3 місяці тому

    Captain kirk?

  • @Mustang-bk4ns
    @Mustang-bk4ns Рік тому +1

    Good for Sagan. If you're a bad guy that wants to make people disappear then "alien abduction" is helpful.
    The same with strange deaths. Blame "aliens" that enter and leave the planet is helpful too. 🤔💯

  • @intelligentpeople6533
    @intelligentpeople6533 3 місяці тому

    If the world 🌍 ever needed a world leader, this would be the guy.

  • @fivehundrediq5212
    @fivehundrediq5212 10 місяців тому

    A stolen logbook of the alien captain

  • @Kgio-2112
    @Kgio-2112 3 місяці тому

    Those ears! Wowza!!

    • @thefinestsake1660
      @thefinestsake1660 3 місяці тому

      One day, when you are old, your ears will be wowza too! Cartilage continues to grow your whole life.
      👂 -> 🦻

    • @Kgio-2112
      @Kgio-2112 3 місяці тому +1

      @@thefinestsake1660 i know, but until then... Wowza!!

    • @thefinestsake1660
      @thefinestsake1660 3 місяці тому

      @@Kgio-2112 lol!

  • @mudkipfan2420
    @mudkipfan2420 6 місяців тому

    Same treatment with claims of religion

  • @jeffclaterbaugh3962
    @jeffclaterbaugh3962 7 місяців тому

    The Celebration of Ignorance is in Full Bloom !

  • @UKLIVENews2017HD4K
    @UKLIVENews2017HD4K 11 місяців тому

    It's jus military weapons we don't know exist just like sr71 blackbird

  • @5cloudwalker
    @5cloudwalker Рік тому

    Its good he had an open mind too bad he never witnessed a UFO I’d be interested to see what his opinion would be if he say one.

  • @ibidesign
    @ibidesign Рік тому

    Not the message he had in earlier years.

  • @ayrsine
    @ayrsine 3 місяці тому

    And because he said that it makes it true? Cool story bro.

  • @manjeetkr.9003
    @manjeetkr.9003 3 місяці тому

    😅

  • @shawnyfin
    @shawnyfin 3 місяці тому

    Nor is there evidence for Nessie or Bigfoot. Yet people believe in them....usually these are the people that give churchfolk a hard time about evidence.. 😂

  • @rantym35
    @rantym35 10 місяців тому +5

    Our brain is too limited to see the invisible

  • @chrisneves1274
    @chrisneves1274 3 місяці тому

    His ear has a mouth

  • @u2tipsy
    @u2tipsy 6 місяців тому

    Visited? Been here way before us. Revisiting for replenishing supplies seems logical. Maybe an evaluation of our progress. A lot of E.T. heads are a shakin'!

  • @Moonman63
    @Moonman63 3 місяці тому

    You could wait for better evidence or get a dumber audience.

  • @jeanne2b2b22
    @jeanne2b2b22 3 місяці тому

    Appatently he did meet or read about two government employees from 1965 (teacher + postman, a middle aged couple married to each other). Their sudden severe insomnia lead to many medical doctor visits, finding nothing wrong, that one dr suggest they try hypnosis, and thats when it was accidentally revealed one night they where abducted from the car, while being separately inspected, the teacher's abilities kicked in and asked many questions of their captures, of which one showed her the constellation they traveled from. Originally no one took them seriously until 40 years later NASA discovered a new constellation that match planet for planet what the teachet drew up. So today it considered true, THE BETTY AND BARNY HILL abduction in the state of New Hamphshire.

  • @YeahNoTellTheTruth
    @YeahNoTellTheTruth 6 місяців тому

    Way ahead of his time. His intelligence is so evident. Look at todays youtubers and supposed geniuses like Elon, raging, shouting, getting emotional.

    • @zufalllx
      @zufalllx 5 місяців тому

      General intelligence and emotions have no correlation.

  • @wardog5537
    @wardog5537 Рік тому +1

    Wonder what he would say after watching those 2017 DoD videos they let the public see

    • @penguincommando
      @penguincommando Рік тому +1

      And people proved aliens exist from those?

    • @wardog5537
      @wardog5537 Рік тому

      Those videos prove that there is science out there that we don't fully understand.. and we still don't know what controls them. And watch the videos again, there was a craft that enters the ocean at incredible speeds with no backsplash. I believe it was filmed by an f-18

  • @AlessandroCalzaStudio
    @AlessandroCalzaStudio Рік тому +1

    This absurd idea that if aliens exist they would so want to come visit us it's so childish and ridiculous

    • @missyaman7053
      @missyaman7053 Рік тому +1

      They would probably want to come to visit us if they have scientists who might be interested in our planet. But I don't think they'll make it some secretive mission to abduct some ppl lol if they're advanced enough to come here then they won't care about our borders and politics.

    • @user-em9tb2ob9c
      @user-em9tb2ob9c 9 місяців тому +1

      Why is that idea absurd? Have you ever visited a zoo? We are a highly intelligent, space-faring civilisation. We have art, literature, music, science and a beautiful & diverse planet. Regardless of their level of intelligence, of course they would would want to come and visit/observe us. Neil deGrasse Tyson is dead wrong on this one.

    • @zufalllx
      @zufalllx 5 місяців тому

      What's childish and ridiculous is thinking they would have no interest, when our own actions are an indicator that the opposite is far more likely.

  • @lauriefrancisco1084
    @lauriefrancisco1084 Рік тому +2

    I'd love to know what he'd think now with the release of the naval air footage, etc.

    • @chrisp3083
      @chrisp3083 10 місяців тому

      The same thing Neil DeGrasse Tyson and Brian Cox said today. Look it up, they think it is not good evidence and they were students of Carl Sagan's philosophy.

    • @user-em9tb2ob9c
      @user-em9tb2ob9c 9 місяців тому

      @@chrisp3083 Maybe not evidence, but if the US government openly admits they have observed UFOs (vessels) moving in ways beyond our ability and comprehension, then this should dilute our skepticism considerably. And Brian Cox actually said "it is possible". Tyson said aliens would not be interested in us...which is just silly considering our tech, culture, etc.

  • @ghstletter5978
    @ghstletter5978 3 місяці тому

    Carl Sagan definitely had high government clearance to know those are all military crafts lool

    • @Truther2001
      @Truther2001 3 місяці тому +1

      All the more reason for him to dismiss it

  • @IRM-cm2ic
    @IRM-cm2ic 6 місяців тому

    He is lying here, but he was part of the system.

  • @lane8534
    @lane8534 Рік тому

    "Promo sm" 👏

  • @frankligas2249
    @frankligas2249 3 місяці тому

    I knew this guy. He was a lying traitor. He knew darn well the truth. He sold mankind out for cash and lots of it. Very few people inflicted more damage or harm on mankind than this guy. I'm glad he's gone.

  • @KyleMcCourt
    @KyleMcCourt 11 місяців тому +1

    But Carl Sagan DID believe in UFO’s and aliens. His job was at risk if he talked about it

    • @chrisp3083
      @chrisp3083 10 місяців тому +3

      He talked about UFOs and aliens every day of his life. He just saw no evidence of aliens visiting Earth even if they have which is obviously a debate these days. And, UFO has the word "Unidentified" in it. What job would he lose anyway? He was an Astrophysicist who would jump at the chance at real proof.

  • @burkeburper
    @burkeburper Рік тому +5

    I think his opinion would be very different today.

    • @damachine3
      @damachine3 Рік тому +13

      Why? Based on what evidence?

    • @djaa7
      @djaa7 Рік тому +3

      Say what now?

    • @rpwatkins99
      @rpwatkins99 Рік тому +1

      So what his opinions be, and what makes you rhink you know?

    • @jasondauenbaugh9060
      @jasondauenbaugh9060 Рік тому

      After the military videos came out your probably right.

    • @damachine3
      @damachine3 Рік тому +3

      @@jasondauenbaugh9060 I was waiting for someone to bring those up. I don't think that would be enough to convince Carl Sagan. My guess is he would assume that was secret Earthling technology.

  • @808bigisland
    @808bigisland Рік тому +1

    He is lying

  • @Edgar_Randolph
    @Edgar_Randolph Рік тому

    Hmmmm. This is the first time I find myself in dispute with ol' Carl. To me, the cases of Travis Walton & Betty (& Barney) Hill are evidence enough. Some lies, fakes, are too extraordinary to be conceivable. So in the end both those cases are literally inexplicable, certainly not conclusive to be simply seen as lies

    • @Edgar_Randolph
      @Edgar_Randolph Рік тому +3

      @Kombat Kompanion That's pretty rude. Yes, maybe if you make an effort to understand those particular cases you'll understand a bit more. Try learning something before writing. Important advice for you personally

    • @bunnyban5365
      @bunnyban5365 Рік тому

      @@KombatKompanion-yd2cumaybe you should open your mind a little bit more instead of being a close minded jerk

  • @consciousobserver377
    @consciousobserver377 6 місяців тому

    So we now know he was wrong!!

    • @ClickDecision
      @ClickDecision 4 місяці тому

      There is not compelling evidence. Ffs grow a brain

  • @DMC1982
    @DMC1982 Рік тому +1

    RIP one of the greatest minds ever