I adore your fantastic videos. The one you guys did for Batman. I still come back and rewatch that one every once in a while. It’s a really good video. I’ve been waiting for you to do a fan casting of X-Men and I have to say just like I do it With Your Batman, When You Said, Ben Barnes. I totally agree with you guys. Elizabeth Gillies, as rogue would be absolutely amazing.
Also, before I forget, Hassie Harrison and her husband absolutely convince me as gambit and rogue and I kind of want a certain someone to grow a beard now 😉😎
I don't want Milly out of this entire list. She to me moreso than Anya is becoming the face we see everywhere. Out of this last I have the most exposure to Victoria Pedretti and Keke Palmer and I really think either of them could pull it off. I think Keke has an energy that could match Channing well both on set and on screen as we watch it. I think capturing that is essential and that is why I think Keke would be a very good choice.
@nerddoctors Personally Milly is over rated. She has talent and can obviously act but this over exposure to her is just not for me. She doesn't have to be put on every possible female fancast list. Which is why I am glad you guys addressed more viable choices whether it be Keke Palmer or Hassie Harrison or Elizabeth Gillies.
Personally, I am not a fan of race swapping sure there has been times where it has improved upon the character, but I just don’t understand the need to do this. I agree with Griffin I think at this point they’re just checking the boxes. They’re just trying to be inclusive, and you can be inclusive without forcing it . I think for rogue out of the people that you mentioned I think 110% and now I’m really praying that this happens Elizabeth Gillis is beyond perfect for the role.
Oh she would be amazing as Rogue. They can easily be diverse without checking boxes. Xmen is one of the most diverse groups out there and it isnt forced
Oh my God, you guys I legit cannot get Elizabeth Gillies out of my head now as rogue in fact, I want her to play this role more than anything else in the world . And like Edward I almost feel like posting a disclaimer. I’m not racist in anyway I promise but I just don’t see the need for race swapping. I don’t understand it. I don’t wanna see an Asian rogue 😂
Victoria Pedretti: Hmm. Maybe. Lily James: Big no. She's incredibly dull. Grace Caroline Currey: Boring choice. Elizabeth Gillies: 100% YES. Hassie Harrison: Too CW. Keke Palmer: Wouldn't mind it. She's fun, funny, sexy. Could easily pull it off. Milly Bobby Brown: NO. NO. NO. Lily Collins: No. More of a Kitty Pryde or even a Jean Grey. Katy Perry: LOL No. Anya Taylor Joy: Love her. Completely wrong for Rogue.
In my opinion. And remember, I'm saying, in my opinion, the only time I've ever seen a race swap. improve upon the character has been Samuel Jackson as Nick Fury. Any other time? it hasn't made The character worst, but I can't sit here and say that it's improved upon the character. Rogue is my favorite X. Men female character, without doubt. And I just don't understand the need to race swap The character's perfect as is Like the saying goes, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. I agree that at this point, Hollywood is just checking boxes. They're putting in the token so and so chest to accommodate people. People don't need to be accommodated. X men and X men characters are already accommodating to most people. You know, there are a bunch of outcasts that are frowned upon by the norm. if you will. As for the casting, I think that either Hassie Harrison or Elizabeth Gillies would absolutely kill it in the role of rogue. They both. are beautiful women and they're both good actresses. I think either one of them would be perfect.
The people who complaine about white washing are the once totally ok with race swapping and gender swapping characters. I think Elizabeth would be so perfect as Rogue I hope to God that happens, he'll that girl would be an awesome Wonder Woman, Catwoman or Talia Al Ghul.
Box checking has always annoyed the s*** out of me is necessity to have the token black guy the token Asian person or the token gay guy in a movie is so jaded at this point. I don't understand how Hollywood hasn't learned their lesson. They think they sell tickets by adding all these things that no one asked for yes Kiki is probably a good actress the white race swap? I can almost guarantee that by making Rogue black is not going to make the character any better I know that that comment is going to piss off a lot of people but at this point it's just becoming ridiculous. Personally I think that Hassie or Elizabeth would be amazing.
I don't think it is necessarily about making the character better or worse but going with the person who embodies the necessary characteristics. If that is Keke and tests well with Channing Tatum go for it. If it is Hassie or Elizabeth go for either of them. Hell, if it turns out to be Katy Perry go with her. I think we need to stop seeing it as box checking and start going with who is genuinely the best for the roles. No matter the choice they make someone won't be happy.
@@nerddoctors Do an open casting call. No one person is treated any differently and have them evaluated based on running lines and other things actors do. It's that easy. Narrow it down to the top 25 choices. Have them screen test with Channing if he is your Gambit or have them screen test with the top choices for Gambit and choose the combo that works.
Oh hell, no stop with the race swapping. I don’t understand the necessity behind that. I have never seen more than one example of it improving the character and as both of you said it has been Sam Jackson playing Nick fury other than that has it made the character worse no but it’s never improved on the character except for the example Spoken of so this need that Hollywood feels to include everyone it’s unnecessary man you can give us a good story without checking the boxes if you will . And I think Elizabeth Gillies can play anything, and I would love to see her as rogue. I think that would kill.
For all the people who want Keke as Rogue I have one for you , how about Emma Stone as Storm ? As far as this fan cast Elizabeth Gillis would fucking Slay
i really want Elizabeth Gillies!
She would rock it
I adore your fantastic videos. The one you guys did for Batman. I still come back and rewatch that one every once in a while. It’s a really good video. I’ve been waiting for you to do a fan casting of X-Men and I have to say just like I do it With Your Batman, When You Said, Ben Barnes. I totally agree with you guys. Elizabeth Gillies, as rogue would be absolutely amazing.
We are glad you like the videos! We do have a video going through our ideal MCU X-Men team coming out soon
Also, before I forget, Hassie Harrison and her husband absolutely convince me as gambit and rogue and I kind of want a certain someone to grow a beard now 😉😎
Haha you could probably convince him better than I. Ill bug him to be safe
Elizabeth would be picture perfect as Rogue
She truly would be
I love your fan casting videos , I don’t want a race swap , Liz would kill it as Rogue
Thank you! We are glad you enjoy them
I don't want Milly out of this entire list. She to me moreso than Anya is becoming the face we see everywhere. Out of this last I have the most exposure to Victoria Pedretti and Keke Palmer and I really think either of them could pull it off. I think Keke has an energy that could match Channing well both on set and on screen as we watch it. I think capturing that is essential and that is why I think Keke would be a very good choice.
Milly is just such an odd choice for people. Victoria would be good and we do still think Keke could win us over
@nerddoctors
Personally Milly is over rated. She has talent and can obviously act but this over exposure to her is just not for me. She doesn't have to be put on every possible female fancast list. Which is why I am glad you guys addressed more viable choices whether it be Keke Palmer or Hassie Harrison or Elizabeth Gillies.
She is very overrated. She did what she had to do for Stranger Things, but outside of that she hasnt been a standout
I'm black and I totally agree I don't want Keke for Rogue or any more race swapping. Elizabeth Gilles as Rogue hell yesssssss!
Liz would be amazing. We could be getting her in a couple of years
Who do you want to see play MCU's Rogue
For my baby Rogue I only see Hassie or Liz
If we get one of those we would die happy
Griffin is correct Studios just checking boxes at this point. Hassie or Elizabeth would make perfect Rogues
They would rock it. Studios are too focused on checking boxes than making good stories. If you truly write a good story diversity comes naturally.
Personally, I am not a fan of race swapping sure there has been times where it has improved upon the character, but I just don’t understand the need to do this. I agree with Griffin I think at this point they’re just checking the boxes. They’re just trying to be inclusive, and you can be inclusive without forcing it . I think for rogue out of the people that you mentioned I think 110% and now I’m really praying that this happens Elizabeth Gillis is beyond perfect for the role.
Oh she would be amazing as Rogue. They can easily be diverse without checking boxes. Xmen is one of the most diverse groups out there and it isnt forced
Oh my God, you guys I legit cannot get Elizabeth Gillies out of my head now as rogue in fact, I want her to play this role more than anything else in the world . And like Edward I almost feel like posting a disclaimer. I’m not racist in anyway I promise but I just don’t see the need for race swapping. I don’t understand it. I don’t wanna see an Asian rogue 😂
She would be soooo good! We really want her too
Victoria Pedretti: Hmm. Maybe.
Lily James: Big no. She's incredibly dull.
Grace Caroline Currey: Boring choice.
Elizabeth Gillies: 100% YES.
Hassie Harrison: Too CW.
Keke Palmer: Wouldn't mind it. She's fun, funny, sexy. Could easily pull it off.
Milly Bobby Brown: NO. NO. NO.
Lily Collins: No. More of a Kitty Pryde or even a Jean Grey.
Katy Perry: LOL No.
Anya Taylor Joy: Love her. Completely wrong for Rogue.
That is a fair assessment. We really want Liz
Elisabetta sarebbe fantástica Briccone
basta con lo scambio di razza!
Questa è una buona scelta
Elizabeth Gilis would be the perfect Rogue , I hate race or gender swapping
She really would be
Hassie and Liz for sure, and enough with race swapping
Let's hope we get a good iteration of the character
In my opinion. And remember, I'm saying, in my opinion, the only time I've ever seen a race swap. improve upon the character has been Samuel Jackson as Nick Fury. Any other time? it hasn't made The character worst, but I can't sit here and say that it's improved upon the character. Rogue is my favorite X. Men female character, without doubt. And I just don't understand the need to race swap The character's perfect as is Like the saying goes, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. I agree that at this point, Hollywood is just checking boxes. They're putting in the token so and so chest to accommodate people. People don't need to be accommodated. X men and X men characters are already accommodating to most people. You know, there are a bunch of outcasts that are frowned upon by the norm. if you will. As for the casting, I think that either Hassie Harrison or Elizabeth Gillies would absolutely kill it in the role of rogue. They both. are beautiful women and they're both good actresses. I think either one of them would be perfect.
If we get either of them we would be very very happy
The people who complaine about white washing are the once totally ok with race swapping and gender swapping characters. I think Elizabeth would be so perfect as Rogue I hope to God that happens, he'll that girl would be an awesome Wonder Woman, Catwoman or Talia Al Ghul.
She really would be great at any of those roles
I’m unsure about the southern accent, but think Peyton List would make a great Rogue.
That is also a good choice. If she can learn the accent she would be next to perfect
Box checking has always annoyed the s*** out of me is necessity to have the token black guy the token Asian person or the token gay guy in a movie is so jaded at this point. I don't understand how Hollywood hasn't learned their lesson. They think they sell tickets by adding all these things that no one asked for yes Kiki is probably a good actress the white race swap?
I can almost guarantee that by making Rogue black is not going to make the character any better I know that that comment is going to piss off a lot of people but at this point it's just becoming ridiculous. Personally I think that Hassie or Elizabeth would be amazing.
I don't think it is necessarily about making the character better or worse but going with the person who embodies the necessary characteristics. If that is Keke and tests well with Channing Tatum go for it. If it is Hassie or Elizabeth go for either of them. Hell, if it turns out to be Katy Perry go with her.
I think we need to stop seeing it as box checking and start going with who is genuinely the best for the roles. No matter the choice they make someone won't be happy.
Honestly whoever can do the best at the character go for it. Just dont close castings to one demographic if race doesnt matter
Yeah, just cast whoever is best
@@nerddoctors
Do an open casting call. No one person is treated any differently and have them evaluated based on running lines and other things actors do. It's that easy. Narrow it down to the top 25 choices. Have them screen test with Channing if he is your Gambit or have them screen test with the top choices for Gambit and choose the combo that works.
Agreed, it is that easy
Stop with the race swapping! And he’ll ya bros for me Hassie or Elizabeth for Rogue 💯
If we get either of those we would be so happy
Hassie Harrison for me y'all and ya not a fan of race or gender swaps
Yeah, it is just weird as it is fake anyways. Make new characters to eb truly diverse.
Oh hell, no stop with the race swapping. I don’t understand the necessity behind that. I have never seen more than one example of it improving the character and as both of you said it has been Sam Jackson playing Nick fury other than that has it made the character worse no but it’s never improved on the character except for the example Spoken of so this need that Hollywood feels to include everyone it’s unnecessary man you can give us a good story without checking the boxes if you will . And I think Elizabeth Gillies can play anything, and I would love to see her as rogue. I think that would kill.
It can help characters such as with heimdall as Idris Elba is an amazing actor who did well in the role. It just may not work well here.
For all the people who want Keke as Rogue I have one for you , how about Emma Stone as Storm ?
As far as this fan cast Elizabeth Gillis would fucking Slay
haha there you go
Elizabeth is perfect she can do it all. As for Keke I mean why????? How does this make the cheracter better?
We shall see. If she is the best for the role then so be it