@lovepeacenappiness1 oh, no. I am from Africa. I was hoping South Africa could care about 750 000 Ethiopia passed in 2023 and the 500 000 dead in Darfur. I'm so sad and tied 😢 😭
@@t-lexx8838 giving them the "freedom" to do such will. remember how fascism was defeated? that was done by rebuilding germany, not by exterminating everyone in bavaria and telling the other states, "we are gonna do the same to you next".
@@nvmtt that is a really poor understanding of how opinions actually changed in Germany. It’s a really fascinating subject, you should look into it. I can’t type out the complexities in a UA-cam comment. It took decades and was actually more successful on the Soviet controlled side believed due to the harsher treatment. Not recommending that, but we need to be aware of the actual facts before developing a suitable post war plan. Regardless, first came defeat.
Palestinians have never had a country. Egypt, Jordan, UK, ottomans, Romans, Kingdom of Jerusalem....ect ect. Arabs don't want peace. A negotiation has been offer for 100 years, Arab leaders won't accept anything. They use the civilians as tools
@@tzipi22It's not normal to live in open-air prison in one side and being expelled and colonized by the other. Isreal seeks a complete occupation of Palestinian and erasing its people, the dignified answer is to fight and make pressure.
that's because it was an ideology that was based on world domination there wasn't a strong motivation behind it not the case here since israel is giving them a reason to keep fighting by occupying them and denying them their right to statehood once they gain their freedom then they would stop this was the case in all the colonized countries they all kept fighting until they kicked out their oppressors.
I'm just worried that Benjamin Netanyahu's idea for a plan of what comes *after* his war on Gaza, is an escalation of war against the Houthi's. There is already a(n active!) Western military presence in the Red Sea to protect shipping lanes. Which have come under Houthi attack over the past weeks. A couple of sailors have died in these attacks. So everything there has been sort of teetering on the edge. Netanyahu says that his military efforts will be finished in Rafah in a 'few weeks'. ...Though no articulated plan for what comes after that in Gaza. And why everyone has to wait weeks is anyone's guess. What will be any different in several weeks worth of more bombing buildings to the ground than is different, say, the day after tomorrow, is anyone's guess. For a short period of time after that (*if* Netanyahu follows through, and *stops* attacking Gaza, ...for some undefined period of time), ...there will, for a brief window, be an opportunity for a cease-fire, during which they can negotiate a real end to war in Gaza. The Houthi's have said that their attacks in the Red Sea and Northern Israel are dependent on whether or not there is a cease-fire in Gaza. *If* Netanyahu hasn't already decided that, ....well, as long as he's right there already, maybe just go on right ahead with attacking the Houthi. And so what if he's a bit out-gunned from the get-go. All of these Western battleship are sitting around there anyway. And sure, we'd really *hate* the idea of being involuntarily drawn into a shooting War-In-The-Middle-East involving a whole *bunch* of nations, but we probably would just allow his a..., hind-quarters, ...to get shot all to pieces, just because he decided to exercise a little too much irresponsible and murderous hubris. ...Would we? *If* that is the case (and I honestly don't know if it is, one way or the other), ...but *if* it is, that would be the exact moment to apply a zero-tolerance embargo on Netanyahu getting *any* more Western weapons, for *any* reason. At least until the peaceful conclusion of all hostilities. If he feels like starting War-In-The-Middle-East involving a whole *bunch* of nations, ...then let him figure out how to stop it. And one good way to stop everything (and keep the Israeli people safe, maybe even along with everyone else) is to call an election in Israel, and vote him and his right-wing extremists the heck out of office. That would sure solve a lot, ...for everyone involved. Owen Jay Korman Philadelphia, PA usa
ideology is a system of idea execute by a man or group of people, if you execute the executors of ideology, then the ideology die automatically. Admiral Daniel Hagari is not saying that Hamas Ideology can not be eliminated, he is saying that the method of eliminating the ideology is wrong if they don't provide an alternative to Hamas in the end. If what he means is that Hamas Ideology cannot be eliminated, then he is wrong, apart from GOD and his people, there is nothing that cannot be eliminated if the proper step is taken.
the conflict has been going on long before hamas existed do you really think it'll stop once their defeated? the main motivation behind them fighting is because israel stole their homes and is occupying them that's where the source of the problem lies if hamas were to be defeates individual attacks will continue and maybe even much stronger groups will rise.
Why doesn't Israel go after the top leaders of Hamas in their pretty houses, instead of soldiers in the tunnels who can be easily replaced? DW gets close enough to them to get a video, but Israel can't find them?
One has to deduce from the last account that the argument for distinguishing between Hamas and the Gaza population is now weakened, given that Hamas’ ranks are being swelled with more and more new recruits. It’s basically a war between Gaza and Israel.
how do you know they're being recruited? israel has killed 40000 palestenians and they basically count every single military aged man as hamas they still have no idea how many actual hamas members they took out.
Is Hamas far right or far left? DW usually refer political opponents as far right. Hamas is always addressed as "many nations consider as terrorists group". Which means DW don't consider them as terrorists. Now that Hamas is neither far right nor terrorists, it must be far left. Right?
I doesn't make sense. If DW says many countries consider them terrorists it mean they don't? They are a media channel they need to report news not tell us their opinion on who they think is terrorist.. and how does make sense if they are not far right they must be far left?
@@AmonTheWitchwhat is a religious right? If there is a religious right, then there must be a religious left too. What will be their ideology? I think religion is right wing and Hamas is definitely on the extreme end of it.
@@user-wo8Iw9km4wDW has an opinion about every right wing party in the world as "Far right" but they never use a term "Far left" to any party any where in the world. DW also has no opinion on Hamas although it has no issue to categorise Hezbollah or Taliban as a terrorist organisation. Anyone with common sense can see the hypocrisy here. You said something which is not far right doesn't mean they are far left. Ok. Then tell me what Hamas is. Is it far right, centre right, centrist, centre left , far left OR just terrorists?
@@myspace1876 maybe DW learned to be unbiased. Again, their role is not to tell us their opinions but to report what happened. Hamas in my opinion is the result of israeli oppression, I don't know what they are but for sure it's debatable and depends on the point of view.
Look at child's clothes, it is too clean to be there......they place them to take a good picture for them. And nobody pointed out that it is child harassment. Such a double standard. Well doesn't matter. People are getting sick of this nonsense and place vote to right to far right. These double standards help right. Decent job buddy.
GERMANY IS VERY AFRAID OF ISRAEL 😅 THEY EVEN MISQOATED THEIR MILITARY SPOKES PERSON BY SAYING 'WE CAN NOT ELIMINATE IDEOLEGY WHILE THE SPEACH WAS 'WE CAN NOT ELIMINATE HAMAS AS GENERAL
It's more like they are reduced in magnitude to be manageable. God-king ideology has been subjugated long ago, but we still get religious cults and Donald Trump in the US. Theocracy has been subjugated, and few remnants such as Iran and ISIS are marginal players at best. Absolute monarchy has been subjugated, but we have today N Korea Kim dynasty. Fascism has been defeated, but clearly not gone. We have Putin and Xi doing it with lots of sway in the world.
Before carrying out the airstrike, the IDF stated that “great effort was made to reduce the risk of harm to uninvolved civilians.” In a statement, the institution said: “Terrorist organizations continue to place terrorist weapons and infrastructure in the hearts of the civilian population, putting them at risk and using them as a human shield.”
Surprisingly nobody from Palestine complain about using civilians as human shields. They only protest in university campuses against Israel. Their extremist ideology is to win no matter what, doesnt matter civilians. Some of them prepared to die. This is how their network runs through brainwashing.
@@joexavier4070 That's right, Palestine is a pariah state, its nation does not exist, its people do not exist, and its history does not exist, it is not even officially recognized by the UN and its only recognition is SYMBOLIC. How unlucky the pariah state is.
Another supported justifying raping, killing babies on 7th of October. What a shame to support region that started this mess again knowing its sensitivity in the region.
The IDF Spoke person is right, they can not eliminate Hamas by war, and he further said, "it needs alternative ways, that means through diplomatic, Political approach. Even some former Israelis, even US and EU officials admitted Hamas can't be eliminated by force. and it's true you can not defeat people fighting for survival, for freedom
@user-uo9eq9fj1l if not a Palestinian state, why not have the Knesset grant Israeli citizenship to Palestinians in Gaza & the West Bank? Israel has a very successful economy & despite being a small state, they have great technology & many resources
@@AB-en9pl - First of all, most Palestinians do not want to become citizens of Israel. Second, if all of the Palestinians were granted citizenship in Israel, in less than 20 years -- given the Palestinian prolific birth rate -- the Palestinians would outnumber the Israelis, and the Palestinians would simply be able to vote Israel out of existence.
@@AB-en9pl - First of all, most Palestinians do not want to become citizens of Israel. Second, if all of the Palestinians were granted citizenship in Israel, in less than 20 years -- given the Palestinian prolific birth rate -- the Palestinians would outnumber the Israelis and the Palestinians would simply be able to vote Israel out of existence.
@@AB-en9pl - First of all, most Palestinians do not want to become citizens of Israel. Second, if all of the Palestinians were granted citizenship in Israel, in less than 20 years the Palestinians would outnumber the Israelis, and the Palestinians would simply be able to vote Israel out of existence.
@user-uo9eq9fj1l If you're talking about the accusations that Hamas rape, burn babies, it seems you're not updated with news. according to some israeli news media, and to some israelis interviewed in the past months. those were not happened in their place, they even said that those names mentioned as victim are fictitious. then another israeli news reporter interviewed one soldier and said that is not true. and till now IDF can't provide evidence.
I wouldn't hold my breath too long on that. I don't think the West has realised yet, that it represents the minority of the world. Times are changing, it will take time, but my guess is that Palestine will not be forgotten.
DW TV ( western media ) People of Palestine are living under a occupation since 1947 and according to international UN law people under illegal occupation have every right to resist their occupiers.
@@AlgernonMoncrieff77 well if its Palestinian land, and they invaded it and consider the occupied territories a country it doesn't legitimise it as a country. Same exemple, if Africans settle in Germany without Germany agreeing to it, and they declare the occupied territories their new country that doesn't make it real, even if the Africa defeated the Germans in combat.
@@user-wo8Iw9km4w Between 1947 and 1967, the West Bank was occupied by Jordan and Gaza occupied by Egypt. Israel occupied both from 1967. In 1993, the Oslo Accords began transferring power to the Palestinian authority. In 2005, Israel unilaterally withdrew from Gaza and completely ended occupation. These are not secrets. This is well known history. Go learn it.
It's actually a trivial exercise to defeat an ideology. You just have to give the Palestinian people the right to self governance and conditions for economic opportunity...
It seems important to point our that as the IDF failed to keep weapons and missiles out of Gaza during the blockade, it is unlikely that they have kept all the Hamas leaders in Gaza. They could be anywhere in the world right now.
Indeed - and that's full on the West. It's incomprehensible siding with Israel no matter how bad they are. What do you expect the Palestinians and Hamas to do? To go on living under Israeli oppression, war crimes and atrocities? Surely you can't be for real?
DW News, be fair and stop being complicit by using passive voice in reporting. Use active voice to clearly mention the doer of the action, Israel in this case.
Say that about yourself, Hamas/Palestine in this case. Nobody even Israel is "not guilty", but I doubt you hold anything that Palestine does at the same regards you do for Israel. hypocrite
@@cat_city2009 The Palestinians are sick of Israel increasing global protein availability at a competitively affordable cost, lessening the burden of waterborne diseases in developing nations, reducing the use of chemical pesticides, improving energy generation, promoting species conservation, increasing efficiency of agricultural production; protecting plants and animals against biotic and abiotic stress; improving food quality, safety, and security; water quality and quantity; functional genomics and proteomics; sensors and robotics; and, sustainable bio-energy systems.
Well Israel has cut it off from Egypt where they believe smugglers have been arming them However remember these are radical militarists who have been on the war path for nearly decades so they likely have enough arms to fight for years
Outside forces arming them do you think its only IDF n Hamas fighting in Gaza other countries are fighting their too lol this is why ur better off watching independent journalists is better because they make more rational sense
Our Father, who art in heaven, hallowed be thy name; thy kingdom come; thy will be done; on earth as it is in heaven. Give us this day our daily bread. And forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us. And lead us not into temptation; but deliver us from evil.Amen
and you think you attempt to Genocide will solve the problem?? maybe if you had treated them with no racism that's when you end a radical ideology. Islam was never radicalized until we started facing colonial racism by the west
Islam guarantees you the right to fight back for your land and loved ones now i'm not saying hamas uses that right the way it should nor are they respecting the rules that come with it but at the end of the day hamas didn't exist out of nothing and this conflict has been ongoing long before hamas existed as long as israel keeps occupying them and stealing their lands the more they'll fight back.
an ideology that is embraced by the majority of palestinians. they voted hamas in as their defacto ruling party. they are now suffering the perils of their decision.
Your view is one way of looking at it, and it certainly makes it much easier to justify the whole sale slaughter of civilians, but hammas is most likely ruthlessly oppressing the civilian population (they are extremist terrorists in power). Do you think any single person or group of people in Palestine have ever had a chance to break away from hamas and the other multiple extremist groups within Palastine. Hamas simply kills, tortures, or imprisons those who think for themselves. Wake up and stop dehumanizing people because it's the easier thing to do.
Zionism is also an idealogy which was embraced by Israel and now just look at it . Israel is isolated in the world and hated across the world and there leaders are complicit in genocide just ask the ICJ and as far Palestinians are concerned they live under occupation and they have every right to resist there occupiers according to UN law.
Of course you can eliminate an ideology. How many still worship Odin or Zeus today? But you can't eliminate an ideology with weapons. You can only eliminate an ideology with education and culture.
@@AmonTheWitch You don't have to go so far. The only difference between an ideology and a religion is that a deity is sad to have told humans how to live where an ideology cuts out the deity and just have one or several humans telling other humans how to live.
This Minister of foreign affairs is the best German minister ever Frank and straight talking lady Real political leader She is loved by us all Thanks 🙏 for your courage and dedication towards the weakest of our society & living together in harmony
An ideology can be rendered impotent when the individual that perceives it distinguishes themselves internally between thought and the self. There is a contradiction in this mental game since everything comes from one immutable unspeakable essence. This is to say everything is creation and to see creation is to measure. By seeing thought as transient we can see something/a presence that is constant. That constant is always there, thought/ideologies of any kids nd are only as powerful as the energy you give it. Energy is given through awareness. Where do you place your attention? If attention is placed on thought we literally become thought. If its consistently placed on other outside the self then we remain dimmed to greater awareness. Place your attention upon yourself. Be self aware. Self awareness outside anything else clears the mind. That self awareness becomes more and more present in everything.
Don’t know of any army in the world who would call people and warn them about an impending air strike. Hamas must stop using their own people as human shields.
Netanyahu has to win if they're not treating civilians as animals and protect the civilians.netanyaho lock of strategy like what by saying the cabinets members.
Very well said about the contradictions in the Israeli army that people seem to fail to understand. It is infiltrated by religious right wing extremists and allowed these elements to get away with many war crimes, it has also been a force for reason, temperance, accountability in many instances that Netanyahu's government has not.
Ha'mas never fired rocket frlm lebanon. Change your narration. And you should have added the popularity of ha'mas. It is unbelievablely famous in all over the world. Billions of people get them as a hope of Palestinian Liberation.
Bravo Andreas Krieg…excellent analysis and your words about the palestinian people facing the choice between Hamas or Israel as being the choice between the cholera or the pest is very apt one…really good metaphore,I just wish Dw would produce more good journalism instead of pandering to that rogue state in the ME
I do not condone the attacks on civilians that Israel has committed and I do think that war crimes have been committed during this war. But it must also be clear that Hamas is clearly using civilians as a shield, and that the true enemy in all of this has always been Hamas, since their brutally inhumane terrorist attack last year. Do I wish that Israel was far more careful in their attacks? Yes. Do I think it's unacceptable that Israel is stopping humanitarian support from reaching into Gaza? Yes. Do I also think that Hamas is a terrible ideology, and that they are, themselves, using their own civilians as meat shields? Yes.
Israel attacks the weapons, fighters, and tunnel shafts, Hamas hides in Gaza's buildings. It would only harm Israel to attack civilians, so they don't do it. Hamas leaders *openly* point out it benefits them when Gaza's civilians are killed, since everyone blames Israel.
Israel attacks the weapons, fighters, and tunnel shafts, Hamas hides in Gaza's buildings. The IDF's efforts to minimize civilian harm are greatly complicated by Hamas's efforts to maximize civilian harm. Hamas's leaders state *openly* their cause is advanced when their civilians are killed, since western media can be counted on to blame every death on Israel.
Even if the human shield myth was true, it is Israel that still chooses to bomb and knowingly kill civilians. Israel itself uses Palestinians as human shields during operations
give me one evidence that hamas is using them as shields cause everyone keeps saying it but no provided any proof for it gaza is the most densly populated place on earth cause israel has pushed all of the palestenians out of their homes into that small piece of land that is now called gaza and israel controls both the waters on gaza's coast amd their airspace and under international law they have a right to fight back against israel since it's occupying them how do you suggest they do that? bearing in mind that they live on a flat piece of land with no thick vegetation so the only way to fight is to dig tunnels.
Resistance: In WW2, in France, it meant kicking out the German army. Today, in Palestine, it means destroying Israel, killing its people, and stealing everything they've built.
The desire for freedom is indeed impossible to remove.
They were free in 2005 and they hated it so much they invaded Israel to bring occupation back.
Doesn't matter if it's hopeless
If gaza is never going to be free then it doesn't matter if desire for freedom cannot be removed lmao
@@qaching Gaza was free in 2005
@@qaching of course Gaza will be free
Wasn't Gaza independently run since 2005?
Free Sudan 🇸🇩. Help Sudanese people
I hope that statement is for the UN, Americans are tired of getting blamed for everything. I’m sure another country will help.
@lovepeacenappiness1 oh, no. I am from Africa. I was hoping South Africa could care about 750 000 Ethiopia passed in 2023 and the 500 000 dead in Darfur.
I'm so sad and tied 😢 😭
Why is the government of South Africa silent when it happens in Africa?
@@online3010 what solution do you recommend for Sudan
@@thiphan264 because they are busy blaming Israel in UN...
Las ideas no se matan ….you can’t kill an ideology
So you think giving it a victory will? And allowing it to keep weapons and an army? You guys make me laugh
@@t-lexx8838but it's ok to arm the settlers? What planet you on ?
@@t-lexx8838 giving them the "freedom" to do such will. remember how fascism was defeated? that was done by rebuilding germany, not by exterminating everyone in bavaria and telling the other states, "we are gonna do the same to you next".
@@nvmttthis is different those fascist you talking about run for asylum in Palestine and now they turn and took their land
@@nvmtt that is a really poor understanding of how opinions actually changed in Germany. It’s a really fascinating subject, you should look into it. I can’t type out the complexities in a UA-cam comment. It took decades and was actually more successful on the Soviet controlled side believed due to the harsher treatment. Not recommending that, but we need to be aware of the actual facts before developing a suitable post war plan. Regardless, first came defeat.
Western countries are responsible for this inhumane situation
West is the root cause of most conflict and problems acorss the world
Iran is not a western country and "palestine" isnt even a country at all
You spelled Islam wrong
Thanks to DW for interviewing Gil Murciano, a knowledgeable and well-spoken advocate for a logical way forward.
And what other option did Palestinians have?
Not choose an antisemitic death cult as their leaders?
Not start a war
They never really had a peaceful plan
Palestinians have never had a country. Egypt, Jordan, UK, ottomans, Romans, Kingdom of Jerusalem....ect ect.
Arabs don't want peace. A negotiation has been offer for 100 years, Arab leaders won't accept anything. They use the civilians as tools
To be normal? Not terrorists supporters?
@@tzipi22It's not normal to live in open-air prison in one side and being expelled and colonized by the other. Isreal seeks a complete occupation of Palestinian and erasing its people, the dignified answer is to fight and make pressure.
How did Germany supress Nazism ideology?
It never did. They are all over Germany and they’re now called AFD
that's because it was an ideology that was based on world domination there wasn't a strong motivation behind it not the case here since israel is giving them a reason to keep fighting by occupying them and denying them their right to statehood once they gain their freedom then they would stop this was the case in all the colonized countries they all kept fighting until they kicked out their oppressors.
How about free Gaza free the West Bank free Palestine 🇵🇸
They knew that from the begining they are now trying to shift there focus
Israel can never be forgiven
HAMAS can never be forgiven
The most bullish news I ever heard
14:45 desperation of people: The started the war. What did they expect?
Of course we can. Look at Spain and italy
After all this American commentators can't pronounce 'Yahya' correctly
polls show that 93% of Americans butcher their pronunciations _intentionally_
I'm just worried that Benjamin Netanyahu's idea for a plan of what comes *after* his war on Gaza, is an escalation of war against the Houthi's.
There is already a(n active!) Western military presence in the Red Sea to protect shipping lanes. Which have come under Houthi attack over the past weeks. A couple of sailors have died in these attacks.
So everything there has been sort of teetering on the edge.
Netanyahu says that his military efforts will be finished in Rafah in a 'few weeks'. ...Though no articulated plan for what comes after that in Gaza. And why everyone has to wait weeks is anyone's guess. What will be any different in several weeks worth of more bombing buildings to the ground than is different, say, the day after tomorrow, is anyone's guess.
For a short period of time after that (*if* Netanyahu follows through, and *stops* attacking Gaza, ...for some undefined period of time), ...there will, for a brief window, be an opportunity for a cease-fire, during which they can negotiate a real end to war in Gaza.
The Houthi's have said that their attacks in the Red Sea and Northern Israel are dependent on whether or not there is a cease-fire in Gaza.
*If* Netanyahu hasn't already decided that, ....well, as long as he's right there already, maybe just go on right ahead with attacking the Houthi. And so what if he's a bit out-gunned from the get-go. All of these Western battleship are sitting around there anyway. And sure, we'd really *hate* the idea of being involuntarily drawn into a shooting War-In-The-Middle-East involving a whole *bunch* of nations, but we probably would just allow his a..., hind-quarters, ...to get shot all to pieces, just because he decided to exercise a little too much irresponsible and murderous hubris. ...Would we?
*If* that is the case (and I honestly don't know if it is, one way or the other), ...but *if* it is, that would be the exact moment to apply a zero-tolerance embargo on Netanyahu getting *any* more Western weapons, for *any* reason. At least until the peaceful conclusion of all hostilities.
If he feels like starting War-In-The-Middle-East involving a whole *bunch* of nations, ...then let him figure out how to stop it.
And one good way to stop everything (and keep the Israeli people safe, maybe even along with everyone else) is to call an election in Israel, and vote him and his right-wing extremists the heck out of office.
That would sure solve a lot, ...for everyone involved.
Owen Jay Korman
Philadelphia, PA
usa
It’s like the Chinese zero covid policy
Just change the morality. Jesus was a prophet too.
Do not focus on Semantics or the messenger, but rather on the message.
ideology is a system of idea execute by a man or group of people, if you execute the executors of ideology, then the ideology die automatically. Admiral Daniel Hagari is not saying that Hamas Ideology can not be eliminated, he is saying that the method of eliminating the ideology is wrong if they don't provide an alternative to Hamas in the end. If what he means is that Hamas Ideology cannot be eliminated, then he is wrong, apart from GOD and his people, there is nothing that cannot be eliminated if the proper step is taken.
the conflict has been going on long before hamas existed do you really think it'll stop once their defeated? the main motivation behind them fighting is because israel stole their homes and is occupying them that's where the source of the problem lies if hamas were to be defeates individual attacks will continue and maybe even much stronger groups will rise.
Why doesn't Israel go after the top leaders of Hamas in their pretty houses, instead of soldiers in the tunnels who can be easily replaced? DW gets close enough to them to get a video, but Israel can't find them?
One has to deduce from the last account that the argument for distinguishing between Hamas and the Gaza population is now weakened, given that Hamas’ ranks are being swelled with more and more new recruits. It’s basically a war between Gaza and Israel.
how do you know they're being recruited? israel has killed 40000 palestenians and they basically count every single military aged man as hamas they still have no idea how many actual hamas members they took out.
@@admar1208 Just by following the news, like most people.
Free Palestine 🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴
Free Palestine from Hamas !
Open borders for Palestinians if they want to leave Hamas.
Open borders to Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon or maybe Saudi Arabia?
6:03 “allowing war crimes to happen”? Or engaging in war crimes? 😅
Is Hamas far right or far left? DW usually refer political opponents as far right. Hamas is always addressed as "many nations consider as terrorists group". Which means DW don't consider them as terrorists. Now that Hamas is neither far right nor terrorists, it must be far left. Right?
I doesn't make sense. If DW says many countries consider them terrorists it mean they don't? They are a media channel they need to report news not tell us their opinion on who they think is terrorist.. and how does make sense if they are not far right they must be far left?
Hamas is the religious right and was part of a coalition party, it's not hard to look that up
@@AmonTheWitchwhat is a religious right? If there is a religious right, then there must be a religious left too. What will be their ideology? I think religion is right wing and Hamas is definitely on the extreme end of it.
@@user-wo8Iw9km4wDW has an opinion about every right wing party in the world as "Far right" but they never use a term "Far left" to any party any where in the world. DW also has no opinion on Hamas although it has no issue to categorise Hezbollah or Taliban as a terrorist organisation. Anyone with common sense can see the hypocrisy here. You said something which is not far right doesn't mean they are far left. Ok. Then tell me what Hamas is. Is it far right, centre right, centrist, centre left , far left OR just terrorists?
@@myspace1876 maybe DW learned to be unbiased. Again, their role is not to tell us their opinions but to report what happened. Hamas in my opinion is the result of israeli oppression, I don't know what they are but for sure it's debatable and depends on the point of view.
Western looking for good leaders for everyone
Israel didn't kill the ideology. Instead Israel raised the consciousness of the ideology, by hurting all the innocents.
Look at child's clothes, it is too clean to be there......they place them to take a good picture for them. And nobody pointed out that it is child harassment. Such a double standard. Well doesn't matter. People are getting sick of this nonsense and place vote to right to far right. These double standards help right. Decent job buddy.
People do still wash their clothes and cook food for the families despite the harsh effect of the war. STOP the knitpicking.
GERMANY IS VERY AFRAID OF ISRAEL 😅 THEY EVEN MISQOATED THEIR MILITARY SPOKES PERSON BY SAYING 'WE CAN NOT ELIMINATE IDEOLEGY WHILE THE SPEACH WAS 'WE CAN NOT ELIMINATE HAMAS AS GENERAL
Nazism is ideology too
Yes, we can. Ideologies have been defeated all the time in human history.
Ideologies never have been defeated by war
It's more like they are reduced in magnitude to be manageable.
God-king ideology has been subjugated long ago, but we still get religious cults and Donald Trump in the US.
Theocracy has been subjugated, and few remnants such as Iran and ISIS are marginal players at best.
Absolute monarchy has been subjugated, but we have today N Korea Kim dynasty.
Fascism has been defeated, but clearly not gone. We have Putin and Xi doing it with lots of sway in the world.
Ideologies were never defeated by war alone.
Ideologies were never defeated without war.
Before carrying out the airstrike, the IDF stated that “great effort was made to reduce the risk of harm to uninvolved civilians.” In a statement, the institution said: “Terrorist organizations continue to place terrorist weapons and infrastructure in the hearts of the civilian population, putting them at risk and using them as a human shield.”
Surprisingly nobody from Palestine complain about using civilians as human shields. They only protest in university campuses against Israel. Their extremist ideology is to win no matter what, doesnt matter civilians. Some of them prepared to die. This is how their network runs through brainwashing.
Pariah state
All of israel’s military installations are literally surrounded by civilian areas. So israel uses their own civilians as human shields as well.
@@joexavier4070
That's right, Palestine is a pariah state, its nation does not exist, its people do not exist, and its history does not exist, it is not even officially recognized by the UN and its only recognition is SYMBOLIC.
How unlucky the pariah state is.
@@mrti3
The desktop indoctrinated are usually quite ignorant.
Bye bye Satanyahu
HE HE MOHAMMED 😂😂😂😂
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Another supported justifying raping, killing babies on 7th of October. What a shame to support region that started this mess again knowing its sensitivity in the region.
Ideology for independent never dies
it dies
look at north korea
no one have ideology for independent , they already accepted their fate
@@yeager112 north korea is independent. No US or japan troops there
@@iggy5347 lmao just move to north korea then genius
@@iggy5347Kim is that you ?
@@vladzîîîî
The IDF Spoke person is right, they can not eliminate Hamas by war, and he further said, "it needs alternative ways, that means through diplomatic, Political approach. Even some former Israelis, even US and EU officials admitted Hamas can't be eliminated by force.
and it's true you can not defeat people fighting for survival, for freedom
@user-uo9eq9fj1l if not a Palestinian state, why not have the Knesset grant Israeli citizenship to Palestinians in Gaza & the West Bank? Israel has a very successful economy & despite being a small state, they have great technology & many resources
@@AB-en9pl - First of all, most Palestinians do not want to become citizens of Israel. Second, if all of the Palestinians were granted citizenship in Israel, in less than 20 years -- given the Palestinian prolific birth rate -- the Palestinians would outnumber the Israelis, and the Palestinians would simply be able to vote Israel out of existence.
@@AB-en9pl - First of all, most Palestinians do not want to become citizens of Israel. Second, if all of the Palestinians were granted citizenship in Israel, in less than 20 years -- given the Palestinian prolific birth rate -- the Palestinians would outnumber the Israelis and the Palestinians would simply be able to vote Israel out of existence.
@@AB-en9pl - First of all, most Palestinians do not want to become citizens of Israel. Second, if all of the Palestinians were granted citizenship in Israel, in less than 20 years the Palestinians would outnumber the Israelis, and the Palestinians would simply be able to vote Israel out of existence.
@user-uo9eq9fj1l If you're talking about the accusations that Hamas rape, burn babies, it seems you're not updated with news. according to some israeli news media, and to some israelis interviewed in the past months. those were not happened in their place, they even said that those names mentioned as victim are fictitious.
then another israeli news reporter interviewed one soldier and said that is not true. and till now IDF can't provide evidence.
And that ideology is called Islam
its called freedom from Israeli occupation and the fight to establish a Palestinian state
@@jebbo-c1l gaza was not occupied
@@uhhhhh341it was blockaded and they had no control over their airspace and waters that sounds like occupation to me.
As long as the EU US SK Australia is complicit with IDF, the world can only cry and do nothing, it's that simple
I wouldn't hold my breath too long on that. I don't think the West has realised yet, that it represents the minority of the world. Times are changing, it will take time, but my guess is that Palestine will not be forgotten.
Mimimi
The worlds demographics are changing rapidly. Even in 1960 Germany had more people that Egypt, Iran, Türkiye and Nigeria
DW TV ( western media ) People of Palestine are living under a occupation since 1947 and according to international UN law people under illegal occupation have every right to resist their occupiers.
Learn history before making a fool of yourself.
@@adamredwine774 please correct what is wrong in this. I'd love to learn if you know something we don't, instead of just insulting this person
There is no illegal occupation. Israel had been recognised by the United Nations. Blame the Arabs who refused the partition plan.
@@AlgernonMoncrieff77 well if its Palestinian land, and they invaded it and consider the occupied territories a country it doesn't legitimise it as a country. Same exemple, if Africans settle in Germany without Germany agreeing to it, and they declare the occupied territories their new country that doesn't make it real, even if the Africa defeated the Germans in combat.
@@user-wo8Iw9km4w Between 1947 and 1967, the West Bank was occupied by Jordan and Gaza occupied by Egypt. Israel occupied both from 1967. In 1993, the Oslo Accords began transferring power to the Palestinian authority. In 2005, Israel unilaterally withdrew from Gaza and completely ended occupation. These are not secrets. This is well known history. Go learn it.
It's actually a trivial exercise to defeat an ideology. You just have to give the Palestinian people the right to self governance and conditions for economic opportunity...
@wilsonnadal3600 the result on 7 October was from 75 years of oppression.
@@sabinehahn9774 absolute BS
@@uhhhhh341 at worst it was just a bit "mowing the lawn" - so no big deal :)
Palestinians need immediate state recognition and the right to self-determination by the UN - WITHOUT US VETO
they will never have a state. why would the world legitimize and reward terrorism?
Lol... They had that chance for 75 years and rejected it saying it will not allow israel to survive by its side
"Ideas are bulletproof."
Alan Moore
Skulls are not
It seems important to point our that as the IDF failed to keep weapons and missiles out of Gaza during the blockade, it is unlikely that they have kept all the Hamas leaders in Gaza. They could be anywhere in the world right now.
*Egypt
@@EpicCrustworld*
@@EpicCrustNetanyahou Mileikowsky is in Tel-Aviv
Indeed - and that's full on the West. It's incomprehensible siding with Israel no matter how bad they are. What do you expect the Palestinians and Hamas to do? To go on living under Israeli oppression, war crimes and atrocities? Surely you can't be for real?
I guess it's not a blockade is what you're saying?
DW News, be fair and stop being complicit by using passive voice in reporting. Use active voice to clearly mention the doer of the action, Israel in this case.
Say that about yourself, Hamas/Palestine in this case. Nobody even Israel is "not guilty", but I doubt you hold anything that Palestine does at the same regards you do for Israel. hypocrite
Leftists and Islamists think the world opinion revolves around them
Why does Palestine keep attacking? It's been 70 years
@@robnoct5195 by all means, enlighten us of those 'standards' lol
You mean Hamas for starting this war who is at fault and hides behind their own civilians
The last guy is wrong. Gazans are sick of Hamas. They want peace. If Hamas is so loved by the Gazans, why haven't there been elections since 2006?
Palestinians are sick of Israel.
because they know who shoots back when idf comes for their children and who hides in their palaces.
@@cat_city2009 The Palestinians are sick of Israel increasing global protein availability at a competitively affordable cost, lessening the burden of waterborne diseases in developing nations, reducing the use of chemical pesticides, improving energy generation, promoting species conservation, increasing efficiency of agricultural production; protecting plants and animals against biotic and abiotic stress; improving food quality, safety, and security; water quality and quantity; functional genomics and proteomics; sensors and robotics; and, sustainable bio-energy systems.
@@MotokoOgawa all of that was done by germans not by jws.
@@cat_city2009 molestinians, fakenstinians, balestinians
It took them 9 month to understand...
I get how they can pull new recruits, but how are they still able to arm themselves after 8 months
Well Israel has cut it off from Egypt where they believe smugglers have been arming them
However remember these are radical militarists who have been on the war path for nearly decades so they likely have enough arms to fight for years
@@tethergobrrr 🤨
Outside forces arming them do you think its only IDF n Hamas fighting in Gaza other countries are fighting their too lol this is why ur better off watching independent journalists is better because they make more rational sense
@@nublex One sows the other reaps
They're not armed?
is not the same image I see in al djazeera ...
Our Father, who art in heaven, hallowed be thy name; thy kingdom come; thy will be done; on earth as it is in heaven. Give us this day our daily bread. And forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us. And lead us not into temptation; but deliver us from evil.Amen
Radical Islam that is the real problem and it manifests in various ways
and you think you attempt to Genocide will solve the problem?? maybe if you had treated them with no racism that's when you end a radical ideology.
Islam was never radicalized until we started facing colonial racism by the west
It has always been and will forever be a repressive ideology
Radical zionism is the problem. The colonisation and occupation of Palestine by Israel is what in turn radicalises Palestinians to fight back
Islam guarantees you the right to fight back for your land and loved ones now i'm not saying hamas uses that right the way it should nor are they respecting the rules that come with it but at the end of the day hamas didn't exist out of nothing and this conflict has been ongoing long before hamas existed as long as israel keeps occupying them and stealing their lands the more they'll fight back.
he sounds like a political scientist. very smart and rational
That includes nazism but they had to destroy what they could.
Nazism is different to freedom
Lol This Is Called Historical Revisionism😂😂😂 What A Fool
Nazism and zionism are two sides of the same coin. If humanity confronted and defeated Nazism just watch what humanity will eventually do to zionism.
@@felixmoyoedonmi the bigger threat is radical Islam not Zionism. You do you.
@@felixmoyoedonmi false.
Why can’t you guys interview a Palestinian representative as well?
That's the tactic of the German press -- no interviews and representations of Palestinians, preferably silence the issue altogether.
because they all fled to qatar
@@fabiofernandes9122 you can do interviews in Qatar.
@@sabinehahn9774 but the representatives from gaza will refuse to do the interview.
Shame on Hamas
Shame on Israel and the international community for 80 years of violence against the people of Palestine.
Shame you either, hypocrite.
shame on israel.
an ideology that is embraced by the majority of palestinians. they voted hamas in as their defacto ruling party. they are now suffering the perils of their decision.
Your view is one way of looking at it, and it certainly makes it much easier to justify the whole sale slaughter of civilians, but hammas is most likely ruthlessly oppressing the civilian population (they are extremist terrorists in power). Do you think any single person or group of people in Palestine have ever had a chance to break away from hamas and the other multiple extremist groups within Palastine. Hamas simply kills, tortures, or imprisons those who think for themselves. Wake up and stop dehumanizing people because it's the easier thing to do.
😂 half the population were not even born when Hamas was voted in.
There has not been an election in Gaza sense 2008. Half of Gaza population was not even born back then.
Zionism is also an idealogy which was embraced by Israel and now just look at it . Israel is isolated in the world and hated across the world and there leaders are complicit in genocide just ask the ICJ and as far Palestinians are concerned they live under occupation and they have every right to resist there occupiers according to UN law.
You know that your argumentation is precisely the ratio Osama bin Laden used in order to legitimize 9/11?
The hypothesis on Hamas by Israel may be far away from the reality.
Look deeper into UNRWA this organization is the source of the ideology.
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💪💪💪💪💪
Ideologies based on religious hatred are impossible to defeat as long as religious divisive forces exist.
You can always defeat the phisical manifestation of an ideology. That's what matters. All else is smoke
Of course you can eliminate an ideology. How many still worship Odin or Zeus today? But you can't eliminate an ideology with weapons. You can only eliminate an ideology with education and culture.
Weapons are a big part of it. Usually in the beginning.
that's a religion
@@AmonTheWitch Religion and ideology is basically the same thing. The difference is very small.
@@dribrom i mean if you reduce both to having opinions then sure they're completely the same thing
@@AmonTheWitch You don't have to go so far. The only difference between an ideology and a religion is that a deity is sad to have told humans how to live where an ideology cuts out the deity and just have one or several humans telling other humans how to live.
Germany, Netherland UK and many european would know those very well, eh?
How delusional these analysts are…
This Minister of foreign affairs is the best German minister ever
Frank and straight talking lady
Real political leader
She is loved by us all
Thanks 🙏 for your courage and dedication towards the weakest of our society & living together in harmony
Lmaoo and only now they figured this out.
Free Palestinian from UK
"An ideology" = the determination of people not allowing to be kicked of their homes and lanas! You bet you can´t defeat such a sentiment!
13:43 its an idea not a movement: If the idea has no weapons to fight with then it will not be a threat.
This report is so biased.
An ideology can be rendered impotent when the individual that perceives it distinguishes themselves internally between thought and the self. There is a contradiction in this mental game since everything comes from one immutable unspeakable essence. This is to say everything is creation and to see creation is to measure. By seeing thought as transient we can see something/a presence that is constant. That constant is always there, thought/ideologies of any kids nd are only as powerful as the energy you give it. Energy is given through awareness. Where do you place your attention? If attention is placed on thought we literally become thought. If its consistently placed on other outside the self then we remain dimmed to greater awareness. Place your attention upon yourself. Be self aware. Self awareness outside anything else clears the mind. That self awareness becomes more and more present in everything.
Yes it’s true like Nazism, zionism😂
Israelis are difficult to indoctrinate, there is an evident freedom of innovative thought in a somehow thriving society
Don’t know of any army in the world who would call people and warn them about an impending air strike. Hamas must stop using their own people as human shields.
That boat left the harbour a long time ago. ....
hamas is in tunnel or is in tent ..... it is false they told them to go there and they drops bombs ....
Netanyahu has to win if they're not treating civilians as animals and protect the civilians.netanyaho lock of strategy like what by saying the cabinets members.
you know they stopped sending warnings months ago right?
They warned everyone first?
I wonder if Hamas does that.
I don't thing warnings help them.
Hamas does not
Why don't you google stats for yourself and stop making a fool of yourself and a burden to the mods?
@@adamredwine774 I don't see how knowing before blowing up helps
Maybe it can help that they can quickly say goodbye to each other? But other than that I don't see how it is helping
It's a bit weird to call a Hamas terrorist organization an 'ideology'. 🤔
Are you an expert on Hamas? Why do you think you have more expertise than the supreme commander of the IDF?
Liberation group
They are not terrorists according to the actual UN rules, only to the racist west who prop up the criminal entity.
The Knesset could just grant Israeli citizenship to Palestinians in Gaza & the West Bank. The Knesset has a very successful economy
Good morning! Some have just woken up (or so they pretend)?!🤔
Appreciated the concise questions and sensible answers in this report.
could not hear anything from the interviewed as someone was slamming dishes constantly in the background
R
Very well said about the contradictions in the Israeli army that people seem to fail to understand. It is infiltrated by religious right wing extremists and allowed these elements to get away with many war crimes, it has also been a force for reason, temperance, accountability in many instances that Netanyahu's government has not.
Ha'mas never fired rocket frlm lebanon. Change your narration.
And you should have added the popularity of ha'mas. It is unbelievablely famous in all over the world. Billions of people get them as a hope of Palestinian Liberation.
Bravo Andreas Krieg…excellent analysis and your words about the palestinian people facing the choice between Hamas or Israel as being the choice between the cholera or the pest is very apt one…really good metaphore,I just wish Dw would produce more good journalism instead of pandering to that rogue state in the ME
At first i thought they were talking about the left supported Hamas😅😅. only Dflp and Dfld do
This guest speaker assessment is off.
Israel is fins but faya is on lsrael u will Sey da u sey u are man u
It's a jungle out there
Destro tel aviv
"we want peace"
What is left of Bibi and what’s he still capable of? Get your speech right, Die Welle
„We can not eliminate an ideology“ Wow, who would have thought! As if there are no more nzzls left today
I do not condone the attacks on civilians that Israel has committed and I do think that war crimes have been committed during this war.
But it must also be clear that Hamas is clearly using civilians as a shield, and that the true enemy in all of this has always been Hamas, since their brutally inhumane terrorist attack last year. Do I wish that Israel was far more careful in their attacks? Yes. Do I think it's unacceptable that Israel is stopping humanitarian support from reaching into Gaza? Yes. Do I also think that Hamas is a terrible ideology, and that they are, themselves, using their own civilians as meat shields? Yes.
Israel attacks the weapons, fighters, and tunnel shafts, Hamas hides in Gaza's buildings. It would only harm Israel to attack civilians, so they don't do it. Hamas leaders *openly* point out it benefits them when Gaza's civilians are killed, since everyone blames Israel.
Israel attacks the weapons, fighters, and tunnel shafts, Hamas hides in Gaza's buildings. The IDF's efforts to minimize civilian harm are greatly complicated by Hamas's efforts to maximize civilian harm. Hamas's leaders state *openly* their cause is advanced when their civilians are killed, since western media can be counted on to blame every death on Israel.
Even if the human shield myth was true, it is Israel that still chooses to bomb and knowingly kill civilians. Israel itself uses Palestinians as human shields during operations
give me one evidence that hamas is using them as shields cause everyone keeps saying it but no provided any proof for it gaza is the most densly populated place on earth cause israel has pushed all of the palestenians out of their homes into that small piece of land that is now called gaza and israel controls both the waters on gaza's coast amd their airspace and under international law they have a right to fight back against israel since it's occupying them how do you suggest they do that? bearing in mind that they live on a flat piece of land with no thick vegetation so the only way to fight is to dig tunnels.
Talking to the wrong people.
It was late to acknowledge it, Elon musk had advised it earlier, he said Hamas can't be destroyed, it's ideology. Idf just requoted it
Like in South Africa, this apatheid occupation is on it last league, and the occupiers are desperately going after innocent women and children.
Wait… you are bombing Gaza for Hamas, but DW news just told you Hamas is firing missiles from Lebanon?
Fighting for justice and family lands is not an Ideology.
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Daniel Gerlach ,you looking a little shabby .Let's see you a lot sharper on air ,we are done with the covid menace .Much love ,child .
Ps. Stacking dishes in the background is very unprofessional.
You CAN eliminate an ideology. Gazans are currently in misery and under rubble. Those that continue to embrace that ideology, well....
Nice Bose speakers. 901s.
🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉
You can accuse Germany (DW), of being pro far left or pro right wing, but never of being anti Genocide!!! They are historically consistent!!!!
Hamas cowereds surrender
The ideology of resistance will always be there.
As it will be on both sides. Israel is a master of said ideology.
Resistance: In WW2, in France, it meant kicking out the German army. Today, in Palestine, it means destroying Israel, killing its people, and stealing everything they've built.