Overcoming Political Tribalism | Amy Chua | 2022

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 66

  • @zachrucker6717
    @zachrucker6717 2 роки тому +14

    I would add one stanza to Langston Hughs poem,
    If America was never America to you, I have one favor to ask, but be true. Live over seas, for a year or three, preferably in a 2nd or 3rd world country. View with your eyes, and ask "are They free?" Then surely you'll believe why America is America to me.

  • @RayBanks
    @RayBanks 2 роки тому +13

    Amazing speech! I really appreciated her ideas of exposing ourselves to different viewpoints and together reaching towards higher ideals.

  • @m.harris2429
    @m.harris2429 2 роки тому +27

    Thank you, Professor Chau for inspiring us to raise our sights and behaviors higher. Your observations and recommendations rang true.

  • @lukehanson_
    @lukehanson_ 2 роки тому +8

    Amazing talk, much needed. Hopefully she can remain a voice of reason at Yale for many years to come.

  • @crystalayers2933
    @crystalayers2933 2 роки тому +11

    She is amazing. She made several valid points.

  • @spencergibby4602
    @spencergibby4602 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you Professor Chau. I appreciate your courage and faith to address a widespread problematic situation. I especially am inspired by the specific factors you pointed out. And I'm grateful for specific suggestions. This shows your love for America, love for unity, and faith in the future of both. You are somebody who is taking steps to help. Thank you.

  • @mikestephens3038
    @mikestephens3038 2 роки тому +13

    I am a huge fan of Amy Chua. I have read many of her books. I have always found her insightful.

  • @psivast8007
    @psivast8007 2 роки тому +11

    She is right on the money here. I hope it's not too late for this amazing experiment called America. Let's all do our part....

  • @amyl3766
    @amyl3766 2 роки тому +9

    I really appreciate her perspective and insights! Great forum!

  • @JazzyUnderscoreTrumpeter
    @JazzyUnderscoreTrumpeter Рік тому +1

    This is great.

  • @Michigan1985
    @Michigan1985 2 роки тому +2

    She's very clever and subtle with how she delivered this speech. It's probably the only way to have this important message well received by this audience. Well done Amy. :)

  • @lesley4215
    @lesley4215 Рік тому +1

    Exciting perspective.

  • @creelabellehoward
    @creelabellehoward 2 роки тому

    Wow! What an incredible talk. The whole country needs to hear this. And I 100% agree that people who grow up in cities need to understand what rural life is like and vice versa. Then they'll understand why people value different things depending on their lifestyle, the jobs in their area, etc.

  • @EricELT18
    @EricELT18 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you for sharing this insightful, fact-based analysis of our current political divisions. Your sensible suggestions to recreate a stronger nation around universal ideals, American achievements and pluralistic patriotism inspire.

  • @GAILandROD
    @GAILandROD 2 роки тому +12

    This is A TED talk. Boy do I miss the good ole days where we just all got along with few labels if any. Your behavior and work determined respect and honor. Nice presentation...as we are all now thrown into a "collective identity "...

  • @stevendorsey4882
    @stevendorsey4882 2 роки тому

    This is a very timely message. Professor Chua makes excellent points.

  • @chenvictor8
    @chenvictor8 2 роки тому +1

    Beautifully spoken

  • @stevenlee9064
    @stevenlee9064 Рік тому

    Dr Chua saw this coming years ago. She almost mouthed the words “make america great again”.

  • @hlim431
    @hlim431 2 роки тому

    WOW she is REALLY an American Powerhouse of hope!!!

  • @yellowyosh470
    @yellowyosh470 2 роки тому

    Thank you so much! What a gifted speaker. 🙌🏼 Thank you for taking the time to share.

  • @Lindatong2
    @Lindatong2 2 роки тому +2

    The former USSR was also a supergroup built on the ideal of its constitution. The failure of that communist experiment should lend some lessons to the USA. There are 2 ways to bring America together:
    1. Find a common enemy - China/Russia
    2. Find inner strength and confidence
    The first way is the easy way. The second way is the right way -
    A) Promote American exceptionalism by facing and solving our problems and finding solutions. don’t try to find excuse or blaming scapegoats because that won’t treat the root issues.
    C) Continue our tradition of the generous inclusiveness built on mutual benefits - legal immigration, fair export/import, peaceful cooperation and competition. Save the money from weapons and prisons and spend them on infrastructure and education.
    D) Eliminate entitlements and welfare (both corporate welfare and social welfare) and separate corporate interests from the politicians by reforming campaign finance.

  • @wenavi8289
    @wenavi8289 2 роки тому +2

    I want to hear the questions, why did u cut it off??! Ugh this was phenomenal

    • @byuspeeches
      @byuspeeches  2 роки тому +2

      As it says in the description, you can hear the question and answer session by listening to the audio version at speeches.byu.edu/talks/amy-chua/overcoming-political-tribalism/ or on the recent speeches podcast.

  • @ildenete3235
    @ildenete3235 2 роки тому +2

    De fato os jovens missionários se tornam pessoas ótimas e na comunidade

  • @rogerandkamiphillips7147
    @rogerandkamiphillips7147 2 роки тому +4

    Our diversity can unify us, let's make it happen. Thank you for inspired word Professor Amy Chia.

  • @amgania
    @amgania 2 роки тому +1

    Great talk. But where's the Q&A portion??????

    • @byuspeeches
      @byuspeeches  2 роки тому +2

      Hi Fred, the recording of the Q&A section isn’t available on our UA-cam. However, you can go to our site and you’ll be able to find the audio which has the entire Q&A period. From what I can tell, that section is about the same length as her speech. Hope this helps, and I hope you enjoy. -Ryan

  • @lindaledesmasoto6731
    @lindaledesmasoto6731 2 роки тому

    Brilliant!! Outstanding...THANK U!!

  • @jackiehowe0505
    @jackiehowe0505 2 роки тому

    Fantastic talk.

  • @crystalayers2933
    @crystalayers2933 2 роки тому

    It says in the last days, people who be lovers if themselves...think "Selfies". Think Tik-Tok & Instagram, etc.

  • @tmcg7254
    @tmcg7254 2 роки тому +5

    A very needed address, especially for this population.

  • @TempleScoop
    @TempleScoop 2 роки тому +1

    Amazing speech so many valid points made.- Chad James

  • @cmil80
    @cmil80 2 роки тому +1

    3 Nephi 7:2
    “And the people were divided one against another; and they did separate one from another into tribes, every man according to his family and his kindred and friends; and thus they did destroy the government of the land.”

  • @harryharrison6930
    @harryharrison6930 2 роки тому +3

    This is spoken in the secular language.
    Here is a translation for us religious people:
    44 But I say unto you, Love your
    enemies, bless them that curse
    you, do good to them that hate you,
    and pray for them which despitefully
    use you, and persecute you;
    For the full passage:
    38 Ye have heard that it hath
    been said, An eye for an eye, and
    a tooth for a tooth:
    39 But I say unto you, That ye resist
    not evil: but whosoever shall
    smite thee on thy right cheek, turn
    to him the other also.
    40 And if any man will sue thee
    at the law, and take away thy coat,
    let him have thy cloak also.
    41 And whosoever shall compel
    thee to go a mile, go with him twain.
    42 Give to him that asketh thee,
    and from him that would borrow
    of thee turn not thou away.
    43 Ye have heard that it hath
    been said, Thou shalt love thy
    neighbour, and hate thine enemy.
    44 But I say unto you, Love your
    enemies, bless them that curse
    you, do good to them that hate you,
    and pray for them which despitefully
    use you, and persecute you;
    45 That ye may be the children
    of your Father which is in heaven:
    for he maketh his sun to rise on
    the evil and on the good, and sendeth
    rain on the just and on the
    unjust.
    46 For if ye love them which love
    you, what reward have ye? do not
    even the publicans the same?
    47 And if ye salute your brethren
    only, what do ye more than others?
    do not even the publicans so?
    48 Be ye therefore perfect, even
    as your Father which is in heaven
    is perfect.
    From Matthew 5.
    I was tempted to prefix this verse with:
    Dis said in seh-cue-lor words.
    Is tra- trans- trensla- ...
    For me easy know. Here better words.
    :But I felt that was too much.

  • @Ryanhelpmeunderstand
    @Ryanhelpmeunderstand 2 роки тому +5

    Zion is the best model…

    • @greentree_
      @greentree_ 2 роки тому

      If it isn't with God, there's no hope. Only Zion will reach that goal now. It will only get worse until Zion.

  • @jimmyedwards1639
    @jimmyedwards1639 2 роки тому +9

    Did someone brief her ahead of time not to use “Mormon” when referring to the LDS denomination?

    • @caffeinatedsaints
      @caffeinatedsaints 2 роки тому +3

      Bruh you’re like those ppl that tell ppl to put a mask on when they walk into a store lmfo let her call us mormon

    • @Ryanhelpmeunderstand
      @Ryanhelpmeunderstand 2 роки тому +12

      @@caffeinatedsaints President Nelson told us to stand up for the correct name of the Church. No matter how small of a correction. This IS NOT comparable to telling someone to wear a mask. The Prophet of God has asked us to say the correct name of Christs Church/His people. That is not a light thing brother.

  • @ruthrodriguez7694
    @ruthrodriguez7694 2 роки тому

    Massive demographic transformation, when one group is overwhelmingly dominant, it can oppress or uplift

  • @dominicbailin2207
    @dominicbailin2207 2 роки тому +19

    I love her energy, but when she says that we need to remember what makes American exceptional, she forgets that there is an entire political party that doesn't believe America is exceptional. I believe in the exceptionalism of America; however, if an entire political party doesn't then the needed civil discourse has no starting point.

    • @benjaminb777
      @benjaminb777 2 роки тому +5

      Recognizing that there is a problem in the country you love is not the same as not believing America is exceptional. A doctor can diagnose a cancer or a disease and fight to get rid of it without hating the patient. Don’t assume that one side doesn’t think America is exceptional just because they point out a problem and fight to change it. That’s the whole point! Making an assumption about what others believe is the issue she’s talking about. One can love America and still criticize its flaws. Don’t be the problem you are pointing out. I can assume that when you say “an entire political party that doesn’t believe America is exceptional” that you are talking about one party when you may be talking about another. I certainly feel that one side is weakening American unity more than the other, yet you may feel it’s quite the opposite. I think she does an excellent job pointing out that BOTH sides are guilty of this type of thinking.

    • @Abogadoarizona
      @Abogadoarizona 2 роки тому +3

      I think you missed the whole point of her talk my friend.

    • @pererau
      @pererau 2 роки тому +2

      Presumably, if you are watching this video, you are LDS. In the church, we believe that repentance is one of the first principles and ordinances of the gospel. We believe that if we identify misbehaviors in our past, we should recognize, repair, and forsake them. This doesn't make us less exceptional; it helps make us more exceptional. I'm no leftist, but I've been able to grow past my fear of the left by trying to understand that point of view. Generally speaking, people on that side believe strongly in America, love her, cherish her strengths, and want to help each person receive her blessings. While I don't agree with some of the policy decisions they espouse to get there, please do not blind yourself to the good motivations of the good people on the other side from you. This kind of sweeping generalization you made is the kind of thing I used to say, and my life is so much richer over the last few years since I started making some efforts to see the world from other perspectives beyond my own.

    • @lukehanson_
      @lukehanson_ 2 роки тому +2

      She did mention in the talk that many on the Left believe America is evil so she does recognize that. Maybe you think she is too optimistic about it, but she's not ignorant of that point.

    • @natandjoec
      @natandjoec 2 роки тому

      You could not be any more correct. They are trying to destroy the very foundation that this nation was built on and replace it's history, meaning and intent. You can't get rid of a good thing until you tear it down, so you can replace it with something else. It is all intentional. Most all of it is based on lies, and it's replacement is far worse. Socialism, and broken families, and dependence on government will never be better than the constitution, faith in God, and strong families. Look to see what party most closely aligns with God's laws. Yes they are both flawed, but tearing down things that work because some things are not perfect is idiotic. Going full out to destroy the very things that made America exceptional in the first place is insane. And it is no accident.

  • @ruthrodriguez7694
    @ruthrodriguez7694 2 роки тому

    When groups feel threatened they close into tribalism

  • @ildenete3235
    @ildenete3235 2 роки тому

    Ou cantamos o hino da Cidade Celestial : Deus vêm e abençoe Sião que Te espera sem cessar com suas lâmpadas cheias.Essa terra está cheia de gente tão esforçada em Ti agradar!

  • @benjaminb777
    @benjaminb777 2 роки тому +7

    Reading through these comments I can easily detect a defensive stance from many of you. Your fears and your political leanings are obvious. I have something to say: you’re missing the point!
    Recognizing that there is a problem in the country you love is not the same as not believing in or loving America. A doctor can diagnose a cancer or a disease and fight to get rid of it without hating the patient. Don’t assume that one side doesn’t think America is great just because they point out a problem and fight to change it. That’s the whole point! Making an assumption about what others believe is the issue she’s talking about. One can love America and still criticize its flaws. Don’t be the problem you are pointing out. I can assume that when you say “that there is an entire political party that doesn’t believe America is exceptional” that you are talking about one party when you may be talking about another. I certainly feel that one side is weakening American unity more than the other, yet you may feel it’s quite the opposite. I think she does an excellent job pointing out that BOTH sides are guilty of this type of thinking. The fact that there are so many defensive comments towards this talk are evidence that it’s true. We are all Americans. Don’t assume that your team owns the monopoly on patriotism. In fact, maybe ask “is it I?” when examining division in our society.

    • @natandjoec
      @natandjoec 2 роки тому +6

      If you don't stand for something, you'll fall for anything. She is pointing out what she thinks is wrong with people in America, and we are doing the same with her talk. She says not to get your news from biased echo chambers, then she proceeds to use "information" that she got from the news that is absolutely incorrect. Yes, love is the answer in a world that is deeply divided by hate, but we can lovingly let her know where she is wrong. I have read the book of Mormon 17+ times, an enemy hath done this by Ezra Taft Benson, the naked communist by cleon skousen, and a handful of other books on the constitution and our nation. Make no mistake about it, the enemy is combined and is trying to destroy what God has set up. We all need to be very aware of the enemy and their tactics to defend the constitution, and our religion and our families. We can love our enemies to the point that we are kind in our discourse, but we do NOT bend on our beliefs and our GOD given freedoms. There has been a rise in hate and animosity due to freedoms being trampled on and abused. It becomes our civic duty to defend what is right. #captainMoroni

    • @lukehanson_
      @lukehanson_ 2 роки тому +5

      Certainly a fair point. But she does point out widespread distain for America coming from the left. We shouldn't assume every Democrat hates America. But we do need to acknowledge just like she did that is is prevalent in places of power that the left dominates. Both sides definitely have problems. Having now gone over it three times. I'm surprised by how little criticism she has for the right. The only explicit example she gives is a white nationalist conference (she must be referring to AFPAC). She had many examples on the left. I even asked her during the Q&A is she had more specifics on things that are problems on the right. She didn't. I asked the question because I very much want to address problems on my side of the political spectrum. She does say the problems are equally bad on both sides. I think I agree. What I wouldn't agree with is that the problems are equally prevalent. In other words ethno nationalism and hating Americans founders are both very bad ideas. But one is more ubiquitous than the other. Her talk seems to confirm this.

    • @blackjay5338
      @blackjay5338 2 роки тому

      I think she overstated the issue of right wingers promoting white supremacy. This is a Leftist trope, a manufactured problem made to profit the Left by stirring up more anger. Write supremacy is, and has been on life support, at least since I was a kid in the 80s and 90s.
      Does racism still exist? Sure. But it does not deserve the incessant talk on Leftist news outlets that it is getting. It's not that prevalent. It's a distraction from many more pressing issues.
      I think my point comports with Luke's reply comment above.

  • @Purriah
    @Purriah 2 роки тому

    I’m pro choice. That means pro choice when it comes to abortion. It also means pro choice when it comes to owning guns. It seems like almost no one can cope with the thought of someone having views and opinions that don’t align or fully disagree with either major American political party.

  • @ruthrodriguez7694
    @ruthrodriguez7694 2 роки тому +1

    Universalists terms

  • @natandjoec
    @natandjoec 2 роки тому +15

    Ok, I'm only like halfway through, but I couldn't disagree more. What this all comes down to, is sin. America has been too prosperous for too long. The people got proud and lazy and the enemy moved in to attack while our defenses were down. Make no mistake about it, there is a very real attempt to divide the people. It is not imagined, and it isn't due to a change in the dynamics of race, or which news station we watch, or even our economic class. We've had all of these things in the past and we were not as divided as we are now. The misinformation war going on is intentional and they are having a huge amount of success due to our wickedness. Nothing else. My son got chased out of his honors English class because he didn't go along with the critical race theory agenda being taught. He was respectful in his views, the the "other side" was not. They wanted violence. It goes to show you the cancel culture going on is huge and powerful, and it typically favors one set of beliefs over another. These are all facts.

    • @natandjoec
      @natandjoec 2 роки тому

      Ok, I just got a little further. She is correct about the constitution being the bedrock that this nation was founded on. So she should ask why there are groups and news stations who are actively trying to tear it down. Maybe I should finish the video first, but sheesh. Not everyone identifies with the left or right. Let's not take everything the media says as gospel. There are lots of people on both sides who don't agree with everything the media says about their side. The right has been grossly misrepresented and demonized. Ok. I'll finish the video

    • @guardianangel9517
      @guardianangel9517 2 роки тому +4

      I agree about sin taking over, even the fact that the Gaddiantons are behind this.
      If you would have finished listening to this speaker, you'd have seen that she's got a WONDERFUL take on solutions and ways to mend communications between diverse people.
      That's one of our problems as a society, that people don't want to LISTEN to each other. Everyone can't just overtalk one another constantly.

    • @harryharrison6930
      @harryharrison6930 2 роки тому +2

      First, I agree that there are very immoral things going on in the world and in this country. I also disagree with some of her points. Some of her points do have truth to them.
      My starting advice is this scripture:
      44 But I say unto you, Love your
      enemies, bless them that curse
      you, do good to them that hate you,
      and pray for them which despitefully
      use you, and persecute you;
      Remember to love others. If nothing else, they are a children of God and God does love them.
      Persecution is very painful, but if we hold fast to our teaching and beliefs, God will support us.
      It may take time, as even the people of Alma weren't immediately delivered from affliction.
      I am sorry with what your family has to go through.
      You shouldn't rebuke people when they are trying to do good. People aren't all knowing and can only learn so quickly. My experience tells me that learning is slow and hard. As such if a person does err, that person should be corrected with love and compassion. If you read through Exodus, you will see that Moses made a good number of mistakes. God still supported him because he was honestly trying to do good.
      If nothing else, we do have the 11th Article of Faith. I believe this applies to all beliefs as part of being on Earth is for people to utilize their agency.

    • @Livhappy25
      @Livhappy25 2 роки тому +1

      Agree

    • @cici7739
      @cici7739 2 роки тому +1

      There's no doubt sin plays a big part, but the secular and spiritual are intrinsically linked in mortality. Both sides have contributing factors

  • @ruthrodriguez7694
    @ruthrodriguez7694 2 роки тому

    christians feel threatened, 8:59