@Claire Shang it's not that serious, it could just be the most confusing lore THEY've ever known, or they could have not known about loona, or they could just simply see it as more confusing even if they do know about loona, so many possibilities, no need to fight over it.
Actually, it's a very common problem in korean culture. People tend to keep to themselves, avoid direct contact and it always leads to misunderstandings and passive aggression
MOA deserves a Clown of the Year award So true Also your name is true,But I think it’s true for all bighit stans because we ARMY’s be clowning the heck out of life right now lol
I have some thoughts I wanna share: 1) In the Nap of a Star MV, when Yeonjun is in his room and first realises he has horns, the lamp starts flickering when he approaches the mirror. I'm thinking that this could be morse code (although I'm only just learning morse code currently so If anyone knows it well, maybe just check it out and see) 2) This is complete speculation but, like we've discussed, the bear represents all of the members' pains- except for HueningKai's wings. What if his secret is his wings, which is why they're not actually depicted in the bear. Maybe, he realised that his members wanted to protect him and his innocence, and because his other pain is in his heart (so is trggered by the other members feeling pain) he kept his wings a secret to not hurt the other members and to let them believe he is still innocent. His angelic wings (NOAS M/V) are fake and mechanical, and perhaps are what he shows his members, rather than showing them his true wings which are the devil/dragon wings (Eternally M/V) 3) As mentioned, one of Kai's pains is his heart. This suggests that he feels pain when the other members feel pain. Perhaps, this pain may have started when baby Kai saw Soobin at the star festival in Eternally MV. As we see, he walks through the magic circle, runs past Soobin but then stops and looks at him. When Soobin saw baby Kai at the festival, it reminded him of the innocence he so deserately wants to protect, causing him to feel pain and sadness. Kai may have noticed this look of pain, and so he ran away to stop seeing Soobin in pain. However, because he ran through a magic circle, he was able to retain this memory of Soobin from the future seeing HueningKai of the past, thus causing Kai to have a pain in his heart, and a desire to stop his friends' pain. (This is kinda farfetched but I still thought it was possible) I'm kinda new to the whole theorising thing, so I'm not sure if these theories (speculations rather) contradict existing theories with actual evidence, so sorry if that's the case. Also, if you've actually reached the end of this essay, thank you for reading it and also sorry for any typos I may have missed lol. Have a nice day
@@LainaSunflower Is it actually?! Omg thanks so much I tried to solve it but I'm not advanced enough in Morse code to figure it out 😅 Also thanks so much for liking my theory/speculation, it means a lot to me!💜 I love your theories!!
im not so sure about the second one- but i think your on the right track with the third one- so heres what im thinking #2: to me i think the reason why his wings aren't depicted on the bear is because the pain in his heart is already depicted and i think its kinda like- they all get ONE pain depicted but i could be wrong, and as for them not knowing about his wings and stuff so hes using fake ones- i think that might be wrong ish too. What im thinking is that, like their song "angel or devil" i think that Nap of the star, is kinda like- "heaven" if you will, cause magic island is a magical happy place where even though they all felt pain in their own ways, they were still happy with each other and got through things together so it was a happy place and everything, so their mystical selves were like, the good versions of their monsters, where as with eternally its the dark place. Like, the place has fallen to ruins, their surrounded by darkness, and they feel alone and like they are apart from each other, aka not happy anymore. So since Nap of the star was they happy and mystical ver, eternally is the dark, and sad version, so their appearances are going to change as well, so going from the bright and happy mystical creatures, so dark and sad devils. ( i hope that made sense) #3 : now with this one im not sure, but i think you could be on to something here, but ill need to do a little more research on it to see ^^ (Also im new to the whole "theories" thing so im sorry if i get my ideas and stuff wrong XD )
@@lilyannakim1616 i rlly like your he’ll vs heaven theory but the thing that makes me believe her kai wings theory is that fact that the first wings are mechanical and the second are actually attached to his body & are made of flesh
I feel like YJ got the cut on the throat because he has problems speaking out about things he's done wrong. Not that he doesn't know he did, he DOES know to some extent but he has no idea how to apologize what to say what to to the right timing and stuff like that so he keeps it to himself
My mother: "Hurry up we need to go soon!" Me: already ready for like 20 minutes only waiting for my parents Also me: "wait can I finish this Video real quick?" My mothter: "how long?" Me: "...40 minutes"
I think Bomgyu is a very interesting character, because on the one side he wants to help and heal everybody, but on the other side he sometimes seems aggressive and also has some lines that can be seen in a brutal or destructive way.
I read online that geckos are messengers of good luck so that ties in with HUENINGKAI being lucky and also I read that geckos symbolizes hope and rebirth
Hope and rebirth? Oh so maybe Kai is also going to have a hand at keeping everyones hopes up, and maybe after they all fix things, maybe Kai will help create a new future for them
What if the 'promise' in Yeonjun's star photo card has a dubble meaning! Obviously it is the promise with the boys/star, BUT what if he made a promise with the cat? If that is the case then the "this isn't just ANY promise, it's a promise for all of us" could be a reference to the line "back then I thought it [the cat] was salvation". Did Yeonjun make a promise with the cat so that they would be ETERNALLY connected?
@@LainaSunflower I know right! While it is on the side of speculation, this mini-theory has some legs to stand on! Why is txt in a time loop? Cause Yeonjun made a promise/deal with the cat to be eternally linked to a friend group. Yeonjun is lonely after all and so maybe it was an act of desperation! Also in NOAS, Yeonjun only runs into the boys AFTER he was cut by the cat! The cat had to have hurt YJ so that he would run away (pun not intended). Thank you for liking the theory, I'm slowly having a mental breakdown over trying to solve this whole thing
@@LainaSunflower hey, can i add on to this thought? So personally i think that Birch right, probably- anyway so my idea is that in the nap of the star the promise Yeonjun made to the cat is that they all would be together forever, but you already know that, so- since he said "it's a promise for all of us" he promised the cat they would stay together no matter what- having said that remember in this video Laina said that there might be two cats? You know one cat thats good, that always tries to help them when they need, and the evil one thats always watching them, and trying to hurt them? Well what if he made the promise to the evil cat in nap of the star? Maybe the evil cats purpose is to cause chaos and destruction, aka its trying to keep them all apart. The cat might have tricked Yeonjun into making that promise, just so it could torment them all and hurt them. Yeonjun also says "back then I thought it [the cat] was salvation" But maybe he says this because my theory is right, the evil cat tricked him into making the promise by pretending to help him, but in reality the cat is ruining their friendships some how, maybe thats why Yeonjun thinks that all this is his fault, why he always says hes guilty, and why we keep seeing him dead a few times because hes trying to fix his mistake.
@@BirchOfficial I really like this idea that Yeonjun made a promise with the cat that he thought would save them/keep them together, but what I'm thinking is that it probably was more of a deal than a promise. We don't know if the cat is actually good or evil, or if we go with the theory that there might be two cats, we don't know which one Yeonjun encountered, but when Yeonjun encounters the cat, he already has his horns, which are one of his pains. So, if he asked the cat to keep them together/save them, maybe the cat asked for something in return, perhaps his voice, thus hurting Yeonjun's throat? It might even tie to his guilt, he made a deal that perhaps cost all of them. I really don't know lol, I'm a baby MOA and I just spent the past few hours trying to analyze everything and it's my first time theorizing so I'm sorry if it doesn't make sense or contradicts itself or other clues.
I’m really late to this but what if THAT promise with the cat is actually the thing that he did horribly wrong/ regrets and blames himself for? cuz what if that promise is the main factor for the chaos and causes his friends deep sufferings maybeee?
So true! I really don't want to understand the concept I want the songs the personality and the visuals and the goofiness of the idols that's what I want!!!
I like the way she talks. Usually when someone explains their theories to me I get bored. But when she does it its like Ear Candy for me. (BTW I agree with her theory, mostly cause it also connects and goes well with my first theory of the tU)
Pluss seokjin has to find the book called map of the soul!!! Somewhere i read that his father was also finding that book and in beomgyu's part in eternally mv he's trying to protect a book from someone... the book possibly could be map of the soul and the guy gyu was fighting with could be possibly SEOKJINs father!!???
About Seokjin’s dad...... It is heavily implied in the BU that Seokjin’s father is related to what’s going on with the boys, and I think maybe that he went through the same thing as a child but eventually gave up and abandoned his friends. And in Taehyun’s concept photo for Star he says “what we are going through, someone else has gone through.” That line immediately made me think of Seokjin’s father in the BU, even before I saw your connection with the desks..... and now the desk point even more to some connection of Seokjin’s father with the TU?? It makes me think Seokjin’s father definitely has something to do with all of this and might be the connection between the BU and TU somehow. I also find it interesting that in the BU, the boys are looking for the “Map of the Soul” which they think will save them. The boys seem to think this is a book and it has been shown to have strong connections to Seokjin’s father. And now we see Beomgyu fighting with *someone* over a book, possibly taking place in Seokjin’s father’s office. IDK. I don’t have much in the way of theories here, I don’t know what this stuff might mean. But these are all connections I’ve noticed so I wanted to point them out!
Okay okay, mind blown. I also have one theory. What if in the BU, when they say a friend of Seokjin's dad got lost, he went to the magic Island and thus Seokjin's dad too. Also, I am kind of coflicted with an Idea I have, because the facts don't really match my speculations, but here it goes. What if the TU happens before the BU, like Seokjin's dad has something to do with the txt boys, or in a non too possible situation, is one of them. Like the two universes coexist, but are different at the same time, and somehow his dad traveled from TU to BU. Cause like we have seen TxT universe has more innate magic than the BU. Or something around that. I really hope this makes sense, and all critics are welcomed. We're all trying to build something up from this beautiful mess.
This can’t happen because these two universes are different but they collide in magic island so if this happened they both are in magic island (sorry if it doesn’t make sense lol)
Why is no one talking about how in the dream chapter star and magic photo cards they're holding the parts which have their pains: Yeonjun: His Throat Soobin: His ear Beomgyu: His shoulder Taehyun: Covering his eye Hueningkai: Holding his chest "Heart"
Yeonjun's cut on his throat also appears for a second in the Magic Island video. It's in the sequence after they're all run over by the train and there's a second where it shows Yeonjun grabbing onto his throat in pain.
50:22 5!! (5 can be read 'O' in korean) 5!! 5!!!! Beomgyu can't choose sides between following 'star song' (taehyun soobin) or 'odd eye cat' (yeonjun hueningkai)!!!!!! It seems like soobin is closer to find their promise and the star. So he tries to make his other friends follow him and taehyun realized it so taehyun observed soobin more. And it seems like yeonjun already found it yet he didn't know? (I don't understand this either) The irony is beomgyu is so 'pressured' (on his shoulder) to keep everyone in the group safe (not being hurt), but he started to not be able to trust them. Huening Kai is the one who maintains the group's positivity, but he's the one who's being blinded from things that might crack their friendship. Maybe that's why taehyun's item is airpod (or headphone)? 'Defeaning' voices around him so he can be focused to see more, but it ended up making him distant too?
I dont know if this information helps but it kinda supports the theory of having 2 cats Cause in the "SAVE ME" ep 1..Jin mentioned 2 different voices calling him...I'm pretty sure he said it after waking up the 3rd time after talking to the other cat...he suddenly heard a voice talking about turning back time to save everyone..he then woke up saying "its a different voice from last time"...
YESSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!! I've been so conflicted about this because in Save Me there are clearly two beings interacting with Jin, the one at the beach and the one that explains to him how to remember the timelines. Also, I'm not sure if it has to do with something about changing the design or not, but the first "cat" that appeared in save me was WHITE, so I'm LOSING my mind over it. Still not sure if it was intentional, or if it was just a change in the design. Help.
About Hyuka and the gecko, a gecko can shed their skin right? So what if it’s smth like Hyuka shedding/losing his “innocence” as he learns more about what’s going on? Or maybe it’s parallel to how he changed(?) from having angel to more devil like wings(like shedding old skin and having new one)? Just thoughts🤷♀️ take them with a grain of salt lol
I noticed something. Although it might be useless here you go: So Laina was talking about there being two cats. If we look back at it then it makes sense a little bit. *We saw a cat without those cat-like pupils with Jin in BU and Yeonjun's side angle in Nap of A Star. Notice how anything bad did not happen. *There is that cat with those pupils which appears in front of Soobin in the concept trailer of Eternity, in front of Yeonjun in Nap of A Star, Magic Island and Eternally. That is when all the bad things seem to happen. I know this isn't a solid theory with proof, but if you see this, please reply and share your opinions on this.
*2 dislikes from Hitman Bang himself from 2 different accounts because Laina might have unveiled their future plans lmao.* Seriously tho. I got too many goosebumps watching and listening to this.
im four months late here oops. but think beomgyu being the diamond is so interesting. diamonds form under extreme pressure, which would relate to the the “weight” he feels on his shoulders. this intense pressure physically appears in diamonds in the form of inclusions, similar to how beomgyu’s pressure manifests as the spikes on his back. it also relates to the butterfly imagery, since out of this extreme pressure, he is going to blossom and become a diamond/butterfly (metaphorically). it’s also interesting to note that diamonds have come to be associated with wedding/engagement rings. in other words, they represent a promise or vow to stay together forever, similar to the promise the boys made when they were children.
What if TXT is the bridge universe between bu and gu and their fate will decide whether they will ever meet or not!! Because in highlight reel everyone had a girl except jimin which means 6 member that of Gfriend.And jimin saw Yeonjun dead in taehyun's timeline may be.May be Jungkook and Soobin has kind of same character in universes.Beomgyu and Taehyung might have similar character and Yeonjun and Suga binds as they are related to fire and are always causing fire which causes trouble.Taehyun and RM kinda searching for things. Kai and Jhope and Jimin kind of connects to innocence i guess.And tbh i am not so similar with gfriend so I don't know! May be BTS and TXT connects more as they are originally formed solely in bighit.
i think the ‘cat’ that appears in front of soobin isn’t actually the cat, i think it’s the dragon in the eternally mv, it’s eyes are smaller and farther apart than the actual cats eyes
Also for soobin... did anyone notice this? In the starboard concept photos, on txt’s “instagram” where they have the short clips next to their pfp? Kinda like stories? And they open their hands to show necklaces with locks and then close their hands in the second clip, its been a while since i looked but soobins hand (you can tell by his sleeve) the necklace chain is wrapped around his hand whereas the other members just have the necklace resting in their palms So maybe thats to show soobins trapped somehow,
Ok so I don't know if anyone ever talked about this but my take on the cat is that is not actually good o evil, but instead is a creature that provides certain abilities to people or makes them go through some situations to teach them a lesson for their own good. For example, in Seokjin's case, it gaves him the ability to go back in time to help his friends, so we perceive the cat as a good creature because it gives Seokjin a "tool" for him to use in order to give his friends a happy ending. But in TxT's case, we see the cat as an evil creature because what is happening with them actually causes them pain. Well, is causes pain to Seokjin aswell because he's going through the pain of failure every time something messes up with the improvements he makes in every timeline. I also don't think their starting situations are provoked by the cat. I mean, yeah, they go through pain, but I believe is the cat's way to teach them life lessons, especially them since in their storyline they are portrayed as highschool students (even though Yeonjun and Soobin are on the doors of adulthood in real life) a.k.a. teenagers, a phase in our lives where we go through so much and different kinds of pain (kind of relates to the BU aswell since in their storyline they met at highschool). So, in conclusion, I don't actually think there are two cats, I believe is just one and we perceive it in a different light depending on what it does in each universe. I hope this makes sense or is at least understandable lol, English isn't my first language so sorry if there's any mistakes :')
Yes this, they make it seem like the cat is an evil one that is trying to lead them to their downfall fall but the cat is really like a guide for them, it’s like they try to show them the consequences that come when they choose different idk, but I don’t think the cat is evil.
@@youngk001 I actually don't think is good or evil itself, as I said, we see it differently depending on which universe we're seeing, because if it wasn't for the cat's "gift" to Seokjin to go back in time, he wouldn't be able to even try to help his friends. Now it's similar un TU since it seems like Soobin is able to go back in time aswell, but their situations are portrayed so different from the BU that we see them go through pain constantly and the cat is always there so it seems like it's evil, but at the end of the day we never know lol, anything is possible in this multiverse haha.
I had a thought the other day about who Beomgyu could have been fighting in Eternally. I'm pretty sure the different timelines and stuff reflect each other, and that something that is in another timeline will show one way or another in a different one. Yeonjun appears dead in a few of the other member's visions, and in Beomgyu's, he (Beomgyu) is seen fighting someone before there are blood splatters or something all over the wall and he doesn't seem to be anxious about the person he was fighting getting up again, most likely meaning that the person is dead. I think it could be Yeonjun because of that. Also, in the first scene, Soobin gives the book to Yeonjun, maybe showing that Yeonjun was trying to get the book. So, if Yeonjun was trying to get the book, he could've been trying to get it from Beomgyu in his vision as well. This is all assuming that the things that the members saw in Eternally was different timelines through dreams and visions or something along those lines. It's also assuming that actions reflect throughout all the timelines and everything will appear (even though it might be represented in a different way, like the boy's pain going from more of a mental thing to physical pains as well as being represented through the bear or the bad memories/mistakes becoming fire). Still, if the reflection thing is right, then it could also be Taehyun because of when Beomgyu and Taehyun fought in a different timeline with CYSM as well as the fact that Taehyun was wearing the same clothes as the guy fighting Beomgyu at the beginning of the Eternally mv. I could also just be crazy lol.
@@ruhirathore79 in save me webtoon, jimin and hobi I think, are in a hospital and they meet this kid who has narcolepsy just like jhops's character in the story. The doctors mention that the kid's surname is Choi so armys and moas were speculating that the kid might be Somone from TXT but it's hard to tell which one it is cuz there are three choi s in TXT however I feel like it's probably soobin and if not him then it's yeonjun
Btw, what if Taehyun isn't actually looking for a patern in their loop, but looking at other timeliness (like Bts or Gfriend) and see if they could resolve their problems and replicate their actions... I'm going crazy lol
Yeonjun started a campfire at the fantasy world (forest), that can also connect to the end of run away where they burn the door because the forest is all burnt and they can’t go there anymore to feel happy. That also can be the reason why the members are mad at him in the can’t you see me music video.
okay txt universe is a lot more interesting than i thought... i've always just listened the songs and watched the music videos as they are haha :D KFKSKDJFKLWKQJF LUV THIS
The way I came to this video thinking “oh I’ll just watch it and do what I need to do a bit later” then looking at the whole time this video is like 👁👄👁
please read!!! oh my god wait i was watching people react to the txt eternally mv just now and noticed something, i just had to come back here to comment something- so basically, when beomgyu is watching himself in room 17 fighting with an unknown person, there is like a dear head on the wall, usually those have horns and stuff on it. the horns on their head resemble yeonjuns horns in the theory of him being a monster and everything like that! i dont know what this means but maybe it could be yeonjun he's fighting with????
2 really basic observations: 1. Their birthdays being mentioned because of constellations and how that ties into stars/the Star. 2. The Devil/Angel imagery because they will all as a group or as individuals, have to make a choice and the consequences of their actions which they haven't considered or have considered to the point of stagnation/impulsivity. also ua-cam.com/video/Q4jkD2eLja4/v-deo.html: The painting behind Beomgyu! The new teaser being called Temptation!
17:05 the cat's eye colors are flipped. In every other scene the cat has the left eye blue and the right one green. The fact that it happened when Soobin saw it is kinda weird since (as you said) it is almost always Yeonjun who sees it. Idk if that actually means something or I'm reading too much into it.
an almost hour long video from one of my favourite youtubers about one of my ult groups? yes please aND IT HAS A PART 2? SIGN ME UP 🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️
23:32 everytime you mention a festival i can't help but remember aboyt the masks in enhypens given-taken mv, and is also in the outro: Cross the Line mv
You mentioned the conflict of choosing between angel and the devil. I think this connects to the song because there was a line "tell me what I should choose between an angel and a devil"
The fact that I just watched a 57 minutes video and understand nothing... I hope that's enough to show you how big my brain is🙃 And why watched it in the first place?? It's a Laina Sunflower video, you actually thought it being 57 minhtes would stop me from watching the whole thing?!
At 33:11 when he had a horn sigh in cysm choreography it could represent yeonjun and that he wants to be at yeonjun’s place and want to be the main character!!!
I just realized that when Yeonjun's and Huening Kai's pains are combined, they form a devil (The horns and the devil wings). Soobin's and Taehyun's pain (The eye and the ears) form an elf. The elf kind of reminds me of Legolas or any elf from Lord of the Rings, as the elves have enhanced vision. This links to the fact that Taehyun is a detective. I think (I'm not sure) that elves in general have sensitive hearing, which shows how Soobin could hear the frequencies at Magic Island. Perhaps the two will team up in the future to gain information about their quest. That would be really fun!
alright this is definitely gonna be a long comment bc a theory popped into my head while watching your video. It seems that the end goal of the boys is to save Yeonjun, as its shown multiple times that he is the one being targeted by the cat and is the one who's always dying. (it's likely that he's being targeted bc of whatever he did in the past that he's *guilty* of) And so, in the other members' individual quests to save Yeonjun, they acquire a certain *"magic"* that will help them. In my theory, Soobin's magic is the die, Beomgyu's is the book, Taehyun's is possibly the clue that he's searching for, and Kai might just be magic himself (like you said, he did go through the magic circle as a child). The only problem is that none of these are strong enough to save Yeonjun on their own and right now, they're all trying to fix everything by themselves. That's why they need to come together and unite their magics to save Yeonjun and fulfill their promise to the star at the same time.
So when you are talking about the “two” cats it reminds me a lot of the zodiac sign, Gemini to be exact, with the whole two sides of the same coin sort of thing. And then I thought what if there is only one cat. The two eyes symbolizes its different personality. The mean one and the nice one. The one that wants to help and the one that wants to destroy
Okay i don’t know why but this makes mi think of Gfriend a lot and its because two members are Gemini (Sinb and Eunha) also i connect this to them because in the behind scenes of apple MV there is a moment were to two (eunbi’s; yes they share their real name too ) said that one of them its good and the other the evil! I dont know if this makes sense but i found interesting!🤔🤔
33:13 i dont think they are horns. to me, it seems like how koreans touch thumbs to lock their pinky promise. hes the only one with the thumb and pinky while yeonjun and kai only have their pinky meaning they didnt lock it or something idk
![TXT TIMELINE EXPLAINED | (+U EXPLAINED PART 2) [OUTDATED]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I8sPZeb16IA/mqdefault.jpg)
unpopular opinion: big hit has the most confusing yet creative storylines in kpop
the loona lore would like to know your location
@@moonflower8890 😳
loonaverse says hi.
@@trashgoblin4476 glad we're on the same page lol, my mind went straight to loonaverse when I read the original comment xd
@Claire Shang it's not that serious, it could just be the most confusing lore THEY've ever known, or they could have not known about loona, or they could just simply see it as more confusing even if they do know about loona, so many possibilities, no need to fight over it.
communication.... the one thing EVERYONE in the Bighit Universe is lacking
PREACH lol
Yeah seriously bro
For real 😭
Actually, it's a very common problem in korean culture. People tend to keep to themselves, avoid direct contact and it always leads to misunderstandings and passive aggression
@@blank_line korean culture? I think people are like that in general not just korean culture
MOAs have 10 braincells, and laina have them all!
Lmao 😂😂😂
MOA deserves a Clown of the Year award So true
Also your name is true,But I think it’s true for all bighit stans because we ARMY’s be clowning the heck out of life right now lol
xd
I have noneshjdjks Also, your name tho 🤡🤡🤡
I'm special! I only have half a braincell left :D
great, now my braincells can do something other than losing themselves.
Lol 😅😌😂 love this coment 😌😌😌
My brain cells were thinking the same
wait, you have braincells?
@@Anna-ep3jl omg my brain cells were also thinking that about themselves 😱
Wait y’all are getting brain cells
People say kpop isn't that deep
Meanwhile the kpop:
fr
Ikr
AH YES NOTHING BETTER THAN TO WATCH A 50+min TXT'S UNIVERSE VIDEO AT 2:00 AM
Honestly the ideal situation 😌
same I'm watching this at 2AM
12:34 am here
ITS LITERALLY 2:00am EXACTLY RN AND HERE I AM DNSNFNSNDN
3:33 here
Laina: Everyone dies!
Me: *takes a big sip of tea*
lol
me just now: actually takes a sip of the tea that's next to me- *SiPinG oF tHe tEa eNsUes*
I'm not even 5 minutes into the video-
You think I'm gonna watch a 57 minutes' video?
You are damn right!
Didn't know it was a 57 minutes video!!😂😂 I'm surprised I finished it before knowing it was that long😂
you think I'm gonna watch a 57 minutes' video that isn't even in my first language?
yes, you think right
@@minhiyori6782 I though i was the only one lol
@@SherryMoon02 nop loool
@@트메야모아야 omg r8 even though it's so long it was so interesting
I think my brain is going to be too small for this.
Laina: speeds up her talk about the movie
me: bro, I need the tea
*slows down vid to 0.5 speed*
AlRiGhT gImMe ThE sPoIlErS uWu
I have some thoughts I wanna share:
1) In the Nap of a Star MV, when Yeonjun is in his room and first realises he has horns, the lamp starts flickering when he approaches the mirror. I'm thinking that this could be morse code (although I'm only just learning morse code currently so If anyone knows it well, maybe just check it out and see)
2) This is complete speculation but, like we've discussed, the bear represents all of the members' pains- except for HueningKai's wings. What if his secret is his wings, which is why they're not actually depicted in the bear. Maybe, he realised that his members wanted to protect him and his innocence, and because his other pain is in his heart (so is trggered by the other members feeling pain) he kept his wings a secret to not hurt the other members and to let them believe he is still innocent. His angelic wings (NOAS M/V) are fake and mechanical, and perhaps are what he shows his members, rather than showing them his true wings which are the devil/dragon wings (Eternally M/V)
3) As mentioned, one of Kai's pains is his heart. This suggests that he feels pain when the other members feel pain. Perhaps, this pain may have started when baby Kai saw Soobin at the star festival in Eternally MV. As we see, he walks through the magic circle, runs past Soobin but then stops and looks at him. When Soobin saw baby Kai at the festival, it reminded him of the innocence he so deserately wants to protect, causing him to feel pain and sadness. Kai may have noticed this look of pain, and so he ran away to stop seeing Soobin in pain. However, because he ran through a magic circle, he was able to retain this memory of Soobin from the future seeing HueningKai of the past, thus causing Kai to have a pain in his heart, and a desire to stop his friends' pain. (This is kinda farfetched but I still thought it was possible)
I'm kinda new to the whole theorising thing, so I'm not sure if these theories (speculations rather) contradict existing theories with actual evidence, so sorry if that's the case. Also, if you've actually reached the end of this essay, thank you for reading it and also sorry for any typos I may have missed lol. Have a nice day
The Light in NOAS is Morse code! It says “save me” 💜
@@LainaSunflower Is it actually?! Omg thanks so much I tried to solve it but I'm not advanced enough in Morse code to figure it out 😅 Also thanks so much for liking my theory/speculation, it means a lot to me!💜 I love your theories!!
Holy cow that second one though!!! I can totally see that!!
im not so sure about the second one- but i think your on the right track with the third one- so heres what im thinking
#2: to me i think the reason why his wings aren't depicted on the bear is because the pain in his heart is already depicted and i think its kinda like- they all get ONE pain depicted but i could be wrong, and as for them not knowing about his wings and stuff so hes using fake ones- i think that might be wrong ish too. What im thinking is that, like their song "angel or devil" i think that Nap of the star, is kinda like- "heaven" if you will, cause magic island is a magical happy place where even though they all felt pain in their own ways, they were still happy with each other and got through things together so it was a happy place and everything, so their mystical selves were like, the good versions of their monsters, where as with eternally its the dark place. Like, the place has fallen to ruins, their surrounded by darkness, and they feel alone and like they are apart from each other, aka not happy anymore. So since Nap of the star was they happy and mystical ver, eternally is the dark, and sad version, so their appearances are going to change as well, so going from the bright and happy mystical creatures, so dark and sad devils. ( i hope that made sense)
#3 : now with this one im not sure, but i think you could be on to something here, but ill need to do a little more research on it to see ^^
(Also im new to the whole "theories" thing so im sorry if i get my ideas and stuff wrong XD )
@@lilyannakim1616 i rlly like your he’ll vs heaven theory but the thing that makes me believe her kai wings theory is that fact that the first wings are mechanical and the second are actually attached to his body & are made of flesh
I feel like YJ got the cut on the throat because he has problems speaking out about things he's done wrong. Not that he doesn't know he did, he DOES know to some extent but he has no idea how to apologize what to say what to to the right timing and stuff like that so he keeps it to himself
My mother: "Hurry up we need to go soon!"
Me: already ready for like 20 minutes only waiting for my parents
Also me: "wait can I finish this Video real quick?"
My mothter: "how long?"
Me: "...40 minutes"
tell them it's 20 minutes long. their sense of time is VERY bad.
I think Bomgyu is a very interesting character, because on the one side he wants to help and heal everybody, but on the other side he sometimes seems aggressive and also has some lines that can be seen in a brutal or destructive way.
i was kinda confused about yeonjuns photocards because bighit has taught me that if it’s easy to understand, it’s wrong
I read online that geckos are messengers of good luck so that ties in with HUENINGKAI being lucky and also I read that geckos symbolizes hope and rebirth
Hope and rebirth? Oh so maybe Kai is also going to have a hand at keeping everyones hopes up, and maybe after they all fix things, maybe Kai will help create a new future for them
also, wasn't kai holding a gecko in the sugar rush ride mv?
the tu is literally better than half of the crap I've seen on Netflix wtf--
IKR
It’s better than any crap I’ve ever watched
for real
What if the 'promise' in Yeonjun's star photo card has a dubble meaning!
Obviously it is the promise with the boys/star, BUT what if he made a promise with the cat?
If that is the case then the "this isn't just ANY promise, it's a promise for all of us" could be a reference to the line "back then I thought it [the cat] was salvation".
Did Yeonjun make a promise with the cat so that they would be ETERNALLY connected?
Ohhhh I like this 👀
@@LainaSunflower I know right! While it is on the side of speculation, this mini-theory has some legs to stand on!
Why is txt in a time loop? Cause Yeonjun made a promise/deal with the cat to be eternally linked to a friend group. Yeonjun is lonely after all and so maybe it was an act of desperation!
Also in NOAS, Yeonjun only runs into the boys AFTER he was cut by the cat! The cat had to have hurt YJ so that he would run away (pun not intended).
Thank you for liking the theory, I'm slowly having a mental breakdown over trying to solve this whole thing
@@LainaSunflower hey, can i add on to this thought? So personally i think that Birch right, probably- anyway so my idea is that in the nap of the star the promise Yeonjun made to the cat is that they all would be together forever, but you already know that, so- since he said "it's a promise for all of us" he promised the cat they would stay together no matter what- having said that remember in this video Laina said that there might be two cats? You know one cat thats good, that always tries to help them when they need, and the evil one thats always watching them, and trying to hurt them? Well what if he made the promise to the evil cat in nap of the star? Maybe the evil cats purpose is to cause chaos and destruction, aka its trying to keep them all apart. The cat might have tricked Yeonjun into making that promise, just so it could torment them all and hurt them. Yeonjun also says "back then I thought it [the cat] was salvation" But maybe he says this because my theory is right, the evil cat tricked him into making the promise by pretending to help him, but in reality the cat is ruining their friendships some how, maybe thats why Yeonjun thinks that all this is his fault, why he always says hes guilty, and why we keep seeing him dead a few times because hes trying to fix his mistake.
@@BirchOfficial I really like this idea that Yeonjun made a promise with the cat that he thought would save them/keep them together, but what I'm thinking is that it probably was more of a deal than a promise. We don't know if the cat is actually good or evil, or if we go with the theory that there might be two cats, we don't know which one Yeonjun encountered, but when Yeonjun encounters the cat, he already has his horns, which are one of his pains. So, if he asked the cat to keep them together/save them, maybe the cat asked for something in return, perhaps his voice, thus hurting Yeonjun's throat? It might even tie to his guilt, he made a deal that perhaps cost all of them. I really don't know lol, I'm a baby MOA and I just spent the past few hours trying to analyze everything and it's my first time theorizing so I'm sorry if it doesn't make sense or contradicts itself or other clues.
I’m really late to this but what if THAT promise with the cat is actually the thing that he did horribly wrong/ regrets and blames himself for? cuz what if that promise is the main factor for the chaos and causes his friends deep sufferings maybeee?
Ok just a crack thought: the chalks Kai draws with is him trying to choose between Yeonjun's blue and yellow hair.
Lol I'm sorry-
Seems legit 😂
**your mind**
My braincells: **non-existent**
Me: **still continues to watch**
Haha... Same here loll
So true!
I really don't want to understand the concept I want the songs the personality and the visuals and the goofiness of the idols that's what I want!!!
I like the way she talks. Usually when someone explains their theories to me I get bored. But when she does it its like Ear Candy for me.
(BTW I agree with her theory, mostly cause it also connects and goes well with my first theory of the tU)
ikr the way she talks makes it more entertaining, also we can see her face and that adds a lot to it being more interesting
Yeah, same..
@@evelinramosmiranda619 and her face also speak to us in entertain way, which make 57 mins felt like 57 sec.
Ok when you said _let's start_ I got an ad of a chicken screaming... That's gonna be my brain throughout this video
🤣🤡
UA-cam wtf 😂😂😂
@@LainaSunflower youtube how did you know
༎ຶ‿༎ຶ
You made me laugh 😂😂
The last part gave me GOOSEBUMPS SKGHKSJDKSHDJDSN
EXACTLY!!!!
Omg same
HELP?????? I DONT GET IT😭😭 BEOMGYU OR ANYONE IN TXT COULD BE SEOKJINS FATHER???????
Pluss seokjin has to find the book called map of the soul!!! Somewhere i read that his father was also finding that book and in beomgyu's part in eternally mv he's trying to protect a book from someone... the book possibly could be map of the soul and the guy gyu was fighting with could be possibly SEOKJINs father!!???
@@junniegyus5873 your mind wtf i love it
sjbdksjsj i'm feeling so powerful at the fact i know what you're gonna say and talk about-
SHHHHH
Sameee😂😂
discord squad 😌✨
About Seokjin’s dad......
It is heavily implied in the BU that Seokjin’s father is related to what’s going on with the boys, and I think maybe that he went through the same thing as a child but eventually gave up and abandoned his friends.
And in Taehyun’s concept photo for Star he says “what we are going through, someone else has gone through.” That line immediately made me think of Seokjin’s father in the BU, even before I saw your connection with the desks.....
and now the desk point even more to some connection of Seokjin’s father with the TU?? It makes me think Seokjin’s father definitely has something to do with all of this and might be the connection between the BU and TU somehow. I also find it interesting that in the BU, the boys are looking for the “Map of the Soul” which they think will save them. The boys seem to think this is a book and it has been shown to have strong connections to Seokjin’s father. And now we see Beomgyu fighting with *someone* over a book, possibly taking place in Seokjin’s father’s office.
IDK. I don’t have much in the way of theories here, I don’t know what this stuff might mean. But these are all connections I’ve noticed so I wanted to point them out!
all those theories my mind is losing brain cells here-
Interesting
Okay okay, mind blown.
I also have one theory. What if in the BU, when they say a friend of Seokjin's dad got lost, he went to the magic Island and thus Seokjin's dad too. Also, I am kind of coflicted with an Idea I have, because the facts don't really match my speculations, but here it goes. What if the TU happens before the BU, like Seokjin's dad has something to do with the txt boys, or in a non too possible situation, is one of them. Like the two universes coexist, but are different at the same time, and somehow his dad traveled from TU to BU. Cause like we have seen TxT universe has more innate magic than the BU. Or something around that.
I really hope this makes sense, and all critics are welcomed. We're all trying to build something up from this beautiful mess.
This can’t happen because these two universes are different but they collide in magic island so if this happened they both are in magic island (sorry if it doesn’t make sense lol)
@@thecherryischillin4959 it's not like it won't happen like there are several other theories that mentioning every stories in hybe is connected so idk
Why is no one talking about how in the dream chapter star and magic photo cards they're holding the parts which have their pains:
Yeonjun: His Throat
Soobin: His ear
Beomgyu: His shoulder
Taehyun: Covering his eye
Hueningkai: Holding his chest "Heart"
yeaa i noticed that tooo
I'm watching this while having online school cuz no one wants to ignore a 57 minute video posted by Laina.
I mean, who wouldn't do that :D
literally me too 😂😂😂
omg y’all have online school in summer?? ☹️☹️☹️
@@MR-fm2nh we have a somewhat testing type class tomorrow so we can practice
Our regular classes starts on Sunday
@M R it's already a habit, most schools in my country do that too 😅
Yeonjun's cut on his throat also appears for a second in the Magic Island video. It's in the sequence after they're all run over by the train and there's a second where it shows Yeonjun grabbing onto his throat in pain.
50:22 5!! (5 can be read 'O' in korean) 5!! 5!!!!
Beomgyu can't choose sides between following 'star song' (taehyun soobin) or 'odd eye cat' (yeonjun hueningkai)!!!!!!
It seems like soobin is closer to find their promise and the star. So he tries to make his other friends follow him and taehyun realized it so taehyun observed soobin more. And it seems like yeonjun already found it yet he didn't know? (I don't understand this either)
The irony is beomgyu is so 'pressured' (on his shoulder) to keep everyone in the group safe (not being hurt), but he started to not be able to trust them. Huening Kai is the one who maintains the group's positivity, but he's the one who's being blinded from things that might crack their friendship.
Maybe that's why taehyun's item is airpod (or headphone)? 'Defeaning' voices around him so he can be focused to see more, but it ended up making him distant too?
oooh maybe! maybe thats why beomgyu tried to suffocate taehyun? bc he was suspicious of soobin and beomgyu thought he was hiding something
I dont know if this information helps but it kinda supports the theory of having 2 cats
Cause in the "SAVE ME" ep 1..Jin mentioned 2 different voices calling him...I'm pretty sure he said it after waking up the 3rd time after talking to the other cat...he suddenly heard a voice talking about turning back time to save everyone..he then woke up saying "its a different voice from last time"...
I really need to read Save me another time.....
YESSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!
I've been so conflicted about this because in Save Me there are clearly two beings interacting with Jin, the one at the beach and the one that explains to him how to remember the timelines. Also, I'm not sure if it has to do with something about changing the design or not, but the first "cat" that appeared in save me was WHITE, so I'm LOSING my mind over it. Still not sure if it was intentional, or if it was just a change in the design. Help.
About Hyuka and the gecko, a gecko can shed their skin right? So what if it’s smth like Hyuka shedding/losing his “innocence” as he learns more about what’s going on? Or maybe it’s parallel to how he changed(?) from having angel to more devil like wings(like shedding old skin and having new one)? Just thoughts🤷♀️ take them with a grain of salt lol
I'm sure Hitman Bang was hiding in every MVs that we didn't know 😂😂
I noticed something. Although it might be useless here you go:
So Laina was talking about there being two cats. If we look back at it then it makes sense a little bit.
*We saw a cat without those cat-like pupils with Jin in BU and Yeonjun's side angle in Nap of A Star. Notice how anything bad did not happen.
*There is that cat with those pupils which appears in front of Soobin in the concept trailer of Eternity, in front of Yeonjun in Nap of A Star, Magic Island and Eternally. That is when all the bad things seem to happen.
I know this isn't a solid theory with proof, but if you see this, please reply and share your opinions on this.
@@adeleneeetran Whoops I don't have discord
@@adeleneeetran OH SHAT.......ADIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
@@adeleneeetran I MISS YOU!!!!!!
I'm sorry but what's BU?
@@sooha5659 BU is BTS Universe
FINALLY I WAS WAITING FOR THIS!AAAAAAA!
*2 dislikes from Hitman Bang himself from 2 different accounts because Laina might have unveiled their future plans lmao.*
Seriously tho. I got too many goosebumps watching and listening to this.
Lol Laina is the only one I trust when it comes to txt theories
First, I clicked on this so fast you don’t understand
Beomgyu is my favorite character in +u... I love him...
same
Same
im four months late here oops. but think beomgyu being the diamond is so interesting. diamonds form under extreme pressure, which would relate to the the “weight” he feels on his shoulders. this intense pressure physically appears in diamonds in the form of inclusions, similar to how beomgyu’s pressure manifests as the spikes on his back. it also relates to the butterfly imagery, since out of this extreme pressure, he is going to blossom and become a diamond/butterfly (metaphorically). it’s also interesting to note that diamonds have come to be associated with wedding/engagement rings. in other words, they represent a promise or vow to stay together forever, similar to the promise the boys made when they were children.
Also in the frost mv beomgyu is literally in a mine. So that does add value to the whole "beomgyu is the diamond" theory.
Soooo 2 YEARS AGOOOO SHE PREDICTED TXT'S NAME CHAPTER at exactly 56:20 SHE IS SOOOO TALENTEDDDD
Oh my God
What if TXT is the bridge universe between bu and gu and their fate will decide whether they will ever meet or not!! Because in highlight reel everyone had a girl except jimin which means 6 member that of Gfriend.And jimin saw Yeonjun dead in taehyun's timeline may be.May be Jungkook and Soobin has kind of same character in universes.Beomgyu and Taehyung might have similar character and Yeonjun and Suga binds as they are related to fire and are always causing fire which causes trouble.Taehyun and RM kinda searching for things. Kai and Jhope and Jimin kind of connects to innocence i guess.And tbh i am not so similar with gfriend so I don't know! May be BTS and TXT connects more as they are originally formed solely in bighit.
great theory my brain hurts just reading that
😱!
i think the ‘cat’ that appears in front of soobin isn’t actually the cat, i think it’s the dragon in the eternally mv, it’s eyes are smaller and farther apart than the actual cats eyes
18:00 going with that theory, I instantly thought of angel or devil..
Also for soobin... did anyone notice this?
In the starboard concept photos, on txt’s “instagram” where they have the short clips next to their pfp? Kinda like stories?
And they open their hands to show necklaces with locks and then close their hands in the second clip, its been a while since i looked but soobins hand (you can tell by his sleeve) the necklace chain is wrapped around his hand whereas the other members just have the necklace resting in their palms
So maybe thats to show soobins trapped somehow,
I think Soobin trapped Taehyun but I ain’t sure to
Ok so I don't know if anyone ever talked about this but my take on the cat is that is not actually good o evil, but instead is a creature that provides certain abilities to people or makes them go through some situations to teach them a lesson for their own good. For example, in Seokjin's case, it gaves him the ability to go back in time to help his friends, so we perceive the cat as a good creature because it gives Seokjin a "tool" for him to use in order to give his friends a happy ending. But in TxT's case, we see the cat as an evil creature because what is happening with them actually causes them pain. Well, is causes pain to Seokjin aswell because he's going through the pain of failure every time something messes up with the improvements he makes in every timeline. I also don't think their starting situations are provoked by the cat. I mean, yeah, they go through pain, but I believe is the cat's way to teach them life lessons, especially them since in their storyline they are portrayed as highschool students (even though Yeonjun and Soobin are on the doors of adulthood in real life) a.k.a. teenagers, a phase in our lives where we go through so much and different kinds of pain (kind of relates to the BU aswell since in their storyline they met at highschool). So, in conclusion, I don't actually think there are two cats, I believe is just one and we perceive it in a different light depending on what it does in each universe.
I hope this makes sense or is at least understandable lol, English isn't my first language so sorry if there's any mistakes :')
Yes this, they make it seem like the cat is an evil one that is trying to lead them to their downfall fall but the cat is really like a guide for them, it’s like they try to show them the consequences that come when they choose different idk, but I don’t think the cat is evil.
@@youngk001 I actually don't think is good or evil itself, as I said, we see it differently depending on which universe we're seeing, because if it wasn't for the cat's "gift" to Seokjin to go back in time, he wouldn't be able to even try to help his friends. Now it's similar un TU since it seems like Soobin is able to go back in time aswell, but their situations are portrayed so different from the BU that we see them go through pain constantly and the cat is always there so it seems like it's evil, but at the end of the day we never know lol, anything is possible in this multiverse haha.
I was arranging all the BU notes and this came...
...I will be emo for some days due to all these theories
I had a thought the other day about who Beomgyu could have been fighting in Eternally. I'm pretty sure the different timelines and stuff reflect each other, and that something that is in another timeline will show one way or another in a different one. Yeonjun appears dead in a few of the other member's visions, and in Beomgyu's, he (Beomgyu) is seen fighting someone before there are blood splatters or something all over the wall and he doesn't seem to be anxious about the person he was fighting getting up again, most likely meaning that the person is dead. I think it could be Yeonjun because of that. Also, in the first scene, Soobin gives the book to Yeonjun, maybe showing that Yeonjun was trying to get the book. So, if Yeonjun was trying to get the book, he could've been trying to get it from Beomgyu in his vision as well. This is all assuming that the things that the members saw in Eternally was different timelines through dreams and visions or something along those lines. It's also assuming that actions reflect throughout all the timelines and everything will appear (even though it might be represented in a different way, like the boy's pain going from more of a mental thing to physical pains as well as being represented through the bear or the bad memories/mistakes becoming fire). Still, if the reflection thing is right, then it could also be Taehyun because of when Beomgyu and Taehyun fought in a different timeline with CYSM as well as the fact that Taehyun was wearing the same clothes as the guy fighting Beomgyu at the beginning of the Eternally mv. I could also just be crazy lol.
Me: trying to pay attention to everything
My mind: Is that labyrinth in the background-?
Me: wait wha-
Mind: ...
Me: *Randomly starts singing along*
Jin's father's desk and one the kid in bts the notes name being choi... coincidence I think not
when i first watched eternally, beomgyu's scene and that room made think of seokjin's father's office?? kinda??? that's where my mind went idk
@@graceysart5435 It could be.... I guess we have to wait and see
Can you plz tell me the vedio name where the notes name is choi.? I want to see it..!
@@ruhirathore79 in save me webtoon, jimin and hobi I think, are in a hospital and they meet this kid who has narcolepsy just like jhops's character in the story. The doctors mention that the kid's surname is Choi so armys and moas were speculating that the kid might be Somone from TXT but it's hard to tell which one it is cuz there are three choi s in TXT however I feel like it's probably soobin and if not him then it's yeonjun
Btw, what if Taehyun isn't actually looking for a patern in their loop, but looking at other timeliness (like Bts or Gfriend) and see if they could resolve their problems and replicate their actions... I'm going crazy lol
Yeonjun started a campfire at the fantasy world (forest), that can also connect to the end of run away where they burn the door because the forest is all burnt and they can’t go there anymore to feel happy. That also can be the reason why the members are mad at him in the can’t you see me music video.
okay txt universe is a lot more interesting than i thought... i've always just listened the songs and watched the music videos as they are haha :D
KFKSKDJFKLWKQJF LUV THIS
Ooof- Youre right , Big hit aint gonna do shit in order
Yeah the BU's taught us that we're going to suffer 😂😂.
The way I came to this video thinking “oh I’ll just watch it and do what I need to do a bit later” then looking at the whole time this video is like 👁👄👁
I'm watching this now to prepare for Frost mv ㅠㅠ
I am never leaving this channel
Honestly beomgyu is the most confusing character and very suspicious. One day he is with his friends the next he is against them
I'm so glad I rewatched everything before watching this,, I was ready 😼
Ain't skipping ads because her of her hardwork 🔥
I am being super honest, people who anylize kpop lore deserve a PHD like..
people are really great in analyzing and making these theories. my respect is all to ya'' and im just here with my empty potato brain-
May i ask why you all ways post right when am about to go to bed!!!?
But Like am still watching the video because we Stan txt and we Stan Laina 😎✌🏻❤️
Ikr same here 😂😂✌🏻
IM SORRY LOL
Laina Sunflower hahaha no problem, keep up the good work 🥰😉
Its only 4:30pm here so I have all day!! So excited
Same i just finished watching your video and it's almost midnight
I WAS WAITING 😭
Your outfit looks soo pretty!!♡♡♡
please read!!!
oh my god wait i was watching people react to the txt eternally mv just now and noticed something, i just had to come back here to comment something-
so basically, when beomgyu is watching himself in room 17 fighting with an unknown person, there is like a dear head on the wall, usually those have horns and stuff on it. the horns on their head resemble yeonjuns horns in the theory of him being a monster and everything like that! i dont know what this means but maybe it could be yeonjun he's fighting with????
2 really basic observations:
1. Their birthdays being mentioned because of constellations and how that ties into stars/the Star.
2. The Devil/Angel imagery because they will all as a group or as individuals, have to make a choice and the consequences of their actions which they haven't considered or have considered to the point of stagnation/impulsivity.
also ua-cam.com/video/Q4jkD2eLja4/v-deo.html: The painting behind Beomgyu! The new teaser being called Temptation!
Can I just say, you’re so smart. I can tell you put a lot of thought into your theories. On top of that, you explain them so clearly and perfectly!
First of all, sis you’re looking really really pretty!!
Secondly I died waiting for youuuuu!
Hueningkai just wants to help all his friends, the universe looks at him and makes him lucky af, in conclusion Hueningkai best boy
YAASSS QUEEN! The longer the video the better.
I studied this harder than I study for college 🤡
17:05 the cat's eye colors are flipped. In every other scene the cat has the left eye blue and the right one green. The fact that it happened when Soobin saw it is kinda weird since (as you said) it is almost always Yeonjun who sees it. Idk if that actually means something or I'm reading too much into it.
where soobin had a bunny in his hands i immediately thought ''soobin holding soobin''
an almost hour long video from one of my favourite youtubers about one of my ult groups? yes please
aND IT HAS A PART 2? SIGN ME UP 🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️
23:32 everytime you mention a festival i can't help but remember aboyt the masks in enhypens given-taken mv, and is also in the outro: Cross the Line mv
You mentioned the conflict of choosing between angel and the devil. I think this connects to the song because there was a line "tell me what I should choose between an angel and a devil"
*Explaining how Kai’s huge expression of loneliness and how he connects with Yeonjun*
Lonely boy comes up out
I can listen to these theories all day long but can't do the same on my class discussions.
The fact that I just watched a 57 minutes video and understand nothing... I hope that's enough to show you how big my brain is🙃
And why watched it in the first place?? It's a Laina Sunflower video, you actually thought it being 57 minhtes would stop me from watching the whole thing?!
At 33:11 when he had a horn sigh in cysm choreography it could represent yeonjun and that he wants to be at yeonjun’s place and want to be the main character!!!
Omg I’ve never considered this! I really like this though Ahh!
bighit better give a whole damn novel series after the story is over
I'll buy that no matter how much it costs~
*laughs in star seekers*
I feel like when Hitman Bang watches a movie he's always thinking on how to put some of the things in the movie to put in HYBE artists storylines.
The cat is Bang PD checking on his boys
sounds about right lol
I just realized that when Yeonjun's and Huening Kai's pains are combined, they form a devil (The horns and the devil wings). Soobin's and Taehyun's pain (The eye and the ears) form an elf. The elf kind of reminds me of Legolas or any elf from Lord of the Rings, as the elves have enhanced vision. This links to the fact that Taehyun is a detective. I think (I'm not sure) that elves in general have sensitive hearing, which shows how Soobin could hear the frequencies at Magic Island. Perhaps the two will team up in the future to gain information about their quest. That would be really fun!
alright this is definitely gonna be a long comment bc a theory popped into my head while watching your video.
It seems that the end goal of the boys is to save Yeonjun, as its shown multiple times that he is the one being targeted by the cat and is the one who's always dying. (it's likely that he's being targeted bc of whatever he did in the past that he's *guilty* of) And so, in the other members' individual quests to save Yeonjun, they acquire a certain *"magic"* that will help them. In my theory, Soobin's magic is the die, Beomgyu's is the book, Taehyun's is possibly the clue that he's searching for, and Kai might just be magic himself (like you said, he did go through the magic circle as a child). The only problem is that none of these are strong enough to save Yeonjun on their own and right now, they're all trying to fix everything by themselves. That's why they need to come together and unite their magics to save Yeonjun and fulfill their promise to the star at the same time.
Wait what?! Isn’t Soobin the liar? Then why is the cat after Yeonjun? I’m confuse
so basically yeonjun is portrayed as the main lead and beomgyu is the real lead
plot twist: beomgyu’s arguing with bang pd
it makes sense that tyun is the detective since he holds txt's 2 braincells
So when you are talking about the “two” cats it reminds me a lot of the zodiac sign, Gemini to be exact, with the whole two sides of the same coin sort of thing. And then I thought what if there is only one cat. The two eyes symbolizes its different personality. The mean one and the nice one. The one that wants to help and the one that wants to destroy
Okay i don’t know why but this makes mi think of Gfriend a lot and its because two members are Gemini (Sinb and Eunha) also i connect this to them because in the behind scenes of apple MV there is a moment were to two (eunbi’s; yes they share their real name too ) said that one of them its good and the other the evil!
I dont know if this makes sense but i found interesting!🤔🤔
Maria Alejandra Villabona Oyola it’s a really cool Coincidence
plot twist: bh writers put the cats in different situations to confuse the fans
Well... it’s nearly 1am but guess I’ll just stay up for another hour QwQ
28:14 no way you just predicted that- I will now trust everything you say, how did u predict that so accurately omg
33:13 i dont think they are horns. to me, it seems like how koreans touch thumbs to lock their pinky promise. hes the only one with the thumb and pinky while yeonjun and kai only have their pinky meaning they didnt lock it or something idk
The gecko in kai’s video makes me suspect about the dragon because gecko or some types of gecko are called as bearded dragon or a small dragon
Laina you're such a genuine gem
I literally learnt more english from +u theory videos than in my whole freaking school life yet-
THANK YOU, LANA! I know this was difficult to make and I greatly appreciate efforts! Much love from the Philippines MOARMY 💜💙🌟💋
Laina you're so good at theories especially TXT UNIVERSE!!
THANK YOU LAINA!!
bless you for carrying and deciphering all of MOAs' braincells 😭
LOL...I litteraly waited for this vid to come!! THANKS for the vid💖💖