The Vicksburg quarter was so much beyond ultra cameo compared to the other silver quarters at 69 I would call it a over-the-top cameo, there's so much cameo It almost overwhelms the coin!!
Wow you got the best one because of that 1986 eagle and a lot more slabs than Rob got! Other than that for the flips and the boxed coin you guys got the same thing plus or minus a year or so.
Came over from Rob's channel. I'm going to give you the edge as your ASE was first year, and his was second year. The bags seemed be to consistent between you. Look forward to watch other videos from you.
Hey Seeker! What great grab bags you and Rob got! Those were some very nice coins, and both bags were very similar in contents. I would say you won this round due to the first year Silver Eagle over Rob's second year Eagle. Another fun video, but hey, I just love seeing silver!!!
@@SilverSeeker True. Rob didn't hide his name at all I guess. They were pretty similar bags, and both awesome, so maybe he just really does have some great stuff he gives out. If so, great place to get some good coins!!
Personally, I liked Rob's better only because I don't have much of a use for slabbed quarters. And as I have said before, the mystery bag videos are fun to watch, but for $150 I would rather buy a Morgan I need for my album.
Think Rob did just a little bit better, but enjoyed your vid. just as much! Looks like a whole lot of fun. I have a lot of couns that i am intrested in liquidateing along with quit a good bit of natural placer gold. I think that i would get a real kick out of providing this kind of fun for more collectors. Realy enjoyed your's and Rob's videos. Thanks do much!!!
never owned a slabbed coin saw robs grab bag as for who has the best tough call both nice grab bags I wiil play it safe and chicken out I call it a TIE
Rob won money wise, but a few of those coins you got. I’d be happy to break even just to see them. So I give you the win. Also, first time watching one of your videos. I only sporadically watch coin hunts, but yours was fun so here’s a subscribe.
SS - that was a great deal, but I bet the seller recognised your address and sent you a loaded bag maybe? I know he had to recognise Rob's address. I'm happy for you, but I reckon if I bought one I'd get a bunch of war nickels. Regardless - sending you that extra coin was classy. I didn't see a clear-cut winner, as both bags were excellent. Congrats on nearing 50K and as I told Rob - that'll be a nice Christmas present - you got this!
He may have recognized RFT but I doubt he recognized Coolstax. Honestly if you look at his description in the listing the bag had exactly what he said it would. Can't get mad at that!
Wow amazing coin both y'all had basically the same thing Rob has one other thing he has the 1992 silverProof Set the only difference so I believe he's the winner
Wow very nice bag. Was hoping for a ND pull. I'm still looking to get myself a nice ND silver quarter being my home state and all. I do have a nice unopened roll of ND state quarters from 2006 from the mint. Time to go see what Rob got.
Wow, I think this was a good score. Think I'll check out Rob's post before I get a mystery pack for myself BUT I've saved the seller to my Watchlist on eBay. Fun video!
Hi Silver Seeker. Rob sent me over to check out your channel. Been a collector for some 45 years my self. I have both US and foreign coins from modern to ancient hammer struck coins in my sets. Have subscribed and bell. Hope you make it to 50K soon.
I saw Rob's grab bag and I think you got the better grab bag. Even though they were both good. When I order grab bags it's usually juck silver with one or two unslabbed coins in paper 2X2's that have proof coins written on them in ink.
Looks like you both got comparable packages, but Rob’s estimate was a little higher around $187 before the bonus. Rob got an error quarter as well, which he estimated at $40, bringing his total to around $227. Agree that the error coin bumped up both your values and we can’t be sure everyone would get the same bonus for late shipping or that the seller didn’t figure out who you guys really were and gave you better packages as a result. But on the whole you both got excellent packages, worth somewhat more than what you paid, so the seller did right by you both-a rarity on eBay. Usually, grab bags are the junk collectors/dealers want to get rid of and know they could never sell well individually. They’ll cover up the junk by throwing you a bone of one decent/rare coin, but the rest is still junk that doesn’t realistically add up to what you paid.
I'm not an expert but I do have common sense. How can you value some of the slab coins at only $15, when just sending it in to NGC or PCGS costs what at least $35. Shouldn't you be able to resell the coins adding the slab price plus the $15?
Hi Silver Seeker I did get see both videos and in my opinion Rob got a slightly better bag for the reason that his bag had a 1992 Silver Proof set. Nevertheless both bags and videos are awesome.
The seller knew who he was sending this bag to, he had to. Lol
Almost identical grab bags. Your ASE is one year older. It's nice to see a grab bag that leaves you on the plus side.
The Vicksburg quarter was so much beyond ultra cameo compared to the other silver quarters at 69 I would call it a over-the-top cameo, there's so much cameo It almost overwhelms the coin!!
You and Rob posted at the same exact time. Lol
100% intentional :)
@@SilverSeeker Haha! I thought so!
A good honest ebay seller. I hope he is fully over his medical issues. An AWESOME lot!!!!!
Nice assortment
That was very kind of the seller to add that extra coin for your troubles
Don’t tell Rob I’m watching your video first. Lol 😆
I'm reckoning you and Rob did equal... makes me wonder if the supplier didn't know exactly to whom he was sending the packs... for the advert value!
My thoughts exactly tly
For real!!!! I would order Mystery bags every single day if I can get one like this
Looks like you and Rob got the same package good chance he knows who you are
I think Rob said he used his channel’s name not sure I think
when you both estimated the coins values it was uncanny how many times you matched exactly, well done.
Very nice bag love the 1986 ASE and the Washington Quarter DDO
A great grab bag and it's hard to pick between them but I will give you the win for the 86 ASE 😁
I'd be satisfied, for sure
Nicceee…hard to pick. Both pkgs had great items in them. 😃
Awesome Grab bag!!
That slabbed 86 ASE was sick wow
Both Grab bags were great
Both you and Rob were so close! Rob had a higher total, but you had a better selection. Awesome mystery package!
Amazing for a mystery pack off eBay!
Both of you got really good grab bags
Cool I have that Gorge Washington 82 quarter very nice coin half dollar... Wow cool mistery coins u got very nice..your was the best winner 🥈🥈👍👍☺️
You both got great bags and your money's worth.
Wow you got the best one because of that 1986 eagle and a lot more slabs than Rob got! Other than that for the flips and the boxed coin you guys got the same thing plus or minus a year or so.
Just started the video. What a great bonus!
Robs was good, but you got him with the slabs😉
👍😊✌🇦🇺
wow what a mystery pack
More mystery pack buys please good sir Ty TY
very cool, gonna go watch robs next, you got some goodies👍❤️
Yeah I'll have to give you the win with the 86 ASE. But other then that both bags were identical.
Came over from Rob's channel. I'm going to give you the edge as your ASE was first year, and his was second year. The bags seemed be to consistent between you. Look forward to watch other videos from you.
Nice bag. I got to give you the win. More slabs coins.
I believe you definitely got the better pack. I may have to start looking into those ebay grab bags.
I enjoy grab bag videos. Nice pick ups.
I think you won because you got a 1986 ASE(Rob got 1987) and your bonus coin was a slightly better grade. Plus there were more slabbed quarters!
Great bag, love the DDO and the 1986.
it was close for me, The 1986 was the defining factor. great opening.
~~waves~~WOW PRETTY CLOSE ON BOTH BUT YOU GOT THE 86 ASE!!! BE SAF, BILL/SURFER
Epic Package brother
Great vid. Think you slightly edged out Rob. I'd be happy to have received either one of these mystery bags!
I watched both video, you won the better mystery pack.
Hey Seeker! What great grab bags you and Rob got! Those were some very nice coins, and both bags were very similar in contents. I would say you won this round due to the first year Silver Eagle over Rob's second year Eagle. Another fun video, but hey, I just love seeing silver!!!
Wow I'd get one for sure
Well, you both had some great bags. Hope it wasn't a little bit of a setup. Very nice!!
I hope so too... it is possible but he wasn't likely to recognize "Coolstax" as I don't use that name in my videos.
@@SilverSeeker True. Rob didn't hide his name at all I guess. They were pretty similar bags, and both awesome, so maybe he just really does have some great stuff he gives out. If so, great place to get some good coins!!
First time commenting on your channel but i think you might have won this one, great fun thx subbed
Love these videos between you guys. Similar but different coins. Congrats.
Wow. That was amazing!! I have to say, now that I have watched Rob's, you win. That ASE and the slabbed silver quarters really cinched it for you!
Couldn’t agree more, the seller was too nice giving him that extra one too😩
All the grab bag sellers on eBay always lose money when they send this guy a “mystery bag! Hmmmm
Both you and Rob had great packages. I am giving this one to you with the slabs and 86 ASE. Congrat's. Good pickup's.
I love mystery packs! Let’s goooo!
I think you both need well. But I liked the Seeker package better.
It is a toss up between you and RFT grab bags, both were awesome!
I watched Robs first i think you got a little better package :)
Personally, I liked Rob's better only because I don't have much of a use for slabbed quarters. And as I have said before, the mystery bag videos are fun to watch, but for $150 I would rather buy a Morgan I need for my album.
I think you got the better coins, both were a great deal
Think Rob did just a little bit better, but enjoyed your vid. just as much! Looks like a whole lot of fun. I have a lot of couns that i am intrested in liquidateing along with quit a good bit of natural placer gold. I think that i would get a real kick out of providing this kind of fun for more collectors. Realy enjoyed your's and Rob's videos. Thanks do much!!!
never owned a slabbed coin saw robs grab bag as for who has the best tough call both nice grab bags I wiil play it safe and chicken out I call it a TIE
Awesome. I think you got a slightly better deal. Both were good deals but I wonder what the average Joe would get.
Great grab bag! I've got to give this one to you - lot's of great silver!
Rob won money wise, but a few of those coins you got. I’d be happy to break even just to see them. So I give you the win.
Also, first time watching one of your videos. I only sporadically watch coin hunts, but yours was fun so here’s a subscribe.
You and Rob basically got the same mystery pack since I seen Robs first I’m going with RobFinds Treasure 😃😃thanks for sharing
Sweet I would buy one
You win the microphone challenge hands down!
Lol thx :) I use a Shure SM7B and a GoXLR for the interface.
I liked your package better ... the slabbed quarter were more appealing to me!
I think Rob's were a little better condition. I'll be buying from that seller next!
Wow patience pays I guess
Its always good to get value for the cost. I think you both won!!
I think the 86 ASE wins it for you, but both were great value! Congratulations!
Holley Molly 👍😁
I haven't watched his yep, but omg! I want in a mystery bag! Who did you get it from. Congratulations
you can get that Washington half for 6-8 bucks in Florida and Alabama. Not a very popular coin with the public
SS - that was a great deal, but I bet the seller recognised your address and sent you a loaded bag maybe? I know he had to recognise Rob's address. I'm happy for you, but I reckon if I bought one I'd get a bunch of war nickels. Regardless - sending you that extra coin was classy. I didn't see a clear-cut winner, as both bags were excellent. Congrats on nearing 50K and as I told Rob - that'll be a nice Christmas present - you got this!
He may have recognized RFT but I doubt he recognized Coolstax. Honestly if you look at his description in the listing the bag had exactly what he said it would. Can't get mad at that!
Nice score S S , gotta wonder if the guy knew where it was going …
Wow nice. Yours was really the same as his, but the 1986 ASE was better because Rob got a 1987.
What an amazing grab bag!
I’m a simple Man. I see ebay grab bag, I click the Like button
Both of you got really good mystery packs, but I think Rob's was slightly better.
Wow amazing coin both y'all had basically the same thing Rob has one other thing he has the 1992 silverProof Set the only difference so I believe he's the winner
I have seen both videos you received more slab coins than Rob. You also got the 1986 Eagle in a slab. I give you the win.
RTF and Silver Seeker both won with the ASE!
Wow very nice bag. Was hoping for a ND pull. I'm still looking to get myself a nice ND silver quarter being my home state and all. I do have a nice unopened roll of ND state quarters from 2006 from the mint. Time to go see what Rob got.
Wow, I think this was a good score. Think I'll check out Rob's post before I get a mystery pack for myself BUT I've saved the seller to my Watchlist on eBay. Fun video!
Hi Silver Seeker. Rob sent me over to check out your channel. Been a collector for some 45 years my self. I have both US and foreign coins from modern to ancient hammer struck coins in my sets. Have subscribed and bell. Hope you make it to 50K soon.
I was just wondering if you could recommend a microscope for looking at coins. Thanks!
I saw Rob's grab bag and I think you got the better grab bag. Even though they were both good. When I order grab bags it's usually juck silver with one or two unslabbed coins in paper 2X2's that have proof coins written on them in ink.
Nice video👍. Gotta give you the win by the 86 ASE. Otherwise it would have been a tie.
Looks like you both got comparable packages, but Rob’s estimate was a little higher around $187 before the bonus. Rob got an error quarter as well, which he estimated at $40, bringing his total to around $227. Agree that the error coin bumped up both your values and we can’t be sure everyone would get the same bonus for late shipping or that the seller didn’t figure out who you guys really were and gave you better packages as a result. But on the whole you both got excellent packages, worth somewhat more than what you paid, so the seller did right by you both-a rarity on eBay. Usually, grab bags are the junk collectors/dealers want to get rid of and know they could never sell well individually. They’ll cover up the junk by throwing you a bone of one decent/rare coin, but the rest is still junk that doesn’t realistically add up to what you paid.
A link for the for the bag?
Both of the packs you guys got were amazing. I think you won overall. I will have to check out this seller.
I think your was better because of the 86 eagle
Just watched robs it was good . 👍
I'm not an expert but I do have common sense. How can you value some of the slab coins at only $15, when just sending it in to NGC or PCGS costs what at least $35. Shouldn't you be able to resell the coins adding the slab price plus the $15?
I checked the link and turns out I ordered from the same seller earlier this year. Thou I can't remember how I did.
Your ASE was better, but everything was close to the same. Rob's value was slightly higher, but I call a tie.
Although you both got good packs, I'd say you won this round. 👍
Thanks Nickel!
I want to know the seller of that bag!! That was an awesome bonus for delay I'll wait a month for something like that too lol
Seeker! You might have to up your stacker box game after this mystery pack! That’s crazy good!
I think the ASE made yours the better of the 2.
I think 🤔 your bag was a bit better then Rob's but Rob's bag was nice too
Hi Silver Seeker I did get see both videos and in my opinion Rob got a slightly better bag for the reason that his bag had a 1992 Silver Proof set. Nevertheless both bags and videos are awesome.
Yours wins with the 86 ASE, Rob got an 87.